☆ joe keery x fan fem!reader ☆
hi guys!! i’m sorry i disappeared for a little bit 😭 life has been a little busy lately, but i’m finally back. i think this is actually the longest one shot i’ve ever written, so i really hope you enjoy it as much as i enjoyed writing it 🥹 thank you so much for all the love on part one, i genuinely didn’t expect it. i love reading all your comments and as always, my requests are open! <3
summary: months after losing touch because of bad timing (and one very unfortunate phone replacement), you unexpectedly reunite at another show. what starts as a backstage catch-up quickly turns into an unforgettable night watching tame impala together.
warnings: fluff, fast burn, concert setting, backstage scenes, kissing, alcohol mention, mild language, public affection, no use of y/n
The formatting has been updated to remove the spaces between paragraphs, as requested.
The number Joe had written on the back of the setlist had seemed unreal for at least the first twenty-four hours.
You had checked it more times than you would ever admit, turning the paper over whenever your friends asked to see it again, studying the uneven row of digits as though one of them might suddenly rearrange itself and expose the whole thing as a joke. It did not help that the setlist itself already felt like something you should have framed instead of carrying around inside your bag. There were creases along the edges from how tightly you had held it after the show, a faint smudge where someone’s hand had brushed the ink, and the short message Joe had written beneath the last song before adding his number.
Your friends had spent the rest of the night insisting that you needed to text him immediately.
You had waited until the following afternoon.
Not because you were trying to seem uninterested. There was no version of the situation in which you could convincingly pretend that you had not spent an entire Djo show pressed against the barricade, singing every lyric until your voice nearly disappeared. Joe had watched you do it. He had handed you the setlist himself. Acting indifferent after that would have been ridiculous.
You had waited because you had no idea what someone was supposed to say to Joe Keery after receiving his phone number at a concert.
Eventually, you had sent something painfully ordinary.
hey, it’s the girl who almost lost her voice last night
His answer arrived less than ten minutes later.
almost? you sounded fully gone by the end
That had been how it started.
For two days, the conversation moved in small, irregular bursts. It was never one of those endless exchanges where both people stayed awake until morning, telling each other things they had never told anyone else. Joe had rehearsals, meetings, and people constantly pulling him in different directions. You were travelling with your friends and already had plans that had been arranged long before he had leaned over the edge of the stage and placed a folded setlist into your hand.
He asked whether your throat had survived. You told him you had been forced to communicate almost entirely through hand gestures at breakfast. He sent back a laughing reaction and said he accepted no responsibility. You told him it was absolutely his fault. He said the band had played exactly the same way they always did and that your lack of self-control could not reasonably be blamed on them.
Later that evening, he had asked what you were doing the next day.
we might be around in the afternoon. you wanna do something?
You had stared at the message long enough for one of your friends to snatch the phone from your hand, read it, and begin silently screaming into a pillow.
The answer should have been easy.
Instead, you already had tickets for something your friends had wanted to do for months, and cancelling on them because a famous man had sent you a last-minute text felt like the kind of decision you would spend the next five years being mocked for.
i can’t tomorrow. we already have plans all day
His response had arrived a few minutes later.
You had sent an apology you did not really owe him. He had told you to stop apologising and added that he would be back in the city soon anyway.
A week later, you asked where he was. He answered from an airport. A few days after that, he sent a photo taken from the back of a car and complained about having no idea which time zone his body thought it was in. You replied while you were at work and could only send short messages between everything you were supposed to be doing. By the time you were free, he was asleep or busy or somewhere else entirely.
Neither of you deliberately ended the conversation.
It simply became harder to restart.
The final exchange was almost embarrassingly uneventful. He asked how your day had been. You answered several hours later and asked about his. He replied the following morning, you reacted to the message, and then nothing came after it.
For a while, you considered sending something else.
You could have asked about the tour. You could have sent him a song. You could have found any excuse at all, but every possible message looked different once you typed it out. Too eager. Too random. Too much like you were trying to remind him that you existed.
He was Joe Keery. His life was filled with film sets, recording studios, interviews, airports, crowded rooms, and people who wanted something from him. You were the girl he had noticed in the front row once. The fact that he had wanted to meet you had been strange enough. Assuming he wanted to continue talking after the timing failed twice felt like pushing your luck.
What you did not know was that, several weeks later, Joe dropped his phone badly enough to make repairing it pointless, replaced it in the middle of travelling, and lost a collection of numbers that had never properly transferred.
He still had the conversation on another device somewhere, probably buried beneath work emails and accounts he barely remembered the passwords for, but he did not have it when he first realised your name had disappeared from his contacts. He had searched for it twice, tried different spellings, and spent enough time staring at the empty results that Jake finally asked what he was doing.
Joe had dismissed the question.
Then tour continued, days blurred into each other, and the problem became one more thing he told himself he would fix when he had time.
