The College Application Process
College application season is just around the corner. As a survivor of the grueling task of completing the application process, I know exactly how daunting, overwhelming, and downright stressful it can be. I hope that by giving you a little โtourโ of the college application process, youโll have a much easier time navigating it. and hopefully youโll be able to craft a successful application.
Before I get right into it, Iโd first like to tell you a bit about myself in the context of college applications. I just graduated high school (in 2018) and Iโm going to attend Cornell University in the fall. I plan to major in Computer Science and Economics, but I remain open to other courses of study that I may find interesting as I progress through my college career. I applied to a total of 17 schools: I was accepted by 8 of them and waitlisted by 1.
Disclaimer: I am not a college admissions officer and thus I am not certain that everything I write in this post will work. This is just what I experienced with my college applications. Also, I will only be talking about college applications in the US, since thatโs where I applied to, but perhaps some of the tips are adaptable to other countriesโ college application processes.
(before summer break - start of senior year)
Before starting your application, it seems pretty obvious that you should have an idea of which schools to apply to. And in order for you to do that, you should do a little research to make sure that youโre applying to colleges that you actually want to attend.
One of the first things you should do is list different factors that you think will affect your decision. Do you want to go to a college in the city or in a small town? A large college or a small one? A chill school or an academically rigorous one?
You should also consider the major/area of study youโre interested inโit doesnโt even have to be super specific. Your potential major can then be used to choose your colleges. For example, if I wanted to study CS and Econ, I would choose colleges that are strong in both areas.
On a side note, I donโt think you should choose an area of study just because youโre good at a certain subject, e.g. just because youโre good at English, doesnโt necessarily mean you should study English or Literature. Instead, choose a potential major based on what you enjoy doing.
When doing your research about these different colleges, reading all of the information on their websites can be tedious and boring. As an alternative, Iโd recommend watching youtube videos or talking to alumni instead. When I was applying, the most effective way for me to get to know a school is through those โA Day in the Life ofโฆโ videos as well as Q&A videos because you not only end up knowing more about the school but also about the student body and the student culture at that university.
I recommend that you apply to a good mix of safety schools, match schools, and dream schools.
Safety schools: you exceed their requirements and youโll definitely get in.
Match schools: admits have similar academic credentials to yours. You have a good chance of admission, but thereโs also a (relatively small) probability that you wonโt.
Dream schools: your scores or credentials fall in the lower end of the schoolโs average range for the previous batch of admitted students.Youโd be lucky to get in.
All the colleges you apply to should be colleges that youโd be happy to attend.
You should start with 6 schools: 2 safety, 2 match, and 2 reach. Then you can adjust the numbers as you wish. If youโre applying to more schools, Iโd say the optimum reach:match:safety ratio is around 3:5:2, so if youโre planning to apply to 10 colleges, that would be 3 reach, 5 match, and 2 safety.
How to classify collegesย
Generally, people categorize their colleges based on statistics, so things like test scores, GPA, and rank. Perhaps the easiest method is comparing standardized test scores. A good way to do this is to look at the 25th to 75th percentile range, which shows you the scores obtained by 50% of last yearโs entering class. If your scores fall between the 25th and 75th percentile, you may have just found yourself a match school! But hold up, the lower percentiles may be reserved for special admits like athletes or donors, so in reality, a match school would be one where your scores lie closer to the 75th percentile.
Aside from standardized test scores, it might also help to figure out what kind of student the college is looking forโsuch as by reading accepted supplemental essaysโand seeing whether or not you seem like the right fit.
Once youโve compiled your list of colleges, it would help to have a table with information about them. This might include information like deadlines, median scores, availability of scholarships, interviews, etc. Hereโs a link to (the blank version of) the spreadsheet I used for my college application. Feel free to modify it according to your needs, but make sure to make a copy before changing things!
What are recommendation letters?
Recommendations letters are letters written by your mentors to provide insight into what youโre like as a student, e.g. your behavior, positive qualities, interests, achievements etc.
Whom should you ask for a recommendation letter?ย
Itโs good to ask teachers who know you very well, either someone who has taught you for a long time or someone who has a multifaceted view of you, such as a teacher who has also advised you in an extracurricular.
Some people would also suggest that you get recommendations from teachers of different subjects to show that youโre a well-rounded student. I think itโs better to ask teachers who can write about your different positive qualities, i.e. one teacher could highlight a part of your character that the other teacher would not be able to.
