Sometimes silly, sometimes smutty, sometimes just ideas I can't get out of my silly little head. All stories are 100% mine and are 18+ unless otherwise specified.
Call On Me (One Shot)
Blue Christmas (series)
Chris as a father to twin boys (request)
Scare Tactics (Halloween One shot)
Hard To Get (one shot)
Cheers (one shot)
Breathe (one shot)
Every Move You Make (mini)
part one
part two
part three
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch âą No registration required âą HD streaming
The last month you had been busy with award show to award show. Always on the red carpet for pictures and interviews while Joe was away on tour. It hurt when he left but you knew you couldnât go with him because of your insane press tour for your latest album.
âI miss you.â Joe says smiling face on the phone.
He was on a car ride back to the hotel after the 3rd show of the tour.
âI miss you too.â
A brief silence falls over the line.
âI saw pictures of you and Malcom yesterday.â You know his tone is off.
âYeah, he was nice I guess.â You subtlety answer not wanting to bring up his tone or lack there of.
âLooked like it.â He says looking past the camera.
âBabe.â You look at him with a really? kind of tone.
âWhat?â
âCome on, seriously babe I was talking to everyone last night.â
âI knowâ his gaze leaves the screen again.
âDo you? Because I think youâre jealousâŠâ
He laughs with a breath âNo Iâm not I was just saying he looks nice.â
âAlright babe whatever you say.â you laugh. âIâm excited to see you tomorrow.â
âMe too. You still up to do Last Goodbye?â
âYeah!â
He nods and smiles sensing your excitement to preform and see him.
The next day comes fast. The minute you land Joe is all over you. His arm is always around you or heâs hugging you from behind. Youâre sitting on his lap in the green room waiting for him to go on.
âOkâ you say beginning to stand up before he pulls you back on his lap with a smirk. You laugh flopping back. âJoe I need to get dressed.â
âYou are dressedâ he says pressing his face in your neck.
âBabe I have to get dressed for the show.â You pull his face out of your neck and run your hands through his hair. âYouâve been so clingy all day for someone who claims they were not at all jealous.â
He pulls back in fake offense. âSo what if I was I missed you.â
âI missed you too and I can assure you there is no reason to be jealous.â You rest your hands on his shoulders.
Joes voice echos through the stadium as he announces your presence. You run through the barricaded pathway to the stage high fiving and smiling at fans. You climb up the stairs and greeted by a tight hug from Joe. He releases you with a smile, bringing the microphone to his lips. âCome on everybody! Look who it is.â The crowd cheered as you laughed and walked over to the mic stand snapping the mic into place. The chords to the intro rang out and you could see some fans recognize instantly.
Joe gazed at you the whole song there was something in his gut he couldnât shake. After tonight he would be far away from you again and people at events would steal your attention. He knew you would never cheat it wasnât you he was worried about it was the lingering glances some people gave you. The obvious flirting in conversations, leaning in closer when you talked. When the song needed he walked over to give you another hug as you waved bye to Javi, Wes, the rest of the band and the crowd. He watched you disappear back into the arena.
The green room was cold and quiet, you throw on one of Joeâs hoodies and a cap. You check your phone, he has 20 more minutes on his set. You make your way down the narrow hallway leading to side stage.
âHey!â You turn to the voice to see Kevin getting ready for his set.
âHey! You excited for another night?â
âAlways. You did great tonight!â He smiles taking a mic pack from a stage hand with a quiet thank you.
âThank you! I had so much fun!â You both begin to walk closer to the side stage discussing the night and how much longer youâre staying.
What you didnât realize is Joe noticed you two on the side and once he noticed he couldnât stop looking. The feeling had returned it was a mix of nausea and something that wasnât quite anger. He knew Kevin would never he had a wife and was nothing but friendly but it was the thought of you with someone else.
Kevin had left to gather last minute things as you finished watching Joes set. He glanced over often way too often. His performer self usually wouldnât waver from the moment and audience for too long but something caught his attention and you know exactly what it was.
The hotel door creaked when you opened it stepping inside. Joe walks straight past you hopping on the bed in exhaustion. You giggle at his dramatics.
âI had so much fun tonight.â You lay next to him both staring at the ceiling.
âMe too.â His answer was short.
You turn on your side. âAlright drama queen whatâs wrong?â His eyes donât move from the ceiling
âNothing just tired.â
âBabe.â you spoke softly but strongly. With that he turns his body to face you.
âItâs stupid.â
âIf youâre this upset it clearly isnât.â you laugh out
âI trust you, you know that.â you nod because itâs true there is a strong mutual trust in your relationship that you both had a hard time finding in previous endeavors. âI just have this irrational fear youâll decide you want better.â he says every word looking right in your eyes.
âI would nev-â his lips crash into yours. A suprised gasp escapes you when he immediately pushes his tongue past yours lips. He was not taking it slow, not tonight. You canât even register how fast every thing before he flips his body to tower over yours breaking the kiss to look into your eyes, a silent look for reassurance before he dives back into your lips.
His hand moves to the hem of your shirt and (his) hoodie pulling it off revealing nothing underneath. He pulls away in shock.
You shrug. âNeeded to get comfy after my 5 minutes of fame.â He lets out a breathy laugh and moves his head to your neck licking and nipping at the soft sensitive skin. Gasps whisper from your lips as you move to take his shirt off, discarding it on the floor. He returns to your lips as his hands knead your bare breasts peaking the buds. You slot your knee between his thighs pressing gently on his obvious hard on. A whine leaves his lips when you put your knee down. You take that as a sign to work the button and zipper of his jeans.
âFuck babe I guess weâre both in a rush tonight.â He says drawing circles on your hips. You pull his jeans and boxes down in one swift motion. You look between your bodies.
âGod.â you throw your head back. The sight never failed to make your thighs clench. He noticed immediately pulling your shorts and underwear down. He moans at the sight of your soaked core.
âNo need for foreplay huh?â You shake your head. âGonna make sure you know you can never leave me.â You moan throwing your hand on his shoulder gripping tight at the thought.
He wasnât joking when he said no foreplay because the next second he slams into you harshly making you arch off the bed with a loud moan.
âFuck Joeâ He keeps pounding into in steady hard motions that hit the spot that makes your whole body tense every time.
âThatâs it baby.â He says looking between your bodies with a groan. âNever gonna forget are you?â
âFuck no Iâm notâ you say with a cry as you feel his lips attach to the sweet spot on your neck. The coil in your gut grows tighter. âIâm close fuck iâm so close.â You murmur between breathy moans.
âMe too babyâ He whispered in your ear making you shatter at the sound you clench around him as his thrusts begin to falter. âQuick babe where do you want me?â he says between groans.
âInside fuck.â youâre still riding out your high.
âOh fuck.â The sound of your voice sent him over the edge spilling deep in you. He lays gently on top of you. Sweat and heavy breathing fill the atmosphere as you sit in silence.
âIâm never leaving you ever Joe.â He looks up with a grin and light in his eyes. âI love you way too much.â
âI love you too baby.â he places a gentle kiss on your lips.
âPlus youâre way too good in bed.â
âOh i knowâ he says full of pride. âYou donât just make those sounds for fun.â You slap him playfully.
Chapter ten: Pretending Costs Nothing Until Morning
Warnings: angst!!!one bad decision leading to a worse one,references to being hurt. pining, secret keeping, lovers-to-exes-to-something-else. sloooow burn.
Description: He climbs through her window like itâs still two years ago. She lets him. Neither of them mentions that this is exactly the thing they swore, an hour earlier, they were done doing. Some people are easy to walk away from. He was never that
word count: 14.5k
Steve Harrington x fem!reader
Authors note: ok so i cried so what. I just love a man that cries. PLEASE PLS PLS lmk what ya think and if you would like to be on the tag list lmk! From the bottom of my heart thank you all so much for the support it means so much to me and I love seeing yâallâs reactions (also gator fic potentially coming soon:))
Series masterlist | previous chapter
-
Your back hit the seat of the car hard enough to rattle the frame, Steve's mouth already on yours, rough and consuming, one hand fisted in your hair while the other gripped your hip like he couldn't decide where he wanted to touch you first. You kissed him back with equal intensity, fingers digging into the front of his shirt, some reckless, unthinking hunger driving every single second of it, neither of you paying the slightest attention to anything beyond the frantic, tangled space between your two bodies in the cramped back seat.
You didn't hear footsteps crossing the grass outside. You didn't hear anyone approach at all until a sharp knock rapped against the fogged-up window, close enough to make you both jump.
"Oh my God!"
You wrenched apart, breathless, disheveled, twisting around to find Lucy peering through the glass, one hand flying up to shield her eyes a half-second too late, Robin and Nancy crowding in just behind her, both of them going instantly, comically still at the sight in front of them.
"I'm so sorry, I did not need to see that," Lucy said, still not lowering her hand, though her voice had already tipped over into something closer to delighted horror than actual apology. "Oh my God. Oh my God, you two."
"This is notâ" You scrambled to tug your dress back into place, face burning, heart still hammering from an entirely different reason a moment ago. "This isn't what it looks like."
"It's extremely what it looks like," Robin said flatly through the glass, arms crossed, though the corner of her mouth was already twitching. "You were basically eating each other alive in the back of Steve's car."
Steve, jaw tight, said absolutely nothing, dragging a hand back through his hair, looking anywhere except at any of the three women currently staring through the window with matching expressions of stunned disbelief.
"How long has this been happening?" Nancy asked, arms crossed, though her tone carried more exasperation than actual shock.
Nobody answered right away, and the silence alone seemed to tell her everything she needed to know.
"Unbelievable," Nancy muttered, shaking her head, though something almost fond flickered underneath the exasperation. "You two are actually unbelievable."
"Okay, can we maybe not do this through a car window?" Robin said, glancing around at the mostly empty street, a few stray party goers still stumbling toward their own cars in the distance. "Get out. Both of you. We need actual words, not fogged glass and vague noises."
You scrambled for the door handle, mortification burning fresh and hot with every second that passed, and climbed out on unsteady legs, tugging your dress down as far as it would go, entirely unable to meet anyone's eyes. Steve followed a moment later, considerably less flustered on the surface, though the tight set of his jaw gave away exactly how uncomfortable he actually was.
"So," Lucy said, arms crossed now, studying the two of you with an expression that had fully tipped over from horror into gleeful, merciless curiosity. "How long, exactly, has 'we hate each other and it's never gonna work' actually meant this?"
"This is literally the first time," you said quickly, cheeks burning. "I swear. It just happened. Tonight. After everything."
"So there's been nothing before tonight?" Nancy asked, studying you both carefully, not entirely convinced.
"Nothing," Steve confirmed, voice flat, though something in his tone suggested even he wasn't sure whether that made it better or worse.
"Huh." Robin glanced between the two of you, some of her earlier teasing giving way to genuine surprise. "Okay, that's actually kind of worse, in a way. One giant unplanned collision instead of a slow, at least somewhat-considered decision."
"Thanks, Robin, very comforting," you muttered.
"I'm just saying, this feels like the two of you finally exploding after days of pretending you weren't gonna, and honestly, that tracks completely with everything else about your entire dynamic." Robin shrugged, unbothered. "Does anyone else know? Lucy, did you know?"
"I did not know!" Lucy's voice climbed, somewhere between offended and thrilled. "I am her best friend and I did not know something like this was even a possibility tonight! Do you understand how out of the loop I feel right now?"
"There was nothing to know," you admitted finally, quiet, exhaustion catching up fast with the mortification. "It wasn't planned. We had this massive fight, and then somehow it turned into â this. We never even talked about it happening. It just did."
"Of course it did," Nancy said, not unkindly, though something knowing settled into her voice. "That tracks. Very on-brand for the two of you."
Steve, still saying almost nothing, shifted his weight, glancing toward you briefly before looking away again, some old, wary discomfort radiating off him at having the whole careful, unspoken arrangement suddenly dragged out into the open like this.
"Look," he said finally, voice rough, "it's complicated, and honestly, it's kind of nobody's business but ours."
"It became our business the second I walked up on you two going at it in a parked car outside a house party," Robin said, though her tone had softened slightly, something more serious creeping in underneath the teasing now. "I'm not trying to embarrass you. I just â I worry about both of you. And whatever tonight actually was, it doesn't exactly sound like a great sign for either of your mental health, if we're being honest, especially considering how the fight that led into it apparently went."
The teasing energy in the little group shifted, quieter now, and you wrapped your arms around yourself against the cold, suddenly feeling far more exposed than the mortification alone could account for.
"We know it wasn't exactly the healthiest way to end a fight," you admitted, voice small. "We just â got carried away. It won't happen again."
"I'm taking her home," Lucy said, already looping her arm through yours with firm, decisive energy, clearly not interested in leaving room for further discussion. "Come on. I think we've all had enough excitement for one night."
You let her steer you away from the group, legs still a little unsteady, and had barely made it two steps before Steve's voice cut through behind you.
"Y/N, wait."
You turned, and he was standing there by the open car door, something raw and apologetic written plainly across his face, the earlier heat between you already replaced by something more sober and uncertain.
"I'm sorry," he said, quiet, just for you, though the others were still close enough to hear every word. "For tonight. For all of it Carrie, the fight, this. I didn't mean for any of it to happen the way it did."
"I know," you said, and meant it, though you didn't have the energy left to say much more than that.
"This probably wasn't a good idea." He gestured vaguely between the two of you, something tired and honest in the admission. "Any of it. I don't want you to think I don't know that."
Something in you bristled, quiet and unexpected, at the phrase. âThis probably wasn't a good idea.â Like the last several hours had been some careless miscalculation instead of the first thing that had actually felt real between the two of you in weeks. You didn't examine why it stung the way it did, only that it did, some small, wounded part of you hearing it and filing it away alongside everything else you weren't ready to look at too closely tonight.
"Right," you said, voice flatter than you meant it to be. "A bad idea. Got it."
"That's not â I didn't mean it likeâ"
"It's fine, Steve." You managed a small, tight smile that didn't quite reach your eyes. "Goodnight."
You let Lucy pull you the rest of the way toward her car, and didn't look back.
Lucy didn't say much until you were both walking away , and when she finally did speak, her voice had lost every trace of the earlier teasing, replaced by something sharper and more serious.
"I'm not gonna pretend I'm not worried about you," she said, eyes fixed on the road. "That whole thing back there, Y/N that wasn't cute. That wasn't some fun, messy hookup story we're gonna laugh about later. You guys apparently had a huge fight and twenty minutes later you're all over each other in a parked car. That's not healthy. That's not even close to healthy."
"I know it looked badâ"
"It didn't just look bad, it was bad." Lucy's voice climbed, frustration bleeding through now. "Steve is not good for you, Y/N. I've watched this happen over and over, this exact cycle, for months now. You fight, you scream, you say horrible things to each other, and then somehow you end up right back in each other's arms like none of it happened, and then it happens all over again a few weeks later. That's not love. That's just two people who can't stop hurting each other and calling it passion."
"That's not fair."
"Isn't it, though?" Lucy glanced over at you at a red light, something genuinely worried beneath the frustration now. "I love you. That's why I'm saying this. I watched you cry in a driveway a month ago because of that boy. I watched you spiral for weeks after he lied to you for a year. And now I'm watching you climb into his back seat the same night you told him it was never gonna work, and I don't know how to keep pretending that's not a pattern worth being scared of."
You didn't have an answer for that, staring out the window instead, exhaustion and shame and something more complicated tangling together in your chest, and Lucy, apparently deciding she'd said enough for one night, let the silence stretch on for the rest of the drive, though the weight of her words sat heavy in the car the entire way home.
Steve hadn't meant to hear it. He'd been standing close enough, still processing the sting of your flat, closed-off âgoodnightâ, when Lucy's voice had carried back to him across the yard, sharp and clear in the quiet night air.
âSteve is not good for you, Y/N.â
He hadn't caught the rest, the two of you already too far away by the time the words registered, but that single fragment lodged itself somewhere deep and immediate in his chest, and he stood there a long moment after your car had pulled away, staring at the empty street, feeling the truth of it settle over him like something cold and inescapable.
"You okay?" Robin asked quietly, coming to stand beside him, Nancy close behind her.
"Yeah." He wasn't. He didn't elaborate.
They stood there in silence for a while, the party's noise still humming faintly behind them, and Steve was still turning Lucy's words over and over in his head when Eddie came stumbling around the side of the house, visibly, spectacularly drunk, tripping slightly over the uneven lawn before catching himself on the fence.
"There you guys are!" Eddie's voice came out too loud, slurred and delighted, arms spread wide like he was greeting old friends after years apart instead of people he'd seen twenty minutes ago. "I've been looking everywhere! Did I miss something? I feel like I missed something. There's, like, a vibe. Very heavy vibe happening right now."
"You missed a lot, actually," Robin said dryly.
"Tell me everything." Eddie swayed slightly, draping an arm heavily over Steve's shoulder for balance, entirely unbothered by his own obvious lack of coordination. "Wait, where's Lucy? I was gonna ask Lucy something important. Very important question. I don't remember what it was, but I remember it was important."
"She just left. She's taking Y/N home," Nancy said, watching him with careful, amused patience.
"Oh." Eddie's face fell, genuine disappointment crossing his features despite the haze of alcohol. "Dang. Okay. Well. Tell her I saidâ" He paused, swaying again, clearly losing his own train of thought mid-sentence. "I don't remember. Tell her I said something nice, though. Something charming."
"I'll pass that along," Robin said, biting back a smile.
Eddie's attention drifted back to Steve, squinting at him with the particular, unfocused intensity of someone very drunk trying very hard to seem perceptive. "You look sad. Why do you look sad? Didn't you leave with Carrie? Where's Carrie?"
"Carrie left a while ago," Steve said flatly.
"Oh." Eddie considered this for a long moment, swaying gently. "Was that because of the thing? The Y/N thing?"
"Sure. The thing." Steve dragged a hand down his face, exhaustion finally catching up with him completely.
"Man." Eddie shook his head slowly, entirely too sincere for how drunk he clearly was. "You gotta figure your stuff out, buddy. I say that with love. Complete, total love. But you gotta figure it out, because thisâ" he gestured vaguely, nearly losing his balance again, "âthis is not sustainable. This is, like, a genuinely unsustainable emotional situation you've got going on."
"Thank you, Eddie," Steve said, dry, though something in his chest ached at how accurate the drunken assessment actually was.
"I'm just saying." Eddie patted his shoulder heavily, nearly knocking him off balance in the process. "I love you, man. I love all of you. This has been a very emotional night for everyone, I think."
Robin caught Steve's eye over Eddie's shoulder, something wry and exhausted passing between them, and neither of them argued with that particular assessment at all.
"Okay, I think we should get you home," Nancy said, gently steering Eddie by the shoulders before he could topple sideways into the fence again. "Before you say something else devastatingly accurate that nobody's emotionally prepared for tonight."
"I contain multitudes," Eddie said solemnly, allowing himself to be steered, though he twisted back to look at Steve one more time before Nancy could fully redirect him. "Hey. Steve. Seriously though."
"Yeah?"
"You gotta actually talk to her. Like, real talking. Not the yelling kind, not the â whatever that was tonight." Eddie gestured vaguely toward the now-empty street where your car had disappeared. "The actual, sit-down, say-what-you-mean kind. I know it's scary. I get it. But you two keep doing the same loop over and over, and loops don't end unless somebody actually breaks them."
Steve didn't answer right away, something in his chest going tight and uncomfortable at how clearly, how simply Eddie had just laid out the exact thing he'd been avoiding for weeks.
"I hear you," he said finally, quiet.
"Good." Eddie nodded, satisfied, already letting Nancy lead him toward her car. "Love you, man. Very emotional night. Somebody get me a burger."
Robin watched them go, then turned back to Steve, arms crossed, her earlier teasing energy fully gone now, replaced by something more careful and searching.
"He's not wrong, you know," she said quietly. "Drunk, but not wrong."
"I know." Steve dragged both hands down his face, exhaustion finally catching up with him completely, the adrenaline of the entire night draining out all at once and leaving something hollow and heavy behind. "I don't know how to do the other thing, though. The talking. Every time I try, it turns into a fight, or it turns into â that." He gestured vaguely at the space where his car had been parked. "I don't know how to just say what I actually mean without it becoming a disaster."
"Maybe you start smaller." Robin's voice softened, some genuine care threading through the practical advice. "Not some big, dramatic conversation. Just one true thing. Next time you see her. One honest sentence that isn't an accusation or an apology dressed up as one."
Steve considered that, turning it over slowly, some old, tired resistance warring against the quiet, obvious sense of it.
"One true thing," he repeated.
"One true thing." Robin bumped his shoulder gently, some of her earlier warmth returning. "You can do that much, probably. Even you."
"Thanks for the vote of confidence."
"Anytime." She managed a small, tired smile, glancing toward her own car. "Come on. I'll drive you home. You look like you're about two minutes from falling asleep standing up."
Steve let her lead him toward the car, Eddie's words and Robin's quieter advice both settling somewhere deep in his chest, and for the first time in longer than he could easily remember, he found himself actually turning over what one true thing he might actually say, if he ever managed to work up the nerve to say anything honest at all.
You woke the next afternoon with a headache pounding steady behind your eyes and a mouth so dry it felt lined with sand, sunlight slicing bright and merciless through your curtains despite your best efforts to bury your face in the pillow and pretend the day simply wasn't happening yet.
The memories came back slow and disjointed, piece by unwelcome piece. The party. Carrie's cruelty. The yard, the screaming, the devastating, exposed honesty of that fight. And then, underneath all of it, the backseat, his hands, the desperate, reckless hour that had followed, and finally, worst of all, Lucy's voice in the car afterward, steady and serious in a way that had cut through the haze of everything else. âSteve is not good for you. That's not love. That's just two people who can't stop hurting each other and calling it passion.â
You lay there a long while, staring at your ceiling, letting the words settle properly now that the alcohol and adrenaline had fully worn off, and found, to your own quiet, uncomfortable surprise, that you couldn't actually argue with a single part of it.
You thought about the pattern Lucy had named so plainly the fighting, the reconciling, the fighting again, an endless, exhausting loop neither of you seemed capable of breaking no matter how many times you swore it was over. You thought about the note, the driveway, the gas station, the almost-kiss, the "get the fuck out of my house," and now this, one more entry on a list that had started to feel less like passion and more like some slow, repetitive injury you kept reopening on purpose.
You thought, too, about how it had felt in the moment desperate and consuming and, for a little while, blessedly uncomplicated, all the exhausting complexity of the actual relationship stripped away into something purely physical, purely present. You understood, lying there with your head throbbing, exactly why it had been so tempting. You also understood, with a clarity that felt almost cruel in the harsh, sober light of afternoon, that temptation and health had never once been the same thing, no matter how much you'd wanted them to be.
You didn't know what you were supposed to do with that understanding. You didn't know if knowing the pattern was destructive actually gave you the power to stop repeating it, or if you were simply someone who was going to keep making the same mistake with the same person, over and over, until one of you finally ran out of chances to try again.
You lay there a long while longer, hungover and exhausted and quietly, thoroughly unsettled, and didn't have a single good answer to offer yourself for any of it.
A year and a half earlier.
You'd been sitting on his bedroom floor, arms wrapped around your knees, watching him pace the length of the small room for the third time in as many minutes, his jacket still on, keys still in hand from wherever he'd disappeared to for the last four hours without a single word of explanation.
"You can't keep doing this," you'd said, voice already raw from the argument that had been building since he'd finally walked through the door. "You can't just vanish for an entire afternoon and come back expecting me to act like it's normal."
"I know. I'm sorry." He'd stopped pacing, dragging a hand through his hair, something exhausted and evasive in the gesture even then. "It's complicated."
"Everything's complicated with you lately." Your voice had cracked, hurt bleeding fast into anger. "I don't even know what that word means anymore, Steve, you use it for everything. I just want to know where you were."
"I can't tell you that."
"Why not?"
"I just can't, okay?" His voice had cracked up loud, frustration and something rawer tangled together underneath it. "I need you to just trust me on this."
"I don't know how to trust something I'm not allowed to understand!" You'd stood up then, chest heaving, tears burning hot and humiliating in your eyes. "You keep asking me for blind faith, over and over, and I keep giving it to you, and it's starting to feel like you're just taking advantage of the fact that I love you too much to actually walk away."
Something in his face had cracked at that, guilt and desperation warring visibly. "That's not what this is."
"Then what is it?"
He hadn't answered. He'd crossed the room instead, pulling you into his arms despite your initial, half-hearted resistance, and you'd let him, exhausted, some old, familiar relief flooding through you the second his arms closed around you, the fight dissolving almost instantly into something softer, more forgiving.
"I love you," he'd murmured into your hair, voice rough. "I know I'm not explaining any of this right. I know it's not fair to ask you to just accept it. But I promise, the second I can tell you anything, I will. I just need you to hold on a little longer."
"Okay," you'd whispered, and meant it, some part of you already deciding, right there in his arms, that this was simply what loving him looked like â fighting, and forgiving, and starting the whole cycle over again the second his arms found their way around you, no matter how little had actually been resolved.
You blinked back into the present, staring at your own ceiling, the memory dissolving as fast as it had come, and understood, with a fresh, unwelcome clarity, that the pattern Lucy had named last night hadn't started at that party at all. It had started here, in this exact shape, over a year and a half ago, the very first time you'd let an unresolved fight collapse into forgiveness without ever actually getting an answer.
You'd just gotten so good at repeating it that you'd stopped noticing you were doing it at all.
Steve found Robin at Family Video the next afternoon, restocking shelves with the same mechanical, distracted energy he recognized in his own hands lately, and pulled up a stool beside the counter without saying anything at first.
"You look like you didn't sleep," Robin said, not looking up from the tape in her hands.
"I didn't."
"Figured." She slid the tape into place and turned to face him properly, arms crossed, something patient and waiting in her expression. "You want to actually talk about it, or are we doing the thing where you sit there brooding until I have to drag it out of you?"
"I want to talk about it." Steve dragged a hand down his face, exhaustion evident in every line of him. "I just don't know where to start."
"Start with what actually happened. Not the version where you explain it away. The real version."
Steve was quiet for a moment, turning the request over. "I brought Carrie to hurt her. That's the real version. I dressed it up as a bunch of other things â proving I'd moved on, giving myself something to focus on besides missing her â but underneath all of it, I wanted Y/N to feel something. Anything."
"Okay." Robin nodded slowly, not flinching from the admission. "That's honest, at least. What do you think that says about you?"
"That I don't actually know how to want somebody to be happy without needing something back for myself." Steve's voice had gone rough. "That maybe I've never actually known how to do that. Not with her, not with anybody."
"That's a big realization for a Tuesday afternoon."
"Yeah, well. I've had a lot of time to think since Saturday." He rubbed at his eyes, tired. "I keep trying to figure out what it would actually look like. Being around her without it turning into a fight, or turning into â whatever happened after the fight. I don't actually know what healthy looks like with her, Robin. I don't think I've ever known."
Robin considered that for a moment, leaning back against the counter. "I think healthy probably starts with not needing anything from her every time you're in the same room. Not comfort, not jealousy, not a reaction, not forgiveness. Just â being there, saying something true, and letting her do whatever she wants with it. No strings."
"That sounds impossible."
"It's not impossible. It's just really hard, especially for you, because you've spent your whole life needing people to react to you a certain way to feel like you matter." Robin's voice stayed gentle despite the bluntness of it. "But it's not impossible. People learn how to do it. You could learn how to do it too, if you actually wanted to badly enough."
Steve sat with that, something in his chest going tight and uncomfortable at how accurately she'd named it. "What if I try, and it's still not enough? What if I finally get good at this whole honesty thing and she still doesn't want anything to do with me?"
"Then that's her choice to make, and you'll have to respect it." Robin's voice softened slightly. "But at least it'll be an honest ending instead of another loop. That has to be worth something, even if it's not the ending you want."
Steve didn't have an answer for that right away, staring down at his own hands, and Robin, apparently deciding he'd had enough to sit with for one afternoon, reached over and squeezed his shoulder gently.
"Small steps," she said. "You don't have to fix all of it today. Just don't do the Carrie thing again. That's step one."
"Step one," Steve repeated, managing something that might have almost been a smile. "Yeah. Okay. I can start there."
Parker ran into the kitchen later that night, practically vibrating with nervous energy.
"You have to come to Mike's Saturday," he said, without preamble, sliding onto one of the kitchen stools. "We rented that new movie, the one everybody's been talking about, the one Steve's been hyping up at the store for like two weeks straight. Everybody's gonna be there. You have to come.â
"Everybody like who?"
"Everybody everybody. Mike, Dustin, Lucas, Max" Parker's words tumbled out fast, barely pausing for breath. "Robin and Nancy are bringing snacks. Eddie's bringing his whole ranked list of horror movie opinions nobody asked for."
You felt your stomach tighten slightly at the obvious, unspoken name missing from the list. "Is Steve gonna be there?"
Parker paused, something careful crossing his face. "Probably. I mean, yeah. He's the one who got the tape in the first place."
You set your mug down, some old, familiar wariness creeping in. "Parkerâ"
"Please." His voice cracked slightly, more urgent now, and you registered, with a small pang of guilt, how much this actually seemed to matter to him. "I know things have been weird. I know you and Steve have been doing the thing where you're barely talking again. But this isn't about that. This is supposed to be, like, a good night. A normal night. I really want you there, Y/N. Please."
You studied his face, earnest and hopeful in a way that made it hard to hold onto your reservations, and felt something in you soften despite every careful boundary you'd been trying to build over the last week.
"Okay," you said finally, and Parker's whole face lit up. "I'll come."
"Really?"
"Really. I'm not promising I'll enjoy every second of it, but I'll come." You managed a small smile despite the anxious knot still sitting in your chest at the thought of an entire evening in the same space as Steve. "For you."
"You're the best." Parker was already sliding off the stool, some fresh burst of energy propelling him toward the door. "It's Saturday, don't forget! I already told everyone you were coming!â
"You already told everyone?" you called after him, though he was already gone, footsteps thundering up the stairs, leaving you standing alone in the kitchen with the lingering, complicated knowledge that in three days, you were going to be standing in the same room as Steve again, whether either of you were actually ready for it or not.
By Saturday afternoon, you'd changed your outfit four times, which felt, on some level, deeply embarrassing for what was ostensibly just a movie night at a fourteen-year-old's house.
You'd started with something deliberately plain, telling yourself firmly that the goal was low-key, unremarkable, a clear signal that you weren't trying to prove anything to anyone. Then you'd worried plain might look like you were trying too hard to look like you weren't trying, which made no sense even as you thought it, and you'd switched to something slightly nicer, only to immediately worry that nicer would look exactly like trying. You stood in front of your mirror now, on outfit number four, genuinely unable to remember what logic had gotten you there in the first place.
"This is insane," you said out loud, to your own reflection, and picked up the phone in your room to call Lucy before you could talk yourself into a fifth outfit change.
"I need you to talk me down from something," you said, the second she picked up.
"Ominous. Go."
"I've changed my outfit four times for a movie night at Mike Wheeler's house." You sat down hard on the edge of your bed, exhaustion and embarrassment tangling together. "Four times, Lucy. For a group of teenagers and my little brother's friends. This is not normal behavior."
"Okay, first of all, we both know this isn't about the teenagers." Lucy's voice carried the particular, patient amusement of someone who'd expected this call. "This is about Steve. Just say it. It'll feel better if you actually say it."
"Fine. It's about Steve." You dragged a hand down your face. "I don't know why I'm this nervous. It's not like anything's gonna happen. I told myself I wasn't gonna do the whole cycle thing again, and I meant it, and now I'm standing here agonizing over a shirt like it actually matters what I look like."
"It matters because you care what he thinks, even if you're trying really hard not to." Lucy's voice softened slightly. "That's not a character flaw, by the way. That's just being a person who still has feelings for somebody, even while trying to be smart about it."
