iâm so sorry this happened to you, but iâm really thankful and proud of you for standing your ground. we see you, and it matters. it matters so much.
this doesnât just affect trans men, but all of us queer folks who align with transmasculinity in any form. whether weâre genderfluid, bigender, nonbinary, or demiboy â if we carry masculinity in our identity or presentation, weâre all seeing folks turn on us.
yes, we are called traitors for being masculine when we had âa choiceâ not to be. yes, we are seen as âfailed girlsâ or âconfusedâ or âbutch womenâ or âtomboysâ or any number of other words to describe us as feminine. anything to escape the idea that masculinity could be a positive experience for anyone, ever. itâs caused so many of my friends to end up back in the closet, using less masculine pronouns, moving their presentation more feminine.
why is the concept of a âfemboyâ more culturally appropriate than a trans man??? why do people feel comfortable shouting that all men are essentially evil, even (or especially) trans men? why is putting he/him in bio seen as an utter betrayal?? why is simply being a man and sharing my experiences enough to make folks call me transphobic, anti-feminist, or even a liar? why do people perceive my existence as a direct attack on other women?
i can tell you why. this mindset has utterly infiltrated common queer thought to the point that weâre trying to destroy and push out expressions of gender that threaten to upset it. and i see a lot of folks call out radical feminism as the culprit â which, yes, they donât much like trans men, do they? â but thatâs the easy answer, isnât it? something insidious and secretive and outside the norm so you donât have to be the problem.
no. itâs rooted in conventional old regular culture, and itâs everywhere. if you talk to any cishet woman of just about any political and cultural makeup, she would agree with you. yes, men canât be trusted. yes, men are inherently violent. yes, men are ugly, evil, and stupid. thatâs not a radical idea: itâs literally the most base level boomer joke there is, right next to a âmy wifeâ joke. so of course when such a woman is faced with the idea that a woman might not be a woman at all? that he might be a man? disgust, shock, horror, fear. and youâre surprised that youâve absorbed this into your worldview? you were raised on it.
âokay, youâre only experiencing this because of misogyny.â so youâre going to degender us again? weâre only experiencing this because we are, in fact, actually women? we have a word to use for this experience that doesnât degender us. itâs transandrophobia. itâs that simple. you can even call it a subset of misogyny or influenced by misogyny if you want. i wonât be pressed, as long as you understand that this experience is real.
does it make you uncomfortable that a trans person is experiencing transphobia that you might be perpetuating? good. get uncomfortable. sit with it. listen to our voices. understand that these experiences are real and tangible.
transandrophobia as a term, is just a word to describe a specific experience almost all of us are having. you canât see it? transmascs are drowning, and you wonât throw us a life preserver because weâre just choking a little actually?
all you have to do is listen.
thatâs all weâre asking for.