“An Unearthly Child”
Season 1, episode 1 - 23rd November 1963
[id: image of the First Doctor, saying “But you’ve discovered television, haven’t you?” and Ian Chesterton responds off camera “Yes.” /end id]
Honestly, this show gets off to a fucking banging start with one of the best episodes of the entire first season. The atmosphere is really well-developed from the mysterious opening through to the slightly unnerving close-ups of Susan’s face in the flashbacks. The setup takes its time, starting off with establishing the characters of Ian, Barbara, and Susan, before any of them need to actually do anything, and then slowly ramping up the tension as we learn more about what’s wrong with Susan. Really, it feels like a one-off sci-fi story that might have been part of any horror anthology show if the resolution had been something more horrible at the end rather than “let’s go hang out with some cavemen”
Susan is honestly the stand-out. Carole Ann Ford is so good as this weirdo autistic child who doesn’t quite fit in with our time. She gets across that slightly alien sense that she knows more than Ian and Barbara, even if some of what she says is absolute bollocks (as far as I know the 5th dimension isn’t “space,” that’s what the first three are for). Ian and Barbara are also fantastic from the moment they’re on screen together, and I love the grumpy old grandad vibes that Dr Who has (and yes, I’m gonna call him Dr Who because at this point in the show, that’s his name, fuck you).
Is it an entertaining watch: 5/5, like I said before, it’s just a really engaging little sci-fi mystery story that happens to be the setup for sixty years of tv.
Does the production hold up: 5/5, Waris Hussein’s direction is noticably so much better than a lot of what the show gets later on. There’s so many little tricks throughout this and the following three episodes he directed, like little moments with the rack focus or other film terms I don’t know the names of, which really elevate the script.
Does it use its time well: 5/5, like I said before, this feels like a complete story in itself, and if the ending wasn’t a cliffhanger into the 100,000 BC storyline, it would feel satisfying.
Are the characters consistent and well-used: 5/5, the core Tardis team are established clearly from the beginning, and the main focus of the episode is establishing how their interactions will cause conflict going forwards.
Is there anything actually going on under the surface: 3/5, there’s not the deep thematic exploration of something like Ghost Light, or the political layers of something like Invasion of the Dinosaurs, but it’s not devoid of substance.
Does it avoid being a bit dodge with its politics: 3/5, the doctor makes one kinda pretty really racist comment which has not aged well, but there isn’t anything built into the foundations of the story which is actively regressive or just openly racist or sexist. It will get a lot worse from here.
Overall score - 26/30










