You do understand the point.Â
Anyway, Kanda has literally stabbed Allen multiple times & attacked his friends & said some pretty horrible shit so uh⌠gotta disagree here right away. I thought about this for .2 seconds. Lavi also literally almost killed Allen though you can say that he was brainwashed or whatever so it doesnât count but still.
Kanda stabbed Allen only once, when he surrendered to his anger yes, and he reacted violently whenever he felt someone intruded his personal space, yes, we pointed that out all of Kandaâs overreactions and the other characterâs disapproval to that.Â
That first time was due to miscommunication, because Kanda and the Order mistook Allen for an Akuma and thought he was going to kill everyone. It wouldnât be the first time this happened, in Laviâs reverse novel it was revealed that a finder, Doug became an Akuma too shortly prior to Lavi meeting Allen and Lavi was forced to destroy Doug to save the people of the Order. Also, seeing how the Order was on a cliff they werenât incorrect to assume that anyone climbing their way up to a secret base is no ordinary human, of course he was deemed a threat.
Even if someone apologizes after shattering a window and yelling, itâs still scary. So, anyway, I find it hard to believe that you can brush this aside so easily when youâre being so critical of Lenaleeâs anger.Â
Lavi admitted his mistake and made effort to amend for his mistake. As I pointed out, he kept doting on Lenalee after that. The difference is that Lenalee rarely admits her mistake and the narrative rarely even implies that maaaybe Lenalee is in the wrong. Plus yelling and actual physical violence isnât on the same scale, Lenalee yelled at Allen too.Â
Lenalee has had no reason to learn to restrain her emotions like this, thus helping to explain their difference in reaction to anger.Â
Jerry taught her how to behave like a lady. And again the emphasis is not on her feeling, anger, but her action, which is being violent. Not taking out your anger on others in the form of violence is basic decency.
So this is a recurring issue I see here where youâre hypercritical of Lenaleeâs actions while brushing off the boysâ actions as harmless banter and fun. Not âpunching him so hard that Lavi canât feel his body anymoreâ does not negate the fact that they ARE STILL PUNCHING EACH OTHER. That is still PHYSICAL VIOLENCE outside of sparring.
This is kinda petty but like⌠just the fact that Lavi always calls Kanda âYuâ despite ALL the times he tells him not to is like⌠textbook not crossing boundaries AND disrespect.
The very nature of the relationship between characters are entirely different.
Kanda and Allen both annoy each other because of differences in their personalities and often cause collateral damage and beat each other to pulp. But their relationship is not unbalanced, they give and take the same treatment. And to be honest, these two are the only ones to exchange blows.
Lavi and Allen both tease and prank each other. Lavi pesters Allen who is being a brat to him in return. During that fight in the Ark Lavi wasnât even conscious, he was trapped in Roadâs world, Lavi too later claimed that when he came to his senses everything was on fire.Â
The only time when Allen actually kicked Lavi was when he intruded on Lenaleeâs privacy saying that âshe will have no boyfriend if she thinks about workoutâ. It was an overreaction on Allenâs part but Lavi did purposedly provoke Lenaleeâs anger.
Kanda usually ignores Lavi, who in turn annoys him wanting his attention but Kanda actually never hit Lavi, at tops threatened him not to call him âYuuâ. While it is a breach of his boundaries, Lavi was most likely unable to tell; seeing how Tiedoll calls him Yuu, he probably thought Kanda was just embarassed; as the records of the Second Exorcist project were all destroyed by Fou, Lavi is unlikely to know about Kandaâs origins. Indeed, Lavi even if unintentionally harms Kanda but again, Lavi has no means to know that Kanda can be triggered, his harm out of ignorance is completely different from Lenaleeâs deliberate desire to hit the boys.
With Lenalee however, all three of them are super respectful (aside from Laviâs occasional sexist remarks). They are always there to comfort her and treat her gentle, and she hits them in return?? You can argue that Kanda is an ass, but again he is not an ass to her. If Kanda is an ass to Allen thatâs their business; if Lavi pesters Kanda until he yells thatâs their problem, not Lenaleeâs personal failure to keep her dogs from fighting. She has nothing to do with the relationship of others.
