I MISS "ALL FOR LOVE" FIRST AX ILLUSTRATIONS BC WHAT THE HECK IS THIS???
The styling decisions here are most definitely... a decision.
Where do I even begin? What an absolute masterpiece of a “corporate focus group” aesthetic design that utterly fails on all accounts. It seems that mai would have this vision during sleep after staying up late at an anime convention.
She looks like"Bellhop at a Haunted Hotel" Look😭, There is just nothing but a vibe of “staff members of a cursed motel” about this whole costume. The most terrible piece here is a old Japanese police hat , it is definitely not fancy, it is small and barely held by gravity atop her head.
What Hellish Proportions they all have 😭
Now let's consider the ratio between mai's sleeves and skirt. The baggy, furry sleeves create an impression of being smothered in material, while the skirt and the ridiculous strapped shoes give the impression that the lower half belongs to some entirely different tacky character. There is 0 layering here; it is merely an outrageous combination.
Not to mention the f***ing "Mannequin" Eyes , there is no soul in those eyes. The expression on the face is plastered on in the same way as one would put it on a department store mannequin that has been taught to be "trying to be cute" but does not comprehend human emotion.
Despite being themed after “Lovely Hotel,” it comes off as an attempt to splash some pink Pepto Bismol paint and muted mauve on a doll from ages past in hopes that something will happen and hopefully works fingers crossed . This is not a nurturing color palette; rather, it is the colors of faded plastic. They're trying to make her inoffensive but they made the most offensive it backfired 😭 . Inoffensively offensively bad design.
The need to brand them at the bottom of the image as “HEROINES” is a clear indication that they understand exactly how forgettable they look. It is an attempt to tell us , “Yes, I know you’re not paying attention, this is the heroine!” but the design only screams, “I am nothing more than a background object!”
It’s doesn't look elegant, it’s not alluring, and it’s certainly not "magical." It’s just... a pile of mismatched clothes on a character who looks like she’s perpetually begging for validation.
The "cute" is absent and definitely non-existent. Bc once you get rid of all the marketese and "sweet" aesthetics, you will be able to admit it is a total design disaster.
They have the Uncanny Mask. mai for example has that eerie quality, that lack of life and soul in the face and eyes. That's not cute. She looks extremely generic it disgusts me a lot. This mask looks like an unfinished CGI-model from the 2000s. The smile doesn't go to her eyes, hinting at something sinister and uncanny. There seems to be absolutely nothing going on inside of her.
Not to mention The Tacky Design. None of this apparel is charming or attractive. On the contrary, these are random elements stitched together , an odd hat for that time period (not really sengoku period) , heavy-looking sleeves, and a skirt that looks like felt. This outfit does not represent some clothes of the heroine; rather, it seems like some "starter heroines pack" bought in discount stores.
The "Please Love Me" Aura though is extremely obvious . In lack of character and any kind of self-confidence, all three of them , the attempt to be cute turns out as extremely desperate. It doesn't look natural at all which makes me feel repulsed! She poses in such a way that should be attractive and charming, yet it just appears extremely so artificial. As it seems, the developers hold a indirect sign that reads "ISN'T THIS ADORABLE?" while the picture itself speaks volumes of emptiness and corporate design.
To call these attempt cute, one would have to really strain their imagination , this picture looks more like an exercise in visual mechanics, they probably wanted to reach a particular target regarding color and style, but forgot to check how realistic it was going to be. Or the opposite!
