it would’ve been easier to grovel . to slip away before he got too close and beg on of the shot girls to trade places with her . it would’ve been easier to avoid him completely , but maybe she missed the sound of his voice , even if there was an edge to it now . she wanted nothing more than to forget the way it sounded whispered against her skin , sighed in the dark of the night , or spoken first thing in the morning . she wanted nothing more than to forget his voice entirely , and yet , sometimes she swore she heard it in her dreams . though when she was sleeping , it wasn’t nearly as bitter as it was in reality . marisol immediately regretted not marching away when she had the chance . ( but then again , matthew montgomery always had a magnetic kind’f pull to him , didn’t he ? ) she inhaled through her teeth , brows furrowing slightly as she looked him over . “ hormonal , huh ? ” she tilted her head , giving him a pointed look of disapproval , “ god , i hope your lyrics aren’t as cliche as that was these days . c’mon , you’re better than that . ” she wondered if he ever wrote about her , if the way she’d made him feel was ever big enough to put into song . lord knows she had plenty of canvases of pale blue tainted by black brushstrokes . was it really so long ago that he sat on the other side of that very counter , looking at her as though she were the only girl in the room ? these days , she wasn’t even sure if that had ever been real . these days , she wondered if it was all in her head .
if she had to guess based solely on the way he spoke to her now , she’d say there was never anything other than disdain between them . i know you think the world revolves around you … her expression faltered , and for a sliver of a moment , she allowed hurt to flash in her eyes before she found her footing again . marisol knew she was a lot of things , but selfish had never really been one of them . and for someone who spent so much of her time bending and breaking to appease others , it hurt to hear . the look was gone as soon as it had come , dutifully replaced by a well - practiced , darling smile . she’d gotten her first bartending gig when she was just eighteen ; five years later , she knew how to put on a pretty face for patrons . and that’s all matt was to her now . so she smiled pretty , and her voice was smooth and sweet as she said , “ most people like my commentary . ” she swiped up a hand towel from her side of the bar and tossed it over her shoulder . maybe she could ignore him . she tried as much as someone else stepped up to the bar , and she filled a pint glass to the brim with some shitty beer on tap , all the while charming him . or rather , asking him about himself . men loved talking about themselves . he went to the university of miami , he was in some allegedly brag - worthy fraternity , and he left her a tip that nearly cost more than the drink itself . but for all her focus , she still couldn’t help but turn back to him . a tide relentlessly crashing upon the jagged shore . “ so … what ? shitty vodka at home not cutting it tonight ? you had to come out , alone , to sit at a bar , alone , and brood ? ” her eyes widened in fake sympathy , a small gasp passing her lips , “ did adrian finally get sick of you ? ” but the theatrics fell quickly thereafter , “ seriously , matt , this is fucking depressing . ”
this is how their little games often went. at first the bitterness was softened by the past, but every blow continued to spiral until they were hitting where it hurt. the worst part of it wasn’t the hurt feelings or the negative attention they’d get from anyone within earshot. no. the worst part was knowing this was preferable. the worst part was knowing that he couldn’t stop. insults were the last thing the two shared, and it seemed that neither party was willing to give up the last strand of connection. “yeah? well, that’s probably because i actually care about my lyrics.” he shot back simply. his fingers curled around the glass, blue eyes focused on the way the ice floated near the top. the insinuation that he didn’t care about her was silly. too much wasted breath on insults for someone to not matter. yet, he said It with conviction. even if his words were far from the truth, he wanted marisol to believe them. he wanted to believe them. not caring was an easier pill to swallow than grief. he’d never been the type of man to mourn at a funeral.
there’s a beat of silence between them. short enough to go unnoticed by the other bar patrons, but long enough for matt’s chest to tighten. for a split second, there’s no malice filled insults or hatred burning between the two. for a split second, marisol just looks hurt. and for that split second, all matthew feels is a deep pit of regret. the same feeling that arose the night they ended things. in this moment, he’s hyper aware of what used to be and what is. there was a time where he would do anything to avoid hurting her. now that was all they did: hurt one another over and over again in an attempt to feel something. however, that second is just a second. a brief moment in time gone far too quickly. maybe if they allowed the feelings to linger, maybe if he allowed himself to feel the pain, he wouldn’t want to create more of it. the potential leaves as soon as it comes though, and they’re back to where they started. fighting at the bar.
the smile she has so delicately placed on her lips is not her own. or maybe it’s just not the one she used to reserve for him. this smile is cold and empty-- maybe it’s the one he deserved from the start. “Doubtful.” He replied back under his breath, though the brunette is already halfway down the bar taking care of someone else. complimenting someone else. charming someone else. his fingers curl tighter around the glass until his knuckles go white. matt can’t do much but sit there and bite his cheek so hard it almost draws blood. he’s never been the type of guy who held his anger well. it’s like filling a pot to the brim and then asking the water to boil. there was no other options than to let It spill over. by the time she came back around, that’s exactly what happened. “you wanna know why i’m here? maybe i’m here to take someone else home. maybe i like watching you look on from the sidelines and know you weren’t good enough to cut it. actually. you wanna know what i think marisol? i think that you’re the only one whose still fucking depressed and it’s really about time you get the fuck over yourself.”