Indiscretions - Chapter 5
Andrew "Pope" Cody x fem!reader
For three years, you were the only thing keeping Pope from losing his mind in Folsom. A bright-eyed, too-good-for-this-world social worker who still believed even a broken system could sometimes manage to do some good. For three years, you tried not to want Andrew, your client, a man with emotional scars that cut too deep for you to ever heal and a violent temper that, for some reason, never turned on you. Now that no guards and no bars remain between you, Pope cannot understand why you insist you can never see him again.
Ch. 1 | Ch. 2 | Ch. 3 | Ch. 4 | Chapter 5 | Ch. 6
Words: 8,6 k
Content: Older Man/Younger Woman, Prison!Social!Worker!Reader, Protective Pope, Forbidden Love, Mututal Pining, Smut, Breaking and Entering - or 'Pope trying to flirt', Inappropriate Behaviour - Pope is desperate for you and won't take no as an answer, reader's father is a serial killer and a psychopath
Pope is such a sub this chapter (not sorry at all)
No use of y/n!
Read on Ao3 or below the cut:
A/N: This chapter was fighting me every step of the way. I'm so happy it's finally done 😭 I hope the end doesn't suck, I have no nerves left to go over it again.
You arrived at the Cody residence far too fucking early for any human interaction - much less the tedious, obnoxious kind - and so far any interaction you’ve had with a Cody that was not Andrew or J had been exceedingly tedious and obnoxious.
You parked your car in front of the garage. At least Smurf’s Jaguar was gone, meaning the manipulative hag attached to it was as well.
But you saw both Craig’s and Deran’s car - as well as Baz’s, though the latter you had been expecting. It was him who called you, after all.
It was pretty pathetic that all these grown-ass men who had their own places still slept at mummy’s all the time, though of course you knew about the manipulative, toxic hold Smurf had over her sons, so that thought was probably not the nicest to have.
It was early! You didn’t have the brain power or will to life required for nuanced takes on anything.
You threw the door of your crappy car shut. Pete gave you shit about it constantly, and how he was bored of fixing a pile of shit all the time when it would just inevitably break down on you again. You were sure his insults he hurled at your car whenever he worked on it were not beneficial to the overall state of it, though he never listened to you when you argued the point.
Craig and Deran - you could finally keep them apart, and wasn’t that a big win? - sat at the table by the terrace door, eating a lavish and fatty breakfast while watching Pope across the pool.
“Oh boy.” You muttered to yourself and sighed.
Baz hadn’t been exaggerating. He called you an hour ago to tell you Pope had been in the garden since before 6 a.m., swinging at his punching bag without a single break as if his life depended on it.
It was now 10 a.m.
He had that expression again… that same expression he wore when he didn’t hear the guards telling him rec time was over while he was bench pressing in the yard. Or the time guards sedated him because he was manically scrubbing at the walls of his cell with his toothbrush…
The concern the sight of him sent through your body like an electric charge was not enough to make you not notice just how hot Andrew was.
His gym shorts sat low on his hips. The exertion he’d put his body through since before the sunrise made his muscles look all the more defined. Sweat clung to his pale, freckled skin and glued the hair that had begun to grow out to the back of his nape.
“You took your sweet ass time.” Baz stepped out of the house, already oozing annoyance, and pulled you from your silent admiration - admiration, definitely not shameless drooling. Nope, you had standards.
And oh, it was too early on a Sunday for bullshit like that!
“Ex-fucking-cuse me? Who do you think you’re talking to?” You crossed your arms.
“I called an hour ago.”
“Yeah? And I’m not at your fucking behest, dude. I’m not even here for you. You can go choke on a bag of dicks for all I care.” You scoffed and turned away from him and his snickering brothers.
You had met a lot of cocky, self-satisfied assholes in your life, but Barry Blackwell was definitely in the top five worst offenders.
Andrew had yet to notice your arrival. He gave a jump when you appeared in his peripheral vision that had narrowed as his focus had honed in on the punching bag, allowing you to get closer to him without him realising than you’d usually ever managed.
“Hey.” You crooned and stepped into his space. Andrew rasped your name, a breathy whisper that dwindled to nothing when you brushed your lips against his in a sweet, fleeting kiss. Your hands found the thick velcro straps of his boxing gloves. You tugged his gloves off him just to slip them on yourself.
You shuddered.
“They are wet.”
A blush spread across Andrew’s cheeks.
“Like really wet.” You held your hands out for him to fix the velcro straps in place anyway.
“Keep complainin’” He huffed. You gave his shoulder a little love-tap with the glove and shot him a wide grin before turning around towards the punching bag.
Your first strike made the metal structure it was suspended from rattle.
Andrew’s eyes widened behind you. You ignored the wolf whistling coming from his brothers. Your next punch landed even harder. His gloves were too big on you, and you felt the wet lining chafe against your unwrapped knuckles, but you hardly cared. Some primal form of satisfaction settled over your raw nerves and buzzed pleasantly every time you landed a punch.
Andrew slipped around you to hold the bag in place, allowing you to exert even more strength. The sun was already smouldering despite it not even being noon yet. Sweat started to gather on your brow and neck. You felt his hazel eyes resting on you. You were so used to his staring at this point - after three years of working with him and weeks of him following you like a lost puppy - it honestly felt strange when he wasn’t doing it.
