Brimestone
Dir: Martin Koolhoven
Every year I hope for one gritty Western. Last year it was the dusty "Bone Tomahawk" and this year a completely different film that was very brutal in its own sense. A mute girl who experiences one tragic event after another (her muteness also linked to one event), that are all connected to a mad reverend and his obsession with her. The story is told in four parts (Exodus, Genesis, Brimestone, Retribution) that reveal the background in flashbacks and a deeper story. There are no heroic cowboys to safe the ladies from the horrors of the nasty Wild West - the few that appear bite the dust very soon. It is about female survival in a very misogynistic world. Where men can exploit their female counterparts without facing any consequences (somehow a contemporary topic if I look at the current presidential debate). Where women are objectified and even juveniles are not protected from predators. One would think that faith is the only remedy, but Religion doesn't provide a safe haven either. Men of god misuse the word of the bible to fulfill their low desires. This is amazingly portrayed by Guy Pearce as the crazy "reverend" who is the devil himself in the saddle. However the women playing Liz and Joanna (Dakota Fanning, Emilia Jones) shine no less as they play the role of the strong victim with so much precision. The Western is violent and graphic in every sense. It led to quite a few walkouts who didn't expect to see this in the "Official Competition" category along with other causal "crowd pleasers". One female spectator was furious in the Q+A and accused the director of using torture porn. He ensures that at no time you feel comfortable with the abuse scenes that shape the storystelling, as anything else would pervert it. This is the Lars von Trier Western he is probably never going to make.