"I don't want to have feelings for somebody I'm trying to be smart about."
"Yeah, well, feelings don't usually check in with the smart plan first." Lucy sighed, though not unkindly. "Look, do you actually want to go? Because if the anxiety's this bad already, you don't have to. Parker would probably survive one disappointing night."
You considered that for a moment, turning it over honestly instead of reflexively. "I want to go. I think I actually do. I just don't want to go and immediately fall back into old patterns the second I see him."
"Then don't." Lucy's voice was matter-of-fact, simple in a way that made the whole tangled knot in your chest ease slightly. "Go, be normal, watch the movie, talk to people who aren't him if it gets weird, and if you feel yourself sliding into old habits, just â notice it. That's it. You don't have to solve the whole thing tonight. You just have to notice when it's happening instead of getting swept up in it without realizing."
"That's annoyingly reasonable advice."
"I'm an annoyingly reasonable person, thank you for noticing." Lucy's grin was audible even through the phone. "Now go pick an outfit and stop overthinking it. Whatever you pick, you're gonna look fine. This isn't actually about the shirt, Y/N."
"I know." You managed a small, tired laugh, some of the tension finally easing out of your shoulders. "Thanks, Luce."
"Anytime. Call me after if you need to debrief. Or if something happens that requires immediate, detailed analysis."
"Nothing's gonna happen."
"Sure," Lucy said, entirely unconvinced, and you could practically hear her smiling. "We'll see."
Mike's basement was already loud and crowded by the time you arrived, the familiar chaos of the group filling the space with easy, overlapping noise Dustin and Lucas arguing about seating arrangements, Max sprawled across one end of the couch with a bowl of popcorn balanced on her knees, Eddie holding court near the TV with an already lengthy, unsolicited ranking of horror movies nobody had actually asked him to compile.
"Grab a spot," Mike said, catching your eye as you came down the stairs, already turning his attention back to the seating debate. "We're starting soon. Dustin's hogging the good blanket, just so you're aware."
"I am not hogging it, I am utilizing it correctly, there's a differenceâ"
"You're sitting on the entire thing, Dustin, nobody else can reach itâ"
You found a spot on the floor near Max, who shifted over to make room without being asked, offering you a small, easy smile and a handful of popcorn from her bowl.
"Glad you came," she said. "It's been kind of a weird week. Feels good to have a normal night for once."
"Yeah." You settled in, some of the tension in your shoulders finally easing at the familiar, comfortable chaos surrounding you. "It really does."
Robin and Nancy arrived a few minutes later, arms full of snacks, immediately swarmed by Dustin and Lucas both making competing requests, and the whole basement dissolved into a warm, easy kind of noise, everyone talking over each other, Eddie's movie rankings continuing uninterrupted in the background, the tape already queued up and waiting in the VCR.
You hadn't seen Steve yet. You found yourself glancing toward the stairs more than once, some anxious, anticipatory energy sitting low in your stomach despite the warmth of everything around you, and told yourself, firmly, to just enjoy the moment you were actually in instead of bracing for the one that hadn't happened yet.
He arrived about ten minutes later, tape in hand, and the basement erupted into a chorus of greetings and demands the second he came down the stairs Dustin practically lunging for the tape, Eddie immediately launching into some passionate argument about whether it lived up to the hype, Max asking if he'd remembered to grab the good candy this time.
Steve handled it all with easy, practiced patience, handing the tape over to Dustin, deflecting Eddie's opinions with a tired but fond half-smile, tossing a bag of candy toward Max without breaking stride, and it was only once the initial wave of attention had settled that his eyes finally found yours across the room.
Something passed between you, brief and careful, neither hostile nor warm exactly, just a quiet, mutual acknowledgment that you were both here, both trying, both uncertain how tonight was actually going to go.
"Hey," he said, simple, no weight thrown behind it.
"Hey," you said back, matching the tone, and something in your chest loosened slightly at how manageable that single exchange had actually felt.
The room, meanwhile, had already begun the familiar chaos of settling into seats, blankets and pillows redistributed with the kind of ruthless efficiency only a group of teenagers could manage, and you found yourself, without quite meaning to, tracking exactly where Steve ended up as the scramble resolved the armchair near the far end of the couch, close enough that you'd be within easy sightline for the entire movie, far enough that it didn't feel deliberate or forced.
You told yourself it didn't mean anything. You told yourself that a dozen times over the next few minutes, watching him settle in, exchange some easy, quiet joke with Robin beside him, and mostly believed it, except for the small, persistent awareness humming under your skin every time your eyes drifted, unbidden, back toward that armchair throughout the opening credits.
Nobody commented on it. If anyone in the room noticed the careful, deliberate distance the two of you were both maintaining, or the way your gaze kept drifting toward him despite it, they were kind enough, or wise enough, not to say anything at all.
The movie had barely gotten through its opening scene when Dustin, apparently unable to let a silence sit for longer than five minutes, twisted around from his spot on the floor to grin at Steve.
"So who was that girl you brought to Tina's party?" he asked, entirely too loud, delighted with himself. "Carrie? You never bring dates to things, man, I almost didn't recognize you. Very smooth. Very suave."
You felt your whole body go rigid, eyes fixed hard on the TV screen, not daring to look anywhere near Steve's direction.
"We're not doing this right now, Dustin," Steve said, voice carefully even, though you could hear the strain underneath it.
"I'm just saying, it's kind of a big deal! Steve Harrington, showing up with an actual date, in public, where people could see." Dustin, entirely oblivious to the sudden, careful tension humming through the room, kept going, clearly enjoying himself far too much to stop. "Did you guys have a good time? Are you gonna bring her again sometime? I feel like this is a whole new era for you."
"Dustin." Robin's voice cut in sharply from across the room, a clear, unmistakable warning.
"What? I'm just teasing him. It's a compliment, technically." Dustin glanced around, genuinely confused by the sudden wall of tension he'd apparently walked directly into. "What, am I not allowed to make fun of Steve for having a date now? That feels like a core part of our friendship."
"Just drop it," nancy said, not unkindly, reaching over to flick him lightly on the arm.
"Fine, fine." Dustin held up both hands, though he was clearly still pleased with himself, and turned back to the movie with obvious reluctance, muttering something about how Steve "used to be able to take a joke" under his breath.
You still hadn't looked at Steve. You could feel the weight of the whole exchange sitting heavy in the room regardless, the easy, comfortable atmosphere from a few minutes ago suddenly feeling considerably more fragile, and it took a genuine, deliberate effort to make yourself focus back on the movie instead of the careful, charged silence radiating from the armchair a few feet away.
You didn't manage it for long. The movie played on in front of you, dialogue and music filling the room, and you found your mind drifting anyway, snagging over and over on Dustin's careless, cheerful words âyou never bring dates to things, man, very smooth, very suaveâ until the memory of that whole night came crashing back in, sharp and unwelcome.
You remembered it clearly now, the way you hadn't quite let yourself sit with it in the days since. Steve hadn't brought Carrie because he liked her. He'd told you that himself, in the yard, voice cracking with the admission â he'd brought her specifically, deliberately, to hurt you. To make you feel something, anything, even if it was pain. You'd been so wrapped up in the fight itself, and everything that had happened after it, that you'd let the actual cruelty of the choice slide past you somehow, softened by his own devastating honesty in the moment.
Sitting here now, listening to Dustin's oblivious, cheerful teasing, the reality of it hit you fresh and cold all over again. He had planned it. He had thought about it, made a phone call, picked an outfit-appropriate excuse, and set the entire thing in motion with the specific, calculated goal of watching you hurt. And you'd kissed him anyway, hours later, in the back of his car, like that kind of cruelty was something you could just skip past on the way to something softer.
Your jaw tightened, some old, familiar fury rising hot and fast in your chest, and you kept your eyes fixed hard on the television screen, refusing to let a single flicker of it show on your face. You weren't going to make a scene. Not here, not in front of Parker, not in front of a room full of kids who had no idea what any of this actually meant.
You just sat there instead, arms crossed, jaw tight, watching a movie you'd completely lost track of, furious in a way that had nowhere left to go except quietly, privately inward, and didn't dare glance toward the armchair even once for the rest of the scene.
Steve noticed anyway.
He couldn't have said exactly what tipped him off nothing dramatic, no obvious shift in your posture that anyone else in the room would have caught but something about the careful, deliberate stillness of you had changed sometime in the last ten minutes, some easy warmth that had been there earlier now replaced by a rigid, controlled quality he recognized immediately, having spent enough time around your anger over the years to know exactly what it looked like even when you were working hard to hide it.
He ran through the last several minutes in his head, trying to place the exact moment it had happened, and landed, with a sinking, uncomfortable certainty, on Dustin's teasing. He hadn't thought much of it in the moment, mostly just embarrassed, eager for the topic to die so he could stop feeling the weight of everyone's attention. He hadn't considered, until just now, watching you sit there with your jaw locked and your eyes fixed hard on the screen, that the joke might have landed somewhere far more painful for you than it had for him.
He spent the rest of the movie only half paying attention, some anxious, uncertain energy building steadily in his chest, and when the credits finally started rolling and the group dissolved into its usual post-movie chaos Dustin already loudly relitigating the ending, Max and Lucas arguing about whether the twist had actually made sense Steve found himself gravitating toward the kitchen upstairs under the flimsy excuse of needing water, some instinct telling him you'd probably end up there too, needing space from the noise.
He was right. You were standing at the counter when he came in, pouring yourself a glass of water with movements that were just slightly too sharp, too controlled, and you didn't look up when he entered, though your shoulders went visibly tighter at the sound of the door.
"Hey," he said carefully, keeping his distance, hovering near the doorway instead of coming further in. "You okay?"
"I'm fine." Your voice came out clipped, flat, nothing at all like the easy tone from earlier in the evening.
"You don't seem fine."
"Well, I am." You set the glass down harder than necessary, water sloshing slightly over the rim, and finally looked at him, something cold and controlled burning behind your eyes that made his stomach drop immediately. "I'm great, actually. Just watching a movie. Having a totally normal night."
"Y/Nâ"
"Dustin's really funny, isn't he." Your voice stayed even, though the words came out sharp enough to cut.
Steve's whole body went still, understanding landing hard and immediate. "That's notâ"
"I remembered it while I was sitting there," you continued, voice low now, careful, clearly working hard to keep it contained. "I don't know why it took me this long, honestly. You told me yourself, in that yard, that you brought her on purpose. To make me feel something. And I was so wrapped up in the fight, and everything that happened after it, that I somehow let that part just â slide past me. Like it didn't matter. Like the fact that you planned it, actually sat down and made a phone call and picked her specifically to hurt me, wasn't actually the whole point of the entire night."
"I know I did that. I've apologized for itâ"
"You apologized in the yard, sure. And then twenty minutes later I was kissing you in the back of your car, so forgive me if the apology didn't exactly stick the way it probably should have." Your voice cracked slightly, some of the careful control finally slipping. "I keep doing this. I keep letting the big, dramatic moments overshadow the actual, specific cruelty underneath them, and then a twelve-year-old makes an innocent joke about your date and I remember, all over again, exactly how calculated it actually was."
Steve stood there, stricken, guilt crashing over him in a fresh, immediate wave. "I don't have a good excuse for it. I know that. I've known that since the second I saw your face at that party."
"I don't want an excuse." Your voice had gone quiet now, exhausted rather than sharp. "I just needed you to know that I remembered. That it's still sitting there, underneath everything else, even when I'm trying really hard to have a normal night with people who don't know any of this happened."
"I'm sorry." His voice came out rough, genuine. "I mean it. I know sorry doesn't undo it, but I am."
You didn't answer right away, staring down at the water glass in your hands, some of the fight draining out of you all at once, replaced by something heavier and more tired.
"I know you are," you said finally, quiet. "That doesn't really change how it felt, though."
Neither of you said anything else for a long moment, the muffled sound of the group's chaos still drifting up from the basement below, and you picked your glass back up, brushing past him toward the doorway without quite meeting his eyes.
"I need to get back downstairs," you said. "Parker's probably wondering where I went."
You left him standing there alone in the kitchen, the weight of everything you'd just said settling heavy over him, and it was a long moment before he trusted himself to follow you back down.
You'd barely settled back into your spot on the floor, forcing your expression into something resembling normal, when Eddie, still deep in his running commentary about the movie's third act, glanced over at Steve with a grin
"Anyway, speaking of dramatic backseat confrontations," he said, gesturing vaguely at the screen, "reminds me of somebody's little car situation a couple days back. Very similar energy, honestly. Very 'this escalated way faster than anyone expected.'"
The room went quiet in exactly the wrong way.
"What car situation?" Dustin asked, immediately, predictably interested, twisting around to look between Eddie and Steve.
Eddie blinked, some slow, dawning realization crossing his face a beat too late. "Oh. Oh, wait. You guys didn'tâ"
"Eddie." Robin's voice cut in sharp, urgent, but the damage was already thoroughly, completely done.
"What car situation?" Dustin repeated, louder now, delighted at the obvious existence of information he didn't have yet. "Steve, what is he talking about?"
"Nothing," Steve said, too fast, jaw tight.
"It's clearly not nothing, Robin just used her scary voice." Max sat up straighter, grinning now too, sensing genuine gossip within reach. "Come on, what happened?"
"I didn't mean toâ" Eddie winced, glancing apologetically toward you, toward Steve, clearly recognizing the scale of what he'd just done even through the fog of trying to backtrack. "I thought this was, like, established information. I didn't realize it was still a secret."
"It's not a secret, it's just notâ" You stopped, humiliation flooding hot and immediate through your chest, every pair of eyes in the room now fixed squarely on you. "It's not something we need to discuss right now. Or ever, actually."
"Discuss what, though?" Lucas asked, entirely too curious for his own good.
"Steve and Y/N made out in his car after the party," Eddie said finally, apparently deciding the cat was sufficiently out of the bag that half-answers were only making things worse. "That's that's the whole thing. That's all I meant. I'm sorry, I really did think everyone already knew."
The basement erupted into a chorus of stunned, delighted reactions âDustin's mouth dropping open, Max letting out a short, disbelieving laugh, Lucas immediately turning to stare at Mike like he needed independent confirmation this was actually real.
"Wait, seriously?" Dustin's voice climbed several octaves. "You guys made out? After everything? After the whole â the whole thing where you weren't even talking?"
You pressed both hands over your face, wishing, fervently, for the basement floor to simply open up and swallow you whole.
"This is not something we're doing right now," you said, voice muffled behind your hands.
"This is extremely something we're doing right now," Dustin said, delighted. "This is the best thing that's happened all week."
"It really wasn't a big deal," Steve said, voice tight, clearly working hard to sound casual and missing the mark entirely.
"Oh, it wasn't a big deal?" You lowered your hands, something sharp cutting through the humiliation now. "Funny."
"I wasn't the one who initiated it."
"You absolutely were."
"I really don't think I was, actually." Steve crossed his arms, something defensive creeping into his voice despite the audience. "If we're doing a full recap, you're the one whoâ"
"Do not finish that sentence in front of a child."
"I'm not a child," Dustin corrected, utterly delighted by the entire exchange, clearly not planning to intervene in any way that might end it sooner.
"It's not relevant either way," you said, ignoring him entirely, glaring at Steve now. "The point is, it happened, it was a mistake, and it is not going to happen again, so can we please move on from this."
"Sure. Fine. Great." Steve's voice had gone clipped, something wounded flickering underneath the forced casualness. "Glad we've got that established. Again. For, what, the third time now?"
"Don't do that."
"Do what?"
"That thing where you make it sound like I'm the one who keeps changing my mind, when you're literally the one whoâ" You stopped yourself, aware, suddenly, of six pairs of wide, fascinated eyes tracking the exchange like it was the season finale of a soap opera. "You know what, this is exactly why we shouldn't discuss this here."
"You're the one who brought up the recap."
"I did not bring up a recap, Eddie brought up the entire topicâ"
"In my defense," Eddie said, holding up both hands, "I really did think this was established information."
"It wasn't," you and Steve said, simultaneously, in the exact same clipped, irritated tone, and the perfect, unintentional unison of it seemed to delight the kids even further, Max actually clapping once, gleefully, at the timing.
"Okay, you guys are, like, actually perfect for each other," Max said, grinning. "In a completely unhinged way, but still."
"We are not discussing this anymore," you said, voice final, dropping back down onto your spot on the floor and crossing your arms hard, refusing to look at Steve, at Eddie, at any of them.
"Agreed," Steve said, equally clipped, sinking back into the armchair with the exact same posture, and the two of you sat there in matching, furious silence while the rest of the group exchanged delighted, disbelieving glances, clearly having no intention of letting either of you forget this particular evening anytime soon.
It took Dustin exactly four minutes to ruin the silence entirely.
"Okay, but hear me out," he said, twisting around again, notebook already appearing from somewhere in his backpack like he'd been planning this the entire movie. "I think we should start a pool."
"A pool," Lucas repeated, already grinning, clearly onboard before he even knew the details.
"A pool for what?" Max asked, though her tone suggested she already had a fairly good guess.
"For whether they actually get back together." Dustin gestured between you and Steve with his pen, entirely too pleased with himself. "I'm thinking a dollar buy-in, winner takes the pot, based on whoever guesses closest to the actual date it happens. If it happens. Which, based on tonight's evidence, feels statistically likely."
"Absolutely not," you said, at the exact same moment Steve said, "We are not doing that."
"You don't get a vote, you're the subject of the pool, that would be a massive conflict of interest." Dustin was already writing, entirely undeterred. "Okay, I'm putting myself down for three weeks. Optimistic, but I believe in you guys."
"I'll take six weeks," Lucas said immediately, grinning.
"Two weeks," Max said. "Based on tonight's chemistry alone."
"This is insane," you said, though nobody was listening to you at all, the whole group now leaning in eagerly to add their own predictions to Dustin's growing list.
"I'm staying out of this one," Robin said, though she was clearly fighting a laugh, glancing sideways at Nancy. "Purely professional distance."
"I'll take never," Nancy offered, deadpan, and the whole group groaned in unison.
"That's not a real bet, Nancy, that's just being difficult."
"It's a completely valid prediction based on observed historical patterns."
"Okay, we're not actually doing this," Steve said, voice tight, though the protest carried considerably less conviction than it had a minute ago, some old, tired resignation creeping into his expression as Dustin continued scribbling names and numbers into his notebook with cheerful, unstoppable enthusiasm.
"Too late, it's already happening," Dustin said. "Steve, you want in on your own pool? Ironic bet."
"No, Dustin, I do not want in on my own pool."
"Suit yourself. More money for the rest of us." Dustin closed the notebook with a satisfied flourish, still scribbling one more name into the margin. "Okay, last call, anybody else? Steve, you sure you don't want to bet on yourself? Feels like a safe investment."
"I said no." Something in Steve's voice had shifted, gone harder and flatter than the tired, resigned tone from a moment ago. "Because it's not gonna happen. There's no pool to bet on. This whole thing is stupid."
The room quieted slightly, the easy, chaotic energy faltering at the sudden edge in his voice.
"Whoa, okay." Dustin blinked, clearly not expecting the shift. "It was just a joke, man."
"Yeah, well, it's not funny." Steve's jaw was tight, something raw and defensive burning behind his eyes now. "You're all sitting here taking bets like this is some kind of inevitable happy ending, and it's not. It's not gonna happen. I would never get back together with her. Not after everything. So maybe collect your dollar bills for something else."
The words landed hard, and you felt them like a physical blow, humiliation and hurt crashing in fast where amusement had been sitting only seconds before. The room had gone properly silent now, everyone's earlier delight curdling into something far more uncomfortable, Dustin's pen frozen mid-scribble, Max's grin fading entirely.
"Okay," you said, voice tight, standing up fast, chest already aching with the specific, humiliating sting of hearing that said out loud, in front of everyone, after everything. "Great. Good to know exactly where I stand. Thanks for clarifying that so clearly."
"Y/N, that's notâ" Steve's voice cracked, some of the anger already draining out of it, replaced by immediate, visible regret. "I didn't mean it like that."
"You said it pretty clearly, actually." Your voice shook, though you kept it low, aware of every single set of eyes on you now.
"I just meant the pool was stupid, I wasn't trying toâ"
"I don't really care what you meant." You grabbed your jacket off the back of the couch, hands unsteady. "Parker, I'm gonna wait in the car, okay? Take your time."
"Actually," Parker said, small and hesitant, glancing between you and the rest of the room like he wasn't sure this was the right moment to bring it up. "I was kind of planning to sleep over tonight. Mom and Dad are out of town, remember? Mike already said it was fine."
You blinked at him, some of the fury momentarily interrupted by the logistical wrinkle. "Since when?"
"Since, like, this afternoon. I told you about it." Parker shrank slightly under the weight of your expression, clearly sensing this was a worse time than usual to be having this conversation. "I thought you knew."
You hadn't checked your messages all day. You stood there a moment, torn between the fresh, humiliating ache still sitting hot in your chest and the sudden, deflating realization that your dramatic exit line had nowhere left to actually go.
"Fine," you said finally, voice tight. "That's fine. I'll justâ" You gestured vaguely, at nothing, at everything, humiliation compounding on itself now that your grand departure had been rendered slightly ridiculous. "I'll head home, then. Have a good time."
You didn't wait for a response, pushing past the stunned, silent group and up the stairs, humiliation and hurt burning hot behind your eyes the entire way, and behind you, the basement stayed dead quiet, nobody quite knowing what to say into the wreckage Steve's words had just left behind.
Steve sat there a long moment after the front door clicked shut somewhere above them, staring at nothing, the weight of what he'd just done settling in slow and undeniable.
"That was really messed up, man," Dustin said finally, quiet, none of his earlier gleeful energy left in his voice at all.
"Yeah. I know." Steve rubbed a hand over the back of his neck, tired more than anything else. "That wasn't a great moment."
"Why would you say that in front of everyone?" Max asked, genuinely confused, none of the earlier delight remaining.
"Wanted the pool talk to stop. It just came out wrong." Steve shrugged, some flat, worn-down honesty in the admission, though nothing about it sounded particularly dramatic. "Not my finest work."
Robin sat down heavily beside him, arms crossed. "You should probably fix that at some point."
"Yeah. I know." He stood up, grabbing his jacket off the back of the couch. "I'll figure it out."
"For what it's worth," Eddie said, from the armchair, still nursing whatever was left in his cup, "you two are honestly perfect for each other. In, like, the most chaotic, exhausting, doomed-romance way possible. This is basically a soap opera at this point. I'm genuinely invested."
"Thanks, Eddie. Very helpful."
"I'm just saying, most couples don't generate this much content." Eddie gestured vaguely with his cup. "You should be flattered, honestly. Not everybody's love life supports an entire betting pool."
"I'm going home," Steve said, though something in his voice had eased slightly, some of the tension from a moment ago loosening at the sheer, familiar absurdity of Eddie's commentary. "I'll deal with it tomorrow."
"Drive safe," Nancy said.
He climbed the stairs, and behind him, the basement settled back into something resembling normal within a few minutes, Dustin already flipping the movie back on, the earlier tension fading into the background the way things tended to with a room full of teenagers, though Parker stayed quiet a while longer than the rest of them, watching the stairs Steve had just disappeared up with a small, troubled frown.
Steve drove for a while without any real destination in mind, jaw tight, hands gripping the wheel harder than the empty roads actually required, replaying the whole disastrous night on a furious, unrelenting loop.
He was angry at himself, mostly, though the anger kept finding other places to land too at Dustin's stupid pool, at Eddie's careless slip, at the whole absurd, humiliating spectacle the entire evening had turned into. He drove past his own street twice without turning, some restless, unresolved energy refusing to let him just go home and lie awake staring at his ceiling the way he usually did after nights like this.
âI would never get back together with her.â The words kept looping back, uglier every time, and he thought about your face when you'd said it back to him â flat, wounded, the specific kind of hurt that came from having something true and something cruel land in the exact same sentence.
He thought about Parker mentioning, almost as an afterthought, that their parents were out of town.
That meant you'd gone home to an empty house. Alone. After everything.
"Fuck it," he said out loud, to nobody, and turned the car around.
He told himself, driving toward your street, that this was a terrible idea, that showing up unannounced after everything he'd just said was probably going to make things worse, not better, that Robin would absolutely have opinions about this if she knew what he was doing right now. He told himself all of that, and kept driving anyway, some old, stubborn certainty pushing him past every single reasonable objection his own brain kept raising.
Your porch light was on when he pulled into the driveway, the rest of the house dark and quiet behind it, and Steve sat there a moment, engine off, staring at the front door, trying to figure out what he was even going to say once he actually knocked on it.
He didn't have an answer. He got out of the car anyway.
He didn't go to the front door. Some old, half-forgotten instinct carried him instead toward the side of the house, toward the trellis he hadn't climbed in over two years, and he found himself scaling it with considerably less grace than he remembered managing back in high school, muttering under his breath the entire way up about being too old for this kind of thing.
Your window was cracked open slightly, and through the gap he could hear you before he could see you, your voice sharp and furious, muttering to yourself as something thudded against a dresser drawer.
"ânever get back together with her, sure, great, very clear, very helpful," you were saying, dragging what sounded like an entire box out from your closet with far more force than the task required. "Don't know why I'm even surprised, honestly, should've expected exactly that, should've known better than to think for one single second thatâ"
Steve pushed the window the rest of the way open and climbed through, landing less smoothly than he'd have liked on your bedroom floor, and you spun around so fast you nearly dropped the box in your hands entirely.
"What the hell are you doing?" Your voice cracked up loud, equal parts shock and fury, the box now clutched defensively against your chest like a shield. "You can't just climb through my window!"
"I used to do it all the time."
"That was two years ago! You don't get to just show up and climb through my window because you feel like it!" You set the box down hard on your bed, chest heaving, still visibly furious, though something underneath the anger flickered surprise, maybe, or something closer to disbelief that he'd actually come at all.
Steve stood there awkwardly in the middle of your room, hands shoved into his jacket pockets, suddenly unsure what to do with himself now that he'd actually made it inside. "I couldn't just go home after what I said. I needed to fix it."
"You needed to fix it." Your laugh came out short, disbelieving, and you turned back to your closet, yanking out another handful of clothes and shoving them haphazardly into the open box on your bed with sharp, angry movements. "Great. Wonderful. You know what would've fixed it, Steve? Not saying it in the first place."
"I know."
"In front of everyone." You kept moving, restless and furious, unable to stay still, pulling books off your shelf now and stacking them with more force than necessary. "In front of Parker, in front of the entire group, like it was nothing, like humiliating me publicly was just a normal, casual thing to do on a Tuesday."
"I know," he said again, quieter this time, watching you move around the room with a kind of helpless, guilty focus. "I'm sorry."
"And then Eddie starts a whole conversation about it, in front of Dustin, in front of Max, like it's just casual gossip, and everyone's laughing, and then Dustin starts an actual betting pool, an actual pool, Steve, like my entire love life is some kind of spectator sport, and I just sat there letting it happen because what else was I supposed to doâ" You kept moving, yanking a sweater off a hanger with unnecessary force, voice climbing higher with every sentence. "And then you, on top of everything, decide the appropriate response is to announce, out loud, to an entire room, that you'd never get back together with me, like that's somehow a normal, reasonable thing to say in the middle of a joke about a betting poolâ"
Steve leaned back against your desk, arms crossed loosely, and something in his expression shifted as he watched you pace, some of the guilt easing into a softer, more helpless kind of fondness despite the chaos currently unfolding in front of him.
"You're really cute when you're mad, you know that?"
You stopped dead, spinning to face him, disbelief written plainly across your face. "Excuse me?"
"I'm serious." He shrugged, entirely unbothered by the murderous look you were now giving him. "You get this whole thing going, the pacing, the throwing clothes around, the very specific, very detailed recap of everything that happened. It's kind of impressive, honestly."
"Are you actually complimenting my anger right now? While I'm still in the middle of being angry at you?"
"I'm just making an observation."
"Well, don't." Your voice climbed even louder, some fresh, indignant fury flaring up at the sheer audacity of it. "You do not get to stand there looking pleased with yourself and call me cute in the middle of me listing every single humiliating thing that happened tonight because of you! That is not how this works!"
"Noted." Though he didn't look remotely chastened, some small, stubborn smile still tugging at the corner of his mouth, watching you with an expression that made you want to throw something directly at his head.
"I hate that you do that." You threw the sweater onto the growing pile on your bed, chest heaving. "I hate that you can just stand there, completely calm, making comments about how cute I am, while I'm genuinely trying to have a real conversation about how badly you hurt my feelings tonight."
"I hear you. I do." Steve straightened up slightly, some of the teasing fading, though the softness in his expression stayed. "I just also think it's true. Both things can be true at once. You can be furious at me, and also be the most beautiful furious person I've ever seen in my entire life."
"Oh my God." You pressed both hands over your face, torn somewhere between wanting to scream and wanting to laugh, the whole absurd, exhausting night finally catching up with you all at once. "You are impossible."
"Yeah," Steve agreed, quiet, watching you with something warm and unguarded in his eyes despite everything. "I know."
"Stop that." You dropped your hands from your face, pointing at him accusingly, though the effect was somewhat undercut by the way your voice had gone slightly less furious and more exasperated. "Stop doing the thing where you say something sweet and it distracts me from being mad at you. I'm trying to stay focused here."
"I'm not trying to distract you.â
"You are absolutely trying to distract me." You crossed your arms, though you'd stopped moving around the room entirely now, some of the frantic energy draining out of your posture despite yourself. "Every time I get going, you say something like that, and it works, and it's infuriating, because I want to stay mad at you, I have every right to stay mad at you, and you keep making it harder."
"Okay. Sorry." Steve held up both hands, though the small, stubborn smile hadn't fully disappeared. "I really am sorry, by the way. For tonight. For all of it. That wasn't fair to you, any of it, and you deserved better than getting humiliated in front of a room full of people who love you."
"Thank you." You said it stiffly, still trying to hold onto the last threads of your fury. "That's a real apology. Good job. Keep doing that instead of the other thing."
"I will." He paused, studying you for a moment, something soft crossing his face again. "You do look really pretty tonight, though. I don't think I said that earlier."
"Steve."
"What? That's not even a distraction thing, that's just a fact. I noticed it the second i walked into Mike's basement." He shrugged, entirely unrepentant. "I'm allowed to notice facts while also being sorry."
"You are actively doing the thing again." Your voice climbed, though it came out closer to a laugh now than genuine anger, some helpless, exhausted amusement finally breaking through despite your best efforts to hold onto the fury. "I specifically told you to stop doing the thing, and you're doing it immediately, on purpose, while apologizing in the same breath."
"I contain multitudes."
"That's Eddie's line."
"I'm borrowing it. It felt relevant." Steve pushed off the desk, taking a slow, careful step closer, watching your face for any sign he should stop. "For what it's worth, I really am trying to actually fix this. Not just distract you out of being mad. I know I keep doing both at the same time, and I know that's probably not helping my case."
"It's really not." Though you didn't step back, some old, familiar pull keeping your feet rooted exactly where they were, the anger from a few minutes ago tangled now with something far more complicated and far less easy to hold onto.
He took another step closer, close enough now that you had to tilt your head up to hold his gaze, and something dark and familiar flickered behind his eyes.
"Take it out on me," he said, low, voice rough. "If you're still mad. I'd rather you actually let it out than stand there swallowing it because I keep interrupting with compliments."
"Go away," you said, though it came out weaker than you meant it to, some traitorous part of your voice already betraying you.
"Say it again." His voice dropped lower, closer now, close enough that you felt the words more than heard them. "Like you actually mean it this time."
You opened your mouth, some old, stubborn defiance rising up automatically, and found the words wouldn't come, your resolve cracking under the weight of his gaze, the proximity, the whole exhausting, familiar pull of him standing there waiting for you to either push him away or not.
