"Somehow, Palpatine returned."
It gets held up as an example of terrible writing, chanted ad nauseum by the online masses like a gotcha that will end all debates.
"Somehow, Palpatine returned."
Because wouldn't that be stupid? Wouldn't it be so stupid if there was a huge war that was fought against an insidious, genocidal, fascist regime, and millions upon millions of people died before victory was finally declaredâonly for those same fascist, supremacist, genocidal ideals to make a resurgence a few short decades later?
"Somehow, Palpatine returned."
Wouldn't it be utterly vacuous, you guys? Wouldn't it make a mockery of the lives that were sacrificed the first time around? Wouldn't it be ridiculous if the democratically elected leadership saw the warning signs that this malignant ideology was gaining momentum once again, and half of them were too busy infighting and enriching themselves to bother doing anything to stop it, while the other half were actively cultivating and promoting it because they saw an opportunity to exploit it for their own advancement?Â
"Somehow, Palpatine returned."
Wouldn't it be so idiotic if a single, elderly woman, who'd been fighting the good fight her entire life, could have such a far-reaching influence that the resistance would crumble upon her death? It would be so unrealistic, wouldn't it? For one person to be all that was standing in the way of a repressive, corrupt government systematically stripping away the rights of vulnerable and historically oppressed groups? The good guys won, remember? People would never stand by and watch the rights for which they'd sacrificed so much and fought so hard be simply wiped away.
"Somehow, Palpatine returned."
And wouldn't it be such a cliche for the figurehead of this cult-like fascist movement to be a shambling corpse, a repugnant, cartoonish, Scooby-Doo-level, mustache-twirling villain? Nobody would fall for someone so obviously evil, right? There's no way someone like that could rally enough people to his cause to actually amass any meaningful power.
"Somehow, Palpatine returned."
Such terrible writing. That would never happen in real life.