I binged Wednesday a few days ago and I’m still having thoughts about it. Thought I’d write them down in an attempt to move on.
For the most part, I really enjoyed it. Loved almost all the characters, loved the setting, loved the mystery and loved the acting. Jenna Ortega was fantastic, as she always is and everyone else did a great job with what they had to work with.
Honestly, my only issue with it was the love triangle. I’m one of those people that felt that Wednesday shouldn’t have had a love interest, let alone two. The writers could have done the correct, smart thing and not included one, but they felt the need to include two. I can only guess it’s because the characters are teenagers, but with Wednesday it just felt unneeded, cliché and poorly written.
Throughout the entire season I didn’t once get the impression that Wednesday was into either boy, so I was confused when she kept agreeing to do things with Tyler, like the dance and the date. Wednesday gave off absolutely zero romantic vibes, so why not just shut it down and tell him she wasn’t interested. After seeing an interview with Jenna, I think I now have an idea of what happened.
Jenna didn’t want a love triangle, she was against it. Jenna said that Wednesday’s primary interest was the monster and the mystery and her interest in the boys wasn’t genuine but just amusement and that boys are the last thing on Wednesday’s mind.
Seems to me that Jenna had a much better idea of her character than the writers did. So going to the dance and on the date were just an amusing distraction, not because Wednesday was actually into it. This at least makes sense with Wednesday’s absolute non-romantic interest in the boys. I’d love to see the script. Did Jenna play it how it was written, or was Wednesday meant to actually care and Jenna decided not to play it like that?
So, the love interests. Xavier was obviously the secondary one. I found it funny that they’d met as kids and Wednesday didn’t remember him. He had to tell that very specific story to get her to remember. Given that for most of the season, Wednesday thought he was the Hyde, there really wasn’t any romance here. Xavier as a person seems kinda terrible. Broke up with Bianca, basically accusing her of using her powers on him when there was no evidence she did. Also asked Bianca, who still seemed into him, at the dance they went to together, to take his memories of Wednesday away. Imagine you’re Bianca and how bad that would make you feel.
Looks like he’s being set up as the future love interest. Jenna also has an issue with this. In another interview (she also mentions being against the love triage here) she said she’d like them to become good friends as safe, platonic friendships between men and women aren’t shown often enough.
I love Jenna for having the courage to speak out like this. I feel like a lot of actors wouldn’t criticise the writers, but Jenna obviously knows her worth.
Now, Tyler. For the most part, I found him to be inoffensive. Apart from the “mixed signals” scene, which was a red flag as Wednesday had given him no signals, he wasn’t too bad. There also wasn’t really much there, he was just a generic “nice” guy. It was funny after finding out he’s the Hyde, Wednesday wasn’t upset. Her only response was a one liner about the first boy she kissed being a monster. This goes back to the fact that Wednesday gave off no romantic vibes and Jenna played it as Wednesday not genuinely being into him.
I would hope he’s off the board as far as love interests go. We learnt in episode 8 that he did remember what he did as the Hyde, and he enjoyed it. Given that he almost killed Eugene, one of two people Wednesday forms an actual emotional bond with, I don’t see her forgiving him.
Now it’s time to talk about Enid, who’s the only other person Wednesday seems to actually care about at Nevermore. Their relationship also doesn’t come across as romantic. However, I feel that if the writers continue to force romance onto Wednesday, this one would at least make sense.
Unlike with Tyler and Xavier, Wednesday does seem to care about Enid’s thoughts and feelings. All we need to do is look at the scenes where Enid moves out and the climatic hug to confirm this. Wednesday is genuinely upset when Enid moves out, we can contrast this with scenes of Tyler and Xavier being mad and her, and her not giving a damn.
The hug is also the emotional highlight of the show and the culmination of their relationship. Wednesday has backed away from hugs in the past, but here she hugs Enid back. It’s not just a pity hug either, or because Wednesday thinks Enid deserves it. She hugs Enid tightly, emotionally, while closing her eyes. This is probably the most emotional we see Wednesday all season and, unlike the Tyler kiss, this doesn’t end badly.
I also found it interesting that Enid is the one who saves Wednesday from Tyler. In a lot of stories it’s the love interest who saves the main character, but here it’s Enid. It’s even more interesting when a bit later we see Xavier try to save Wednesday from Joseph, which fails spectacularly and results in Wednesday getting hurt.
It would be very easy to turn this from a friendship to a romance. A lot easier than establishing something with Xavier, or someone new. I also don’t think they’ll do this. Gough and Millar have written for shows with wlw rep, The Shannara Chronicles and Into the Badlands, but I get the impression they are pushing the Wenclair friendship and want to keep them straight. This is also stupid because the whole point of the show is about being an outcast. They even equate this with being queer with Enid’s subplot about conversion camp and her parents accepting her for who she is. Many queer people still fell like outcasts and this show could do so much good in having their main character, who has so much name recognition, be actually queer.
That was a lot. If you liked the romances I’m happy for you. I do hope there’s a season two as the good greatly outweighed the bad.
I see Wenclair is already a popular tag :)
izzy806
ellievsbear
dailybridgerton
prguitarman
pixelskylines
vaporwave
