So, I was posting the Cool Screenshots and noticed a... Small pattern, I would say, regarding close-up shots of Simon's eyes, mainly the ones showing reflection around. Hopefully I didn't miss any of these lmao
00:11:40. When Simon notices the proximity and direction wheel warning. The reflection is on his left eye, with just the face format indicating the right eye, it doesn't really appear here. Before THIS, the scene was showing Simon's left eye moving around wildly, observing, searching.
Edit: @212thghost pointed out this moment at 00:19:46 (I hope I got the right moment! If not, just say and I'll keep searching 🧐), as Simon is confronting Ava about being sent down again. He's exactly saying "there's something alive". You need to open the screenshot and zoom in, but on his left eye, there's a brief glint of red being reflected from the blood, making his eye seem red for a brief moment. While both of his eyes are shadowed, the fact that his left eye is the one that glimmers red, only at this moment... Oh, this is a very interesting choice
00:43:06. This one is a bit hard to pinpoint, with the the eyebrows to the right and a faint wrinkle on the down of the picture, and how Simon gets up, this seems to be his right eye.
00:44:02. This is just as Simon got up and took a picture to be able to look around. Considering the format, it looks like left eye too.
00:52:55, as the Porthole shielding is closing. Again left eye.
And 01:23:13. This as Simon looks upon the Light picture. The reflection is clear on the right eye, but, unlike the previous one, we have the left eye blurry, including the reflection of the Light.
I remember how people have spoken about Right vs Left side in Iron Lung, including left being associated to misticism and mystery. This doesn't fit exactly in these choises of which eye shows which: the Light is a mystery, after all.
What I think is that, when something is shown on Simon's left eye, these are things *Simon sees as a threat or danger*: the proximity sensor warns of something too close, the porthole shielding closing is about something that could have killed him, the camera picture reflected on his eye was sudden enough that it felt like a danger to his sight.
On the other hand, if shown on his right eye, then it's probably something that Simon doesn't see as a threat or danger. The camera button light, for example, Simon was just waking up, he was neutral to it. And the Light... He was mostly confused about it. And in this shot, we end up seeing an infling of the other eye, instead of focusing fully on the right one. To show Simon is... Worried, at least?
And as an extra, 01:51:50. This is as Simon's left eye goes red, as he screams at the Eel "do you want to eat me?!". He's fully seeing the Eel as a danger he needs to deal with (Also, the eye *remains red* for the rest of the movie)
There are other shots focused on Simon's eyes, but not in the pattern of "reflecting something", at least from what I remember: just a bit before his left eye goes red, and before he uses the fire extinguisher on the radio. In these, it's very clear that the intention is to show Simon's breaking point of anger.
I may have missed some shot that will throw a wrench into this, but as of now, that's what it looks like to me lol
Edit: not me lying down to sleep and remembering one of the things we hear in the voice of Simon's mom in the voice flashback when he's going back to the SM8:
"Simon. It's a trap. It's right behind you. It's still there. On your left."
Now, I know like... Me and mostly everyone assumes these lines are probably not exactly flashbacks but something-else using her voice to warn Simon.
But. BUT. With this possible pattern of close shots of reflections on Simon's eyes... what if these lines are from an actual memory of Simon about his mom? His mom gave him a knife after all. The Eel taunts him with words about if she would be proud of the killer she spawned or not.
Her warning Simon of when humans make traps for another, teaching him to recognize and deal with them... Could very well be part of it.
This post got out of hand lmao