"There's no platonic explanation for this" <-you need to be nicer to your friends. Right now
I actually think about this constantly & I need to vent just a tiny bit.
I’m on the ace & aro spectrum. I have not had a romantic or sexual partner in over 7 years. I have also been in fandom for a long time & have always been a shipper, and I GET how it feels to see a character do something on screen & go “holy shit that’s such deeply queer behavior?!”
But as someone whose primary relationships are ALL either familial or platonic, I struggle a lot when I hear “there is no platonic explanation for XYZ.”
I get what people are saying is that “this behavior clearly reads as romantic/sexual between these 2 characters” and hey, I’m with you! I also read it that way! I also want my two blorbos to just kiss already!!
But “there is no platonic explanation” is a definitive statement that is not open to nuance. It’s literally saying any possibility of a platonic explanation doesn’t exist or doesn’t count. And I never see said in the context of “there’s no platonic explanation for why this single character would behave this way toward’s this other particular character”. Instead, it’s always followed by “people who are just friends don’t act like that.”
So here are some examples of things from my own real life experience with my just friends that people insist there is no platonic explanation for:
- physical affection with close friends: this includes long hugs, forehead kisses, hand holding, lying with our heads (or feet) in each others laps, cuddling together, running hands through their hair, etc.
- sleeping in each other’s beds
- going on “dates” where we spend quality time together one on one & treat each other for an activity or meal
- bought each other flowers/treats/gifts for “No reason”
- inviting them to family events like Thanksgiving, Christmas, camp outs, vacations, etc., including overnight events
- taking one another to the hospital & being their emergency contact
- caring for them during surgery recovery to the point we become the other’s point of contact for extended family/friend groups
- agreeing I would be their kid’s legal guardian if they died
- attending parent teacher conferences
- discovering our kids think we’re dating
These are just the ones I could think of off the top of my head. Literally ALL of these have happened to me personally & all have been in platonic relationships.
Real people do all this stuff platonically. I know. I’m real people! That doesn’t mean the characters you’re discussing are doing it platonically. I’m not saying your interpretations about fictional characters are wrong, but I am asking that we check our allonormativity & consider other ways to talk about queer coding that isn’t dismissive of other people’s real experiences.
And like OP said, be nicer to your friends! You don’t have to be ace/aro or even queer at all to give the platonic people in your life some love.
























