PLL Thoughts, Theories, and Ramblings

If Cece was in Radley how was she also Rosewood High prom queen and featured in the year book?

Why would Cece send Ali a message saying “I buried your mom the same way I watched her bury you”?

Marion and Alison met when Alison was a teenager; yet she supposedly died when Charles was around 12, making Alison a child.

Wilden worked on the case of Marion’s death, despite him being probably a few years older than Charles. He would have been a teenager.

Seth the creepy Ravenswood kid said a male and female were after Ali and they both had dark hair. Who was he talking about?

Wren gave Cece visitors passes to see Mona in Radley, despite her already being a patient.

Cece knew Ali was alive as she was helping her; why did she dig up the grave? Why was she always searching?

We were told we could rewatch from season 1 and it would become obvious, despite Cece being absent until season 3.

How were we to know Cece stole the game from Mona? This was always used as a hint, yet until last night, we had no idea she was in there.

The entire show has been about A and the liars. The reason for her hating them was so simple. What was the point of it all?

Where are the NAT videos?! What was in them?

Why was Jessica nice to Bethany if she accused Charles of pushing Marion?

Why was Bethany’s whole story a huge let down? She was a huge mystery and we didn’t even see her face.

How was Cece out of Radley for so long when she visited Cape May? Very unrealistic.

Why was Cece pretending to be Ali in Radley?

How realistic is it that a transgender woman would have a male persona? Why did she identify as Charles in the dollhouse?

Why did Leslie say Charles and Bethany escaped Radley together and they were friends?

Did Jason see Bethany that night? If so, why was she talking to Melissa?

What is Sara’s motive?

How did Cece literally transition over night?

Why did Spencer say Charles was familiar and felt like a “childhood friend”? Cece wasn’t familiar to her at all.

Who killed Jessica?!

Why did Marlene always emphasise the title Black Widow?

What the hell did Maya know? Just tell me about Maya please.

What was the relevance of the song Walkin After Midnight?

Where is Wren, Melissa, Jenna, Noel, Lucas? Why did they all have so many clues?

What was the rotting smell coming from the Dilaurentis basement?

Why did we need to know Andrew was adopted?!

Why did Spencer have blood on her in the dollhouse?

Why did Cece make Aria dye her hair?

How did Cece keep up the A game whilst she was a Radley patient? How was she always in and out without being caught?

Why was Shana in Wren’s apartment before she was “A” and tried to kill Ali?

How did Mona never know she killed Bethany when she was literally helping Ali fake her death like an hour later?

Why would Cece dig up and desecrate what she thought were the remains of a sister she loved?

How did Cece have the time/means/resources to build the dollhouse without help?

How was Cece able to have friends from high school and an active social life, connections at UPenn, an apartment with a roommate, and a high ranking full-time position at a boutique if she was sneaking in and out of Radley the whole time?

What was with Jessica’s story about Cece checking herself into Radley as Alison? How would the Radley staff not recognize her and call Jessica asking bout Alison?

What about Cece’s story about Alison getting her kicked out of school?

Both Red Coat and Black Swan/Widow were introduced long before Sara was even mentioned on the show, how were we supposed to have been able to guess?

Red Coat and Black Widow are one in the same.

or 

Black Widow and A are one in the same.

This post is fully in response to this amazing theory from AnalyzingA (pictures from there as well).

Back in Season 1, episode 16, Aria finds out Hanna gave her mom the ticket to the art exhibit that she was going to with Ezra. Aria is extremely mad and they have what I think is the biggest fight that we’ve ever seen any of the four liars have with one another. Aria is seen at the end of the episode writing furiously in her diary. It wasn’t until I saw these screencaps that I had any idea what she wrote in the diary, as it only flashes on the screen for a second or so.

In case you can’t read that, check out the theory I linked above. It has the full text (the parts that are legible, at least). But basically, Aria is writing about Mrs. Potter (the woman from the bank who Ashley stole money from her safety deposit box). What’s interesting is that Aria is writing about James Leland, the guy who shows up to town claiming to be Mrs. Potter’s only living relative.

There are two VERY odd things about this:

1. Aria writes this in her diary in S1E16. James Leland doesn’t show up until S1E17. How in the world would Aria know about him before he showed his face at Ashley’s bank?? Aria never even had mentioned knowing anything about Mrs. Potter, let alone her nephew. In fact, keeping that a secret was what A had on Ashley that she used to blackmail her with to get her to give Ella the ticket to the art exhibit. Suspicious.

2. If you look at the wording Aria uses in the diary entry and then watch the scene in S1E17 when Hanna discusses James Leland to Ashley on their porch, you will notice the wording is EXACTLY the same. Word for word. I really don’t know what to make of it… but Aria wrote the script for that scene.