By the time Djo was announced as the opening act for Tame Impala in Miami, you had almost convinced yourself that the entire thing with Joe belonged to the same category as the concert itself. An improbable night that had happened, mattered, and then ended before ordinary life had the chance to ruin it.
The Tame Impala tickets had been purchased long before the opener was announced.
You and your two friends were already insufferably excited. The three of you had spent weeks sending each other live videos, arguing over which songs had to be included in the set, and planning how early you needed to arrive if you wanted any chance of making it close to the front. When the venue announced that Djo had joined the show, your group chat had become unreadable within seconds.
Your friends remembered everything.
They remembered the setlist. They remembered the number. They remembered the way you had attempted to act normal while repeatedly checking your phone for the next two days. Most importantly, they remembered that the conversation had ended without any actual explanation.
One of them had called it fate.
The other had said that calling a concert lineup fate was exactly how people ended up embarrassing themselves in public.
You had told both of them to shut up.
Still, arriving in Miami felt different after that.
You tried not to build the possibility into something larger than it was. Joe might not see you. Even if he did, he might not recognise you. Months had passed, the first venue had been smaller, and stage lighting made the audience look like a dark, moving mass interrupted by phones and flashes. There would be thousands of people in front of him this time. Believing he would pick you out again sounded delusional when you said it aloud.
That did not stop your friends from forcing their way towards the barricade with the determination of people entering a battle.
By the time the venue filled, the three of you were pressed together near the front, close enough to see the crew checking cables around the circular stage. The setup stretched into the centre of the floor, surrounded on every side by fans. Technicians moved beneath white work lights while the crowd grew louder each time someone appeared who vaguely resembled a musician from a distance.
Your friends were excited in the same way you were, but the possibility of Joe recognising you made them nervous on your behalf. They kept looking at you whenever the stage lights shifted, smiling like they knew something you did not.
“You both need to stop doing that,” you said, leaning close enough that they could hear you over the music playing through the venue speakers.
“We’re not doing anything,” one of them answered, already laughing.
“You’ve looked at me six times in the last minute.”
“That’s because you keep pretending you’re calm.”
Neither of them bothered replying. Their expressions were enough.
When the house lights finally dropped, the argument disappeared beneath the sound of the crowd.
Post Animal entered from the narrow passage cutting through the audience, surrounded by security and stage staff. You saw the them first, figures moving quickly through the darkness as hands reached over the barriers on either side. Then Joe appeared behind them with his guitar, head slightly lowered while he followed the others towards the centre platform.
For one brief, stupid moment, every message you had almost sent returned to you at once.
Then the first song began, and none of it mattered.
You had not come to stand still and wait for him to notice you. You had come because you genuinely loved the band, and the second the opening notes filled the venue, you fell back into the same instinct that had caught his attention the first time. You sang. You shouted with your friends. You recognised every transition before it happened and reacted to guitar changes before most of the people around you understood what song was coming next.
The stage was larger, the lights brighter, and the distance between you and Joe slightly greater than it had been at the previous show. Sometimes he faced the section opposite yours. Sometimes his attention stayed on the guitar or another member of the band. Whenever he moved towards your side, your friends pushed closer together and tried not to laugh at the fact that you suddenly seemed determined to focus anywhere except directly at him.
Joe did not recognise you immediately.
He noticed your section because it was loud. That was all.
The circular setup made it difficult to focus on any one part of the audience, and the light coming from beneath the stage cut harshly across his vision whenever he looked outward. Faces appeared in fragments, visible for a second before colour and shadow changed them again. He could tell that a group near the barricade knew the songs. He could hear three voices shouting lyrics loudly enough to reach the stage during quieter sections.
Something about one of them felt familiar.
He looked towards you twice without making the connection.
The first time, you were turned towards one of your friends, laughing after she sang the wrong line and attempted to cover it by yelling louder. The second time, a spotlight moved directly across the audience and forced him to look away before he could see more than the shape of your face.
By the middle of the set, the familiarity had begun irritating him.
He knew he had seen you somewhere.
He also knew that thinking that way during a show in front of thousands of people was probably meaningless. Musicians saw countless faces from stages, backstage corridors, airports, restaurants, and rooms full of strangers. Familiarity did not always mean recognition. Sometimes it was only the brain trying to organise too much information at once.
Your friends noticed him looking before you did.
One of them leaned towards you during the end of a song and shouted, “He keeps looking over here.”
“He’s looking at the crowd.”
“There are people behind us.”
“There’s a barricade behind us.”
You ignored her and took a drink of water, refusing to give either friend the satisfaction of watching you search for him.
The band moved into the next song. For several minutes there was no space to think about anything except the music. Joe crossed to the other side of the stage, Wes said something into the microphone that made the crowd laugh, and the three of you shouted along with everyone else when the song ended.
Not a dramatic one. Just the few seconds needed to adjust equipment and prepare for the next song. The noise from the audience surged into the opening, individual voices competing to be heard before the instruments started again.
