Oh man just read the proposal extra and I feel so bad for both of them. Does Tony remember proposing the next day?? Does he at least acknowledge (if only to himself) that he fucked up or is he in such crisis that he can’t even admit it? 😭
[FYI this is in reference to the botched marriage proposal deleted scene from Want for Nothing - which I suggest you read first!]
So, yeah -- it is such a bad situation for both of them. As I mentioned, I have no set thoughts on where this goes next, but let's give answering your questions a go and see where this lands.
First off, Tony would 1000% remember absolutely everything with painful horrific detail. As soon as Peter safeworded out of the whole situation, he came crashing down to reality and basically interpreted that as a breakup. After Peter left with Vision, he let Musk's strippers feed him never-ending shots out of a desperation to remember nothing at all. Or ideally to never wake again.
(He failed.)
When he's finally sober, though, he doesn't know what to do. Peter is gone, not speaking to him, gone off who knows where -- not officially breaking up with him, but also very much *not* in contact.
Sideline -- Peter would have told FRIDAY to tell Tony he needed space and told her to send Tony's personal doctor for a hangover drip.... because he can't not care. (He also sees the horde of strippers making their way into the Tower and, for a miserable moment, considers asking FRIDAY to keep an eye on that -- but he still trusts Tony. At least that far.) (But his mind niggles at him, you trusted Harry too, see how that worked out.) Peter is holed up with Vision in, like, Scotland for his whole breakdown, fwiw, so we skip over any potential "Tony ignores his boundaries" issues.
Back to Tony, once Peter does get back to the city, days will have passed and Tony will have had time to move away from hyper-self-destructive and back to anything-to-fix-this. So he'll do the right thing of pinging Karen and asking to see Peter when Peter has time -- and it will be Peter sets the terms of that meeting.
Tony will start spitballing suggestions, like they elope or Peter just takes all of his money, even without the marriage. How does full control of SI sound?
But Peter cuts him off -- because the problem isn't money. The problem is everyone else. "And, Tony, if you can't fix that, then there's nothing to fix between us."
Here we devolve into a much more confrontational version of their conversation in Ch9:They Deserve Nothing. Instead of trying to "fix" things with Tony's friends for him, he is asking Tony to do the heavy lifting himself. Which isn't quite fair of Peter, but considering the nightmare Tony just put him through -- and the horrible way he spoke about Peter to his friends -- now the burden is now on Tony.
Tony agrees to it all, and doesn't worry about any supposed "unfairness". He tries to initiate physical intimacy with Peter and Peter shuts it down. He's not ready yet. "I need time, Tony. I love you but I-- I need time."
("Tony", not "sweetheart".)
Tony had heard similar words from Pepper before she left him and he thinks, desperate, Not this time. He'll get them back to where they were, he promises himself. He'll go to therapy, he'll take Peter to therapy. He'll beat in every Avengers' head until they stay on straight.
Tony goes to leave and Peter tries to give him the ring back, and that? That cuts like a knife.
"No. It's yours. It's always been yours. Throw it away if you want to but... it's yours."
Peter stares at Tony, considering, and Tony hopes, desperate in a way he hasn't been since a cave in Afghanistan, that he won't be hurt again.
Peter slips the ring back on his finger, and Tony's heart un-clenches.
"I'll keep it, Tony. Always."
Thanks for the inspiring ask @weatheredskies !















