(She/her) 25yo || Trans rights are human rights 🏳️⚧️|| Masterpost || Ao3 ||
Lover of pathetic fictional men || Snape and Adar obsessed ||
Collector of hobbies
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality
Anya is LIVE right now
FREE
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
For three years, you were the only thing keeping Pope from losing his mind in Folsom. A bright-eyed, too-good-for-this-world social worker who still believed even a broken system could sometimes manage to do some good.
For three years, you tried not to want Andrew, your client, a man with emotional scars that cut too deep for you to ever heal and a violent temper that, for some reason, never turned on you.
Now that no guards and no bars remain between you, Pope cannot understand why you insist you can never see him again.
Ch. 1 | Ch. 2 | Ch. 3 | Chapter 4 | Ch. 5
Words: 10,2 k
Content: Older Man/Younger Woman, Prison!Social!Worker!Reader, Protective Pope, Forbidden Love, Mututal Pining, Eventual Smut, Breaking and Entering - or 'Pope trying to flirt', Inappropriate Behaviour - Pope is desperate for you and won't take no as an answer, reader's father is a serial killer and a psychopath
No use of y/n!
Read on Ao3 or below the cut:
Your hand reached across the mattress, finding it empty and cold. You peeled your eyes open groggily.
Clad in the shadows that the moon cast across your bedroom through the gap between your curtains was Andrew. He sat on a chair in the corner of the room. The dirty clothes that used to occupy it probably sat folded in a laundry basket by the door now, waiting to be taken downstairs to be washed.
“Andrew?” You murmured, voice heavy with sleep, and rubbed the back of your hand over your eyes. He didn’t reply. He only wore his boxers. His pants still lay discarded on the floor where he left them when you dragged him into your bedroom, and his shirt currently kept you warm.
“Come to bed.” You patted the mattress.
Andrew didn’t move.
You didn’t expect he would.
He was sleeping even less than you. You’d seen him like this in Folsom. He’d go without sleep for so long his sleep-deprived brain amplified all his usual symptoms tenfold until he barely functioned anymore, aggression and paranoia skyrocketing. It always ended with the guards forcing sedatives down his throat and him sleeping for three days straight.
You feared you had become a central part of his OCD thoughts, though you’d probably been to some degree for the past three years, you’d just never been around him enough to realise, and Andrew knew how to hide it from you.
He couldn’t now.
Not when he was not forcibly kept away from you by guards and metal bars.
He often followed you when you were out and about in Oceanside. He’d show up next to your cart in the grocery store out of nowhere or in the parking lot to help you load your bags into the car.
He sat in the corner of your bedroom and watched you sleep…
Most people would have found it creepy.
You should find it creepy to wake up to the ex-con you used to work with and now went out with (you still were not entirely sure what to classify it as. It was more than just sex, but it did not feel like a real, committed relationship, the change to your dynamic too fresh to be something so meaningful.) sitting in your dark bedroom, watching you sleep.
A shameful part of you preened at the attention.
He always wanted to hear about your day. He listened to you rant at the show you were currently watching. Or let you stand in front of your TV to explain the intricate web that was the plot, family relations and romantic relationships of The Vampire Diaries as if you were giving an important presentation to the board of directors of a Fortune 500 company.
You’d leave work just to discover three texts from Andrew asking if you had drunk any water twice, the third text being him apologising because he forgot you can’t take your phone inside again.
It was… nice having someone to talk to who wasn’t Marvin. And let's be real, you never really talked with Marvin to begin with.
Whenever Andrew wasn’t with his family - and lately he tried to get away from them as much as he could without sending his mother into a tantrum - he was following you like a lost puppy.
You worried what this meant for his mental health journey.
Marvin worried about you.
He thought you were repeating the same thing you’d done with your father. Cling to the manicured fantasy a violent, unstable criminal promised, throwing yourself into your desire to fix others because you could not fix yourself and losing yourself in their lies because you simply didn’t know what true connection and unconditional love felt like.
Like a child that was never allowed sugar didn't know how to stop when they finally got their hands on some.
