First time I hold you - A.C
part I: nothingâs gonna hurt you baby - fresh out the slammer
content/warnings: mdni, established relationship, pregnancy, mental health, soft!andrew, girldad!andrew, pet name angel, flashback from later seasons
summary: you found out youâre pregnant after andrew got arrested (pre s1)
wc: 3.6k
a/n: ay first time writing ever, didnât think itâd took 2 weeks itâs a lot harder than i thought but IâM SO GLAD I FINISHED THIS. anyway i hope yâall enjoy this fic, idk if it make sense or not kinda just my excuse to write yearning fic tbh. so let me know what you think or content/warning i left out or if you wanna be tag for the next part (gonna take a while). also check out fanart on my blog!
dividers by @uzmacchiato
partII
One thing Andrew Cody does to keep himself somewhat sane is count, whether itâs the steps as he paces around the room, the boxes of cereal or even days. When heâs not taking his meds, sometimes heâd mix up imaginary with reality. Counting days often helps or simply keeping track of important days so he wonât lose them in the sea of illusion. He could remember the date when you first met, the first time he asked you out and most importantly your anniversary. Though thereâs one day he wishes he could erase from his memory.
3 years and 19 days ago, the California sun was rising as he stood in front of your house, a waterfront house with a beautiful view (he bought it for you just last month after he asked for your hand). Heâs been standing there for quite some time, making sure for the 10th time the doorâs lock properly before he leaves for the job. Itâs still early, you were sleeping and he just canât risk anyone breaking into your house when heâs gone.
Heâs out on a job with the Baz, sitting beside his brother in the stolen car as they scout the area, see how the land lies before going in. The street is quiet, not many people wandering around, which is great. His eyes still fixed on the bank when he brought up Cath and how Baz needs to do better with her and Lena, sure heâs engaged to you but it doesnâtchange the fact that she was his friend. Baz didnât look too happy when they got out, striding across the street to the building. Andrew followed close, shotgun in hand as he threatened the clerk to put money in the bag. Things were going just like they planned, it didnât take long for the alarm to go off, he looks down at his watch to see how much time they have left. He then tosses Baz the money bag before telling him to go get the car while he collects more money from the civilian. Before Baz could step out suddenly everything is going sideway. He tripped. The guard tried to reach for his gun. Andrew has to pull the guard away for Baz to get the car. They take turns punching for about half a minute, and soon the guardâs lying face down, blood on the floor. By the time he rushed out, the car was driving away almost out of sight already. All it takes is 16 seconds for Baz to leave him behind, 16. Last thing he remembers before he got busted is that he was running, as fast as he could while Baz saved himself. Itâs not the first time Baz bailed on him either. It wouldn't matter that much to him before but now he has you to come home to, it shattered him just to think about how long itâll be until he sees you again if he got caught, it made his chest boiled how could Baz just left?. Even then as he sits on the back of the copâs car, all he worries about is how youâd be waiting, cooking his favourite meal maybe curl up on the couch, fell asleep while you wait. He missed you already.
When he realised Smurf couldnât help him out, part of him was full of anger from the betrayal. On the other hand, he couldnât help but forgive her, sheâs his mother after all. He could almost accept the state he was in until a week later you sent him a letter. Youâre pregnant, 2months. It changed everything. How is he supposed to take this? Heâs in a fucking prison while his fiancĂŠe is pregnant with his child. One, two, three, four, five, six, he counts his steps as he paces around the cell, your letter clutched in one hand, all of a sudden the room felt smaller like itâs shrinking around him. That night hedidnât sleep, didnât even try, he has too many thoughts that needed to be processed. He just sits on the metal thing they call bed, eyes fixed ahead at the wall. What is he gonna do? What can he even do being in prison like this?