You had already screamed enough that your throat felt rough.
The words left your mouth with no plan behind them.
Both friends snapped towards you. One doubled over against the barricade, laughing so hard she could barely breathe. The other covered her face with both hands, shoulders shaking.
Onstage, Joe lifted his head.
The response came through the microphone before he had fully decided to say it, amused and slightly confused. The crowd around you erupted, partly because he had answered and partly because several sections had no idea who he was answering.
You shouted it again, but the noise swallowed most of the sentence.
Joe narrowed his eyes against the lights and stepped closer to your side of the stage.
“Oh, hey,” he said, laughing as though he could see whoever had yelled clearly enough to acknowledge them, even though all he really had was a vague outline and the certainty that the voice had stirred something in his memory.
Your friends were completely useless after that.
One grabbed your arm hard enough to make you stumble sideways. The other was staring at Joe with an expression of open disbelief, silently mouthing that he had answered you as though you had not also heard it through an enormous sound system.
You tried to tell them that it meant nothing.
You were still smiling when the next song began.
He did not properly identify you until the set was over.
The band finished to a roar that seemed to travel around the entire circular stage. They thanked the crowd, threw a few remaining picks, and began moving towards the exit route while crew members hurried forward to start changing equipment for Tame Impala. The transition had to happen quickly. Cases rolled onto the platform almost before the final feedback disappeared, and security formed a moving line to clear a path through the audience.
You knew the band would pass close to your section.
The barricade shifted beneath the pressure as people leaned forward, raising phones and stretching their hands into the narrow walkway. Security repeatedly told everyone to step back, but the warning barely changed anything. Your friends pushed you towards the edge of the group, both insisting you needed to be closest to the passage.
“You’re being insane,” you told them, trying to keep your balance.
“You’re welcome,” one replied.
Joe appeared behind two other members of the band, still holding the guitar pick he had used during the final song. His hair was damp from the heat, his shirt clinging slightly at the collar, and he looked more focused on following security through the chaos than on any one person in the crowd.
He slapped several outstretched hands as he passed.
Your hand was one among dozens at first. He touched it briefly, already turning towards the next person, and nearly continued walking.
Something made him look back.
Maybe it was your face now that the stage lights were no longer between you. Maybe it was your expression, caught somewhere between excitement and the nervous expectation that he would move past without recognising you. Maybe it was simply the fact that he had spent an entire set trying to place a voice he had heard months earlier.
You saw the exact moment the familiarity settled into recognition.
Joe’s eyebrows lifted, and a short, surprised laugh escaped him. He did not stop long enough to create a scene because the people behind him were still moving and security was trying to keep the path open, but he turned fully towards you for one second.
He reached for your hand again.
This time, instead of a quick touch, his fingers closed around yours. He pressed the guitar pick into your palm and held your hand just long enough to make it clear that it had not been an accident.
“Hey,” he said, almost lost beneath the crowd.
There was no time for anything better. No perfect line, no reference to the messages, no explanation for why months had passed without either of you managing to speak again.
Joe glanced at your two friends behind you. Both had gone strangely quiet now that he was close enough to hear them.
Then as he waked away, he looked at the security guard walking beside him.
“Those three,” he said, pointing subtly towards your group. “Can you bring them back?”
The guard followed his gesture. “All three?”
“Yeah. In a few minutes.”
Joe looked at you once more, as though confirming you had understood him, then security pushed the line forward and he had to keep moving.
Your hand remained closed around the pick.
For several seconds, none of you spoke.
The crowd surged back into the space left by the band, everyone beginning to reposition themselves for Tame Impala while the crew dismantled and rebuilt parts of the stage. Your two friends turned towards you at exactly the same time.
“What just happened?” one asked.
The pick sat in the centre of your palm, warm from his fingers.
“He told security to bring us back,” the other said, sounding as though repeating it might make the sentence easier to understand. “He specifically said all three.”
“You’re being way too calm.”
Your voice cracked slightly on the final word, destroying any possibility that they might believe you.
Both of them began laughing.
The next five minutes felt longer than the entire Post Animal set.
You stayed near the barricade because you had no idea what else to do. Every member of security who passed made all three of you look up. Your friends kept adjusting their clothes, checking their hair using their phone cameras, and telling each other to act normal while behaving in the least normal way possible.
“You’re not allowed to mention the text messages,” you warned them.
One friend looked offended. “Why would I mention the text messages?”
“Because you have no self-control.”
“You’re the one who screamed that he was hot through a silent venue.”
“It became silent to me the second you did that.”
Before you could answer, the security guard returned.
He leaned over the barrier and pointed towards the three of you. “You’re with her?”
Your friends nodded instantly.
The crowd around you noticed.
