we had it all. (J.Logan)
Pairings: John Logan x fem!reader
Summary: Logan realizes his crush for Hannah isn't actually a crush, but is it too late? or, you realize that Logan has a crush on Hannah through little interactions and decide to distance yourself only for Hannah to make Logan realize his mistake and try to get you back before its too late.
Word count: 5.4k
âËŕż tina's note đđËâ I've always been a Logan girl so here we are. I used a bit of Hannah and Logan's actual scene of realizing he's not actually into her but adapted it a little to fit this story. This is the first time in a while that I write this much so fast so hopefully its good I did not proofread or edit and the ending kinda sucks but oh well.
You weren't dating, not really, John Logan didn't do relationships, but you were together in all the ways a relationship conveys without the formality of a title. You cheered for him on game day, he would call you every time he had a bad day, you would always find each other at parties and at some point along the way you'd found yourself a spot at the hockey house.
The change started slowly, so slow it was almost unnoticable at first. Your first significant meet with Hannah outside of Malone's was at the block party, you'd been having drinks with the guys and a few girls who had joined in hopes of scoring a hookup when Logan noticed how detached Garret had been from the party. That was the first time you noticed the longing glances, but they still didn't register fully because he still spent the rest of the party on your side and you still ended up in his bed that night.
"Lo I think someone's knocking" Tonight a bunch of people were over at the hockey house, it wasn't a party per se, but the entire hockey team plus a few other friends were around. You were currently sitting on the couch watching the guys play a hockey videogame.
"No one ever knocks" Logan replied not taking his attention off the tv.
"Exactly" You pointed out making it clear that if someone was knocking there must have been a reason.
"Fine" He sighed and handed you his controller, he started walking away and then turned back around "Wait no, she'll score an own goal, pause it!" But you were already moving your little guy around the ice, in circles really instead of actually playing the game.
He didn't seem to pay much attention to Hannah that night, just an extra look when a half naked, straight out of the shower Garrett took her upstairs.
Your next encounter with Hannah was Beau and Dean's party. You had coordinated outfits with one of your friends, Logan was a bird aliongside Tucker's bee and you were all throwing shots when she walked in. Hannah looked amazing in her head turning bunny costume that made Garretts magician make sense now.
In all honesty, you wouldn't have noticed anything weird with Logan if it hadn't been for the way his hold on your waist had instantly dropped when he noticed her. You played it off as nothing when Tucker appeared next to you and dragged him away for their little tradition, but your brain filed it away anyways.
"Mmm we're late" You mumbled into Logan's lips, you were parked on a lonely dark street a few streets away from Malone's because he, verbatim, had said 'you look too good I'm not making it the whole night without a taste'
"Mmhmm" He mumbled against your lips grinding his hips up to you "Don't care"
"Oh come on" You separate a little, he follows as if you were connected by a string, chasing your lips "Karaoke night is my favorite"
"You won't even sing" He complained pushing his forehead against yours.
"Maybe tonight I will" You tell him.
"You're telling me if I drive us to Malone's right now you'll actually sing tonight?" You nod, it's not true, you're most definitely not singing tonight, but you know if you're any late you're gonna fall victim to Dean, Tucker and Beau's incessant teasing the whole night "You're on baby"
When you get to Malone's you get the great surprise of Tucker on stage singing Save a Horse Ride a Cowboy "Holy shit" You gasp hitting Logan's arm.
He chuckles, Jules walks up to you with the song request clipboard "I'll put you and Garrett up for Summer Nights" They say already scribiling down the words.
"I know that's a joke but I would kill Sandy" Logan replies "Anyways, put this one down for Shake It Off"
"Noted" Jules writes down your name and song.
"Do not" You say but Jules smirks and walks away "Jules!"
They don't even turn around, just puts their hand up and waves approaching another group of people, Logan laughs "Come on, let's get a drink" He guides you to the bar, Tucker's voice flowing through the place with the crowd joining in every chorus.
Garrett and Hannah are at the bar, Hannah seems to be enjoying herself as she says hi to you all giggily sipping on what seems like a piĂąa colada "I'll take one of those please" You call out to the bartended who nods getting to prepare the drink.
"Logan!" Hannah exclaims after pulling you into a drunken hug "You fixed my car" She points at the man, Logan nods with a strained 'yeah'. The girl turns to Garrett "He fixed my car"
Garrett looks confused "You have a car?"
