Subtleties
Gossip runs rampant at Hogwarts. The loudest rumour seems to be that Tom Riddle is dating the Slytheirn Head Girl: (Y/N). A Ravenclaw Head Boy is determined to prove otherwise. Part 2 in Complexities. WC: 3009 Category: Character Study, Romance? Links To Other Parts: 1 - 2
A/N: I finally finished part 2!!!! Again, I do hope you enjoy this part! I'll be finishing up part 3 very soon! Please let me know if you'd like to be tagged in the next part!
Relationships were always the centre of gossip at Hogwarts. Students adored whispering about the latest student affairs: who was seeing who at Hogsmeade, who was kissing who in their common roomsâhell, there were whispers about professors secretly meeting with students. But none were more talked about than the rumour that Tom Riddleâthe boy who had turned down every girl, who was rumoured to be loveless, the untouchable, the untameableâwas committing the most scandalous offence imaginable for a prefect: secretly dating his own Head Girl.
One of the biggest of the non-believers was the Ravenclaw Head Boy. He'd spent his fair share alongside the Slytherin head boy through classes and prefect duties and not once had the Ravenclaw Head Boy seen an ounce of care outside his study. In class, Tom was at the front, his eyes never leaving the board, professor or parchment. Outside of class, Tom was always in the prefectâs private classroom, studying some enormous and advanced textbook intended for older students in pure silence. Within crowds, Tom refused to engage with students unless absolutely necessary. Whilst the Ravenclaw head boy didn't know what Tom could be doing in his common room, his astute mind concluded it wouldn't be too different. Emotionally vacant, scarily studious, and absolutely focused, to the Ravenclaw head boy, there was no room or ability to care.
Which is why he vehemently refused to believe he was dating (Y/N), the Slytherin Head Girl, who was quite possibly the exact opposite of Tom Marvolo Riddle.
The Ravenclaw Head Boy had also spent his fair share with (Y/N) and it was⊠less than desirable. (Y/N) was a smart but extremely loud girl. In class, (Y/N) tried to pay attention to her professors, but inevitably found herself whispering to those around her. The Ravenclaw Head Boy had always found it strange that someone intelligent enough to earn top marks seemed so unwilling to behave like it. Outside of class, (Y/N) was the loudest in her friends' study groups, taking great pride and sneering at others whenever she came first in their weekly quizzes. Within crowds, (Y/N) was all smiles and constantly pointing, always excited to see someone she recognised and stalling a whole classroomâs worth of students from getting to class if it meant she could have a laugh. It was well known around Hogwarts that (Y/N)'s rather brash attitude didn't change in the Slytherin common room. From the Ravenclaw Head Boy's perspective, it seemed that everything Tom had lacked-or more so, hated-(Y/N) had in abundance. (Y/N)âs tie was generally skewed, her hair was never parted evenly, she spilt pumpkin juice all the time, sheâd talk while she was eating, she had crooked handwriting for her Charms notes, sheâd even laughed at some first years when she beat them at Gobstones. But perhaps the most egregious act that convinced the Ravenclaw Head Boy that the two couldnât be dating? The most heinous crime that Tom would absolutely denounce her for?
She had an overdue library book. Heâd discovered it not too long ago and had already reprimanded her on it too. All she did was smile, thank him, and promise sheâd return it the next day. The utter gall. The absolute arrogance. To think she was above the library. How dare she!
Knowing this, the Ravenclaw Head Boy concluded there was no way they were dating. Â For Tom Riddle, of all people, there was just too much wrong with that girl.
***
And then the fifth Quidditch match of the year started: Slytherin vs Gryffindor.
The house head boys and girls all attended separately, slowly starting to fill their established seats. The Ravenclaw Head Boy did try to attend with the head girl, but she got held up in the library and arrived later. It was only Tom and (Y/N) who walked together, but only because school policy recommended that house heads attend together.
The Ravenclaw Head Boy heard parts of their conversation.
"Professor Slughorn requested the attendance sheets be signed off." Tom instructed, face focused on the Quidditch field and hands held behind his back. (Y/N) held a hand up to her face, inspecting her nails lazily as she hummed.