Several people began asking what was happening while the guard opened a narrow section near the barricade. You slipped through first, your friends directly behind you, and tried not to think about the number of phones turning in your direction. The guard led you away from the main floor through a side entrance beneath the seating, where the sound of the crowd became muffled by concrete walls and heavy doors.
The backstage corridors were colder than the venue and brighter than you expected. The shift from coloured stage lighting to plain fluorescent white made everything feel abruptly real. Crew members pushed equipment cases past you. Someone carrying a bundle of cables stepped aside at the last second. Voices came from rooms with temporary signs taped to the doors, and every few feet another member of staff hurried past with a radio clipped to their clothing.
Your friends had become silent.
The friend who had spent the entire show shouting now held both hands tightly around her phone, eyes moving across everything as though she were afraid to miss a detail. The other caught your gaze and immediately began smiling.
“I was going to say you look terrified.”
The security guard glanced back, amused, but did not interrupt.
He led you through another doorway and into a wider backstage area crowded with members of Post Animal, technicians, a few guests, and people wearing laminates you could not read from a distance. The band had only just returned. Bottles of water were being passed around. Someone had opened a cooler near a row of folding chairs, and several instruments were already being moved towards cases.
Joe was sitting on the edge of a large black flight case with a towel draped around his neck, listening to Javi say something while attempting to open a bottle of water.
He saw you almost immediately.
His attention shifted past Javi’s shoulder, and the tired expression left his face.
So did two other members of the band.
You felt both friends move closer behind you.
Joe stood, finally managing to twist the bottle cap loose. He took a quick drink before walking towards the three of you, looking between your face and the pick still held in your hand.
“It’s been five minutes.”
“People lose things fast around here.”
“That sounds like a personal problem.”
Javi made a short sound behind him, something between a laugh and an approving reaction.
Joe looked over his shoulder. “Don’t start.”
Your friends were trying not to laugh. One failed first, hiding it behind her hand. Joe glanced towards her, then at the other, who immediately looked down as though being caught watching him was somehow embarrassing after she had stood in the front row of his show.
“You guys can talk,” he told them. “We’re not going to make you sign anything.”
That made both of them laugh properly.
“They were louder before,” you said.
“We were not,” one protested.
Joe pointed towards the venue. “I heard all three of you from the stage.”
“It was definitely mostly you,” your other friend added, enjoying the chance to turn against you. “She’s the one who yelled during the silence.”
Joe looked back at you, recognition dawning for a second time.
You stared at him. “You knew that.”
“I couldn’t see anything. Those lights are basically pointed directly into our eyes.”
“So you said ‘oh, hey’ to a random voice?”
“That’s not the same thing.”
“It was a strong feeling.”
Javi walked past with his own bottle of water. “He spent half the set staring at your section like he was trying to solve something.”
Joe turned towards him. “You have somewhere else to be?”
Javi grinned and remained exactly where he was.
The awkwardness that had followed you through the corridor began to disappear. It helped that Joe did not act as though he had brought you backstage for a serious private reunion. He introduced your friends to the people standing nearby, and the others welcomed them into the space without making the situation feel like an interruption. Someone offered all three of you water. Another person moved a few bags from the folding chairs so you could sit if you wanted.
Your friends remained slightly quieter than usual, but not silent. Their nerves showed mainly in how often they looked at each other before answering, as though checking whether they were allowed to admit how excited they were. They told the band they had followed their music for years. One mentioned a song she had been hoping would make the setlist, and the conversation quickly turned into a debate over which tracks were most difficult to perform live.
Joe stayed beside you through most of it.
Not so close that the choice seemed obvious, but close enough that every time the group shifted, he ended up in the same place. When someone opened the cooler and passed drinks around, he handed one to you before taking anything for himself.
For the first few minutes, neither of you mentioned the phone.
There were easier things to talk about.
Miami. The heat. The show. The circular stage, which Joe said was far more disorienting from the middle than it appeared from the crowd. You told him it looked incredible. He told you that was because you had not spent soundcheck trying to figure out which direction counted as the front.
Your friends slowly became more comfortable. One of them asked Javi a question about the tour and ended up talking to him for several minutes. The other was pulled into a discussion with Sam and Jake about Tame Impala’s live arrangements. She kept glancing towards you with an expression that clearly said she could not believe any of this was happening, but at least she was no longer standing behind you like she had forgotten how conversations worked.
Joe took another drink and leaned back against the flight case.
“So,” he said, lowering his voice slightly. “I owe you an explanation.”
You looked at him. “Do you?”
“That sounds convincing.”
“No, I do. I just don’t know whether it makes me look better or worse.”
He rubbed the side of the bottle with his thumb, looking briefly embarrassed in a way that made the entire thing feel less intimidating.
You blinked. “That’s the explanation?”
“And your new phone doesn’t send messages?”
“I lost some contacts when everything transferred.”
You stared at him for a second, then felt yourself begin to smile despite trying not to.
“I didn’t lose it on purpose.”