The brunette gives him a weirded out look "No"
You stiffle a laugh at her response and squeeze her a little when you notice her somber expression "Had a car" Logan clarifies "Great car"
"I'm buying you a very special thank you drink" Hannah announces then "And you, for being a new friend" She turns to you, then there's confusion in her eyes "We can be friends right?"
"Yes Hannah, we can be friends" You chuckle, she beams.
"Great!" Then she leans over the bar and whispers something into the bartender's ear "Okay you're gonna love it!"
"Hannah has discovered the piĂąa colada tonight" That explains the girl's drunken state, she's probably had too many but thankfully he is with Garrett who is probably the most responsible guy in this bar tonight.
"I've only had one, or four" Hannah laughs, she seems to be having fun.
"Is that what I'm getting too?" Logan asks, you don't miss the way he says 'I'm' but you ignore it, for now.
"Mmm nope" She turns back to you and Logan just as the bartender sets your piĂąa colada and two very bright blue drinks "Okay, for my mechanic, and my new friend, I call this the bluebaru"
She hands you each a glass, you look behind her at Garrett as if asking for help but he just looks amused "Oh! It looks like wiper fluid" Logan says as he inspects the drink.
You take a sip, your face scrunching up at the taste of it at the same time as Garrett says "That might actually be wiper fluid"
"It's mostly blue curacao" Hannah explains "With the secret ingredient" She leans in closer to you and Logan "More blue curacao"
"Oh! I'm so excited" You laugh at Logan's clear suffering at the simple thought of drinking this, you already know you're handing this to either Dean or Beau the moment you see them, those two will drink pretty much anything.
You've just found Dean and Beau, the latter being occupied with his tongue down a redhead, when Hannah's name is announced. "Here have this" You shove the drink into Beau's hand and slip into the seat next to him.
"What's this?" He asks but is already taking a big gulp of it "Fuck!"
You smirk "Hannah Wells' creation, the bluebaru"
"You've got some competition" Beau nods at Logan who is staring intently at Hannah as she performs, that's the first time you really notice it.
"Oh hell no" Dean speaks making you realize the redhead's gone.
"She's with Garrett" You point out.
"Right" Beau nods but the damage is done, for the rest of the performance you can't stop noticing the way Logan looks at her like she's the most interesting thing in the planet and how his look changes to a more somber one when Hannah starts serenating Garrett more openly.
"Kinda sweet isn't it" Jules approaches their brother when they notice the looks he's been giving the girl performing "Garrett being serious about someone"
"You think he's serious?" Logan asks.
"Everyone on fifth line seems to think so" Jules replies "They get more likes than anything else I post" When their brother doesn't say anything they sigh knowing the conversation isn't going anyways "Not that you should care or anything"
"What are you talking about?" He asks, Jules doesn't reply, instead they nod to the booth where you and Beau are watching Hannah sing and Logan can't help but to feel a pinch of guilt in his gut.
You don't sing that night, and you're surprised when, after a few hours of him hanging out with everyone but you, Logan comes over and asks if you're ready to go. Your roomate is out and Logan takes full advantage of that giving you multiple orgasms, you don't think about why he's being so good to you, he'd already shown how interested he was earlier, but he can't help but think he has to make it up to you all night long.
The last thing Logan wanted tonight was to end up talking about Hannah with Garrett but here he was because he couldn't help himself but to ask, and he hated himself for the relief he'd felt when Garrett basically confirmed they weren't together "Hannah was just a distraction"
"Yeah, I mean, sometimes you don't get everything what you want" Logan said "But⌠you're Garrett Graham, alright? Things are gonna work out for ya okay? They always do"
Garrett chuckled "Yeah well for you too man, I mean, you've got the girl, and you make it look so easy" Logan felt a pang of pain at the mention of you and his friend's perspective of your relationship, things there weren't easy, hell he'd been ignoring you for a few days now, giving you dumb excuses as to why he couldn't see you and it all was because he couldn't get his friend's 'girl' out of his head "And it's me and you in the bruins, that's the plan, right?"