"Already done." Tom barely spared a glance towards her as he sighed.
"Not fast enough." He declared as (Y/N) let out a questioning and obnoxiously loud 'eh?', turning to face Tom and tilting her head forward, puzzled.
"I got them to his desk before the match started!" She said, one eyebrow raised at his claim. Tom seemed to think she wasnât worthy of another glance.
"You were late." Tom concluded as (Y/N) rolled her eyes.
"You're always so huffy in Quidditch season." (Y/N) remarked, changing the subject to avoid further trouble.
"I have no interest in this barbaric waste of time." Tom spewed, eyes dark from annoyance from her idle chat. âThe Keepers consistently fail at outmanoeuvring their opponentâs beaters from their overt reliance on an undisciplined freeform technique.â (Y/N) stared up at him with an eyebrow raised, not impressed with what she heard.
âDude, Tom, itâs Quidditch.â Tom rolled his eyes at her. âYou donât even like it.â She said deadpanned.
âPrecisely, but Iâm not foolish enough to attend events I have no understanding of.â He said as (Y/N) shrugged. âDonât mistake my passing understanding as enjoyment. I already predict our loss.â Tom finished, irritated as he spoke.
"Oh, come on, maybe if we cheer hard enough, Slytherin will win!" (Y/N) chimed, a cheeky smile on her lips.
"Don't be daft," Tom scolded. "If our team must rely on cheering, then we never would have won." (Y/N) only giggled. It seemed she was back to pushing his buttons.
"Watch, I'll cheer our seeker on and we'll win." (Y/N) bet as Tom shook his head at her in disgust. Throughout their conversation, all head boys and girls had gathered in their private booth, a privilege of many for their hard work. Whilst the Gryffindor heads tried to antagonise Tom and (Y/N), Tom scoffed, no interest in the petty squabble of house politics, and (Y/N) stuck her tongue out, a true sign of her childishness.
The Ravenclaw Head Boy saw this as more proof that dispelled the rumours. Their interaction wasn't one of lovers, not even of friends. Tom dismissed and insulted her, but (Y/N) was, as Tom described, too daft to care or simply oblivious. The Ravenclaw Head Boy decided she was the former.
As the game officially started, (Y/N) started cheering her team, name-dropping every player as they flew by, earning a wave back. Tom remained standing and pulled out a small book titled 'Mastery and Expertise in Highly Advanced Potion Making' and refused to watch the game. Every particularly loud cheer earned (Y/N) a disapproving glance from Tom before he buried his nose back in his book. Tom had never tolerated loud disruptions and (Y/N) was no exception. (Y/N), however, clearly couldn't care less at his look.
For the first thirty minutes of the game, this attitude remained.
It wasn't until a Gryffindor beater hit the bludger incorrectly, a clear desperate move to stop himself from being struck, that the rhythm changed. The bludger was flying practically at Mach speed straight to the head student stands. The Ravenclaw Head Boy couldnât even process a thought, much less a scream to get down before (Y/N) undoubtedly would be hit.
But she wasn't.
(Y/N)'s breath barely hitched before Tom looked up, seeing the bludger, and immediately pushed her down. (Y/N) couldn't even mutter out Tom's name before she was safely out of the way. The Ravenclaw Head Boy noticed just how inhumanly fast Tom had reacted. In an instant, the bludger crashed violently through the stands, leaving a large hole and even larger cracks in the backing. Splinters and dust floated and showered the head students as Tom kept (Y/N)'s head down. Furthest from the debris, the Ravenclaw Head Boy was safe as he was closer to the edges, same for the head girl, but the sheer chaos of it all still left his mind hazy and skin paled. Tom quickly looked up, searching the area for immediate danger. A shattered stand held them up with broken beams threatening splinters or worse. At the very least, the bludger was gone and it was safe to stand again. Tom gave a quick look towards all the student headsâ direction, including Ravenclaw Head Boy's, a glance to see he wasn't injured, then turned back to (Y/N). As she rose, there was the slightest shake in her body, like she was trying to be brave, but couldn't quite hold it. She stared up at Tom, eyes slightly widened and mouth ajar as strands of her hair slowly fell on her face. Somewhere in that shocked reaction, the Ravenclaw Head Boy almost mistook her expression for gratitude.