For some reason, they managed to make the MCs resemble workers in completely different haunted hotels. While the emma seems like someone dressed up like a fancy train attendant from inside a vintage doll museum, and the beige tights together with the leg warmers are battling for their life here, the color combination could’ve been chic if it weren’t for the odd proportions and layering,it looks so cringe 😭
Meanwhile, kate seems like she wants to appear like a gothic villainess combined with a magician’s assistant at a community theatre 💀 The combination of too much purple and asymmetry with a miniature hat doesn’t really work.Not to mention the cocktail dress trying to appear victorian like it's mixed up mashup of two different time periods 😭
However, the typography and vintage style of the hotel could have been good . The idea behind the "Lovely Hotel" was a meh one to me. The problem lies especially in the characters’ costumes, which somehow gave them an anime convention look at two in the morning. 💀
Especially the purple one seems to have this creepy quality 😭, bc the combination of the eyes, the smile, and the posture somehow make her look creepier rather than attractive. The style tries really hard to create that mysterious and elegant character, but what came out is this kind of plastic and inhuman look. Plus, the clothes seem to clash too much. Srsly trying to make her mysterious and cute as in acceptable to everyone has made her look like neither!
emma has a softer color scheme btw but her posture is weird stiff and her expression looks exaggerated and fake , more like manufactured , while kate… wow 💀 everything about it looks unbalanced. Yes, no wonder why I have a strong bad feeling about it . There are times when an anime illustration fails to have that aesthetic quality that will make the character look charismatic. Srsly kate having highlights while others don't , we're way past that level , idk why the highlights are there but it's not in their place!
That’s the joke here, making the male characters super attractive especially the ones with most fan base , and then they just give the mc “default savior/martyr mannequin syndrome” 😭
They definitely lack some sort of personality in comparison to the classic otome heroines from back then , both story wise and appearance wise😭 There doesn’t seem to be anything that ties the design elements together into an elegant or even charming ensemble. emma’s outfit is particularly bad too , with its fur-lined sleeves, weird silhouette, and tacky huge chunky rose belt, it looks like a department store christmas mannequin. 💀
Neither of these faces is much help either. They both have that overly slicked-up mobile game look in which the personality just does not ring true. Tbh hating their writing and personality makes you hate it even more visually because none of it rings true or comes off as charismatic at all, it looks flaky!
kate in particular seems to have tried too hard for a quirky seductive villainess vibe without really knowing what made that character type alluring. Thus she comes off as more awkward cosplay instead 😭
They don't seem as enchantingly magical as you'd expect from an otome game heroine. In fact, these are more akin to ugly, randomly put-together fashion items than graceful designs. They seem artificial in composition, lacking charm in their appearance.
I particularly think that emma is trying way too hard to pull off cute and elegant, while Kate trying to look seductive villain while failing spectacularly its color scheme and proportions look so wrong for that. kate just seems too out there with its styling 💀
Unfortunately mcs aren't used to be much more memorable and charming before, as bland or forgettable. It almost feels like these were made to fit into decorative NPCs rather than MCs.
The sweetness doesn't feel genuine to me. The MCs are intentionally designed to be sweet and cute instead of giving them any kind of real depth or making them seem alive and well-developed.
The overly sanitized version of the ideal MC in an cybird game especially makes them soft, pure, agreeable, emotionally nurturing, innocent, "kind to all people," inoffensive, safe to everyone to try to relate to but failing hard again, artificially lovable on purpose, and so on but when the formula is used too much, it becomes fake. In this way, it is almost like looking at a mascot instead of a person, they look like they're trying too hard, it doesn't look genuine or flowing 💀
It's especially apparent in their expressions and body language. Their smiles aren't genuine; instead, their expressions seem like, "Please like them." Their pose is not filled with confidence, mystery, charisma, or anything else unique about themselves or natural at all that gives them personality or makes them seem interesting.
For that reason, more emotional characters stand out.That’s why stronger characters or more emotionally layered tend to stand out ,they feel like they have an inner fire, not just “designed niceness.”
You can almost hear the boardroom meeting saying"Make sure they're soft, make sure they're saccharine, make sure they don't offend anyone, and for the love of god, keep their expression blank so she doesn't distract from the love interests."
It’s almost like they’re trolling the audience at this point
Let me cry in peace bc the designs are getting worse every single year just for the money (I think azel would still approve of that bc Material gains😭)














