Hii! I love you so much. Can you please write a really smutty poly!mauraders with a fluffy ending? (Ignoring wormtail because I'm still mad at him.) If not it's okay, I just love your writing! đŤś
competition | poly!marauders
pairing: poly!marauders (james, remus, and sirius) x fem!reader
warnings: smut (MDNI 18+), anal, not proofread
a/n: everyone in my inbox always tells me how much they love when i make the boys bicker, especially in the bedroom, so i hope it's okay that i threw that in here a bunch :) i also donât know if this is as smutty as you wanted, but i hope itâs okay!
ââââââ âž ââââââ
Remus flicked the ashes of his cigarette out of the bedroom window, smoke leaving his lips along with a chuckle. "Yeah, right."
Sirius shrugged as he took a drag from his cigarette. "The results speak for themselves."
James, who didn't smoke because it would taint his athlete lungs (as he so humbly put it), propped one leg up as he backed up against the bed frame, adjusting his position on the floor. "You fucking wish."
"I could do that if I tried. You're not special, Pads. I just don't because I know it would be too much for a girl, especially around the full moon," Remus said.
"Oh here he goes again with his rough sex werewolf shit," James threw his hands up in the air, getting a laugh from Sirius.
"Stay jealous, Prongs. Stay jealous," Remus replied.
"Never made a girl squirt though, have you? You stay jealous, Moons," Sirius challenged.
"Surely you know that we do not believe you," James said.
Sirius sighed, leaning back onto his mattress, propping himself up on his elbows. "Well, when her cum shot all over my face, it did feel pretty fuckin' unbelievable."
"Just because virgins think you're good in the sack doesn't mean you are," Remus chimed back in, "how are they supposed to know that there's so much better out there?"
"Oh, I'm sorry," Sirius said, leaning back up and tilting forward in Remus's direction, "I didn't realize you have a history of fuckin' making virgins squirt. I didn't realize this topic was so familiar to you, how dare I."
"It can't be that hard to make a virgin squirt, Sirius, I'm feelin' like that's pretty easy," James said.
"The real challenge is with experienced girls," Remus said, blowing more smoke out of the window, "You think you're all that? Get back to me when you make someone impossible to please come. Not even to squirt, just to come."
Sirius diverted his gaze from Remus to James, who looked to Remus, who looked back at James, who then turned to Sirius. "That a challenge?" Sirius asked.
"Maybe it is."
"Well if I'm gonna try, you're gonna try, you fucking asshole," Sirius told Remus.
"What, is James just off the hook? We all know he can't do it anyways."
James threw his hands up again. "I can do it."
"Okay, so pick a girl," Sirius said, raising his brows in challenge.
In a mocking voice, Remus joked, "but how will we ever find a girl that sex god Sirius Black can't please?"
"You think Y/N would do it?" James asked.
"You don't think that might ruin our friendship?" Remus questioned.
"Let's review," James said, standing up and beginning to count his points on his fingers, "one, we've all been friends with her for forever, so she trusts us. Two, we all know she's got experience, and we know there's a bunch of guys who haven't been able to make her come. Three, she doesn't strike me as someone who would get attached and ruin our friendships over sex. And four, perhaps the most important of all: she's hot and we all wanna fuck her."
"How the fuck do we even broach that subject?" Sirius asked, "are we supposed to ask her to let us fuck her as a competition? Do we just try to kiss her and see where it leads? This is Y/N for fucks sake."
"Correct," Remus responded, "it`'s just Y/N. I feel like it'll be way easier to ask her than some other random girl."
"Oh, Sirius has no problem asking random girls for sex," James joked, though he was serious.
"The only reason we're friends with Y/N is because she turned you down, do you remember that, Jamie?" Sirius shot back.
"She didn't turn me down, jackass, she was in a relationship. Otherwise, I would have for sure gotten to hit that."
"Big bad James and his big bad muscles on the big bad Quidditch team, ok then," Remus joked, "irresistible to all girls. Oh wait! Except for one."
"If you're jealous of my body, Moons, just say it. This," he gestured down his torso, "takes a lot of work."
"You're really talking yourself up when my skinny ass gets more girls than you do, and more boys too, for that matter. I'm sorry, which one of us has had sex with the majority of your Quidditch team? Oh, not you? Weird," Remus responded.
