This is probably how Lily found out Remus was a werewolf
Lily : Hey Remus! Can I ask you a question? I just want to say that if you don't want to answer this question, it is fine, but if the answer is yes I would never look at you any differently. You will still be the same-
Remus : Lily...who told you? Did you tell anyone else?
Lily : Nobody...figured it out myself. And no I will never tell anyone if you don't want me to. Though I am pretty sure a lot of people suspect it already.
Remus : Wait what! So the entire school already knows that I am a werewolf!
Lily : Wait what...you're a werewolf...
Remus :
Lily :
Lily : I was asking if you were gay....