Another lie he was keeping, the one where he was pursuing hockey alongside Garrett when he graduated "Yeah, that's the dream"
The next few weeks are like torture for Logan, you eventually wear him down enough for him to start hanging out with you again but he's distant every single time. In the meantime, he's trying his hardest to stop thinking about Hannah while the girl spends every free moment she has in their house because apparently, her and Garrett are officially together now. Every few nights he has to actually leave the house and stay over at your dorm because he can't stand the sound of his best friend hooking up with Hannah and his headphones are not enough.
Thanksgiving had been, surprisingly nice, Garrett and Hannah had gone to his father's to celebrate, Dean was away in New York and that left Tucker, Logan and Jules, the last one inviting you over even before the invitation had been extended to everyone who didn't have a place to go.
"He's gonna burst something" You mumble into Logan's ear, the man being surprisnigly affectionate today.
"Hey, he wanted to do all this" Logan replies squeezing your waist as he hugs you from behind making you giggle.
"Yo lovebirds, get to work" Tucker points at you with the knife he was holding making both of you to put your hands up in surrender before moving to do whatever you were appointed to do.
Logan ends up leaving with Jules a while later, they go to visit their mom at rehab even though that's the last place he wants to be and you stay behind with the rest of your friends. The turkey, much to Tuck's dismay, ends up being a disaster and you all migrate to the rink instead.
You suck at skating but you manage to stay upright enough to glide around as the group plays hockey using parts of the charred turkey as a puck. You've found yourself in the middle of the rink, with the help of Kendall, when Logan and Jules return with their marshmallow attack. You shriek as one hits you square in the chest and glide your way to them as good as you can but you end up slipping and falling straight into the arms of Logan who laughs as he helps you up.
"What are you guys doing?" You ask laughing as your friends in the rink shriek when the siblings keep pelleting them with marshmallows as they skate around.
"It's a Logan thanksgiving motherfuckers!" Jules screams and continues their attack.
"Let's call G and Dean" Tucker suggests, pulling his phone out.
That's where your night changes drastically, when the illusion that you'd been keeping up shatters, because while you'd spent today in Logan's arms whispering jokes to each other and sneaking in kisses here and there the moment Hannah and Garrett's faces appear in Tucker's screen he drops your hand and his expression falters.
Your hand immediately feels cold at the loss of touch and you can't concentrate on the words being exchanged, you smile through it and then when they hang up you unlace your skates and replace them with your shoes and get the hell out of there.
Logan doesn't notice until Jules mentions it.
You stop reaching out to him, your replies come out short when he texts and you always have an excuse as to why you're busy or he can't come to your dorm. In just a week you've shifted your entire friend group from the hockey team to the football team. They greet you in with open arms, you've hang out with them before and Beau adores you, you also find out that the football girlfriends are real good friends who you can girl talk with even though you haven't been close for too long.
"Honestly, good for you" Mia, one of the wide receivers girlfriend's says, you're telling them the story of why you've ended up hanging out with them more lately while trying not to freeze your ass off while you watch the team practice "For having a backbone"
"Men can be so dense" Lily shakes her head "I bet you he's still wondering what he did to piss you off"
"I think he's taken the hint" You shrug "He's stopped spamming me at least"
"Sooo now that he's out of the picture⌠you and Beau?" Mia asks suggestively wiggling her eyebrows.
"Nope" You deny immediately "Been there, done that, we're friends and that's where we're staying"
"Wait you've hooked up before?" Lily's eyes are so impossibly wide "Okay share!"
You chuckle "We were freshmen, it happened a few times and then we figured out we enjoyed hanging out with each other but neither of us wanted a relationship so it kinda fizzled out" You shrug "But I also became friends with the hockey boys and Dean and Beau come as a package so we just stayed friends"
"I've always wondered" Mia trails, her eyes following Beau as he runs drills "When people say they come as a package, do you guys think they like⌠have threesomes and shit?"
You choke on nothing, heat rising up your neck "Oh. my. God" Lily jumps pointing at you "You dirty slut" But there's no real judgement in her voice, just curiosity.
"Would you look at that? I think I better go work on my psych paper" You stand up ignoring the girls asking you to come back behind you.
Malone's is packed by the time you make it in, Mia and Lily insisting they needed you there so here you were. You knew the hockey guys would be here, it was after all their fundraiser, Logan is at the entrance when you arrive "Hey you came" He looks surprised about your presence.