Not that he said any of that out loud, but you knew him well enough to know what he was thinking. And, honestly, the same could be said about your friendship with him!
You also knew Marvin would not hesitate to get his old buddies together to take aluminium bats to Andrew’s teeth and bones.
You sighed and pushed the blanket away, setting your bare feet down on the cold laminate to step in between Andrew’s spread legs.
“Talk to me.” Your whispered words sounded louder in the quiet of your bedroom. Only the stray cats in the alley behind the house and the seagulls camping out on the balcony railings were still awake. You cupped Andrew’s face in your hands, feeling his stubble scrape softly against your skin as you tipped his head back.
He blinked. His gaze grew focused, and he inhaled suddenly, as though just now realising you were talking to him, standing in front of him, touching him.
“I know it feels like it, but you are not alone in this… that doesn’t have to change, just because this-” You gestured between him and you. “-has changed.”
Hazel eyes glinting golden in the moon’s light stared up at you. He traced the shadows dancing across your face with them, and a treacherous part of him could not help but think he was still in Folsom, still trapped in the SHU, forcibly kept awake by light and blasting music, with his only respite being the daydreams of you his mind conjured up to curl around him like a protective blanket.
“Don’t wanna hurt you.” He finally muttered after a while of charged silence. His hands came up to cradle your wrists, holding you with such aching tenderness it made your knees weak.
You watched him take a shuddering breath, resistance melting away under your gentle but unshrinking presence. Andrew closed his eyes and dropped his forehead against your chest.
“I keep thinking about hurting you- keep seeing it happen. Keep thinking when I close my eyes something is going to harm you- something I can’t stop because I’m sleeping. But if I stay awake, if I watch over you-”
“Something could still happen.” You interrupted him. “It is scary, but that’s not within your control no matter what you do, Andrew. These are intrusive thoughts, love, and now is not the time for intrusive thoughts. It’s the time to sleep.”
“I can’t make them stop.”
The misery in his voice cut right through your heart. The urge to suggest treatment - both therapy and medication, proper medication - shoved the words into your mouth immediately, but you swallowed them down. Now was not the time for that either.
“You don’t have to make them stop.” You said against his hair, stroking your thumb over his cheek slowly. “You just have to try not to give in to them. Come. Come to bed, Andrew.”
You let go of his face to take his hand. To your surprise, Andrew gave in when you tried to tug him towards the bed. You lay down, and he curled up next to you, dragging you against his chest as his arms closed around you in a bear hug.
You ran your fingers through his hair and down the back of his neck, scratching your nails along his spine just the way he enjoyed. He shivered, like he always did.
“You will not hurt me, Andrew. You would never hurt me.” You murmured while smoothing down the blanket over both of you. “You can’t control intrusive thoughts, but you can choose how to respond to them. They are like… cornstarch and water. The harder you try to fight that shit, the stronger they stick around. But you don’t need to solve any problems right now. Just breathe with me, love.”
You deepened your breaths, pushing your chest against Andrew’s so he could feel the way it moved every time your lungs inflated and deflated. You kept going, even when he didn’t join you right away.
“Curl your toes as tight as you can.” You spoke even quieter, slipping into a low, soothing murmur he had to strain his ears to even catch. You counted to five in your head before telling him to relax again. “Now bend your ankles up, pointing your feet towards your body, as far as you can without it hurting… and relax…” You moved up along his whole body, instructing Andrew to visualise and deliberately tense and relax muscles in his body. His thighs, then his butt, his back and shoulders, arms, hands, lips, nose, eyes, scalp, until he was putty in your arms, until his breathing slowed, until he was asleep and you watched over him with only the moon and seagulls keeping you company.
You were woken by rapid knocking on your front door.
You couldn’t have been asleep for long. You felt like someone dragged you through a bog, put a gun to your head and demanded you recite some poem you had to learn for kindergarten.
Andrew stirred next to you but didn’t wake up. He’d gone without sleep for too long as that he’d be woken easily after just - you peered at the alarm clock on your nightstand - two hours.
