─── 1: before the bodies fall ∬ ֗ ₊
ა ˙˖ summary: forced into an unlikely partnership, you and batman uncover a conspiracy far larger than a single murder. and gotham’s forgotten victims finally get the chance to tell their stories.
when you batman first asked for your help, he technically never asked you in person. instead, he left a tan manila folder on an empty park bench at 2:13am. inside was just one photo, the victim’s file and a note. the woman was in her late thirties, had curly brown hair, green eyes and a mole under her eye. you took the note off the folder that said, “can you help?”
you frowned. you picked up the folder, stuffed it in your bag and walked home. you walked up the stairs to your apartment building. you lived on the third floor so you then went to the stairs that led up to your place. pulling the keys out your bag, you jammed the key into the lock and cursing when it didn’t turn. this building was very old so when you first moved in, the landlord told you that sometimes the lock would fight the key turn. you eventually got the door open, after turning it the opposite way and falling into the apartment. you threw the folder down and got to work. you stared at the photo, trying to connect the dots to the file. you stared at it for a very long time.
“well?” a voice asked over your shoulder. you learned a long time ago that the dead rarely meant any harm. the woman from the photo leaned over your shoulder. she looked the exact same. “hm. he finally asked about me.”
you looked over at her. “batman?”
“yep. been yelling at him for weeks.”
the dead drifted through your home like roommates with terrible boundaries. there was an old soldier watches late-night television despite being unable to change channels. there was a victorian child sitting upside down on your couch humming lullabies and someone from the 1800s keeps trying to understand your microwave.
you ignored them all. instead, you focused on the woman in front of you. you tapped the pen on the notepad, waiting for the woman to speak. “my name’s claire. they said it was a mugging.” you wrote that down as claire rolled her eyes. “it wasn’t.”
you continued to write. “tell me everything.”
the thing with ghosts? they remembered things in flashes. when ghosts die, they don’t die with all the memories of your death. and because of that, it was hard to understand what exactly the ghosts really want from you since they couldn’t remember everything. but this was what claire did remember:
perfume. rain. the squeaking of leather boots and the sparkle of a wedding ring scraping against her skin as someone grabbed her throat. she remembered arguing and gold cufflinks engraved with the initials R.A along with a silver lighter. “you can’t keep doing this, claire.” the man told her as she struggled to breathe with the man’s hand around her throat. “you should have stayed quiet.” then all she remembered was utter darkness.
“you knew him?” you asked, getting up to make a coffee even though it was 2:30 in the morning. you knew you weren’t going to sleep anytime soon. claire followed you and shook her head, “i knew his hands.” you nodded as you added ice to the mug and asked if she remembered anything else and she told you that he cried and that he didn’t want kill to her.
“he didn’t want to kill me but he did. he kept saying, ‘i’m so sorry, he’s going to kill my family.’” by sunrise, your living room wall was completely covered in notes and clues and the evidence from the folder. you knew for a fact that batman would have called all of this useless but you know better.
day two and you went around to the ghosts in the city. these were the earthbound spirits that refused to cross over no matter how hard you tried. harold, a dockworker, recognized the lighter. a bartender named emory remembered the boots. a woman named francine who died over 20 years ago recognized the perfume because her husband used to sell it. you had never been more thankful that the dead gossip and were more effective than the internet. because of them, by sunset you had a name.
marcus hale. lawyer. married. two daughters.
you went back to claire with everything but she shook her head. “no. not him.” you frowned.
“yeah, i know what i said. he might’ve killed me but he isn’t the reason why i died.” claire said as you blinked at her. “you’re looking for the man who ordered the hit.”
“what the fuck does that even mean?”
the ghost rolled her eyes. “marcus was told to kill me.”
“by who?” you asked, sighing.
claire smiled. “now we’re asking the right questions.”
day three. batman went to the same bench. the folder was already sitting on the bench with everything you gathered from the city’s ghosts. along with new evidence. a flash drive and a handwritten confession from marcus hale. in the confession, marcus said that the man who ordered the hit was a named ralph de angelo. you left a little note that said ‘she said you missed something.’ you watched his jaw tighten and he looked up.
you were standing under a dying streetlamp. you fixed the purple umbrella on your shoulder since it was pouring down. you stuffed your hands in your black raincoat. batman walked over and you shared your umbrella with him. “you found him, the murder weapon and the confession.”
“yes, i did. well, with some help, of course.” a breeze flew through the trees as batman studied your face. you looked past him, over his shoulder, at claire.
you frowned and gestured to the folder on the bench. he flipped through everything and watched as everything registered on his face. he read over the confession from ralph de angelo. the man admitted to everything. he even included details no one had known before. “so he was following orders?” batman asked when you nodded. batman cursed. “well, who told you all this?”
“the victim. i see and speak to earthbound spirits. but..didn’t you already know that?” you asked, confused. didn’t he ask you to help because you spoke to the dead?
batman shook his head, “i asked you for help because of commissioner gordon. he said you were friends with barbara. that you had good people skills that could help me. now, i know she meant people skills as in dead people.”
you laughed. of course this was barbara’s idea. silence stretched between you. finally, batman slipped the evidence back into the folder. “i’ll verify everything.”