You might also want to ask teachers who can write well. In my experience, letters from teachers in the humanities and social science departments tend to be more convincing and well-written than those in the science and math departments (I know not all teachers are like this; this is just a generalization). But again, itโs definitely better to ask teachers who know you well and can write about your qualities.
The first recommendation letter I used was from my Economics teacher, who was also my MUN (Model United Nations) advisor - an extracurricular in which I was very active. My classmates and I also had a pretty good relationship with this teacher, especially since our class was only 3 students.
My second recommendation letter came from my Math teacher, who taught me for 6 years. Math is also my strongest subject, so thatโs definitely a plus point (get it? :p).
Another letter that might be useful to submit is the additional recommendation. This is a recommendation from anyone other than your teacher, it could be your coach, another mentor, or even a friend. I think you should only consider submitting an additional recommendation if it highlights qualities that havenโt been covered in your other ones.
What do I have to do as an applicant?ย
Be prepared to answer questions your teachers may have about you so that they can write a more valuable recommendation letter. Compiling a resume or list of achievements and activities might help, or you could simply sit down for a conversation.
When should I ask for these recommendation letters?ย
Preferably before your senior year starts so your teachers have enough time to put some thought into what theyโre going to write.
Do I really need to take standardized tests?
A lot of colleges recommend (read: require) you to take the SAT or ACT (and TOEFL if youโre an international student like myself), but remember that they are not your entire application. Just do your best in the standardized tests you take.
When should I take them?ย
I say whenever youโre ready, but no later than the deadline specified by the college (usually October of your senior year would be the latest to take the general SAT). I did my SATs in October during my junior year, my younger sister took it at the end of her sophomore year, and a lot of my friends took in October during our senior year, so again, it really depends on when you feel youโre ready.
How many times should I take them?
I donโt think you should do each test more than once unless youโre sure your scores will improve. Your application wonโt look very good if you sat for the SAT 3 times and your scores decreased each time, assuming the college looks at all your scores.
Which scores do I send colleges?ย
Different colleges have different requirements for the submission of these test scores. Some only require the highest scores, while others would like to see all of your scores. On the CollegeBoard website, when you enter colleges to which youโll send your scores, the site will also inform you of the requirements for those colleges.
How will colleges receive my standardized testing scores?
Youโll have to fill a form in the Common/Coalition App. In addition, some schools require you to send official score reports from the testing agency. I suggest that you send in your scores as soon as you know what colleges youโre applying to, just so that you donโt have to pay an extra amount to โrushโ your score sends (i.e. have it sent to colleges in 2-4 days as opposed to the regular 1-2 weeks).
Take challenging classes and do well in them
Colleges look at the classes you take in high school and how well you did in them. You should consider taking classes that are both challenging and in the area of study you might want to pursue. Taking challenging courses allows college admissions officers to see that youโre taking initiative to further your education.
What if I catch senioritis?ย
If youโre a senior, youโll definitely go through a phase where you donโt care about anything and just feel like having coffee and talking to your friends in class. I know I did. Senioritis is totally normal, but you should still try to put effort into your studies. Colleges can rescind your admission if they see a drastic fall in your grades, so keep your grades up and donโt overwhelm yourself with too many unnecessary activities.
Extracurriculars show college admissions officers that you can manage your time well and that you have other interests aside from school. It also shows them that you are an active, contributing member of your community, and that youโre proactive in developing your passions and interests.
What type of activity counts as an extracurricular?ย
Well, it can be anything you do in your free time. It could be a school club, a club outside of school, an online activity, etc. Maybe you programmed an app in your spare time. Maybe you had a part time job. Or maybe you ran a blog that helps students navigate their academic lives. You just have to find something that matters to you and is significant and meaningful. It would be even better if the activities in which you participate can demonstrate leadership and commitment.
If youโre having a hard time picturing what that could be, Iโll give you a couple of examples. One of my friends expanded his love of reading by starting a hip hop literature club that has branches in Japan and in multiple states in the US. A junior of mine established a website that brings together people from all around the world, who are experienced in the MUN community, to give newer members advice and guidance so that they may thrive in the MUN world.
Stage 2: Completing the Application
Different Application Platforms
The first thing you should do after youโve compiled a college list is to find out where you should complete your application.
The most common application platform is the Common App, which is used by more than 700 colleges in the US. Itโs super convenient if youโre applying to a lot of colleges, but the site does limit you to 20 colleges.
