Once Upon A Broken Heart (pt.4)
She left Birmingham five years ago, swearing she'd never come back.
Then one letter changes everything.
Now she's trapped in the city she escaped, hunted by dangerous men, haunted by the boy she once loved—and forced into an arranged marriage with the one person she'd rather die than call her husband.
Thomas Shelby isn't the boy she remembers.
He's colder. Crueler. Untouchable.
And surviving him might be harder than surviving the enemies trying to kill her.
A/n: pt 4 IT’S THE WEDDING DAYYYYYYYY
tbh I wasn’t expecting people would read this but hiii
do not proceed if you are uncomfortable with any of these warnings. you are responsible for your own media consumption. series warnings: minors, do not interact. Stalking, depression non-consensual detailed observation/description of intimate/sexual acts, language, violence, smut, not canon. tommy x reader. might make a master list later
TAGLIST: @ourtiger04 @emilycookie86
The morning arrived grey and merciless.
The rain had stopped sometime before dawn, leaving tiny droplets clinging to the bedroom window. Birmingham looked clean from the outside.
Inside, nothing had changed.
Y/n hadn't slept.
She had spent the entire night sitting on the window seat with her knees tucked against her chest, watching the street below until darkness slowly gave way to morning. Every hour she'd told herself she should try to sleep.
She never did.
There was no point.
Sleep was for people who woke up with something worth waking for.
A soft knock came at the bedroom door.
She didn't answer.
Another knock.
Silence.
The handle turned anyway.
Lou stepped inside first, carrying an ivory wedding dress folded carefully over both arms. Polly followed behind her with a small polished wooden box tucked beneath one arm.
Neither woman spoke.
"...Morning, sweetheart," Lou said gently.
Y/n kept staring out of the window.
"Is it?"
Lou's smile faded.
She laid the dress across the bed with almost painful care.
It was beautiful.
Simple silk.
Long sleeves.
Tiny pearl buttons.
The sort of dress little girls imagined wearing after falling asleep listening to fairy tales.
The sort of dress Y/n had imagined wearing once.
When she was seventeen.
When she thought Thomas Shelby would be the man waiting for her at the altar because she couldn't picture a future where he wasn't.
Now it felt like a funeral dress.
Polly watched her for a long moment.
"You should wash your face."
"I did."
"No."
Y/n finally looked at her.
"I cried afterwards."
Neither woman answered.
Lou crossed the room and gently tucked loose strands of hair behind Y/n's ear.
"Oh..."
Her voice cracked.
"My poor girl."
The skin beneath Y/n's eyes had turned almost purple.
Her eyelids were swollen.
Her lips were split from biting them through the night.
She looked less like a bride...
...and more like someone who had been mourning for years.
Lou instinctively reached for her hand.
"When did you last eat, sweetheart?"
"I'm not hungry."
"That's not what I asked."
"I'm still not hungry."
"You didn't come down for dinner."
Silence.
"You missed breakfast."
Another silence.
"You didn't even drink your tea."
Y/n looked down.
Polly's voice became quieter.
"When?"
She knew that voice.
It was the same one Polly had used whenever she already knew the answer.
"When did you last have a proper meal?"
"...Yesterday."
"What did you eat?"
"A little bread."
"And before that?"
Y/n shrugged.
"The café lets us take home whatever's left."
Lou frowned.
"...Whatever's left?"
"If there is anything left."
"And if there isn't?"
"I make tea."
Lou stared at her.
"Tea?"
"It fills your stomach."
"No."
"It tricks it."
Silence settled over the room.
Polly didn't move.
"Has it really been that hard in London?"
Y/n gave a tired laugh.
"You've never tried paying London rent on café wages."
Nobody answered.
She shrugged again.
"I managed."
Polly shook her head.
"No."
"You survived."
"Those aren't the same thing."
Y/n couldn't argue.
Because Polly was right.
Lou quietly turned away, wiping at her eyes before anyone noticed.
Polly simply looked at the girl she'd helped raise.