Sometimes I waiver on my feelings about Aria being A, but I am just completely at a loss as to how this could be explained UNLESS Aria is A. She not only predicted the future… she wrote it.

This post is fully in response to this amazing theory from AnalyzingA (pictures from there as well).

Back in Season 1, episode 16, Aria finds out Hanna gave her mom the ticket to the art exhibit that she was going to with Ezra. Aria is extremely mad and they have what I think is the biggest fight that we’ve ever seen any of the four liars have with one another. Aria is seen at the end of the episode writing furiously in her diary. It wasn’t until I saw these screencaps that I had any idea what she wrote in the diary, as it only flashes on the screen for a second or so.

In case you can’t read that, check out the theory I linked above. It has the full text (the parts that are legible, at least). But basically, Aria is writing about Mrs. Potter (the woman from the bank who Ashley stole money from her safety deposit box). What’s interesting is that Aria is writing about James Leland, the guy who shows up to town claiming to be Mrs. Potter’s only living relative.

There are two VERY odd things about this:

1. Aria writes this in her diary in S1E16. James Leland doesn’t show up until S1E17. How in the world would Aria know about him before he showed his face at Ashley’s bank?? Aria never even had mentioned knowing anything about Mrs. Potter, let alone her nephew. In fact, keeping that a secret was what A had on Ashley that she used to blackmail her with to get her to give Ella the ticket to the art exhibit. Suspicious.

2. If you look at the wording Aria uses in the diary entry and then watch the scene in S1E17 when Hanna discusses James Leland to Ashley on their porch, you will notice the wording is EXACTLY the same. Word for word. I really don’t know what to make of it… but Aria wrote the script for that scene.

Sometimes I waiver on my feelings about Aria being A, but I am just completely at a loss as to how this could be explained UNLESS Aria is A. She not only predicted the future… she wrote it.

This post is fully in response to this amazing theory from AnalyzingA (pictures from there as well).

Back in Season 1, episode 16, Aria finds out Hanna gave her mom the ticket to the art exhibit that she was going to with Ezra. Aria is extremely mad and they have what I think is the biggest fight that we’ve ever seen any of the four liars have with one another. Aria is seen at the end of the episode writing furiously in her diary. It wasn’t until I saw these screencaps that I had any idea what she wrote in the diary, as it only flashes on the screen for a second or so.

In case you can’t read that, check out the theory I linked above. It has the full text (the parts that are legible, at least). But basically, Aria is writing about Mrs. Potter (the woman from the bank who Ashley stole money from her safety deposit box). What’s interesting is that Aria is writing about James Leland, the guy who shows up to town claiming to be Mrs. Potter’s only living relative.

There are two VERY odd things about this:

1. Aria writes this in her diary in S1E16. James Leland doesn’t show up until S1E17. How in the world would Aria know about him before he showed his face at Ashley’s bank?? Aria never even had mentioned knowing anything about Mrs. Potter, let alone her nephew. In fact, keeping that a secret was what A had on Ashley that she used to blackmail her with to get her to give Ella the ticket to the art exhibit. Suspicious.

2. If you look at the wording Aria uses in the diary entry and then watch the scene in S1E17 when Hanna discusses James Leland to Ashley on their porch, you will notice the wording is EXACTLY the same. Word for word. I really don’t know what to make of it… but Aria wrote the script for that scene.

Sometimes I waiver on my feelings about Aria being A, but I am just completely at a loss as to how this could be explained UNLESS Aria is A. She not only predicted the future… she wrote it.

This post is fully in response to this amazing theory from AnalyzingA (pictures from there as well).

Back in Season 1, episode 16, Aria finds out Hanna gave her mom the ticket to the art exhibit that she was going to with Ezra. Aria is extremely mad and they have what I think is the biggest fight that we’ve ever seen any of the four liars have with one another. Aria is seen at the end of the episode writing furiously in her diary. It wasn’t until I saw these screencaps that I had any idea what she wrote in the diary, as it only flashes on the screen for a second or so.

In case you can’t read that, check out the theory I linked above. It has the full text (the parts that are legible, at least). But basically, Aria is writing about Mrs. Potter (the woman from the bank who Ashley stole money from her safety deposit box). What’s interesting is that Aria is writing about James Leland, the guy who shows up to town claiming to be Mrs. Potter’s only living relative.

There are two VERY odd things about this:

1. Aria writes this in her diary in S1E16. James Leland doesn’t show up until S1E17. How in the world would Aria know about him before he showed his face at Ashley’s bank?? Aria never even had mentioned knowing anything about Mrs. Potter, let alone her nephew. In fact, keeping that a secret was what A had on Ashley that she used to blackmail her with to get her to give Ella the ticket to the art exhibit. Suspicious.

