🂫 Your Favorite Unreliable Narrator 🂫

The White Tank

Style: Starting from the inner layers, the white tank top is possibly the most iconic thing he wears and also the easiest to find. I'm fairly certain this type of shirt is available no matter where you live. Various names for this style of shirt include: tank top, A-shirt, undershirt, "vest" in the UK, and is still sometimes called a "wife-beater" in the US. The public perception of the shirt became entangled with racist and classist stereotypes in the US (because this country sucks)--here's a brief article about that.

Nigel clearly wears this style of shirt for sleeping and night-time lounging--he was wearing it when Alex kidnapped him while he slept and he wears it again when sitting in his parent's bed. He does seem to change the one stained by Helen's blood for a clean one, since we do not see any bloodstains on the shirt he wears to chase down Alex at the train tracks. It's perfectly reasonable; these types of shirts are meant to be worn as a base layer under other shirts, and typically one will have multiples for daily use.

Sourcing: The specific type that Nigel wears is ubiquitous and has been around for decades. Search white ribbed cotton tank top (or undershirt) and you'll almost certainly find them for cheap, often in multipacks. For accuracy, make sure you get this finely-ribbed cotton, rather than a plain smooth jersey. Fit should be snug, and the cotton should be thin--they're meant to be worn underneath another shirt so bulk is minimized. (I may sound like a broken record, but DO get cotton, not polyester blends--anything close to your skin should be breathable.) There are options marketed for men and women, but apart from some length variations and perhaps slightly more room at the bust, these shirts are incredibly unisex. Women and those with more fem-shaped bodies have been buying and rocking the men's version for decades (bless you, Gina Gershon in Bound 1996.)

Pajama Pants

Style: Another easy win for the Nigel enthusiast. These appear to be very simple, plain gray cotton pajama pants. Elastic waist, slant pockets, baggy and comfortable. Nigel wears them often, paired with his tank top for sleeping and also while working on homework at night in the dorms. A guy after my own heart--why wear pants when you can be comfy? I believe these are a plain, lightweight cotton based on the fabric drape we can see in the train shot below--the crispness of the bunching/creasing indicates a plain-weave cotton rather than a flannel which would have soft, loose folds and creases.

Sourcing: Gray cotton pajama pants. You'll find this style available across gender-specific lines, but you're more likely to find this dark gray color in the men's section because of silly gender norms. Right now (July 2026), Old Navy has an almost exact match for these available--I bought them and can vouch for both comfort and similarity to the screen version. Finding these might be harder depending on season--stores are more likely to have cotton in the warmer months, but focus on flannel or fleece for cold months.

Small Details - Slippers: While we are here looking at these photos, there are two other items to point out. First, Nigel seems to wear some kind of hard-soled slippers when he's wandering around the dorms of an evening. It's the only time we see these, and we don't get a very good look at them. On the train, Alex has put shoes (and possibly socks?) on Nigel before dragging him into the night. At home, he's been sitting in bed with his feet under the covers so he's just barefoot. As he walks out of Alex's room, it looks like they are closed back, so here's a few possible options for what they might be like:

Small Details - Underwear?: The other red box above highlights the gap between his tank top and his sagging pants. As far as I can tell, this may be the only time we see anything that might be underwear. From the texture/bunching of the fabric, I think this might be evidence that Nigel wears boxers. Briefs are snugly fitted against the skin and would not have that kind of bunched up fabric appearance.

Cardigan

Style: We see Nigel wear a plain cardigan twice. Once while dissecting the bird, layered over one of his school button up shirts, and again during the cleanup after John and Helen die, thrown on over his tank top and PJ pants. I think this cardigan IS actually black, unlike Alex's v-neck which I've already opined is likely a dark blue. It's a simple cardigan with a deep V neckline and no collar or even noticeable texture. You can just barely make out a fairly narrow band of what is likely to be neckband ribbing, and the cuffs are similarly banded. As I highlighted below, there are probably 4-6 relatively large buttons (he has the top button undone in the last shot).

Fiber Content: Like most of the knitwear in this movie, I would hazard a guess that it is wool rather than synthetic or cotton. Due to the relatively loose, relaxed drape of it and how it moves on Nigel's body, it's fairly thin and could be a nice soft merino, or mayyyyybe a cashmere. The Colbies are fairly wealthy and care about appearances--anyone that gives their son a waistcoat and a pocket watch to wear with his uniform might also be willing to splash out on some cashmere. The idea of him wearing a cashmere cardigan to dispose of his parents' bodies is somehow peak Nigel. Why would he care?