Also hereâs Allen âlashing outâ and trying to punch Komui so hard that he bends what looks to be a metal clipboard. Â
Komui purposedly scared Allen because he wanted to laugh at him. Allenâs anger and violent reaction, even as overreaction is pretty legit seeing how Komui wanted to make Allen the butt off a very mean joke. If Allen had some sort of heart disease or was prone to panic attacks this âjokeâ could have harmed him seriously. Small stuff, but thereâs no data what material that clipboard was, mostly theyâre cardboard.
UhâŚ.. have you ever had someone do something incredibly stupid that almost killed them in front of you? It is very difficult to hold back on screaming at them. Youâre criticizing Lenalee for not considering Allenâs feelings when you arenât even entertaining the idea of what she felt herself. Allen should feel guilty for his stupid actions; thatâs what can prevent him from going on another suicide mission. Maybe itâs just me but not all guilt trips are bad lmao. Thereâs a reason we feel guilt.
Even though all the above was annoying as hell, this is the most infuriating.
We feel guilt when we do something wrong, when we wrong someone else. Why do you act like Allen personally wronged Lenalee?! Â
Bear it in mind that Allen doesnât act like this because he enjoys it, merely because he is so damn mentally mutilated because of the abuse and trauma he endured that he thinks himself to be worthless unless he fights.
He went after an Akuma he knew he couldnât defeat, that he knew would kill him, because to him being âuselessâ, dying without a meaning is more terrifying than death.
During his early childhood he was punished for being âuselessâ and later in the Order he was rewarded for being an Exorcist, he was loved for being âusefulâ. Not to mention that abhorrous cruse inflicted by the father he loved the most. Imagine how much that hurt. Of course he would think about himself like this. Even if he admitted something bothered him heâd rather just swallow it, because he is terrified of being a burden. Even if Allen consciously knows that his friends wouldnât abandon him and stop loving him, you cannot just stop a deeply ingrained mechanism like that.  Thatâs how mental illnesses work.
Even if she didnât mean it, in that moment her message was that âyour input doesnât matter, you should do nothing that would upset meâ. That was the a turning point in their relationship, when Allen decided he must always prioritize Lenaleeâs emotional needs, even over his own life. Allen keeps comforting her but he never exposes anything about himself to her, he acts more like he was Lenaleeâs parent than a friend. Â
Lenalee of course didnât mean to do this to Allen, but you can harm others even without meaning. It is part of living as social creatures. You still need to take responsibility and change.Â
It might be difficult to hold back, thereâs a thing called self-control. If one cannot exercise that then they shouldnât be offended when they are called out, period. Â
And even if we consider her feelings, there were many different ways to react conduct that scene. She could have said âI was very scared that Iâd lose you and your violent reaction infuriates meâ or âwhat if you died? we might not know each other for so long but you are already precious to us, do you know how painful it is to think that you might die?â just to name two.Â
Even if Allen didnât have or didnât currently have a traumatic childhood himself, consider:
Allen is by no means responsible how Lenalee feels. He is by no means obligated to place her emotional needs over himself.
Everything is better than bloody guilt-tripping. It. Never. Helps.
If you want to prevent someone from suicidal tendencies then you have to help them find a meaning why to carry on living. Even if Lenalee wanted âgoodâ, the execution was horrible, and thatâs the problem.Â
 You donât solve a suicidal personâs problem by shaming them for their suicidal tendencies. You canât solve any fucking problem by shaming people. Quite the opposite, you put an additional burden on them and make them want to die more. You just install anxiety in them. Jesus Christ, donât ever say that, that is abusive.Â
Anyway, she didnât bring him somewhere private because Allen was the one who started the conversation. This âbig sceneâ she made didnât even upset Allen, so I donât see why youâre acting like this is abusive towards him. Sheâs upset in their conversation, yes, but did you actually read the words she said? Sheâs offering support to him while expressing her own feelings. People are allowed to be angry at each other; that doesnât make them bad people.
Lenalee basically kept ignoring and avoiding him until he apologized, even though yes, he was upset. And just fyi, studies show that being ignored is registered by the brain the exact same as physical pain.
âResearch has shown that the act of ignoring or excluding activates the same area of the brain that is activated by physical pain.â: X, X, X, X,Â
If she wanted to be comforting she could have just called him aside to talk about this in private, instead of having this out in the open which ultimately is paired with a feeling of shame, because this whole scene is on public display.
