You truly did try your hardest for me. I understand why you feel broken, rejected, and alone. I have heard the stories of my predecessors now, and have come to realize that you tried your best only for me. Unfortunately, your best was not good enough. Your best was still controlling and hurtful, abusive and abrasive. Your best made me feel my lowest, so I can only imagine how she felt.
That's not to say I don't miss you, though. I see the promise of what you could be, how you could thrive, and how you could succeed. You believe you are perfect though, already attuned to health and tranquility. I am in love with your potential, and the man that could be.
That man does not match your actions, your words, nor your dreams. That man is who you pretended to be. Whether it was a lie or a mask, I find myself longing for that man to come back. The one that showered me in flowers, adoration, and support. But that is the same man that put this knife in my back.
Even though I'm aware of this, it doesn't quell the ache. It doesn't subdue the longing. It doesn't quiet the pain. I can recognize when something is harmful towards me, but the heart can not be tamed. In the dark of the night, when the world has gone still, I look beside me and wish you well. I look at your empty space, the one I refuse to fill, and remember what it was like to lay beside you. I remember how it felt, with my head on your chest and the even pace of your breath. I remember the drowsy midnight kisses when I rolled away and you followed, pulling me close like I was about to disappear. I remember the laughter, the love, the wholeness I felt. I curse the world, for none of it was real.
I know the whole story now, not the one that you gave. I've seen the sweet pet names, the ones that made me melt, spoken to another girl. I've seen the story you made for me, leaving out the fact of your role. I've seen the way you ran back to her when our relationship failed. You swore up and down that it was only me, that that intimacy was reserved for me. The lies brought so much pain, even though I thought I healed. It reopened the wounds, and for some reason a piece of me is still under your spell. I wonder how long your new woman will last, if she will fit in my shell.
Whether you believe it or not, it's a tall order to fill. I left you vacant and void, for I could see through your shell. I touched pieces of your soul that you didn't know existed, left kindness and warmth in my wake, because I saw how you craved it. You were different to me than the others. With them you were cold and distant, didn't bother hiding your flaws. But with me, oh lord, how hard did you fall? With me, you obsessed and chased. With me, you actually tried. Imagined a future together, despite the other girls you denied. How will she fill the spot I left, the gnawing wound in your chest that you try to avoid. Everything is a memory of me, just as you are to me. Do you think you'll survive?