“Someone at the prison found out.” You muttered between punches. “About you.” A dull pang tore through your knuckle the next time your fist connected with the punching bag, the weight you put into it causing a harsher impact with the unyielding material of the bag. You didn’t even wince. “About my father.” The next punch landed even harder. “About everything. You know that place. Rumour spread like a goddamn wildfire.”
You didn’t meet Andrew’s apologetic eyes. You knew the second he found out he’d feel responsible, which was why you hadn’t planned on telling him. He wasn’t. This was your cross to carry, always had been. Andrew added little to that burden.
“You can fight.” He rasped, his voice so small in comparison to the man it belonged to. It was almost laughable.
“Don’t think I’d have survived juvie otherwise.” You huffed between punches. “Or the loony bin.”
You took a step back and wiped your forehead on your arm.
“I’m not gonna lie, Andrew, I’ve been thinking about doing the thing I always do when things get difficult since Thursday. Didn’t even want to go to work on Friday but that would have just added fuel to the rumours.” You slumped down on the springboard next to the bag, right next to Pope’s towel and water bottle, though as far away from the edge of the pool as you could.
“These are really disgusting.” You hold your gloved hands out to him. A fleeting smile tugged on the corner of Andrew’s mouth. He sat down next to you, in between you and the water, to free you from the sweaty boxing gloves. You could take them off on your own, had many times, but you rather enjoyed watching Andrew’s profile and the concentrated expression on his freckled face as he undid the straps and gently tugged the too-big gloves off your hands. It was… nice to be taken care of for once…
You reached for the towel to wipe your hands.
“What do you usually do?” His question came out barely loud enough to interrupt the silence between you.
“I leave.” You shrugged. “I run away. I’ve never been in a place that was great enough that I’d be willing to deal with discomfort.”
Andrew ducked his head. His eyes slid off you, falling to the floor to your feet instead. He understood. He loathed that you were about to leave him, but he understood.
“But…”
He glanced up. Your expression softened.
“...I don’t want to. The instinct is still there of course - will always be, I guess - but… when I was thinking about it, I had to think about leaving you too, and… and I don’t want to do that.”
A crease formed between Andrew’s brows. You reached out to smooth it out with your thumb, letting the pad of your finger drag over his sweaty skin. Andrew leaned into the touch, eyes fluttering shut. You wondered whether anyone had ever offered him such simple affection, affection that wasn’t tied to manipulation or demands.
You sure knew nobody had done it for you.
“Shit is really fucking messy, and that terrifies me, Andrew… but I feel things for you I’ve never felt before and I think… I think if I let myself be driven away from this, if I continue acting the way I have been, denying these feelings and hiding from whatever this between us is… I’ll regret it for the rest of my life.”
You didn’t know whether you’d ever been that open with Andrew - or anyone. Perhaps when you told him about your father, though this felt… bigger.
“I haven’t been taking this seriously.”
“‘tis okay.”
“It’s not though.”
Andrew opened his eyes. Sad, big, hazel eyes met you. He’d leaned into you further without even noticing and was taken aback by this sudden proximity for a brief moment. Your hand slipped down his face to cup his cheek.
“You deserve better. You deserve to have your feelings and relationships taken seriously.”
Andrew licked his lips nervously. “We are in a relationship?”
A smile tugged on your mouth. “Yeah.”
His insides did a somersault. His hand wrapped around your wrist, softly, always with such aching gentleness for you - as if he believed, truly believed you deserved it - to keep your hand on his cheek.
“Will you be okay at the prison? With people knowing?”
“Well, they don’t know. They have rumours. It’ll give me some headaches for a while, but I don’t think it’ll escalate beyond the fact a few more guys will think they can get into my pants. And you’ve seen me shut that shit down in the past.” You shrugged. Your gaze wandered over the garden, the tiki bar in the corner and the pool, growing distant and empty. “There will be a fire in my office on Monday.”
Andrew next to you tensed.
“I won’t be there, but many files and documents will be lost. Yours will be among them.”
“What about digital copies?”
You scoffed. “Folsom is too underfunded to have anything digitalised, sweetheart. There will be no proof you were ever one of my clients.”
“People know.”
“People think to know. You were part of my book club. You came by to talk sometimes, to escape the mistreatment of the guards. That’s not enough for an official client-relationship.”
“And the warden?”
“Oh, I still have the CCTV files from the SHU. The warden does not want your abuse to become public knowledge. If someone comes sniffing around, I’ll have him heel and say exactly what I want him to say, no problem.”
“You’re ruthless.”
“Hm.” If you had to be.
You watched the ripples on the water surface of the pool. Your hand dropped to Andrew’s thigh when he let go of your wrist. “Vin is out.”
“I know.” Andrew sniffed. “He came to me. I have it under control.”
You nodded. “Just thought I’d give you a heads-up.” You shook yourself, forcing yourself out of the sombre mood that had taken hold of you and turned towards Andrew. “So, that was me. What has you abusing poor punching bags since six a.m.?”
“Who told you that?”
“Baz called me.” You plucked a dead leaf off your skirt and flicked it away. “I intend to give his phone number to every pesky charity organisation and car dealership I can find. You know, as payback for going through your phone to find my number and thinking he can call on me like some fucking servant.”
“I’m sorry.”
You just shrugged it off and watched Andrew wring his hands in his lap. You didn’t urge him to talk or scramble to fill the silence with some useless drivel. Either Andrew was going to talk in his own time, or he wasn’t.