"I can't," you admitted finally, voice barely above a whisper, some of the fight draining out of you all at once. "I don't actually want you to go. That's the whole problem."
Something in his expression shifted at that, relief and want tangled together, and he reached up slowly, giving you every chance to stop him, tucking a strand of hair back behind your ear with a gentleness that felt almost unbearable after everything.
"I know," he said quietly. "That's my whole problem too."
"We're so bad for each other." Your voice came out soft, almost a laugh, though there was nothing funny about the ache sitting underneath it. "Everyone keeps telling me that. Lucy, Robin, my own brain at three in the morning. And they're right, they're completely right, and I still don't want you to climb back out that window."
"Maybe we are bad for each other." Steve's hand stayed cradling your jaw, thumb tracing slow along your cheekbone. "Or maybe we're just two people who've never actually been taught how to do this right, and we're figuring it out badly, over and over, because nobody ever showed either of us a better way."
"That's a very generous interpretation."
"I'm trying it out. See if it sticks." A small, tired smile pulled at the corner of his mouth. "Either way. Bad for each other, or just bad at this. I don't really care which one it is right now."
"That's not a good enough reason to do this again."
"No," he agreed, quiet, his forehead dropping to rest against yours. "It's probably not."
Neither of you moved. The space between you had gone thin and charged, every rational argument you'd been holding onto for the past hour dissolving slowly under the weight of his hand still cupped gentle against your face, and when he finally closed the last inch of distance between you, it wasn't fast or desperate the way it had been in the car just slow, and certain, and achingly soft, like he had all the time in the world to prove something he didn't need words for anymore.
You kissed him back the same way, unhurried, some old, exhausted resignation settling into the shape of it, both of you fully aware, even as it happened, that you were doing the exact thing you'd both just agreed was probably a mistake, and choosing, anyway, in this one quiet, unguarded moment, to let it happen regardless.
You pulled back first, breathless, both hands still resting against his chest, and stared up at him with something raw and searching in your expression.
"Why are we like this?"
Steve blinked, caught off guard by the sudden shift. "What do you mean?"
"I mean this." You gestured vaguely between the two of you, voice cracking slightly. "This exact thing. You say something cruel, and then something tender, and then we fight, and then we end up right back here anyway, every single time, like we're incapable of doing anything differently no matter how many times we swear we're gonna try. Why do we keep doing this?"
Steve didn't answer right away, something helpless and lost crossing his face, and the silence stretched out long enough that you weren't sure he was going to answer at all.
"I don't know," he said finally, quiet, and it wasn't a comfort, wasn't the start of anything resolved â just an honest, exhausted admission that hung there in the space between you, unresolved, the question still sitting heavy and unanswered in the quiet of your bedroom.
You stepped back, putting real distance between you for the first time since he'd climbed through the window, and neither of you said anything else at all.
"Don't go yet." Steve's voice came out low, rough, before you'd even fully processed moving toward the door. "I know I don't have an answer. I know I can't fix it tonight, or probably for a while, maybe not ever. I'm not asking you to believe it's gonna be different. I just don't want to be alone right now, and I don't think you do either."
You stood there, chest still heaving, some old, exhausted ache settling deep in your bones at the sheer, unguarded honesty of it no promises, no easy resolution, just a plain, simple admission of wanting to not be alone.
"That's not the same as fixing anything," you said quietly.
"I know it's not." He didn't move closer, didn't reach for you again, just stood there, hands loose at his sides, letting the choice sit entirely with you. "I'm not pretending it is. I just don't want tonight to end with both of us alone in separate houses, replaying this exact conversation by ourselves. That's all. Nothing more than that."
You didn't have an answer for that. You stood there a long moment, torn between every rational instinct telling you to send him back out the window and something quieter, more tired, that simply didn't want to be alone tonight either.
"Okay," you said finally, voice barely above a whisper, and crossed back toward him, not for another kiss this time, just close enough to rest your forehead against his chest, his arms coming up slowly to circle around you.
"I hate this," you murmured, muffled against his shirt. "I hate that I can't just stay away from you. I know it's hurting me. I know it's hurting both of us. And I still can't do it."
"I hate it too." His arms tightened around you slightly, voice rough above your head. "I keep telling myself I'm gonna give you actual space, real space, and then I end up climbing through your window at midnight anyway. I don't know how to stop wanting to be near you even when I know it's not good for either of us."
"Maybe that's the whole problem." You closed your eyes, exhaustion settling deep into your bones. "Maybe we're just gonna keep doing this to each other until one of us actually finds a way to stop."
"Maybe." Steve's voice was quiet, honest, no reassurance offered, no promise that things would be different. "I don't have an answer for that either. I just know I couldn't stay away tonight, and some part of me isn't even sorry about it, even though I probably should be."
He was quiet for a moment, his chin resting against the top of your head, and when he spoke again his voice had gone rougher, more exposed than anything else he'd said all night.
"I hate that I still love you," he said, barely above a whisper. "I've tried not to. I've tried so hard not to, for months now, and it hasn't worked once."
You went very still against him, the words landing heavy and quiet in your chest, and didn't say anything back.
The silence stretched out, and Steve didn't push it, didn't ask, just held you a little tighter instead, some old, familiar ache settling into the space where your answer should have been.
"You're my undoing, you know that?" he said quietly, into your hair. "Have been for years. And I've thought about it, more times than I probably should, whether it would just be easier to let you go completely. Stop doing this to both of us. But I'd rather have you like this â messy, unresolved, hurting both of us half the time â than not have you at all."
"That's not a healthy thing to say to somebody," you murmured, though there was no real fight left in the words.
"I know it's not." His voice stayed rough, low. "You ruined easy for me a long time ago. I don't really know how to talk about you with any actual sense left."
You didn't answer that either, some tight, aching knot forming in your throat at the sheer, devastating honesty of it, and after a long moment, Steve finally loosened his arms, stepping back slightly, something resigned settling over his expression.
"I should go," he said quietly. "It's late. And I don't think either of us actually knows what to do with any of this tonight."
He turned toward the window, one hand already reaching for the sill, and you stood there watching him go, some old, exhausted ache rising up fast in your chest at the sight of his back to you.
"Stay."
The word came out small, barely more than a breath, and Steve turned back around slowly, and it was only then, in the quiet, unguarded stillness of you standing there alone in the middle of your room, that he really saw you arms wrapped tight around yourself, shoulders curled slightly inward, something small and defeated in the whole shape of you that hadn't been there a moment ago, like the effort of watching him leave had cost you more than either of you had accounted for.
"Okay," he said, quiet, and didn't move toward the window again.
"I'm gonna regret this in the morning," you said, voice thick, wrapping your arms tighter around yourself. "I already know I am. I'll wake up and think about everything we just said, and everything that's still not fixed, and I'm gonna hate myself a little for asking you to stay."
"Probably," Steve admitted, not arguing with you, not trying to talk you out of the feeling. "I might regret it too, honestly. Doesn't change what I want right now."
"I just don't want to be alone tonight." Your voice cracked slightly, some of the exhaustion of the entire evening finally catching up all at once. "That's the whole reason. Not because it fixes anything. Just because I don't think I can be by myself in this house right now."
"That's a good enough reason." He crossed the room slowly, closing the distance between you again, careful and unhurried. "You don't have to justify it beyond that."
You let him pull you back into his arms, resting your head against his chest, and closed your eyes.
"Can we just pretend, for tonight?" you murmured, voice muffled against his shirt. "Just for a few hours. Pretend none of it happened âthe party, the fight in the yard, tonight. Pretend we're just happy. I don't want to think about any of it right now. I just want one night where we're not doing this to each other."
Steve went very still above you, and when he finally spoke, his voice had gone thick, unsteady in a way you hadn't heard from him all night.
"Yeah," he said, rough, and you felt him press a kiss to the top of your head, felt the faint, telltale catch in his breath that gave him away before he could hide it. "Yeah, we can do that."
You pulled back slightly, glancing up at him, and found his eyes shining, one hand coming up fast to wipe roughly at his face before you could fully register what you were seeing.
"Are you crying?"
"No." His voice cracked slightly on the denial, betraying him completely, and he let out a short, watery laugh at how obviously unconvincing it was. "Maybe. A little. I don't know. It's just that sounds really nice, actually. Pretending. I don't think I realized how much I wanted that until you said it out loud."
You reached up, brushing your thumb gently beneath his eye, and he let you, some old, aching tenderness passing quietly between you that had nothing left to do with anger, or blame, or anything except two exhausted people wanting, for one night, to simply not hurt.
"Okay," you whispered. "Let's pretend."
"Do you want to lay down?" you asked, quiet, gesturing toward your bed still half-covered in the scattered clothes and books from your earlier, furious cleaning spree.
"Yeah." His voice was still thick, eyes still bright, though he managed a small, watery smile. "Yeah, I'd like that."
You turned away instinctively, reaching for the hem of your shirt out of old habit, and Steve's voice stopped you before you'd gotten very far.
"You don't have to hide from me," he said, quiet, no weight or expectation behind it, just simple honesty.
You hesitated a moment, then let the old habit go, pulling your shirt off in front of him without turning away, left standing there in just your bra and underwear while you crossed toward your dresser for something more comfortable to sleep in. Steve didn't say anything, though you felt his eyes on you the entire way, something reverent and quietly amazed in his gaze, like he was committing the sight of you to memory all over again every detail achingly familiar and somehow, after everything, still capable of stealing the breath clean out of his chest.
You pulled an old, soft T-shirt from the bottom drawer without really looking at it, tugging it over your head, and it was only once you'd turned back around that you registered, distantly, the faded logo across the front and the specific, worn-in softness of the fabric his shirt, one he must have left behind at some point months ago, folded away and forgotten in the bottom of your drawer without you ever quite deciding to get rid of it.
You didn't say anything about it. Neither did he, though something flickered across his face when he noticed too, some quiet, aching tenderness he didn't try to hide.
He reached for the hem of his own shirt then, pulling it off in one smooth motion, and you found yourself watching despite everything, some old, familiar warmth curling low in your chest at the sight of him âthe same broad shoulders, the same faint scar along one side you remembered tracing once, years ago, in a very different kind of quiet. You realized, watching him fold the shirt absently over the back of your desk chair, that you hadn't actually seen him like this in a very long time, not since long before any of the lying, the fighting, the year of wreckage that had piled up between you since. Something in your chest ached at the realization, sharp and unexpected, the sheer, ordinary intimacy of it landing harder than anything more dramatic could have.
Steve caught you looking, and neither of you looked away right away, some quiet, unspoken understanding passing between you before he finally crossed toward the bed, pulling back the blanket and waiting for you to join him.
You climbed in beside him, both of you stiff and awkward at first, careful not to touch, lying there on your backs staring up at the ceiling with several inches of space still sitting stubbornly between you, neither of you quite sure how to bridge the strange, careful distance despite everything that had already happened that night.
It was you who moved first, shifting slightly closer, and Steve met you halfway, his arm sliding beneath you, pulling you in against his chest until you were properly tangled together, your head resting over the steady, familiar rhythm of his heartbeat, his other arm wrapping loosely around your back like he was afraid you might disappear if he didn't hold on tightly enough.
You felt it before you heard it a slight, telltale shudder in his chest, his breath catching unevenly above you and when you tilted your head up to look at him, you found tears slipping silently down his face, quiet and unguarded in a way that undid something in your own chest completely.
"Steveâ"
"I hate that I can't have you," he said, voice breaking apart on the words, thick and raw. "Not really. Not the actual way I want to. I get thisâ" his arms tightened around you slightly, "âthese stolen, temporary nights where we pretend everything's fine, and then morning comes and it all falls apart again, and I don't know how to stop wanting the real thing even though I know, every single time, that it's not what I'm actually gonna get."
You didn't have an answer for that, some matching ache rising up in your own throat, and you reached up instead, brushing the tears gently from his cheek the way he'd let you do earlier, saying nothing, because there was nothing left to say that either of you hadn't already said tonight.
He pressed a soft, lingering kiss to the top of your head, and you settled back against his chest, listening to his heartbeat slowly even out beneath your ear, both of you lying there in the dark, holding onto something neither of you could name or fix, choosing, for just this one night, to hold onto it anyway.
content warnings: angst with fluff, bittersweet ending, no y/n, use of nicknames (bunny, baby, darling), unwanted touch of another man, accusations of cheating, fighting, gator is a mean, insecure and jealous bitch, oral (f and m receiving), nipple play, p in v sex, creampie, switch!gator and reader, love confessions, gator becomes soft.
ethel cain â mondays
When you and Gator decided to go to the club together, you didn't think it'd end up with him throwing a tantrumâembarrassing you in front of everyone and making you feel like shit.
"Y'all were flirtin' in front of my face!" he raised his voice as you argued in your car, your face scrunching in disbelief at his words.
"Are you hearing yourself? I was not flirting with him!"
And you really weren't.
Earlier, at the club, Gator went to the bathroom and left you alone for a while, so you decided to wait by the bar and order a cup of water. When you drank, exhausted from all the dancing, you heard someone shouting your nameâit was your old colleague from uni, Jack.
He came up to you, giving you an awkward hug, but you smiled at him nonetheless, keeping a light conversation about what you've been up to these past years.
It was brief, not really going into detailâjust two people who used to know each other catching up.
But then he asked for your number, his hand sneaking up around your waist. You smiled uncomfortably, though still polite, because fuck...you really didn't want to cause a scene in case he tried to do something.
"Sorry, I have a boyfriend." you said, slowly freeing yourself from his grip. "But it was real nice seeing you."
It's like he didn't hear you at all, because his other hand landed on you too, his face inching closer as he said "I always liked you, you know? Such a pretty face."
But before you could do anything, his body was ripped apart from yours, almost falling over in the process.
"Get the fuck away from my girl."
Gator's voice was cold, but so powerful at the same time. You could swear the veins in his neck looked like they might pop any time, his hand latching onto the collar of Jack's shirt.
"Didn't know she was taken, dude." he said, lying like a bitch.
Gator's eyes found yours, his cheeks reddening with anger. "You didn't tell him?"
Was he really that dumb?
"Of course I told him!" you screamed, hands forming into fists. "He just didn't want to listen."
Jack was able to free himself, slowly stepping away from both of you, but not before he looked at you and said:
"It was nice seeing you again."
Oh, that made Gator furious.
He caught up to Jack in seconds, punching him two, maybe three times before some people forcefully took Gator away from him.
Jack's nose was bleeding, some of it spilling onto his shirt. He looked at you one more time and fucking smiled, before turning away and disappearing into the crowd of people that formed around you.
"You fuckin' serious? Flirtin' with that jackass when I was gone for five fuckin' minutes?"
Jackass. How fitting.
"I wasn't! He threw himself all over me!"
But he wasn't listening, spewing some bullshit accusations with anger.
"Gator, please." you stepped closer, catching his hand. "Not here."
He shook his hand away from yours, turning around and heading to the door.
When you caught up to him, he was leaning against your car, smoking a cigarette.
"You promised you wouldn't do that anymore." you said, standing before him.
"I can smoke if I want to."
You scoffed, pulling the cigarette from his mouth and taking a puff. "I'm not talking 'bout smoking."
He raised his brows, trying to get his cigarette back, but you threw in on the ground, your boot stomping on it as you looked at him.
"You promised you wouldn't cause more scenes. Wouldn't throw tantrums over the wrong things."
"And how the fuck was this wrong of me, huh?"
"Are you serious? He practically assaulted me and you took his side!" you screamed, stepping away and unlocking the car, slipping into the driver seat and taking a long, calming breath.
You turned on the engine when the passenger door opened, Gator flopping into the seat with a thud.
"I'm not talking to you right now." you said, overwhelmed with all that's happened.
It was one thing to get assaulted, and another to have your boyfriend, someone who was supposed to trust you, believe that you just let it happen.
"Great. Didn't want to anyway."
And that's how you got here, arguing while you drove through the highway.
"How long since ya been seein that guy?"
"Oh my god, what are you even talking about?"
He took his cap off, throwing it with unnecessary force. "That guy said "again", so obviously y'all know each other."
You exhaled, exhausted with his baseless accusations.
"We know each other from uni, used to have classes together. That's why he came up to me, tried to get my number."
"And?" Gator said, his tone filled with annoyance.
"And, I fucking told him that I have a boyfriend."
"Yeah, that's why your faces were inches away. Stop lyin' to me." he rolled his eyes, turning away from you and looking out the window. "Should've known it'd be like this."
"What the fuck is that supposed to mean?"
Annoyed, he ran a hand through his hair, messing up the usual, neat slicked-back style.
"You think I'm not good enough for ya, yeah? Have to get with another man."
He was actually insane. You couldn't believe that he would stoop so low, accusing you of cheating when you've always been loyal, staying by his side throughout all these monthsâthe good and the bad.
"You're such a bitch, Gator."
You gripped the steering wheel harder, rage flooding through your whole body.
It shouldn't even be surprising, you two fought a whole lot. At this point it was your routineâmeet up, have a good time for a while, then argue about something meaningless.
Then fuck, but we don't have to get into that.
But this was too much. It wasn't meaningless anymoreâit was about your safety, your loyalty and respect that he had for you.
Or rather didn't.
"Real big of ya, callin' me fuckin' names."
"You're making shit up and then getting mad at it! I'm so over your attitude." you countered, speeding up and passing some other car on the usually empty highway.
"Then don't give me reasons to." he said, crossing his arms and looking at you accusingly.
That was enough, you had enough.
You slowed down, pulling to the side of the road.
"Get the fuck out."
It was quiet, like he didn't fully understand what you were saying.
"What?"
You closed your eyes, tears threatening to spill from them.
But your voice didn't waver when you ordered again.
"Get out of my car. I don't even want to be near you."
You heard him exhale, and then there it wasâa light touch of his fingers to your forearm.
"Bunnyâ" he started, but you didn't let him finish.
"Get. the. fuck. out."
Every word was delivered slowly, putting as much coldness into them as you could.
Gator had to feel that, because seconds later he was outside, closing the door after him with force.
And when you finally opened your eyes and looked at him through the window, he was looking right back at you, his expression so incredibly painful, almost like he wanted to cry.
But you didn't let that get to you, not this time.
So you drove away, leaving him in the middle of the highway, his "stark county sheriff" cap laying forgotten in the backseat.
Gatorđ: call me back
Gatorđ: let's talk about this
Gatorđ: you can't ignore me forever
These kind of texts were waiting for you every time you picked up your phone.
He was really adamant on winning you backâdidn't stop for two whole days.
On day one he came up to your house, telling you to come talk to him, but you only stood there, listening to his ramblings trough the door. You didn't open it for him.
The second day, he sent you flowers. Sure, they were pretty, and you put them on display on your kitchen counter, but the note attached to them ended up in the trash.
"Forgive me, bunny"
It wasn't that easy.
His words and accusations hurt you so bad, you ended up crying for the rest of the night that you left him. You woke up the next day, eyes swollen and red, missing sixteen of his calls and twenty unread texts. All of them a variation of the same things.
And then came day three, the one where you actually answered his call.
"What do you want?" you said coldly, trying not to cry again.
"Just wanna talk. Make things right." he answered, though he didn't try to hide the worry in his tone.
"Yeah, should've thought about that before you accused me of cheating."
"Bunny, come onâ" he exhaled, and you could practically see him pacing around while talking. "I talked to the guy."
It was like your whole body froze, and then immediately started to boil in anger.
"What the fuck do you mean?"
"Ran into him the other day, his nose was fuckin' broken, can ya believe that? Didn't know I hit that hard." he laughed, though with no humor behind it.
"Gator. The point."
"'Ight, well..." he replied, stopping for a second before spilling it all out. "He was scared shitless, thought I'd beat his ass again, so I ordered him to tell me the truth or I actually would. So now I know you told him 'bout havin' a boyfriend, and didn't want to give him your number."
You could feel a tear coming down your cheek, your hands shaking with frustration.
"So you only believed it when it came from him. Not your girlfriend, not the one you should actually trust."
"Bunny, I'm real sorry, I didn't mean to blow up like that."
Funny, the word "sorry" was something you didn't expect to hear from Gator. He usually avoided it like fire.
"Yeah, 'course you didn't." you said, tears running freely now.
"I'm coming over. Be there in ten."
And just like that, he ended the call, deciding for the both of you like always.
You sat there on your couch, crying until you heard the doorbellâGator actually keeping his word, how surprising.
You opened for him on weak legs, tired from all the pain he put you through.
But when you saw his face...he looked almost worse than you.
Bags under his eyes, hair loose and messy, lacking the usual shininess from the gel he used. He wore his casual clothes, plain jeans and a white t-shirt.
"Baby..." he muttered, looking at you with softness that you didn't really expect from him.
How full of surprises he was today.
"Great, now that you're here you can take your shit and go. Think your shampoo is still in my shower."
You didn't have to add that you used it yesterday, just to remember his scent.
"Not 'till you listen to me." he said, walking through the door and closing it behind him, heading towards your couch.
"What the fuck do you think you're doing?" you asked with annoyance.
"Just sit next to me, will ya?"
You sighed, too tired to argue with him even more. With careful steps, you headed towards the couch and sat on the opposite side of where he was, keeping a safe distance.
He had a way of winning you back with his...touch. You had to be careful.
"I was jealous. So fuckin' much that I wasn't thinkin' straight. My head just...convinced me I wasn't enough for ya. I mean, I know I'm not...I'm a fucking asshole, sayin' shit I don't mean when something hurts."
"Why did you think I was lying?" you asked, your voice sad but steady, not giving away to his words yet.
"'Cause I'm fuckin'...insecure or some shit. Hard to believe you're actually still with me."
"Gator..."
"No, really. But it's like...just tell me ya don't want me, don't flirt with other people."
"I wasn't."
"No, no I know that. I was jus' too caught up in my jealousy, thought ya didn't want me anymore."
"And you think I'd rather cheat on you than tell you that? If I did feel that way."
His cheeks went red, embarrassment creeping up on him. His explanation didn't made that much sense to you, but you also didn't get how he could be insecure.
"I'm such a fucking bitch." he said, his voice cracking slightly. "Bunny, I'm so, so sorry for everything. If you'd just...give me one last chance, swear I'd make this right."
You exhaled, your head spinning from all of the new information he gave you.
"I've been so loyal to you, Gator. Yeah, we fought a lot but I've never...not wanted you. You're the only one on my mind."
The lighting in your living room was weak, but you swore you saw a tear run down his cheek.
Gator Tillman didn't cry, right?
Then why was his voice so weak, when he uttered those three words to you.
"I love you."
Yes, you were in a relationship, but you never exchanged your feelings like that before. Never told him that you felt this way.
You stood up from the couch, your own eyes glazing with tears once again.
"You can't say things like that just because you want me to forgive you. That's fucking cruel."
Gator stood up too, coming closer and catching your hands into his, looking at you with something utterly soft in his eyes.
"Not lyin', bunny. I fuckin' love you so much."
Both of you stood there, crying softly while looking at each other and processing all that was happening.
"You're pretty when you cry." you said, and he laughed weakly, his hands hugging your waist.
"Don't get used to that."
The kiss that you shared after was like something you've never felt before. His taste mixed with salty tears, mouth working against yours like he was scared it would be the last time he got to kiss youâand maybe he was right, because you haven't really decided what's next.
You only knew that hearing him actually spill his feelings out for you, something he rarely did before, hearing him confess and cry for you...It made you want him more than you'd normally would.
"Bedroom, now." you said against his lips, and he actually whimpered, lifting you up and heading there while you still kissed, knocking over some things in the process.
When he lowered you onto the carpeted floor, you took him by the collar, making him look at you.
"On your knees."
"Bunnyâ"
"Now."
Usually, he was the one taking control, but fuck, you just had to put him to use after all that he's done.
You expected him to argue, but he was kneeling before you in seconds, taking off your shorts as you got rid of your shirt, tossing it somewhere on the floor.
Thank goodness you didn't have any underwear on.
"Such a pretty pussy." he murmured, gaze fixed on the already wet flesh.
"Touch me." you ordered, looking down at his face.
He caught your gaze, his finger making contact with your clit, moving it in slow circles.
You exhaled, already feeling your shoulders relax. You focused on his face as he focused on yours, bringing his mouth to your wet pussy.
He started slowly, licking into you like he was tasting you for the first time. Then, he went deeper, tongue between your folds as he moved with precision.
"Fuck..." you moaned, arching your back and pushing yourself forward into his face even more.
"Tastes like fuckin' heaven." he said, the vibration of his voice going through you.
"More, Gator." you whined, looking at him through halfway opened eyes.
He listened, adding one, then two fingers, going in and out of your entrance while still eating you out, his mouth working eagerly.
"Oh fuck." you breathed, your eyes rolling back as you felt your approaching orgasm.
"Come on, darlin'. Give it to me."
You came with a cry, latching onto his hair. You rode his face, prolonging your pleasure as he drank up every single drop of what you gave him, moaning into you with excitement.
When you stepped away from him, you didn't wait long. Your thighs clenched together again as soon as you looked downâhis chin glistening with your juices and his spit, hair messy where you pulled at it, and his cock, so obviously hard, straining against his zipper.
"Take your clothes off." you ordered again, stepping backwards and laying down on the bed while still looking at him.
"Yes ma'am." he said, and you smiled at the serious way in which he addressed you.
Maybe you should take control more...
His clothes were on the floor in seconds, joining the pile of your own.
"Where do you want me?" he asked, slipping out of his underwear.
His cock was painfully hard, leaking from the top down his length.
"Next to me."
And when he was, you sat on your knees between his thighs, fingers curling around his cock.
"Bunny, please..." he breathed, his hips jerking up as soon as you made a little bit of movement.
"You're surprisingly nice to me today." you laughed, slowly working him up and down.
"Iâ need ya so bad. Dreamed of this...fuck...pussy every night." he confessed, moaning softly as you touched him.
"Yeah? Even when I was mad you only thought about my pussy?" you taunted, though you knew that wasn't what he meant.
"Stop playin', ya know what Iâ Oh, fuck." you interrupted him with your mouth closing around his cock.
Your head bobbed on him, up and down, until he was whining and moaning under you like a bitch.
Then, you stopped and laid next to him, laughing at his confusion.
"Such a tease."
"Better show me what you've dreamed of."
Now, it was his turn to lay between your thighs, his mouth finding yours and kissing you. His tongue fought with yours as his fingers closed around your hard nipple, squeezing and playing with it just how he knew you liked.
His kisses went lowerâto your neck, collarbone, where he gently bit the skin there, and finally to your other nipple.
His tongue swirled around it, sucking and biting gently, causing you to moan out his name.
"Yeah? Ya like it?" he asked, smiling against your skin.
"Yes, Gator. Oh, fuckâ" you answered, words becoming a breathless moan when you felt the tip of his cock gently pushing between your folds.
"You want it? Tell me you do."
"Please." you nodded, your glances meeting as he pushed himself deeper.
He kissed you just as he bottomed out, his hips slowly backing out almost all the way and slamming back into you again.
"Never want to get over you." he murmured, the sound of skin slapping against each other starting to fill the room.
"Gator..." you moaned, his cock pushing harder, meeting all the perfect places in you.
"Yeah? Like when I go deep? When I fuck ya like I hate ya?"
And you could only nod, because you knew that he was right. You loved when he slammed into you like this, your whole body buzzing with pleasure.
Without a warning, he moved your body like it weighed nothing, turning it around and positioning you on your elbows and knees, your ass in the air and perfectly on display for him.
He slammed back into you, one hand placed on your hip as the other sneaked to your peaked nipple, squeezing it as he pleased.
"You're fuckin' gorgeous." he breathed, his hips meeting your ass with every thrust. "Made for me."
It was straight up obsceneâthe way you moaned around his cock, pleasure overwhelming your senses. Your back arched as he pushed himself deep into that one special spot, drool pooling in your constantly open mouth, unable to close under all the sensation.
"Gator, I'm..." you tried to warn him, but he only went faster, slamming into your dripping entrance.
"Me too, baby. Come with me."
His words tipped you over, his name spilling from your mouth as he spilled into you, your pussy clenching on his length.
"Fuck...you're so good to me, so right." he babbled as you felt the warmth of his cum going down your thigh.
You stayed like this for a while, calming your ragged breathing, until he took himself out, placing a sweet kiss just above your ass.
He helped you lay on your back, then cleaned the mess between your thighs as you drifted in and out of consciousness, too tired and fucked out to do it yourself.
Finally, with Gator and you under the sheets, you looked at him, and smiled softly.
"I love you too, you know?"
He stilled, eyes widening.
"Say that again."
You laughed, coming up to his mouth and kissing it gently. He kissed back, hand cradling the back of your neck like he didn't want you to stop.
"I love you too." you repeated.
He exhaled against you and then kissed you with more force, a tear spilling from his eye once again.
"Does that mean that I get another chance?" he asked, his eyes glossy and hopeful.
"Gator, Iâ Let's talk about this tomorrow, okay?"
"But you saidâ"
"I know what I said. Me loving you doesn't change the fact that you've hurt me. Many, many times."
"I get that." he said, voice cracking. "And I'm sorry."
You exhaled, gently touching his cheek. "I know you are, Gator. So give me time to think, yeah?"
"Yeah. As long as ya need, bunny."
And he meant it, because when Gator Tillman loved someone? He loved with his whole beingâeven when he was bad at showing it.
Robin had invited you and Steve to go see a bull show where everyone would be in proper cowboy clothing.
So when the day arrived, you put on your best cowgirl looking outfit, brown cowboy boots with bootcut dark wash jeans and a thick buckle belt topped off with a plaid brown shirt.
You walked out of the bathroom feeling as confident as you could be before stopping in your tracks and laying your eyes on Steve.
Dark wash bootcut jeans with a matching jean button-up and a white shirt under, topped off with a brown retro jacket and with the final accessory a cowboy hat that matched his leather boots.
Steve had turned to look at you, taking in your outfit.
his hazel eyes widening just a fraction as they dragged slowly down your body, taking in the way your dark wash jeans hugged your hips, the thick buckle belt cinching your waist, the plaid shirt tucked in just right, and those brown cowboy boots that made your legs look endless. The corner of his mouth twitched upward into that signature cocky Harrington smirk, but there was something warmer underneath it tonight.
âWell, damn,â he drawled in a thick country accent, voice low and a little rougher than usual, like the sight of you had knocked the usual smooth talk right out of him for a second.
He adjusted the brim of his cowboy hat with two fingers, the retro brown jacket pulling across his broad shoulders. The white shirt underneath was unbuttoned at the top, giving you a teasing glimpse of tanned skin and the edge of that infamous chest hair. âLook at you, cowgirl. Trying to kill me before we even get to the bull rodeo?â
He took a step closer, boots thudding softly on the floor, until you could smell the faint mix of his cologne and the leather from his boots. His gaze flicked back up to your face, playful but heated.
âRobinâs gonna lose her mind when she sees us,â he said, chuckling. âBut right now? Iâm having a real hard time remembering why weâre leaving the house at all.â
ânow donât get ahold of yourself, there Harrington, we promised we would go on the double date with robin and vickieâ you say patting steveâs chest before grabbing your leather purse and leaving the bedroom leaving steve alone in the room dumbfounded.
After arriving at the rodeo, the four of you found good seats and settled in to watch the show. The arena lights glowed against the night sky as bull riders took their turns, the crowd cheering wildly with every buck and spin. Robin and Vickie were practically glued to each other, laughing and sharing a giant bucket of popcorn, while you and Steve sat close enough that his thigh pressed against yours.
The energy was electric, dust kicking up under the floodlights, the smell of fried food and leather in the air. Steve kept stealing glances at you the whole time, his arm draped casually behind your shoulders. Every time a rider got thrown, heâd lean in closer, lips brushing your ear.
