Storm T. Winterlis

I think that Sophie's father is Gethen, and I have several reasons to support my case: First of all, they both have blonde hair. It's not a big thing, btu it is something, because when one parent has blond hair, usually if the other parent has another colour (besides red), you'll get at least a dirty blonde, but Sophie has plain blond hair. Second of all, Gethen is a strong Telepath, just like Sophie. Genetically, it would make sense, because although Shannon Messenger states that genetics aren't related to abilities, in the books, they DO tend to be. Thirdly, it would be a great plot twist, for Gethen, a member of the NEVERSEEN, to be Sophie's father. It would be very interesting for the readers. And last but not least, have you noticed that although he's cruel, Gethen doesn't really seem like a killer in the books? Also, Sophie can't just randomly get her photographic memory- Mr. Forkle can't just insert it into her brain. (Unless he can haha.) And Oralie doesn't have a photographic memory. No, we don't know that Gethen does, but it seems that it happens more to people who have mind-related abilities- meaning Telepaths and Empaths. Again, Gethen is a Telepath! Okay, I lied, I still have more points. Fifthly (I think it's fifth), why were there no registry files on Gethen? Could it be... that his existence is hidden in Oralie's cache? Sixthly. Wow. My sixth point. If Gethen used to be a Councillor, or not (he might be a Councillor, see point five), a child born of the Neverseen and a Councillor (Oralie) would certainly change everything- maybe even end the series! It would either bring the two sides together or push them apart even more... AND NOW THE SEVENTH. WHen he was interrogated, he ONLY threatened Oralie- Sophie's mom! He literally said he was going to "cut her pretty little head" off.

Mr. Forkle’s gonna die soon.

Why do I say that? So, so, so, so, so, many reasons. But to spare your time, I’ve cut it down to one. It’s short, but it’s EVERYTHING.

Well, the answer everyone wants answered. Who is Bramblestar’s impostor? The sneak peek of the next book already tells us that it’s Ashfur... But that he’s working with someone. Ashfur has never been smart enough to pull of something like intruding the spirit world. He’s been cruel, but not very intelligent...

No, I think that the impostor is Scourge. That’s right- Scourge, who died in the last book of the first series, hardly to be mentioned again. He has blue eyes, although they’re icy blue, but still... Blue. He’s wayyyyy smarter than Ashfur, and he definitely has the guts to attack the Clans. The why, I think is obvious... He wants to take revenge on Firestar’s friends. I betcha Graystripe will die eventually, you know?

Bramblestar had a point when he told Stormpaw that there were too many stars for Benny to not go somewhere (Bramblestar’s Storm) after his death. So who and what’s to say that Scourge never went to the Dark Forest?

No. Thing. Nothing. NOTHING. NOTHING. NOTHING. NOTHING.