Hard to love
pairing: mattheo riddle x f!reader
Summary: mattheo is your ex who upon hearing that some boy invited you on a date, realises how important you are to him.
Word count: 1,6k
Warrnings: cussing
Authors note: yearning mattheo. :p
ā”ā”ā”
I sat on the sofa in the Slytherin common room, my arms folded tightly across my chest.
āI donāt give a fuck who youāre seeingā he said coldly, his jaw clenched so hard it looked painful.
I rolled my eyes, though a faint ache twisted in my chest.
āSee? Then you shouldāve gone on that date with Jakeā Pansy chimed in, inserting herself straight into the middle of our argument. A sly smirk curled across her lips as her gaze flickered between me and Mattheo again and again.
At her words, Mattheoās head snapped towards me, fury blazing in his eyes.
āHim? Seriously?ā he scoffed.
āThe fuck is your problem? I thought you said I could see whoever I wantedā My voice dripped with mockery. I wasnāt even trying to hide how much this argument was getting under my skin.
āBut him? Out of every fucking bloke?ā
His stare burned straight through me, yet I couldnāt bring myself to look back at him.
āYou said you didnāt careā I murmured quietly, my heartbeat thundering harder with every second.
āI donātā he replied coolly, though we both knew he was lying. āItās just⦠he wonāt be good for youā The last part came out quieter.
āAnd what the fuck is your problem with him anyway?ā I snapped suddenly, finally meeting his gaze with open irritation.
He parted his lips as though he were about to say something, only to shut them again a second later.
An uncomfortable silence settled between us.
āHeās boringā he said finally. āWhat the hell are you even going to do with him, play chess?ā he added coldly, letting out a mocking laugh.
I said nothing. I genuinely didnāt know what to say.
āYou deserve someone spontaneous. Someone whoāll actually make you feel alive, not some pathetic little twatā Mattheo went on.
āSomeone like you?ā I asked, rolling my eyes at the implication. Who the fuck did he think he was? We broke up six months ago. It was my life.
āYeah. Exactly someone like fucking me!ā
He said it louder than heād meant to, with far more emotion than heād shown until now.
My eyes nearly widened out of their sockets. I was so shocked at first, but then anger flooded through me in an instant.
I only caught Pansy muttering, āoh, fuckā under her breath before I rose to my feet and strode closer to him.
heād already slipped that cold bastard mask back into place. he stood there unmoved, wearing a perfectly stony expression, pretending none of it had affected him at all.
āI was fucking insane, yeah, but we used to sneak out together, you never got bored with me, we were always laughingā he said right to my face, sounding as though he genuinely believed heād been the perfect boyfriend.
I was furious with him. Standing there in front of him, watching every flicker of expression across his face, I finally snapped.
āYeah, except you conveniently forgot the part where you were constantly fucking stoned or drunk. I never knew where you were because you didnāt give a shit about me! Do you even remember me lying awake in bed worrying about you, and then youād just tell me it was ānothing seriousā? You spent more time off your face than you ever did with me on all those fucking āsneaking outā nights or ālaughing togetherā!ā
The words exploded out of me as I screamed every single thing at him that Iād never had the courage to say when I broke up with him.
The silence that followed my words was even louder than before.
Mattheo had gone pale, and for a moment it felt as though he stopped breathing entirely, until I finally forced myself to move.
I turned away from him and started walking towards my dorm.
āWaitā Y/N, wait!ā
I heard his voice behind me, followed by the sound of hurried footsteps rushing after me. A second later, his hand closed around my arm, stopping me in my tracks.
I turned to face him. He took his hand off of me.
āWhat?ā I began sharply. āam I fucking wrong, Mattheo?ā I asked in a cold voice.
Mattheo looked at me now without that empty stare he always hid behind. I could see that what Iād said had hurt him.
He dragged a hand through his hair, looking at me with those brown eyes Iād once loved the most.
āIāā He swallowed hard. āYouāre not wrongā
He said it so quietly I almost didnāt hear him.
We stood there on the staircase, suddenly alone together. Just the two of us.
