high school!daryl dixon x fem!reader
warnings/tags: totally not inspired by the virgin suicides, smut, high school era characters but they’re both 18, p in v, make-out sesh, insecure reader, consent checks, reassurance, crying at one point, implied aftercare?, first time nerves, virginity loss, daryl being so sweet it hurts
homecoming used to be something you didn’t look forward to. it was always a little boring, stuck in the corner dancing with your shadow while others bounced and cheered in the glowing lights. you never thought you’d ever find a guy that would go with you, let alone offer to dance with you. but this year was different. you’d worked up the courage to approach your long-time crush, daryl dixon, over the summer, and everything changed for you when the autumn winds came calling.
you and daryl had just had the time of your lives. crowned prom queen and king, you two snuck out of the party in the gym, wanting to find a place to watch the stars.
somewhere in your mind, you knew stargazing with the school’s pretty boy would lead to what you’d been hoping and longing for.
butterflies soared in your stomach, the both of you lost in each other on the deserted football field. his lips were on yours, sharing the sugary flutter of first love. daryl guided you through it, and you were glad he took over, letting you slowly gain your confidence as you went.
daryl’s touch moved downward, getting a handful of your ass, smirking when you giggled against his mouth. you peppered little kisses all along his jaw, watching his pale skin flush, his eyes gleaming in the misty moonlight.
you could feel the moment pushing further, knowing from the feeling in your stomach exactly where this was going. daryl knew it too, his touch growing more insistent. you were just as desperate, but still so scared.
“want you…” you admitted, a tremble in your breathless voice. daryl reached for you, not to touch your chest just yet, but to take off your sash, following with his own.
daryl licked his lips, pretty eyes heavy-lidded. “i want you too, baby.”
when you kissed him again, a million emotions flooded over you. wonder, ecstasy, and melancholy all at once, all at war with your fragile mind.
he was so warm, so fucking handsome… his eyes, his hands all over you… his lips feel so good… were you being immature? could he see the stretch marks on your legs? how could he ever love someone as pathetic as you, let alone fuck?
you opened your eyes, tears slipping out from the overwhelming surge of it all.
“i just.. jus’ can’t believe I’m doing this.”
he stopped, the look in his eyes almost as shy and soft as yours.
“you know we don’t gotta do this, ‘ight?”
“no, no, no, please— i really want to.”
“i want it too, yknow. want you so bad.”
daryl dove in again, leading you with a tilt of his head. your hand came up to brush his jawline, so perfectly chiseled. you felt as if you were walking on a dream.
you both pulled away at once, and then he took your hand in his. “c’mere.”
he leaned forward for more of your sweet taste, lip balm and candy and something floral, dew on roses and fresh summer honeysuckle. all the while, he guided you until your back was pressed into the grass, neither of you minding the mist over the field.
daryl quickly came over you, the both of you tangled up in each other, furious kisses contrasting with gentle hands on each other, exploring, dancing, intertwining. your fingers worked on the buttons of his shirt, only undoing the top few, just enough to see the little tattoos on his chest and collarbone. you leaned up to kiss the tiny x at the junction of his shoulder and neck, sending a shiver through him.
you were so fucking proud of yourself for that.
still, it was as if your thoughts were linked, despite your experiences. if you were afraid to unbutton his shirt, he wouldn’t rip your dress off and throw his cares to the wind. he was a charmer, but he’d hate to scare away something so dear and sweet.
he trailed his hand up the skirt of your dress, bunching up the floral satin around your hips. he loved the way it fit on you, so flattering on the body that you hated. he drew his tongue across your bottom lip, and you answered his question, accepting him into your mouth. it only made your panties more damp, kissing him deeper like this. you figured out quick that you’d be asking him to do that all the time.
as daryl pulled away, he took a moment to gaze down at you, just to see how beautiful you were again. your sash had been discarded so he could paw at you, your little silver pendant visible along the elegant line of your neck. your face seemed to glow in the light of the moon that reflected off the dew-spotted grass.
he reached down, unbuckling his belt with shaking hands, pushing his pants down his thighs just enough to free his dick. you followed, hooking your fingers into your panties, pulling them down and off. you bit your lip at the sight, reaching out to stroke him while he spread your wetness over your folds.
“am i doing this right?” you breathed, already a mess this far in. daryl hissed at the feeling of your hand, pumping in that perfect rhythm, your thumb rubbing over his tip making him gasp.
“so right, baby,” he groaned, sighing in bliss as he let you take over, eventually pulling your hand away when he felt he was ready.
“mmhm,” you hummed back, nodding slowly, pressing your lips to his chin as he settled on top of you once more. “jus’ go slow.”
daryl ran his hand over himself once, twice, hands braced on your hips. “hold onto me.”
he eased forward then, slow and careful, his dick finally making its way inside you. a little whine slipped from your lips at the feeling, his tip running along your sensitive walls as he let you adjust. he groaned into your neck, fingers tangling in the grass. your head spun at the stretch, the slight discomfort giving way to a heady fullness that made your skin tingle with warmth.