“That’s exactly what someone who lost a number would say.”
You raised your eyebrows.
“The phone that didn’t have it?”
He looked at you, apparently deciding whether to defend himself or accept that the explanation sounded ridiculous.
“When you say it like that, it seems less effective.”
“It was never effective.”
He laughed, lowering his head for a moment. “Okay. You’re right.”
“I assumed you just didn’t want to talk anymore.”
The sentence came out more honestly than you intended. There was no accusation in it, but it changed his expression slightly.
“I did,” he said. “Want to talk, I mean.”
You glanced down at the drink in your hands.
“You could’ve probably found me.”
“I could’ve written again too.”
You gave him a look that should have made the answer obvious.
“You’re famous. We talked for two days, couldn’t make plans, and then the conversation stopped. I wasn’t going to keep messaging you until you answered.”
Joe frowned slightly. “I answered.”
“And I didn’t know about the phone thing.”
“So from my perspective, it looked like you got busy and forgot about it.”
He nodded, accepting the logic even though he did not seem to like it.
Something in the way he said it made you look at him again.
It was not dramatic. He did not hold your gaze as if making a confession, and he did not try to turn a failed text exchange into evidence of some enormous hidden feeling. He said it plainly, almost frustrated by the months of misunderstanding contained inside such a small problem.
Before either of you could answer, one of your friends appeared at your side with a beer she had apparently been given by someone near the cooler.
“Are we interrupting?” she asked, already smiling in a way that proved she hoped the answer was yes.
“No,” Joe said at the same time.
She looked between you. “Interesting.”
“I came to tell you they’re starting the stage visuals.”
From beyond the backstage walls, the crowd had begun growing louder. A low, distorted sound rolled through the venue as the final equipment checks ended. Someone nearby said there were roughly ten minutes until Tame Impala went on.
Your friend did not leave immediately.
Instead, she looked at Joe. “She thought you ghosted her.”
Joe laughed. “We covered that.”
“She complained about it for weeks.”
Your second friend joined the group at exactly the wrong moment. “She did.”
Joe took a slow drink, visibly enjoying your discomfort. “What did she say?”
One of your friends ignored you. “Mostly that she wasn’t going to embarrass herself by writing again.”
“And that famous people probably have someone whose job is deleting numbers.”
Joe looked genuinely confused. “Why would anyone have that job?”
“You said something like that.”
Javi had wandered close enough to hear the final part of the conversation. “We should hire someone for that.”
Joe pointed at him without looking away from you. “You’re all being very helpful.”
Your friends laughed, and even you could not stay annoyed for long. The entire situation was too strange to take seriously. An hour earlier, the three of you had been pressed against a barricade wondering whether Joe could see you. Now your friends were exposing every ridiculous thing you had said after the first concert while members of Post Animal stood around drinking and preparing to watch Tame Impala.
Another member of the crew stepped into the area.
The energy shifted immediately.
People began collecting drinks and moving towards the corridor that led to the guest viewing section. Someone handed your friends the proper wristbands they would need to remain in the area, tightening each one before waving the next person forward.
Joe pushed away from the flight case.
“You’re coming with us, right?”
The question was directed at all three of you, but he looked at you when he asked it.
Your friends answered before you could.
The hallway became crowded as the group started moving. Members of the band, friends, crew, and guests filtered towards the side entrance in loose clusters. You ended up beside Joe, while your friends walked directly behind you with Javi, Teddy and Adam.
The backstage route was narrower now that equipment was being moved away from the stage. Large black cases lined one wall, forcing everyone into a single path while technicians squeezed past in the opposite direction. Radios crackled. Doors opened and closed. Someone pushed a cart through the intersection ahead, and the group had to stop until it cleared.
Joe looked back towards your friends.
Then he looked at you. “Stay close. It gets annoying through here.”
“I’m capable of walking through a hallway.”
“I saw you almost fall over at the barricade.”
Your friends immediately denied it from behind you.
The group began moving again. A pair of crew members hurried around the corner carrying equipment, forcing you to step closer to the wall. Joe waited until they passed, then placed his arm across your shoulders and guided you forward with him.
The gesture was so natural that for the first few steps, you barely processed it.
His hand rested loosely near your upper arm, not pulling you against him but keeping you beside him as the hallway narrowed. He continued talking to someone ahead, apparently unconcerned by what he had done. You looked up at him once. He felt the movement and glanced down.
“I’m allowed to look at you.”
His arm remained where it was.
Behind you, one of your friends made a tiny strangled sound.
You turned your head just enough to see both of them attempting to hold in laughter. Javi noticed too.
“You two okay?” he asked.
“Perfect,” one replied too quickly.
The other pressed her lips together and nodded.
Joe glanced back, then at you. “They’re not subtle.”
“We can hear you,” your friend said.
