My developing theory about Riley
We still donât know who Riley is. We donât know anything about her family. We donât know why everyone treats her like a child or why she just goes along with it.
Iâve got a theory forming about who she might be. Hereâs the breakdown.
In the first episode, she mentions that her car was actually her grandmotherâs.
But then in this update, Mrs. Romano calls her an orphan and a charity case. I donât know if she meant that Riley was actually an orphan or if she was just insinuating that Riley wasnât one of them.
But if she truly is an orphan, it would explain why we havenât heard anything about her parents. So maybe Riley lost her parents somehow, then was raised by her grandmother until she died. After that, she was put in the system. The Fairchilds then took her in as a foster child. It makes them look generous and charitable just in time for Marcusâs reelection. It also conveniently overshadowâs Lilyâs terrible behavior.
Iâm getting the feeling that Riley wasnât actually from that town. We know she stayed with the Fairchilds for that one summer when they were 16. But she wasnât present for the first mixer with Lilyâs harp performance. Sheriff Hawthorne also didnât recognize her when she drove in.
I had previously assumed Riley was staying with the Fairchilds for the summer because she was friends with Lily. But I donât think thatâs it. I think the Fairchilds took her in and she lived with them for some timeâno more than a year.
After Lilyâs death, she was no longer part of the LIsâ lives. They all continue to live their lives in that town without her. Yeah, she goes to college out of town, but she left before they even finished high school.
If she was being fostered by the Fairchilds, it makes sense that sheâd be removed from their home following the death of one of their own children. They wouldâve been deemed unfit to foster her. She wouldâve been placed into a different home after that.
This also aligns with my White Oleander comparison. It would also explain why Riley doesnât seem to have her own identity.
Not only that, Lily was about to be shipped off to a boarding school. If Riley really was being fostered by the Fairchilds, she wouldâve then replaced Lily while Lily was away. But Lily dying threw a wrench in that plan. The state took her away and they were no longer able to make her part of the family.
Now fast forward five years, theyâre throwing this elaborate wedding and Vivienne is oh so eager to induct Riley as an official Fairchild.
Why is everyone worried about Riley?
Declan, Fabian, Luna, and Emma all seem extra protective and worried about her. They treat her like sheâs fragile. Declan and Emma have both implied that she might be a danger to herself.
So my next question is this: What happened to Riley in the aftermath of Lilyâs death? Did she feel guilty and try to kill herself? Did she have a mental breakdown and get sent to a psychiatric facility? Or are they aware of some tragic past that we just donât know about yet?
Surely, she must have some sort of traumatic past. She shakes off trauma like itâs a regular thing. Sheâs almost numb to it. She just picks herself up and keeps going, because thatâs how sheâs had to live her whole life.
I think we also havenât seen much of her past because her life has been lived in fragments. Years with Mom. Years with Grandma. Year with the Fairchilds. Year in Foster Home 2. College.
Putting it altogether, my theory is this:
Riley was an orphan the Fairchilds were fostering as a charity case. It was supposed to make them look good. Lily had issues with the law and made them look bad. Riley was agreeable and everybody took a liking to her. They decided to ship Lily off to boarding school and to keep Riley, eventually adopting her. Everyone would forget about Lily and celebrate Riley instead. They would also get the glory for whatever success Riley achieved in the future, because without them, none of it wouldâve been possible.
Lily was onto their plan and began her own plan of sabotage. She decided that if she died, then everyone would mourn her and remember her positively. While it also would make Marcus and Vivienne look like terrible, negligent parents. Marcus would lose his election. Most importantly, they wouldnât be able to replace her with Riley, because Riley would get taken away. Thatâs exactly what happened.
Oh. Another thing, Lily sabotaged Rileyâs future chances with Fabian/Luna. By dating them, sheâs permanently put Riley in her shadow. And we see this now in the present. Riley feels uneasy pursuing anything with Fabian and Iâm assuming Luna for wlw. They will always remember Lily first and are now marked with feelings of betrayal, secrecy, and being left behind.
Years later, Amelia is getting married. This is the perfect opportunity to invite Riley because she was âlike part of the family.â Conveniently, Marcus is also running for reelection.
The wedding event is three months long because itâs all a plan to absorb Riley into their world. This is why Vivienne is trying to set her up with Julian. If Riley marries Julian, then she would stay in town permanently. Vivienne could continue to pretend to be the benevolent mother figure and act like Riley was the long lost daughter who returned. Riley then fulfills her role as the âtrophy daughterâ. She makes them look good and erases their tarnished reputation left behind by Lily. And again, whatever success she achieves in the future would be credited to the Fairchilds for their wonderful, benevolent hearts.
Riley needs to decide who she really is and who she wants to be. She has to learn that sheâs an adult now. Her life no longer needs to be dictated by her circumstances. She has the power to drive her own plot and to change it. But itâs been so engrained in her that nothing is within her control. I think somehow sheâs going to have to learn how to fight for that control: for her identity and her future.
Water lilies grow in murky water. Theyâre a symbol for rebirth and resilience. I think this represents Rileyâs and the LIsâ difficult upbringings. They will grow from and in spite of their terrible circumstances and transform into people who flourish.