You braced your hands against the lounger behind you and leaned back, closing your eyes and tipping your head up to enjoy the warm sun on your face. The pool filter gurgled softly in the background. Bits and pieces of his brothers’ conversation - some plans for a big party tonight - drifted in and out of your focus.
“She put meds in my food.”
You turned your head at the familiar sound of tiny pills rattling against plastic. Andrew shoved two orange pill bottles into your hand. You read the names on the prescription on the labels.
“Who’s that guy?”
Andrew shrugged. “The guy Smurf stole the pills from?”
“She’s been giving you these? Without you knowing? What the fuck?!” You turned the pill bottles over to read the name of the medications. They didn’t ring a bell, not that that surprised you. You were a social worker, not a clinician. You knew a little bit about medication from your experience of working with your clients, but not nearly enough to recognise meds by their names and know what they were prescribed for.
“She only told me because my piss test came back positive and they kept me in lock up overnight. Said I took LSD, but I don’t do that shit, never have. Smurf confessed then.”
Andrew wasn’t with you every second of every day, despite it often feeling that way, but had you really missed that he’d been locked up?
“Many medications for like ADHD and shit are considered controlled substances. They are very strong stimulants. You even need a paper trail to bring them to a different country without getting charged for drug smuggling.” You looked up to find Andrew already looking at you. “Are you alright? With your PO, I mean.”
“He let me go with a warning.”
You nodded.
“Smurf told me to keep takin’ them, that I need them. Said I should tell my PO I’m back on my meds before my next piss test.”
You blinked at him in disbelief. “She thinks that’ll take care of this? Andrew, if these show up as LSD on your drug test, your PO will want to see a doctor’s note and a prescription. Taking prescription-only pills without one is the same as taking coke in the eyes of the law. And- and you don’t even know if these are appropriate for your needs! Taking just any random psychotropics, especially without a doctor overseeing it, does more harm than good.”
He ducked his head. “So you think I shouldn’t take them?”
“I-” You stopped yourself. You weren’t his social worker anymore. You didn’t have to be neutral. “Not these, definitely no. I’ve been offering you for three years to help you look into medications to help you cope. I’m not saying you should now stop considering it, but if you want to look into meds to help you cope, do it the right way, Andrew. These- who is to say these have made you feel any better?”
“Smurf says they have. Said they made me calm.”
“And how would she fucking know that, huh? Most pills take several weeks to show their full effects. They just make you sleepy before then, doesn't mean they are helping.”
“But I’ve been better… right? I- I- I’ve been normal.”
“Sweetheart…” You sighed and chucked the pill bottles aside to take his face into your hands. A big, trembling shudder coursed through him at your touch. His eyes fluttered shut, concealing the wetness beginning to gather on his lower lid. “Normal is a concept created by those who wanted an easy excuse to discriminate against everyone they deemed unworthy of receiving basic human decency. No one of us is normal. You’ve been… different, but honestly I thought you just had time to settle a little after getting out. It can be quite overwhelming to be back in the real world.”
Andrew grasped at his thigh, digging his meaty fingers into his thighs just above his knee until the skin over his knuckles and beneath his fingertips turned white. “So you like me better now? When- when I take them?”
“Andrew…” You murmured and caught his chin in your hand. He resisted your urging to look at you, and even when he gave in shortly after and moved his head, he didn’t lift his eyes. “Andy, look at me.”
Tension coiled tightly around his shoulders, but your soft tone combined with your gentle touch, and the unfamiliar nickname that oozed such easy fondness, poured prickling warmth straight into the centre of his being and underwashed the walls he’d drawn tightly around himself as a little boy so nothing would ever hurt him again until they crumbled to dust beneath your steady, grounding, calm gaze.
Andrew lifted his eyes.
“I liked you when you first arrived at Folsom. When you sat in that room with me so stiff, I thought maybe they had brought in a statue instead of a man, when you were so on-edge and scared and overwhelmed that you could barely talk to me. I liked you when the reality of your prison sentence settled in, and you lashed out in all your fear, when you attacked that guard and when you got in my face and yelled at me.”
Andrew winced at the memory. You didn’t seem bothered by it.
“I liked you when the guards had shoved so many meds down your throat you could barely do more than drool. I liked you when you were in the middle of a psychotic episode in solitary, and I liked you when you showed up in the parking lot of my workplace out of the blue. Andrew, I have liked every version of you.”
“She said you wouldn’t.” His voice sounded raw and heavy, as though a barrage of unshed tears were pressing down on his vocal chords. “If I don’t take them. That you’re scared of me.”
You stroked his cheek and wrapped your free hand around his in his lap to peel them away from his thighs before he hurt himself. “There is only one man I am afraid of, and it isn’t you. I wasn’t scared when you cornered me in the library, was I, love? Why would I be now?”
“Didn’t mean ta scare ya.” He muttered, ducking his head again. The pill bottles had found their way into his hands again somehow. He turned and twisted them between his fingers and peeled at the labels.
“I know.” You murmured.
“Just… just wanted to be near you.”
“I know.”
You leaned in. A wolfish grin tugged on your lips. “And look at that… I’m right here. No bars, no guards, nothin’ keeping you from me. Isn’t that something?”
An almost shy smile skittered across Andrew’s lips. You took the pill bottles from his lap and promptly chucked them over his shoulder and into the pool.
“But you won’t be taking those. Not if I can stop it, handsome. I’m not letting you go back to prison.”
Andrew shuddered at the thought.