Sourcing: Search up mens black deep v neck wool cardigan and you'll come up with a plethora of options, but scan offerings carefully. You'd think this would be an easy to find, but there's just so much variety when it comes to cardigans. Getting the exact right one is like finding a needle in a haystack, only the haystack is actively fighting against you bc google has become maliciously unusable in the past few years. So many products that google shows you now are garbage quality, misleading, or scams. Modern men's cardigans tend to be shorter and more snug than the one Nigel has and often have a higher/shorter V neck, but there are quite a few options if you sift through. Also avoid sweatshirt/jersey materials, or cable-knit textures.

Sweater/Jumper

The differences in nomenclature for this garment will do your head in, as no one can agree on a standard name even within a single country. I invite you to peruse the Wiki article for a little taste of this confusion. We'll just call it a jumper, since the movie is set in the UK and that's the most likely term Nigel himself would have used.

Style: Once again, a simple garment--no embellishments, no cabling or ribbing, dark gray, plain knit. There's a chance the yarn could be marled (slight fiber color variations mixed in). This one appears to have more inherent texture than the cardigan, which gives me the impression of being made from a thicker, somewhat fuzzier wool yarn.

This is a timeless piece. You could easily find someone wearing the same garment 100 years ago and today. I keep circling back and underlining wool, but Britain does produce a huge amount of wool. It's also cold and rainy, and wool is an incredibly practical fiber for insulating against the cold even when wet. Nigel may not be a fisherman, but he does like to gallivant about at night in British weather, not to mention spending a lot of time in that cold, damp basement.

Sourcing: Search for gray crewneck jumper (or sweater) wool and get ready to sort through the many options, just like the black cardigan. You can find these marketed for male or female bodies, but it's a very unisex garment. For closest accuracy, avoid anything with cable patterns or ribbing. In the examples below, you can see the slight tonal variegation of a marled yarn.

Note: While it may seem logical to assume that Nigel would wear another undershirt/tank top with his jumper, he actually wears a white t-shirt. This is confirmed through a behind the scenes photo taken while they were filming the basement scenes. You can see the hem poking out in the first two, which could be either tshirt or tank top. The collar peeking out in the bottom right shot is a giveaway--the strap of a tank top wouldn't be likely to lie at that spot against his neck.

The BTS photo shows Eddie in full costume as Alex (hoodie and scarf and all) while Tom is there without his sweater. The basement scenes were filmed in Australia where it would have been the middle of summer and probably quite hot, so not wearing a wool sweater while the scenes are blocked out by Greg makes sense. Wearing a t shirt under a wool jumper also makes sense given how rough and scratchy wool can be against the skin--more of your skin protected from the wool is a bonus.

Black Jeans

Style: On his evening excursions, Nigel wears a pair of black pants. The seams on these pants suggest jeans, and another BTS photo shows both the white t shirt and what is pretty clearly a pair of black jeans. Although they look gray next to Nigel's coat, I think black is more likely. The denim weave tends to reflect light in such a way that black looks a bit more gray. If you run a search for black jeans, you'll see that many of them appear grayish. You're more likely to find black jeans regardless, but do whatever works for you!

Sourcing: You don't need my advice for finding a standard white crew neck t-shirt. Black jeans are likewise going to depend entirely on finding something that will fit your specific body, so I can't help much there. These are just standard jeans, looks like a straight leg, very moderate cut--not too baggy or too tight.

That last photo leads us right into shoes. Apart from the slippers mentioned above, Nigel wears two different pairs of shoes in the film.

Dress Shoes

Style: First, we have his school shoes--very basic black leather derby dress shoes. We don't have a lot of detail on these in any shots, but I can see the lacing flaps clearly sewn on the outside of the shoe. It's hard to see if they are cap toe, plain toe, or apron toe, but any of those styles would work. From the small glimpse as Nigel walks out of the church, the sole is smooth with no tread pattern--likely leather which is considered the more formal and higher quality sole for a shoe, but you could get away with a half rubber finely-treaded sole or even just fully rubber/Dainite. Just try to maintain the classic styling with the separate heel, and relatively thin profile.