“really good…” you mused, reaching up to run your hand over his soft brown hair. his nose bumped yours, and he smiled shyly, leaning down for a kiss, slow and saccharine-rich. you swore you’d never forget the flavor of him, bubblegum and the subtle earthiness of cigarette smoke.
he pulled back slowly, leaving space for you before he pushed forward again, grinding his hips in an easy circle. he watched as your lips parted, head tilting with a soft moan, partly of pleasure and the slightest bit of uneasiness.
“you okay?” he whispered, more to himself than you. “it don’t hurt, right?”
“no, no, i promise… keep going, dar.”
he ducked down to kiss your neck, chuckling against your skin, partly to hide the pang of timidness he felt. he may have been confident, but he still had those worries somewhere, bone-deep, wanting to please you as much as those models in the magazines he read. he started his pace, fucking you slow and steady, breaths slowly starting to match his rhythm.
you didn’t know where the hell to put your hands. you touched every inch of him, fingers running along his broad shoulders through the fine-threaded linen of his shirt. you felt as if you were floating as he took his time thrusting in and out, all those dreams you had of him at last becoming real.
daryl silenced you with a strong kiss, tongue boldly tasting yours, still going steady enough to draw a gasp from your lips as he pulled away.
“don’t be,” he murmured, tucking your hair behind your ear. “just feel me, kay?”
and you did. he filled you like nothing you’d ever had before. your hands were graceful, but they didn’t have the rhythm of daryl’s hips, gentle and calculated all at once, knowing exactly how to make you melt. this was his goal: to see that pretty girl he’d been wanting for so long come undone for the first time.
“there you go… shit, baby.”
you whimpered and gripped his shoulders, and he sensed it. he’d found your g-spot before you even could. you moaned softly against his neck, wanting to bury your head deeper in embarrassment. of course, he didn’t let you.
he pushed you gently back into the grass, focusing on how lovely you looked underneath him: long hair fanned out below you, tiara tilted atop your head, dress pushed up so he could have perfect access while keeping you warm enough on the cold, dew-spotted field. your cheeks were wet and rosy, a lovely warm flush that he could gaze at for hours on end.
“you like that? huh?” he smirked, rolling his hips in a teasing circle, tip brushing oh-so right against that place. “that your sweet spot, hmm?”
“uh-huh,” you mumbled in reply, completely drunk on the feeling it gave you. “c-can you do that again?”
and he did, a little harder this time, watching you twitch and cry out louder. he could tell you were holding back, scared to truly lose yourself.
“there’s nobody out here,” he reassured you, glancing over his shoulder, returning himself to you. “cry for me, baby.”
he adjusted his angle, holding up your leg and driving into you faster, hitting that sweet spot of yours over and over. you squeezed him hard enough to make him curse and clench his fist, your own hands curling into his arms for leverage. the two of you were a beautiful disaster, doomed from the start because of your awkwardness, somehow blooming into something far beyond what you thought you’d ever get. You being comfortable enough to be so vulnerable with him only made him fall harder.
“daryl…” you pulled back to look at him with nervous eyes. this was the only part you didn’t know the feeling of. “i think i’m gonna come.”
“me too, baby,” he murmured, lips trailing up your neck, leaving marks across your collarbone and chest that bloomed in burgundy and pink. he reached down to rub at your swollen bud, watching your legs twitch and your face twist in bliss.
“don’t you stop, sunshine.”
“o-oh my god— daryl, please!”
you clutched him tighter, and he let you, reveling in your sweet noises, those soft whines and moans that made him swoon further over you. he was everywhere — the scent of his shirt, the guidance of his hands, the warmth of his body moving over yours, the softness of his hair as you ran your fingers through it.
“dar… m’gonna… fuck, i’m gonna—“
“come on, baby. i gotcha.”
and you did, crying out as warmth flooded your skin, coating daryl’s length with your sweet release, he reached for your hand, gripping it tight as he his rhythm turned erratic. he thrusted into you sloppily, slowing down until he came with a groan, letting himself finish inside your heat. he collapsed on top of you, careful of his weight, holding you there on the field. the scent of sweat and daryl’s shirt surrounded you, the both of you dizzy on the comedown of your high, bodies tingling, exchanging shared breaths.
“you ok?” he finally asked, lifting himself up on his spent arms. you nodded, answering with a sleepy “mmhm”, hands cupping his face for one last kiss. it was slow and almost agonizing, knowing you’d never get to relive a time this good. that was what made your first time all the more special.
“how was i?” daryl asked, rubbing your shoulder where he’d bit a little too hard.
“the best i’ve ever had,” you sighed dreamily, squeezing his bicep weakly, as if to make sure you weren’t dreaming.
“the only one you’ve ever had,” he joked, playfully leaning in to peck and nibble at your neck. “you were fuckin’ amazing.”
“so were you…” you admitted, voice trailing off as he pulled out, drawing a whimper from your lips and a faint moan from his own. sensitive from your orgasm, you pressed your legs together, keeping his spend safe. “did i—“
“you were great, baby. don’t ever doubt it, ‘kay?” he reassured you, pressing a chaste kiss to the corner of your mouth. he pulled your panties back up, helping you sit up and put your sash back on.
“c’mon… i’ll clean you up and drive you home.”