Redefiners: Unusual Suspects Winners
Our winners this week are @bread-into-toast, @thepeppermintpig, and @yd12k.
~
@bread-into-toast — Spellthirst Vitalist
While big splashy cards have an undeniable appeal, one thing you'll often find about me in particular is that I prefer lower-to-the-ground, value-heavy designs, of which this is a perfect example. This card presents a very clear gameplan, capable of generating unbelievable amounts of advantage off of an aggressive body, and heavily encouraging you towards a spellslinging playstyle in a black/green deck, which is exactly what this contest asks for.
@thepeppermintpig — Jushi Balance-Keeper
Another value engine, but this one much splashier. Encouraging a direct mixture of enchantments and artifacts, with both the nontoken restriction on the trigger and the actual effect ensuring you can't just cheat one of the two with token generation, this presents a very interesting deckbuilding puzzle, tasking you with finding a way to get the best of both worlds, without leaning too hard into one or the other. Excellent combination of flavor and gameplay in that regard. One minor note, though: the effect should say "return up to one target enchantment card from your graveyard to your hand."
@yd12k — Guul Draz Arena
Sometimes, simplicity is best, and this card serves as a perfect example of that. On its face, this is just a sidegraded Phyrexian Arena, a comparison the card is designed to get you to make. But, on a closer look, the way it plays is very different. In a baseline scenario, where you're simply playing one land every turn, it functions much the same way as its phyrexian counterpart, drawing you a single extra card extra turn, albeit with the chance of an unlucky draw preventing you from getting the advantage next turn, and the ability to turn it off whenever you want. However, when you start to build around it, it has the chance for explosive amounts of power, turning even a simple evolving wilds into a massive burst of card advantage—as well as a massive burst of self-damage. Taking all the risk-reward elements of the original arena and putting them on an all-new axis makes this a clear winner for me.
Stay tuned, runner-ups will be arriving shortly.

















