Are You There, Roger? Itâs Me, Justin...
The cheap thing to do here would be to ramble on about how much I hate the Patriots, lament how they always get the calls, and blah blah blah.
However, after the refs blew a number of calls tonight in the Bills/Pats game, I am left wondering this:
How in the hell is it that we, as fans, put up with such lousy and, seemingly, subjective and inconsistent officiating?
Before delving into that, I will say this: It is late here in the Eastern Time Zone, where I am now located, and I have a long day of getting shit done tomorrow and thus do not have the energy for a full on, properly researched piece. Or, in other words, this will be more of an opinion piece based on my years of watching football with tonightâs game as the prime example. Perhaps somewhere down the road, once I am not annoyed at yet another Bills loss, among various other things, Iâll give this the full research and devotion Iâd like to dedicate to it.
In the mean time, letâs consider the following:
First, that inadvertent whistle call...
Somehow the refs mangled this one twice. First was by blowing the whistle in the first place, costing New England not only what could have been a huge gain, but also by ruling that the whistle came after Amendola (the Pats receiver) caught the ball. The reality, though, is that the whistle came well before the catch while the ball was in the air. In the case of an inadvertent whistle being blown while the ball is airborne, the down is replayed. Thus, the Bills defense got screwed because of the yardage given to the Pats as a result of where the ball was called dead (regardless of the penalty yards tacked on afterward).
Second, letâs talk about that Sammy Watkins catch with two seconds left in the fourth...Â
You know, the one where he caught it and slid backwards out of bounds untouched... Yeah. Right. Untouched. Thus, clock stops, right? Wrong. Instead, the refs said he was down inbounds, two seconds quickly rattled off, and game over. While right now at 12:34 am, I am admittedly too lazy to look up the specifics, my question is why in the hell didnât SOMEONE in the officiating crew bother to stop and say âWait a minute... No one touched Watkins before he slid himself out of boundsâ? [Editorâs Note: A good friend of mine, despite his being a fan of the Miami Dolphins, said to me that even the Pats fans he was watching the game with said Watkins was out of bounds and the clock should have stopped.]
Now I know, poor officiating in the NFL has been all over the sports world media pages this season, so this (unfortunately) isnât really news. Yet, it is extremely unsettling.
I remember growing up, NFL refs seemed to have their officiating (generally) on lock down. They seemed confident, professional, and while not infallible, gave the impression of having a good handle on things. Or at least that is how my brain remembers it all.
Over the last ten or so years, though, I feel like Iâve been watching guys that havenât officiated anything higher than JV football calling these games, and itâs starting to really wear on me. Not only does the officiating seem wildly subjective, but the inconsistency seems to increase year after year.
And what does the NFL do about this? Nothing seemingly more than circling the wagons, providing general radio silence, and reminding teams not to criticize officials or other teams. Or complicating things further by adding rules, amending existing ones, and instilling a somewhat bizarre replay policy that often just exacerbates the fact that football is not very good at dealing with any kind of grey area in terms of the interpretation of its rules or the reality of the game and the rules themselves. This all leads to choppy game play and rules that are as confusing as reading the most frustratingly obnoxious Orwellian-type legalese one could ever dream of.
This is all, to me, insulting at best and horrifically reminiscent of Dubya/Rumsfeld/Cheney type sentiments of âYour either with us or against usâ at worst.
What makes this double frustrating to yours truly is that the league had the same kinds of reactions and sentiments over the concussion studies that have been coming out over the last few years, which draws further comparisons to collusive (and ultimately corrupt) actions by entities such as the tobacco industry and the Dubya Years.Â
Which in turn leads me to say that the NFL in its current state (and under Roger Gooddell) is a complete extension of the perverse privatized corporate culture that has regained its most firm grip on this country.
One must simply open a history book to find out the ugly truths and outcomes of such industries/corporations/entities that turn inward in times of outside criticism to see how dangerous this type of behavior can be. Not only is it frustrating in the most superficial sense of it all in that it costs teams wins and potential playoff spots, but with regards to things like concussions, this costs people their lives.Â
Perhaps at this point, you may be thinking âYeah Justin, but youâre quite the hypocrite criticizing this all while watching it on TV and then bothering to write about it at such a grotesque hour of the evening.â Which, sure, may be somewhat true. Actually, itâs entirely true in many ways.
But at the same time, I would argue that I have a true love and appreciation for the United States of America, good and bad and ugly, and thus I have similar feelings toward the NFL and the Buffalo Bills. Thus, I do not like to see either of them muddled and besmirched by with-us-or-against-us mentalities and business practices. That, however, is likely another diatribe for another occasion.Â
To circle back around to my point, I will close with this: Until the NFL drops the idea that it is an all-mighty and infallible American institution, it will do nothing but slowly break down its image and relevance over time. While this may seem impossible, given that the league dominates a huge chunk of this countryâs culture and identity, all one has to do is look at the tobacco industry to see how, over the course of time, entities that withdraw inward and point the finger at anyone but themselves eventually erode their relevance and image and reputation one questionable PR move at a time.Â
And yes, bad officiating and all, Iâll still be watching the NFL. Just like Iâll still want that cigarette after watching the Bills lose because of dumb penalties, poor play calling, and lousy officiating.Â
Call me a hypocrite, just donât call me a Pats fan...