But that was absurd. Tom hadnât saved (Y/N). Heâd saved a student, the head girl of Slytherin. Heâd have pushed any student out of the way, the Ravenclaw Head Boy concluded.
He went back to watching the duo. Tom gave one last look before turning to the Gryffindor player and a furious glare.
Tom breathed out slowly, "Are you that half-baked that you fail to hit a bludger correctly?" He spat, venom lacing his tone. This wasn't anything new, whenever a student failed to obey school rules or had nearly been the cause of a slip, Tom was ready to curse them with one single line. He deserved the lashing, the Ravenclaw Head Boy thought. But Tom continued. "Your infantile abilities nearly caused injury to your heads of houses." Tom stood straighter, one hand pointing at the Gryffindor player, one remaining firmly on (Y/N). "Your acceptance into the Gryffindor Quidditch Team wasn't a mistake, but a clear joke." Tom loved scolding those he viewed beneath him, the Ravenclaw Head Boy thought... and he agreed with Tom that this one deserved more than his usual one-liners.
Tom was ready to spew more bile at the Gryffindor player until Professor Hooch flew over to assess the damage.
"Alright, alright, let me see." Hooch quickly looked over each student, barely passing a glance to each, nodding. "Nothing's broken. Prewitt!" She turned to face the Gryffindor player. "You're out for the rest of the game." The Gryffindor player sighed and started to fly down as Tom scoffed. Hooch turned back to face the students. "If you feel sick, please attend the Hospital Wing." She turned back to the players. "Otherwise, resume in two minutes from the middle!" The players and rest of the cohorts cheered as Tom started to push (Y/N) and escort her out.
"Get out." He commanded sternly.
"Tom, I'm okay!" (Y/N) tried to reason as Tom remained on his path.
"We're leaving this pathetic match before more damage can be done by moronic leeches." Tom continued to usher her out, one hand firm around her shoulders due to her trying to fight out of his grasp. The Gryffindor heads booed the Slytherins as Tom glared hard enough to make one whimper. (Y/N) kept trying to plead with Tom, but he was having none of it, keeping a stern posture.
"You're so annoying!" (Y/N) whined loudly as she eventually followed.
"Watch your mouth and go." Tom again commanded as (Y/N) groaned, again, loudly.
How annoying for Tom that he had to escort his head girl out of the game because she was causing such a scene, the Ravenclaw Head Boy thought. It was an extra shame because he was having such a delight in proving his theory right. There was positively no believable scenario that Tom was capable of caring for such an annoyingly loud and disruptive girl.
Oh well, the Ravenclaw Head Boy sighed to himself. There was always next time to collect more data.
***
Neither Slytherin heads were seen until dinner in the great hall and rumours were circulating like wildfire. Tom had taken a bludger to his arm to protect his Head Girl, (Y/N) was seen kissing him after she was saved, Tom had pushed (Y/N) in front of the bludger; it was tiresome to the Ravenclaw Head Boy. Such frivolous lies went against all logic; there was simply no gain from storytelling which made him wonder why Tom put up with the rumours. It especially made him wonder just how different Tom would react to the rumours if he knew the truth. He could always tell him right now, after all he was sitting on the opposite table. Just that final seed in a litany of tiresome ones he endures through her. One seed too many to make the damn collapse and for him to break her feeble little heart like so many of the other pathetic girls he tired of so quickly. The Ravenclaw Head Boy looked over at (Y/N) and Tom and noticed that (Y/N) seemed unharmed, confirming to him that she was being dramatic. Tom of course, looked extremely annoyed at her.
"How ridiculous," Tom tutted, clearly about to hurl some well-deserved insults to (Y/N). "I'll be discussing with Headmaster Dippet our idiotic mandatory attendance."
⊠What?
The Ravenclaw Head Boy blinked in confusion before he focused back on the duo. (Y/N) had giggled, but Tom lasered his wrath on her. "And you, you're no better." (Y/N) immediately stopped laughing and let out a big 'Huh?!'.