The passage opened into a wider platform leading towards the VIP viewing area. The sound of the audience became enormous again as soon as the final door opened. Blue and violet light spilled across the walkway, and the first waves of the intro pulsed through the venue floor.
Joe kept his arm around your shoulders as he led you onto the platform.
From the guest section, the circular stage seemed to float in the centre of the crowd. Thousands of people surrounded it, phone screens scattered through the darkness like small lights. The production had transformed completely during the changeover. Screens curved around the centre structure, colour moving across them in slow, liquid patterns while smoke drifted through the beams above.
Your friends stopped behind you.
“Oh my God,” one whispered, even though the music was already too loud for anyone outside your group to hear.
Joe finally lifted his arm so he could reach towards a table set against the side of the platform. He picked up two beers, checked one briefly, and offered it to you.
He collected another for himself and leaned beside you against the rail.
The rest of Post Animal spread across the section. Your friends stayed close at first, but within a few minutes Javi and the others had drawn them into the group. They were still visibly nervous, especially whenever anyone asked them a direct question, but the music made conversation less important. Everyone was there to watch.
The lights dropped completely.
Tame Impala stepped onto the stage.
For the first song, you barely looked anywhere else.
That was part of what Joe remembered most clearly about you from the first concert. You did not spend the show watching to see whether he was watching. Once the music began, your attention belonged to it completely. You knew when the synth would change, when the drums would enter, when the entire crowd would shout a lyric together. Your excitement was not careful or performed. It moved through you too quickly to hide.
Joe watched the stage too, but every so often he looked at you.
You took a sip of beer and caught him during one of those glances.
“I’m allowed to look at you.”
You stared at him for a second before recognising your own words.
“It worked when you said it.”
He laughed and turned back towards the stage.
The first few songs passed quickly. You and Joe talked in pieces whenever the music allowed it, leaning close to hear one another and giving up entirely when it did not. Sometimes he pointed out something in the live arrangement that was different from the recorded version. Sometimes you reacted before he could, already recognising the change.
Your friends relaxed more with each song.
One danced beside Teddy and Wes, laughing whenever she caught you looking at her. The other kept moving between the rail and the group behind you, unable to decide whether she wanted to focus on the stage or watch what was happening between you and Joe.
During a slower transition, Joe rested his forearms against the barrier and took a drink. You stood beside him, close enough that your shoulders touched each time either of you moved.
The contact stopped feeling accidental after the third time.
When the next song began, the entire VIP section shifted forward. Someone behind Joe bumped into him while moving past, and he steadied himself with one hand on the rail. A moment later, almost casually, he lifted the arm holding his beer and placed the other across your shoulders.
There was no announcement in the gesture.
He did not look down first or ask a question with his expression. He simply settled his arm around you while taking another sip, his attention still fixed on the stage as though this had been the obvious position for both of you all along.
Joe felt it and glanced at you over the edge of his cup.
You smiled back and returned your attention to the stage.
Behind you, your friends saw everything.
One immediately turned towards the other. They stared at each other with matching expressions of disbelief, then began laughing when they realised they had reacted at exactly the same time.
You caught them from the corner of your eye and gave them a warning look.
Javi followed their gaze towards you and Joe, then shook his head as though something he had expected was finally happening.
Joe rolled his eyes, but his arm stayed around your shoulders.
The beers disappeared faster than you noticed. Someone offered to bring another round, and your friends accepted before checking whether you wanted one. By the time the next bottles arrived, the stiffness of the first backstage conversation had fully dissolved. You were not drunk, but the warmth from the alcohol, the music, and the crowd made every decision feel easier. Joe had become more relaxed too. He laughed more freely, leaning closer whenever you spoke, occasionally tightening his arm around you when the people behind shifted.
Halfway through the set, the music changed.
You recognised the opening before most of the crowd did.
Your head snapped towards the stage, and a sound escaped you somewhere between a gasp and a laugh. The lights spread across the circular screens in a wash of colour while the first notes filled the venue.
You turned towards Joe immediately.
You had to say it close to his ear, but the excitement in your face would have communicated the sentence even if he had heard none of it.
You nodded, already smiling too hard to appear remotely calm.
Then, before you could turn towards the stage again, he leaned down and kissed you.
A soft, direct press of his mouth against yours that lasted barely more than a second, impulsive enough that neither of you had time to think through what it meant before it was already over.
Joe pulled back just far enough to see your reaction.
His expression changed slightly, the confidence of the decision giving way to the realisation that he had actually done it.
For a second, everything around you continued at full volume while the space between you went completely still.
Joe’s shoulders loosened.
You turned back towards the stage, still smiling, and he laughed quietly beside you. His arm rounded and tightened around your chest, drawing you closer until your back rested against his front.
Your friends had seen the entire thing.
One had both hands over her mouth. The other stared at you with wide eyes before turning to the first and grabbing her arm. Javi looked between them and started laughing at their reaction.
You refused to look back again.