Men's Dress Shoes: As a general rule, the more details on a man's shoe, the less formal it is. The most formal men's shoes are the most minimal. Therefore a derby is less formal than an oxford due to the visible detail of the lacing flaps on the outside. Here's the difference illustrated for those who don't know how to spot a derby vs an oxford, with the examples on the left, from top to bottom--cap toe derby, plain toe derby, cap toe oxford:

Sourcing: Search for mens black leather derby. This type of shoe is widely available in men's sizes at varying levels of quality. It is harder to find the right style marketed towards women, as the "feminine" versions often have thicker soles, higher heels, and/or more embellishment. Anyone can wear any shoe, but for masc or fem people with small feet, finding proper classic men's dress shoes in your size can be challenging. Most manufacturers only go down to a certain size--typically the lowest men's dress shoe size offered:

US: M7 (W8.5-9), UK 6.5, EU 40. A few sellers go down to US: M6 (W7.5-8), UK 5.5, EU 39.

Men's shoes offered in sizes below M6 are typically considered children's shoes, and will be found in those sections. They do make some dress shoes for kids but be warned: children's shoes are often less refined/elegant and more cheaply made (since they're intended for kids who will outgrow them anyway.) Access to school uniform suppliers would probably be helpful since they will have a range of sizes for smaller feet. There are a couple sellers (such as Allen Edmonds--really great shoes btw) who offer sizes down to M5, but these are very expensive shoes and probably outside the price range most of you are looking for.

One final note on fit: Classic men's dress shoes (any of the ones discussed above) are intended to fit quite narrow and tight to the foot. Be prepared for a shoe that does not have the same width and room as a sneaker, and for a level of stiffness that some will find uncomfortable until the shoe has broken in some. They also are styled with a longer, narrow toe box that extends a bit past the end of your toes--this exaggerates the length of your foot and is to be expected. The important aspect to pay attention to when selecting the right size is that the natural bend point of the shoe falls at the ball of your foot. If the shoe is too long, this bend will instead push into the top of your toes, causing pain and blisters and also looking awkwardly clown-like on your feet.

Casual Shoes

On his extracurricular excursions with Alex, Nigel wears a pair of medium brown shoes. We can see them in several quick glimpses during the basement sequence, and even from these brief shots I get the impression that these are heavily worn in, well used shoes. If they are what he wears for his nightly prowling to who knows where doing who knows what, this would make sense. The school dress code would likely require students to keep their dress shoes well polished, and that type of shoe isn't exactly practical for crawling around in the dirt anyway. These are his adventuring shoes.

The shots showing the shoes prove they are brown, but fail to give much detail other than that. Thankfully, that BTS photo above reveals that they are NOT shoes, but rather boots. You can see the top edge peeking out from behind Tom's hand, and also that the boot extends up the ankle past where a normal shoe would end.

Style: These fall into the category typically termed "dress boots"--patterned after dress shoes, with some of the same stylistic/construction choices, still dressy but a bit more practical for cold weather. The wide banding at the cap toe seam suggests a perforated/brogued seam, but this could just be a doubled up/wider plain seam. The side seam shows the lacing flaps attached in the derby style, and the laces are brown and fairly thin rather than bulky utilitarian laces. The sole is smooth rather than treaded, as one might see on more practical boots. Soles are also quite thick--possibly a double or even triple leather sole, commonly used in boots for additional insulation from the cold ground.

The boot isn't super tall, but does come up past where a chukka or Chelsea boot would end. Based on the proportions, I think you're looking at an 8 hole boot (meaning 8 lacing holes). We can see from this shot that there is no zipper on the inside to allow cheating easy access, so these are lace up only. In keeping with the observations I made above, they are very scuffed on the toes and ankles, and the sole is quite worn--he clearly wears these to crawl in and out of his secret room and probably for a lot of other skulking, lurking, exploring, and miscellaneous shenanigans. It's giving big Dark Academia vibes.

Sourcing: Try mens dress boots cap toe cognac (or tan or walnut). These are likely going to prove hard to acquire for most of you. Dress boots certainly exist, but there aren't many cheap versions in this particular style. The examples above are close--they have the derby style lacing and the wider cap toe seam with the brogueing (the decorative perforations along the seam lines and on the toe). There's a bit too much brogueing elsewhere on the body of the boot, and the soles are normal thickness rather than doubled, but I feel confident that you could still get away with something like this. These types of boots typically run US$200 or more, though careful shopping might find something that works for under $100. You will also run into the same sizing issues as discussed above. While you might be able to find some similar boots offered for "women" with smaller sizes, there will be fewer options to choose from in terms of price and quality.

The Coat

Finally, the capstone of Nigel's wardrobe--his coat. You're thinking to yourself, "If I could just find that coat, I could look like Nigel." You're gonna need some luck to make that happen, I think.