38 days gone by, he has never responded to your letter. No, you deserve better. He's sentenced for 6 years, the kid would be 5ish by then and they wouldnât know their father. They shouldn't, heâs a criminal. No, he canât have that, thatâs his decision. The guilt would gnaw him alive not being there for you and the kid. But for your sake, he has to let you go. He knows you loved him, though it still surprised him that you kept sending him letters after letters, eager to tell him about your day, about the baby, and also send him the ultrasound after you went to your first appointment alone. He keeps everything you sent him. Heâd look at them every night, take time memorising each small details. A few hours later heâd get tired, then heâd hold them close to his heart before he goes to sleep (if he did sleep at all and not just stare at the ceiling).
Then you came, he looks at you through the glass, itâs so close yet so far away. You managed to give him a small smile, he always wondered how you have that smile when youâre with him. The roomâs poorly lit with the dark wall around it but with you here itâs radiant enough.
âHey, Andyâ You greet him first. One hand rests on your belly, still not that noticeable but he could see youâre changing, glowing. He avoids your eyes, heâs having a hard time adjusting to this horrible place and a hard time trying to let you go. He canât bring himself to speak, heâd break as soon as he does. But god, if he wouldn't trade his soul just to whisper sweet nothing to you as he holds you in his arms in this moment. So he just listens to you talk, only responds with a mumble âyeahâ and âokayâ, his eyes fixed on your belly. It's getting harder and harder to comprehend whatâs really happening. one, two, three, four, five, six, he counts your breath, it calms him down a little to know that youâre here with him.
92 days, another ultrasound with a letter. The size of a banana you say? Then itâs almost like heâs choking his own spit, his chest tightened as he sees the word, Girl. He canât tell if this is really happening or if he's just made it all up, his mind is playing tricks on him lately. Sometimes heâd hear Smurfâs voice or your voice telling him how heâs not good enough for the baby nor deserve to have good things in his life. He knows heâs a sinner, not a saint and definitely not a pope, but he doesn't need reminders. He recalls when he was little, holding that boy under water after he persecuted Julia, remembers the look she gave him after, what would his daughter think of him?
âIf we confess our sins, he is faithful and just and will forgive us our sins and purify us from all unrighteousness.â John 1:9 is what keeps him going. It gives him hope that whatever he did, it could be forgiven, heâs desperate for forgiveness and a chance to rinse himself clean for a new life. Hopefully with you if youâd still have him.
165 days, when Andrew went to prison, you had to take more jobs since you didnât want to take money or anything in general from Smurf. It takes a while for you to be free enough to send a request to visit him face-to-face in prison and a whole month to get the approval. You canât wait to see him. The day you finally visit him you choose a light purple maternity dress on purpose, you know he secretly loves purple (lavender) and itâd be good for him to see some colour apart from the same old uniform every day. You were pacing around the room when the guard took him inside. Your eyes light up immediately at the sight of your man. You take a step closer, so does he.
âHey angelâ He greets you first this time, his hand clenches into a fist beside him at the urge to reach out, to feel your body underneath the palm of his hand. He needs to know your real.
Almost as if the baby could hear his voice, you feel the sudden kick. You let out a small laugh before reaching for his hand, bringing it to rest against the bump.
âCan you feel that? I think she knows her daddy's voice.â And you smile. He loves your smile, the way your eyes seem to brighten the world (his world), the way your lip curls up, you seem to belong in heaven not in a hellhole like this place.
âYeah..I could feel thatâ He murmurs before reluctantly removing his hand.
You both sit down and you start rambling about your life while he just sits there happy to hear your voice that didn't come from inside his head.
âYou know I'd come sooner but I've been taking more jobs, people're getting married a lot these past months.â As a floral designer, it's a golden opportunity for you and he knows it, but still.
âYou shouldn't be working too much. Didn't Baz pay you my cut? I told him toâ He frowns. Every cent of his cut should go straight to you, he told Baz that.
âEasy, honey. I told him to save it for you after you got out. You know I don't want Smurf money.â You let out a sigh.
âIt's MY money, I earned itâ He said sharply, giving you a glare.
âWell, you can use it for our daughter after you get out, but i won't take any money from Smurf's hand or Baz.â You stand your ground and now it's his turn to sigh. He knows you're stubborn but that's one of millions of reasons why he loves you.