“you don’t seem offended.”
“to be fair, i would be worried if you didn’t.”
for the first time that night, you had thought you caught the faintest hint of amusement beneath the cowl. however, it was gone before you were sure it was ever there. you followed batman home to the batcave and stood in the threshold of the cave. “they don’t like this place.”
“the spirits. they’re yelling at me to leave.” despite that, you stepped inside anyway and looked around all the computers and gadgets around the place. “oh!” you stopped walking and looked up at a cabinet. “there’s a little boy.” a child who had to be around 10 years old was sitting on stop of the cabinet, swinging this legs back and forth. he had messy black hair, a gap tooth smile and a hospital bracelet. you were well aware that you looked like you were speaking to air. “hi. what’s your name?”
“hi. i’m t-tommy.” the boy said. you glanced at bruce and saw him changing into a gray turtleneck and black pants.
“why are you here, tommy?”
he pointed in bruce’s direction. “i was looking for him.” you watched as bruce’s expression hardened, picking up on the conversation even if he was only able to hear your side of it. “what’s he saying?” bruce asked, leaning against the counter with his arms crossed.
“a ten year old boy named is tommy.”
tommy looked between the both of you. “i liked superheroes.”
you frowned. “what happened?” you always got emotional when speaking to younger spirits, especially children. the boy tilted his head. “i got sick.”
“my mom said batman always saved people. she waited outside the hospital every night,” tommy continued and you relied to bruce. “she thought maybe he’d would come. i knew he couldn’t.” tommy smiled again. “so it’s okay.” you look at bruce.
“he knows, tommy. he knows.”
tommy smiled again and looked over your shoulder. “can you see that?” you shook your head, you had been at this long enough to know that he saw the light. “i see my mom.”
you grinned. “you can go home now, tommy.” and he did. he’d simply been waiting years to deliver one last message. bruce finally spoke. “...what did he say?”
you turned to him, away from the cabinet. you looked at him for a long time. “he wanted you to know it wasn’t your fault.” bruce closed his eyes and inhaled then exhaled. then he turned back to the batcomputer. “show me everything you have on ralph de angelo. please.”
you walked over, setting your notebook on the console. “i should warn you, bruce.”
claire appeared beside the computer, her expression grave. “there are more ghosts following this case.” bruce looked up. “how many?”
you glanced around the cave and the answer made your stomach drop. “twenty-three.” claire’s voice was barely a whisper. “and every single one of them was murdered by the same person.”
by the time you left the batcave, it was nearly dawn. claire lingered beside you as you stepped into the cool gotham air. “he trusts you.”
you huffed a laugh, rolling your eyes. “no. he tolerates me.”
claire raised an eyebrow. “is there a difference?"
three hours later, bruce was standing in the manor’s study, reading ralph de angelo’s confession for the seventh time. “it checks out,” tim said from the computer.
“everything matches. bruce, what are you getting at?” bruce remained silent and shut the folder. “it’s too perfect.” you, on the other hand, had spent your morning somewhere far less glamorous. gotham general hospital because claire asked you. “i left something.” she lead you through old hallways until you reached a forgotten locker in the basement. “they never emptied it, thankfully.”
inside was an employee badge, a spare sparkly pink sweater, a tiny stuffed rabbit and a folded envelope. claire smiled softly. “my daughter’s birthday card.”
you slipped it into your bag and put it on your shoulder. “i’ll make sure she gets it.”
later that night, you found him waiting at the same bench as before. he handed you a tablet. “three more victims.” the photographs appeared one after another. a photojournalist from the daily planet, a defense attorney and a city planner. all the deaths were ruled accidental and each of them were connected to ralph de angelo. you let claire study the pictures. “no.” claire said, crossing her arms. batman noticed your expression. “what?”
“they’re not victims. they’re witnesses.” hours and passed inside the batcave. tim typed faster than should be humanly possible, babs patched into the system remotely, dick arrived halfway through carrying takeout. alfred appeared with tea as if he materialized from thin air.
“miss.” he offers you a cup.
“thank you.” you said, taking a sip.
“you’ve been keeping master bruce awake.”
you nearly choked on your tea. “i’m sorry?” alfred’s face remained perfectly composed. “he spends considerably more time discussing your findings than he does sleeping.”
dick coughed into his sleeve to hide a laugh. tim outright snorted and bruce pinched the bridge of his nose. “alfred.” you looked at bruce. however, bruce was starting determinedly at the evidence board. dick was trying very hard not to smile and even barbara’s voice crackled over the speakers. “i’m not touching that one.”
unfortunately, the moment didn’t last. one of the batcomputer monitors flashed red. tim’s smile disappeared. “i’ve got something, you guys.” bruce was beside him instantly. “what is it?”
tim shook his head. “no.” he zoomed in on a rental agreement. the signature wasn’t ralph de angelo’s. it was someone else’s. a name no one in gotham had ever heard. claire’s face drained of what little color ghosts had. “oh no.”
you stared at her. “what?” she looked directly at you. “i know that handwriting.” bruce noticed your expression immediately. “what did she say?” you met his eyes. very quietly, you answered. “she said... the person we’re looking for already knows who i am.”