Berkshire Hathaway 2016 Annual Meeting Highlights
Despite streaming the Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting live on the internet for the first time, Warren Buffett still managed to fill the CenturyLink Arena in Omaha, Nebraska with more than 40,000 people. Iâve been trekking to Omaha most years since 1998 to attend the annual meeting. Itâs always insightful and uplifting to hear Buffett and his business partner, Charlie Munger, discuss a wide range of issues over five hours. I canât think of a better continuing education course for investors. Attendees come away with a good idea of how Buffett and Munger think about investments and life in general. Itâs a celebration of capitalism and a reminder of the power of business done the right way.
Here are a few highlights from the meeting that I jotted down in my notebook. I assume readers have some knowledge of Berkshireâs businesses. Even if you donât, I think youâll find Warren and Charlieâs observations worthwhile.
Ideal business âAn ideal business uses no capital and every year grows its earnings. You have double-barreled growth since the earnings are growing, and you get to keep those earnings.â âWarren Buffett
Burlington Northern âBNSF has lower but decent returnsâin the 10 to 12 percent area.ââWarren Buffett
âWhile we prefer businesses that donât require capital, our large amounts of capital forces us into more capital intensive businesses. When something is forced on you, you might as well prefer it! But itâs plan B.â âWarren Buffett
âDecline in coal volume is secular. Itâs about 20 percent of the volume at Burlington Northern.â âWarren Buffett
Precision Castparts âPrecision Castpartsâ CEO, Mark Donegan, is one of a kind. One of the best CEOs weâve come across, and weâve seen a lot of managers over the years.â âWarren Buffett
âBeing part of Berkshire could be an advantage for Precision Castparts over time. Now Mark can spend 100 percent of his time thinking about making engine parts. He doesnât have to waste time on things that arenât productive.â âWarren Buffett
âWeâve almost gotten as good at picking superior managers as in picking no-brainer businesses.â âCharlie Munger
Life and regrets âIâm doing exactly what I want, I eat what I want, and I work with people I love.â âWarren Buffett
âI donât regret that I didnât make more money or that Iâm not better known. I do regret that I didnât wise up sooner. But thereâs a blessing in that, too. Now that Iâm 92, I still have plenty of ignorance left to work on.â âCharlie Munger
Reinsurance business and Berkshire selling its 3 percent of Swiss Re and 10 percent of Munich Re over past year âThe reinsurance business wonât be as good over the next 10 years as it was over last 10 years. Thatâs in part because of low interest rates. They canât earn as much on the float.â âWarren Buffett
âFloat is worth more to Berkshire than other insurance companies when interest rates are low because Berkshire has a broader range of options for what to do with it.â âWarren Buffett
âThereâs a lot of new capacity in reinsurance. Thatâs totally different than Precision Castparts where a customer would be crazy to switch suppliers.â âCharlie Munger
GEICO and competition âThere was an uptick in auto fatalities last year for the first time in a long time. Distracted driving may be the cause.â âWarren Buffett
âGEICO has quintupled market share over timeâI wouldnât worry about a competitor having a good quarter or two.â âCharlie Munger
Retailing âWe failed in retail so miserably that we reduced our troubles.â âCharlie Munger
Studies on harmful effects of soft drinks âIf youâre happy every day, I think youâre going to live longer.â âWarren Buffett
âOne ghastly error people make is that they look at the disadvantages without looking at the advantages. Itâs immature and stupid.â âCharlie Munger
Derivatives and banks âDerivatives are a problem when there is a discontinuity. Even in good times, they can be problematic. Gen Re unwound its small derivatives holdings and lost $400 million. And we werenât under any pressure or in a hurry.â âWarren Buffett
âAnd the accountants blessed those values.â âCharlie Munger
âIf you take the 50 largest banks in the world, we wouldnât be interested in 45 of those.â âWarren Buffett
Investing in stocks âWhen you buy a stock you get in the mental state of mind as if youâre buying a business.â âWarren Buffett
âThe average client of a stockbroker wonât do well.â âCharlie Munger
NV Energy and renewable energy âBerkshire is required to buy power at $0.10/kilowatt hour when it could buy it in the marketplace at $0.035/kilowatt hour. The concern is having to buy electricity at higher prices that only benefits 17,000 people (people who purchased solar panels). The question is who should pay the subsidies?â âWarren Buffett
âMid-American could not have done whatâs itâs done in renewables without being part of Berkshire.â âWarren Buffett (Berkshire can use the tax credits for its overall business)
Higher education âIf you expect a lot of financial efficiency in higher education, you are howling at the wind.â âCharlie Munger
âMonopolies have pernicious effects everywhere, and universities arenât immune.â âCharlie Munger
âIf we have a problem in our school system, itâs not because weâre cheap.â âWarren Buffett
âI was involved with an endowment that went from $8 million to over a $1 billion. But I didnât see tuition go down.â âWarren Buffett (endowment was Grinnell College)
âI have all the enemies I can afford at the moment.â âCharlie Munger
âI tell students to go work for an organization you admire or an individual you admire, which usually means that most MBAs I meet become self-employed.â âWarren Buffett