BARELY BITE LMAOOOOOO how could you even say this about Kanda. Anyway even if you wanna believe heâs just bark, you canât deny his bark is pretty damn painful for his friends sometimes.Â
Link might have wanted the two to stop fighting but he intruded his own views at Kanda. âYou are a soldier of the Pope, act like itâ - sure, Link who dedicated himself to his profession by his own free will thatâs natural he thinks this way. But Kanda who was denied dignity in his death, forced to live again without free will or any memories, ripped apart every day so that he could be the Orderâs tool? Of course he is furious! Just imagine someone telling Lenalee that she should be proud to be have been abused because a âholyâ organization did it to her. She wouldnât exactly fancy that person either.Â
As for the situation with Allen, as a friend he did fail, but it is very human reaction to run away. He always did that and yes, it is both very selfish but also very human. Allenâs problems is not his responbility though. He cannot be expected to throw away everything because âAllen Walkerâ reasons. Being the sort of person he is, of course Allen thinks this is his fault, but that has little to do with Kandaâs attitude and more with the already mentioned mental abuse he endured.
Komui has literally put peopleâs lives in danger before so⌠yeah⌠Iâm kinda with Lenalee on kicking him into a concussion.Â
Then why do you bring up Allen punching him as bad?
Neither of them are in the right actually, Komui acts as if he owned Lenalee which leads to a lot of annoyance but kicking him off several levels wonât solve the problem. I just wish this gross part was left out of the story. But you cannot overlook it that Lenalee uses a freaking weapon that rips through Akuma to disciple Komui while Kanda and Allen only pointed weapon at each other during the fight at Alma Karma Arc where they both surrendered to their anger. Yes, they usually brawl and beat each other to pulp during training, but they both consent to that. Context and consent matters.
Iâm really surprised I didnât see any disagreement in the reblogs of this post because HOLY HELL how can yâall not respond to this??? This post is inspiring me to make a âkanda is violent goddamn it stop babying your favsâ masterpost.
Now this is guilt tripping. Congratulations.Â
And good on Kanda for not hitting Lenalee, but Iâm pretty sure thatâs because of the cultural âdonât hit womenâ thing rather than a âKanda is not abusive UNLIKE Lenaleeâ thing.
According to the fanbooks Kanda treats men and women the same. The only one he makes exception with is Lenalee for some reason. No one said Kanda was unproblematic baby who never did wrong. He did shit things, he was called out on it and later he admitted it as well. Thatâs character development.Â
I think most people would classify a threat as a hurt. Like does this ever happen in real life?:Â âOk, so I know you said youâre going to stab me, but you havenât actually done that as of this moment, so I have no fear or paranoia that you are going to do exactly what you said and will continue my life as normal.â
Kanda threatens heâd cut, but again, Lavi purposedly provokes him and actual stabbing never happened.Â
1) You are literally using Kandaâs past to excuse his actions. You are that person. You did that right here with this paragraph.
2) Kanda DOES hurt people.
3) Kanda eventually had Tiedoll, Noise, Komui⌠It doesnât erase the past but the fact is that he did eventually have people that protected him like Lenalee did.
4) Wow I wish people loved and protected me so much THAT THEY TIED ME TO A BED AND DIDNâT LET ME LEAVE WHILE I CRIED. Also how can you type âYes she was kidnapped and taken by forceâ and then literally in the next sentence go âbut luckilyâŚâ like ???? Iâm sorry is this trauma not good enough for you??? Should we have seen a panel of her being literally beaten for her situation to not be considered lucky??? Also I think this panel does imply that she was denied water/food and/or beaten by those marks on her cheeks, the fact that sheâs regaining consciousness (not waking up from sleep), and the lines around her mouth.
The whole paragraph was to show that yes, Kanda has his reasons to act the way he does, he was abused far worse than anyone in this series (with the exeption of Alma maybe) but that doesnât mean heâs free from blame. He might have been abused but his actions are ultimately his decision. Lenalee too might have been confined and abused but she shouldnât be granted leeway saying âshe was abused thatâs why she acts in such wayâ. The statement is true, but it shouldnât be used to just sweep Lenaleeâs mistakes under the rug.Â
No you do not know that Kanda would have said yes eventually. Kanda probably would have kept saying no. Thatâs part of the âhumorâ in this panel - getting Kanda to do something heâd never do.