"Yep" You nod "Here I am"
The air is only awkward for a few seconds before your savior, Beau Maxwell, steals you away with a quick comment at Logan and soon enough he has you at the bar with a drink in hand.
"Hey!" Hannah greets you, you haven't seen her since before thanksgiving either and although she is, unknowingly, the reason why you and Logan fell out, there's not a single cell in your bone that resents her "Great party right?"
"It always is" You nod with a smile "Although I kinda like this venue better than the usual one"
Hannah curtsies "Thank you, all my idea. Have you met Allie?"
You nod and wave at Allie who's behind the bar "Yeah, hi"
"Hey" She smiles back but then her eyes track someone behind you. You turn to see who it is and your mouth falls agape when you find Dean walking by, a smirk on his face as he squeezes your waist and continues in. You look back at Allie who looks exactly like someone who's been caught doing something they shouldn't be doing "I-"
You chuckle and shake your head letting her know she doesn't need to give you any explanation, thankfully for her Hannah had been too distracted with the band on stage to notice.
"Give it up for after hours everybody" Dean says once he's up on stage "And a big round of applause to my buddy John Logan for putting on this killer event" You clap alongside everyone, for all his faults John Logan really cares about the Little Canes and has always pulled through for them "Look at him, doesn't get any more good looking than that. And he's single ladies" The crowd of girls around the room cheer, you chug your drink.
Allie gives you a look sliding another drink in front of you before going back to paying her full undivided attention to Dean "I thought you and Logan wereâŚ" Hannah says confused.
"Nope" You reply taking your drink and walking away to find either Mia and Lily or Beau.
"Ugh look at him" You grumble staring at Logan's smile as he talks to Hannah, you're now a few drinks in and your filter is running thin "Like her boyfriend is not his best friend who also happens to be 5 steps away lik get a grip dude"
Mia and Lily chuckle, you've found yourself in the middle of them while each of them has their boyfriend with them, luckily for you, because as upset as you are you don't want Logan's crush on Hannah being public knowlege, the guys are too busy engrossed on a conversation about how awful their season is going.
"I think" Lily says "You need a little distraction"
"Mhm" Mia agrees scoping the crowd out "How about⌠him?" She points at a brunette guy.
"Too complicated, he's on the hockey team" You tell them.
"That would just make things more interesting" You shake your head "Fine, no athletes then" She thinks about it for a few more seconds "How do you feel about artists"
You look the way she is, her gaze locked onto Justin Kohl "That⌠I might consider" The girls giggle next to you.
You do end up talking to Justin once his set is done and find yourself entertained enough to consider leaving with him. Key word: consider because when you are getting your coat while he waits by the door to join him Logan stops you.
"Hey can we talk?" He grabs your arm, soft enough to not hurt you but strong enough so you can't just slip away.
"Uh I gotta go" You say "Someone's waiting for me"
"What- I mean, what happened?" You give him a raised brow "We don't even talk anymore and I just need you to help me understand what happened"
"Logan come on, you're not that dumb" The dumb comment doesn't affect him but you calling him Logan makes him recoil. You never call him Logan, it's always Lo or John.
"Please" He says "I- I thought we were good" You scoff "What?"
"You're in love with your best friend's girlfriend Logan" You deadpan, if you had had one less drink tonight you probably wouldn't have said anything, but here you are.
"What? No I'm not" He argues.
"Yes you are!" You tell him "And honestly? That's a problem for you and them because you and I weren't even together"
"Don't say that" He shakes his head.
"Don't say what? It's the truth. We had fun while it lasted but now you clearly have your sights set on someone else and I think that's something you really have to deal with soon because it's not fair for anyone" You look at him for a few seconds, waiting for your words to sink in and then you say goodbye and walk away no longer in the mood to hook up with Justin.
It takes Hannah and Garret to breakup, fighting and then making amends with Garrett and Hannah and Garrett getting back together for Logan to start to accept his feelings, and once again, he hates himself for it. You were right the night of the fundraiser, this crush he had on hannah wasn't fair to anyone.
"Okay no, this is ridiculous and we need to talk" Hannah stops him as he tries leaving the kitchen as soon as she entered it even though he was halfway through making a sandwich. Something he'd been doing for weeks, avoiding her at all costs "Garrett said to ignore it, that it would eventualy go away, but I can't keep doing this"
"Wellsy I don't know what you're talking about" He tries to lie.