“Not going back there. Ever.”
“No, you aren’t.” You agreed and ran your fingers through his hair. You couldn’t wait for it to grow out, for the pretty auburn curls you only got one look at during your initial intake interview with Andrew and then never again.
“I know some people.” You continued once Andrew’s fidgeting mellowed out to a more normal, more settled level. “In a clinic not far from Oceanside. They specialise in mental health crises, but I could probably get you an appointment - if you want to discuss a drug regimen that would actually be suitable for your needs.”
“And what-” Andrew rubbed his neck and stared at the orange pill bottles floating in the pool. “-what d’you think those are?”
“I’m not an expert in these things, love.”
“Yeah, but… you’re really smart.”
“Charmer.” You chuckled and pressed a kiss to Andrew’s cheek. He tried to turn away from you to hide the blush creeping up his neck, but you saw it regardless.
“And you know me.”
“I really can’t tell, Andrew, and it’s not about me anyway. It’s about what you feel you could need some extra help in coping with. It could be the slight, rather pronounced OCD tendencies my apartment has been getting to now.” You bumped his shoulder with yours. “Or sleeping. Paranoia, anxiety, depression. All things a little chemical serotonin boost could alleviate a little. Help you function with a little less struggle.”
“I- I- I’ll think about it.”
“Oh, now he thinks about it?” You teased and pinched his side, earning a gruff look from Andrew. “What? A girl not allowed to be a little salty? I tried for three years to get you to at least consider it and now, what? I let you lick my cunt and suddenly he considers it?”
A furious flush spread across Andrew’s cheeks. It only spurred you on.
“If I had known that was all it took… maybe I would have let you do it in the library three years ago.”
He opened his mouth, but no sound made it out, so he closed it again before finally managing a quiet, choked-off, “-you wouldn’t have.”
“Hm, I don’t know. I’ve always been very motivated to help you.”
The shift in his expression was a split-second thing, but you’d spent three years watching his face like a hawk to decipher what was going on in him when he refused to talk. You were up and running from him with a squeal on your lips. Andrew chased after you. You adored how much more playful he had gotten in just the last few days. You adored that you could make him feel safe enough to just be… himself. To just exist without questioning his every move.
You adored that you’d been made one of the few people on this earth who knew just how goofy his humour could get, and you adored his humour.
It was almost suffocating how much, how deeply you cared.
You were not yet brave enough to put the proper name to it, and all the less for the shadow of your father looming over you.
But there was no shadow right now.
You chased across the grass, narrowly avoiding Andrew’s things so uncharacteristically strewn across the entire place and almost crashed into a sun lounger. Andrew was on your heels. You knew the only reason you’d made it more than a couple of steps was that he was letting you.
A breathy chuckle behind you announced your imminent defeat.
You climbed over another lounger and tried one last, rather desperate dash for freedom that brought you dangerously close to the pool - a circumstance you did not realise in your frantic, giggling running.
Just like the puddle on the smooth bricks surrounding the pool.
You slipped on it, not enough to land on your ass, but enough to lose your footing - right next to the pool.
Your heart climbed into your throat. Sheer, blind panic flooded your nervous system and drowned out any fun you’d been having, any sense, and any ability to figure out an escape from the imminent, terrifying plunge into the deep water.
You tried regardless, arms flailing in the air, breath trapped in your throat, heart hammering in your chest as your insides twisted in mortal fear-
Arms wrapped around you from behind and tugged you back sharply. Your back collided with Andrew’s firm chest. His warmth coiled around you, normally unbearable in the scorching heat of the California sun, but comforting in this moment.
You were trembling all over.
Tears already stung in your eyes despite nothing having happened, and you hated it. It was a pool. You’d have clung to the edge like a wet cat and hated your life, but it’s not like this was the ocean with deadly waves and sharp rocks and all the other dangers lurking beneath the surface.
“I’ve got you.” Andrew muttered against your hair, lips pressed to the crown of your head. His arms coiled around your middle kept you upright even when your legs crumbled under the weight of the fear crashing down on you.
You had no reason to feel this way. Nothing happened.
That’s not true, you forced yourself to think. I am afraid of deep water and just almost fell into deep water. It is normal to have a bodily reaction to that. It’s not nothing. You are afraid. It’s not rational. It doesn’t have to be.
You pressed your eyes shut and tried to count the seconds while taking a deep breath. Your fingertips strained against Andrew’s strong arms. Your nails were probably driving into his flesh, but he didn’t flinch, didn’t seem to even think about moving away from you.
He just held you.
He held you and buried his face against your neck, breathing in the same calming pattern you had shown him and were now failing gloriously at implementing.
He held you until you weren’t trembling anymore, until you patted his arm as though to tap out of a fight.
You wiped at the corners of your eyes in what you hoped was a subtle way, but Andrew noticed. His brows were furrowed and lips pressed into a thin line tightly. He glanced over your shoulder at the pool, and oh boy. If looks could kill, that pool would have been deader than the Dead Sea.
“It’s okay.” You murmured and forced yourself to release the tension in your shoulders. “I’m okay.” You ran your hands through your hair and emitted an empty laugh. “You can stop trying to kill the pool by looking at it, Andrew.”
He huffed. Then, without warning and in an unusually handsy fashion considering the fact you weren’t alone, he tugged you into him by the waist and buried his face against your hair again.
“Don’t like it when you’re scared.” He muttered.
You couldn’t help but smile as you wrapped your arms around his neck.