Okay, so here is something youâre probably not going to like: the reason people find this humorous is BECAUSE itâs a reversal of roles. People think these kind of jokes are funny because âhaha, a women would never be able to overpower a man and make a man do that.â Itâs not female empowerment - itâs actually the opposite which is why this is a joke. Thatâs the context of the culture we are in that makes this panel a joke. If the genders were reversed, this would never be a joke outside of misogynistic media because most people recognize that it is a real life issue of abuse. Is this sexist and wrong? Yes. The fact is that this was still made as a joke and never intended to be a serious part of canon. Kanda being beaten up is exaggerated as well - do you really think canon Johnny would see a hurt and bleeding Kanda and just laugh about it? No. He would help him. God, do I really have to explain that this panel did not seriously occur as Kanda getting beaten bloody and then modeling as a result in canon?
Why would you want to force someone to do something they obviously do not want, what the hell? Kanda is an incredibly private person who avoids people and interactions as much as possible, thereâs no way he would have said yes out of his own will, ever.Â
Thereâs nothing funny about this in either setting. I love Hoshino, but seriously, sometimes her jokes are just plain gross. If Lenalee wanted a model Allen was actually more than willing. Or she could have done it too. Even if for a joke, this was pointless and people only accept it because âKanda is an asshole he deserves to be hitâ, if it was Krory, Marie or Miranda no one would laugh. Again, you make it look as if Kanda personally wronged Lenalee because he didnât want to obey.
Oh⌠my⌠god. Seriously? Iâd think this were a troll post at this point if so many people didnât reblog this in agreement. Lenalee is being traumatized in that scene! One of her worst nightmares is coming true!
All my hope is that this is a troll reply.
Allen was having the absolute worst moment of his entire hellish life. Neah was awakening, he was unsure wether Mana loved him, he was unsure wether Cross, annoying as he is but a very important part of Allenâs sanity, is alive or not, he just lost Kanda and Alma, realises Linkâs loss while he is thrown into a dungeon waiting for his the execution he was sure to have, only to have Apocryphos come and try to erase him and then have Tyki tell him that he has no right to blame anyone because his own bad decisions led to just as much grief. Everything Allen loved was ripped away from him and his âmeaning of existenceâ, his whole world was turned upside down with him having no one to turn to for help.
Yes, Lenaleeâs reaction is understandable and human. She has the right to seek comfort. No one can expect her to drop shit, forget about Komui and her own goals because of Allen Walker reasons. But at the same time she cannot expect Allen to alwas be there for her.
In all honesty, Lenalee will be fine as long as Komui lives. Losing friends hurts but as she got over Suman, Daisya and the rest who were killed and Anita, she would eventually get over Allen.Â
Also, the scale of loss are entirely different, she may lose a single piece but Allen lost everything again. In that moment Allen needed help more than any time ever and not worry about Lenaleeâs feelings. In that scenrio it really should have been her offering at least some comfort. She later realises this too.
Sheâs not forcing him to stay - sheâs bargaining, trying to see a way out of this situation where everything doesnât go to shit.  Â
In indirect way she tried to make him stay. âIf you leave we have to fight each otherâ and such. She was in denial, thinking that this was a Noah trap. But it doesnât change the fact that Allen was exiled. Even if Allen went back on his own accord he would have been killed.
I cried when I read this scene because it was so emotional and do you know how much the mood would have been KILLED if Lenalee responded the way you think she should have?
How about let Allen have a moment of weakness and have Lenalee comfort him? Lenalee realising that Allen is a human too and canât be always there for her because he has his own shit to tend to as well?
Allenâs last memory of her was not a bad one! He understands why she acted that way! He isnât guilty about it; he uses it to fuel his motivation to accomplish his goals. Lenalee is who he thinks of when heâs losing his grasp on what heâs suppose to be doing!
Moments before Lenalee came Allen was ready to break down, you cannot just recover in a blink of an eye. Just because he understands it doesnât mean it doesnât hurt. Just because he doesnât admit it it doesnât mean the sentiment is not there. Allen the one doing this to himself but suppressing hurts.Â
And that scene in 222, Allen once again puts her feelings before himself. Not only this is harmful for him but it wonât fuel him forever. You cannot truly live living someone elseâs life. Allen will need to find a reason to live for himself.
Honestly, I think you just havenât been in the fandom long enough. Lenalee hate was all the rage back in 2007 and it resurfaces at least about once a year now.