You stay for about an hour, after you leave he spends all day with you on his mind, at least itâs better than counting things or making bed again and again even if itâs already tidy.
210 days, this time is not an ultrasound but rather a picture of your newborn baby girl, lying on your chest. Shit, he could get on his knee for you again if itâd express how grateful he is for you giving him another reason to live. Youâre smiling but the tiredness in your eyes mixed with trace of tears could be seen. He wishes he could at least hold your hand while you give him a miracle, a perfect mix of you and him. Under the picture have your handwriting that says âAudrey.â On the other side have a short note âShe got your eyes. Anyway I hope you like the name, kind of sounds like yours. Love you, always.â After everything, you still tell him you love him, his heart almost gave out at the thought. Heâd dig his way out of this place and knock off anyone who got in his way back home to you if you just say the word. The only thing holding him back is that he knows you wouldnât want that. So he just keeps his head low, maybe heâd have a chance of getting out early.
Later that night when he looked back at the picture, it made him think of Julia. How long has it been since he last saw her? Too long. Suddenly, all the memories float through him like an old film, pictures blur and fading. All those timetogether, he protecting her from the outside world while she protecting him from the inside, from himself and Smurf. She has a kid too, Josh. Maybe he could visit her, take you and the baby with him too. Itâd be nice after a long, long time.
365 days, one year passed in blur, memories mix with reality. You didnât send him letters as frequently as before, busy taking care of the baby. Itâs tearing him apart day by day. He wants to reach out, his heart burns trying to resist the urge. Itâs better this way, maybe you will start to forget him, bury him with the past as you move on with your life. But even when he try to be reasonable, the deepest part of his heart still hopes that when he gets out youâd take him back. Heâd do anything for you, heâll try to be the best husband and dad, hell heâd even find a way to move the ocean for you if you ask him to. But you wouldnât, you love the ocean, the air, the sound of waves crashing, thatâs why he bought a 2 mil house by the beach for you in a heartbeat after you said you liked it.
1 year and 117days, things are getting dark for him, late at night as he lay on the hard metal bed, walls surrounding him while thoughts consumed his mind. Too much thought, too many voices that didnât seem to go away no matter how hard he tried. The counting and the ordering didnât do much help either. Heâs not doing well. Though when the morning comeshe receives your letter, itâs almost like a light pulling him out of the darkness of his soul. You told him that the baby started babbling already. It makes his heart clench when you said you show your baby pictures of him and tell her itâs her daddy. âI donât want you to be a stranger in your own homeâ is what you said. Oh, Angel, only if you knew how much it means to him, he wouldnât survive this long without you. He imagines hearing the word dad as he enters the house, itsounds foreign yet it sent spark of joy through him, he never had a dad growing up. Baby, his baby girl, whatâd she be like? Does she cry a lot or all smiley like her mom? What food would she like? She could eat solid food now right? Heâd need to learn a lot about how to be a dad after this but heâd be more than happy to.
1 year and 210days, the baby is one year old already. He wants to be there, he needs to be there for her first birthday, apart of him got ripped apart as the day goes by being away from you and the baby. If he has a chance to be there heâd buy her toys, books anything for his baby girl. Heâd read her bedtime story as he tucked her in for the night. Heâd watch her sleep, count her breath just to stop the voices in his head, to make sure itâs all real and that sheâs safe and sound. But thatâs just happened inside his head, his mind didnât know that though, itâs real enough for now.
The reality kicks in later when the guard tells him he has a visitor. When he entered the small room his eyes immediately found you, sitting on the chair across the table with your baby on your lap. Youâve been wanting to visit him again after the birth but you waited for the baby to grow enough so you can take her here too, itâs a special day after all. He doesnât know what to do, his eyes bore into yours as he stands there, frozen. You could feel your eyes burn, throat tighten, what has this place done to him? What brings the two of you back is the sound of the baby babbling âdadaaâ as she points at him. Shit, this is real, heâs not dreaming and now his world is crumbling. He inches closer to you as you get up, then there goes a hug. He wraps his arms around you, pressing a gentle kiss on your temple. He could smell the scent of your hair, feel the softness of your skin. He then looked down at the baby in your arms. God, sheâs so tiny, his heart leaps when she reaches out for him. He looks back at you like heâs asking for permission before he hesitantly takes her from you when you nod. Fortunately, the guard that accompanied him were paid by Smurf, almost everyone is paid by her so you get to have this privilege.