Ah, here it comes.
"You looked like a coward. Leaders are meant to be looked up to. You looked like a child." He insulted as (Y/N) scoffed. That was more on par, thought the Ravenclaw Head Boy. Maybe right now was the right time.
"I nearly got hit by a bludger, but thank you Tom, you're so thoughtful." (Y/N) sarcastically said as Tom's eyes continued to check over her for any more injuries, something he kept having to do since she kept bringing it up.
"Grow up." (Y/N) mimicked his growled words as Tom glared harder to no effect as per usual. Daft, the Ravenclaw Head Boy called it. "Insolent." Tom said, practically agreeing with the boyâs thoughts. (Y/N) only continued to mimic him as Tom continued to tirelessly check over her just to stop her from whining. The Ravenclaw Head Boy could see Tomâs eyebrow arched in annoyance, now was definitely the time to enact his plan.
The Ravenclaw Head Boy stood up, head held high and arms by his side. He started to make his way to the Slytherin table, heâd have to go to the other end and make his way back, but that gave him more than enough time to figure out how to tell Slytherin Head Boy Tom Riddle that his stupid head girl was more trouble than she was worth. Maybe he could show Tom the overdue slip, he still had it after all. A month late â a month?! The hubris of the girl, the scene playing before him already in his mind â the loud shouting, the cold final word from Tom. Maybe he could slyly bring it up, see (Y/N) writhe and look down until Tom questioned her stupidity. Or better yet, he could ask (Y/N) where the book was, watch her dig herself into a deep hole, then reveal the slip, that would be genius! The Ravenclaw Head Boy smirked to himself as he turned at the end of the table, slowly making his way back to the duo, starting to hear bits of their conversation again. God, he couldnât wait. He simply couldnât wait to see (Y/N) have her heart broken!
Then he heard Tom speak.
âIf you donât quit complaining, I wonât give you that gift that I promised.â The Ravenclaw Head Boy stopped in his tracks. Did⊠Did he hear that correctly?
âHmph, fine!â (Y/N) said in a sulking tone, slouching. But you could still see the half-smile she tried to hide peeking beneath.
The Ravenclaw Head Boy hadnât moved since. Why was Tom getting her a gift? Why was he rewarding such indecent and childish behaviour? What gain would Tom even have from getting her something?! No, no, there had to be something he missed, something he overlooked. Tom? Giving something to others?! Gift?! He just needed to review the facts again. The Ravenclaw Head Boy realised he was standing near the middle of the Slytherin table, starting to gain stares, as he quickly walked back to his own. Now absolutely wasnât the time, heâd have to find a better opportunity. There would have to be a better time to tell Tom.
Wait⊠that was it! That had to be it! Tom was simply waiting for the time (Y/N) would let her guard down before he unleashed his wrath. He wasnât finished using her. That was it! The Ravenclaw Head Boy smirked once again, figuring out Tomâs plan and even feeling pride in it. He would give it another week until he gave Tom the opportunity he needed to rid himself of her once heâs done. A week, surely no more until heâs done with her. So, all he had to do was observe and wait until that time finally came. For now though, the Ravenclaw Head Boy could revel in his previous observation: The entire match and dinner was pure proof that the rumour of Tom Riddle dating head girl (Y/N) was irrefutably incorrect.
He spared one last glance at Tom and (Y/N) where he continued to insult her as she stupidly declared it a form of affection, earning her a disgusted look.
Exactly, The Ravenclaw Head Boy thought. It was impossible that the two were dating. The rumours would continue, undoubtedly, Hogwarts loved a ridiculous story after all. But the Ravenclaw Head Boy knew better. Tom Riddle did not love. He did not like. That was beneath him. He tolerated. He calculated. He used. And (Y/N), for all her intelligence, was just another stupid girl who had mistaken that for something more.
Tom Riddle was just simply incapable of loving such an annoying girl. Heâd finish using her and break her tiny heart like all the others. Itâs just a question of when.
Tags: @its-jennarose

