That might be but that was literally a decade ago. And then it wasnât exactly about Lenalee herself, more like that standard âthis female character is sooo weak and emtional, all she does is cry all the time and moan the main characterâs name and is nothing more than a love interestâ. See: Haruno Sakura, Hyuuga Hinata, Inoue Orihime.Â
This argument isnât even about Lenalee being emotional or pointlessly bashing her for it, itâs about the things she did do and needs to be held accountable for.
UhâŚ. youâve literally said Kanda doesnât use violence ever so I think you may need to do a check on self awareness. Donât feel bad though, a lot of people excuse the stuff Kanda does.Â
Actually Choco said: âKanda never really hurted people. Yes he pushed/shoved people away hard or yelled or even threaten them with Mugen. But he never hit or actually cut someone down.â Not that Kanda is not aggressive and violent, but mostly with words and not to a degree that would incapacitate others. Physically he only brawls with Allen and Alma, who always stood up and fought back. Do feel bad for twisting words and shaming people for not wanting to start a Discourse.
Anyway people say Cross isnât abusive when he clearly is (should I discourse on that too?) & excuse a shit ton of stuff the guys do. Do you check out DGM fanfics? Those are always the worst offenders.
Cross is not unproblematic and the fanfictions that depict him as such are few, more like the âCross is an irredeemable asshole who only used Allen for his own gainâ is dominant. He might be an excellent soldier but he is a massive asshole, never denied that. You forget that these fanfictions are mostly written by amateur teenagers and young adults, not to mention theyhave the right to interpret a character as they like. But fanon representation has nothing to do with this matter.
Again, you have to look at the chemistry. Is Cross hitting Allen and barks at him? Yes. And what does Allen do? Bite back, hit back, insult and sass. The point of abuse is to control oneâs behaviour or convine oneself to be superior to others (which connects back to being in control). Cross doesnât particularly care about that, he actually enjoys is when Allen is being a brat - his true selfish self that he keeps trying to suppress. Crossâs attitude seems to be more of a mix of Kanda and Laviâs. If you say that Cross is abusive because he hits Allen and pesters him then basically you could say that everyone abuses Allen, Lenalee included. Who by the way would never be hit in return.
Exactly? Lenalee is not abusive, so why are you making it seem like she is? This post is part of the problem. If you want less fics about Lenalee doing awful things then why are you trying to convince people she is worse than she really is? I donât understand what this paragraph is trying to say.
Lenalee does shit things in fan representation too, which actually stands closer to her flawed character.Â
The problem is that canon and in general itâs played off as a joke because she is a girl and threats and violence from girls are not taken seriously. They are even portrayed as some courageous example, rather than saying that perhaps this is not the best way to treat people you claim to love and who basically worship you.
One of her flaws is about how deeply she cares about her friends while not caring about how it effects other people but part of this post was criticizing her for that so, again, I donât understand what the goal is here. Non-problematic flaws arenât really flaws, so I donât get what youâre looking for.Â
Caring for your own people more than outsiders isnât particularly a flaw, more of an attitude, she might claim she is a bad girl but she has yet to actually harm others to save her own. DGMâs accent is on showing different behaviours and their consequences rather than trying to tell whatâs right and wrong.Â
The fact is, Lenalee HAS hurt people physically (thatâs what part of this post is aboutâŚ) so thatâs another âflawâ that is canon to include in a fic. The issue I have is that she doesnât do it more than the other characters, so I donât get why her violence is being emphasized over the otherâs.
Being quick to anger is the flaw. Hurting others because of poor anger management is a mistake.
The difference is that all the people she hits would never hit her back even if their life depended on it.
Honestly this paragraph just makes me go âughhhhhâ âcause âsometimes [fandom] even portrays [male characters] better than canon in a realistic wayâ is so⌠ughhhhhh. I can only think of two authors I would apply this statement to without hesitation, and one of them has deleted their works & the other has hidden them. Fandom doesnât accept the male charactersâ flaws; they hide them, excuse them, or ignore them.
I agree on the ughhhh, because thereâs hardly anyone who is able to not reduce them to their flaws. Â
Kandaâs violent side is magnified 90% of the time, Cross is just an irredeemable asshole and Komui is nothing more than a sis-com, the Noah are stripped from their human side and are nothing more than killing machines. Then there are actually fics where Lavi is????? Abusive???? Â
Still, yet again most fanworks are from amateurs so of course you canât expect some mind-shattering character developments and deep instrospections.