Another common platform is the Coalition for Access, Affordability, and Success, which is a fairly new platform that has 132 members. It does have a cool feature I like, though: it allows you to compile a kind of portfolio by uploading documents and files to your โlockerโ on the website. Furthermore, the Coalition App is specifically aimed to help lower-resourced and underrepresented students, so the colleges listed there have substantial financial aid and scholarship opportunities.
Some colleges also have their own applications, such as the UCs and MIT.
Youโll have to fill in your
Personal information (This is probably the easiest part of the application, so even if you donโt have anything else ready yet, I recommend you fill this out just to get it over with.)
Extracurricular activities
Essays (the Common/Coalition App essay and supplementary essays)
Your counselor will submit
Your high school transcript
Your mid-year and final transcript
The counselor recommendation
Your teachers will submit
Their recommendation letters
Now, even though you arenโt submitting every single thing on the form, you are the person responsible for the punctuality of these documents. Your teachers are busy and they might forget, so itโs your job to remind them.
For real though, one of my teachers forgot to upload his recommendation onto one of the external application websites. Fortunately, the university gave me and others in my position an extra 22 days to send in any missing documents.
The Essay (and other essays)
Ah, yes. The much dreaded Essayโข. Probably the most challenging part of the application, and the one that sucks the life outta ya. Thereโs a reason for that, though. The essay is an important part of the application because it humanizes the applicant instead of merely showing them as a collection of statistics and facts. You should aim to showcase something about yourself that canโt be found in other parts of the application.
Ideally, you should start thinking about potential essay ideas over the summer, maybe come up with a rough draft if you can. But itโs really no rush, though. Sometimes the best ideas come later. I wrote my first common app essay over the summer. Completely scrapped it. Wrote a second one in like September-ish and used that for Early Action. Scrapped it again. The final essay I sent in was first written on December 17th. Sometimes life works that way.
One method that helped me is making a mind map about myself (my counselor recommended this to me). Youโd start by writing down the things that define you: your personality, qualities, and values. Then, youโd think of activities, events, or other things in your life where you exhibited those traits or exercised those values. Since all college essays pretty much boil down to โWhat good qualities do you have?โ, mind mapping your good qualities will help you answer all sorts of essays.
One important thing you should know is that your essay topic doesnโt have to be super deep or anything, just that it says a lot about you. And just because your essay is really personal, you shouldnโt divert your focus away from writing it well. You also shouldnโt write about something everybody experiences unless you can find a way to make it unique.
As soon as you have several topics for your essay, you can create outlines for each of them, and see which one would give a greater contribution to your application. If youโre not the outline type of person, start writing away, and see which one turns out to be more effective.
Start writing as soon as you have an idea. You donโt have to perfect it yet, just see where and how far the idea goes. You can always edit it or scrap it later. Or, if you prefer a more structured approach, make outlines for all the ideas you have.
How should I structure my essay?
When writing your essay, I would recommend using a narrative structure since people generally respond better to stories. However, if you think your essay would read better without the narrative structure, then use a different one.
What writing techniques are important?
Imagery is your best friend. You want your readers (the admissions officers) to be able to picture what youโre telling them so that they could understand more clearly and comprehensively whatever it is about yourself that youโre trying to convey.
Using an extended metaphor is also an excellent way to compose a memorable essay. Be aware that theyโre fairly difficult to pull off, but if you have an idea, you should try and write it out first and see how that works out.
What are some common mistakes applicants make?
Some applicants make the mistake of sounding too preachy, you know, something like โWe should make the world a better place!!โ You might think, โbut arenโt these types of essays supposed to be like that?โ Thatโs what I thought, too, when I first wrote my essay. The admissions officers, however, are only there to get to know you, not to be preached upon. Instead, you should tie in the message you want to convey with your personal experience.
Lastly, you shouldnโt summarize at the end of your essay. It really isnโt as useful as you might think. In other words, you should write your essay so that it doesnโt need to be summarized in order for the readers to understand what youโre trying to tell them.
You should be prepared to write and rewrite and, like I said before, completely scrap essays. Donโt let yourself get attached to a particular sentence or phrase or even essay topic. Rewrite as needed. Write something else if you must.
After youโve written your first draft, leave your essay for a couple days before coming back to it to edit. This is because right after youโve written your essay, the ideal image of the essay is still the one you have written down, so you likely wonโt make any meaningful changes.
What if I exceed the word limit?
If your word count is waaay past it, Iโd suggest you write it from scratch without referring to the original draft. This helps eliminate the less important details since you yourself donโt remember them.