âYou know that fraternization on the team would be frowned upon, why would you say that when you know-â
âOh relax,â Remus cut James off.
âDoesnât matter how many guys you get, Moons, you still canât make Y/N come.â
âWhat are we, just going off the honors system here? I already donât believe Sirius made someone squirt, you two want me to believe you if you just say you did it? Whereâs the proof?â James questioned.
âProof? What do you want us to do, suck her cum up in a syringe, you fucking weirdo?â Remus replied.
âNo no, itâs a fair point,â Sirius chimed in, âI donât believe half the shit you tell me anyway.â
âOk, so what do you wanna do then? Fuck her at the same time?â Remus asked.
James and Sirius exchanged a long glance.
âYou two arenât serious.â
James and Sirius both shrugged.
âIâm not fucking her with you two idiots in the room ruining it,â Remus said.
âOh, I beg to differ,â Sirius said, âIâd only make it better. For her especially.â
âWould not.â
âWould too.â
âYou think youâre such a fucking sex god-â
âItâs not a little weird to fuck the same girl at the same time? What are we gonna do, take turns?â James asked.
âSheâs got three holes,â Sirius said.
âOkay, but the entire point of fucking her is to see who can actually make her come, idiot,â Remus said, âso obviously that doesnât matter. Iâm not sticking my dick somewhere that Iâll be able to feel one of yours, guys.â
âWhy not?â James asked genuinely.
âBecause, because-â
âBecause, because, come on, Rem, itâs only weird if you make it weird. Iâve seen your dick before.â
âMe changing in front of you is not the same as us fucking someone at the same time.â
âThe thought of watching her get railed by one of us doesnât do anything for you?â James asked.
Remus blinked, unable to cohesively think of a rebuttal. âI mean.â
âMhm,â Sirius nodded.
âOkay, so itâs agreed, weâre all gonna fuck her with the rest of us there so we have proof we arenât lying, and weâre gonna see who can make her come,â James said.
âWhat if we can all make her come?â Remus asked.
âThen whoever does it first?â James tried.
âThat doesnât necessarily mean anything, I mean what if she comes harder for one of us? Once she comes itâs gonna be too easy to make her come again. Like thatâs not a good gage,â Sirius said.
âNo no, we share space equitably. No one hogs any part of her. Whoever makes her come first, wins,â Remus said.
âWins what, exactly?â Sirius said.
James shrugged. âLetâs let her decide.â
ââââââ âž ââââââ
Your gaze diverted between the three boys in front of you, your book laying open in your lap as you adjusted your cross-legged position on the common room couch. âAre you joking?â
âNope,â said Sirius.
You processed for a few moments. âOkay, and what exactly do you get if you make me come first?â you asked.
James dipped his head and smirked. âWe were uh- we were actually gonna let you decide that one.â
You raised your brows. âYou were, were you?â
ââŚYeah.â
You nodded your head up and down, thinking and processing. âAnd you all just assumed Iâd say yes?â
âHonestly I donât think we ever got that far,â Remus admitted.
âRight, right,â you said, âright.â
âYou can say no, you know,â Sirius said.
You turned toward him. âI know.â
âSo are you saying no?â he asked.
âNo,â you replied, quicker than you anticipated.
âAre you saying yes?â Sirius pressed.
You pondered Siriusâs question. âCan I have a day or two to think about it?â
âOf course, of course,â James said.
Luckily you had plans in Hogsmeade the next day, which gave you an opportunity to give the boys an answer.
When Dorcas and Mary left the Hogâs Head early to âwork on some overdue assignments,â you were left alone with the boys.
âSo I have an answer for you,â you said.
âAlready?â Remus said.
âYeah, already, jackass.â
âAnd?â
âIâm down.â
All three boys exchanged glances. âYeah?â
âDonât act so surprised. You said no strings, you guys are hot, and fuck if I donât need a good orgasm. The boys around here donât do it for me, as you well know.â Youâd tipsily told them several times how none of the boys at school could make you come.