A fight isnât real without someone getting hurt, physically or emotionally. Mistakes cause damage. Real people donât always realize when they are in the wrong or even apologize half the time. These are bad things people do. They are normal things people do.Â
It is true that we make mistakes and may even cause damage, but we still have to live up to it. She needs to live up to it. Just because people donât do it it doesnât mean they shouldnât be. Itâs basic human decency. It is actually disturbing how you want to normalise Lenalee hitting people because sheâs upset.
The description you have here is of an angel, not a person.
That is how Lenalee is described 90% of the time. Half of the cast sings about how âbeautiful and strongâ she is.Â
I addressed earlier why I believe this behavior in female characters is actually based on a lack of female empowerment. Again, there is a reason this is seen as comic relief and not a serious threat.
Female characters donât need to be able to fight or be professionals to be good characters. The problem is that authors are just scared to give flaws to female characters that make them more relatable and human. At the same time, authors hardly dare give feminine traits to men.Female empowerment is about appreciating feminine values and not have them portrayed as inferior to masculine.Â
These are the flaws you say you want in a character (Though I disagree with the idea that she hurts others too extremely). Flaws are flaws; you donât get to pick and choose.
Bruh. Just let them wish.
Anyway, fandom doesnât ignore Lenaleeâs flaws - for the most part, they exaggerate it. There used to be a lot of discourse about how she does nothing but cry and be a selfish and awful damsel in distress. You probably havenât seen a lot of this in more recent years because the topicâs been beaten to death at this point.
Whenever someone says that âlook, Lenalee doing this is not coolâ the reply is âbut the others are like that too!!!â. Two bad donât extinguish each other. Thatâs not how it works. Every character has a problematic side and it should be accepted instead of denied.
Allenâs problematic side is that he is so focused on trying to save everyone by himself that he overlooks more efficient routes. In a way he hurt Kanda because he kept trying to make him forgive Alma when Kanda had every damn right to be furious. He tends to put his unrealistic expectations and ideals on others as he pursues some sort of justice for all but more often than not this hurts people, just as Tyki pointed out. Tyki asks him âdo you have the right to make people suffer because you refuse to learn the truth and just pursue your own justice?â where he calls out on his mistake.
Kandaâs problematic side is that he angers too easily and ignores everything he doesnât like and in extreme cases uses force if someone gets in his way. His question is âdo you have the right to kill people for your goals?â. He admitted it too and now he tries his best to change.
Almaâs problematic side was that they wanted to kill Kanda regardless of his input.
Cross knows he is doing something horrible by asking Allen to give in and doesnât try to deny it or ask forgiveness.Â
Road is asked:Â âdo you have the right to grief over how much it hurt you to lose your family when you rip families apartâ?
Lavi is asked: âdo you have the right to complain how humans kill each other when you could actually make an effort to stop it but you refuse to?â Road pointed the question âdo you have the right to judge people for waging wars when you do the same?â to which Lavi did realise his own hypocrisy.
Zu Mei Chang and the Order is asked:Â âdo you have the right to use humans as tools to save humanity?â
The same way, just as Lenalee questions if god has the right to make her fight:Â âdo you have the right to blame the god who makes you fight when the god gives you power to protect the ones you claim to love?â
These questions cut deep, because they reflect on the good intentions that do more harm than good. All these forms of behaviours are human, and the point of this manga isnât to evaluate them as right or wrong, it shows the unkind consequences of their decisions and actions.
True! For some people it does manifest as violence because of bad self control, but you can learn to manage your anger and hold it in through self discipline or therapy.
Something thatâs in order for her.
Iâll just continue with my train of thought earlier and say that yes, she is an ass sometimes, and thatâs one of her flaws.
I donât think anybody needs to outright tell her sheâs behaving badly? Thatâs pretty awkward for a conversation in a story. It just shows in how people get stressed or uncomfortable  or the mood changes around her in situations like that.
Her being an ass is not the problem, pretending she is a perfect angel who can do nothing wrong is. When Allen or anyone else is being an ass thereâs always the context pointing out that âkids, donât do this at homeâ, but not with Lenalee.
And yeah, you generally donât want to make your friends cry even when theyâre being mean.
Then maybe donât hit friends who risk their lives to save yours??? And why is Lenaleeâs feelings more important than actual lives???Â
Agreed for the most part but can you show me where he never blamed anyone else? âCause I was just flipping through the manga to respond to this post and I found this while looking but didnât notice what you said:
Kanda??? Realised his huge mistake almost instantly??? He was horrified???
