The Carrie show sounds bad, but pretending that haunting of Hill House and haunting of Bly Manor weren’t incredibly beautiful is wild. And also, at the end of the day, these are just stories and there’s no reason to have so much vicious hatred for one guy just cause he doesn’t tell stories you like. I hope you have a good day!
they’re serviceable as entertainment but they aren’t so beautiful when you consider the stories they bastardized. the haunting of hill house is a novel that is, at its very roots, about familial and social isolation. eleanor has no one who cares for her, no home to call her own. she spends the first 30-some years of her life caring for a mother who does not love her. she lives with her sister’s family, who she mutually resents. she leaps at the chance to go to hill house, to be special, to belong. she does not have a happy ending. whatever walks at hill house, crucially, walks alone.
the show does not respect jackon’s story, it is not in conversation with it. it frankly takes great pains to trample on everything that makes the novel what it is. as someone who loves shirley jackson’s whole body of work, who has read at length about her fraught relationship with her own mother and with family and the expectations placed on the women of her time, i cannot see the show as anything but insulting and misogynistic.
i can’t speak about bly manor because i haven’t read the turn of the screw, though i’ve heard similar complaints from those who have.