âAnd you think we can?â
âIf youâre really gonna try this hard, I think at least one of you has a shot. With all the sex you have? Please. If one of you canât make me come, no one can. Itâs worth a shot, and three tries is better than one.â
âOh, so youâre using us?â Sirius joked.
âMm, only because you guys wanted to use me first,â you lightheartedly shot back.
âFair enough,â Sirius surrendered.
The conversation quickly shifted when butterbeers and pumpkin juices arrived, and all attention turned toward drinking games and late-night escapades.
As you walked through the cool-breezed, darkened streets of Hogsmeade, you took note of the lack of people around. You were sure the boys didn't notice.
"Where are you going?" Remus asked, watching you drift toward an alleyway.
You made a come-hither motion at the boys as you stepped into the alleyway, scanning quickly for any sign of life and finding none.
"What are you-" you grabbed Remus's face, cutting him off with a kiss. Without a second thought, Remus's hands found your waist, pulling you closer to him on instinct.
Both you and Remus were experienced enough to turn the kiss into a heated exchange quickly. You bit his bottom lip, and in turn, he took the moment of disconnection to slip his tongue into your mouth.
He took steps forward, backing you up until your back collided with the outer brick siding of Scrivenshaft's Quill Shop. Remus pulled away, thinking he had slammed your body into the wall too hard, but you immediately pulled him back. His body had no choice but to respond immediately, his hand holding the side of your jaw in place as his lips traveled down to the side of your neck.
The gap of his face in front of yours allowed you time to open your eyes and see Sirius and James watching the exchange intently.
"Guess Remus is going first then?" you teased.
"No, no, that's not the arrangement," Sirius said, "we all said no hogging. We all get equal shots. Move the fuck over."
Sirius grabbed your throat and pulled you forward into a kiss, causing Remus to stumble to the side in defeat.
Remus gestured to James to do what was just done to him to Sirius, but James wasn't one to fight for attention. James was one to wait until he was wanted, and until you were begging from attention from him. He would wait his turn patiently.
"Heathens," he snickered, "let her breathe for 2 seconds, would ya?"
Sirius pulled away, but his hand remained on your throat. "I'm sorry, I don't see you winning right now, do I? Shut up and maybe you'll learn something."
He resumed kissing you, and his hand dropped from your throat, tracing down your body until it landed between your legs. He pulled away to look into your eyes. You gave him a "yes" nod to signal that you consented to his touches.
That was the moment Remus decided he was done standing there like an idiot.
He dropped to his knees directly beside Sirius, tracing his fingers tauntingly slowly up your thighs, aiming for under your house-colored skirt.
Sirius noticed his efforts, and their hands collided directly on your underwear.
Like petulant little boys, you felt Sirius smack Remus's hand away, then Remus's hand smack him back, and then Sirius pulled his hand out from under your shirt and smacked Remus on the side of the head.
"Ass," Remus said his body moving sideways, causing his hand to leave its place under your skirt, "what the fuck was that for?"
"No one said we have to play fair," Sirius replied, shoving his hand back under your skirt and cupping between your thighs.
You barely reacted apart from a small gasp.
"You really are a tough one, huh?" Sirius teased, his hand falling for a moment.
Smirking, you responded, "you wanna make me come? You're gonna have to put in the work. Unless you think you can't handle it? Too busy fucking girls and not women?"
"Working me up is only gonna make this more intense for you," Sirius taunted, "you're playing a dangerous game."
"Don't listen to him, he's a cocky fuck," James laughed from behind Sirius.
You shifted your hips and let out a small moan. Sirius thought his words were really working you up, until he looked down to see that Remus had not only snuck his way between your legs while you and Sirius were talking, but that his head disappeared under your skirt.
Sirius decided to let Remus do some of the hard work before he chimed back in to bring you to the edge, so he stepped back, crossing his arms and sighing as he stood next to James. "At least flip the skirt up for me, gorgeous."
You pulled your skirt up, bunching it up and tucking it into its own waistband, leaving Remus visible, and when he pulled away to breathe, your core as well.
Remus flicked his tongue over your clit, one hand on your hip hooking a thumb around the fabric of your underwear to keep it to the side. Your fingers intertwined into his soft curls, keeping him in place as he moved his tongue faster and faster.