Also??? He came back to the organisation that tortured him through multiple lifetimes to make amends??? He even wanted to have a conversation with Allen, where they settled things.
âLenalee however makes Allen publicly humiliate himself and itâs caring.âÂ
Uh⌠when?
She fights to keep them alive too? Nobody said sheâs entitled to punch them.
Thatâs the bloody point weâre trying to make.
I didnât remember this happening so I fact-checked and uh? I only see her being shocked; where is the punch? Did it get shown in like a flashback or something and I forgot about it?
Here you go, another omake about Komui going after Kanda for drinking the Innocence from her hands and Lenalee punching Kanda for it. Which again is hypocritical when you remember that she often breached Allenâs personal space.
itâs played for laughs when Kanda calls her ugly too. Itâs played for laughs when Bookman beats Lavi. Itâs played for laughs when Cross hits Allen in the head with a hammer. A lot of the violence in the manga is played off for jokes; why is everyone so heated about this one with Lenalee? Why not get mad about all those other instances too?
Wow, calling someone ugly is equal with being punched the more you learn.
I am mad about Bookman. Lavi might provoke Bookman but it is indeed overreaction, and it confuses me why Bookman is such an ass. But again, heâs another matter.
And again: different chemistry, different dynamics, different context.
I donât know where youâve seen this much justifying of Lenaleeâs behavior. Actually, I still havenât even seen an example of really horrible behavior pointed out outside of âsheâs an ass sometimesâ except for that stupid humor panel yâall keep bringing up.Â
Youâre probably not familiar with the âLenalee canât be abusive because she is an abusive victimâ post. Lenalee is incredibly selfish alone just by hitting her friends because their actions upset her.Â
I mean⌠in this post alone we have 2 people saying Kanda hasnât done that bad stuff despite his abuse as a child when⌠he has hurt people too. You can say heâs an asshole, but then when you say âKanda isnât even remotely rude to Lenaleeâ and say that his fights with Allen are mutual spars and say that despite his threats he would never actually hurt Lavi, you excuse his asshole-ishness.
Is this the real life? Did you actually read this post? I keep saying that Kanda did bad stuff and that thankfully itâs not used to make him look like someone who never did anything wrong. He almost killed a finder out of wrath. He killed Alma. He let Allen get worse because he wanted him to hurt the Order from the inside. Kanda is not a character Who Did Nothing Wrong. The point is that he admits it and aims to change. Bringing up the dynamics was so point out how often the fandom exxagerates Kandaâs violence saying that heâs going to brutally slaughter Allen/Lavi depending on who pissed him off. The âhe isnât remotely rude to Lenaleeâ is to show that she really has no reason to hit him, because he always treats her nice.
The fact that thereâs been multiple fandom dramas over calling Lenalee selfish just shows, in my opinion, that her behavior does not get excused - it gets discussed a lot. And what rewards does she get? Sheâs been apologized to, but thatâs not a reward.
She is selfish tho? And thatâs not necessarily a bad thing? If Allen was selfish he wouldnât be in so deep in shit. And being apologized to in that manner? Yes, it is a reward.
Girls hitting people = cute is sexism. The only way you can think it is cute is if you canât see women as a threat. If someone thinks itâs cute, thatâs not a positive for Lenalee.
Yes, the writing is sexist. Booking her violence as cute is sexist.Â
Doesnât Lenalee wear shorts under her skirts to prevent panty shots? Was there a panty shot I forgot about?
Sometimes I canât even tell if she wears underwear tbh. (Even with the Eshii fight the size of her shorts kept changing???) Pretty disturbing when you remember that she is 17. Another sexist stroke in this story. I hope with the reserialisation this wonât happen. Sadly Road was subject to flashing as well (even if he is practically ~50 she still looks like 13 and I want to call the child services)
This part irritates me because OP and this response both end with the idea âlet Lenalee have flaws and be brattyâ but it comes after a rant about all of her flaws. Do you want a flawed character or not?
Her flaws are not the problem, itâs her mistakes. Flaws are not necessarily mistakes. You are not doing anything wrong if you are temperamental, itâs who you are, you canât influence that. But you can control how you manifest these feelings and violence is bad. The problem is that the writing makes her do bad things but thereâs no indication that this is percieved as bad. When you try to present someone as perfect hate happens. Lenalee did some shit things but not even the context implies that she shouldnât be acting like this. The reaction is âyou deserve it for upsetting Lenaleeâ not that âLenalee, noâ.