The song had started, and you were determined to experience at least part of it without your friends making silent screaming faces behind you.
That plan lasted less than a minute.
Joe leaned towards your ear. “You okay?”
You turned your head. “You kissed me.”
“And now you’re asking if I’m okay?”
You laughed. “A little late.”
You were close enough that the next movement required almost no distance at all. This time, when you kissed him, it was not as brief. Your hand found the side of his waist without planning to, holding lightly at his stomach as he turned towards you. The kiss remained soft, made slightly awkward by the bottles you were both still holding and the fact that thousands of people surrounded the stage below, but neither of you seemed interested in pretending the first one had been an accident.
When you separated, Joe stayed close.
“There,” you said. “Now it’s even.”
“I don’t think that’s how that works.”
The rest of the show changed after that.
Not in one dramatic moment. Nothing needed to be discussed. You simply stopped leaving space between you.
During faster songs, you danced with your friends and the band, shouting lyrics and laughing whenever someone nearly spilled a drink. Joe stayed close enough that his hand kept finding your waist or your shoulder each time the group shifted. When you returned to the rail, he moved behind you, one arm resting across your middle while the other held his beer away from the people dancing around you.
You leaned back against him without thinking about it.
His chin brushed near the side of your head when he bent down to hear something you said. Sometimes he understood. Sometimes he shook his head because the music drowned you out, and you both laughed instead of trying again.
Your friends alternated between joining you and openly observing.
At one point, one of them moved beside you and shouted, “Are we going to talk about this?”
“When are we talking about it?”
“Not during Tame Impala!”
Joe leaned closer. “What did she say?”
“She said she loves this song.”
Your friend looked offended. “That is not what I said.”
Joe laughed, and you pushed her gently back towards the others.
Several songs later, the beers and the music had made the group looser. Wes and one of your friends were arguing over a lyric. Jake was trying to convince your second friend that a particular live version was better than the studio recording. Everyone kept moving, trading places along the rail and stepping around discarded cups.
His arms settled around you more fully during one of the slower songs, both of you swaying with the crowd rather than properly dancing. You rested your hands over his forearms, fingers brushing his wrist whenever the rhythm changed.
He pressed another quick kiss near your temple.
You turned enough to look at him.
“You keep doing things and saying nothing.”
Joe laughed against your hair. “Good argument.”
You shifted until you were facing him more fully, still held loosely inside his arms. The stage lights moved across his face in changing colour, making his expression difficult to read for a second at a time. He looked happy. Not in the polished way performers looked while acknowledging a crowd, but relaxed, slightly disbelieving, and amused by how quickly the night had turned into something neither of you had expected.
Somewhere below the VIP platform, a phone camera moved.
It would have been impossible not to notice the phones.
The guest section was elevated above part of the audience, visible from several sides of the circular stage, and Joe had spent long enough being recognised in public to know exactly what happened when he stood anywhere with decent lighting and no wall between himself and a crowd. Every few minutes, another screen tilted towards the platform. Some people were filming the band watching the show. Others were clearly focused on him.
Your friends noticed too, although they were far less accustomed to it.
One of them leaned closer while Joe had his arms around you from behind.
“There are, like, ten people recording up here.”
You followed her gaze towards the audience.
She was probably exaggerating, but not by much. Several phones were visibly raised in your direction, and one person near the side barrier did not even attempt to hide the fact that the camera was zoomed in.
Your friend stared at you. “And you’re fine?”
You glanced back at Joe. He had heard enough of the conversation to understand what she was asking, but his expression remained relaxed. There was no sudden movement to step away from you or turn his back towards the audience. He only looked down at the phones for a moment before returning his attention to the stage.
“They were filming before,” he said.
“That was before you started kissing her,” your friend replied.
Joe smiled slightly. “Fair.”
You laughed and took another sip from your drink.
The reality of it sat somewhere in the back of your mind, impossible to ignore but not strong enough to ruin the night. Joe was Joe. People recorded him walking out of buildings, standing beside stages, talking to friends, and doing absolutely nothing interesting at all. Of course they were going to record him with someone’s arms around his neck while he kissed her at a Tame Impala show.
You had known that the moment he kissed you.
That did not mean either of you needed to perform for them, but pretending the cameras did not exist would have been pointless. Joe had already looked towards one of the phones while you were dancing, and you had seen the quick recognition in his face before he turned back to you. He knew exactly what the clip would look like once it reached the internet.
He just did not seem particularly bothered.
Your friend lowered her voice even though the music made privacy unnecessary. “People are going to lose their minds.”
“They lose their minds when an inch of his tummy is showing,” you said.
Joe laughed behind you. “That’s not completely inaccurate.”
“You’re both being way too calm.”
“I’m watching Tame Impala,” you answered. “I’m not stopping because someone has a phone.”
That seemed to satisfy her, or at least make it clear that warning you again would achieve nothing. She shook her head with a disbelieving smile and returned to the others.