"You're kinda good at this," you spoke breathily, earning a moan of acknowledgement, the vibrations adding to your pleasure.
James decided to step in, standing to your side and turning your face toward him to finally take his turn at a kiss. The kiss was slow and passionate, the intimacy of it making you even wetter for Remus between your legs. His glasses fogged up due to the heat radiating off of your body.
When James pulled away, he kept a hand under your chin to keep your eyes on him instead of Remus. Remus's unoccupied hand began to take over his tongue's spot, circling your clit as he moved his face further back, teasing your entrance.
You let out a moan, staring into James's eyes. James nodded when you made the noise. "Good girl, that feel good?"
"Mhm," you responded, moaning again.
Remus's tongue began to fuck into you, his hand still working your clit. You used your hand to press his face further into you, refusing to give up the pleasure. You so rarely were properly pleasured by men, since they were typically unfamiliar with how to actually work their way around a woman's body, but you had a feeling that at least one of these three had to know what they were doing. You hoped it would be all of them.
As far as who you wanted to win, well, you didn't really have a preference. Honestly, all of them were hot, and you would be happy coming for any of them. Of course, there was a little bit of stake in the game. They allowed you to pick the prize for whoever won. You hadn't told them yet, but the prize would be you. Consistent sex-capades with the one girl around who could truly do it for them? That's a prize in itself.
You knew they had a lot of sex. You knew they slept with a ton of people, but you also knew that they were usually the ones giving the pleasure, not receiving it. The prize? That would change.
"Fuck, Jamie," you moaned, still staring into his eyes as Remus ate you out.
Remus pulled away, his hand never stopping as he said, "that's not fucking fair, I'm the one doing the work down here. He didn't even earn his name."
"And you think you did?" James challenged.
"She's only moanin' cus of me," Remus shot back.
"Well, you clearly haven't made her come, and you've been down there long enough," James said, "my turn."
Remus had the same thought as Sirius, and opted to let James do some of the work as well.
He sighed and backed up, and James dropped to his knees.
Despite being on his knees, James gripped the back of your thighs, hoisting you up so that your thighs were resting on his shoulders. You squealed in surprise at his strength.
"You're strong," you said.
"You have no idea," he responded, gripping your ass and pushing you into his face, immediately beginning to move his tongue at a rapid pace, his head shaking back and forth from the speed.
"Oh fuck," you moaned, throwing your head back and knocking it against the brick, "fuck, just like that."
Sirius approached again, standing directly behind James an pushing his head further into you. He leaned over James and kissed you, swallowing to whimper that followed.
James refused to stop, eating you out like he was starving. Each time you made a noise that Sirius found hot, he pushed James's head harder into you. James didn't let out a single noise of protest.
You looked down and spotted Sirius's hand on James's head, forcing him to increase the pleasure his mouth was giving you, and it caused your core to flex.
"Fuck," you gasped, "oh my god, James, fuck."
"Earned his name, I see," Sirius teased, turning to Remus.
Remus pretended to act annoyed, but anyone could see his dick straining against his pants for dear life. Even if the name you moaned wasn't his, it was still hot nevertheless, and he knew it would be his name when he was the one making you come. He had no doubts. Why not let James and Sirius have a little fun first?
Part of the reason you were so hard to make come was that man didn't understand that just eating out or just penetration wasn't enough for you. These boys had no idea that as long as they remained kneeling between your legs, they were already way off.
It took ten minutes of James eating you out before he took a breath. "Fucking hell, are you close?"
You giggled. "I don't know, am I?"
Remus caught on. "You need to be fucked, huh?"
"Okay fuck you, she might actually be close," James said, but stood up anyways.
"Didn't you guys pick me because you knew it wouldn't be easy?" you asked.
James gripped your chin and pulled your face against his, trapping you in a heated kiss to remind you that he could, in fact, make you feel good.
âUp,â Remus said, snaking his arms around your thighs, prompting you to jump and wrap your legs around his hips.
You watched in the gap between your bodies as Remus pushed everything below the waist down, exposing his long, slender cock.
He gently pressed his forehead against yours, looking between your bodies as well as he lined himself up with your entrance. He waited a moment for you to revoke consent, but when you didnât, he pushed himself into you.