"Stop that!" She points at him with that scary authority the guys had come to know and fear "Do you have a thing for me?"
"Well, this has been fun, but I think I'll go upstairs and kill myself now" He says attempting to walk away but her voice stops him.
"Sit down" He does so because although Hannah is comparably smaller to him, she's scary.
"There's no point talking about this Wellsy I think we both know what the answer to your question is" He sighs.
"Just⌠answer it"
"Fine" He huffs "Yes I have a thing for you"
"Why?" She asks after a few moments of silence that felt like hours to him.
"I- What?"
"I'm so not your type and we both know it" She lets out.
"You don't know that" He accuses.
"Oh yeah? Prove it, what is it that makes you have a thing for me?"
"I'm tired of the parties and hookups and hopping from girl to girl, you made me realize that, you with your movie nights full of cuddles and cheering at our games and cooking dinner and the looks you give Garrett-" She snorts then interrupting his rant "Why are you laughing?"
"Because you're not hearing yourself, Logan⌠you don't want me, you want my relationship" Hannah tells him.
"I'm not into polygamy" He defends.
"No thats⌠thats not what I'm saying you idiot" She sits next to him "You say you're tired of hookups and hopping from girl to girl but tell me, how many girls have you slept with this year?" He thinks about it and the answer is easy, one, you're the only one he's slep with in over a year "You want cuddles and movie nights and someone cheering for you at your games and someone to cook you dinner and give you loving looks well I'm sorry to break it up to you pal but you had all that already" The 'pal' should've hurt but it just gets lost in the middle of the rest of the words as Logan realizes the truth in Hannah's words "Logan⌠you had the girl and you let her go and for the longest time I kept wondering why because it made no sense and here it is, the reason actually makes no sense"
"Shit" He cursed dropping his head onto the counter.
"Yeah, shit" The girl patted his back.
"Wellsy did you get lost on your way to the popcorn? Because- oh what happened?"Garrett entered the room.
"Logan here just realized he's been a bit of an idiot" Hannah explains and although he can't see them, Logan knows the couple is communicating with stares.
"Oh" Garrett lets out "Is this aboutâŚ"
"Yeah"
"I've lost her haven't I?" Logan mumbles looking up to his friends.
"Uhhh" Garrett looks at Hannah for help.
"Noooo" But her tone doesn't sound sure "I mean⌠surely there's something we can come up with to help you get her back"
Logan groans and drops his head once more.
"Woah, what's with all the somber in here?" Dean walks in with Tucker trailing behind.
"Girl trouble" Garret lets out.
"Oh shit, finally got your head out of your ass huh?" The blonde slaps Logan on the back making him jump up.
"Dude" Tucker scolds him "Okay so⌠what are we doing? How are you fixing this?"
"I don't know" Logan admits.
"Right" Dean nods and pulls out a notepad and pen from one of the drawers "Operation GLGB starts now"
"GLGB?" Tucker questions.
"Get Logan's Girl back" Dean says in a 'duh' tone.
"You could've just said that" Garret argues.
"Well yeah but Logan here is always making up these terms so I thought it was fitting" The blonde counters.
"Okay whatever you wanna call it just⌠anyone has any ideas?" Hannah stops the argument before it gets too far.
It takes the group two whole weeks to come up with a plan and execute it.
"Beau I swear to God" You complained, Beau had come to your dorm earlier and dragged you out with no reason even when you complained you were working on an essay "If I don't get to finish my essay because of you I will cut your season short"
"You'd be doing me a favor honestly" He grumbles "Team's still doing so shit"
"Maybe because you spend your free time dragging girls out of their dorms instead of practicing" You point out sarcastically.
"Usually I don't have to drag them, they come on their own"
"Yeah cause you don't know how to get them there" You tease.
"Oh you know damn well I can" He smiles back.
"Ew no" You make a face, you'd rather leave those days in freshman year.
"Anyways, wait here" You're standing under a big tree in the middle of campus where the block party is usually held.
"Why?" You question.
"Just⌠stay" He pleads.
"Woof" You retort he chuckles and jogs away.
You sigh looking around, there's nothing Beau could be remotely interested in here, just people walking to and from classes and or dorms which your friend tends to stay away from as much as possible.
"Hey" You hear that familiar voice behind you, you don't turn, instead you're planning an escape that he doesn't let you complete as he stands in front of you.
