Toby and I had what in our city was an uncommon dilemma- we were both tops. Our friends referred to us as the “What a Waste Couple,” and couldn’t understand why, with the seemingly limitless supply of bottoms around us, we would choose to be together. Sometimes I wondered myself.
We were both pretty fit otter-y types, me, 29, and Toby, 32. We met at the gym, scoping each other out. We had similar builds- 5'11’’, 165ish- and similar vibes. Our interests overlapped, as did our social circles, and both thought the other was sexy… but the sex had been a bit of a problem. Sure, we often would bring in a local bottom who was only too happy to be spit roasted between us, but sometimes you don’t want to go through the whole Grindr “Let’s find someone we’d both fuck” rigamarole and just wanna plow the man you go to bed with every night, am I right?
Anyway, neither of us really wanted to bring it up, and when I finally tried to address it point blank last night, Toby said he didn’t want to talk about it and left. After a few restless hours, I fell asleep, alone.
I woke up coughing. There was some kind of weird taste in my mouth.
“Sorry about that, boy,” I heard a familiar voice say. “Didn’t mean to make you choke just yet.”
Toby stood over me, two tiny green glass bottles in his hand, one of them empty. He was dressed head to toe in leather gear- pants, jacket, gloves.
“Did you just pour something down my throat?” I asked, between coughs. I cleared my throat. “And what’s with the leather?”
“Just a little something I picked up for the two of us,” he said with a smirk and a wink.
“This,” he said, shaking the full bottle a little. “Is the answer to our problem.” He then popped open the top and chugged it.
“What is it? Some kind of 5 hour energy or something?” I asked. My voice felt strange.
“Last night I went to a sex shop in Chinatown and the old guy who worked there said he had just the thing for us. Two bottles- one to make you a submissive bottom boi and one to make me a full blown leather daddy. I felt like I should dress the part.”
My legs were tingling, as was my face.
“No more jockeying for the top,” he grinned. “We’ll finally know our roles. I’ll be the real alpha, and you’ll just be my little fuckboy.”
Toby stood up and looked at me. The leather outfit looked big on him.
“Feeling the changes yet?” he asked.
I was feeling something alright- my face felt itchy, not like my normal five o'clock shadow.
“You asshole,” I said, clearing my throat. “I can’t believe you’d do this.”
A look of confusion flashed across Toby’s face.
“Why is your voice lower?” he asked. His hand flew to his own throat and his eyes widened. “Why – *ahem* is…. is my voice higher?”
Toby’s jacket was now positively baggy on him. He looked a few inches shorter as well. My hand stroked the scruff that was spreading across my face as I looked at Toby’s ever more boylike features.
“Well, boy,” I said with a grin, standing up. Toby had indeed shrunk and was looking up at me in shock. “Looks like you should have paid attention to which bottle was which.”
My back cracked as I stretched and looked down at my hairy, beefier chest and ballooning thighs. My cock looked fatter, and started to swell.
Toby grew even more slender and boyish. He looked younger with each passing minute, ticking back towards his early 20’s…. 20… 19. The look on his face kept alternating between confusion and fear before morphing into something else…. desire?
I caught a glimpse of myself in the mirror. I was probably 6'2’’ and close to 200 lbs. My features were darker, older, and a full beard wreathed my chin. I was every inch a leather daddy, minus the leather.
“You look ridiculous,” I said to my now shrunken boyfriend. “That leather belongs on a real man, don’t you think?”
“Say, yes, boy,” I commanded. Something shifted in Toby’s eyes.
I didn’t even have to push my new fuck boy to his knees. He knew his place.
“You were right about one thing,” I said, my hand pushing his head down even farther on my throbbing cock. “We finally know our roles.”
My twinky boy toy moaned in agreement, his too-large pants around his ankles, his little cock hard in his pumping, leather-gloved hand.