The child who'd followed Arthur around insisting she wanted to learn how to box.
The girl who'd spent every summer afternoon talking Thomas Shelby's ear off while he pretended he wasn't listening.
The teenager who laughed louder than anyone else whenever Tommy laughed.
Now...
She could see every bone in her shoulders.
"...Come here."
Y/n obeyed without thinking.
Polly opened the wooden box.
Inside rested an old silver hairbrush.
Her mother's.
Y/n hadn't seen it in years.
Polly began brushing the knots from her hair exactly the way she had when Y/n was little.
Slowly.
Patiently.
Neither of them spoke.
Some silences were kinder than words.
After a while Y/n whispered,
"I thought you'd stop him."
"The marriage."
The brush paused for only a heartbeat.
"I tried."
Y/n blinked.
"You did?"
"He'd already made up his mind."
"You could've changed it."
Polly smiled sadly.
"I can't always change Richie's mind."
"You usually can."
"Usually."
Y/n laughed bitterly.
"So everyone thinks this is for the best."
"No."
"Then why?"
"Because Billy Kimber won't stop."
"I can protect myself."
"I know."
"I've done it before."
"I know."
"I don't need Thomas."
"I know."
Tears blurred her reflection.
"So why?"
Polly carefully set the brush down.
"...Because I buried one girl already."
Y/n froze.
Polly almost never spoke about her sister.
No one did.
The room suddenly felt smaller.
"I still wish..." Y/n whispered.
"No."
"I do."
"No."
"It should've been me."
Polly turned her around so quickly the chair scraped loudly against the floor.
"Don't."
"It should've been me."
"Don't ever say that again."
"She would've known what to do."
"No."
"She was better than me."
"No."
"They took the wrong sister."
Polly grabbed her face between both hands.
"They took your sister."
Her voice broke.
"They did not leave me with the wrong daughter."
Silence.
"I miss her."
"I know."
"I still hear her laughing."
"I know."
"I still wake up thinking she's alive."
"I know."
Y/n finally broke.
She buried her face against Polly's shoulder and sobbed like she hadn't since she was sixteen.
"I'm scared."
"I know."
"I don't want this."
"I know."
"I wanted..."
She couldn't finish.
She didn't have to.
Polly already knew whose name she couldn't say.
Thomas.
Not the man waiting downstairs.
The boy.
The boy who had climbed through Richie's bedroom window because he'd been too nervous to knock.
The boy who laughed until he couldn't breathe because she'd accidentally punched Arthur instead of the training bag.
The boy who kissed her behind the house at seventeen and promised, with all the certainty only teenagers possess, that when the war ended they'd never have to say goodbye again.
Polly stroked her hair.
"So did Thomas."
Y/n slowly looked up.
"What?"
"The Thomas you loved."
Not Thomas Shelby.
Not Mr. Shelby.
Thomas.
"The boy before France."
Silence.
"He would've asked your uncle properly."
A tiny smile touched Polly's lips.
"He would've spent weeks rehearsing it."
Y/n laughed weakly through her tears.
"He would've forgotten the ring."
"He would've."
"He would've stumbled over every word."
"And Arthur would've laughed at him for months."
Another tiny smile.
"He would've smiled the whole day."
Polly nodded.
"He used to smile all the time."
The smile disappeared from both their faces.
"...He's gone."
Polly didn't argue.
She simply nodded.
"Yes."
Not dead.
But gone.
"The war brought Thomas Shelby home."
She gently wiped another tear from Y/n's cheek.
"But the boy you loved..."
Her own eyes filled.
"...he never came back."
Silence settled over the room.
Even the rain seemed quieter.
Lou finally lifted the wedding dress.
"Come on, sweetheart."
Together they dressed her.
The silk slid over her shoulders.
Lou fastened each pearl button one by one.
When Y/n looked into the mirror...
She barely recognized herself.
She looked beautiful.
Not like a bride.
Like someone preserving the memory of the girl she used to be before walking toward the life she'd never chosen.