The thing is, the audience and canon doesnât even take her hits seriously so thereâs nothing for her to âget awayâ with.
And I donât get why youâre so angry about the idea that Lenalee doesnât work to improve or learn about other peopleâs point of view
You take that out of context. âLet her have arguments and learn about other peopleâs point of view. Let her make mistakes, get called out on her mistakes and fucking work to improve.â â> Make Lenalee an antithesis. Treat her like a character with her own values and not just making her constantly worry about others and their problem. She wasnât directly confronted with the Thirds or Link in this context but it would have been a lot better. And work to imrove is to work to not make the same mistakes again eg: not hitting someone when they upset her.
I think this a overtly defensive response to someone pointing out something they observed: âpeople always find a reason to hate on her.â
If you donât follow choco-azelle you probably donât know but there was a precedent to this post, the OP in a dgm ask expressed their problems with Lenalee and immediately got this ask in reply. If they put that out in the main tags or Lenaleeâs, Iâd understand the reaction, but this was only published on their private blog. But write someone anon hate because they expressed their opinion on their own blog? Now thatâs intrusive. They could have just unfollowed, blacklisted or blocked them, what the hell is the guilt tripping for.
Theyâre not assigning moral purity; Lenalee just gets hated on more than the other 3 of the main four.
If you mean bashing the ratio is basically irrelevant. There are very few fanfics where Lenalee is an evil bitch who steals Kanda from Allen or something the like. When googling all I found was one long post from some dgm-allensexual 2 years ago and an anti club thatâs actually quite dead. There are actually more posts about âwhy does everyone hate Lenaleeâ that are basically more salt-hinting than actually making a point. No one owes you to like anyone.
I donât give a shit if people hate Lenalee - hell, I had a phase in middle school where she annoyed the fuck out of me - but this post was just so BIZARRE to me. Lenalee isnât more violent than the other 3 guys??? Out of all the characters you could call abusive and violent - Cross, Bookman, LEVIHOWTHEFUCKDOYOUSPELLHISNAME, maybe Kanda if you feel like upsetting a lot of people - LENALEE is the one who gets called out?? Like what. I just had to say something, especially since just, what, last month? there were a ton of posts going around arguing about why Cross ISNâT abusive.
If itâs not a problem for you why bother a long essay like this?
Again, the problem is that the phsysical violence is one-sided. She hits and itâs ok because you upset her. She gets called out because this shit not is not ok either and as I said, two wrong donât extinguish each other.
Cross is problematic yes. I guess people donât give a damn about Bookman? He is pretty much the most violent. Leverrier is a scum of the Earth and he knows it too. The Cross defences I know of are my own and silver-wolvesâ.
^^^^^^ OP needs to shut the fuck up. Lenalee is bae. Go release your internalised misogyny onto someone else. I thought we were past the stage where we hate all female characters for being female, but alas.
Not admitting a female characterâs flaws is just as mysoginist as hating female characters for being female. Which is not the case this time. No need for this fake sjw input.
Now that I broke this all down, a synthesis.Â
The main problem around Lenalee isnât her flaws, itâs the shitty mistakes she make and the narration around her. Even if she does marginally better than most female leads, there are traces of sexism and mysoginy. Even with all her flaws, it wants to wrap up her into some âLenalee is a cute and perfect waifu uwuâ portrayal as men shamelessly oogle her. An âinnocent girlâ who is put into some strange poses to deliver to the male gaze. She is called beautiful and strong so many times as if that was her only value as a human being or as a character with her own story?Â
Authors often donât dare to give unsighty âflawsâ to female characters like horrible morning breath, a scar that would âruin her beautyâ, being selfish without being demonized for it. When they make mistakes they are either infantilized or demonized and it shouldnât be like that. They have to be faced with the negative consequences of their actions and let them fix it. Let them have character development. Her represantation is not her fault, but it can distance you from her character.
This is not about dragging Lenalee. Having flaws doesnât make her a bad person, it makes her human. Itâs about pointing out that yes, Lenalee can be an ass and it should not be ignored so that we can say that Lenalee Is 100% Unproblematic And Did Nothing Wrong.