If you think you can simply cut down on a few phrases, there are several things you can do: delete redundancies, shorten your introduction/conclusion, simplify phrases, rearrange sentences, and use contractions, for example.
Should I ask other people to read my essay?
Somewhere along the road, youโll also want to ask other people to read over your essay. I wouldnโt recommend asking a friend to do this for you since they might give a biased opinion. Plus, they know you too well. Instead, ask a teacher, your counselor, or even an acquaintance with whom youโre comfortable letting them read your essay.
Honestly just refer to your mind map if you made one, or make outlines for each of your supplemental essays. Donโt be afraid to reuse essays, just make sure to change the name of the college if mentioned.
Some colleges also require you to write about an extracurricular. A guide to the extracurricular essay will be covered in the Extracurriculars section of this post.
College Essay Masterpost by @genericappblrurlโ
Prolly the most comprehensive guide to college essays bless u
Covers nearly all essay types
College Essay Masterpost (links) by @sootudyingโ, includes
Each of the common app essay prompts
โWhy college X?โ essay guides
Extracurricular essay guides
Contribution essay guides
Influence in life essay guides
โWhy major X?โ essay guides
College Essay Masterpost (links) by @sequoia-studiesโ, includes
General essay advice (articles + videos)
How to Write a Bomb Ass Essay for College Applications by @education-tipsโ
Colleges love applicants who are contributing members of their communities as well as those who are actively developing their passions and skills. The extracurricular section of the college application allows the college to see just that. As Iโve said before, an extracurricular activity can be anything you do in your free time, but one in which you hold a leadership position will pique the interests of the admissions officers.
How many activities should I list?ย
The Common App gives you 10 slots for extracurricular activities (the Coalition gives you 8). However, itโs completely fine if you donโt have 10 activities. For the most part, colleges prefer to see quality over quantity, so having a few activities youโre passionate about and to which you made significant contributions would be better than filling all 10 slots with activities that you donโt care about all that much. The best combination of activities would be 1 - 3 significant activities with a large number of hours and several others with a lower number of hours.
What if I have too many activities?ย
Choose the activities that you invested the most time in and gained the most experience from. You can also combine multiple activities into one slot. For example, I organized quite a few events and fundraisers when I was in the Student Council, so instead of writing โOrganized and volunteered for sports cupโ, โDesigned and produced school merchandiseโ, and โOrganized a charity festivalโ, I wrote them all under โStudent Councilโ.
Note: Extracurricular activities arenโt the same as Honors and Awards.
What activities should I include?
As Iโve stated previously, colleges prefer quality over quantity. However, you can aim to be eitherย โpointyโ or โwell roundedโ. Some students have activities that are only in one area of study (โpointyโ). This shows colleges that youโre focused and have an intense desire to pursue a single passion.
Despite this, being more โwell-roundedโ and having a diverse range of activities can also be beneficial since it shows that youโve gained a lot of experience, and that you arenโt afraid to try different things.
Your activities donโt even have to be conventional extracurricular activities either. Two of the extracurricular activities I listed were 1) this studyblr; and 2) my instagram poetry page. I mean, I am a Gen X kid; Iโm bound to spend large amounts of time on social media. Fortunately, it turns out I made a pretty significant contribution, I would say, and also learned a lot from the experience, so they definitely count as extracurricular activities.
Describing the extracurricular activities
This blog post from College Vine is super comprehensive and helped me a lot when I was writing about my extracurriculars. Iโll sum up some key points below:
Select extracurriculars that will present the best image of yourself
Use action oriented verbs (e.g. โfacilitatedโ, โmanagedโ, โmaintainedโ)
Quantify your accomplishments as much as possible
Certain activities will look better if you emphasize the valuable skills you learned instead of what you did
Some colleges will require you to write an essay in which you reflect upon a particular activity you did: what you learned and how you grew. This post from College Essay Guy covers pretty much everything I have to say about the extracurricular essay. Main points:
Write a good clear sentence about what the activity meant to you
Show a little, but not too much
Start with a problem to be solved
Write it long first, then cut it
But which extracurricular activity should you write the essay about? Hereโs a helpful link that tells you just that.
The honors and awards section is another component of the application that can help you stand out from other applicants. These are basically any achievement, award, or recognition youโve received in high school.
The common app limits you to 5 honors/awards, and I would recommend that you choose your most impressive honors, e.g. an international competition would be more impressive than one within your school.