āI cried almost every night because I didnāt know what to do to make you good to meā I whispered..
Tears welled in my eyes, so I turned away before he could see them and started walking towards my room.
This time, he didnāt stop me.
ā”
It was dark when loud knocking at the door dragged me out of sleep.
Reluctantly, I pulled myself from bed and stumbled towards it before opening the door.
To my surprise, Mattheo was standing there.
The water dripping from his hair and the state of his soaked clothes made it obvious heād been outside for a while.
He stood in the doorway pale-faced, his eyes glistening strangely in the dim light. I could smell alcohol on him, mixed with cigarette smoke and his cologne.
For a moment, neither of us said a word. We simply stood there in silence, staring at each other.
And then, to my complete surprise, he suddenly closed the distance between us, cupped my face in both hands, and kissed me.
At first, I didnāt know what to do, but after a moment I kissed him back, threading my fingers through his wet hair.
The kiss was filled with longing.
His lips were cold from the rain, but the kiss burned.
Mattheo let out a quiet groan against my mouth. He kissed me like a drowning man finally dragging in breath after hours spent beneath the water. A kiss carrying six months of silence, anger, regret.
One of his hands cradled my jaw while the other settled on my waist, pulling me closer as though he were terrified I might disappear.
The moment our lips finally parted, Mattheo rested his forehead against mine. For a few seconds, neither of us spoke. The only sound was the rain beating softly against the windows outside.
At last, he opened his eyes and looked at me as though he hadnāt seen me in years. He swallowed hard before whispering in a voice roughened by alcohol,
āI miss youā
I looked back at him sadly.
āYouāre drunk, Mattheoā I whispered.
My words changed nothing.
Before I could push him away or shut the door, he caught hold of my wrist. His eyes were burning now.
āIām not lyingā he whispered sharply. āI miss you every fucking dayā His voice cracked on the last word.
It was the first time in my life Iād ever seen him like this.
āI didnāt realise it⦠i didnāt fucking understand when we were togetherā He swallowed hard. āI was stupid. Always high. I walked away when i shouldāve been with youā His voice broke again. āI didnāt know how to be good to someone who actually mattered, because no one had ever mattered to me the way you doā
āMattheoāā I started, but he lifted his hand, pressing his finger gently against my lips to silence me.
I decided there was no point arguing with him in that state.
āHearing Pansy say your name alongside Jakeās, hearing about some other boy taking my placeā¦ā He stopped for a moment, as though the words themselves were difficult for him to force out. āI wanted to fucking hit him just for daring to ask you outā
He let out a quiet laugh, though there was nothing happy about it.
Then he took both of my hands in his. He brought one hand up slowly and pressed a kiss to my knuckles.
āYou were my best thingā he murmured āAnd I ruined itā
Then suddenly
He dropped down onto his knees right there on my bedroom floor and wrapped both arms around my waist tightly, burying his face into the fabric of my nightgown.
āI want another chanceā he whispered brokenly āPlease⦠give me one more chanceā
I looked down at him, feeling something inside me crack apart, and that was when it hit me that I still loved him.
Pulling myself free from his grasp, I knelt down in front of him and wrapped my arms tightly around him.
āI donāt know what to doā I admitted quietly, stroking the back of his head gently.
He wrapped his arms around me.
Then he spoke, his voice rough and hoarse.
āIāll be better, i swear to fucking everything, i wonāt drink this much anymore, i wonāt disappear, i wonāt make you sadā
He pulled me back slightly just so he could look at my face properly.
His thumb brushed away the tear sliding down my cheek.
āYou were right about everythingā he whispered. āI was selfish and stupid, but if you let me try, if you give me one more chance, iāll fix thisā
I looked at him, smiling through tears.
āDo you know how long I waited to hear that?ā I said, my voice trembling.
āIām just a fucking idiotā he laughed softly, and a second later I found myself laughing with him.
āI love you, Y/N. I never stoppedā he whispered.
And the moment I heard those words, I crashed my lips against his in a kiss.
ā”ā”ā”













