The three types of people artists will interact with are: other artists, normal people, and narcissists.
The other artists will relate, admire, buy, and be inspired. The normal people will relate, admire, buy, and be inspired. The narcissist will be jealous, imitate, pretend to admire in a shallow way, buy but with the expectation of 100x back to them, and intend to take - not be inspired but take your energy and anything you've attained in life.
The normal person and other artist will interact minimally but positively, keeping boundaries and respect, if they purchase they will do so with minimal contact and no issues. The narcissist will persistently present a shallow imitiation of 'fan' or 'artist' behaviour; an imitation of admiration but not actually understanding or observing specifics. An imitation of admiration for aesthetics but none of their aesthetics are original. They can't make good art. If they do it's a copy or low quality, unsellable, unappealing. They mostly put all their effort into the facade of being an art admirer or artist, but see past the facade and there's nothing there. Someone who says they admire music but doesn't want to hear it and thinks they should be praised for listening. Someone who says they admire paintings but they own no paintings.
Someone who can't consistently be who they pretend to be, meaning they need rest and recuperation from the facade before they can repeat it. This was particularly easy in the past online, where infrequent posting was normal; now daily posting is expected it's more difficult to maintain a consistent facade.
Why is someone putting on a facade a problem? Because if you let the narcissist close to you, they will, while seeing your worth and wanting to take it all, will convince you you are worthless so you will submit to them and give them your energy, money, and life. The facade is the lure so you drop your guard. They create an appealing imitation of what you are so you trust them before they take it all from you. Along with longlasting physical and emotional damage.
They are the biggest threat to an artist and they are guaranteed to swarm around any artist, consistently and regularly. You will see the signs, everything is about them. Look at me. Why isn't everyone looking at me. Actually the most important thing about your lifetime of work is how it affected them for 5 minutes, maybe they bought a t shirt or caught a bus. That's more important than your lifetime of work and you should treat it accordingly.
They like to believe if they throw you £5 you can be their eternal servant and energy source, because while they initially approach with shallow 'admiration' without insight or analysis, they believe you are inferior to them and exist to serve them. The gaslighting that an artist can experience while simultaneously having energy, traits and skills they want to drain while being treated as subhuman. You are both valueless and highly valued - they will never admit the latter.
They might act like your lifetimes work is a hobby or novelty. They won't compliment but will say copypaste phrases without sentiment. They might write or say lengthy paragraphs where they repeat your words back to you with slight rephrasings and misunderstandings, like a chatbot, or will find something simple you did which doesn't require observation and sarcastically act like it is the second coming of Jesus. Praising something meaningless while overall treating you as servant, worthless, and demeaning your work and very being.
Of course, if they acted how they really feel they would not gain access. So you get vapid, copypaste 'praise' and imitation which doesn't create happiness or inspiration, no thought evoked, it is just the entry fee to your attention. At the end, the artist will be left near dead, emotionally and physically, in disbelief that someone would adopt an entirely fake personality, be a skinwalker, and insincere appreciator, with the intent of slowly draining every drop of life from you. They actually, most of all, want to see you fail, see you suffer, and access to you is needed for that to happen. An enemy in the package of an 'artist' or fan.
How to spot:- 'selfish online content or 'art' either it has no meaning or it's just about them.
- Not consistent. The feelings and opinions they claim to have do not evenly and equally present themselves day after day, they appear randomly and inconsistently
- They are a grown adult, claim to be an art appreciator and make it their personality, but don't make any art, or if they do, it is unoriginal, meaningless, or plain bad. If they have the intelligence to put something together, it may seem almost ai generated - disconnected, without purpose or meaning or sentiment. The purpose of the 'art' is to create a persona to present to others, rather than help other people, inspire, or express sentiments (inb4 people can make whatever art they want - sure they can but if someone is trying to insert themselves in your life in a negative way, this is one way to spot them. Generally it will be an adult, of course budding artists will have incomplete ideas. But if they are 25+, call themselves an artist, but with incomplete, meaningless or skillless, traced, copied, uninspired etc 'art' it becomes a red flag imo)
- victimhood/sob story. Most people who actually have had bad lives, are suffering or have suffered or been vulnerable, keep quiet about it. You don't announce your vulnerabilies to a crowd. The narcissist will make their sob stories part of their personality as a way to draw attention from sensitive people, and also monopolise care that other people need.