2. If you look at the wording Aria uses in the diary entry and then watch the scene in S1E17 when Hanna discusses James Leland to Ashley on their porch, you will notice the wording is EXACTLY the same. Word for word. I really don’t know what to make of it… but Aria wrote the script for that scene.

Sometimes I waiver on my feelings about Aria being A, but I am just completely at a loss as to how this could be explained UNLESS Aria is A. She not only predicted the future… she wrote it.

*I want to look back on this after the episode and see what we actually got and what we didn’t*

- We will see the first scenes from the time jump at the end of the episode.

- Ali will learn a lot of things about the Dilaurentis family 

- The Charles reveal will happen within the first 20 minutes of the episode.

- One or more People may die in the episode.

- There is a possibility someone is Alive 

- Something about Sara will be ‘shocking’

- A/ Charles is someone Alison and the girls know - Someone they would least expect to be ‘A’ and it rocks the girls’ world.

- Everything will make sense. And ties together beautifully. But the episode will be dark and emotional.

-A is someone we’ve seen before, both unmasked and masked, he is not a random character and has been in 5 episodes, -A is under 50 and is not a parent, -A has many disguises and is not one of the liars. 

- There are a few secrets about Alison and we’ll learn about them.

- We will see dead people in the finale. And the Charles reveal will explain how he has a “personal connection” to each of the girls.

- The Carissimi group will be discussed and we will discover how they link to the girls and Charles and also Mrs. D. Also Rhys Matthews’ role will be unveiled.

- We will discover Who hit Alison over the head? Who killed Bethany? Who killed Toby’s mom? Who is Red Coat? Who is Black Widow? and Why -A became -A, and also how -A has so much money.

-  There is one big shocker that does have to do with Mona

- We should prepare Kleenex for the finale because it makes her cry every-time she see’s it.

- Red Coat will be in the finale

- We will find out who Charles is at the exact same time as the liars

- We will see the Yellow Top again in the finale

- We will learn more about Marion

- We may learn more about Sydney/ Jenna/ Mona

- We will learn why A has been targeting the PLLs all of this time

- And we will learn the story of why Charles became A

- We will get closure on Toby’s mother

- We’ll get answers about the Lodge fire from 3x24

- We’ll get to see Bethany Young’s face (Mar then said this was a hard question to answer so this may not happen)

- Emison will have a ‘sweet’ moment

-  Charles’ revenge or whatever he’s looking for, whatever makes him want to be ‘A’ – has been happening for way longer than Mona’s motives for being ‘A’ were. They are way bigger than anyone could’ve ever imagined. There will be more on that and it’s pretty crazy! Charles has been planning this thing for a lot longer than when Mona was even wearing the hoodie.

1. A is a human

2. A lives in the continental United States

3. A has a cell phone

Who is going to rewatch the WHOLE series between now and January to find all the clues they missed?!?!?!?!?

I’ve been re-watching some episodes again and In 4x19 Shadow play Ezra is talking to Spencer and he says

Which reminded me of this in 6x06 No Stone Unturned

There’s a poem and basically everyone should know it even just the well known part ‘Cross your heart, hope to die stick a needle in my eye’ The childish oath meant that you were very serious about maintaining a secret or verifying to your truthfulness.I looked around and managed to find the full version.

“cross my heart and hope to die stick a needle in my eye wait a moment, i spoke a lie i never really wanted to die. but if I may and if I might my heart is open for tonight though my lips are sealed and a promise is true I won’t break my word, my word to you. cross my heart hope to die stick a needle in my eye. a secret’s a secret my word is forever I will tell no one about your cruel endeavour. you claim no pain but I see right through your words in everything you do. teary eyes broken heart, life has torn you apart cross my heart hope to die stick a needle in my eye I loved you then i love you now I’ll still love you though I’ll break my vow. I can’t hold this secret any longer it’s hurting you not making you stronger. you’re my friend so I’ll risk your respect by hurting you i can protect I’ll save yourself since you will not you might hate me but I'll give it a shot. I’m willing to risk our bond that we own so long as you’re safe you won’t be alone. cross my heart hope to die stick a needle in my eye break my promise tell a lie save my friend though, maybe it’s ‘bye.”

The poem speaks for itself really it could also perhaps signify the saying ‘An eye for an eye’ (and a tooth for a tooth)  which is said to show that you believe if someone does something wrong that person should be punished by having the same thing done to them.

I’m back, bitches, and I know EVERYTHING. - A