âStill thinking we shouldâve stayed home?â he murmured during a break, voice low and playful, that cowboy hat tilted just enough to look unfairly good on him.
You all grabbed food from the stands, corn dogs, funnel cake, and cold beers, and found a spot near the fence to eat while the next event started. Robin was midstory about some chaotic customer at work when Steveâs hand found your waist, pulling you gently back against his chest.
âHaving fun, cowgirl?â he asked, his breath warm against your neck. His fingers gave a light squeeze through your plaid shirt, eyes sparkling with that signature Harrington charm. âBecause Iâm having a real hard time focusing when youâre standing here looking like that.â
He gave you a slow, flirty smile, clearly still thinking about that moment back in the bedroom. The rest of the rodeo flew by in a blur of cheering crowds, bucking bulls, and stolen touches. By the time the final event wrapped up and the lights started to dim, the tension between you and Steve had only grown thicker. Robin and Vickie said their goodbyes in the parking lot, both of them grinning knowingly as Steve practically rushed you toward the car.
The drive home was quiet but charged with sexual tension. Steveâs hand stayed firmly on your thigh the whole way, occasionally rubbing his thumb in a circle against your jean covered thigh or drifting higher, his eyes flicking to you every chance he got. You could feel the heat radiating off him.
As soon as the front door clicked shut behind you, Steve was on you.
He pulled you against him hard, mouth crashing into yours in a hungry as he walked you backward toward the bedroom, hands roaming over your hips and ass.
âBeen thinking about this since you walked out in that outfit,â he growled against your lips Once you reached the bedroom, clothes hit the floor in a frantic pile. Steve stripped completely, you took your shirt and bra off quickly but when you bent to take off your brown cowboy boots, he caught your wrist.
âLeave âem on,â he said, voice husky with want.
you quickly peaked his lips â let me take my jeans off first and iâll put them back on baby.â you mumbled before taking your boots off then later your jeans.
You stood there completely naked except for the boots. Steve sat on the edge of the bed, then reached for his cowboy hat. With a small smirk, he placed it on your head, adjusting it just right.
âFuck, thatâs perfect,â he groaned, eyes raking over your bare body. âNow get up here, cowgirl.â
You climbed onto his lap, knees sinking into the mattress on either side of his hips, the boots still on. Steveâs cock was hard and flushed, pressing against your inner thigh. He gripped your waist, guiding you as you lined him up and slowly sank down, taking every inch of him. The stretch was delicious, pulling a deep moan from your throat as he filled you completely.
âShi- shit, so tight,â Steve hissed, head falling back for a moment. His hands slid up your bare torso, cupping your breasts and rolling your nipples between his fingers as you started to move.
You rolled your hips in slow, deep circles at first, savoring the way he dragged against your walls with every motion. The cowboy hat tilted slightly as you rode him, and Steve couldnât stop staring.
his gaze locked on where your bodies joined, then up to your breasts bouncing softly, then to your face under his hat.
âThatâs it, baby⊠ride me just like that,â he encouraged, voice rough. One hand stayed on your hip, guiding your pace, while the other slipped between your legs, rubbing firm circles over your clit with his thumb.
The pleasure built steadily. You picked up speed, bouncing on his cock harder, the sound of skin slapping skin filling the room along with your moans and Steveâs low curses. He thrust up to meet you, hitting that perfect spot inside you every time. Sweat started to slick your skin, your boots planted firmly as leverage while you rode him.
Steve sat up straighter, wrapping one arm around your back and pulling you closer so your breasts pressed against his chest. He kissed you messily, tongues sliding together as you kept grinding down on him, the new angle making you whimper into his mouth.
âYou feel so fucking good,â he panted against your lips. âLook so goddamn hot wearing nothing but my hat and those boots.â
He leaned down to suck one of your nipples into his mouth, tongue flicking over the sensitive bud as you rode him faster. The tension coiled tighter in your belly. Steveâs thumb never stopped working your clit, pushing you closer and closer, making the rope in your lower belly tighten.
When your orgasm finally hit, it crashed over you hard, your walls clenching rhythmically around his cock, thighs shaking in the boots as you cried out his name. Steve groaned loudly, gripping your hips tight and thrusting up into you, guiding you through your orgasm, and chasing his own release. A few more deep, desperate strokes and he came hard, spilling inside you with a broken moan, burying his face in your neck.
You both stayed locked together, breathing heavily. Steve gently lifted the cowboy hat off your head and tossed it aside, then pulled you down with him as he collapsed back onto the pillows.
Steve wrapped his arms around you tightly, one hand stroking soothingly up and down your bare back while the other cradled your head against his chest. He was still buried inside you, softening slowly as you both came down.
âYou okay, sweetheart?â he whispered, pressing soft kisses to your temple, your cheek, and finally your lips. His voice was gentle now, all the heat replaced with warmth. âDid I wear you out too much?â
You shook your head with a tired smile. Steve chuckled softly, carefully helping you lift off him and sitting you on the edge of the bed.
He disappeared for a moment, returning with a warm, damp cloth. He cleaned you up tenderly, when steve was finished, he took the boots off, massaging your feet for a moment before placing soft kisses on each foot then crawling back into bed, tucking you against his side and pulling the covers over both of you,
He kept one arm around you, fingers tracing lazy patterns on your skin. Every few seconds heâd press another kiss to your forehead or the top of your head, his heartbeat steady under your cheek.
âGod, I love you like this,â he murmured, voice sleepy and full of affection. âAll soft and cuddly after you just rode me like a damn cowgirl .â He grinned, squeezing you closer. âWeâre keeping those boots right by the bed from now on. And the hat.â
You laughed quietly, snuggling deeper into his chest. Steve pulled the blanket higher around your shoulders and nuzzled into your hair.
âBest night ever,â you whispered against his chest. steve whispered against your hair âDouble dates with you are dangerous, in the best way. Iâm keeping you hostage, cowgirl, like a damsel in distress.â
He held you close until you both drifted off, warm, satisfied, and wrapped up in each other.
i saw a pic of joe wearing a cow boy hat and that really had my mind goingđ”âđ«đ”âđ«
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch âą No registration required âą HD streaming
Summary: Youâve been friends with Javi for years,the kind of years that turns someone into family. Heâs the one who pulled you into his inner circle, which just so happens to include Joe Keery. Youâve liked Joe for forever, and somehow the only person who hasnât figured that out is Joe himself. So what happens when you finally decide to tell him?
Previous Chapter
You woke up smiling.
For one sleepy second, you couldn't remember why.
Then you did.
You buried your face in your pillow.
"Oh my God."
The words came out muffled against the fabric.
You laughed at yourself.
There wasn't anyone there to hear it.
Your apartment looked exactly the same as it had the night before.
The same books on the shelf.
The same coffee mug you'd forgotten to wash.
The same sweater draped over the back of the chair.
Nothing had changed.
Everything had.
You stared at the ceiling for another minute before reaching up to touch your lips.
Immediately you groaned.
You dropped your hand over your eyes.
"This is embarrassing."
Another laugh escaped you.
If anyone could see you right now, they'd never let you live it down.
Your stomach flipped.
Joe.
The smile found you all over again.
Your phone buzzed on the nightstand.
You reached for it so quickly you almost knocked it onto the floor.
A single message waited on the screen.
Joe:Â Good morning.
You smiled before you'd even finished reading it.
A second message appeared almost immediately.
Joe: I've replayed last night an embarrassing number of times already.
You laughed.
Your thumbs hovered over the keyboard.
You:Only an embarrassing number?
The typing bubble appeared almost instantly.
Joe: I'm trying to sound emotionally stable.Â
You laughed so loudly the sound echoed around your apartment.
The bubble appeared again.
You: Yeah? How's that going?
Joe: Poorly. I walked three blocks past my apartment last night.
You frowned.
You: Why?
His answer came almost immediately.
Joe: Well...obviously.. I was thinking about kissing you.
You read it once.
Then again.
Then once more, just to make sure you'd read it correctly.
Your face grew warm.
You bit your lip, smiling so hard it almost hurt.
You: That seems like a valid excuse.
This time, it took him a little longer to answer.
Joe: I thought so too.
You could picture him on the other side of the city.
Probably sitting at his kitchen table.
Coffee growing cold beside him.
Smiling at his phone the same way you were.
Your coffee maker beeped from the kitchen.
You didn't move.
Another message.
Joe: Too much?
Your heart squeezed.
Already.
Already he was checking.
Already making sure he hadn't crossed some invisible line.
You smiled.
You: Not even close. Luckily, you walked me to my place or else I would have probably done the same thing.
Joe: Haha, I took that hit for you.
You smiled to yourself.
Maybe today would feel different.
Maybe tomorrow would too.
And maybe...for the first time in a very long time...
Different wasn't something to be afraid of.
You were halfway through your coffee before you realized you'd been smiling into the mug.
"This has to stop," you muttered.
It didn't.
You got ready for work in half the time it usually took.
Not because you were rushing.
Because for the first time in weeks, your mind wasn't somewhere else.
It was exactly where you were.
The walk outside felt different.
The air was crisp.
Someone had left a little dachshund tied outside the coffee shop on the corner.
It wagged so enthusiastically at you that you laughed and bent down to scratch behind its ears.
"You seem to be having a good morning too."
The dog's owner smiled as they came back outside.
"I was just thinking the same thing."
You smiled to yourself as you continued down the block.
Maybe everyone looked happier today.
Or maybe...
You did.
Halfway to work, your phone buzzed again.
You glanced down.
Joe: Can I ask you something?
You smiled.
You: That depends.
Joe: Be honest.
You: Now I'm worried.
Joe: Did I actually say "Worth the wait?"
You stopped at the crosswalk, laughing before you could help yourself.
You: You absolutely did.
A long pause.
Long enough that you wondered if he'd thrown his phone across the room.
Joe: I was awake at two this morning thinking about that.
Your smile softened.
You: Well Joe....It worked out for you.
Another pause.
Joe: Good to know.
Three dots appeared again.
Joe: Still.
You laughed quietly to yourself.
There it was.
The man who could stand on stage in front a million strangers without blinking...and lose sleep over four sincere words.
The light changed.
You crossed the street still smiling.
Maybe this was what everyone meant when they talked about falling in love.
Not the grand gestures.
Not the dramatic declarations.
Maybe it was just...learning that the person who made your heart race was just as wonderfully, hopelessly human as you were.
Your phone stayed quiet for the rest of the morning.
There wasn't any pressure to fill every minute with conversation.
Last night had already said enough.
You were halfway through lunch when your phone buzzed again.
You glanced down.
Joe: Question.
You smiled.
You: Answer.
Joe: Funny. lol Everyone's coming over to my place tonight.
Joe: Join them?
Your smile softened.
There was something about the way he'd asked... hopeful.
You: I'd like that.
The reply came almost immediately.
Joe: Good.
Joe: I was trying to sound casual.
Joe: I don't think I pulled it off.
You laughed.
You: Not even a little.
Three dots appeared.
Joe: See you tonight?
You stared at the screen for a second before answering.
You: See you tonight.
For the rest of the afternoon, the words stayed with you.
By the time you left work, the nerves had finally caught up with you.
Joe's apartment.
Not your first time there.
Just...the first time since everything had changed.
Javi was already waiting outside the subway station, hands shoved into the pockets of his jacket.
"There you are."
"Well hello."
You fell into step beside him.
For a few blocks, you talked about nothing.
Work.
The weather.
Whether the pizza place on the corner had actually gotten worse or if the two of you were just getting older.
Then Javi looked over.
"So."
You kept your eyes ahead.
"So."
"You gonna make me ask?"
You sighed.
"I kissed Joe."
Javi stopped walking.
You made it another two steps before realizing he'd disappeared.
When you turned around, he was staring at you.
"You what?"
You laughed.
"I kissed Joe."
"No."
He pointed.
"No, no. You don't get to say that while we're crossing the street."
You laughed harder.
His mouth opened.
Closed.
Opened again.
"I have been rooting for this for..." He looked toward the sky as if searching for the number. "...an unreasonable amount of time."
"I know."
"No, I don't think you do."
He caught up beside you.
"I almost started a betting pool."
"You did not."
"I considered it."
You bumped his shoulder.
"I hate you."
"No, you don't."
You smiled.
"I don't."
Javi looked at you for a long moment.
Then his grin softened.
"You look happy."
The words were so simple they almost caught you off guard.
You looked down at the sidewalk.
"I am."
He nodded once.
"I know."
And somehow...
That felt like enough.
The two of you walked another half block before Javi spoke again.
"So...have you talked to Wes?
You glanced sideways.
Your smile faded just enough for him to notice.
"No."
He nodded slowly.
You looked down at the sidewalk.
"I don't even know what to say."
"You probably don't have to say much."
"I still feel like I owe him something."
Javi was quiet for a moment.
"You owe him honesty."
You swallowed.
"And kindness."
He looked over at you.
"But don't confuse that with guilt."
You didn't answer.
Because that was exactly what you'd been doing.
Javi sighed.
"He's gonna be okay."
"You don't know that."
"No."
He smiled, though it was smaller now.
"But I know Wes."
You looked at him.
"He cares a lot about you."
The words landed gently.
"So this is going to hurt."
A beat.
"But he's also going to want you to be happy."
You felt your throat tighten.
"I hate that those things can both be true."
"I know."
He nudged your shoulder.
"He's one of your best friends. And that's exactly why you can't decide how he gets to feel."
You let that settle between you.
A few more steps passed before Javi spoke again.
"When you're ready..."
He shrugged.
"Just be his friend."
Nothing more.
Nothing less.
You nodded.
"I can do that."
Javi smiled.
"I know you can."
By the time you reached Joe's building, your shoulders had relaxed.
A little.
Javi held the front door to the building open for you.
"You ready?"
You took a breath.
"I think so."
"Good."
He grinned.
"Because if Joe burned dinner, I'm not pretending to like it."
"He ordered pizza."
Javi laughed.
"I just wanted you to know where I stand."
You laughed as the two of you climbed the stairs.
Before either of you could knock, the apartment door swung open.
Joe stood there.
"I thought I heardâ"
He stopped when he saw you.
It wasn't dramatic.
His sentence simply...disappeared.
A smile found him before he seemed to realize it.
"Hey."
It came out quieter than he'd probably intended.
"Hey."
For a second, neither of you moved.
Then Javi cleared his throat loudly.
"You two gonna keep staring at each other, or are we actually eating?"
Joe blinked.
"Right."
He stepped back from the doorway.
"Sorry."
You walked past him into the apartment.
As you did, his hand brushed lightly against the small of your back.
Barely there.
Just enough to guide you inside.
It lasted less than a second.
No one else would've noticed.
You did.
The apartment smelled like pizza and garlic.
Music drifted quietly from somewhere in the kitchen.
It felt...warm, comfortable like somewhere people stayed longer than they'd planned to.
Javi disappeared toward the boxes stacked on the counter.
"I'm claiming first slice."
"That's not how this works," Joe called after him.
"It is if I'm loud enough."
Joe laughed.
Then he looked back at you.
"You made it."
The words were simple.
But the way he said them...
As though he'd been waiting for that exact moment all evening...
Made you smile.
"I did."
"About time." you heard a familiar voice shout.
You looked toward the living room.
Wes was sprawled across Joe's couch, one foot tucked underneath him, a slice of pizza balanced on a paper plate.
He smiled the second he saw you.
Your shoulders loosened without your permission.
"Hey Wes."
He stood and crossed the room before you could think too much about it.
His hug was familiar.
Easy.
Exactly the same as it had always been.
"Hi."
He stepped back, studying your face for half a second.
"You look..."
He tilted his head.
"...different."
Your stomach dropped.
"Oh?"
He smiled.
"Happier."
The knot in your chest loosened just enough to let you breathe.
"I'll take that." you smiled.
He reached over and stole another slice of pizza from the open box.
Joe looked over from the kitchen.
"Hey."
"I was hungry."
"That was my slice."
"It was."
Wes took a bite anyway.
"Now it's mine."
"You are the worst."
"I've been saying that for years," Javi called from the counter.
"No one listens to me."
The room dissolved into overlapping laughter.
You found yourself watching them.
Joe arguing over pizza.
Javi pretending to referee.
Wes grinning around a mouthful of food.
For a moment...
It almost felt like nothing had changed.
Then Joe walked over carrying two drinks.
He handed one to you without asking what you wanted.
Your favorite.
You looked up.
"You remembered."
He looked almost confused.
"Of course I remembered."
He said it like there had never been another possibility.
Like remembering things about you wasn't something he did on purpose anymore.
It was simply something he did.
"You guys need anything else?" Joe asked, looking around the room.
Javi held up an empty soda can.
"I'm good unless somebody else is volunteering."
"Helpful."
"I try."
Joe shook his head with a smile and disappeared into the kitchen.
A moment later, you found yourself following him.
You leaned against the counter while he searched through the refrigerator.
He glanced over.
"Hi."
You smiled. âWe've already said hi."
"I know." He closed the refrigerator. "I just..."
A sheepish smile.
"...missed you."
You laughed, shaking your head.
"I missed you..even though it was thirty seconds"
He stepped closer.
Not all the way.
Just enough.
His eyes searched yours for the briefest moment.
The same silent question he'd asked outside your apartment the night before.
You answered with a tiny nod.
His smile softened.
He leaned in and kissed you.
Quick.
Gentle.
Like he'd only borrowed the moment.
When he pulled away, neither of you moved.
He rested his forehead lightly against yours for just a second.
"I wanted to do that the second you walked in."
Your smile was impossible to hide.
"So that's why you forgot Javi's drink."
Joe looked down at the empty hand he'd walked into the kitchen with.
"...Huh."
You laughed.
"I'll get the sodas."
"I was distracted."
"I noticed."
He smiled to himself.
"Worth it."
He reached into the refrigerator again.
This time, he actually remembered why he'd come in.
When the two of you walked back into the living room, no one looked up.
Javi was still trying to convince Wes that pineapple belonged on pizza.
"It adds balance."
"It adds betrayal," Wes shot back.
"You two are exhausting."
"You love us," Javi said.
"I tolerate you."
Joe handed Javi his soda.
"There."
"You remembered."
"I almost didn't."
Javi narrowed his eyes.
"...Concerning."
Joe only smiled to himself.
You caught it.
And suddenly smiling back felt dangerously easy.
"You know what?" Wes said, setting his plate down on the coffee table.
"We're settling this."
"Oh no," Javi groaned.
"Oh yes."
Wes reached underneath the coffee table and pulled out a worn deck of cards.
"You still have those?" Joe asked.
"Of course."
"You've moved three times."
"And yet..."Â Wes held them up triumphantly. "...they survived."
Javi sighed dramatically.
"I already know I'm going to lose."
"You say that every time."
"Because every time one of you decides the rules are 'open to interpretation.'"
"They are."
"They're absolutely not."
Within minutes, pizza boxes had been pushed aside.
The coffee table disappeared beneath scattered cards.
Arguments started over rules no one actually remembered.
Someone accused Joe of cheating.
"I literally shuffled."
"Suspiciously well," Javi replied.
Wes nodded.
"I've always said that."
Joe looked at you.
"See what I deal with?"
You laughed.
"I think you're outnumbered."
"I usually am."
He said it with a smile.
Like he wouldn't have it any other way.
The cards slid across the coffee table.
Someone stole the last slice of pizza.
Music changed three times before anyone noticed.
At some point, Javi ended up lying upside down across the couch insisting it helped him think.
It didnât.
Wes won the first game.
Joe claimed heâd been cheated.
No one believed him.
You laughed so hard your stomach hurt.
Somewhere between one round and the next, the conversation drifted away from the game entirely.
It always did.
Movies.
The worst haircuts anyone in the room had ever had.
Stories youâd all heard before.
Stories that somehow got funnier every time they were told.
Every now and then, your knee brushed Joeâs beneath the coffee table.
Neither of you moved away.
You caught him looking at you once.
Then twice.
By the third time, you stopped pretending not to notice.
âWhat?â
He smiled into the rim of his soda can.
âNothing.â
âLiar.â
His smile only grew.
âI just like looking at you.â
The room carried on around you.
Javi was halfway through another story.
Wes interrupted every third sentence.
Nobody noticed the conversation the two of you were having without saying another word.
Eventually, the stack of cards grew untouched.
Conversations stretched a little longer between sentences.
Someone yawned.
Someone else checked the time and looked genuinely surprised.
âWhen did it get so late?â Javi asked.
Wes glanced toward the window.
âA while ago.â
âNo one thought to mention it?â
âYou were telling the same story for twenty minutes.â
âIt was a good story.â
Joe started gathering empty soda cans from the coffee table.
âIâll get these.â
âIâll help,â you said, already reaching for the pizza boxes.
âYou donât have to.â
âI know.â You smiled.âI want to.â
For a few quiet minutes, everyone cleaned without really talking.
Paper plates disappeared into the trash.
The cards were tucked back into their worn box.
The music kept playing.
Softer now.
When everything was put away, the apartment somehow felt smaller.
Like the evening had packed itself up with the empty pizza boxes.
Javi grabbed his jacket first.
âI should probably head out.â
Wes nodded.
âYeah.â
You reached for your own jacket hanging over the back of the chair.
Joe was already holding it before you got there.
âOh.â
He smiled as he helped you slip it on.
It was such a small thing.
And somehowâŠÂ no one said a word about it.
Because there wasnât anything to say.
It just happened.
The way some things already seemed to with him.
The four of you made your way toward the door.
Javi was already halfway into his jacket.
"I've got an early morning."
Joe unlocked the apartment door.
Cool evening air drifted into the hallway.
For a moment, everyone simply stood there.
Like no one wanted to be the first to actually leave.
Then Wes looked at you.
"I'll walk you home."
The words were so familiar they almost answered themselves.
For as long as you could remember, that had been the routine.
If it was late, Wes walked you home.
Simple as that.
You looked up instinctively.
Joe had gone very still.
Like he knew this wasn't his place to interrupt.
The silence stretched for only a heartbeat.
"If..."
Joe rubbed the back of his neck.
"You don't mind..."
He looked at Wes first.
Then at you.
"I was kind of hoping to steal the walk tonight."
His voice was careful.
Almost apologetic.
As though he wasn't asking for permission to walk you home.
He was asking to change something that had belonged to someone else for a long time.
The hallway grew still.
Wes looked between the two of you.
Just for a second.
Then he smiled.
Small.
Real.
He stepped back.
"Go ahead."
Joe blinked.
"You sure?"
Wes nodded once.
"Yeah."
A beat.
"I'll see you both tomorrow?"
Joe held his gaze for another second.
Then smiled.
"Yeah."
"See you tomorrow."
You looked at Wes.
"I'll text you when I get home."
"You better."
"I will."
He smiled.
You stepped toward him before you could think about it.
"Come here."
Wes laughed softly.
"What?"
You wrapped your arms around him.
The hug was quick.
He hugged you back just as easily.
"You okay?" he asked quietly.
You nodded against his shoulder.
"Yeah."
He gave your shoulder one gentle squeeze before letting you go.
"I'm glad."
When you stepped back, he smiled.
The same crooked smile he'd worn for years.
"I'll expect that text."
"You'll get it."
He glanced at Joe.
"Take care of her."
Joe didn't answer right away.
Not because he didn't know what to say.
Because he understood how much those four words meant.
Finally, he nodded.
"I will."
Wes smiled once.
Then turned toward the stairs with Javi.
The apartment hallway suddenly felt much quieter.
You listened until the sound of their footsteps faded down the stairwell.
Only then did you look at Joe.
He was still standing exactly where you'd left him.
Hands in his pockets.
Watching the hallway.
Quiet.
"What's wrong?" you asked.
He looked over.
A small smile.
"I just..."
He exhaled softly.
"I know how much he means to you."
You looked down for a moment. "He always will."
"I know."
There wasn't even a flicker of hesitation in his voice.
"I'd never want that to change."
Your eyes found his again.
"You mean that?"
He almost looked surprised you'd asked.
"Of course I do."
He stepped a little closer.
"I didn't want tonight to feel like I was taking something away from him."
"You weren't."
"I know."
A small pause.
"But I wanted him to know I knew."
Your chest tightened.
It wasn't guilt.
It was gratitude.
Because somehow...Joe had managed to make room for everyone you loved.
Without asking you to choose.
You reached for his hand first.
His fingers slipped easily between yours.
"So..."
"So?"
"I've been very patient." he says with a devilish grin.
You laughed. "You kissed me in your kitchen."
"I know." He smiled. "I was hoping for a little more."
You stood on your toes and leaned in.
This kiss lingered longer than the first.
Slow.
Passionate.
When you pulled away, he rested his forehead against yours.
"I could get used to this."
You smiled.
"I was just thinking the same thing."
He laughed softly.
"Good."
He squeezed your hand once.
"Come on."
This time, when the two of you stepped into the hallway together...
Neither of you let go.
The city had settled into that strange kind of quiet only found after midnight.
Streetlights stretched across the sidewalks.
The air had cooled just enough that you found yourself walking a little closer to him.
Neither of you spoke for a while.
There wasn't any need to.
His hand stayed wrapped around yours.
Warm.
Steady.
Like it had always belonged there.
Every now and then, your shoulders brushed.
Sometimes because the sidewalk narrowed.
Sometimes for no reason at all.
You caught yourself smiling.
"What?" Joe asked.
You looked over at him.
"Nothing."
He smiled.
"Liar."
You laughed softly.
"Maybe."
He didn't ask again.
He simply smiled to himself and kept walking.
By the time your apartment came into view, you realized something.
All evening, you'd been waiting for the moment everything would start to feel different.
Like crossing some invisible line.
Like becoming something more with Joe was supposed to change the shape of the world overnight.
But it hadn't.
The streets were the same.
The city sounded the same.
The people you loved were still the people you loved.
The only thing that had changed...was the hand holding yours.
By eight in the morning, your apartment already smelled like your cafe. Batter splattered the countertop. Cooling racks covered every available surface. One hundred cupcakes sat neatly lined across the dining table, each decorated with pastel frosting and tiny sugar flowers.
You wiped your forehead with the back of your hand, admiring your work. "Welcome home, Joe," you whispered proudly. Youâre planning to have a welcome home party for your future husband. Then, out of habit, your thumb brushed over your ring finger.
Your right hand felt nothing, you looked down, and your engagement ring was gone. Your entire body froze. "fuck." Your soul genuinely left your body. "No no no no, no."
You checked your other hand. Your apron pockets, kitchen counter, nothing. You practically threw yourself onto the floor, checking beneath the dining table. Neither in the bathroom, bedroom, closet, laundry basket, under the pillows, inside Ponkanâs cardboard house, inside Cookieâs little tunnel.
You stopped in the middle of the apartment, suddenly remembering exactly what you'd been doing all morning. You slowly looked toward the mountain of cupcakes.Â
"I decorated one hundred cupcakes while wearing my engagement ring." You stared at the cupcakes. "Oh my god."
Thirty minutes later, your apartment looked like an emergency meeting.
It was two in the afternoon. You stood in front of everyone with your hands on your hips. You took a deep breath. "Okay, I need everyone's help." They nodded seriously. "You all have to eat these cupcakes."
"YES!" Javi shouted immediately. The apartment echoed. He cleared his throat. "Sorry, please continue."
You pointed at the cupcakes. "And if anyone feels something hard..." You swallowed. "raise your hand."
Your co-baker frowned. "Why?"
You answered much too quickly. "No reason."
Matt narrowed his eyes. "Y/N, you lost the ring, donât you?."
"What? No way, fine, yes I lost it. So, please.â You sighed dramatically. "I only have four hours before Joe gets home." The apartment collectively gasped.
Jake immediately cracked his knuckles. "I volunteer."
Before anyone could respond, you added, "The person who finds it gets one month of free pastries."
Complete silence filled the apartment. Dalton lunged for the table. Matt shoved him aside.
"You moved first!"
"Not so fast!"
Jake quietly grabbed six cupcakes while they argued. Your barista immediately slapped his hand.
"Excuse me."
"What is your problem?"
"I'll find the ring and get the free pastries I want."
"You'll find diabetes."
Yes, Jake and your barista get on each otherâs nerves. You donât mind them, all you care about at the moment is finding your ring.Â
The old man from 6D calmly selected three cupcakes. "I'll have these."
"Only three?" your cashier asked.
"I'm seventy-nine, Iâd like to see eighty." He smiled politely.
Meanwhile, Dalton already had frosting on his nose and on his cheeks. "I've eaten fifteen."
Matt swallowed another cupcake, icing splattered on his shirt. "Sixteen."
Dalton grabbed two another. "Seventeen."
Matt immediately took two. "Eighteen."
Wesley pinched the bridge of his nose. "This isn't a competition."
Both of them answered at the same time. "Ooh, it absolutely is."
âYou only say that because this ainât macarons. If this is macarons, youâre throwing yourself at the tablââJavi didnât even finish his sentence when Wesley shoved a cupcake in his mouth.Â
âEat, man. Eat.â Wesley said, unwrapping one more cupcake.Â
Your youngest employee suddenly stood up. "I...cant" She covered her mouth, she sprinted toward your bathroom. The sound of the door slamming echoed through the apartment.
Jake watched her go. "Weak."
Your barista glared. "She's just had eight."
Jake shrugged. "I've had twelve."
âJust keep eating, I donât care who ate more.â you bite three cupcakes all at once. Completely under pressure.Â
Hours passed. Cupcake wrappers covered the coffee table. Crumbs everywhere. Plastic cups on the floor. The apartment smelled aggressively like chocolate, vanilla, and regret.
Javi had somehow fallen asleep sitting perfectly upright in a dining chair, still holding half a cupcake in one hand. Every now and then his head dipped forward before jerking back up again, only for him to continue sleeping as if nothing had happened.
Dalton sat slumped against the couch, one hand dramatically over his stomach. "I don't think Iâll ever eat again." he muttered weakly.
Across from him, Matt looked equally miserable, yet somehow still refused to surrender. "I've had...twenty-two," he swallowed carefully.
Dalton immediately lifted his head. "...Twenty-three."
Jake, meanwhile, attempted to reach for another cupcake from the table. His hand made it halfway before giving up and slowly dropping back onto his lap. "You know what never mind."
Your barista watched the entire thing unfold with the most judgmental expression imaginable. "I told you."
Jake sighed dramatically. "You always do."
"And I'm always right."
Wesley had completely disappeared into the bathroom nearly fifteen minutes ago. Every now and then, his exhausted voice drifted through the hallway. "I don't even like cupcakes anymore. I wonât even eat cupcakes for a year."
Your youngest employee sat on the rug with tears streaming down her face. "I don't know why I'm crying."
Your cashier gently patted her shoulder. "It's the sugar, girl."
"I miss vegetables."
Your co-baker had reached the stage where everything was funny. She pointed at Dalton and started giggling. Looked at Wesley and laughed even harder. Then glanced at absolutely nothing before dissolving into another fit of laughter.
"I can't stop," she wheezed. "It isn't even funny anymore." Which only made her laugh harder.
In the middle of all the chaos, the old man remained perfectly composed. He crossed one leg over the other, lifted his teacup, and took a slow, civilized sip.
After a thoughtful pause, he nodded once. "I believe I'm done investigating."
You checked every empty wrapper, nothing. Your eyes burned. "Oh god, what am I going to tell Joe?"
Just then, Cookie suddenly launched himself across the living room. Zoomies is the biggest enemy when it comes to Cookie, if Ponkan doesnât care about the world, Cookie is the total opposite.Â
Cookie went straight toward the couch. He bounced against the cushions repeatedly, pawing at something. Ponkan, who had been asleep for the last six hours, barely opened one eye.
"Mreow." Cookie kept bothering him.
"Cookie," you sighed. "Leave your brother alone."
You walked over, gently scooping Ponkan into your arms. The orange cat stretched dramatically. A tiny sparkle caught the afternoon sunlight.