GDP growth âReturns on tangible equity have not fallen. GDP per capita has gone up six times in my lifetime. No presidential candidate will interrupt that.â âWarren Buffett
âGDP underweights achievements. Real achievements are way higher.â âCharlie Munger
âNo one thinks theyâd rather live 50 years ago yet they think today is bad.â âWarren Buffett
"Microeconomics is what we do, and macroeconomics is what we put up with." Â âCharlie Munger
Leasing business âThe math of the leasing business is not attractive. We have to bring something to it. Pure money-type leasing is not attractive since others have a lower cost of funds.â âWarren Buffett
âAircraft leasing does not interest us at all. You donât want to try to fix something that is not fixable.â âWarren Buffett
Valeant âValeantâs business model is enormously flawed.â âWarren Buffett
âPeter Kiewitâs description of what to look for in a manager: you want someone who is smart, energetic, and has integrity. If they donât have the last one, you better hope they donât have the first two.â âWarren Buffett
âI watched the House testimony by Valeant executives. It wasnât pretty.â âWarren Buffett
(I watched it after Warren mentioned it and itâs well worth a look: http://www.c-span.org/video/?408805-1/valeant-pharmaceuticals-business-model-repercussions-patients-health-care-system)
âSequoia as reconstituted is reputable. Theyâve fixed it.â âWarren Buffett
âValeant is a sewer. Those involved got all the opprobrium they deserve.â âCharlie Munger
Hedge Funds âHedge funds are a compensation scheme. Itâs unbelievable to me.â âWarren Buffett
"No consultant in the world is going to tell you to buy an S&P index fund and sit for the next 50 years. You don't get to be a consultant that way. And you certainly don't get an annual fee that way." âWarren Buffett
Berkshire governance âThree criteria for Berkshire directors: (1) business savvy (2) shareholder oriented (3) special interest in Berkshire.â âWarren Buffett
âWe have no committees at Berkshire. We may have one, but I donât know about it.â âWarren Buffett
Share buybacks âA full wallet is like a full bladderâthereâs an urge to pee it away.â âWarren Buffett
âCan you imagine buying a business without knowing its price? Itâs like that with share buybacks at any price.â âWarren Buffett
âBuyback press releases never mention valuation.â âWarren Buffett
Nebraska Furniture Mart âDallas Furniture Mart will be a $1 billion annual volume store. Itâs our largest.â âWarren Buffett
Lubrizol âLubrizol has performed as expected. One large acquisition it did was a big mistake. It was in in the oil industryâmade just before oil declined.â âWarren Buffett
Anchoring effect âWe try to avoid the worst anchoring effectâanchoring on your previous conclusion. We try to destroy our previous conclusions.â âCharlie Munger
Acquisitions and due diligence âWe want to add every year something to the normalized earning power of Berkshire.â âWarren Buffett
âImportant to recognize what you canât do. Try to only swing at things in your strike zone. You donât need a high IQ. But you do need emotional control.â âWarren Buffett
âAfter making money, people risk what they need for what they donât need.â âWarren Buffett
âWeâre really trying to become well. Win fairly, use wisely.â âCharlie Munger
âMistakes in acquisitions are in bad assessments of economic future. Â Itâs not due to a lack of due diligenceâa bad lease, etc. The key thing is whether you have a fix on the economics. Is Amazon going to kill it? No diligence list has a fix on this.â âWarren Buffett
âIf I owned a bunch of department stores and shopping malls, I would be thinking very hard about what they will look like 10 years from now.â âWarren Buffett
3G and companyâs employee size âUnable people you canât fix.â âCharlie Munger
âAmerican companies are loaded with people who arenât doing anything or doing the wrong things.â âWarren Buffett
âIâve never seen anyone run things more superbly than 3G when it comes to firms that arenât run well.â âWarren Buffett
âGenerally speaking, companies that are lean do better than companies that are overstaffed. Overstaffed companies are like a human beings weighing 400 pounds.â âCharlie Munger
Van Tuyl (auto dealerships) âVan Tuylâs economics have been almost exactly as expected.â âWarren Buffett
Negative interest rates âI donât think anyone knows much about negative interest rates because weâve never had them before.â âCharlie Munger
Bad businesses âCattleâone of the worst businesses I can imagine.â âCharlie Munger
Incentive plans âYou get what you reward for. GEICO has two variables in its bonus plan that applies to 20,000 employeesâgrowth in number of policies in force and profitability of seasoned business. Thereâs a multiplier effect on the bonus as you move higher in the organization. You donât want to reward profits because you can just stop advertising. You want to reward profits of seasoned business.â âWarren Buffett
Managing working capital âItâs hard when youâre rich and our supplier is not. Itâs better to bend over backwards to have a win-win relationship with your supplier.â âCharlie Munger
Adjusted earnings âThings are good enough at Berkshire where we donât have to inflate the figures.â âWarren Buffett
âIf you see the world accurately, itâs bound to be humorous because it is ridiculous.â âCharlie Munger
Those are a few of the highlights of this yearâs Berkshire annual meeting. There was much more, not to mention all the activities going on in Omaha before and after the meeting. Itâs a terrific weekend for Buffett fans. If youâre free the first weekend of May, Iâd recommend a trip. Hope to see you there next year!
Photo: Bloomberg via Getty Images