Joe’s hand tightened slightly at your waist.
“You sure?” he asked near your ear.
You turned enough to look at him. “About what?”
You studied his face, wondering whether the question was really for you or whether he was giving you an easy opportunity to step away before the night became public.
“They were always going to film you.”
His eyes stayed on yours for another second.
It was not an agreement about what would happen tomorrow. Neither of you knew what people would say, how widely the videos would spread, or whether strangers would manage to find your name before the night was over. It was only an agreement about the present moment. You knew you were visible. He knew you understood what that meant. Neither of you was being tricked into anything.
When you turned back towards the stage, Joe remained behind you, his arms still loosely around your middle.
A few minutes later, during another song, you looked up at him with the same bright, excited expression you had worn all night. Joe smiled, leaned down, and kissed you again without checking where the nearest phone was pointed.
Several cameras caught it.
This time, you both knew they would.
The final notes lingered through the stadium long after the band had disappeared beneath the stage.
For a few seconds, nobody moved.
Thousands of people stayed exactly where they were, almost unwilling to admit it was over. The lights slowly brightened again, conversations returning all at once as everyone began collecting bags, empty cups, and phones.
You let out a quiet laugh.
“I don’t think I’ve ever wanted a concert to last longer.”
“I’ve said that after every Tame show.”
“You’ve seen them more than once.”
The rest of Post Animal slowly gathered around the VIP section again. Dalton stretched dramatically before walking over, pointing between you and Joe.
Joe already knew what was coming.
“I haven’t even said anything.”
“I was just gonna ask if we should pretend we’re surprised.”
One of your friends laughed into her drink.
“I don’t think anyone here is surprised.”
“Except maybe her,” Dalton nodded toward you.
“I’m actually doing surprisingly well.”
“You almost passed out when he answered you during the set.”
Joe laughed quietly beside you.
“You screamed at me first.”
The atmosphere stayed easy after that.
No one made a big deal out of anything. Someone started talking about the setlist. Another person argued that one song should’ve been played earlier. Your friends were finally relaxed enough to jump into the conversation without whispering to each other first, and within minutes it felt less like you had been invited backstage and more like you’d simply fallen into the group’s orbit for the night.
Eventually, the venue staff began encouraging everyone toward the exits.
People had flights to catch.
Reality had a habit of returning far too quickly.
“You’ve got terrible timing.”
“I was about to say the exact same thing.”
He laughed, shaking his head.
“Guess we’re consistent.”
You looked at him for a second before speaking.
“Just… don’t lose my number this time.”
Joe let out a laugh loud enough that a couple of people nearby turned to look. “I deserve that.”
“I figured texting you out of nowhere after months would’ve sounded insane.”
“You could’ve just said, ‘Hey.’”
“You made this so much harder than it needed to be.”
You couldn’t help laughing.
He reached into his pocket, pulling out his phone.
“Let’s make sure neither of us has an excuse this time.”
He typed in the number while standing right beside you. A second later, your phone buzzed. You looked down.
Don’t let me lose this one.
You smiled before typing back immediately.
Only if you stop breaking your phones.
His own phone vibrated almost instantly. He looked at the screen and laughed. “Deal.”
For a moment, neither of you said anything.
The crowd around you had already started disappearing down the corridor. Your friends were a few steps ahead, politely pretending not to watch while very obviously watching.
“We’re giving you, like… thirty more seconds.”
“You’re generous,” Joe said.
She grinned before pulling the other away again.
“I’ll text you tomorrow.”
“You said that last time.”
“I’ll believe it when I see it.”
He stepped a little closer.
“Guess I’ll have to prove it.”
He leaned down, stealing one last kiss before either of you could overthink it. Short. Warm. Enough to leave both of you smiling when he pulled away.
You started walking backward toward your friends. After a few steps, you looked over your shoulder to make sure you weren’t about to walk into anyone. When you looked back, Joe was still standing exactly where you’d left him.
Then your friends immediately surrounded you the second you reached them. One of them grabbed both of your shoulders.
“You are telling us absolutely everything the second we get in the Uber.”
“I was there,” you laughed.
“The director’s cut,” the other added.
You shook your head, laughing as they pulled you toward the exit. Behind you, Joe watched the three of you disappear into the crowd before finally turning in the opposite direction with the rest of the band. Neither of you noticed the phones anymore. For tonight, it didn’t matter.
Tomorrow could deal with itself.
thank you so much for reading!! 🫶 if you enjoyed it, please consider liking, reblogging or leaving a comment, it honestly means a lot and motivates me to keep writing 💗 i’m not sure yet if this is the end of backstage number or if i’ll end up writing a part three… we’ll see 👀
taglist: @mr-joel-keeny @lilacdreamrxo @helaenabugmom
also if anyone wants to be added to my tag list you can send me a message, ask, or just comment and i’ll add you !! ☆