Llannerch Pellger

So I decided, as an enthusiast of the history of the abrahamic faiths, to give my ten cents.. because Gwaedlladd knows that just my two cents wouldn't be enough.

Lilith is technically Jewish.. but only in the same way that Mithras is technically Roman.

That is to say.. she isn't. Not really

Both are foreign deities (in Lilith's case, Mesopotamian) with a native (exilic-period Judean) coat of fanficy paint.

Only two groups of people could possibly argue with this.

The Jews.. who would obviously be biased towards their own faith (since at the end of the day, Jewish religion is still a religion. I don't know how many of you need to be told that but there you go).

People who genuinely believe that Lilith was a major character in the Bible.. and thus haven't done any real research on the figure outside of watching Supernatural and Hazbin Hotel.

Both groups would basically be doing the equivalent of saying the character of Spock from Star Trek belongs to Marvel comics because he knocked out Wolverine in a crossover once.

And just to drive the point home and get myself in as much trouble as possible.. yes, I am explicitly "talking over" your precious Jews right now.

Because unlike you all, I don't give a single fucking SHIT that the 1940's happened. I give a shit about who's done their homework and who can look at that homework with an unbiased eye.

So.. me. I give a shit about me and what I'm saying.. because I'm fucking right and all of you "educated" dipwads are fucking wrong.

The Mesopotamians are gone. Lilith is open.

Doesn't matter what people who easily have their heartstrings pulled think about it.

Doesn't matter what the "oppressed" group doing the heartstring pulling has to say about it either.

Or do you need a couple more minutes to reach it?

But yes there are very few things that I would confess myself to not be unbiased about.

The study of religion is not one of them.

My audience will see me however it is they please to. You do not have access to the inside of my head and you never can.

I'm unbiased.

And the only thing you're proving with that last paragraph is that you're exactly the kind of pop-culture-worshiping twerp I was gunning after in my original post.

This isn't your college debate club. It's not my job to convince you of objective reality. You're a big boy and should be able to see it for yourself.

Oh wait no you're not going to because you're content to use your humanity as an excuse to be biased, by your own admission.

So I decided, as an enthusiast of the history of the abrahamic faiths, to give my ten cents.. because Gwaedlladd knows that just my two cents wouldn't be enough.

Lilith is technically Jewish.. but only in the same way that Mithras is technically Roman.

That is to say.. she isn't. Not really

Both are foreign deities (in Lilith's case, Mesopotamian) with a native (exilic-period Judean) coat of fanficy paint.

Only two groups of people could possibly argue with this.

The Jews.. who would obviously be biased towards their own faith (since at the end of the day, Jewish religion is still a religion. I don't know how many of you need to be told that but there you go).

People who genuinely believe that Lilith was a major character in the Bible.. and thus haven't done any real research on the figure outside of watching Supernatural and Hazbin Hotel.

Both groups would basically be doing the equivalent of saying the character of Spock from Star Trek belongs to Marvel comics because he knocked out Wolverine in a crossover once.

And just to drive the point home and get myself in as much trouble as possible.. yes, I am explicitly "talking over" your precious Jews right now.

Because unlike you all, I don't give a single fucking SHIT that the 1940's happened. I give a shit about who's done their homework and who can look at that homework with an unbiased eye.

So.. me. I give a shit about me and what I'm saying.. because I'm fucking right and all of you "educated" dipwads are fucking wrong.

The Mesopotamians are gone. Lilith is open.

Doesn't matter what people who easily have their heartstrings pulled think about it.

Doesn't matter what the "oppressed" group doing the heartstring pulling has to say about it either.

Or do you need a couple more minutes to reach it?

But yes there are very few things that I would confess myself to not be unbiased about.

The study of religion is not one of them.

My audience will see me however it is they please to. You do not have access to the inside of my head and you never can.

So I decided, as an enthusiast of the history of the abrahamic faiths, to give my ten cents.. because Gwaedlladd knows that just my two cents wouldn't be enough.

Lilith is technically Jewish.. but only in the same way that Mithras is technically Roman.

That is to say.. she isn't. Not really

Both are foreign deities (in Lilith's case, Mesopotamian) with a native (exilic-period Judean) coat of fanficy paint.

Only two groups of people could possibly argue with this.

The Jews.. who would obviously be biased towards their own faith (since at the end of the day, Jewish religion is still a religion. I don't know how many of you need to be told that but there you go).

People who genuinely believe that Lilith was a major character in the Bible.. and thus haven't done any real research on the figure outside of watching Supernatural and Hazbin Hotel.

Both groups would basically be doing the equivalent of saying the character of Spock from Star Trek belongs to Marvel comics because he knocked out Wolverine in a crossover once.

And just to drive the point home and get myself in as much trouble as possible.. yes, I am explicitly "talking over" your precious Jews right now.

Because unlike you all, I don't give a single fucking SHIT that the 1940's happened. I give a shit about who's done their homework and who can look at that homework with an unbiased eye.

So.. me. I give a shit about me and what I'm saying.. because I'm fucking right and all of you "educated" dipwads are fucking wrong.

The Mesopotamians are gone. Lilith is open.

Doesn't matter what people who easily have their heartstrings pulled think about it.

Doesn't matter what the "oppressed" group doing the heartstring pulling has to say about it either.

Or do you need a couple more minutes to reach it?

But yes there are very few things that I would confess myself to not be unbiased about.

The study of religion is not one of them.

So I decided, as an enthusiast of the history of the abrahamic faiths, to give my ten cents.. because Gwaedlladd knows that just my two cents wouldn't be enough.

Lilith is technically Jewish.. but only in the same way that Mithras is technically Roman.

That is to say.. she isn't. Not really

Both are foreign deities (in Lilith's case, Mesopotamian) with a native (exilic-period Judean) coat of fanficy paint.

Only two groups of people could possibly argue with this.

The Jews.. who would obviously be biased towards their own faith (since at the end of the day, Jewish religion is still a religion. I don't know how many of you need to be told that but there you go).

People who genuinely believe that Lilith was a major character in the Bible.. and thus haven't done any real research on the figure outside of watching Supernatural and Hazbin Hotel.

Both groups would basically be doing the equivalent of saying the character of Spock from Star Trek belongs to Marvel comics because he knocked out Wolverine in a crossover once.

And just to drive the point home and get myself in as much trouble as possible.. yes, I am explicitly "talking over" your precious Jews right now.

Because unlike you all, I don't give a single fucking SHIT that the 1940's happened. I give a shit about who's done their homework and who can look at that homework with an unbiased eye.

So.. me. I give a shit about me and what I'm saying.. because I'm fucking right and all of you "educated" dipwads are fucking wrong.

The Mesopotamians are gone. Lilith is open.

Doesn't matter what people who easily have their heartstrings pulled think about it.

Doesn't matter what the "oppressed" group doing the heartstring pulling has to say about it either.

Or do you need a couple more minutes to reach it?