Had anyone ever said that to you? Or even felt that way?
“I’m okay. You saved me.”
Andrew hugged you tighter.
When he eventually pulled back, he reached out to cup your face, not without brushing your hair aside so he could have an unrestricted view of you. He wore a pensive expression.
You waited for him to find whatever it was he needed before being able to speak, your hand wrapped loosely around his wrists.
It was easy to be patient for Andrew.
“I’ll go talk to those clinic people.” He murmured eventually, gaze sliding off you to fix on something behind your back.
“I’m very happy to hear that. You don’t have to agree to any meds or anything, but I think hearing what they might have to say could be good.”
“-if-” he continued and looked back at you. “-you tell Pete he can put people on your street.”
You tried not to roll your eyes. Emphasis on tried. You wanted to squirm out of his grasp, but that man was almost freakishly strong.
“A few gangbangers on my street won’t change anything, Andy.”
“If it doesn’t change anything, why insist on saying no?” Now he was the one who sounded exasperated with you.
Variety is the spice of life - or something like that.
Andrew grabbed your wrist when you pulled harder to get away from him and dragged you back towards him, looming over you with that intense, almost feral expression he always got before starting a fight on the block.
His brothers tensed. Baz made half a step towards you while Deran and Craig were up and out of their seats.
It made your blood boil that they actually seemed to think Andrew would hurt you. It made you absolutely furious.
“It would just put them in danger-”
“-they’re gangbangers-”
“-so they deserve being cannon fodder for a serial killer?! I don’t need you or Pete to realise I’m nothing but a huge bitch, alright?! For fuck’s sake, Andrew! Can’t you just accept my decision?”
You didn’t mean to blow up on him.
You deflated when he dragged you away from the pool and onto the lawn before letting go of your wrists.
“You’re not.” He whispered.
“I don’t care about his victims, okay?” You replied, voice even quieter than his. “The people he kills? It doesn’t affect me. Remember how- how we talked about dissociation?”
He gave a small nod.
“Well, I think I dissociate from empathy or something, because I feel bad for the feelings my mum has to go through when he breaks out and for my former best friend from college he put in the hospital during one of his vacations, but I feel absolutely nothing for the truckers I lured in for him-”
“-They were predators. They fucking deserved it-”
“Or for my boyfriend I had when I was eighteen. My first boyfriend. My first love. My father killed him, fucking slaughtered him, and when the cops showed me pictures of his body I felt nothing. I knew about those girls, those girls he’s killed since escaping this time, before Pete told me and I. don’t. care.”
Tears clouded your vision. Not for his victims but born of shame because what horrible, wretched person would be left so utterly unaffected by such senseless, brutal killings?
Andrew was quiet for a moment, and his silence hurt worse than if he had turned away in disgust, worse than you could have ever anticipated it would feel.
What would he think now? Now that he was forced to realise you weren’t some pure, perfect, angelic being? It was terrifying to let him see the ugly, broken parts of you. Yeah, you’d spend three years holding the broken pieces of him together in a ruthless, broken system with nothing but determination and a debilitating inability to give up on people, but who could ever look at you after hearing that and deem you worthy of the same?
Of course he would no longer care about you once the perfect, idealised version of you he’d created in his mind in his lonely, cold cell during long nights shattered before his eyes.
When he found out everything about you was nothing but a fucking lie.
You were a lie.
He made a step towards you. You backed away on instinct. Skittish like a deer unsure about the man approaching.
“You said- dissociation is emotional detachment or severe disconnection from physical and emotional experiences… it’s a- a coping thing. When shit gets too heavy to carry, the brain just… just shuts it off so it won’t hurt you anymore. Like- like cutting off a rotting limb so the rest can survive. It doesn’t make you bad, just… just human.”
A tear rolled down your cheek. “He kills girls who look like me, Andrew. Because they dare to look like me. And I still love him.” The last part, that terrible confession that haunted your whole life, escaped your lips in a breathless whisper. “It is bad. It’s fucking evil.”
“It’s heavy.” Andrew said. “Not evil.”
You forced a smile.
It was sweet that he was trying to comfort and help you - you didn’t miss how he’d incorporated some of the things you’d told him over the years - but no matter how sweet his words, he could not undo all the years those feelings and convictions had had to take root inside you.
Just like you could not undo all the damage Smurf’s manipulations had done, nor how deep her hold over him ran, and likely always would.
You pressed the heels of your hands into your eyes and groaned. “It’s too early for emotional vulnerability and deep dives.”
“It’s 10 a.m.”
“Yes. Early.”
Andrew raised a brow.
“It’s Sunday. That’s for- for sleeping in and brunch and rotting on the couch in sweatpants. I hate being awake.” You whined the last part.
You watched Andrew suck his bottom lip between his teeth through your lashes. “‘could buy you breakfast.” He muttered, glancing to the side to escape your attention, another blush already beginning to creep up his neck.
“Those oatmeal and chocolate chip pancakes you like so much?”
“You would?” On any other day, with any other person, you’d cringe at your hopeful, sweet, pleading tone and the fucking puppy eyes you made, how his simple offer had all the tension slipping off your body, leaving you all soft and sweet - and opening your heart to another person was so disgusting.
And at the same time you knew, if the roles were reversed, you’d be quick to offer Andrew the same. And it would make you happy too, to take care of him.
The day had barely started, and you were already exhausted.