The first time that the weight of the baby settled in his arms, his whole world changed, almost like someone woke him up from a nightmare with cold water, itâs real. He could see her eyes, hazel just like his, her tiny nose, suddenly heâs hyperaware of everything, itâs too much for him to process. You look at him with the baby, notice the feather-light kiss he pressed on her head, he wouldnât want to hurt her in any way. The sight fills the void in you, you missed him terribly.After a few moments he hand her back to you before sitting down on the chair across from you. When youâre seated with the baby, you reach out for his hand, hold it in yours, thump rubbing his knuckle before you start talking.
âWe missed you, Andy.â You smile softly at him. Heâs now glancing away, guilt written all over his face.
âI miss you too, Angel.â He mumbles before finally looking back at you, giving that desperate gaze that makes your heart flutter. âI-I wish I could be there for you.â He let out a shaky sigh, pausing for a moment then he blurted out. âDo you think itâs possible for me to start over? Iâll do everything you asked, I promise. Itâs just- youâre the only one who really cares about me. I canât-.â His voice cracked, shaking his head before looking down at the ground.
âHey, Andrew look at me.â You squeeze his hand gently. âOf course, we can start over together, alright? Iâll be waiting for you no matter how long it takes and Iâm sure our baby girl will want you back too.â You assure him. He smiled, itâs small almost unnoticeable but itâs the first time in months.
The conversation continued for an hour or so, during that time you never let go of his hand, you kept him grounded. He didnât want this to end, neither do you but when the time comes you both have to say goodbye and go back to your own world.
1 year and 238days, on this exact day is the day he asked you out, not knowing his life would change for the better. Years ago he was obsessed with Cath and the fault love he feels for her. He went to buy her flowers, maybe itâs fate considering that at the time you didnât have much event to work on, so you opened your small flower shop to keep yourself busy. You always thought whoever he buys flowers for must be the luckiest woman ever since he came back week after week for 3months.
He didn't know since when his feelings for Cath shifted but the day Cath told him it was weird for him to give her flower she didnât feel as hurt as he thought itâd be. It takes him all night staring out the window to know the reason he keeps buying her flowers is because he wanted to see you, to hear your words telling him how nice it is for him to get flower for the woman he loves or he thought he did. The next day he comes back to your shop, though not for flowers but to take his chances and ask you out. You were surprised but you said yes.
It makes him smile thinking about the good old days, he could still hear your words echo in the deep chamber of his memory, your scent too but itâs fading, so is the warm spread through his body where your hand once held. The small piece of you he has with him now is your letters and his engagement ring. Heâs grateful they let him keep his ring.
2 years 3days, for the first time ever, he called. He canât bear pushing you away any longer, the precious part of him still clings onto you and every time he pushes you away heâs back to Pope. He just wants to be your Andrew.
When you pick up the phone the panic in your voice is obvious. You ask him if he's okay, if heâs hurt. âNo, just talk, pleaseâ Was all he said. It confuses you, he never calls, why would he call now if itâs not emergency, yet you keep talking.You hope heâd call you more, the sound of his voice is something you never want to forget.
Sometimes when you couldn't sleep, youâd ask him to talk. Youâd lie your head on his chest, listen to the steady heartbeat and the way his chest rumbles as he speaks. It was something he learned to love. For him itâs not as simple. At the beginning of your relationship when he couldnât sleep he didn't dare to ask for your comfort, heâd rather lie there and watch you sleep than be vulnerable. But after 6months in heâd grown comfortable enough to ask for it, then he realised itâs better than he could imagine.
3 years and 19 days, heâs out. The smell of fresh air has never been this good. He had been waiting for this day for so long and he knew the only place he ever wanted to be after this was back home with you.

















