Hey babe! Hope your good! I have an ask for u. Itâs kinda big but donât worry if u donât wanna do it all, Iâm a thirsty bitch and loving what u write, just wanted to give u options, but feel free to go with what u want. So, iâd like Mikey, who else for me, right? With... 95 (80 or 81) 53 36 23, not much eh?! Lol. I love the whole nervousness from Mikey but how he still tries to act cool, and I love the build up to him getting the guts to make a move! Anyway, I will leave this in your beautiful capable hands! Donât rush, I will be waiting patiently đ§Ąđ§Ą
It will be my pleasure @nittleboo đ§Ą
Warning: Language and NSFW content đ
Mikey couldnât quite put his finger on the moment he fell in love with you. It couldâve been the day he texted you to complain about having to miss the Knicks game due to gang activity, and you recorded the game on your dvr and ordered pizza to cheer him up. Or maybe the day you agreed to go sewer surfing through the pipes with him and laughed outrageously over getting soaked. Or maybe, it was the night you called him to come over and keep you company because your cat was sick and had to stay overnight at the vet clinic and you were too worried to sleep. You were his confidante, his partner in crime, his best friend. You shared movies, pizza and dirty jokes. It was inevitable, wasnât it?
He found himself thinking about you far too often. His brothers noticed him daydreaming even more than usual these days, and suspected they knew the reason. You, however, were completely clueless as to his growing feelings for you. Mikey was conflicted on how to handle the situation. If he kept it to himself, he didnât risk your friendship. But it would slowly drive him crazy. If he confessed, you might reject him, and the thought of that was too painful to consider. Either way, he feared he was headed for a broken heart.
He finally reached his breaking point one warm weekend in July. It was hotter than hell outside, and muggy to boot. There had been a pipeline burst that knocked out the running water in your apartment building and it wouldnât be fixed till Monday. You had asked to spend the weekend at the lair, and of course, the guys were gracious enough to say yes. Mikey was beside himself. Part of him was ecstatic to get to spend a whole weekend with his crush, and the other part wanted to throw up because, hello, an entire weekend trying to pretend that he wasnât head over heels for his best friend.
When you arrived with your duffel bag, you were greeted by voices coming from all over lair. Raph lifting weights, Donnie working on the computer, and Leo practicing his katas in the dojo, exactly where you expected them to be. You frowned when you realized you hadnât heard anything from your orange banded bestie.
âWhereâs Mikey?â you looked around quickly, expecting him to jump out and try to scare you.
âUm, his room, I think,â Donnie answered, never looking away from his monitors.
You tossed your bag by the couch and made your way to your favorite turtleâs bedroom. Normally, youâd just waltz right in but today, you paused. This was the first time you had come to stay the night and, if you were being honest, you had nervous butterflies in your belly. Like the stealthy ninja he was, Mikey had managed to sneak into your heart. You had no idea if he would ever see you as anything other than his best friend. You were hoping that the close proximity this weekend would help you figure out what to do.
You raised a hand to knock on the door when it abruptly opened. Mikey blinked in surprise, then grinned broadly. He met your raised fist with his own in an odd fist bump.
âBabycakes! Youâre here!â
You couldnât help but beam back. His smiles always brightened your day.
âHey Mikester! Are you ready for all the fun weâre going to have?!â
He giggled and you could swear that his cheeks had a touch of pink to them. He grabbed your arm and dragged you back over to the couch, where he produced two controllers and a stack of dvds.
âGames or movies first?â
âGames. Iâm going to kick your scaly green ass!â
âOh youâre on, y/n!â
Playing video games with Mikey was a very active experience. He was not above pushing his opponent and half wrestling to make them lose. An hour of gaming and horseplay later, you were sweaty and ready for a break.
Your head whipped around so fast, you nearly gave yourself whiplash. Mikey chuckled nervously, âI mean, look how sweaty you are!â
You narrowed your eyes momentarily, then let it go. Mikey wasnât flirting with you, right?