You texted Pete and called your acquaintance at the clinic while Andrew showered. You refused to go out in public with him reeking of sweat.
You yawned at least three times during the drive to your favourite diner, and if Andrew drove around the block a couple of times while your eyes were closed, your forehead resting against the window, well, you wouldn’t have been able to tell.
He knew how exhausting it could be to be afraid, to be emotional and to let other people see that side of you. His sessions with you at the prison had often left him drained, which was a good thing - sleep had been even harder to come by in that place.
You dug into your stack of pancakes with all the fervour of a starving woman. And you were. Starving. You got the call from Baz while still deep asleep and just rolled out of bed to make your way over to Smurf’s place. You were already proud of yourself for managing to put on some matching clothes, brush your hair and not forget your shoes before leaving the house.
Andrew watched you with faint adoration twinkling in his hazel eyes. You glared at him, wrapped your arm around your plate and turned away from him. He hadn’t made any move to touch your food - he hadn’t moved at all since sitting down - but from your reaction, he knew better than to try. Ever.
He didn’t fancy getting bitten.
Or, well… maybe.
You didn’t ask how Andrew knew about your favourite breakfast you only got on special occasions or when you desperately needed a pick-me-up.
Of course he knew.
It was hard to imagine that there’d been a time before Andrew, that there were things he didn’t know about you.
He’d gotten so deeply entwined in your life, even before he was released, and it had only gotten worse in the days after.
Not that you minded.
Especially now that you’d made the decision that you didn’t care what other people thought, that you wanted Andrew, whatever the consequences of that would be.
“You know,” You said, chasing a drop of maple syrup running down your lip with your tongue and pointing at him with your fork. Andrew’s eyes followed your tongue. His cheeks tinged pink, a colour that only darkened when he abruptly tore his eyes away. You smirked. “My Sunday is holy to me. I have a whole system.”
“A system?”
“Uh-huh, and I’ve already bent it for you, mister.”
“Should I feel honoured?”
“You should.” You nodded. “Especially after I touched your nasty gloves. You know, I’m almost relieved to know you have at least one thing in your life that isn’t squeaky, shiny clean.”
“I’m pretty sure nobody says ‘squeaky, shiny clean.’”
“They should!” You muttered around a mouthful of pancake. “I’m just sayin’.” You swallowed with barely any chewing, like a pelican devouring a fish. Andrew looked slightly disgusted, but also as if he was oddly fascinated. “If you want to spend the rest of the day with me, you have to follow my rules.”
Andrew leant back in the booth, draping his arm over the back casually and grinning at you. “Lay it on me, boss.”
“When we get home-”
“Home?”
“Home. My home. It’s straight to bed. I’ve already missed-” You glanced at your watch. “-two hours and forty-two minutes of bed rotting time.”
“Oh no.” Andrew said in the most detached, unimpressed tone ever.
“Exactly, mister. We’ll need to rot extra hard to make up for the lost time.”
“Consider me at your service.”
“Good.”
“Do the pancakes make up for some of the lost bed rotting time?”
The term sounded odd coming from Andrew’s lips.
“Mh-hm. A little. Teeny bit.” You finished the last bite of sugary goodness and grabbed your cup of water before mirroring Andrew and leaning back against the cracked synthetic leather. “So, bed rotting. How familiar are you?”
The corner of Andrew’s mouth rose even higher.
“A total newbie.”
You clicked your tongue in disapproval. “I see, I have my hands full with you.”
“You always do.”
“Charmer, but this is serious, Andrew. Get your head in the game, or you’re out.”
“You wouldn’t do me like that.”
“Oh, I would, handsome. I take my Sundays very seriously.”
“Okay, okay, okay. I defer to you, ruler of the holy Sunday.”
“That has a certain ring to it- Stop distracting me, Andrew!” You huffed and crossed your arms. Andrew gave you his best puppy dog eyes, which paired with the grin still plastered across his stupid handsome face and that faint auburn five o’clock shadow, ruined a perfectly good pair of panties within seconds.
“Bed rotting, only comfy clothes or no clothes allowed. Shitty movies or scrolling on the phone. Nothing that required even an ounce of brain power. Snacks-”
“In bed?” Andrew raised a brow.
“The unhealthier and crumblier, the better.”
He wrinkled his nose.
“The only getting up allowed is for snack refills, the toilet, or to get the takeout order from the door.”
“Takeout?”
“Oh, yes. Takeout. At least two different kinds and enough for at least the entire next week. I want to be drowning in spring rolls and pizza buns.”
Andrew chuckled.
“And there may or may not be some devil’s lettuce involved.”
“You smoke?” His lips curled again, one corner of his mouth climbing so high it revealed one pearly white fang. You swiped some syrup up off your plate with your finger and sucked it clean. He placed a few dollar bills on the table, including a generous tip for the waitress.
“I dabble. Perhaps. Sometimes.”
“I never would have thought.” Andrew held the door open for you, and then again the car door.
The drive to your apartment was quiet, Andrew for once forgoing his obscure playlist of miscellaneous rock songs from different genres and eras. You never knew what to expect next.
As soon as the door shut behind you two, you dragged Andrew closer by the collar of his shirt and pressed your lips to his. He stiffened beneath your touch, a tiny gasp falling into your kiss to be crushed by your lips.
“Does this fall under bed rotting regulations?” He mumbled as you walked backwards to your bedroom, taking him with you.
“All bed-based activities are permissible.”