You tilted your head back as he bottomed out, barely giving you any time to adjust before he started fucking you.
You locked your legs behind him, crossing your feet to keep you in place. He kept his hands under your thighs to hold you up as he fucked you, his lips trailing down to your jawline.
âShit, Remus,â you moaned.
The use of his name only egged him on more, causing him to start fucking into you faster. âGood fucking girl, I can feel you squeezing me,â he whispered into your air.
You whined and whimpered as his cock pumped in out of you, and Remus was beginning to lose control.
You squirmed momentarily, and Remus grabbed your hand in his own, moving it over your head and pinning it against the brick wall. âStay fucking still.â
You saw a window of opportunity, and arched your back. âOr what?â you breathily asked.
Remus nearly growled, immediately dropping your hand and wrapping his fingers around your throat. He snapped his hips harshly, not caring about the competition anymore, just caring about fucking you the hardest youâve ever been fucked. His hand pressed your neck into the brick, rendering you unable to move your head. In tandem with deep thrusts, he repeated, âstay. Fucking. Still.â
You obeyed.
You opened your eyes and spotted James, who was covering half of his face with his hand, breathing deeply to maintain self control. The eye contact only added to your arousal, because Jamesâs eyes were trained on you so intensely that you almost couldnât handle it.
Your hands explored Remusâs body, feeling muscles on his arms that you couldnât see in the light of day on his relatively skinny frame. You pawed at his hips, involuntarily trying to push each thrust even further into you.
Sirius approached you two, his cock in hand as he gently stroked himself. âLet her off the wall.â
Remus, sweaty and losing breath, removed his lips from sucking your jawline to look at Sirius. âIâm fucking occupied.â
âLet her off the wall,â Sirius repeated, âI didnât say you had to stop fucking her.â
Remus dipped his head into the crook of your neck. âI fucking hate you,â he said, directed as Sirius, but he remembered the terms he agreed to, and knew he was hogging you. So he moved his hands to your thighs again, and stepped backward from the building, his cock still in you.
The shifting of his hips as he moved was causing stimulation without Remus even trying.
Remus turned so that your back was to Sirius, and he resumed fucking you, slower this time. His arms moved you slightly up and down to aid in his thrusts, his hips moving the best he could without you pressed against the wall.
Sirius pressed your back against his chest, his head dipping into the crook of your neck as he began to kiss your shoulder, your neck, and your jawline, until he turned your head sideways and kissed you.
You allowed your body to fall into him, Remusâs thrusts causing you to jerk upward every few seconds. Sirius fought to hold your head against his, but honestly you moving due to getting fucked only made him harder.
âYou ever done this back here before?â Sirius whispered to you.
âMhm,â you responded, barely able to speak from how hard Remus was thrusting into you.
Sirius spit into his hand and rubbed it up and down his cock, preparing himself.
âStop for a second,â Sirius told Remus.
âFuck no,â Remus said, lost in pleasure.
âStop for a second or this could hurt her, dumbass,â Sirius clarified.
Remus stopped thrusting and pressed his forehead to your collarbone, catching his breath for a second and trying to stay still until he could resume movement.
Sirius lined himself up, wrapping one hand around your stomach, and using the other hand to hold your ass up as he slowly pushed himself into your ass.
You leaned your head back onto his shoulder, allowing him to take his time stretching you.
âWould you fucking hurry up?â Remus snapped, clearly annoyed.
âYou can wait 10 more seconds,â Sirius replied, trying to focus on restraint.
âShouldnât have to, selfish fuck.â
âIâm selfish? Who just stood here fucking her without me or James getting-â
âJust fucking get to it,â Remus was losing control by the second.
âThatâs what Iâm doing, thank you very much.â
âItâs just like you to be cocky while youâre literally sticking your dick in-â
âWell maybe if you stopped fucking distracting me then I-â
âWould you two please shut up and fuck me?â you chimed in.
Sirius was finally bottomed out, and he tested the waters by thrusting only an inch or two at a time. Once he started a normal pace, Remus began his own relentless pace again, barely even acknowledging that Sirius was there.
When Remus thrusted in, jerking you backward, Sirius would take the opportunity to thrust forward as well, the two boys not having to move a ton because you were being tossed between their cocks, the movements giving you makeshift thrusts.