- They are actually jealous of the vulnerable because of the attention and sympathy they may receive (see; munchausen)
- A true artist can only make good art by being honest, caring and attentive about other people. The narcissist can never make good art because they have no actual care for others, they imitate attention and care in order to gain access to another artist's attention (the attention of the artist themselves plus the attention *they* will receive from others is coopted and intercepted).
But they never actually think about anyone other than themselves; it is not interesting to them. They are a fan of nobody, an admirer of nobody, everyone other than them is seen as inferior and dull. So if they claim interest they want your *things* whether that be attention, skills, social network, money, fame, business. They do not admire or care for you. How can you tell the normal person, fan or artist from the narcissist - quickly?
The normal person, fan or artist will not try and insert themselves into your life. They won't attend every public appearance you do, show up at the front and every meet and greet (or artist stall, gallery show, and so on) to ensure you see them. (Meaning you *seeing them* or them forcing you to look at them was the goal, attending at the back or not trying to *be seen* is different, still a bit strange if it's more than a couple of times imo but the insertion/boundary crossing is the issue) They will not talk about your family members or pets by their first names as if you are close. They will not repeat something you posted, said, part of art, etc as if it was a personal conversation you had or reference it like it was an in-joke. They don't use phrases which imply you know each other 'meet' 'last night' 'last weekend with' 'spent evening/night/with' in reference to public sightings (performance, con, stall, etc) 'been with/been a supporter or for x amount of time' in reference to how long they followed you.
All these personal phrases are inappropriate and leading. I have even seen people say things like 'it has been the longest relationship of my life' to refer to admiring an artist for many years. All of this stuff is verbally inserting themselves into the artist's life and are red flags. You might think it's normal but 90% of fans and customers don't do this. It's easy to admire something without trying to act like you are a part of the thing, which these behaviours and phrases do.
I don't know how I would respond to these but I'm gonna make a narc avoidance plan for my future art business because over years of being online, and also my personal life, I have seen it all. I think if someone says something like that to me, I will reply with very clear legal english, them: 'seeing you last night' me: 'I'm glad you enjoyed watching my public performance at (location/online), thank you name/username' them: 'Longest relationship of my life' me: 'I'm glad you have been an online follower of my art accounts for such a long time, thank you name/username' just clarifying statements.
If you reply vaguely, it confirms their misleading statement especially to an outsider reading or overhearing. I also think this behaviour is offputting to potential new fans and customers, imagine going into a shop and there's a weird gaggle of people who don't work there or contribute in any way, but who stand near the till for hours saying strange things - that's the narcissist 'fan' who camps out online and in person to 'lay claim' to the artist they want to subsume.
I think people have free speech (not in england but, theoretically) and are free to express themselves. However I think certain statements and behaviours are inappropriate and are red flags for narcissist fake 'fans' which artists need to be aware of. Normal people tend to keep to themselves, the best type of fans quietly admire without any attempts to imply public connection or history as described above. I think one of the reasons artists are afraid to succeed is the psychological toll of dealing with certain types of people. Over the last year I think I've gained greater understanding and I could handle it now. Every scenario needs clarifiers and deterrents to prevent narcissists having any power over the artist they want to subsume. It's something I didn't really think about until 2024 and actually is a major risk for all artists. Because your enemy puts on a disguise as another artist, or fan, and the red flags or tells are reasomably subtle.
But once someone like that has personal access, they can cause immense destruction or d3ath, as dramatic as it sounds, and they will convince you, truly, that your life doesn't matter anyway and your d3ath will have no impact. It's difficult to be faced with this, a person who wants you d3ad but keeps you around because they want to drain your energy and all that's good about you.
The inappropriate behaviour as described above is intended to lead to this; a situation where they can change the dynamic to be one of draining the life from you. All the effort and time they put into to imitating a safe person for you to trust is insidious - the people who truly do care and help you may not look so different. The small tells of inconsistency, lack of good art, shallow 'attention' or 'appreciation' boundary crossing, lack of insight or consideration of others, all these are necessary to tell the real from the fake.