Everyone froze.
There, your engagement ring was perfectly nestled into the couch cushion. Looks like Ponkan slept on it. The apartment fell silent. Everyone exchanged glances. Your barista slowly lowered her cupcake.
Dalton whispered, "No way."
Wesley looked at the mountain of empty wrappers. "We ate ninety-three cupcakes."
The old man from 6D quietly took another sip of tea. "Could've been worse. We could've eaten one hundred." Nobody had the energy to laugh.Â
You burst into relieved tears instead, laughing so hard you almost dropped Ponkan. "Oh my god!" You slipped the ring back onto your finger, kissing the top of Ponkan's head over and over. "My sweet boy!" Ponkan blinked lazily. Completely unaware he'd just ended the most ridiculous investigation in history.
Right on cue, the front door unlocked. Joe stepped inside carrying his duffel bag and suitcase. "Honey, Iâm home!" He stopped. His eyes slowly scanned the apartment. âDid I miss something?"
Summary: A perfect birthday unfolds in paradise, powerful alliances quietly take shape, and beneath the warmth of celebration, Maggie's trap begins to close around Marshall Beaumont
Note: Spot the chapter Mimi wrote whilst ovulating.... Also, this chapter reveals that I know fuck all about playing the piano lol. Anyway, enjoy my horny ovulating mind... Mimi <3
Masterlist
Keratolysis
Translation: The Peeling of Skin
From lysis, meaning âa loosening, dissolution or breaking apartâ. The shedding or peeling of the outer epidermal layers.
Friday morning found you back in the Yukon with Jack, once again, behind the wheel. You'd quietly decided you liked travelling with Jack. Not because he was particularly talkative, if anything, he was the opposite, but because there was something reassuring about the way he drove. Nothing was hurried. Every movement was deliberate. He never seemed surprised by anything happening on the road, as though he'd already anticipated it several seconds before everyone else.
Maggie occupied one of the captain's chairs in the middle row, already halfway through reading something on her iPad.
You and Gator had claimed the back.
You'd curled naturally into his side almost as soon as you'd climbed in, your legs tucked beneath you across the leather seat while his arm rested around your shoulders, holding you comfortably against his chest. Every now and then you felt the idle movement of his thumb against your arm, completely unconscious on his part.
Outside, the familiar roads of Stark County gradually gave way to long stretches of open countryside. Every now and then Jack adjusted the cruise control as another small town disappeared behind you. You watched the trees drifting past outside for another minute before your curiosity finally won. You looked towards Maggie.
"So, you gonna tell us more about where weâre going?"
"Take note, Gator,â she said, without looking up from the tablet. âThis girl is no good with surprises."
You felt Gator laugh quietly against your temple before his lips found the top of your head.
"Itâs opening weekend at my hunting lodge. Itâs a closed event so plenty of room to take you with me."
"You hunt? Is it like, a members thing?"
"I hunt and it is exactly a members thing,â Maggie nodded. âLuckily for you, I own the place so Iâm sure theyâll look past the lack of membership."
"You own a hunting lodge?" You asked with knitted brows.
"Where'bouts?" Gator asked.
"Turtle Mountains, near Lake Metigoshe. The Briar. I donât have too much to do with it in the day to day, but I always head up for opening weekend."
You tried picturing Maggie owning a hunting lodge. Strangely... It fit. Not because you'd ever imagined her wandering around forests carrying a rifle, but because Maggie had always collected projects the way other people collected hobbies, she collected those too. The plants in her office, housing projects. Basically, anything you could do to keep your hands busy; Maggie Heaton had tried at least once.
"Are there other guests?"
"This weekend is invite only. The first hunt for a select few that I invite personally."
"Got a feelinâ thatâs a specific list," Gator smirked.
Maggie finally abandoned the iPad altogether. She crossed one leg over the other before turning in her seat to face the pair of you properly.
"They each have their purpose." A knowing smile tugged at the corner of her mouth. "You wanna know whoâs coming?"
"Will I know them?"
"Youâll know some." She counted them off almost absent-mindedly. "Judge Keating; Warren, heâs been a good friend for some time. Senator Vale; Richard, the man is a spineless rat, but he has his uses. Thomas Bellamy, typical finance guy. Harvey Sloan, attorney, again bit of an ass but useful. The doctor, Isaac Whitmore, private surgeon, careful with him Baby, heâs no trouble but heâll be sizing you up like a prize cow, offering you all sorts of nips and tucks."
Before you could answer, Gator's arm tightened around your shoulders, he pressed another kiss into your hair.
"Donât need all that shit, yâperfect."
Heat crept into your cheeks. You smiled, squeezing the hand resting against your shoulder before leaning over to kiss his bicep.
"Damn right she is." Maggie smiled. "Who else? Omar Haddad? Omar is a good man, family man. He owns a trucking firm. Lionel Baptiste, land developer. Rafael Alvarez-"
"I know that name,â you interrupted. âHorses, right? Race horses."
Maggie nodded.
"Yeah, he breeds horses, nice guy, youâll like him. Oh, Leon DuPont, youâll love Leon, he owns casinos and clubs across the country. Heâll talk your ear off about the clubhouse refurb, Baby. Celestino Vega-"
"I know him too! Doesnât he have a Grammy? Blues singer?"
"Yeah, voice full of soul, owns a whiskey brand now. Good one too. Then, who am I missingâŠ. Oh, Dean Holloway-"
"The very same. Great guy, lot of fun. Vincent Moretti, legal firearm manufacturer, which is hilarious considering he is the worst shot of the lot." She paused briefly. "And then one, Marshall Beaumont."
You straightened in your seat.
"Heâs coming?"
"He was invited long before I knew, but yes, heâs coming and he has no idea Iâm onto him. So, a perfect opportunity for me to take measurements for his coffin."
A low chuckle escaped Gator beside you. You weren't quite as convinced.
"Is that not a bit risky?"
Maggie simply smiled.
"He has the privilege of being a rich old white man. Part of that benefits package includes his complete God complex. Ivory men in ivory towers,â she winked at you, repeating the words her father told her. âHe doesnât know anything and he thinks heâs untouchable, I plan to keep it that way until the very last moment."
You let yourself sink back against Gator again, resting your head beneath his chin. Almost immediately his arm tightened around you, pulling you a little closer.
"Iâm not shooting any animals,â you stated. âJust so youâre aware."
Maggie's laugh filled the cabin.
"Of course not. Didnât bring you to hunt. I just figured itâd be nice for you two to get away from the madness for a moment. Iâve put you in one of the outer lodges, overlooks the lake, private deck. Thereâs plenty to do that isnât shooting deer, Baby. We got boats on the lake, a horse trail, hiking trails. Chef Mario puts on a dinner to rival any meal youâve ever eaten. Heâs been planning your birthday dinner all week."
You looked down at the hoodie you were wearing before glancing towards the bags sitting in the cargo area behind you. A private lodge. A birthday dinner. A room overlooking a lake. Suddenly the contents of your suitcase felt woefully inadequate.
"Why do I feel like I have desperately under-packed for this?"
"Baby, yâpacked half the closet,â Gator laughed softly. âThink yâgonna be jusâ fine."
"And I might have packed you a thing or two." Maggie added.
"I was suspicious of your lack of gift this morning," you chuckled.
Your birthday had actually started several hours earlier, even though it wasnât technically until tomorrow. Like every birthday in the Heaton house, nobody was allowed to simply wander downstairs, collect a present and carry on with their day. Maggie insisted birthdays were occasions, which meant everybody piled into the living room before breakfast, still half asleep and clutching oversized mugs of coffee while the birthday person sat in the middle of the chaos opening presents.
Brooks had gone first. His present had been a Wrangler denim jacket, lined for winter. Ford had followed with a new pair of boots that fitted perfectly. Neither of your uncles had ever really been shoppers, which left you quietly convinced Maggie had accompanied them for both purchases. She'd deny it, of course.
Nicky and Rhodes had proudly presented a slightly squashed box containing homemade cupcakes alongside hand-drawn birthday cards. Within ten minutes they'd each managed to eat at least three cupcakes while happily watching you unwrap everybody else's presents, leaving a trail of icing across the arm of the sofa and somehow on Rhodes' forehead.
Walker had surprised you; he'd become oddly good at buying presents. He'd found a tote bag from some small online business you'd never heard of. It was quilted by hand with different patches stitched across the front. A little Bronco. A football. A heart. A cowboy boot. Right in the middle, one embroidered patch simply read Baby. It was ridiculously thoughtful. It was sitting now in the footwell beside your feet.
Tucker's gift had been equally unexpected. A bottle of perfume. A nice one too, not something he'd grabbed from a supermarket shelf on the way home. You strongly suspected Walker had steered him in the right direction, but Tucker had looked so pleased with himself when you'd smiled that you hadn't questioned it.
Then Logan had wandered over with his present. Inside had been the tackiest photo frame you'd ever seen; bright pink and green stripes, plastic with enormous bubble letters across the bottom spelling out BFFL. It was completely ridiculous and entirely Logan.
You'd laughed the second you saw it. Then you'd looked at the photograph inside. It had been taken after the boys won All-State back in high school. The four of you were perched across the tailgate of somebody's truck, boys still wearing football gear, medals hanging around their necks. Logan sat in the middle with an arm thrown around both you and Noah, grinning so hard his eyes had almost disappeared. Noah was laughing at something outside the frame.
And Gator... You hadn't noticed it all those years ago. But he was stood beside you, one hand resting on the tailgate barely an inch from your thigh. Looking at you. Not the camera, not the boys. Just... You. Like the photograph had accidentally captured something nobody else had realised was happening. On the back Logan had simply written four words.
It was always you.
The frame itself might have been awful, but the sentiment wasn't. By the time breakfast had dissolved into the usual chaos of children needing wiping down and adults pretending they hadn't also eaten cake before nine in the morning, you'd been thoroughly spoilt.
Maggie adored birthdays, she wasn't the sort of woman who quietly forgot to give a present. If anything, the complete absence of one made you far more suspicious than if she'd handed you something wrapped in a giant bow.
Maggie glanced back over her shoulder, the faintest smile already playing at the corner of her mouth. Then, without saying another word, she bent to retrieve her handbag from beside her seat.
"Like Iâd forget to get you a gift,â she smiled. âHere."
She held out a small box wrapped in thick cream paper, a dark green ribbon tied carefully around it. You accepted it, looking at her suspiciously.
"Hang on, you said you packed stuff for me, whatâs this?"
"Thatâs your gift, the stuff in my case is just in case you wanted options. Go on, open it."
Your curiosity got the better of you. The ribbon slipped free beneath your fingers before you peeled back the paper, revealing a familiar deep red presentation box beneath. You recognised the colour long before you spotted the logo.
"Oh my god..."
The words escaped under your breath as you lifted the lid. Nestled inside the box was a Cartier PanthĂšre watch. It was beautiful. Not flashy or oversized or designed to announce itself. Just elegant. Gold links caught the light filtering through the windows as the Yukon rounded another bend, each one gleaming softly against the white satin lining beneath it. You looked from the watch back to Maggie.
"This is⊠beautiful. Maggie, this is too much, itâs way too expensive."
She waved the concern away as though you'd commented on the weather.
"No such thing. Couldnât send it back even if I wanted to, turn it over."
Frowning slightly, you lifted the watch from the box and turned it over in your hand. The engraving sat neatly across the back. Baby. You leaned forward between the seats, wrapping your arms around Maggie as best you could.
"Thank you Mags, I love it."
"I know," she laughed quietly, hugging you back with one arm.
There was something wonderfully Maggie about that response. No false modesty or pretending she'd been uncertain. She'd chosen it because she'd known you would love it. You settled back into your seat, still smiling to yourself as you tried fastening the watch around your wrist. Beside you, Gator chuckled.
"Here, lemme do it."
You passed him the watch, and he took your wrist gently in one hand, his fingers warm against your skin. It took him only a few seconds before the clasp clicked into place.
"There."
You turned your wrist slowly, watching the gold catch the afternoon light, it fitted perfectly. You held it up towards him. He looked at the watch for all of half a second before his attention settled back on you instead.
"Looks good, Baby."
Then he leaned down and kissed the top of your head with the same quiet affection he'd shown you all morning. Across the aisle Maggie smiled to herself before turning back around in her seat. A little while later Jack's voice broke the comfortable silence from the driverâs seat.
"Weâre twenty minutes out,â he asked, looking at Maggie in the rear view. âWant me to call ahead?"
"No, thank you. Iâll call Henry, let him know weâre almost with him."
Jack acknowledged her with a small nod before returning his full attention to the road, the Yukon continuing north.
The road narrowed until it felt like the forest had swallowed it completely. Pines crowded either side, their branches meeting high overhead and throwing shifting patches of shade across the windscreen. Every now and then the trees parted just enough to reveal flashes of blue water somewhere off to the right before closing again. Jack slowed almost imperceptibly as the truck rounded another bend.
Ahead, a pair of enormous timber gates stood open between two stone pillars. Carved into a simple wooden sign suspended between them were two words.
The Briar.
The tyres left the main road and rolled onto a long gravel drive; it stretched on far longer than you expected. Woodland continued for another minute or two, broken only by occasional glimpses of riding trails disappearing deeper between the trees. Then, almost without warning, everything opened up.
The lodge emerged from the clearing, and you found yourself leaning forwards slightly. It was stunning. The entire building seemed to belong there. Huge timber beams framed walls of pale stone, enormous windows reflected the surrounding forest, and wide porches wrapped around the building beneath a roof that looked as though it had been built to withstand a hundred North Dakota winters.
Your eyes drifted towards the parking area beside the entrance, several luxury SUVs sat neatly in a row. A Bentley. A Rolls Royce. The sort of vehicles that belonged to people who never had to think twice before spending money. Jack eased the Yukon beneath the covered entrance and brought it smoothly to a stop. The front doors opened before the engine had even fallen silent.
Staff appeared almost immediately, not rushing, simply moving with the confidence of people who had done the same welcome hundreds of times before. Somewhere between Jack opening his own door and climbing out, two members of staff were already making their way towards the rear of the vehicle.
Jack circled around to Maggie's side first, he opened her door and offered his hand, she accepted it with an easy smile as she stepped down onto the stone. A tall man in a dark suit was already approaching, his glasses caught the light as he walked, every part of him immaculate, from the perfectly pressed jacket to the polished shoes.
"Maggie, weâve had several guests arrive already, theyâve been shown to their allocated rooms and Billy is providing drinks in the East Lounge."
"Straight to business, Henry,â Maggie smiled warmly. âNo loving welcome."
"Of course, apologies,â Henry looked faintly embarrassed. âGreat to have you back."
He leaned in, kissing each of Maggie's cheeks before stepping back again. Behind them, the trunk was lifted open. Staff began unloading luggage with the same quiet efficiency they'd greeted you with while Jack remained beside the passenger door, turning instead to offer you his hand. You smiled your thanks as you climbed down. The cool mountain air hit you, it smelled different here, like pine and fresh water.
Maggie reached for your hand.
"Henry, this is my granddaughter, Baby and her boyfriend, Gator."
You felt strangely proud hearing her say it. Henry shook Gator's hand first before turning to you.
"A pleasure. Youâre the birthday girl?"
"Tomorrow, yes." You laughed.
"Well happy birthday."
He stepped aside, gesturing towards one of the younger members of staff waiting nearby. A young man in a neatly pressed uniform smiled and stepped forwards.
"Devon here will show you to your lodge. Maggie has put you up in Tamarack, our best suite."
You looked back towards Maggie. She'd already slipped effortlessly back into work mode. Another member of staff had quietly appeared beside Henry carrying a leather folder and Maggie's attention had already begun drifting towards whatever needed her next.
"Go ahead," she said. "Get settled. Iâve got some business to do, but Iâll come find you after."
She squeezed your arm briefly before turning back towards Henry. You and Gator followed Devon away from the main entrance. Somewhere behind you, your luggage had already been transferred from the Yukon into the back of a waiting RTV without either of you noticing it happen.
Gator waited while you climbed onto the bench seat first before settling beside you, one knee brushing yours. Devon climbed into the driver's seat, started the little vehicle and guided it away from the lodge.
The gravel paths wound gently through the estate, weaving between towering pines and smaller guest lodges tucked carefully into the landscape as though somebody had deliberately tried not to disturb the forest any more than necessary. After a minute or so, Devon glanced back over his shoulder with an easy smile.
"You been here before?"
"First time," you smiled.
âLet me give you the tour, then."
The paths meandered through the estate rather than cutting straight across it. Nothing about The Briar felt accidental. The buildings were tucked amongst the trees instead of clearing them away, the winding roads forcing everything to slow down until the outside world felt impossibly distant. Every few hundred yards another lodge appeared between the pines before disappearing again behind the forest.
Devon seemed to know every inch of it. As he steered the RTV between the trees, he pointed towards a cluster of cabins scattered amongst the woodland.
"So, these are the Aspen lodges. Noone staying in them this weekend, but rest of the year theyâre booked up."
You watched them disappear behind you. They were smaller than the main lodge but built in exactly the same style. Timber and stone, wide porches overlooking the trees, each one tucked far enough away from the next that it felt completely private. You couldn't imagine hearing another guest from any of them. The path curved again, through the trees you caught sight of a long timber building bordered by white fencing.
"Through there is the stables. Weâve got 18 horses you can loan for the trails, then 4 working horses. You might see horseback security riding around; Luca and Chris."
You looked up from the passing scenery.
"Horseback security?"
"Yeah,â Devon smiled in the rear-view mirror. âEasier to take the horses through the woods, you know? RTVâs are good, but it gets dense in the thick of it, canât always get the clearance. Plus those horses are mad quick."
It made sense, the estate was enormous. The further you drove from the main lodge, the more you realised this wasn't simply a hotel tucked beside a lake. It was its own little world. Miles of woodland stretched in every direction, broken only by cabins, trails and the occasional glimpse of another RTV disappearing between the trees.
A few minutes later the woodland opened out completely and water sparkled ahead of you. The RTV rolled to a slower pace as Devon gestured across the shoreline.
"Then down here we have the lake. Well, lakes. Itâs kind of like loads of little lakes surrounding one big one? This is the South Waterfront; this is all for fishing."
Small wooden docks reached out into the water, the lake itself stretched much further than you'd first realised, disappearing around wooded peninsulas that broke it into smaller bays. Rather than turning back, Devon carried on around the shoreline. The next waterfront felt entirely different.
Rows of boats bobbed gently against floating pontoons; kayaks stacked neatly beside a boathouse with paddleboards lined up along a dock. You found yourself smiling. It felt peaceful, the kind of place where hours disappeared without anybody noticing.
Eventually the paths began leading back towards the centre of the estate. The main lodge appeared again through the trees, somehow looking even larger now you were seeing it from different angles. Devon slowed as they passed beneath it.
"Main lodge is the hub of everything. Youâve got the different lounges, the dining room, the bar. Itâs built on a hill, so looks like one floor but when youâre inside it actually goes down. Doesnât look big from the outside but insideâs huge. There are twenty two suites inside, thatâs where the weekendâs guests all are, you guys are the only ones in a lodge."
"Only ones in a lodge,â you glanced sideways at Gator with a grin. âSpecial treatment."
He looked back at you with that familiar crooked smile before leaning across to steal a quick kiss.
"No-one to hear yâscreaminâ my name," he whispered.
Heat flooded your face before you could stop it. You gave his thigh an indignant poke, earning nothing more than a quiet laugh and an entirely unrepentant wink in return. Devon, thankfully, seemed to have mastered the very useful skill of pretending not to hear anything happening behind him.
The RTV continued onwards until another pair of heavy timber gates appeared ahead. Unlike the entrance to the estate, these remained firmly shut. Beyond them, all you could see was forest, Devon pointed as he drove past.
"That leads through to the hunting grounds, so essentially, just donât go through there unless you want to shoot or get shot at. Jonah, the groundskeeper, he runs the hunts so just check in with him."
Then the path turned west and the woodland thickened once more before gradually opening onto another stretch of water. Nestled on the shoreline sat a single lodge. It was larger than the Aspen cabins, set well back from the path beneath towering pines, with huge windows looking straight across the lake and a broad covered deck wrapping around the front. There wasn't another building in sight. Devon pulled the RTV to a stop.
"Then this is you, Tamarack. Youâre on the West Waterfront. Everythingâs done on directions, so you shouldnât get too lost. Main Lodge is at the centre, everything else on a rough circle around it."
You climbed down onto the gravel and looked out across the water. For the first time in days, everything felt quiet. The good kind. The sort that made it feel as though the rest of the world had been left somewhere beyond the trees.
The lodge sat slightly raised above the shoreline, built in the familiar A-frame style that echoed the rest of The Briar but somehow felt more intimate. Rich redwood cladding wrapped around the exterior, weathered just enough to soften the colour against the surrounding forest, while a broad stone foundation anchored the whole building into the landscape. It looked less like it had been built there and more like it had always belonged amongst the pines.
Devon lifted both your bags from the back of the RTV before leading the way up the short stone path. The front door opened with a soft click.
The entire back wall of the lodge was glass. Floor-to-ceiling windows stretched from one side of the room to the other, framing the lake like a painting. Beyond them, a private deck reached out towards the water, the afternoon sun scattering diamonds across the surface as a light breeze disturbed the otherwise perfect reflection of the trees.
For a second you forgot to move. Everything else seemed to disappear behind the view. Only when Devon stepped further inside did your attention finally drift back into the room itself.
Every surface invited you to touch it; wood, stone, leather, wool. Everything chosen because it would only become more beautiful with age. Devon placed your bags neatly on the bench at the foot of the bed.
"So, everything works from the tablet."
He crossed to the dining table, picking up what looked like an ordinary digital tablet before holding it out towards you.
"Lights, stereo, tv, air con, fire, blinds. You just tap the screen and tell it what you want."
As he spoke, the lights dimmed slightly before brightening again. Soft music drifted quietly through hidden speakers somewhere in the ceiling. He smiled.
"Also, from here you can order anything to the room, just type a message in here and it goes right to the front desk. Theyâll respond. You can also ask for someone to come get you, if you want an RTV to come bring you up to dinner or something. Basically anything you want, all on this screen."
He gave the tablet a little shake before placing it back exactly where he'd found it. Then he crossed towards the glass doors and slid them open. Fresh air rolled into the room. You reached instinctively for Gator's hand as you followed Devon outside, your fingers threading through his.
The deck overlooked nothing but water and trees; no neighbouring lodges, no passing guests, no sounds except the faint ripple of the lake against the shoreline and birds somewhere high in the pines.
"This lake is essentially yours," Devon explained. "No activities run on it so itâs just for you two. Just no diving off the deck, itâs rocky at the shore and itâs a walk in lake, so not that deep at the perimeter."
The lake was impossibly clear, the shallows revealing smooth stones beneath the surface before the water deepened into rich blues further out. Across the opposite bank, untouched woodland stretched as far as you could see.
You squeezed Gator's hand. When you looked up at him, he was staring across the water with exactly the same expression you imagined was on your own face, one of quiet amazement. Behind you, Devon continued as though breathtaking views were simply another item on the tour.
"Now, it isnât common, but we are close to Canada and occasionally we do catch sightings of bears, but it is rare and not this time of year. But just in case, if you see one, just head inside, close the door and use the tablet to message reception. Jonah will come sort it. But like I say, unlikely."
Back inside, Devon cast one last practiced look around the room, checking everything was exactly as it should be before pointing towards another door tucked discreetly beside the fireplace.
"Bathroom."
He reached into his pocket, producing two keycards before handing one to each of you.
"Keys. You need anything else?"
You looked around the lodge one more time.
"No, this is perfect,â you beamed. âThank you so much."
"My pleasure and happy birthday, Miss."
"Thank you."
He gave a polite nod before letting himself out, the front door clicking quietly shut behind him. For a moment neither of you moved and then you looked up at Gator. He was still smiling. Slowly, he turned another circle, taking in the room before looking back at you.
"Well this ainât bad,â he smirked.
You laughed.
"No," you agreed softly, looking back towards the lake beyond the windows. "Yeah, I think itâll do."
Maggie had called not long after you'd unpacked, apologising that business had kept her tied up longer than she'd expected. She'd promised she'd find you both later that evening and, true to form, solved the problem before either of you had the chance to think about it. Dinner had appeared at the front door barely twenty minutes later, delivered by another smiling member of staff.
So you and Gator had eaten outside on the deck that overlooked the lake, the water turning to molten gold beneath the lowering sun while the trees cast long shadows across the opposite bank. Neither of you had spoken much. There hadn't been any need. Every now and then one of you would point out an eagle circling overhead or a fish breaking the surface before settling back into the quiet again. It was exactly what Maggie had wanted for the two of you, a pause.
Afterwards you'd both showered, washing away the drive. The clothes Maggie had promised were already hanging neatly from the wardrobe door.
Across the room Gator was crouched beside his duffel bag, a towel slung low around his waist while he searched for something he'd inevitably packed at the bottom. The bruising across his face had faded considerably over the last couple of days, the angry colours softening into pale yellows around his cheekbone.
His body was another story. The marks still stretched across his back and ribs in deep washes of purple, blue and red, each one bleeding into the next until they looked less like bruises and more like somebody had painted them onto his skin with watercolours.
You crossed the room, your fingertips settled gently against his waist before slowly tracing upwards, careful never to press hard enough to hurt him. He stilled beneath your touch, and you leaned forward, pressing a soft kiss between his shoulder blades.
"Still sore?"
He glanced back at you over one shoulder.
"Looks worse than it is, had worse."
You knew that was probably true, it didn't stop you kissing his back once more. You wandered over to the bed instead, sitting cross-legged beside his open bag.
"We donât have to go up to the lounge, could always stay here. Maggie wonât mind."
"Anâ miss mâchance to talk to Dean Holloway? Not a chance, baby."
"I knew that'd be the selling point," you couldn't help laughing.
Leaving him to continue rummaging, you crossed towards the wardrobe where Maggie's garment bags hung waiting. The first one unzipped to reveal a beautifully tailored shirt and pair of trousers. You held them up, looking from the clothes to Gator.
"I have a feeling youâve been promoted to one of Maggieâs mannequins."
"She went tâget my stuff from dadâs,â he grinned. âClearly wasnât up tâher standards."
"Maggie went?"
"Um, yeah, she took Ford anâ Brooks. Said she didnât want me goinâ back there."
Something warm settled quietly in your chest. That sounded exactly like Maggie. She'd simply removed another problem before Gator ever had to face it.
"Good," you smiled, holding the clothes out towards him. "Well, here, might as well dress the part if youâre going to spend the night schmoozing the Dean Holloway."
He accepted the hanger with an amused shake of his head while you reached for the second garment bag. Inside hung a dress, you'd barely taken it out before smiling. It was unmistakably something Maggie had chosen; expensive and beautiful.
A little while later the two of you stood by the front door, ready to leave. You gave the lodge one last quick glance to make sure nothing had been forgotten.
"You got the key?"
"In mâpocket."
Gator looked you over once before his eyes narrowed slightly.
"Yâgonna be cold in that, whereâs yâcoat?"
"It doesnât really go with the outfit, Gator."
"Donât care, baby." He folded his arms. "Better than yâgettinâ sick. Put the coat on."
You sighed with theatrical reluctance before turning back towards the wardrobe. He only smiled as you slipped your jacket on.
The Main Lodge somehow felt even grander after dark. Warm light spilled from every window, glowing against the surrounding woodland like a beacon amongst the trees. As you and Gator climbed the broad stone steps to the entrance, the heavy timber doors were already being opened for you before either of you reached them.
Inside, everything smelled faintly of cedarwood and a fire burning somewhere deeper in the building. Before you'd even had chance to properly look around, somebody appeared beside you with a warm smile.
"May I?"
You slipped your jacket off, Gator following suit beside you, and within seconds both had disappeared somewhere behind the reception desk. Another member of staff stepped forward.
"If you'd like to follow me."
You and Gator exchanged a quick glance before following him deeper into the lodge. The building seemed to unfold one elegant room after another, all rich timber panelling, soft lighting and artwork that looked tastefully curated.
The staff member stopped outside a pair of tall double doors and opened them. The lounge itself looked like something lifted straight from the pages of an interior design magazine. Rich leather seating gathered around an enormous fireplace, polished timber floors reflected the warm amber lighting overhead. At one end of the room an elegant bar stretched the full length of the wall, bottles glowing beneath softly lit shelves.
The noise washed over you immediately. Conversation filled the room from every direction, glasses clinked together, somebody laughed loudly enough to briefly drown out everyone else. Every voice belonged to a man, except one.
Maggie.
She was perched casually on one of the bar stools. Her platinum bob caught the light every time she turned her head, the deep burgundy three-piece suit somehow making her stand out even more amongst a room full of very wealthy men. The second she saw you, she smiled and crossed the room towards you.
One by one, conversations began faltering, not stopping entirely, just... shifting. Heads turned after her almost instinctively until, by the time she'd reached you, you had the distinct feeling most of the room had quietly noticed your arrival too.
"Baby! You look beautiful!"
She kissed your cheek before stepping back to admire you properly. Then her attention moved to Gator.
"Gator, looking good. Letâs get you two something to drink."
Before either of you had chance to answer, she'd looped an arm through yours and guided you both towards the bar. Waiting behind it was a man a little older than you, sleeves rolled neatly to his forearms, already polishing a crystal tumbler. He looked up as you approached, an easy grin appearing.
"Baby, Gator, this is Billy," Maggie gestured towards the bartender.
"What can I get you both?" He asked.
"Gatorâs a whiskey man, good stuff,â Maggie answered for you. âBut youâll have to get imaginative for Baby, she doesnât do liquor."
Billy looked at you with an expression that suggested he'd already accepted the challenge. His lips curved into a cocky smile. He was unmistakeably handsome, and he clearly knew it too.
"You trust me?"
"Um, sure?" You laughed.
"I can work with that."
A few moments later he slid a tall glass towards you. The drink was bright with fresh fruit, garnished with mint and something that looked entirely too pretty to actually drink. You took a cautious sip. It was delicious. You looked back up at him, smiling despite yourself.
"Okay, I see why she hired you."
"Nah, the drinks were a bonus,â Billy laughed. âMaggie hired me for my good looks."
"Keep dreaming, Billy boy."
Billy placed a hand dramatically over his heart while Maggie only shook her head with long-suffering affection. Then she gently turned you by the shoulders until you were facing the room. Dozens of conversations continued around you, some of the faces you recognised, most you didn't. Maggie rested a hand lightly against your arm.
"So..." she said, surveying the room with the quiet confidence of somebody introducing you to her own living room. "Who do you want to meet first?"
The rest of the evening settled into exactly what Maggie had promised it would be. She guided you and Gator through the room with effortless ease, introducing you to people whose names you recognised from newspapers, television interviews and business magazines as though she were simply introducing neighbours at a barbecue. Every conversation seemed to begin the same way. Warmly. Personally. Maggie never listed achievements or titles, only what mattered about the person standing in front of you.
Warren Keating turned out to have the dry humour of somebody who had spent too many years sitting in courtrooms listening to bad excuses. Richard Vale was exactly as Maggie had described him, all polished smiles and carefully rehearsed charm. Thomas Bellamy spoke almost exclusively in numbers, while Harvey Sloan seemed determined to convince everyone in the room that being an attorney was far more interesting than it actually sounded.
Isaac Whitmore really did spend the first thirty seconds studying your face before complimenting your bone structure, Maggie had called that one perfectly.
Rafael Alvarez spoke with such genuine enthusiasm about horses that you found yourself smiling before he'd even finished introducing himself, while Omar Haddad insisted you and Gator visit him if you were ever passing through Minneapolis. Every person seemed to carry some little piece of the country with them, different accents weaving through the room until it felt less like North Dakota and more like a gathering pulled together from every corner of America.
