Companion post to “is your fantasy world free of misogyny, or did you just put women in the warrior class?” (See here)
I’m chewing over the notion that mothers and children in the story can give the squick. Maybe I don’t quite get it because ElfQuest was a formative story for me starting at age 12.
There was certainly a lot of fantasy fiction I read early on that centers the girl empowerment story, where she hates embroidery and/or kitchen work (depending on her social class) and takes up the sword to go on a quest. Maybe she falls in love (with a boy of course) but definitely doesn’t have kids, because that would nullify her claim to power and freedom. (Also she’s probably like 16 max).
ElfQuest does it different. It’s about family from the start, because what are we fighting for if not our family’s survival? “Family” as it turns out means all elves, no matter how strange their ways are. Certain individuals don’t buy into this, they are collectively referred to as “the loveless ones.”
One of the biggest themes is that love is the opposite of control. You can’t claim to love someone and also make their choices for them.
Maybe this is why fantasy often shies away from motherhood and young children as central characters - because we’re acculturated to have a lot of our choices taken away when we’re in those life stages.
The post about misogyny I’m referring to gives examples of what a fantasy world without misogyny might look like, and it’s more than getting to fight and bleed. At the most fundamental level, it means everyone shares all kinds of work, including raising children.
ElfQuest addresses this problem right away, with the ordeal of Recognition. Leetah is terrified of not being in charge of her own choices. It’s not so much that having kids would be terrible, elf children are rare and precious. It’s that she doesn’t know who she would be once motherhood is a huge part of her life.
I have to believe that a lot of this fear must come from being in a relationship with Rayek (one of the most controlling characters in the whole saga). Because this isn’t really what the elves in general are like. It takes some motherly advice from Savah to point out that no one is going to make her be any particular kind of mother. There may be an ancestral biological magic imperative at play, yet she’s still in charge of what happens next.
This post is getting long, but essentially one of the things that makes ElfQuest so fascinating is that it’s an empowerment fantasy that doesn’t only focus on the young adventurer trope (it’s there, just not always).
All kinds of ages and stages are included, contributing in their unique ways, desiring different kinds of lives, and antagonizing each other in ways that underline the point. Ultimately showing that cooperation, growth and change are painful, but necessary for anyone to both live free and survive together.