Tita and Carmy
NOTE: This has been sitting in my drafts since 2024. I never really continued working on it.
Like Water for Chocolate (1992) 10/10, excellent.
I came across a couple of posts mentioning some similarities between The Bear and the Mexican film "Como agua para chocolate" (Like Water for Chocolate). I remember watching it years ago, however, I didn't remember it 100%. HBO recently added it to their platform, so I rewatched it, and I totally agree: there are similarities, starting with the most obvious one, food.
I'd like to share some parallels between Tita, the protagonist, and Carmy. I should mention that other people have already pointed out some of these, but I wanted to add a few more.
Spoilers ahead.
Three siblings.
Tita and Carmy are the youngest children.
A difficult birth. Both Tita and Carmy are their mothers' last child and the most difficult delivery (this observation comes from @freedelusionshere ).
A family with an absent/dead father. Tita's father died when she was a child; Carmy's father disappeared.
A mother who, in the father's absence, has to take over the family business. Mamá Elena takes charge of the family hacienda, while Donna takes charge of The Beef.
A protagonist who expresses their frustrations and desires through food.
A mother who takes out her frustrations on her children, especially the youngest one (other blogs have already pointed this out as well).
Pedro, Tita's love interest, has to redirect the feelings he has for her toward her sister Rosaura; however, he does this in order to stay close to Tita. This reminded me of the metas that suggest Carmy redirects what he feels for Syd toward Claire.
An absent/deceased sibling. Mike on one side; Gertrudis on the other. The middle sister runs away, and Mamá Elena forbids anyone from mentioning her name again. To her, Gertrudis is dead—or at least that's what she says in public, while privately she mourns her absence. Later, it's revealed that Gertrudis is the daughter of Mamá Elena's one true love (who is not her husband), which explains the depth of her grief. As a result, we could infer that Gertrudis was Mamá Elena's favorite child.
Tita reaches a mental breaking point and withdraws into herself for a time. It's worth mentioning that a bowl of beef broth helps restore her sanity. This part of the story reminds me of posts suggesting that a dessert or dish might become the catalyst for Carmy and Syd's relationship. Likewise, others have suggested that when the dish is finally ready, the relationship will be ready too.
Tita lives under her mother's shadow even after her death. It isn't until she confronts Mamá Elena's ghost that she fully frees herself. I've seen posts suggesting that Carmy, by confronting Donna, will begin his path toward peace.
That's as far as I got with this draft. I saw that @otherworldlyfatevoyage was looking for a post connecting The Bear and Like Water for Chocolate, so I decided to post it now.
Another note:
By the way, Like Water for Chocolate (Como agua para chocolate) is a Mexican expression. According to the internet:
"The phrase comes from traditional kitchens when preparing hot chocolate. For the chocolate to turn out perfectly frothy, the water must reach its exact boiling point and be actively boiling. The metaphor compares that state of the water—hot, turbulent, and about to overflow—to a person who is 'boiling' with anger or passion."
In Mexico, hot chocolate is traditionally made with water and cinnamon.
My mom says my grandmother used that expression all the time when she was angry, so I've always associated it more with someone boiling over with anger












