AI Overview
+1
The claim of a "lost verse" in the Quran about stoning, often attributed to being eaten by a goat, is a controversial and widely debated topic within Islamic scholarship, with many scholars rejecting the idea that such a verse ever existed or was lost.
Here's a breakdown of the issue:
The Hadith:
Some hadith (sayings and actions of the Prophet Muhammad) mention a verse about stoning and breastfeeding an adult ten times being revealed and written on a piece of paper that was then lost when a goat ate it.
Scholarly Debate:
Rejection: Many scholars, including those from prominent Islamic institutions, strongly refute the idea that a verse about stoning was lost or abrogated (repealed).
Alternative Interpretations: Some scholars argue that the hadith is unreliable or that the verse, if it existed, was not part of the Quran itself.
Focus on Quranic Text: The Quran itself does not explicitly mention stoning as a punishment for adultery.
The Current Quran:
The Quran prescribes flogging as the punishment for adultery, not stoning.
Traditional Islamic Law:
Some traditions in Islamic law, however, do include stoning as a punishment for adultery, but this is based on interpretations of the Quran and hadith, not a specific verse in the Quran itself.
Modern Interpretations:
Modernist Muslims often reject the practice of stoning, arguing that it is not supported by the Quran and is a form of violence.
In summary, while there is a hadith that mentions a lost verse about stoning, the claim is disputed and not supported by the Quran itself. The Quran prescribes flogging for adultery, not stoning.