âJames,â you said.
He perked up, somewhat shocked that you said his name while sandwiched between his two best friends.
âYeah?â
âI need you to touch me,â you said.
Remus and Sirius both looked up to acknowledge what was happening, but ended up looking up directly at each other.
They stayed watching each other for a moment, their breaths staggered and their faces glistening from sweat.
Sirius reached past you and grabbed the back of Remusâs head, pulling him in.
Sirius and Remusâs lips collided directly next to you, and the sight of them kissing as they both fucked you almost did you in.
Almost. James approached your other side, not daring to interrupt the hotness of the kiss, and he placed his own soft kiss on your temple.
âYou want me to touch you?â he teased.
âPlease, Jamie,â you were not above pleading to get what you want.
James ran his hand down your body, which was still bouncing up and down, slowly dragging between your breast area and down your stomach. He stilled just under your skirtâs waistband.
âAsk me for it again,â James said.
âPlease touch me, James, I need it so bad.â
His hand moved lower.
âHow bad? You need me to make you come?â
âI need it, I wanna come, please Jamie, please.â
âAtta girl,â he said.
He kissed you as he began circling your clit with his finger. You moaned into the kiss, garnering the attention of Sirius and Remus, who breathily pulled away from one another to watch your body react to now being touched.
You leaned back against Sirius, your moans escalating in both frequency and volume.
âOh m- fuck, Iâm gonna come,â you moaned.
Sirius and Remus both began to fuck you harder, but you stopped them quickly.
âNo, no, do what you were doing,â you said, âdonât escalate. Fuck me like you were.â
The boys both resumed their previous pace, and you felt the knot begin to form in your stomach.
James applied a slight bit more pressure to your clit, and you knew you were in for it.
âIâm coming, I-â
You came hard, your wetness completely coating Remusâs cock as your orgasm washed over you. It was so intense, likely from your body not being used to men making you come like this, that your legs started to shake. You would have fallen if it werenât for two boys holding you between them.
James gradually slowed his hand down, kissing you through the orgasm to help calm you down.
Remus couldnât help himself but join you. He hit your cervix with three brutal thrusts as he allowed himself to come, his head resting on your shoulder as he took a breath.
After you and Remus had calmed down, Sirius pulled out of you, allowing Remus to place you down. You stayed clinging onto Remus, not convinced that your legs would work after being hoisted up for so long.
Sirius had already taken a step back to finish himself off, roaring lowly as he came and painted a brick on the wall white.
That left James, who looked completely pleased and content.
âYou didnât-â
âOh, I did,â James said, looking down.
You spotted the wet patch between his legs, and realized that James came without any stimulation of his own, but just from watching all of you and doing to you what he did.
Remus finally pulled out of you, stepping back from you and running his fingers through his hair. âFuck.â
After a few minutes of everyone resetting and catching their breath, it was Sirius who finally asked, âso? Who won?â
âClearly me,â James said, âshe asked me to touch her, and thatâs what did her in.â
âIâm sorry, whose cock was hitting her g-spot?â Remus smiled.
âIt was the DP that did it, obviously, idiots,â Sirius defended himself.
They all turned to you.
âTie.â
âNo no no, itâs not a fucking tie,â Sirius said, walking back over to you, âwhich one of us did it for you? You have to pick one.â
âNo I donât,â you shrugged.
âYes, you do.â
âNo, I donât, Sirius,â you said, âIâm allowed to decide itâs a tie. Iâm not in your little competition, I donât have to follow any rules. Itâs a tie.â
âBut-â
âYou were all fucking me at the same time, what did you expect?â
âSo- so who gets whatever the winner gets, then?â James asked.
âAll of you, I guess.â
âYeah? And what do we all get?â Remus asked.
âWell, you all just came, so I guess you gotta wait,â you responded.
James raised his brows. âThe prize is a blowjob? From you?â
âYeah,â you said, âas many as you want, whatever you want with me, whenever you want, yeah.â
Remus smirked. Sirius chuckled and smiled wide, and James was still in disbelief.
âI havenât come that hard in months,â Remus said.
âAnd that was without me even trying.â