âYou guys ready to eat? I got pizza!â Raph yelled from the kitchen. You knew the drill, you jumped up and raced as fast as your legs could carry you. These fellas could put it away and if you wanted any for yourself, you needed to snatch and grab quickly. Armed with a plate of pizza slices and a can of soda, you planted your butt on the center cushion of the couch. All four turtles joined you around the tv, and Donnie started a movie from the stack on the coffee table. He sat on one side of you, and as per usual, Mikey took the other spot. The movie was cheesier than the pizza but at least it was entertaining. You laughed uproariously at the commentary from Donnie and Leo, and groaned at the burping contest between Raph and Mikey. Towards the end of the movie, you glanced to your left to find a pair of baby blue eyes looking back dreamily.
âUm, can I help you? Why are you staring at me?â
You felt a slight flush and knew that your cheeks were probably pretty pink. Thank goodness it was mostly dark in here. Mikey felt panic rising at being caught staring.
âUh, I just, um...â he babbled.
âMan, that movie sucked ass.â
Oh thank god, saved by Raph. Mikey breathed a sigh of relief. That was close. Everyone started making their way to bed. Leo gave you a pillow and a blanket before bidding you good night. Mikey stood by the couch awkwardly while you went and changed into your pajamas, a tiny tank and shorts set. âYou gonna tuck me in?â you joked. Mikey chuckled and made a big show of tucking the blanket around you.
âSweet dreams Angelcakes,â he whispered as he leaned over and kissed the top of your head, surprising you both. He quickly straightened and went straight to his room without another word. As soon as he was safely hidden from your view, he collapsed on his bed. Mikey rubbed his hands over his face. He had almost blown it. You had been so absorbed in that terrible movie, he couldnât stop looking at your beautiful face. The way your eyes lit up when you laughed had made his chest feel warm. He tugged his blanket up and stared at the ceiling. How was he supposed to sleep when you were so close? He tossed and turned for nearly an hour, when he heard his bedroom door creak open.
âMikey? Are you awake?â
âIâm sorry if I woke you, but that couch is really lumpy and uncomfortable. Can I, um, can I sleep in here? With you?â
Mikey froze. âWith me?!â he squeaked. Act cool, act cool, he chided himself. âYeah, sure.â
He scooted over and pulled the covers back for you. You climbed in next to him and pulled the covers up to your chin. The silence was awkward for you both. Mikey felt hot and cold all at once. He was half afraid that he might throw up. You frowned in the darkness. You could feel the shift in Mikey and it worried you. Maybe you misread him earlier?
Mikey took several deep breaths. He was being ridiculous. You two were best friends, you could move past this if his feelings werenât reciprocated, right? Either way, he was miserable trying to act like nothing has changed. It was time to suck it up and spit it out. He rolled over to his side, facing you, and braced himself for rejection.
âHey, y/n, thereâs something I need to tell you.â
You rolled towards him nervously, âYou know you can tell me anything, Mike.â
âYeah right, of course,â he rubbed his hand over his bald green head. âLook, you are....my best friend. I couldnât stand it if that ever changed. But...dude, this is hard.....â
You placed a hand over his in encouragement and squeezed. He gulped and tried again.
âI, uh....IthinkIâminlovewithyou.â he winced, and waited for you to break his heart.
Your eyes widened and you swallowed hard. Slowly, so as not to spook him, you scooted closer and placed your hand on his cheek. You touched your forehead to his, and whispered, âI love you too, Mikey.â Then you pressed your lips so softly to his.
It felt like time had stood still for Mikey. His heart pounded faster and faster as you kissed him. His first kiss and you initiated it. You kissed him and you said YOU LOVE HIM. In an instant, you found yourself on your back with an exuberant turtle on top of you. You couldnât help but giggle as he covered your face in kisses. You grabbed his head to hold him steady and kissed him more firmly this time, and he caught you by surprise when his mouth opened slightly and his tongue licked tentatively against your lips. You opened your mouth and moaned quietly as he wasted no time tangling his tongue with yours. His hips were settled between your thighs and the longer you made out, the more you couldnât help but notice the impressive bulge pressing against your heat. His hand snaked under your cami and squeezed your waist, then feeling braver, he slid it just under your breast. âCan I touch you?â he breathed. At your eager nod, he cupped the mound and swiped his thumb over your puckered nipple. Pushing your top up, he nuzzled your boob, giggled at the way it jiggled, and decided he needed a taste.