Eventually the introductions slowed and six of you settled around one of the larger tables near the fireplace, the conversation naturally splitting into smaller groups.
Dean Holloway was every bit as broad as he looked on television, somehow making Gator seem almost average-sized sitting beside him. Celestino Vega leaned comfortably across the table, laughing as the two of them disappeared almost immediately into a conversation about football, old coaches and stories that seemed to involve increasingly questionable locker room behaviour.
You weren't entirely sure how Gator had gone from quietly sitting beside you in the Yukon that morning to happily debating defensive formations with an NFL linebacker by the evening. He looked completely at ease.
Across the table, Leon DuPont proved exactly as Maggie had warned. He could talk. His voice carried the warm, rolling cadence of French Creole, every sentence softened by an accent you could happily have listened to all evening. There was something reassuring about it, familiar even though it wasn't. Within minutes he'd somehow steered the conversation towards the clubhouse refurbishment, asking thoughtful questions about the plans you'd drawn up, the materials you'd chosen and the contractors you were using.
Unlike so many people who asked questions simply to appear interested, Leon actually listened to the answers. He threw out ideas, mentioned suppliers he'd worked with, recommended stone yards in Montana and a furniture maker in Louisiana whose work, according to Leon, was "worth eâery damn penny."
The longer the conversation continued, the more confident you became discussing it. For the first time, you found yourself talking about the project not as Maggie's granddaughter helping out, but as the person actually responsible for making it happen. It felt good.
Then the lounge doors opened. You saw Maggie notice before anybody else. It wasn't obvious, if you hadn't been looking directly at her, you might have missed it altogether, just the slightest tightening of her jaw. Gone almost as quickly as it appeared. By the time the man crossing the room reached the edge of the lounge, Maggie was already smiling as she stood to greet him.
"Marshall, glad you could make it,â she cooed. âYou hit traffic?"
"Had a last minute meeting but all dealt with."
He looked exactly how you'd imagined. Expensive suit. Expensive watch. The sort of confidence that came from spending too many years believing nobody would ever tell him no. Maggie rested a hand lightly against his arm, guiding him towards the table.
"Marshall, this is my granddaughter, Baby and her boyfriend, Gator."
His eyes barely lingered on you, instead they landed on Gator. Recognition flashed and he held out a hand.
"Tillmanâs boy. Small world."
You felt Gator hesitate for the briefest fraction of a second before taking it, the handshake lasted no longer than politeness demanded. Maggie was already steering Marshall towards the bar before another word could be exchanged.
You looked instinctively towards Gator. and he caught your eye, whatever he saw on your face made him give the smallest wink. A quiet reassurance. Everything's fine. You smiled back before turning once more to Leon, determined not to let Marshall Beaumont occupy another second of your evening than he already had. Leon watched the exchange over the rim of his whiskey before leaning slightly closer, lowering his voice just enough that it stayed between the two of you.
"You donâ wanta be catchinâ dat manâs attention, chers. Man is a gwo kochon. Donâ care âbout nobody but heself."
ă»â„ă»
You woke slowly, for the first time in what felt like weeks there was nothing waiting to drag you out of sleep. The room was warm beneath the duvet, sunlight filtering through your closed eyelids until you blinked awake. Gator was still completely asleep. One arm lay loosely across the mattress until, sensing your movement, it shifted instinctively around your waist, drawing you against him with a sleepy little sigh before he settled again. You smiled to yourself, even in his sleep he reached for you.
For another minute you simply stayed there, your cheek resting against his shoulder, listening to the steady rise and fall of his breathing. The lodge was so quiet you could hear the faint movement of water outside. When you eventually lifted your head, the view beyond the bed stole your attention all over again.
Morning light flooded through the huge windows overlooking the lake, scattering across the room in dancing reflections as the water caught the sun. The entire back wall of the lodge seemed to glow. Beyond the glass, the lake sat almost perfectly still beneath a cloudless sky, the surrounding pines mirrored so clearly in its surface they almost looked painted there.
A grin spread across your face before you could stop it. It was your birthday. Not only that, but you were waking up exactly where you wanted to be. Somewhere beautiful. Somewhere quiet. Beside the man you loved. There really wasn't much more you could ask for.
Careful not to wake Gator, you slipped quietly from beneath the duvet. The wooden floor felt cool beneath your feet as you crossed the room, reaching first for your phone on the bedside table before lifting the thick wool blanket draped across the leather armchair. You wrapped it around yourself as you slid open the glass doors, the cool morning air meeting you, fresh with the smell of pine trees and the lake below.
You settled into one of the chairs overlooking the water, tucking the blanket around your legs before unlocking your phone. Overnight it had filled with birthday messages. The family group chat was already alive with photographs and far too many emojis. Brooks had sent a simple Happy Birthday, kiddo. Ford had followed with one of himself, Nicky and Rhodes pulling ridiculous faces around the breakfast table. Hannah had written an entire paragraph telling you how much she loved you, while Megan's message was mostly demands for photographs of wherever Maggie had spirited you away to. You were halfway through replying when your phone buzzed again with a call.
Maggie.
You answered immediately.
"Happy Birthday, Baby!"
Just hearing her voice made you smile.
"Thank you, Mags."
"You just getting up?"
"Mh-hm." You looked back through the open doors towards the bed where Gator hadn't moved an inch. "Gatorâs still out but Iâm out on the deck. This place is beautiful."
"I knew youâd like it." There was the sound of voices in the background before Maggie moved somewhere quieter. "Iâm just calling to let you know what Iâm up to today. Itâs ritual masculinity day. Weâre heading out hunting, so the rest of the estate will be empty. Yours to make the best of. But I need you both dressed and ready for a special birthday dinner at seven. Until then, if you need me, call me or ask Henry at the Main Lodge."
You smiled out across the lake again; it was hard to imagine wanting to be anywhere else.
"Ok. Thank you again, for bringing us."
"Youâre welcome, baby. I hope that boy spoils you today. Love you."
"Love you too, Mags."
The call ended, leaving only the quiet sounds of the lake around you once more. You lowered your phone onto the table and moved to stand at the edge of the deck. You looked out across the water for a while, feeling the morning sun beginning to warm the blanket around your shoulders.
A moment later, familiar warmth settled around you. Gator's arms slipped comfortably around your shoulders from behind, drawing the blanket and you both against his chest as he bent to kiss the top of your head.
"Happy birthday, Baby."
You smiled, letting your head rest back against him.
"Mhm, morning. You sleep good?"
"Always do wâyou."
You turned within the circle of his arms until you were facing him properly. His hair still stood in every direction from sleep, his t-shirt only half pulled on, and despite everything that had happened over the past few days there was something softer about him this morning. Rest suited him. You reached up, brushing your fingers lightly through the hair at the back of his neck before kissing him.
His hands disappeared into your hair, holding you a little closer as he kissed you back, unhurried and still carrying the warmth of sleep. When you finally pulled apart, he rested his forehead lightly against yours.
"Breakfast is here. Maggie sent yâpancakes."
"She knows me too well," you laughed.
The tray had been left quietly inside while you'd been outside on the deck. Pancakes occupied the centre of the tray, stacked impossibly high with Happy Birthday written across the top in looping chocolate sauce. Beside them sat bowls overflowing with strawberries, blueberries and raspberries, still glistening from where they'd been washed that morning, along with fresh coffee, juice and maple syrup in little glass jugs.
It looked almost too good to eat. Almost.
The two of you sat cross-legged on the end of the bed sharing breakfast between you, stealing fruit from one another's plates and quietly watching the lake through the windows while the morning drifted by without any urgency attached to it.
Afterwards, you both changed into something more practical for the day ahead. As you laced your boots, you looked over towards Gator.
"Maggie said the whole place is ours, theyâve all gone off hunting."
He looked up from where he was pulling on his own boots, the corner of his mouth lifting knowingly.
"Yâwanna go for a walk? I know yâwanna be nosy."
You laughed because he wasn't wrong.
"Itâs so pretty here, seems a shame to waste it."
He stood, crossing the room until he was close enough to tuck a loose strand of hair behind your ear.
"Sâyour birthday, baby." He smiled. "We do whatever yâwanna do."
You and Gator wandered without much destination in mind, following whichever trail looked interesting, fingers loosely intertwined as the estate unfolded around you. Every turning seemed to reveal something new. A narrow footbridge crossing a stream that fed the lake. Another secluded cabin hidden amongst the pines. A wooden bench overlooking a meadow that looked as though nobody had sat on it in weeks.
It was impossible to feel rushed somewhere like this. The further you walked from the main lodge, the quieter everything became until the only sounds left were birdsong, the occasional breeze moving through the trees and the steady crunch of your boots over gravel.
You were halfway through pointing out a hawk circling high above the treeline when Gator's arm shot out across your chest. He stopped you so suddenly you froze.
"What--"
He didn't answer, instead he nodded towards a clearing between the trees to where a doe stood amongst the long grass, her ears twitching gently as she grazed. Beside her, still all awkward legs and oversized ears, a tiny fawn copied her every movement.
You both stayed perfectly still, even breathing felt too loud.
The pair wandered peacefully across the clearing for another minute before something cracked somewhere deeper in the woods. Both heads lifted at once. In the blink of an eye they bounded back into the trees, disappearing so quickly you almost wondered whether you'd imagined them. You let out the breath you'd been holding.
"I think that's the closest I've ever been to one."
"They're even prettier when they ain't runnin' from hunters."
By the time you found yourselves back near Tamarack, the sun sat high overhead and the lake shimmered beneath the afternoon light exactly as it had that morning, you wandered down to the shoreline. The water looked impossibly inviting. You kicked off your boots, peeled off your socks and stepped carefully onto the smooth stones at the edge before dipping your toes into the lake.
It was colder than you'd expected. Not freezing, refreshing. Behind you, Gator watched with folded arms.
"Y'crazy?"
"Itâs not that cold,â you laughed, looking back over your shoulder. âCâmon."
Before he could answer you'd already unbuttoned your jeans, stepping out of them and leaving them in a heap beside your boots.
"Baby, whatcha doin'?"
"Going in. You coming or are you too chicken?" You grinned.
His expression suggested he was rapidly questioning every decision that had brought him to this exact moment. Meanwhile you were already wading further into the lake.
The water climbed slowly from your ankles to your knees, then your thighs, cool enough to steal your breath for a second before your body adjusted. You pulled your sweater over your head, tossing it back towards the shore, Gator caught it automatically.
A second later you carried on until the water reached your waist, the lake wrapping around you in gentle ripples. Behind you came a long, theatrical sigh. You glanced back just in time to see him giving in. Piece by piece he discarded his clothes until he was left in nothing but his boxers before cautiously following you into the lake.
You smiled to yourself and deliberately faced forwards again. The water climbed to your shoulders as you wandered further out.
You'd barely taken another step before two familiar arms wrapped around you from behind. Gator turned you effortlessly to face him before lifting you out of the water. Your legs found his waist automatically as he carried you another step deeper until the lake reached his shoulders instead.
"Yâhappy now? Soakinâ wet in a cold lake."
You laughed, looping your arms around his neck.
"Happy now youâre in it with me."
You kissed him softly. When you pulled back, the world around you felt impossibly still.
"I donât think Iâve ever heard quiet like this."
He looked out across the lake before back at you.
"Sânice."
For a while you both enjoyed the silence, simply floating there together while tiny ripples spread lazily across the water around you. Eventually you leaned backwards, trusting him completely. His hand slid beneath your back, supporting you as your hair drifted into the cool water behind. Sunlight danced across the surface above your face while the ends of your hair spread weightlessly around you. Gator kept one steady hand beneath you the entire time before leaning forwards, pressing a gentle kiss against your stomach that made you laugh quietly. He pulled you upright again and you settled back against him; arms wrapped comfortably around his shoulders.
"You have a good time with Mr. NFL last night?"
"Gotta stop callinâ him that,â he snorted. âDean Holloway is a legend. Who was you talkinâ to?"
"Leon DuPont. He owns a few bars with Maggie, but he also owns casinos, hotels, bars. Designs them all himself. He was asking me about the clubhouse refurb."
Gator nodded thoughtfully.
"Maggie knows a lotta important men."
"I think she does it on purpose." You glanced back towards the direction of the main lodge, hidden somewhere beyond the trees. "Like, look at this place. Maggie doesnât care about hunting and compare the lounge last night to the Gilded Lily. This place is designed specifically to feel like a boys club, she makes them feel at ease, thatâs why she was all fake last night to Marshall."
"Keep yâfriends close anâ yâenemies closer."
"Exactly."
He chuckled, shaking his head.
"Tellinâ ya, I ainât ever met no one as smart as your grandma."
"Donât let her catch you calling her grandma, sheâll mount your head above the fireplace in the dining room."
That earned a proper laugh. He buried his face into the crook of your neck for a second, his shoulders still shaking with it before finally pulling back. His eyes drifted out across the lake, following the tiny ripples spreading away from you.
"Y'remember that storm?" he asked quietly.
"What storm?"
"Must've been... yâsenior year," He frowned to himself. "Hot as hell fâweeks. Nobody wanted t'do nothin'. Madison was pregnant with Rhodes."
You smiled immediately.
"She was miserable."
"Thought she was gonna kill somebody." He chuckled. "Then that rain finally came in, soon as it started she got everybody outside. Didn't give nobody a choice."
You could almost see it again. Thick summer rain falling so hard it bounced off the lawn. The relief of cool air after weeks of relentless heat. Gator smiled to himself.
"Madison decides she's gonna lay in the grass, but she canât get up âcause she was huge.â
âSheâd have killed you for saying that,â you laugh.
âShe was huge!â He was smiling wider now. âSheâs hollerinâ for somebody tâhelp her, so you run over, made it âbout two steps before yâfeet went straight out from under ya.â
âI forgot about that,â you chuckled.
"Y'ended up lyin' there beside her instead. Neither of ya could get up." He let out a quiet laugh. "Madison's laughin' so hard she's cryin'. You're laughin' so hard you ain't even tryin' t'help anymore."
He fell quiet for a beat.
"...Think I stood there fâgood five minutes jusâ listenin'."
"To what?" You looked at him.
He shrugged, like the answer should've been obvious.
"You."
The lake went silent again, Gator looked back out across the water.
"Prettiest girl I ever seen." A small smile tugged at the corner of his mouth. "Best sound I ever heard."
Heat bloomed in your chest. He said it so simply, like he wasn't confessing anything at all. Just remembering. Before you could think of a reply, he leaned forward and pressed a quick kiss against your forehead.
"C'mon," he murmured. "We better get y'dry before y'catch a shiver."
Before you had chance to argue, he carried you back towards the shore. He set you carefully on a warm sunlit rock before collecting the scattered pile of clothes, handing you your sweater first so you could pull it over your damp skin. Then, with the rest of the clothes bundled beneath one arm and still dripping in his boxers, he suddenly scooped you up again. Only this time you found yourself unceremoniously slung over his shoulder.
"Gator!"
You squealed, laughing helplessly as he started back towards the lodge, entirely unbothered by your half-hearted protests and every attempt you made to wriggle free until the front steps finally appeared beneath his feet.
He lowered you to dig the keycard from the crumpled pocket of his discarded jeans, still bundled beneath one arm with the rest of your clothes. The front door clicked open and, before you knew it, you were both back inside with the warmth of the lodge wrapping around you again.
The chill from the lake settled in surprisingly quickly. You wandered straight through to the bathroom, turning on the taps for the enormous freestanding tub to fill. Steam gradually curled across the room, fogging the mirrors.
The hot water chased the last of the cold from your skin as you settled back between Gator's knees, resting comfortably against his chest while he gently worked shampoo through your hair. You closed your eyes again, letting yourself melt against him while he rinsed the shampoo away.
Neither of you paid much attention to the time. Eventually the water cooled enough that neither of you could pretend not to notice anymore. Reluctantly, you climbed out first, wrapping yourself in one of the enormous white towels waiting on the heated rail before wandering barefoot back into the bedroom. You flopped dramatically across the end of the bed, still cocooned in the towel while your damp hair spread across the duvet beneath you. Gator leaned down, stealing an easy kiss before smiling against your lips.
"Yâwant yâpresent now or later?"
You looked up at him, your entire face lighting up.
"Now, obviously?"
He laughed quietly to himself before rubbing the back of his neck with one hand, suddenly looking oddly uncertain. Crossing to his duffel bag, he crouched down and rummaged around inside before pulling out a neatly wrapped package. He carried it back over, holding it out towards you.
"I ainât good at presents, so yâainât allowed tâjudge me. Anâ it definitely ainât no competition fâMaggieâs expensive watch. Shoulda given you it before her."
Instead of opening it, you carefully placed the present on the bed beside you. Then you climbed onto your knees and reached for him instead. He stepped closer and you slid your hands around his waist, drawing him in until you could press a gentle kiss against his lips.
"You didnât have to get me anything. And I donât care about expensive." You smiled up at him. "Itâs from you, thatâs what matters."
You kissed him once more, lingering there for just a second before finally settling back onto the bed. You smiled to yourself as you carefully peeled back the wrapping paper, deliberately taking your time now you'd seen how nervous he'd suddenly become. Gator had never been good at hiding when he cared about something. While you focused on the paper, he quietly wandered back over to his bag, rummaging around for something else before returning to stand beside the bed.
You only glanced up briefly; he was holding a pair of wired headphones. Your brow furrowed for a moment, but before you had chance to ask, your attention was drawn back to the gift itself.
Inside the wrapping sat a smart little box. You lifted the lid and nestled against the dark lining was a fine gold chain with a heart-shaped pendant resting neatly in the centre. It was beautiful, simple and elegant. Entirely unlike the sort of jewellery you imagined Gator picking out on his own.
You looked up to thank him, but he was already stepping closer. Without saying anything, he gently settled the headphones into your ears before reaching for the necklace in your lap. Your eyes followed his hands as he turned the pendant over, sliding open a tiny panel on the back that you hadn't even noticed was there. A small port was hidden beneath it. He plugged the wire into the pendant, then rested his thumb lightly against the front.
A heartbeat filled your ears. For a second you simply stared at him, then he reached back into the box and handed you a tightly rolled sheet of paper. You uncurled it across your lap. It took your brain a moment to recognise what you were looking at, an EKG. But not just one trace, two. A red line moved unevenly across the page, every beat a little unpredictable, while beneath it a black line travelled with quiet consistency, each rhythm measured, steady and sure. Gator reached over and eased one of the earbuds away from your ear.
"Red line is you, from the hospital. Black line is me, know an EMT owed me a favour. One in your ears is me." He rubbed awkwardly at the back of his neck, his eyes dropping somewhere towards the floor. "Somethinâ Logan told me, âbout how you listen tâmy heartbeat when yâlayin on me, try tâmatch it. Now yâalways got it with ya."
You looked back down at the page. Slowly, your fingertip traced the black line as it travelled across the paper. You remembered every one of those nights. The nights when sleep refused to come because your own heartbeat seemed too loud inside your ears. When every missed beat or flutter became impossible to ignore until anxiety took hold and all you could hear was your own chest betraying you. Those were the times you found yourself curled against Gator, your head resting over his heart, listening to the slow certainty beneath his ribs until your breathing matched his and your own heart gradually stopped feeling like something to be frightened of.
Somewhere between Logan mentioning it in passing and today, he'd quietly gone away and found someone willing to help him. He'd called in a favour. He'd thought about it long enough to turn one of your greatest fears into something you could wear around your neck.
The necklace wasn't the gift, the heartbeat was. The thought behind it was.
Your vision blurred before you even realised tears had started falling. One landed softly against the EKG paper. You folded it carefully before placing it back inside the box, protecting it almost instinctively. Then you pushed yourself up from the bed and closed the space between you in two quick steps, your arms wrapping tightly around his neck.
"Itâs perfect. I love it. I love you."
The words came out through tears you made no attempt to hide. You kissed him before he could answer. His hands found your face, gentle as always, his thumbs brushing beneath your eyes to catch the tears while he kissed you back with the same quiet tenderness he'd poured into the gift itself.
Somewhere beneath it all, through the single headphone still resting against your ear, his heartbeat carried on.
Slow.
Steady.
Constant.
And, just as he'd promised, no matter where you were now, you could always find your way back to it.
ă»â„ă»
By the time the two of you reached the Main Lodge again, the last of the daylight had disappeared behind the trees. Music drifted faintly through the open entrance as the doors opened.
You glanced sideways at Gator as you walked. Maggie had struck again. He'd somehow ended up in another perfectly fitted shirt and tailored trousers that made him look as though he'd belonged at weekends like this his entire life. His shoulders seemed even broader beneath the crisp fabric, his hair still slightly damp.
He looked ridiculously handsome. The sort of handsome that made people stare. But as much as you appreciated the view, you realised your favourite version of Gator would probably always be the one waiting for you at home in worn cargo trousers and one of those tight t-shirts that clung to his shoulders after a day spent working. Grease beneath his fingernails. Hair a mess. Looking entirely unaware of the effect he had on you.
That was your Gator.
He just happened to clean up exceptionally well. His fingers tightened gently around yours as you climbed the front steps together. Henry was waiting in the lobby, the moment he spotted you, his face broke into a warm smile.
"Happy birthday, Miss Heaton! The rest of the guests are gathering in the dining room, right this way."
"Thank you."
He led the pair of you through the lodge to an elegant dining room where a single long table stretched almost the entire length of the space, candles flickering gently between towering floral arrangements while glasses and polished silver caught the light overhead.
Heads turned towards the doorway as you entered. Before you had chance to feel remotely self-conscious, Maggie was already on her feet.
"Thereâs my birthday girl!" She crossed the room without hesitation, wrapping you in a hug before you'd even reached the table. "How was your day?"
"Yeah we took a walk, went for a swim in the lake, it was nice.â You smiled. âHow about you, have fun playing hunter?"
Maggie laughed.
"Absolutely, I outshoot every one of these old timers."
Several of the men around the table protested through amused laughter, earning nothing more than an entirely unapologetic grin from Maggie. She slipped an arm around your shoulders as she guided you and Gator towards your places at the table, the conversation quickly beginning to swell back to life around you once more.
Dinner unfolded, nobody seemed in a hurry to finish one course before the next arrived. Conversation drifted easily around the table, splitting and reforming as bottles of wine were passed from one end to the other and stories became steadily louder with each passing hour. Leon was halfway through recounting an impossible tale involving a poker game in New Orleans that nobody around the table seemed entirely convinced had happened, while Dean and Gator had somehow picked up exactly where they'd left off the previous evening, now debating college football with the same enthusiasm they'd shown for the NFL.
At the head of the table, Maggie floated effortlessly between every conversation at once. She had an odd gift for making everyone in the room feel as though they'd had the most interesting discussion of the evening.
The food itself deserved every bit of the praise Maggie had given it. Each course arrived looking almost too beautiful to disturb; but somehow tasted even better than it looked. You found yourself slowing down simply to make it last a little longer, while every now and then Mario appeared quietly from the kitchen to check on the room before disappearing again with the quiet pride of somebody who genuinely loved feeding people.
By the time plates were finally cleared away, you were comfortably full. Then the dining room doors opened again, and Mario emerged carrying an enormous cake. It was spectacular. Layers of marble sponge towered above the cake stand, iced simply in cream with Baby written neatly across the front in looping script. Delicate curls of white and milk chocolate climbed one side like ribbons, catching the candlelight as he carried it carefully towards the table.
A single sparkler candle protruded from the very top. You couldn't stop smiling, Mario set the cake carefully in front of you before lighting the sparkler properly. Almost immediately, the room broke into song. Happy Birthday echoed around the dining room, a collection of voices in different accents somehow finding the same tune. You laughed, feeling your face grow steadily warmer as every eye settled on you.
Halfway through the song your gaze wandered unintentionally down the length of the table. Marshall Beaumont was watching you. He was singing along with everyone else. Smiling. But there was something about it that made something inside you tighten. It didn't reach his eyes. It felt rehearsed somehow, performative in a way that instantly made your skin prickle.
You looked away instantly.
Maggie was smiling at you from across the table, Gator's shoulder rested comfortably against yours, Leon was singing far louder than anybody else. When the final line came to an end, you leaned forwards and blew out the sparkler. The room erupted into applause. Mario looked almost as pleased as you felt, you leant across the table towards him.
"Thank you so much. Everything was incredible."
He smiled warmly, dipping his head in quiet acknowledgement before disappearing back towards the kitchens to leave the guests to enjoy the cake. The evening lingered long after dinner had officially finished. Coffee replaced wine for some. Whiskey appeared for others. Chairs scraped gently across polished floors as conversations continued in little clusters around the room until, eventually, Maggie rose from her seat.
Almost instinctively everyone else began doing the same. With the easy confidence of somebody who had hosted this same gathering many times before, she shepherded the party from the dining room, laughter and half-finished conversations spilling out into the hallway before continuing through towards the South Lounge.
The South Lounge felt completely different to the East. Where the previous evening had centred around the bar, this room invited people to settle in for the rest of the night. The entire back wall was nothing but glass, looking out across the South Waterfront where the lake reflected the moonlight in long silver ribbons. A fire crackled somewhere behind you, taking the chill from the room, while pools of warm lamplight gathered around deep leather sofas and low tables that encouraged people to sit close and stay awhile.
Off to one side stood a grand piano. On the other, a poker table had been assembled for the weekend. It didn't belong to the room in the same way everything else did. It had the temporary feel of something brought in especially for this gathering, already stacked neatly with cards and heavy clay chips waiting for whoever eventually wandered over.
Maggie disappeared towards the bar, Billy already waiting behind it with the sort of grin that suggested he knew exactly what everyone would be drinking before they asked.
Across the room, Dean Holloway had somehow reclaimed Gator before either of you had made it halfway inside. The two of them dropped easily into one of the sofa areas, already deep in another conversation that looked as though it had simply resumed after dinner rather than ever ending. Every now and then Dean laughed loudly enough to turn heads, Gator shaking his own with a grin that reached all the way to his eyes.
You couldn't help smiling. You'd worried, before coming here, that he'd spend the entire weekend politely enduring conversations he didn't care about simply because Maggie had invited him. Instead, he looked comfortable and interested, like he'd genuinely found people he enjoyed talking to. That alone made the weekend worth it. You were still watching him when a familiar voice drifted up behind you.
"Donât just stand there letting the dust settle on your shoes, birthdays mean you get to make a little noise."
You turned to find Celestino smiling warmly at you. Before you had chance to answer, he'd already gently steered you towards the piano. He settled onto the bench, leaving just enough room for you beside him before lowering one finger onto a single key. The note rolled slowly through the lounge; deep and rich. It lingered in the room long after he'd lifted his hand away.
âYou play?â he asked.
You shook your head.
"The piano is a whole world." His left hand settled over the lower keys. "The left hand⊠thatâs the earth. Thatâs the road you gotta walk on."
He played again. This time a heavy bass rhythm rolled from the piano, slow and deliberate, each note settling comfortably against the one before it.
"Hear that? Thatâs the ground right there. Holds you steady when everything else is shaking."
His left hand never stopped moving, keeping the rhythm alive beneath everything else while he nodded towards the higher end of the keys.
"Now, Iâm gonna hold down the road, but I need you to give us a little sky. See the black key, the middle one in the cluster of three?"
You nodded, suddenly very aware of how little you actually knew about playing the piano. Your fingers hovered uncertainly above the keys.
"Donât be shy with it. Thatâs the blue note. Thatâs where the rain lives and where the sun comes out. When I hit the change, I want you to lean your finger into it. Let it cry a little."
The bass line shifted and something inside the rhythm opened, a space appeared that hadn't been there before.
"Right now. Give it to me, sugar."
You pressed the key and the note cut cleanly through the bass beneath it, melancholy and bright all at once. Celestino laughed softly.
"Just like that, get the taste for it. But a bird canât fly with just one wing, we gotta give that note some company."
He kept the rhythm rolling beneath your single note. His right hand hovered above yours, never quite touching.
"See these two ivories, tucked under your thumb, just there? Theyâre waiting on you, slide on down to âem. Walk it down real slow, like youâre stepping off a porch step in a hot summer, nice and slow."
Again the bass shifted beneath you as he left you space.
"Go on now, walk it out. Talk back to me."
You pressed the black key once more before letting your fingers drift onto the two white notes he'd shown you. It wasn't perfect, you knew it wasn't, but somehow it didn't matter. The notes found each other anyway, your hesitant little melody weaving naturally through the steady rhythm beneath it. Celestino closed his eyes. A soft hum escaped somewhere deep in his chest. Before long the humming stretched itself into words.
"The stars up in the heavensâŠ"
He smiled without opening his eyes.
"They donât shine half as bright as youâŠ"
Another chord changed beneath your hands, you found the notes almost instinctively this time, walking the pattern he showed you. Celestino bumped your shoulder with his own.
"Yeah, the stars up in the heavens⊠they donât shine half as bright as you. You got a smile so sweet, Baby, make a bluesman forget heâs blue."
The final notes drifted gently away into the room. For a second neither of you moved. Then Celestino threw back his head and laughed, the sound warm enough that several people around the lounge smiled without even knowing why. He gave your shoulder an affectionate pat.
"MM-hmm, you got the blues in you, Baby."
By the time you looked up again, Maggie had appeared beside the piano carrying two fresh drinks. She handed one to you and the other to Celestino.
"Where you been hiding this pretty girl, Miss Maggie?"
Maggie's smile softened as she looked between the pair of you.
"Gonna revive that career to write songs about my Baby?"
Celestino let out another easy laugh.
"Oh, sheâd be quite the muse." His eyes settled on you with a mischievous smile. "Itâs all in the eyes, looks like a heartbreaker to me."
The evening settled into an easy rhythm after that, the sort that only seemed to happen when everyone in the room knew one another well enough that conversation never had to be forced. People drifted naturally between the bar and the sofas, old stories resurfacing between fresh rounds of drinks while the poker table gradually became the centre of attention.
Maggie sat at one end, Marshall Beaumont occupied the seat opposite, Vincent Moretti lounged comfortably to one side with an ever-growing stack of chips in front of him, while Thomas Bellamy and Lionel Baptiste completed the table. They looked as though they'd been playing together for years, cards moving confidently between their hands, conversations continuing uninterrupted beneath the game itself. Maggie caught your eye and beckoned you over.
"You wanna see how I win our shopping money?"
You smiled, wandering over to stand beside her chair. Marshall looked up then, finally taking his attention away from his cards.
"Oh so this is the little lady whose wardrobe Iâm funding?"
The smile on your face disappeared almost as quickly as it had arrived. It wasn't what he'd said, it was the way he looked at you while he said it. His eyes travelled over you with an ease that made your skin tighten instinctively. It wasn't admiration. It wasn't even curiosity. It felt more like appraisal, as though he were looking at something that could be bought if he decided he wanted it.
Without thinking, you shifted a little closer to Maggie and she noticed.
"Please, you donât bet enough to keep my Baby dressed up." She gathered her cards without so much as glancing at Marshall. "Keep your eyes on your cards, Marshall."
The table laughed and Marshall did too, but something in the room had shifted all the same. It was only then that you noticed Jack. He stood several feet behind Maggie, almost blending into the edge of the room, his attention seemingly nowhere in particular. You hadn't seen him since he'd driven everyone up to The Briar the afternoon before and, truthfully, you hadn't even thought about where he'd disappeared to. Now you realised that had probably been the point.
He was simply watching, always close enough that Maggie never had to wonder where he was. You settled beside Maggie's chair, watching over her shoulder while she quietly explained what she was doing. Poker, according to Maggie, wasn't really about the cards at all. It was about people. Who played cautiously after a win. Who bluffed too often. Who always reached for their drink when they were nervous. Before each hand was revealed she'd quietly lean towards you, gesturing almost imperceptibly at another player before whispering what she thought they were holding. Every time the cards turned over, she was right.