You tugged at the button of his jeans. The back of your knees hit the edge of your bed. You let yourself slump down on the mattress and pulled on his jeans to take them down with you. You pushed his shirt up and into his hands to get access to his tanned, freckled skin. He took your hint and pulled the shirt over his head to drop it on the floor.
Your fingers hooked under the waistband of his boxers. You looked up, finding Andrew’s eyes already trained on you, a furious blush blooming on his cheeks.
“‘this okay?”
“Y-yeah.”
“Yeah?” You rolled the waistband down, revealing more of the firm muscles stretching across his hips. “And this?” You pressed your lips to his hip. A shudder tore his entire body. He pressed his lips into a tight, thin line and gave you a tiny nod.
You cupped his already hardening dick through his boxers.
“I want to make you feel good, Andy.” You purred and mouthed at the bunched-up waistband. You tipped your head to the side, watching him. “Do you want that? Do you want me to make you feel good?”
“Y-yes-”
That was all you needed to hear. You pushed his boxers down further and slipped off the bed, coming to kneel between his feet. Andrew’s hands were clenched into fists at his sides. You ran your palms up his thighs and towards his arms, dragging them down until they reached his hands.
“Relax for me, love.” You opened up his fists and guided his hands to your hair. He kept them there, awkwardly resting against your skull while you ducked your head to lap at his twitching cock. Andrew inhaled sharply above you.
“Relax.” You cooed and rubbed his thighs while peppering soft, coaxing kisses all over his twitching, velvety skin. “You’re so tense.”
“‘m always tense.” He mumbled, embarrassment and shyness colouring his raspy voice.
“Mhm… we’ll just have to fix that.”
Still stroking his thighs and hips, you straightened up to spread a trail of kisses up his firm, if a little protruding, stomach and back down towards his hips.
Andrew grabbed your head all of a sudden and gently pushed you off. You were confused for a moment, not used to guys turning down freely offered blowjobs - but then again Andrew wasn’t like most guys.
“Hey,” You cooed and got up to cup his cheeks in your hands. “What’s the matter? You don’t want it?”
“I-” He clenched and unclenched his fists at his side. Hesitantly, he put them on your waist, barely touching you, as though he was still unsure whether he was actually allowed to hold you. Like someone could have changed the rules without telling him.
“It’s okay if you don’t.” You brushed some of his hair back and nuzzled his jaw with your nose, pulling him closer, wordlessly reassuring him that physical contact was more than welcome.
“Don’t like- standing over you like that… seeing you on the ground…”
“Naw, you’re so awfully sweet, Andy.”
You didn’t miss the way he shuddered at the nickname. You turned him around, pushing him down on the bed to straddle his lap.
“This better?”
“Yeah.”
“I can still suck your cock.” You purred, walking your fingers along his pec. You felt him twitch, his cock pressed to your already damp panties. “I can get all comfy between your legs while you sit over there, with your back to the headboard. It’s nice and padded.” You murmured between fleeting kisses pressed to his jaw and cheeks. His hands tensed at your hips.
“Go on, love, get comfy for me.” You slipped off Andrew’s lap and watched him scoot back before settling between his legs. He still looked awkward and tense and uncomfortable, but that was pretty much his baseline…
“This better?” You ran your hands over his chest and stomach, past his hips and over his thighs. He gave a tight nod in response. You took it as permission to proceed, bending your head down to pepper kisses over his hips, ignoring his hard cock for now.
You stroked his thighs and hips, rubbing your own thigh together as you lay on your side, nestled between Andrew’s legs.
Tentatively, almost shy, Andrew weaved his fingers into your hair eventually.
“That feels nice.” You cooed and leaned into his touch, encouraging him to keep it up. He dragged his blunt nails softly over your scalp, coaxing a quiet moan from you that felt like liquid fire in his veins.
You didn’t touch Andrew’s cock again until he was shifting his hips restlessly, bucking up against the air while you covered his thighs in kisses, gentle bites and hickeys.
He rasped your name, a sound so delicious, so decadent and rich, you had to close your eyes and bite your bottom lip against the wave of desire it poured straight into your core.
“You want more, love?”
Andrew nodded.
“Use your words for me, big boy. What do you want?”
His mouth fell open around a silent moan, and he dropped his head back against the headboard, squeezing his eyes shut. His fingertips curled against your scalp.
“What do you need, Andy?”
His mumbled words were almost too quiet to make out, even in the relative silence of your bedroom (the seagulls were once again giving one of their concerts).
“-to suck my dick-”
Your grin widened. “Good boy.” You purred. Andrew groaned. You wrapped your fingers tightly around his base and dragged your flat tongue against his swollen, leaking head, lapping up the pre-cum already beading at his slit and moaning at the taste of him spreading over your tongue.
His hands fell away from your hair, instead twisting into the sheets. You watched with both idle fascination at the pleasure tugging at his features, and wicked delight to see him come undone at your touch so easily.
You kept things slow and light, spreading sweet kisses and tiny kitten licks across his entire length after one, rather half-hearted, suck against his balls had him cursing and tensing up.
You didn’t want to break poor Andrew the first time you had his dick in your mouth.
You took his tip into your mouth and swirled your tongue over him.
“Andrew.” You purred and pressed a kiss to his leaking slit. “Look at me. I want you to look at me when I make myself choke on you.”
He shook his head. “‘m gonna come.”
You dropped a hand between your thighs, pushing aside your skirt and panties to relieve some of the desperate need gnawing at you.