Sometimes awards are directly tied to an activity, such as winning Best Delegate in an MUN conference. In this case, you should mention your award in the activities section. Awards that arenโt tied to an activity should be listed in the Honors and Awards section. These might include scholarships, academic awards, etc.
If you have too many honors to fit into the form (lucky you!), you might want to consider sending in a resume. Some colleges provide this option, while some merely have a section for extra information.
Interviews are another way the college can see you as a whole person. Some colleges might provide you with an option to take the interview or decline it, but if given the chance, go for it!
What is the interview, exactly?
For me, this was probably the most nerve-wracking part since youโre practically telling things about yourself to a stranger (can you tell Iโm not into socializing?) and itโs like youโre being evaluated and you donโt really know what to expect.
But honestly theyโre basically regular conversations where you talk about yourself and the things you love. Theyโll ask about your school, your family, your aspirations, your hobbies, but the conversation can lead anywhereโfood, human rights, pop culture.
Itโll probably start with an open ended question like tell me about yourself and then branch off from there.
There might also be another type of interview where itโs more like a Q&A about the school and you get to know the college through an alumni (Cornellโs โinterviewโ was like this).
A bad interview really wonโt hurt your application, unless of course you fail to answer why you want to go to that university.
It really just gives you an extra boost and another factor to consider when the university decides whether or not to admit you.
Plus, you get to elaborate on things that you didnโt on your application.
Interviews can be anywhere from 15 minutes to 1.5 hours, so donโt worry if you think it was too short or too long.
Arrive early. It helps to take a few seconds to breathe and take in your location and surroundings before you start your interview.
Wear something comfortable. I wore a plaid shirt and trousers to most of my interviews. In my experience, Western people tend to be more lenient with clothing, so if you wear a t-shirt, itโs fine. Indonesians (and some other Asians) kinda want you to dress at least semi-formally, maybe a button up and formal pants or a skirt.
If your interviewer asks if you want to order anything, go ahead, they wonโt mind, and youโll get free food or a free beverage. I would usually order coffee or tea.
How to answer the question tell me about yourself.
How to answer the question why do you want to go to this school?
How to answer other common questions. Donโt script your answers though. Just think about them so you know what the focus of your answer will revolve around.
Your resume, in case they ask for one.
Research the college and prepare some questions to ask the interviewer.
Research the interviewer, e.g. what they studied, what their job is, anything you think would be important to bring up, like one of their research projects or theses.
Send the interviewer a thank you note/email
Thank them for interviewing you
Recall something memorable from the interview
Relax. Then relax some more.
15 Questions to Know for College Interviews by @solustudiesโย
The 14 College Interview Questions You Must Prepare For by PrepScholar
Check and recheck! Everything! Like actually tho, I typed in my friendโs TOEFL score instead of my own on one application, and on one essay, I wrote the wrong name of the university. I fixed them, though. But yeah check, recheck, and have someone else check it for you too, if possible.
If youโre strong in the arts, send in an arts supplement! I sent in some poetry samples (although I donโt actually know if theyโre good haha) to demonstrate my extracurricular interests.
Just be your honest self in all parts of the application. Donโt try to mold yourself to fit the university youโre applying to. Iโm sure the admissions officers will be able to tell if you arenโt being genuine.
A Masterpost for Applying to College by @science-is-goldenโ
College Application Timeline by @applicantmusingsโ
A College Studentโs Masterpost by @eruditekidโ
Uni Application Masterpost by @study-earlyโ
Stage 3: Post-Application
Enjoy your senior year, but again, keep up those grades. Donโt be consumed by senioritis.
Spend more time with your friends since itโs probably gonna be your last year together. Actually spend more time with everyone around you and join activities you normally wouldnโt. But again, donโt overwhelm yourself.
Even though youโre having fun, remember to check your email regularly. Colleges will update you about things, e.g. if youโre missing a component from your application.
Prepare to view your admission results.
College applications are tough, and youโre amazing for being able to put up with such a daunting task. Itโs meant to be hard, so applaud yourself!
Also remember not to wear yourself out! Take breaks and revitalize because youโre going to craft a much better application if you have a clear mind and a healthy body.
And when announcement day arrives, be prepared for whatever result youโll get. Congratulations if you get into your dream school! And if you donโt, thatโs alright; maybe the school wasnโt a good fit for you after all.
Thatโs it for now. Hope you found this post helpful, and best of luck for your college applications!