By the time she'd collected another comfortable pile of chips, Billy appeared beside the table carrying a fresh tray of drinks. Without looking up from her hand, Maggie accepted a fresh whiskey.
"There should be a crate of cigars in the back office. Have Henry bring them in."
"Sure thing, Iâll call through."
Billy disappeared back towards the bar while Vincent smiled across the table.
"Hope youâre blessing us with your Cubans, cara?"
"Wouldnât waste your time with anything else, Vincent. You ask me nicely and I may have even come through on that other thing you were after."
"You have always been good with the impossible, Maggie." Vincent laughed into his glass.
The conversation moved on as another hand began, but the phrase stayed with you. The other thing. You leaned down slightly, keeping your voice low enough that only Maggie could hear.
"The other thing?"
She never took her eyes off her cards, instead she nodded ever so slightly towards Vincent's wrist.
"Vincent has a proclivity for the finer things in life. Not all of them are easy to get hold of, and not all of them can be legally imported. See his watch?"
You glanced across discreetly, the gold watch looked expensive enough to make you nervous simply looking at it.
"One of a kind. Watch face is crafted with Hawksbill turtle shell. Illegally hunted, endangered. $140,000, of which I took twenty percent as an import charge."
You looked back at her, trying to keep your surprise from showing.
"So, this is one of the⊠other things."
"I donât mess with drugs or people. Iâm not interested in that. But goods, sure. Vincent wants himself some crocodile leather shoes or a box of Cuban cigars and Iâm who he asks."
The conversation settled quietly in the back of your mind while another hand unfolded around the table. You found yourself looking differently at the room. At the watches catching the firelight whenever somebody reached for a drink. At cufflinks that probably cost more than most cars. At handmade shoes and tailored jackets and the effortless wealth sitting around every corner of the lounge.
These weren't simply influential men. They were customers, maybe not all of them. But enough. People came to Maggie because she knew how to find the things other people couldn't. You realised then that you probably still only understood half of what your grandmother actually did for a living. Just when you thought you'd finally worked her out, another layer quietly revealed itself.
After another hand was dealt, you bent to kiss the top of Maggie's head. She reached up without looking away from her cards, her fingers finding yours for the briefest moment before giving your hand a gentle squeeze. Then she returned to the game, already calculating her next move while you slipped quietly away from the table to find Gator again.
You found him exactly where you'd expected him to be. Dean had claimed one of the leather sofas nearest the fire and Gator was stretched comfortably beside him, one ankle resting across his opposite knee, a whiskey balanced loosely in one hand while the two of them continued a conversation that, from the animated gestures alone, had clearly never strayed far from football.
Neither of them noticed you straight away. Dean was halfway through demonstrating something with his hands while Gator nodded along, occasionally interrupting with a grin that told you he was enjoying himself far more than he'd ever admit.
You wandered over quietly and perched yourself on the arm of the sofa beside him. Almost immediately, without interrupting whatever Dean was saying, Gator's arm found its way around your back, his hand settling comfortably against your waist as though it had always belonged there. Only then did Dean look up.
"How you doing, birthday girl?"
"Iâm good, sorry, didnât mean to interrupt."
"Not at all, just boring your man to death with stories."
"Well, I know that isnât true,â you laughed. âGator can talk football for hours; I usually tune it out."
Dean clutched dramatically at his chest.
"Youâre breaking my heart, you not a fan?"
"Oh, I know when to cheer. Not being a fan in my house, not an option, itâs in our blood. Have two younger cousins who live and breathe the game."
A broad smile spread across Dean's face.
"Ah, your boy here has already shown me some footage of them. Helluva pair. And for kidâs their age? Ainât seen no one else like âem."
You felt Gator glance up at you, there was an unmistakable look of satisfaction on his face.
"Gonna need yâto be witness when I tell âem he said that."
"I don't think they'll ever let you forget it," you laughed.
The conversation lingered for another minute before movement around the room gradually drew everyone's attention elsewhere. Billy appeared from the hallway carrying a large wooden crate beneath one arm. The moment the lid came off, the rich smell of cigars drifted across the lounge.
Like clockwork, several of the older men abandoned their seats almost simultaneously, making their way towards the bar to replenish drinks and help themselves. Dean was no exception. He pushed himself to his feet with a good-natured groan, clapping Gator once on the shoulder before wandering off after the others.
Within moments the two of you were alone again, tucked together on the sofa while the rest of the room slowly gathered around the fire and the cigars Maggie had quietly produced from somewhere, just as she always seemed to produce exactly what people wanted before they'd even thought to ask for it.
The smoke had started hanging thick enough in the lounge that Gator found himself watching it. Every curl that drifted towards the ceiling had brought his thoughts back to you. To your heart. To monitors in hospitals. To every little thing that could so easily become something bigger. Enough was enough for one night.
"Yâwanna get outta here?"
"Thought youâd never ask," you smiled.
He laced his fingers through yours and, on the way out, paused only long enough beside Maggie to quietly let her know the pair of you were heading back to Tamarack. She smiled, squeezed his arm in understanding and waved you both on without another question.
Now, with the lodge behind you, he found himself paying less attention to the path than he probably should have. The little lights lining the walkway cast a warm glow across your dress as you walked beside him, catching on the gold of Maggie's watch every time your hand swung between you. The necklace he'd given you rested against your collarbone, glinting softly beneath the lights.
He couldn't stop looking at you. It wasn't the dress or the jewellery. It was you. His attention lingered a fraction too long. The toe of his shoe clipped the edge of the path, and he stumbled just enough to have to catch himself. Your laugh rang out through the trees.
"Stop staring at me and look where youâre going!"
"Canât help it, yâlook too good," he grinned, completely unashamed.
Still smiling, he led you the last few yards to Tamarack. The lodge sat quietly amongst the trees exactly as you'd left it, warm light spilling through the windows onto the deck overlooking the lake. He finally let go of your hand just long enough to fish the keycard from his pocket before tapping it against the lock.
The door clicked shut behind you, the quiet settling around the two of you. The sounds of the lodge, the laughter from the South Lounge, the rest of the world, it all disappeared the second you were alone.
Gator didn't take his eyes off you. There was something about the way he looked at you that had always undone you. It was never simply appreciation. It wasn't vanity or possession or anything so shallow. He looked at you as though he'd reached the end of a long journey and somehow still couldn't quite believe he'd been allowed to stay.
It made every insecurity fall silent. You could spend hours wondering whether your dress was right or your hair sat properly or whether anybody else in the room liked you, but none of it seemed to matter when he looked at you like that.
As though you hung the moon.
The distance between you disappeared almost of its own accord. His hand found the small of your back, stepping into you until your shoulders met the wall beside the door. His mouth found yours in a kiss that still carried the warmth of the whiskey heâd drank and the quiet happiness of the evening, one hand settling against your waist while the other brushed carefully through your hair.
When he finally pulled back, only far enough for both of you to breathe, you smiled, your nose brushing softly against his. Something had been circling your thoughts all evening. You weren't entirely sure how he'd respond, but you knew if you didn't say it now, you'd probably never find the courage again.
"I want you to do something for me."
His forehead rested lightly against yours.
"Anythinâ. What dâyou need Baby?"
You kissed him once, softly. Your fingertips traced slowly along the line of his jaw before you looked back into his eyes, you swallowed.
"Donât be gentle with me."
For the briefest moment, everything stilled. You watched the change pass across his face almost imperceptibly, something deeper settling behind his eyes as he searched yours, making certain he understood what you were asking and that you wanted him there with you.
Gator kisses you like a man starved; hungry, deep, like heâs been waiting forever just to have you this close, and you give it right back, just as eager. He can feel your fists tightening in the front of his shirt, knuckles white, as if youâre trying to pull him even closer, as if thereâs any space left between you to close. But he has to be sure; he has to know this is what you want, not just something you think he expects. He canât go further unless he knows itâs your choice, fully and freely.
He breaks the kiss slowly, resting his forehead heavy against yours, his dark eyes searching yours for any trace of doubt.
âYâsure?â
You nod firmly against him, no hesitation at all.
âIâm not going to break. I want you to fuck me.â
Before Gator can even fully process the words, before his brain can catch up to what you just said, youâre pulling him right back into another deep, searing kiss, your tongue sliding boldly into his mouth. If there was a single rational thought left in his head, it vanishes instantly, every drop of blood in his body rushing straight down to his cock, making it throb hard and heavy.
He tugs his shirt free from where itâs tucked into his waistband, fumbling with the buttons one after another as fast as he can, still kissing you all the while, before shrugging it off his shoulders and letting it fall to the floor. Then his hands move to the thin silk straps of your dress, sliding them slowly down over your shoulders, and his cock twitches at the soft, breathy little gasp that slips past your lips. The fabric slips further down your arms, revealing youâre not wearing a bra, and continues gliding over your hips until it pools in a soft heap at your feet, leaving you standing before him in nothing but a tiny, barely-there thong.
Gator smirks, taking a slow step back just to look his fill, drinking in every inch of you.
âThis sâgonna be fun.â
Then he closes the distance again in one quick move, wrapping one strong arm tight around your waist to pull you flush against him, never breaking the kiss as he starts walking you backward through the room, toward the tall floor-to-ceiling windows that look out over the quiet lake beyond.
You stumble a little, balancing precariously on your heels and moving backward, but Gatorâs hold on you is solid and unwavering, keeping you steady even as his lips stay locked to yours. You come to a sudden stop when your back meets the cold, smooth surface of the glass, but right as it happens, Gator lifts one hand to cushion the back of your head, making sure you donât knock it hard against the pane.
His kisses shift, moving from your mouth to your jaw, then trailing down the side of your neck; hot, wet, a mix of soft, open-mouthed kisses and small, sharp sucking nips that make your skin prickle and heat rise under your flesh. He travels lower still, across your collarbone, and then takes one of your nipples into his mouth, swirling his tongue around it before sucking gently. You react instantly, your hands flying up to tangle in his hair and hold him there.
Gator lets out a low growl against your skin, then pulls back just enough to grab both your wrists in one firm grip, pinning them high above your head against the glass. He holds your gaze steady, eyes dark and intense.
âStay.â
Your breath catches in your throat, heart hammering faster, but you nod, and he drops his head again to take your other nipple into his mouth, this time giving it a playful, light little bite that makes your hips buck forward and a loud moan spill from your lips.
âMhm⊠GatorâŠâ
He just smirks against your skin and keeps moving lower, his lips tracing a path down over your stomach, and even as he kisses his way down, his eyes stay locked on yours. You keep your hands raised as he told you, but tilt your head to look down at him, and the sight makes your knees weak; his amber eyes looking up at you, burning with want, framed by dark hair.
He kneels in front of you, making quick work of your heels, sliding them off one by one and tossing them carelessly behind him. You think briefly that he probably wouldnât have been so rough if he knew just how expensive those shoes were, but the thought vanishes the second his lips return to your hip bone, trailing kisses there. Then his tongue darts out, sliding under the thin fabric of your thong, and he catches the elastic between his teeth, pulling it down slowly until it slips past your thighs and knees. He helps you step out of it, then lifts your left leg and rests it over his shoulder, opening you wider for him and without any warning, he buries his face right between your legs.
His nose brushes firm against your clit while his tongue makes one long, deep stroke through your wet folds, and you arch your back off the glass, letting out a soft, shaking moan. But Gatorâs hands come up to grip your hips, holding you still and pressed tight against him with enough strength that you know thereâs no squirming away. His tongue dives deep into your entrance, and you gasp, fingers twitching where theyâre still stretched above you.
âFuck⊠GatorâŠâ
His fingers flex harder against your skin, and he starts eating you out like heâs starving, fucking you with his tongue, swirling it deep inside while his nose keeps rubbing that sensitive little bundle of nerves over and over. This time, when your hands come down to tangle in his hair and hold him right where you want him, he doesnât stop you at all. He seems perfectly content to stay buried between your legs, not coming up for air, just working you harder and deeper until your thighs are shaking, your back arched, and you come apart with his name falling from your lips like a prayer.
Gator lifts your trembling thigh gently off his shoulder and sets it back down on the floor, then stands up, wiping his mouth with the back of his hand as he rises. He spins you around smoothly, pressing your front flat against the cool glass, and grabs your wrists again, guiding them to rest spread wide against the window. He leans in close, his lips brushing right against your ear.
âBe a shame tâwaste the view.â
He rests his chin against your shoulder, one hand sliding up to curl around the back of your neck to keep you still and steady, while the other trails slowly down your spine, making you shiver at the light, tickling touch. He smirks to himself, he loves how responsive you are, how every little movement of his hands affects you so clearly, and he knows none of it is for show; itâs all real, all for him. His hand travels lower, grabbing a firm handful of your ass before giving it a sharp, playful smack that makes you gasp and push back against him. He watches your breath fog up the glass in front of you, tracing the pattern with his eyes.
He licks a slow line up the side of your neck, then catches your earlobe between his teeth and tugs gently. He uses his foot to nudge your ankle apart just a little, and smirks wider when you instantly spread your legs for him, opening yourself up without him even having to ask.
He reaches around from behind, his fingers finding your entrance easily, already slick and warm and ready, and pushes two thick fingers inside you in one smooth motion, just resting them there for a moment, letting you feel the stretch. His voice rumbles low and rough right against your ear.
âGivinâ ya one last chance tâback out, baby.â
You shake your head fast, almost frantic, pushing your hips back against his hand.
âNo⊠Want it⊠Want youâŠâ
He lets out a quiet, satisfied chuckle. Well, if thatâs what his girl is asking for⊠He nips at the soft skin just below your ear again, his voice dropping to a growl.
âAlright then⊠yâasked for it.â
Then without warning, Gator starts to plunge his fingers into you at speed; fast, deep, relentless, each stroke driving right into that sensitive spot inside. The sound of your wetness is loud and obscene, filling the quiet room, and you can feel yourself dripping down around his digits, slick and hot.
âOh, fuckâŠ.â you gasp, your fingers scrabbling uselessly against the cold glass, only sliding across the smooth surface instead of finding purchase.
His hand on the back of your neck tightens just enough, pushing you gently but firmly forward until your forehead rests flat against the pane, your breath fogging a patch of clear glass in front of your face. He doesnât let up, his fingers moving in a steady, punishing rhythm, and you can already feel the heat coiling tight and fast in your belly, your next orgasm building quicker than the last. Your walls clench hard around his fingers, squeezing him.
âYâgonna cum fâme?â he growls behind you, his voice rough and thick. âYâhear how fuckinâ wet you are fâme?â
You canât answer even if you wanted to, your breath is coming in short, shallow bursts, your knees already trembling, and then the wave crashes over you, sharp and overwhelming. Your whole body tenses and shakes, your back arching as you come apart, your vision blurring for a second.
Gator slows his fingers but doesnât pull them out, keeping them buried deep and moving in slow, shallow strokes to ride you through every last aftershock.
âFuck⊠Gator⊠fuck⊠IâŠâ you try to speak, but your mind is too fuzzy, your words breaking off into a soft moan.
He chuckles low and warm, the sound vibrating through your body. His hand leaves the back of your neck, but he keeps his fingers moving inside you; slow, deep, dragging against every sensitive nerve, while you stay pressed against the glass. You hear the rustle of fabric, the distinct clink of metal, the slide of a zipper as he starts to undress. Then, without warning, he pulls his fingers all the way out, leaving you empty and aching so suddenly you let out a small, desperate whimper.
âNhmm⊠pleaseâŠâ you beg, pushing your hips back instinctively.
âDonât worry, baby,â he murmurs, right against your ear. âAinât done with ya yet.â
His arm slides around your waist, and you feel the cool, hard leather of his belt press against your stomach. Thereâs a soft clinking sound as he works the buckle, then a sharp tug as he pulls it tight, cinching it firmly around your middle. With his free hand, he guides you to step back until your body is pressed flush against his chest. Then he brings his palm down hard against your ass, making you jolt and whimper.
âHands back on the glass, baby,â he orders, voice low and commanding. âBend over fâme.â
You obey instantly, reaching forward to plant your palms flat against the window and bending at the waist, arching your back just how he wants it. The leather of the belt digs gently into your skin, holding you right where he wants you.
Gator wraps the loose tail of the belt tight around his fist, using it as leverage to hold you steady and keep you from sagging forward. He pauses for just a moment, letting his eyes roam over the sight before him: hands braced wide against the glass, back arched, your ass lifted perfectly for him, every curve and line of your body exposed just for his pleasure. How the fuck did I get this lucky? he thinks, still half-convinced heâs dreaming.
Heâs already shed his trousers and boxers down his legs, kicked to the side, and he spits into his free hand, stroking it quickly over his cock; hard, throbbing, and aching so bad it feels like it might split. Not that he needs it; youâre already so soaked youâre practically dripping down your thighs, ready and waiting.
He lines the broad, flushed head of his cock up against your entrance, and when you push your hips back to meet him, he smirks, eager little thing, but tightens his grip on the belt just enough to warn you to stay still. He drags the tip slowly up and down through your slick folds, rubbing it over your clit then back down to circle your hole, teasing you mercilessly.
âGator⊠pleaseâŠâ you whimper, your fingers curling against the glass.
He stops, holding the head right at your opening, just barely pressing in.
âTell me what yâwant, baby.â
âWant youâŠâ you breathe out.
âNuh-uh,â he tuts, dragging the tip back and forth again. âYâknow exactly what I wanna hear.â
âFuck⊠want you inside me⊠please⊠need itâŠâ
âYeah⊠thatâs it.â
He pushes forward in one smooth, deep motion, sinking all the way to the hilt in a single stroke. The feeling is so perfect, so hot and tight and wet, that a guttural groan tears from his throat before he can stop it.
âAh, fuck⊠yes⊠GatorâŠâ you cry out, your voice shaking.
Gator knows right then he will never, ever get tired of hearing you say his name like that; like itâs the only word you know, like itâs the only thing that matters.
Gator tightens his grip on the belt, and it ends up doing more than just holding you in place; your legs have turned to jelly, completely weak and unsteady, and itâs the only thing keeping you upright. You push harder against the glass, bracing your arms and flexing your muscles just to stay on your feet, while the feeling of him inside you makes your head spin. You feel so full, so stretched open, like heâs reaching all the way into your stomach, filling every inch of you completely.
His free hand slides down your spine, his palm warm and heavy against your skin, and you shiver all over at the touch.
âYâgood? Still sure?â he asks, his tone rough but soft around the edges, checking in even now.
It makes a small, fond smile tug at your lips, even when heâs taking you apart, he still cares enough to make sure you want it. And you do, more than anything.
âSo sure⊠so goodâŠâ
Thatâs all the confirmation he needs. He brings both hands to grip the belt, using it as his anchor, and pulls back until only the tip remains inside you, then thrusts forward hard and deep, burying himself to the root again. The force makes you cry out, your eyes fluttering shut, and when he does it again, faster this time, you let that smile spread wide across your face. This is exactly where I want to be.
âSo fuckinâ wet⊠fuck⊠so fuckinâ tightâŠâ he grunts, his hips snapping forward in a steady, punishing rhythm.
He pulls you back onto him with every stroke, using the belt to pull you tight against his thrusts, driving into you over and over. You can barely form words anymore, only broken moans, gasps, and soft, incoherent sounds falling from your lips. His pace is fast and hard, and the room fills with the sound of skin slapping against skin, his rough grunts, your cries, and the wet, slick sounds of your bodies meeting. Itâs loud and lewd and completely, utterly glorious.
Gator cannot get enough of the sounds youâre making; each gasp, each cry, each broken moan only drives him harder, deeper, faster.
âYeah, fuck⊠yâcan be as loud as yâwant⊠ainât no-one around tâhear ya⊠all by ourselvesâŠâ he growls, the words vibrating low in his chest.
One particularly deep, hard thrust hits that perfect spot inside you, and you practically scream, your fingers slipping across the glass, so you lose your grip entirely. Gator reacts instantly, releasing one hand from the belt and sliding his forearm beneath your chest to catch and support your weight. He lets the belt drop to the floor with a heavy clink of metal, then steps you closer to the window until your chest rests flat against the cool pane. He grabs both your wrists and pins them firmly behind your back, holding them tight as leverage, never stopping his rhythm, driving into you over and over.
He can feel every single clench of your pussy around him, every ripple of your muscles squeezing him tight, and every sound you make seems to vibrate right along his cock.
âFuckinâ grippinâ me so good, baby⊠takinâ every inchâŠâ
Your reply comes only in broken, breathless mumbles, and Gator knows youâve gone completely boneless, the only thing keeping you upright is his grip on your arms. He needs to see you, though; needs to watch your face, see the pleasure written all over it as you come apart for him.
Without warning, Gator pulls all the way out, and you let out a sharp, disappointed whine, almost tipping forward into the glass, but he catches you. He drags you upright, then turns you around until your back is pressed firmly against the window again. He then lifts you up and holds you suspended there, using his own body to pin you in place, like you weigh nothing at all.
âNeed tâsee that pretty fuckinâ face,â he murmurs, his voice rough and warm. âGonna cum fâme again, huh?â
You wrap your arms tight around his neck, trying to help hold yourself up, but your body feels weak and useless and that feeling only gets worse when he reaches down between your bodies, guides his cock back to your entrance, and pushes in again in one smooth stroke.
âOh, fuck⊠Gator⊠please⊠feels so goodâŠâ you gasp, burying your face in the curve of his shoulder as he starts to move.
Somehow, at this angle, heâs even deeper than before, stretching you open in a way that makes your eyes roll back and a cry tear from your throat. But his hand comes up to tangle in your hair, gripping gently but firmly, and pulls your head back until youâre forced to look straight at him.
âWanna see ya⊠yâasked for it⊠so fuckinâ take itâŠâ
You can feel the heat building fast, coiling tight and hot in your belly, and you blink hard, trying to keep your eyes focused on his, but itâs impossible, your vision blurs, and your eyelids flutter shut.
âPlease⊠mâclose⊠Gator⊠pleaseâŠâ
Gator drinks in the sight of you; lips swollen, cheeks flushed, eyes glassy and half-lidded, still so beautiful it feels unfair. When your eyes roll back completely, and he feels your walls start to clamp down hard around him, he knows youâre right there, and he isnât far behind.
He tightens his hold in your hair, leans in, and swallows your next moan with a deep, hungry kiss, his tongue tangling with yours. In this moment, he isnât aware of anything else: no bruises, no Roy, no worries, nothing but you. Your mouth, your soft skin, your heat, your wetness, every breath you take, every clench, every sound you make; itâs all that exists.
You break away from the kiss, tipping your head all the way back to expose the long line of your throat, and cry out as your orgasm crashes over you. Gator buries his face right in the crook of your neck, his hips stuttering and driving deep one last time as he spills himself inside you with a guttural, shaking groan, filling you completely.
You go limp against him, your head falling forwards onto his shoulder, and he can hear your breath coming fast and shallow, too overwhelmed to speak. He doesnât rush you, instead, he turns his head and presses his lips to yours again, this time soft and slow and gentle, a complete contrast to what just came before. When you pull back, you gasp for air, your chest heaving. Gator chuckles softly, brushing a strand of damp hair from your face.
âYâgood?â
You move your head, half a nod, half a shake, still trying to catch your breath, and for a split second, Gator feels a flicker of panic, his heart skipping a beat.
âAlright⊠breathe fâme, baby. Big one⊠in.â
He watches closely as you try, first a small breath, then a little deeper, and then your face breaks into a bright, dazed smile as you finally draw in a full lungful. Your eyes flutter open, and relief floods through him so hard he almost sighs aloud, though he keeps it hidden behind his own smile.
âGood⊠Iâm okayâŠâ you murmur.
âAlright⊠keep breathinâ, yeah?â
You nod, following his instruction, and he watches as your breathing starts to steady, coming easier and deeper now. Gator braces his forearms against the glass and slowly lifts you just a little higher, so his cock slips gently out of you. You gasp softly at the sudden emptiness, your face pinching just a little, and he presses a quick, apologetic kiss to your cheek.
âMâsorry⊠keep breathinâ⊠you got it.â
He keeps his gaze fixed on your chest, making sure each rise and fall is smooth and steady. Your next breath fills your lungs fully, and when you open your eyes again, Gator is looking down at you with the softest, warmest smile youâve ever seen.
âIâm okay,â you say again, more sure this time.
âYeah⊠I know you are,â he replies, his voice low and fond. âGonna put yâdown now, alright?â
You nod, and he lowers you slowly until your feet touch the floor, but as soon as your weight settles, your legs give out entirely, turning to water beneath you. Gatorâs arm wraps around your waist instantly, holding you up, and he laughs, warm and amused.
âAlright⊠maybe not.â
He bends and lifts you properly, one arm under your knees, the other supporting your back and you donât even try to stand, just let yourself go limp in his hold, draping your arms around his neck and resting your head against his shoulder. He carries you easily across the room and over to the bed, climbing onto the mattress with you still held close. He leans back against the headboard, settling you comfortably across his lap, and pulls the duvet up to wrap around both of you, then presses a soft kiss to the top of your head.
You tilt your head back to look up at him, then lean in to meet his lips for a slow, lingering kiss; sweet and deep and full of everything you canât put into words. When he pulls back just enough to rest his forehead against yours, the look in his eyes takes your breath away all over again.
No one has ever looked at you like this; like youâre the only thing that matters, like you hold the whole world in your hands. It makes you remember what Maggie told you about Wayne, how he used to look at her like she was everything. This is exactly what that feels like. If you ever had even a second of doubt about how much Gator loves you, all youâd have to do is look at him; eyes soft and bright, a quiet smile on his face, watching you like youâre the most precious thing heâs ever known.
His voice comes, soft and warm against your skin:
âHappy birthday, Baby.â
Taglist: [Comment to be added] @keerygirlie98 @mystickittytaco @imdjoverit @lofi-fics @kristywidget97 @janehartt  @ms-mountebank @louisbelongstome28 @eller41 @slutforpumpkins @roridemie @mrmountebankk
summary: You and Steve bickered like a married couple in highschool, but when you rediscover the romantic tension between you after a night with the kids, matured Steve exceeds your expectations.
warnings: bullying and late night confessions <3
note: So⊠I started writing this when I was bored one day and god incredibly carried away. Pretty sure this is the longest oneshot Iâve written! I am very proud of this, I hope you enjoy!! c:
Steve Harrington. King of Hawkins high and your mortal enemy.
The pair of you had butted heads in high school like there was no tomorrow, you hated his guts and he hated yours right back. Well, you assumed so anyways.
Steve had everything a teenage boy could want. Perfect hair, popularity, a place on the coveted basketball team and a steady stream of pretty girls waiting at his every beck and call.
You on the other hand were popular in your own way. You were a confident at heart, nerdy and fun and never afraid to stand up for whatâs right.
It was only when one of your fellow Hellfire Club members had issues with Steve that you began your infamous bickering, you were like the Lord Capulet to Steveâs Lord Montague.
Steve had been with Carol and Tommy when he hurled an insult at your friend, obviously trying to show off. You? You were livid. And the rest was history. The event had created a rivalry between the two of you like no other.
To you, he was an absolute man-child. No manners or care for any breathing thing that wasnât him. For someone who talked so big, he did not meet your expectations for âthe dream boyâ like everyone said he was.
But at the end of the day, it was kind of fun fighting with Steve, finding out what parts of him hurt the most to pick at. Whether it was his parents or a failed exam, you knew all of his weaknesses. It was like collecting pokemon cards in a way, how many ways can you hurt Steve âThe Hairâ Harringtonâs feelings? But somehow, he never found yours.
The rude remarks he threw at you werenât personal at all. Heâs say you looked weird, or call you a name or two, but none of them were things that could actually hurt someone, especially you.
What you didnât know is that Steve never had wanted to upset you. He loved fighting with you just for the mere purpose of being able to talk to you. Of being able to stand close and look down at your face. His eyes had always seemed to find you, even in class or when walking home. Steve was quite frankly infatuated, but you couldnât know that.
In his heart he knew itâd be better to have this than nothing at all.
~*~*~*~*~
Highschool had come and gone, but you somehow still found yourself constantly surrounded by kids.
Dustin Henderson, one of the youngest Hellfire members, had introduced you to his menagerie of equally as weird friends. You wanted to help out, so youâd host the odd sleepover or drop them off to a movie, sometimes being dragged into whatever insane adventure theyâd whipped up.
The kids simply took you since you were a cool adult who would be willing to get them into places they really shouldnât be, but the real leader of the children?
The one and only Steve Harrington.
You loved the kids, but youâd stubbornly refuse to do anything involved with Steve.
âCome on! Itâs one movie, itâll be fun!â Dustin begged you, adamant that you could still have fun at tonightâs movie marathon even if âStevieâ was there.
Little did you know, when Dustin had mentioned you to Steve, he jumped at the opportunity to get another chance to talk to you. So now? Steve had a wingman. A very enthusiastic wingman.
âPleaseplease puhleeeeaseeeee!!!â
If only shutting your eyes could block out Dustinâs voice.
âI know Steve is coming, but we really want you to come! You know, heâs not who he used to be!â
âOh yeah?â
No way heâs changed.
âIâll hold my breath until you say yes.â
So, the boy sits there, face slowly turning red as he dramatically puffs out his cheeks and holds his breath.
âŠ
âŠ
âŠ
âFine! Fine. He has to prove to me how heâs better. Iâll believe it when I see it.â You finally gave in. If Harrington was going to be there, you might as well have a little bit of fun and see how he turned out.
He canât have changed.
Right?
~*~*~*~*~
What certainly didnât change was Steveâs looks.
Youâre stood at the Henderson householdâs door, exchanging monotone pleasantries with⊠Harrington.
Hair the same, clothes the same, annoyingly handsome face the same - just older, but an unmistakable amount of maturity has changed him in a way you canât quite note yet.
âYou came.â
You raise an eyebrow at his remark.
âNo shit, Sherlock. Can I come in or what?â
God, how you wish you could wipe that gorgeous smirk off of his face.
Steve steps aside, giving you room to enter. Once you close the door behind you, youâre met with a herd of children barrelling towards you.
âYouâre here!â
âHey!!!â
âI told you sheâd come.â
Steve simply stands and stares as you calm down the chaotic kids, his face a picture of awe. You were always so good with them, he knew how hard they were sometimes so seeing you deal with them perfectly only added to your attractiveness.
Piling into the living room, the children take their usual spots. Some on the couch, some on the floor, but Steve assumes his claimed spot, the right side of the couch. The kids shuffle together to make room for you, right next to Steve.
Perfect. Just perfect.
As the evening drifted away into night, you were still squished thigh to thigh and shoulder to shoulder with Harrington. The children had all fallen asleep to The Outsiders, Willâs head on Mikeâs shoulder and Max draped over Lucasâ lap with a line of drool down her cheek.
But you and King Steve?
Wide awake.
Throughout the night, youâd witnessed just how much he had changed. His charming smile had stayed the same, but he was so incredibly caring to the group, he cooked dinner and make jokes and always ensure everyone was okay amongst a million other things which truly made him such a good guy, and which truly made you blush.
But you still hadnât spoken to him, not wanting to give in.
So now, the two of you were sat in silence, the tension so thick not even the fumes from Steveâs hairspray could diffuse it.
âHey⊠Listen.â Steveâs voice pops the bubble of silence which had formed around you, and you turn to look at him, meeting his brown doe eyes.
You hum in acknowledgement, giving him room to continue.
âIâm⊠Iâm sorry. For how I treated you in high school.â His eyes were locked on the TV, his face a picture of nervousness, something youâd never seen on Steve before.
âI was a massive dick. I thought popularity and âlegacyâ was⊠was more important than being a decent fucking human.â He lets out a laugh devoid of any humour, his gaze finally turning back to meet yours once again.
âSteve itâs fi-â you begin, but he cuts you off.
