#1 michael afton defender

his scene with the ghost crew is so good because you can see on his face exactly how unsure and scared he is. he’s smiley outside the pizzeria, he’s smiley even when he hears the sounds of Lisa being killed he smiles, because a small part of him still feels what he felt when he was concocting his plan, the thought of following in his fathers footsteps. but as soon as he actually SEES one of them die, he’s horrified, and starts to feel the impact of what the animatronics could actually do, realizing he’s in way over his head.

even when he investigates the puppets box downstairs, he’s nervous, and as soon as he’s chased by charlotte, he runs out of the restaurant terrified.