“That is kind of the end goal here, sweetheart.”
He shook his head again. “Want to fuck you- want to make you feel good.”
“Yeah? You’re so sweet, Andrew.”
“‘m not sweet.”
You crawled up Andrew’s body, tugging your panties down at the same time, and pressed a kiss to his jaw.
“To me you are.”
He grabbed your waist with much less reservations this time. You straddled his lap and shamelessly pressed your sopping cunt against his hard cock.
His breathing was heavy and laboured, pupils blown so wide only a thin sliver of hazel remained visible. His auburn hair shone like molten metal in the narrow strips of light that fell through the gap in your curtains.
Andrew buried his face against your neck. His arms came up to wrap around your waist, to pull you closer, feel you rocking against his aching cock. “Tell me- tell me how to- make you feel good. Please.” He rasped out your name between groans, pleading, begging for you to tell him what to do, for you to give him clear instructions, to save him from this state of never quite knowing what the whole world seemed to intuitively get without ever needing explanations, to give him a task he could not fail at and the praise he’d never received.
He jumped to your every request eagerly, and quickly you found yourself on your side, with one of Andrew’s arms around your waist, the other curled around your throat, trapping the back of your head against his chest as he nuzzled the crown of your head and fucked into you from behind.
Like a beast finally unleashed, he pounded into you, each thrust accompanied by lewd squelching noises and the tell-tale slap slap slap of flesh hitting flesh. He pressed his mouth to your head, breath heavy and loud, and peppered kisses against your temple and the shell of your ear. You dug your fingers into his arms or tore at the sheets beneath you, delirious from the pleasure he slammed into you.
“Your thick cock fills me up so well, Andrew-” You moaned, toes already curling and feet kicking helplessly against the sheets. Andrew hooked his leg over yours and put more of his weight onto you, pushing you harder into the mattress while you all but screamed his name.
You came hard, your walls tightening around Andrew and dragging a broken groan from his lips. His hips moved ceaselessly, keeping up their brutal pace throughout your climax, forcing his cock deeper into your constricting hole and dragging every last drop of pleasure from you, until you were sobbing his name and drooling all over his arm.
He didn’t stop.
He rolled onto his back and pulled you into his lap again, hugging you to his chest while fucking into you from below, moaning and sobbing into your neck while you ran your fingers through his hair and whispered sweet praise, repeating again and again how good he made you feel, that he didn’t hurt you, that you liked it when he got rough.
At one point, when he was draped over your trembling body, your knees aching against the mattress, head squished into the pillows, ass in the air, you called your safeword - the word you’d told him meant he had to stop no matter what, the word that existed for his comfort more than your safety, so he’d know even when he got rough because you asked for it, you would tell him when it stopped being good.
You didn’t say it because you wanted to stop - you were good right where you were, getting fucked into oblivion by your smoking hot boyfriend - but you sensed Andrew needed the break.
His breathing came rapidly, erratically, not in the same, out-of-breath-from-physical-exertion-way.
And you wanted him to know you’d actually use the word, actually tell him to stop - and you needed him to know, to realise that he would.
That no matter how deep he was in the throes of need and want and pleasure, he would stop.
You curled up at his side and talked him through breathing exercises, your hand running up and down his sweaty chest - until he relaxed, until he turned to putty beneath your fingertips again. You pressed sweet kisses to his cheek and whispered quiet praise while your hand wandered down his abdomen, towards his still hard cock.
He’d been too in his head, too wrapped up in spiralling thoughts and the feeling he had to perform for you one certain way to even come. Poor thing was exhausted and still pent up, pounding into you with no sense or reason, and while you didn’t object to that - you couldn’t enjoy yourself if Andrew wasn’t enjoying himself as well.
You pumped his cock, his skin slick from your arousal, keeping your hold on his nice and firm, running your thumb over his tip every once in a while.
“Come for me, love.” You purred and dragged your teeth along his jaw. Andrew tensed. A guttural, deep groan rumbled in his throat before he came, splattering ropes upon ropes of cum all over his lower abdomen and your hand.
“Good job, sweetheart. Did that feel good? You came so hard for me, darling, thank you.”
Andrew turned his head to the side, eyes glossed over with unshed tears. Your smile softened further. You leaned in to kiss him, deep and slow, and utterly unhurried. You lay there for a while, ignoring the mess Andrew made of himself and you made of the bed, kissing and grabbing at the other person’s body, hands stroking across sweaty skin and squeezing supple flesh, drowning in each other and the moment until long after Andrew’s cum had dried.
Next Chapter
Taglist (Please feel free to let me know if you want to be added or removed): @princessgiyuu @chanelwidag @gabbyella @stardustworlds @mostdefinitelyhasissues @landpiranha-blog @vicky066 @pupppyyy55 @sofia-the-scholar @insidethegardenwall @mxkhxx @3-smi @bombtasticbritt91 @punkshyteee @honimoon @mortiswicki @morgan-aaa @tubby23 @snowwythegloww @annwoods91 @dendulinka6 @swiss-mrs @a-true-janian-reply @shellshore1 @buttercuppy8 @naxxsstuff @peachjellyy @g0dsfav0riteprincess @ceceseason @aoi-warrior @its-a-me-mario-21 @realwhoreforfictionalmen @flowerlover006 @jennataurus @imaginexred @callmefatherr @topaz125