âNo, itâs not.â He practically launches himself to turn and face you fully, freezing for a second when Jane stirs before continuing his rant.
âI promise you Iâm a better person. Iâve worked on myself. Plus, working at Scoops really does put everything into perspective.â Steveâs lips curl up into a sort of melancholy smile, one you return.
âYeah⊠Dustin has told me many times how cool and kind you are. Guess you really changed huh Harrington?â Your smile grows wider, your muscles relaxing as you settle into comfortable conversation with the boy you always thought youâd despise.
âWell, Dustin has told me many times how cool you are.â Steve playfully nudges your shoulder.
Sneaking out a quiet giggle, you nudge him back.
âOh yeah? When he told me how youâve changed I at least hoped I could experience better insults.â
âYou- what?â
Your eyebrows furrow, what the hell is he confused about? You thought it was quite obvious how surface level his insults were.
âSteve. Câmon. You couldâve been more imaginative when you were mean. Like, you used âyour momâ jokes!â You pushed out a laugh through your confusion.
âYeah,â he laughed out, shaking his head as he stared down at the floor, âI did. Itâs because I didnât want to upset you.â
okay. what the fuck.
âUpset me? Steve, that was the point. We hated each others guts!â
âMaybe you hated mine.â
Steveâs words stun you to silence.
After a few moments, you notice the nervous look on his face.
âI kinda⊠I kinda begged Dustin to get you to come here so I could prove to you how much Iâve changed.â His brown doe eyes gaze into yours, brows furrowed in pure desperation.
You burst into laughter, before quickly quietening down as to not wake the kids. Smacking him playfully on the chest, you say, âyou dingus! Oh my- youâre such a loser!â
âWasnât expecting that huh?â Steve laughs, but it comes out more like a puff of air.
His teeth bit into his bottom lip, trying to distract himself from his nerves, before his tongue ran over the now red area where he had bit, wetting it.
âSo⊠uhh⊠do I have a chance?â
Smiling so hard your cheeks hurt, you took his hand in yours.
âFine. You can take me out, Steve.â
And it only got better from there.
p.s: how would we feel about a part two? or maybe a whole series! c:
Steve was laying on his back, grabbing fistfuls of the thigh that was hooked over his side, chest heaving with each stuttering breath he tookâ completely overstimulated and impossibly hard from the way you rolled and squeezed at his pretty little nipples between both thumbs and forefingers.
They were so soreâ puffy and protruding crudely from the constant tugs, but the way his cock stammered and bucked on its own accord made it blatantly obvious he was enjoying it.
âPleaseâ fuck,â he hissed through his teeth, so sensitive now and even more than before, pretty lashes fluttering against his cheeks. âYouâre killinâ me, baby.â
Steve reached for his cock, not fully grasping it, but carefully teasing the immense sensitivity that was his flushed tipâ all pink and pretty and leaking pearlescent beads of pre-cumâ however, you soon slapped his wrist away, replacing it with one of your own hands.
The unoccupied nipple crooned for affection, so with only one hand free, you enveloped it with your hot mouthâ lathering it with spit and suckling at it desperately, tongue lolling crudely and slickly over the now-red flesh.
âTouch meâ please, mâso hard,â he was whining into the stuffy air, face all sweaty and flustered, mouth practically drooling from the stimulationâ but of course the greedy boy wanted more. âneeda cum so bad.â
â§ïœ„ïŸ: *â§ïœ„ïŸ:*
⥠link to my masterlist
⥠reblogs, likes and comments are always appreciated!
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch âą No registration required âą HD streaming
steve would have you holding yourself open. heâd guide your hands down behind your knees and gently press your own fingers into your legs, moving your body with you as he let you spread your own legs for him.
heâd lean in close and youâd hold your breath, because his mouth is soclose to you, but he doesnât do anything other than give a kiss to your thigh and then inhale your scent, mouth open like he wants to try and taste you too from inches away. you make a small noise in your throat and then he turns, shifts a little, sucks in his cheeks and then spits right onto your open core, the glob of saliva dripping down the seam of your lips, rolling over your slit down to your slit, where it settles, shiny, warm; you shudder.
and then heâs up on his knees, hovering above you, his hands exploring your body, caressing your tits and your sides and your stomach, settling in your waist as he leans in, the heavy weight of his cock settling on top of you, nestled against your thigh. he reaches one hand down, correcting the placementâhe lets it lay across your quivering folds, and rolls his hips. you feel the pass of his cock lightly, because heâs just laying on you, no pressure, nothing holding him against youâand then he starts in.
he takes hold of his cock and strokes himself, thumb smoothing over the head, focusing on the slit like you do, and you watch transfixed until he slides his hand to the base and holds himself, erect, flushed at the tip, over you. then, with one quick, clean movementâhe slaps the head against your clit.
youâre not worked up enoughâyetâto have much of a reaction but that doesnât deter him. he just does it again, every now and then smoothing his palm over your pussy, rubbing at your clit with the pads of his fingers, working you up to it gradually, and every time you get close he just uses his cock on you again, like itâs a toy, not part of him. like itâs only good for looking pretty and giving you something to suck on and bat away at your clit with the spongy head until you come from the play.
youâre so wet from him touching you that you can hear it when he taps the head repeatedly against you, his thumb stretched along the top so you really feel it when he pushes the head into your clit, circling it over you, and when he pulls away thereâs an obscene wet, almost sucking sound like your fluids and his precome were keeping you stuck together, like your body and his didnât want to part but for the force of him pulling away.
you sighâthe one he knows, where you like it but want more, and so he gives you one last flick of his wrist, the head popping against your clit again, before he lowers his mouth to you instead, broad shoulders against the backs of your hands as he licks at you, tonguing your clit and sucking it. and thatâs about all it takesâa couple soft pulls with his lips, some long quick strokes with his tongue, and you come apart against his mouth, releasing your knees and curling your hands into his hair instead, holding on for dear life as you ride your orgasm out on his face.
&&
gator would definitely make use of his cuffs and have you laying there with your arms up above your head, not able to move while he has one of your legs up against his front, your calf resting on his shoulder. heâd just gently kiss your ankle which would be such a stark contrast to the way that heâs holding your other leg down flat, palm splayed out against your thigh so youâre spread open. heâd probably have you like that for what feels like hours, playing with your pussy almost idly, like he doesnât care, like heâs not affected, like his cock isnât rock hard and dripping precome.
heâd use his other hand to hold onto himself and just bat the head against you, nudging your clit with the tip, curling his hips forward so the underside rubs against your swollen, desperate clit, your lips puffy with all the attention heâs been giving them. heâd swap out and use his hand on you every couple passes of his dick, and youâd watch as he pulls away, not able to touch anything but keeping your fingers tangled together. the bottom of his cock is shiny with you, and heâd slap your pussy and dig his fingers into your cunt, scissoring them apart before pulling them out once you start squirming, enjoying it too muchâand then heâd just smear your arousal over himself and take hold of his shaft again.
heâd sidle closer on his knees, looming over you and snap his wrist downward, his cock hitting against your clit and youâd twitch, because youâre so worked up and fucked out and the only part of him thatâs been inside you is two of his fingers. youâd push your hips up, try to widen your legs, his fingertips pressing divots into your thigh, and he brings his cock down against you. your whole body jumps, and even he gasps as your pussy spasms. he meets your eyes and you nod, whining, so he does it again, and again, your whimpers turning to mewls turning to simpering moans and then heâs slotting his cock between your lips and fucking through them, between them, the slide slick and easy and the pressure and hard ridge of his cock dragging over your soaking folds, his hand rough on your leg, is what pushes you over.
your cunt clamps down on itself, empty, empty, empâ
gator bullies his cock into you as you come, your orgasm drawn out, lasting forever, and your whole body kicks again, your toes curling as he fucks into you, winding you up again, stomach tensing as you feel him inside you, deep, moving in and letting you milk his come from his cock. he fills you up, his arm tight around your leg, holding it to his chest, flooding you with his release, until you both relax and he pulls out and his spunk dribbles out after him
but he doesnât relent, even as you tug at the cuffsâhe just starts again, slapping the wet head against your clit, so sensitive itâs just on this side of too much. the grin that splits his face doesnât soften his hard eyes, and you settle yourself down for another go-round.
fluff, firefighter!steve, baker!reader, meet cute, female reader, no use of y/n, she/her pronouns for reader | request by @violatedvibrators (greatest username of all time)
wc: 1.1k
Steve Harrington had been kicking himself for almost a whole week for not asking for your number when he had the chance. In his defence, he had been working at the time and since he was making sure that your building didn't burn down after a baking recipe gone wrong, asking for your number hadnât been too high on his priority list.
But man, he really regretted not asking for it anyway.
Because he knew there had been something between the two of you that nightâthat it wasnât just gratitude for putting out the fire you had accidentally started in your eyes.
He wanted nothing more than to go back to your apartment and ask you out but he knew how insane and deeply inappropriate that was and so, Steve had decided to leave it in the hands of fate. He told himselfâif it was meant to be, youâd find each other again.
And fate intervened one rainy Saturday morning just before his shift.
One of his colleagues, Sam, had recently moved and came into work the other day raving about a little independent bakery a few blocks away. He had said their cinnamon buns were to die for.
And so, Steve wanted to see for himself just how good Sugarplum Bakes was.
The bell above the door had barely rung all morning. Saturdays were usually your busiest day but with the rain hammering down outside, no one seemed to want to venture outside for a pastry.
And so, you hum to yourself as you finish a fresh batch of blueberry cinnamon buns, the quiet morning giving you some time to work on a new recipe.
You had been more careful this time since your last attempt at a new recipe had resulted in a small kitchen fire. You had naturally panicked about it but when the fire brigade turned up and the most gorgeous man you had ever seen put out the fire like it was nothing, you found yourself feeling flustered for reasons that had nothing to do with the burnt pastries.
You had been so deep in thought about said gorgeous fireman that you barely even notice how much icing you had been pouring over the cinnamon buns.
âShit,â you mutter to yourself, eyes on the excessive amount of icing now covering the buns. It was definitely a little more than you would usually use on your cinnamon buns but they still looked delicious.
You suppose you could blame it on the gorgeous fireman who had been on your mind for the past week.
You were just slicing up the buns when the bell above the door sounded for the first time in over an hour.
âComing!â You call, wiping your hands on your apron before rushing out of the kitchen to greet the customer who was carefully inspecting one of the displays.
You open your mouth to do your usual greeting, one that you knew like the back of your hand but you freeze when the manâwho was wearing a Hawkins Fire Department jacketâlook up and you see the eyes of the fireman who had prevented your apartment from burning down.
You stare at him with wide eyes, briefly wondering if you were dreaming or perhaps even hallucinating his presence.
But he smiles at you and says, âhey. You burnt any more pastries yet?â And you knew then that you were definitely not dreaming.
You laugh nervously as your hands hastily smooth down your apron like it would help you in this situation. Like it would stop your heart from racing or make the fluttery feeling in your stomach go away.
âNot yet,â you reply with a small smile, your cheeks feeling hot all of a sudden. âThat was a one time thing, I assure you. No fires here.â
âThatâs a damn shame,â he says, the corner of his mouth lifting and amusement glittering in his warm eyes. âIâd love an excuse to see you again.â
Your stomach does something funny at those words. You decide to ignore it for the time being.
âWell, this is actually my bakery so feel free to stop by anytime,â you tell him, trying to keep the nerves out of your mouth. âOn the house, of course. Since youâyou know, stopped me from burning down my kitchen.â
The man laughs and the sound makes you feel warm inside, makes you forget about the rain pouring outside.
âIâm Steve, by the way. Steve Harrington.â
You tell Steve your name and his smile widens.
âPretty name for a pretty baker,â he tells you. You pray he doesnât notice how flustered that makes you feel, how those words seem to have rewritten your brain chemistry entirely.
You should say something smart, something that would make him feel as flustered as you feel. But you come up short and so, you say nothing.
âSoâIâve been told your buns are pretty good.â
You blink, something twists low in your gut. âSorry, what?â
Steve falters, his face and the tips of his ears turning red as he realises the accidental euphemism that had slipped from his lips. The fact that he was now flustered makes you feel even more endeared to him.
âYour cinnamon buns,â he explains, cheeks still burning. âI justâIâve heard good things. I didnât meanââ
It was your turn to smile now, your turn to revel in his slightly flustered demeanour.
âI actually just made some blueberry cinnamon buns. New recipe Iâm trying out,â you tell him. âFair warning, I used way too much icing on them. But Iâd love a second opinion.â
Steve pauses then smiles and says, âthereâs no such thing as too much icing.â
You take extra care with the bun you pick out for Steve, making sure it was the best one from the bunch (for feedback purposes, obviously) and you pack some of extra blondies and a danish swirl in the takeaway box.
You hand it over the counter to Steve and there was a moment where your fingers brush against his and the fire in your gut burned so hot you werenât sure that there was anything that could put it out, even the firefighter stood in front of you.
âDoes this come with your phone number?â Steve asks, a hopeful edge to his voice. âYou knowâjust so I can give you a full review on these over-iced buns.â
The question does nothing to help your heart ponding in your chest, in fact, it makes it beat even faster. Makes you feel a lightheaded.
âIt does.â
You smile back at him before grabbing a nearby pen you use for noting orders and a napkin, which you scribble your number on.
Steve takes the napkin, barely able to contain his smile as he slides it carefully into his pocket.
âIâll call you,â he promises, already planning on calling you the second his shift ends. âUntil thenâdonât start any fires. Or do, at least then Iâll get to see you again.â
You laugh as he leaves the bakery, thanking your lucky stars that Steve Harrington decided to stumble into your bakery.
Fic for @moonstoneandmoonlight and @graywrenhart âs The Steve Harrington Summer Sleepover đ€
Summary:
Youâre a hardworking high school student and recently lost your father. You in love with the schoolâs most popular boy, Steve Harrington, through anonymous online messages. After overcoming misunderstandings and standing up for herself, you have one of the greatest love stories with Steve Harrington
Content Warning:
Greif, crying, venting, arguing, cussing, two idiots falling in love, flirting, overthinking, kissingâŠ.
Authorâs note
This story will be similar to the movie âA cinderella storyâ but will not be exactly the same. I decided to remove her evil step mother and step sisters (because they annoy me too much). There will be changes. I hope you enjoy this as much as I enjoyed writing itđ€
Your life was always simple, living happily with your father. He owns a small diner, that is not too popular but always filled with regular customers.
Your mother left you when you were 5 years old. You donât remember much, but that doesnât hurt you at all. Your dad provided everything you couldâve asked for.
Your relationship with your father was really close. You always communicated with him about your future, and always got assured that if you work hard, your dreams would come true. And you always believed that.
Tragically, shortly after, your father passes away in an earthquake leaving you devastated. Youâd lost your only family member. While you were capable of taking care of yourself, the reality of being alone weighed heavily on you.
Your life felt like it had crumbled and your dreams were slipping away. Your father had promised to help with the finances at Princeton University, wanting his daughter to receive the best education. However, it seemed that dream would never come true.
On the other side, a friend of your father took over the diner. All you could do is continue working as a waitress in the diner.
You continued living your life, grieving for your father and your dream.
At your school, you always kept a low profile, embarrassed of being poor and working at a diner. You were far away from those popular girls who wore designer bags and heels to school.
Most of your school days are spent together with your best friend, Robin Buckley, an actor who performs dramatic speeches.
âWhy donât you try acting?â Robin asked you, placing her books into her locker while you leaned on the other one behind her.
âMe? acting? Youâre funnyâ you chuckled
âWhat? Youâre already beautiful you just need some practiceâ she locked her locker.
âRobin no, I already have a lot on my plateâ
âNever too late to change your mindâ she bumped your shoulder.
While Robin was talking about her upcoming performance, you accidentally made eye contact with Steve Harrington.
The most popular boy in your school, the one with the perfect life. Handsome and ridiculously rich, and the captain on the football team who was admired by everyone in the school. Everyone is talking about the football star he will become.
While you were at work, a group of high school students walked in, and sat in the booths. You felt like you could die on the spot. You hated serving people that were at your age.
When you approached the table, roller skating with your skates (you hated them but they were a part of the uniform) Nancy said âWell if it isnât the diner girl?â
You could feel anger rising, but kept a calm face.
âWhat can I get you guysâ you asked
âWhat can I get here that has no sugar, no carbs and itâs fat-free? Nancy asked.
âWaterâ you nodded
âWas that supposed to be a joke?â Nancy asked
âIt was funnyâ Steve said
âSteve!â she smacked his arm, it looked like she was mad at him the whole entire time they were there.
Today was a sunny Saturday, of course you had work at the diner.
You spent your weekends working until lunch, and then studying at night.
Although two nights something happened. You got an email from somebody called âHairsprayâ
You began chatting with him, neither knows the otherâs real identity.
You used the username âPrincetonâ. You spent the night talking about school, and found out that youâre in the same grade.
Later when you arrived at home from work, you got an email.
Hairspray
Hey youâre at work?
Princeton
Just got back home, what about you?
Hairspray
I was helping my dad around the house, what are you up to?
Princeton
First rest and then iâll study:â)
Hairspray
So you were serious about Princeton?
Princeton
Yes, is it weird?
Hairspray
No not at all
Actually Iâve been thinking about something
Princeton
about what?
Hairspray
about Princeton
Ever since I was a kid i wanted to be a writer but my dad pressured me with football and I never got to do what I actually want
Princeton
Itâs not late to start focusing on writing
Hairspray
You think so?
Princeton
I do.
Hairspray
Thank you for understanding
Princeton
Itâs alright
I do have this huge fear of not making it to Princeton though
Hairspray
But why youâre smart and all
Princeton
but it also costs a leg
Hairspray
Canât you get a scholarship or something?
Princeton
Im trying for that now, If i donât get it I wonât have a chance.
Hairspray
I think youâll get it, youâve been studying your ass off
Princeton
You think so?
Hairspray
Im sure 100%
Princeton
Too confident, no?
Hairspray
Hmm no
Princeton
If you say so
Hairspray
So you go to the same school as me
Princeton
Well if you didnât lie about your school then yes
Hairspray
Please iâve been more honest to you than my parents
Princeton
Oh i feel special
Hairspray
You should ;)
Princeton
Why is your username âhairspray?â
Hairspray
Because I use a lot of it
Princeton
But youâre a guy arenât you?
Hairspray
Yes I am
Canât guys use hairspray too?
Princeton
You can of course itâs just weird not many use it
Hairspray
Well i do
Princeton
Hmm so i should look out for a guy that uses hairspray at school huh?
Hairspray
Careful thereâs lots of them
Princeton
No thereâs not you just made that up
Hairspray
Okay yes i did
Princeton
Are you by any chance Mr. Williams
Hairspray
What our chemistry teacher? NO
Princeton
Okay thank god
Hairspray
Is it safe to say that I hate him
Princeton
I hate him too.
Hairspray
Now i like you even more
Princeton
You like me?
Hairspray
As a friend:)
Princeton
A friend you donât know the name of and how she looks
Hairspray
well youâre my special anonymous friend
Princeton
How many anonymous friends do you have?
Hairspray
One.
(What you didnât know is that âHairsprayâ was actually Steve Harrington).
You couldnât help it but blush a little. He made you feel seen and understood just like your dad used to. You could be walking past this person at school every day and not know who he is.
Over the last 2 weeks, âHairsprayâ and âPrincetonâ grew closer and closer. You two got to know so much about each other. Cracking jokes at 1am, venting, and talking about their future. Throughout the talking, feeling were developed for each other, but both of you were still unaware.
Eventually they decide to meet. They agreed on meeting at the schoolâs Halloween Homecoming dance. Making it more romantic, they will recognise each other by clues. You said that you will be wearing a white dress with a matching white mask. Hairspray agreed to meet you exactly at midnight.
However, an unexpected problem arose first. The manager of the diner was not letting you attend the dance. However, Rhonda one of the other waitresses, covered for you and let you go to the dance.
You curled your blonde hair, and wore a beautiful white dress that made you look straight out of a movie. While the white eye mask made your blue eyes stand out.
You found out who âHairsprayâ was. It was Steve Harrington. Of course itâs him, heâs the only guy in the school with hair that holds a ridiculous amount of hairspray.
Not going to lie, he looked really handsome tonight. He wore a black tailored tuxedo that fit his body like a glove, making him look formal and match the fairytale atmosphere.
At the dance, Steve finally found the mysterious girl he has fallen in love with.
You spent the night chatting and walking around the beautiful garden outside. The music from the inside could be heard perfectly, so Steve asked you for a dance outside, where you two were completely alone.
He knew how to dance really good, his arms around your waist felt way too warm. You could feel your stomach do a flip from his touch.
âNow will you tell me your name, Princeton girl?â he smirked
âHmm maybe try guessingâ
âI love a challengeâ he replied
âOf course you doâ
For a moment he stared at your eyes, unsure if he should say it or not but he did anyway.
âYou have beautiful eyesâ
âThank youâ you could feel blush creep up on your cheeks.
For the first time you felt truly happy. And Steve realised that youâre everything he has been searching for.
Eventually Steve discovers that you are the mystery girl after you removed your mask.
âHow come I didnât thought about you?â
âHm I donât knowâ
âYou- wait you work at the diner right?â He started connecting the dots
âI- yeahâ you sighed, embarrassment creeping up on you
âWhy didnât you mention anything about it?â
âBecause Iâm embarrassed by my lifestyle Steve!â
He lifted your chin up with his pointer finger, looking into yours eyes.
âDonât be embarrassed, not from meâ
âBut what about the others? Theyâll say that-â
âShh hey who cares what the others thinkâ he looked at you with a confused look
âSteve Harrington seen with this unpopular girl that works at a diner and people barely know her name?â
âSo? they will learn itâ he smiled
âNo Steve you donât understandâ you shook your head
âWhat tell me, whatâs there to understand?â
âYouâre a good looking guy with a great reputation, and im just meâ
âYeah you with the smartest brain ever and the prettiest blue eyesâ he tucked a hair strand behind your ear.
âI donât think we can do this, sorryâ you squeezed his palm once and turned around to leave.
âWait no what do you mean?â
âIm sorry Steveâ you sobbed, running away.
You couldnât get to do this, you managed to keep your low profile for so long, you didnât want to ruin that.
Especially you didnât want to become the new centre of attention.
When you came home you saw the wall clock tick 00:00, then you realised you have lost your phone. Things felt so hard you couldnât help it but sob.
The next day at school you managed to ignore Steve as much as possible. Today the school class presidents hosted an event, giving awards to the best students.
You were in the crowd, sitting next to Robin. Then you heard Nancy say âBest athlete of the year - Steve Harrington!â
Funny how his ex girlfriend was presenting the award to him.
The crowd immediately stood up and began cheering and applauding.
Steve stepped out on the stage âI want to thank my coach, my family, teammateâs and my closest friends for always supporting meâ his eyes found you in the crowd, and they never left yours.
As Steve was about to leave the stage, Nancy said âNot only our heâs our best athlete, he makes sure to get the best princesses at homecoming!â
Your heart stopped. People started whispering and mumbling, you could hear a few âOohhâsâ in the crowd.
Steveâs face turned pale. He saw you trying to run away from everyone, but decided to follow you.
While you were in the hallway of the school, leaving, he called out
âHey no wait!â he started running âYou canât just walk away from me every timeâ he stood in front of you, blocking your way out
âLet me go-â
âNo youâre not leavingâ
You finally looked at him, his face had a worried expression âFrom what are you so afraid? Tell meâ his voice cracked
âFrom everything Steve, everything! I donât want to become famous in the whole school and have every girl gossip about me! Iâm already going through a lot, and you know itâ
âI- nobody will gossipâ he tried to confront you
âThey will!â
âMaybe they will but that will be just the beginning! Then everyone will forget!â he cupped your cheeks
âYouâre used to being alone, and thatâs why you donât want more people to know youâ
He was right. You were afraid of letting people in your life, scared that they are going to leave you again.
âI want to be with you! I want to- want to take you out on dates, I want to buy your favourite snacks and watch stupid rom coms with youâ He said.
Your heart was pounding so hard, It almost left your chest.
âCan I?â he asked
âCan you?â
âJust- do you trust me?â
âYesâ
His face was coming closer to yours, then suddenly he kissed you. He kissed you so fiercely that he was terrified youâd flee him again. For the first time, you stopped pushing him away and simply followed your heart, diving into the kiss.
Wrapping your arms around his neck, you pulled him closer. You could smell his cologne , and god he smelled like heaven.
âHoly shitâ he broke the kiss, panting for air.
You looked at him with your doe blue eyes, Steve swore he could happily die on the spot.
âGosh youâre so sweetâ he kissed you again, not being able to get enough of you.
Normally right now in this moment, youâd try to run away, but you didnât, you stayed.
His words made you blush.
âBe mineâ he whispered close to your lips.
âI think I already am, Hairsprayâ you chuckled
âThen Iâm one lucky guy, Princetonâ he said, kissing you again.
âOh and you forgot this, Cinderellaâ Steve pulled our your phone from his pocket.
âOh my how did you find it?â you took it from his hand
âYou forgot it at the garden, or left it on purpose just so you could talk to me againâ he winked and wiggled his eyebrows.
You smacked his chest âYes oh my god Iâve been dying to talk to youâ you said sarcastically then you went closer up to his ear and whispered âAnd to kiss youâ you whispered.
âYouâre going to be the end of me, my Princeton Cinderellaâ
Liked by: djotime, b.i.g.s.h.r.i.m.p, stinkyjavi and 52, 368 others
Reader_ : Life recently managing (babysitting) these amazing guys! so proud of them and can't wait to see whatever happens next
-view all Comments-
djotime: Best manager ever đ€liked by author
‷ Reader_ : Best band ever
weswesp__ : Joe looks so cute in those pictures đ€liked by author
‷ postanimal_fan: Wait why did she heart this!?!?
‷ Keerys-girl98: omgggg she liked itttttt
stinkyjavi: thank you for managing (babysitting) us đ€liked by author
‷ Reader_ : I love my job
gatenmatarazzo: Joe is so sexy
‷ djotime: um...
‷ harringtons.left.sock: im dying
Authors Note: hey everyone sorry this is kind of shit it's my first time doing a smau sooooo let me know what we think. Life is hectic right now, but I hope to be posting more soon. <3 (also these are not my pictures I found them on pinterest)
Thank you so much for reading <3
Make sure you like, reblog, and follow for more!!!
Message me to be added to my tag list so you can be alerted when I post a new fic.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch âą No registration required âą HD streaming
girl next door drabble where sheâs obsessed with joes bicepsđđ
âËàż the girl next door (is not a grandma) drabble đđËâ
You couldn't lie.
There was just something about Joe's arms.
Maybe it was because he always rolled his sleeves up the way his forearms flexed while kneading dough, or how his biceps looked unfairly good in the simplest white T-shirt.
Whatever the reason was, you found yourself staring far more often than you probably should. God really took his time making those, you thought.
Which was unfortunate because you were currently supposed to be measuring ingredients. Instead, your attention had wandered completely toward your boyfriend, who was happily kneading bread dough on the kitchen island. The muscles in his forearms shifted with every push. You blinked and blinked again.
"Honey?"
"Hmm?" you answered absentmindedly, eyes never leaving him.
Joe looked over his shoulder. "I think you just poured three cups of powdered sugar."
"What?" Your eyes dropped to the bowl. "That's flour, right?" Joe slowly shook his head. You dipped a finger into it before cautiously tasting it. shit.
At first, Joe didn't think much of it.
He simply assumed you were naturally affectionate. Holding his hand. Looping your arm through his. Leaning against his shoulder while reading. Normal couple things.
It wasn't until the old man from 6D pointed it out that Joe began noticing a very specific pattern.
The three of you had just finished dinner, the old man had invited both of you over, insisting he'd "accidentally made too much food," despite the fact he cooked enough for three every single week.
Now the dishes had been cleared away. The old man and Joe sat across from each other discussing whether Frank Sinatra was better than Dean Martin.
You, meanwhile, had curled up beside Joe, completely absorbed with Wings of Starlight.Â
Without realizing it, your fingers had wandered to Joe's arm. You absentmindedly traced tiny circles over his bicep, occasionally giving it a gentle squeeze whenever you reached the end of a chapter. Joe didn't even react. Apparently, this happened so often that neither of you noticed anymore.
The old man watched for a full minute before finally setting his teacup down. "Young lady," You hummed, eyes still on your book. "If you keep petting him like that he's going to start purring."
Both of you looked, your hand was, in fact still gently squeezing his bicep. "...ooh."
You immediately hid behind your book. "I'm not petting him," you mumbled from behind the pages. Joe laughed so hard you wanted to smack him with your book.Â
Eventually, Joe started paying attention. He noticed that whenever you walked together your hand somehow always ended up on his arm, aways his bicep.Â
A week later, the two of you were grocery shopping. Joe reached for a box of cereal while pushing the cart with one hand. Without thinking, you wrapped both arms around his other.
An older woman passing by slowed with a knowing smile. "You two newlyweds?"
Joe smiled politely. "Not yet."
"I could tell."
You tilted your head. "How?"
The woman pointed toward Joe's arm tucked securely against your chest. she chuckled warmly. "girls don't hold onto a man's arm like that unless they're completely gone." She continued down the aisle, laughing softly to herself.
Your entire body heated with embarrassment. "...Oh."
You immediately let go. Joe looked at the empty space beside him for exactly two seconds.
Then, without a word, he reached over and gently tucked your arms back around his. "There." You looked up and he kissed the top of your head. "Sweetheart, I'd be offended if you stopped."
You couldn't help smiling. "really?"
"Mhm." He flexed ever so slightly, but you knew, you freaking knew.
You immediately looked at him. "...you just flexed."
"I stretched."
"Nope, you flexed."
"I breathed." Joe only laughed.
Maybe he had started doing one extra set at the gym. Purely coincidentally. Definitely not because he knew exactly where your hands would end up afterward, nope, absolutely not. (yes, he was lying)
That night, you were curled against Joe's side beneath a mountain of blankets, your heating pad resting over your stomach.
Your period always made you a little strange. A little clingier. A little sleepier. And, a little more obsessed with your boyfriend's arms. Joe looked down as your fingers found his bicep again. "Honey, you've been petting at my arm for fifteen minutes."
"I'm just thankful.."
He laughed. "You appreciate it every day, huh?."
"Because it's cute." You nodded seriously. "It looks squishy."
Joe flexed instinctively, poked it too. "It isn't squishy." He relaxed again.
You gave it another squeeze. "See?"
Joe rolled his eyes. "I don't think muscles are supposed to be described like marshmallows."
"They're not but yours are."
Joe chuckled, shaking his head. You stared at his arm for another few seconds.
Nom.
Joe let out the most offended gasp imaginable. "OW!"
You immediately pulled away, eyes wide. "Sorry."
"You bit me! It lookedâ" Joe looked down at the tiny crescent-shaped teeth marks blooming on his arm.
"I couldn't help it!"
"You absolutely could've helped it!"
"I really couldn't."
Joe tried so hard to look annoyed. He lasted exactly three seconds before laughing into one of your plushies. "I can't believe this."
You buried your face against his shoulder. "Are you mad?"
He wrapped an arm around you. "No honey, maybe slightly offended."
"I'm sorry."
"You'd better be."
"Can I still hold your arm?" you pleaded with puppy eyes.Â
Joe sighed dramatically. "You never lost arm privileges."
You smiled. "Thank you."
"But no more biting."
"i'll try." and yet, you still keep biting it, and Joe doesn't have much choice but to endure it.
Morning came, and Joe walked into the studio carrying two coffees. Javi looked up from his guitar. "Joseph, my man. "
Joe blinked. "What?"
Javi pointed toward his arm. "What happened there?"
He thought for exactly half a second. "Ooooh, Ponkan happened."