Ok so I know for a fact @lireavue totally reblogged this as bait BUT IâM GOING TO TKE IT because no no no. While I endorse and absolutely agree with OPâs point they have actually undersold Ăomerâs Battle of the Pelennor badassery as far as the book goes and we cannot have that.Â
Ăomer comes across ThĂŠodenâs bodies and tells what the book frames as his âknightsâ* off the field while extemporising a mourning poem[1] (while also crying, despite starting it with âmourn not overmuchâ).Â
Shortly thereafter he does indeed find what he thinks is Ăowynâs dead body and does in fact lose his shit for a while in a âyou wouldnât like me when Iâm nihilistically enraged and believe everything is hopelessâ and kills a lot of the enemy but he also manages to get himself WAY over his head and ends up surrounded on a small hill with more or less his werod/knights backing him up and the rest of his people kinda scattered, and shakes off some of his Hulkout and realizes huh, MAYBE that wasnât wise.Â
[Ăomer] let blow the horns to rally all men to his banner that could come thither; for he thought to make a great shield-wall at the last, and stand, and fight there on foot till all fell, and do deeds of song on the fields of Pelennor, though no man should be left in the West to remember the last King of the Mark. So he rode to a green hillock and there set his banner, and the White Horse ran rippling in the wind.
Out of doubt, out of dark to the dayâs rising
I came singing in the sun, sword unsheathing.
To hopeâs end I rode and to heartâs breaking:
Now for wrath, now for ruin and a red nightfall!
These staves he spoke, yet he laughed as he said them. For once more lust of battle was on him; and he was still unscathed, and he was young, and he was king: the lord of a fell people. And lo! even as he laughed at despair he looked out again on the black ships, and he lifted up his sword to defy them.
In other words when he realized he was totally fucked (and let me be clear: he was at that point totally fucked) Ăomer had the same reaction that his sister did (although she had a much more pervasive, soul-eating and all-encompassing pathological sense of âeverything is fucked and nothing has any pointâ) which was âfine fuck it Iâm dying fighting to the last breath without fear in a way that would make my ancestors proud even if nobody ever knows about it!âÂ
Because we are not done!Â
He looks at what he knows at that point is his absolute doom (the black ships) and basically shouts COME ON IF YOU THINK YOUâRE HARD ENOUGH! at what he knows is the army thatâs gonna smash him and the last of his army to red ruin. In verse.Â
Because ManwĂŤ is a marshmallow.Â
The wind catches the banner on the lead ship. Which is ⌠not the Corsairs of Umbarâs banner. But is, in fact.Â
Aragorn Elessarâs banner. Made by Arwen UndĂłmiel, descendant of both LĂşthien Meliansdaughter and of the House of FinwĂŤ, who made it embroidered with gold wire and mithril and complete with actual gemstones just for extra ability to catch attention to say, in fact, âHEY LOOK MY BOYâS HERE TO FUCK YOU UPâ.Â
Whereupon Ăomer Ăomundson whoops, throws his sword in the air AND CATCHES IT, while laughing why in the name of GODS did you not stick to the damn book PJ and cuts his way across the space between him and the landing! So he can go HOLY SHIT DUDE I DIDNâT THINK YOUâD MAKE IT.Â
After which not only did he and Aragorn sort of slaughter their way across the field but also, âsuch was their skill at armsâ that neither of them even got a minor wound.
Heâs also man enough to admit, at the subsequent meeting, that all this shit is WAY over his head but Aragorn is definitely his bro and he and Gandalf are both very smart and he, Ăomer, is pretty good at fighting things and theyâre suggesting fighting things so yeah letâs go with that.Â
And to be totally fair to him he also took Gandalf going â ⌠.kid, YOU got to ride around doing shit while everything went to hell, whereas your sister got stuck at home, RIGHT THERE WITH WORMTONGUE, looking after your uncle, with nothing to take any of it out on - yeah, no, Aragorn was not what fucked your sister up.â at him later with pretty good grace for such a horrible revelation.Â
*as Tolkien certainly knew but which would have been hella confusing to put in there, âknightâ was essentially a later-Old-English remix of the much older werod and hearthwerod, so think less âguys in shining armourâ and more âthe kingâs personal warbandâ - in sending ThĂŠodenâs men to take his body off the field Ăomer is both acknowledging their intense personal fealty to his uncle AND HOWEVER at least temporarily losing at least a handful of his baddest ass fighters.Â
Mourn not overmuch! Mighty was the fallen,
meet was his ending. When his mound is raised,
women then shall weep. War now calls us!