the fallacy of the two cakes meme is that it assumes there are actually a lot of the "holy shit, two cakes!" guy. if the cake that isn't yours is getting praised to high heaven while no one's taken a single bite of yours, let alone said they enjoyed it, of course you're going to feel like your cake was inferior, maybe even that you're a failure as a baker, and no amount of waving that meme in front of people disappointed that no one liked their cake is going to make them feel better about it. it's almost mutated into another example of internet toxic positivity.
Yeah, it's... fandom IS full of people who are at least partly in it for popularity and clout, and of people who are neurotic about comparing their hits-to-kudos ratio to that of every other fic in the fandom and feel like every rec someone else's fic gets is an indictment of theirs, and both those types need periodic reminders to relax!
It's just ALSO full of people whose problem is... not that.
Someone who just wishes their fics or ideas or blorbo posts got SOME engagement isn't going to be helped by a cheerful "unclench, it's not about the popularity!"
Also this is going to sound mean but I feel like the two cakes thing applies more the more... cookie-cutter the fics are?
I mean, I'm not innocent here. I just recently had a resurgence of interest in an old fandom and I must've read a dozen "my OTP are overcome by passion while working in the lab" scenarios in the last couple of days. Sometimes that's exactly what one wants! And execution matters! And smut or fluff doesn't mean there's no depth or real emotion!
But still, the more complex or rare an idea is, the more likely that people are going to look down on one of the two creators for plagiarizing - even if that's not what's going on! (Which it often isn't. More than one person's creativity can be sparked by the same post or theory, and sometimes they go in similar directions, and you'd think fic writers of all people would get that, but...)
Or, even if no one gets mad at you for bringing a second cake to the party, they're just not going to be wanting a second similar dessert after gorging themselves on the first one.






