Style: Black knee length single-breasted wool overcoat with a stand collar and slant pockets. Time to get pedantic about yet another topic--what to call this coat. There's a common tendency to call any long coat a "trench coat", but this is not really the accurate term for this garment.

Overcoat: Designed to protect the wearer from cold weather. They’re heavier, which provides superior protection. Silhouettes vary, but most overcoats range from full-length to one that ends at the knee. Trench Coat: Designed to protect the wearer from rain/snow. They’re water-resistant, and a bit more lightweight. As such, you’ll need to layer up underneath the trench coat to stay warm and dry at the same time. Silhouettes vary, but most trench coats range from the knees to the mid-shin. While they originate from military garments, the modern versions are really just fancy raincoats with some of the same military-inspired details like epaulets, cuff bands, belting, etc.

Nigel's coat has none of the details nor the correct fabric type and weight that I would associate with a typical trench coat. If you search online, you will see every imaginable type of coat associated with every possible name--all of these designations have become diluted and mixed together and used interchangeably. This inattention to accuracy makes our job harder, but you will likely find more suitable results by searching for overcoat rather than trench coat.

Adding to that complication is the very specific and uncommon style of collar. A stand collar is so-called because it's meant to stand upright most of the time, unlike lapel collars that can be turned up but are meant to lay flat generally (like the coat John Colbie is wearing above.) While you can find coats available with stand collars, most of the options I've found have a notch or offset at the seam where the collar band meets the body. Nigel's is a straight, continuous line (see below).

Fit: While this style of coat is meant to be relatively well-fitted with enough allowance to be worn comfortably over a suit or winter garments, Nigel's coat appears to be a bit too big for him. The shoulders fit well, but the body seems quite roomy--though it's hard to tell since we never see the coat properly closed. The sleeves seem a touch too long judging by how much they bunch up when he has his hands in the pockets. Compare to John's coat which is visibly more tailored. I also point out that in the church photo further up, his pants are also far too long--they aren't meant to bunch up like that. There are other background students with pants too long (possibly just due to available costume rentals being limited in size options). Perhaps you can explain this by imagining his parents bought him clothes a bit larger than needed in the assumption he would continue to grow. If you want to get judgy about the Colbies, you could also imagine that it's a sign of no one paying much attention to him, including what size clothing he actually needs.

The waist isn't notably emphasized/snatched, but there IS some subtle shaping you can see in the profile shot above. He doesn't have enough of an ass to make the coat flare like that on his own. There's no belt or horizontal waist seam, so the shaping is done through the vertical seams only. That shaping combined with the single back vent will help create that slightly flared out back silhouette.

The coat has 5 total buttons, and when entirely buttoned, the stand collar would wrap around and just barely overlap at the front, under the chin. If you examine the detail I highlighted in the funeral shot, you can see that there is a hidden placket for the buttonholes. We never see him with his coat properly buttoned, but when closed, those buttons will be invisible behind the outer shell of the coat, creating a very streamlined, minimalist look.

Sourcing: God help us all. The searches I've run trying to find something suitably similar are infinite, and the results abysmal. Multiple factors are working against us here. First, clothing has become both shittier and also more expensive in the past 20 years. Second, google has completely shit the bed when it comes to giving you results relevant to your actual search terms. Third, there is a massive overwhelm of sketchy bullshit "stores" selling products from god knows where, and which are not in any way something you should be giving your money (or personal info) to blindly. I've been banging my head against this for days and still have nothing solid to offer.

You can try: mens coat black wool "stand collar" knee, but frankly no search term combos I've tried make any difference in getting relevant results. I invite anyone to share their results if they can find a coat that meets even just 75% of screen accuracy. For everyone else, it may simply come down to finding something that at least creates the same vibe.

Priorities should be: approximately knee length, wool or wool-blend fabrics, fairly plain, single-breasted, and a collar that can at least be turned up when you want the full Nigel effect.

To sum it all up, the Nigel capsule wardrobe will consist of:

white cotton tank top/undershirts

white cotton t-shirts

gray pajama pants

boxers

gray slippers/house shoes

black deep v-neck cardigan

gray crew neck pullover jumper/sweater

black jeans

black knee length overcoat

black dress shoes

brown boots

school uniform

gray waistcoat

optional accessories include: silver pocket watch, composition notebooks, dissection tools, black doctor's bag, red personal "bible", blood, rain, shotgun

Good luck and happy hunting.

Costume Breakdown: School Uniforms

Like Minds Masterpost - Aesthetic/Creative (costuming posts will be linked on this masterpost)