Cowpoke Hell

the only good thing about hosea dying in ch. 4 is that he didn’t have to watch arthur slowly die and dutch go insane. it would have broken his heart.

the ppl saying that jason and lucia are gonna b a reincarnated arthur and mary are driving me crazy. mary never wanted that kind of life and that’s the reason they could not be together.

i’m really scared of rockstar making RDR3 and ruining the first two but if it ends up being hosea and dutch raising little arthur and doing outlaw stuff in the true old west i will forgive any other characters or plots they massacre. show me why arthur said “dutch saved me” with such conviction in his voice. show me what the gang was like before it was a gang.

i’ll see so many “what if arthur didn’t get TB” posts from dudebros on reddit and then just paragraphs of what’s essentially AU and it’s like. babygirl just write your fix-it fanfic. ao3 is waiting

arthur says ‘we can’t be rescuing people from federal prison’ in chapter two and in chapter six he rescues john from sisika lmao

gonna be honest if you’ve played through RDR1 and RDR2 and you still think that jack isn’t john’s biological son i think you should consider going to an optometrist

we’re all in agreement that there is no heterosexual explanation for the nickname ‘old girl’ right