"Hi"
"I'm sorry" He lets out "About everything, and I know you don't want to listen to me but please just hear me out"
"I can't" You try to say "I have an essay I need to finish, I'm just waiting for-"
"Beau" He interrupts you "Yeah, I know, I needed someone to lure you out of your dorm" You scoff running your hands through your hair "Please don't go just⌠just let me get this out and if you decide you want nothing more to do with me I promise I'll never bother you again"
"Two minutes" He nods.
"This is where I saw you for the first time, block party, freshman year, you were standing right here on your own" He motions to the spot you're standing in now "There were fairy lights on the tree and they glowed all around you like a halo. Garrett caught me staring, he told me to make a move, and I did, and honestly? I thought the most I was getting out of it would be a hookup but then we started talking and I knew that I needed you to be in my life as more than that"
"We didn't hook up in freshman year" You tell him "We barely spoke after that"
"True" He nods "Because you had that thing going on with Beau, and Beau was Dean's best friend and I didn't want to cause any drama within the team. But then one night we were out and he mentioned you two were just friends and I thought okay this is it, this is my chance" The two minutes are close to being over but you don't mention it "Sophomore year I realized no other girl made me feel the way you did, I stopped hooking up with random girls, I had no one night stands and I found myself looking for you in every room I walked into. And I've been the biggest idiot, I got in my head, I have a million things going on right now and the only good ones are you and hockey, in that order" He points at you "You and then hockey, but I let myself get wrapped up on the mentality of the other guys, the one where I couldn't possibly have a girlfriend because that meant leaving hockey behind"
In the entire time you've known John Logan you've never known him to be someone who can stand still for too long, a hockey player trait probably because all the guys are the same, but through this entire exchange he's stood right in front of you staring you in the eye as if he will spook you if he moves too much, the distance between you is a couple steps and it's probably the furthest he's stood since the night you met right here.
"But then, Garrett stated dating Hannah, Garrett Graham, the guy whose determination when it comes to hockey is so strong he's shaped his entire world around the sport, got a girlfriend, and he was doing great, he was thriving, he was happy. And seeing him like that made me jealous because I wanted that, I wanted to have the happy relationship and I confused that with wanting Hannah" He takes one step then, so small it makes nothing to decrease the distance "But I didn't, I didn't want Hannah, and I realized it too late. I realized that I had all that, I had it all with you I was just too much of a coward to call it what it was"
"Lo-" He cuts you off.
"Please" You've never seen him this broken "Please don't call me by my last name, I can't stand you calling me Logan"
You nod "John I don't know if I can just⌠move on from all this like it was nothing. We were together for over a year and never made it official, and it was okay back then because it was what we both wanted, but I'm not sure that's what I want anymore"
"But-" You put your hand out stopping him.
"I hear what you're saying, but what's to say we get back together and you realize it really is not what you wanted?"
"It is" He's basically prÂĄleading my now, sure he said if you wanted to he would dissapear from your life, but he's sure as hell not going to do it without putting up a fight first "I know it is because we already had it and I loved it" He stops then and something flashes in his face, recognition "I love you"
Your eyes widen "Lo"
"I do, I love you" He chuckles shaking his head and gone is the man who stood still for so long because he's now cut down the distance and standing so close he's blocking your view of anyone else "I love going to parties and having you by my side the entire time, I love going to sleep with you in my arms and waking up to you basically on top of me, I love late nights snacking on Tuck's leftovers and I love seeing you in the stands at my games, I love you"
You're smiling now because you can tell he's being serious.
"I never had a crush on Hannah, baby you're the only one I've wanted so please, please cut me out of my misery and say you'll be mine again" His brown eyes bore into yours and you can't help but to pull him down by the neck and kiss him.
"Only if we do this right" You say once you separate, not that he let you go far, his hands are on your waist pulling you flushed against him and his forehead is on yours "No more situationship or casual or whatever it was"
He nods "It was never casual" And he pulls you in for another kiss.
You break out of the kiss when you hear your friends cheering behind you.
"Hell yeah I did that motherfuckers!" Beau exclaims clapping loudly.
"The only thing you did was take me away from my essay" You tell him "And the threat still stands" He puts his hands up in surrender chuckling.






