âHoly fuck Mikey!â you whisper-yelled at the first strong suckle. He pulled back to swirl his rather large mutant tongue around the pert nub, then sucked it back in between his teeth for a gentle nip. Turning his head, he lavished the same attention on your other breast, while you tugged your cami the rest of the way over your head. At this, he lifted his head as he held still.
âUm, do you, you know, maybe wanna, you know...â
âThis?â you purred, rolling your hips up against his obvious boner.
âYES! Uh, yeah, ya know, yep.â
You canât help but laugh softly. This was your Mikey, innocently naughty. You raised your knees up and hooked your toes in his shorts, shoving them down. He lifted his hips to help, and you were pleasantly surprised to find he was commando. Once his shorts hit the floor, his hands went straight to your pj bottoms and grabbed the band of the shorts and your panties and pulled them both off, tossing them over his wide shoulders. He sat back on his haunches and admired what he could see of your body in the darkness.
âHot damn, youâre gorgeous Babycakes.â
Before you could say thank you, your legs were over his shoulders and his snout was nosing at your pussy. You never thought you would experience this with him, not in a million years, and the sight of his shiny green head between your thighs caused a gush of hot liquid to drip out of your core. Mikey noticed immediately and took his fingers and spread your labia to get a closer look. âSmells fucking amazing,â he whispered as he went for his first taste. His tongue flattened against your entrance and oh so slowly swiped up to your clit. He closed his eyes and savored the flavor of your juices on his tongue. Then he attacked like a starving man at an all-you-can-eat buffet. You had to bite your fist to hold back your squeals and squeaks. It was sloppy, it was messy, and you were bucking your hips uncontrollably. Everything you would expect from your beloved Mikey.
âFuuuuuck!â you moaned as your first climax hit with the force of a typhoon. If this was what it was like with him as an amateur, you shivered to think how good he will be with experience. He kept licking as you rode out your release, then lifted his head with a grin, shiny from your juices.
He sat up and positioned himself at your entrance.
âIs this, you know, still okay?â
When you sat up with him, he feared that you had changed your mind. He wasnât expecting you to grab his shoulders and push him down to the bed. When you straddled his waist, his face lit up. And when you lifted yourself over his straining cock and pushed down, he lost his breath. Damn, you thought to yourself, heâs bigger than anyone Iâve ever been with. You took your time easing down, having to take a few breaks to adjust to his size. Once he was all the way in, you began ride. Up and down at a reasonable rhythm for your first time together. Mikey felt like he had died and gone to heaven. You felt so hot and tight, milking his member, and the friction was making him see stars.
âAre you doing okay?â you asked breathlessly. It was hard to read his face in the dark, his expression was either completely blissed out, or wincing in pain.
âPer-mmm-perfect!â he managed, grabbing at your hips to guide you. He began to buck up wildly as he slammed you back down, âIâm gonna cum,â he whined.
âGo ahead, baby,â you panted. But he shook his head vigorously.
âNo, you have to-fuck-you gotta cum again f-first!â
He was trying so hard to hold it back, but you felt too good and it was his first time, after all. He made an odd sound, almost like a growl, hips stuttering, then he was thrusting madly as he shot his load deep in your womb.
The only sounds in the room were your harsh breaths as he lay beneath you, chest heaving.
âY/n. That was so fucking incredible!â his voice rose with each word and you had to shush him before he woke the rest of the lair. âYeah, Mikey, it was.â you whispered. Everything had changed now and you couldnât be happier.
âCan we do that again?â