You slipped out of his embrace and padded across your living room, taking out the shotgun from under the dining table before peering through the peephole.
Two men stood in your hallway, one significantly taller than the other, probably significantly taller than most others. Both had long hair and a careless, unkempt air around them that reminded you of every frat boy surfer ever.
You unlocked your door and the deadbolt that had appeared on it the day after Andrew stayed over for the first time.
“What the fuck do you want?” You hissed quietly and rubbed the sleep from your eyes.
“Pope here?” The taller one asked. Was that Deran? Or Craig? You couldn’t keep them apart, though to be fair, you had barely interacted with either since Andrew got released.
You raised a brow.
“Manners really aren’t part of the Cody experience, apparently.” You muttered to yourself and pinched the bridge of your nose.
“Sorry for waking you.” The shorter one muttered, shoving his hands into his pockets and curling his shoulders forward in a gesture that was so Andrew, it threw you off for a moment.
“Is this important?”
“Yeah.” The taller one said with a slight shrug. You narrowed your eyes. He shrunk back ever so slightly.
“Andrew is asleep. He doesn’t sleep. He has been awake for days. He desperately needs to sleep, so I ask again, is. this. important?”
“It’s a family thing.” The shorter one said, looking at least believably apologetic.
You didn’t want to.
You wanted to shut the door in their faces and go back to sleeping in Andrew’s arms, and you sure as shit didn’t want Andrew leaving you to go to his manipulative, abusive mother - but that was not a decision you could make for him.
“Fine.” You stepped aside and let Andrew’s brother in. “I’ll wake him. Don’t touch my shit.”
Setting the shotgun down on the dinner table, you went back into your dark bedroom and sat down on the edge of the bed.
“Andrew…” You put your hand on his shoulder, shaking him softly, unaware of the two pairs of eyes watching you curiously. “Andrew, sweetheart, wake up.”
He flinched, eyes ripping open just for his mind to toss him into raw, animalistic survival instincts. You caught his wrist, stopping his flailing arm before it could hurt you. Had Andrew been any more present in the moment, he’d have been surprised by your sudden show of strength.
“Shh, it’s okay. It’s okay, love. You’re in my bedroom, in my apartment. You’re not in Folsom, Andrew. You’re safe.” You gingerly reached out to put your hand on his cheek. You remembered well just how violent he could get when someone woke him after him staying awake for far too long.
He murmured your name, quietly, almost disbelieving, and blinked away the sleep still clinging to him.
He somehow looked more tired than he had when you dragged him to bed.
“Deran and Craig are here.” You whispered and ran your fingers through his hair. It was already starting to grow out. “They said it’s important family stuff.”
Andrew was awake and alert immediately. He stalked out of your room, leaving you alone with the sweet call of your pillows. You curled back up, inhaling the scent of him still clinging to your sheets and gave in to the heavy weight dragging your eyelids down-
“Hey…”
You startled awake.
“I’m awake. I’m awake.”
Andrew chuckled. “Sure, sweetheart.” He wiped some hair from your face. “I need my shirt back.”
You grumbled something unintelligible into the pillow.
“You were the one insisting your elderly neighbours wouldn’t survive seeing me without my shirt.”
You didn’t reply. Andrew pursed his lips.
“I don’t get how you can sleep in that thing anyway. I wore it all day. It’s filthy and now your bed-”
“Oh my god, fine!” You sat up and, without opening your eyes, struggled out of the oversized shirt. “God forbid I like how you smell.” You let yourself drop back onto the bed. Andrew, pretending the blush creeping up his neck didn’t exist, put on his shirt and bent down to press a kiss to your temple, muttering a quiet sorry before pulling the blanket up to your chin.
“I’ll lock up behind me.”
You were already back asleep.
Andrew stayed in the doorway a moment longer, watching you. Your hair was a mess, spread out over the pillow and still knotted from the way he ran his hands through it earlier in the evening when he was fucking you, though using that word in any context with you never ceased to leave a foul taste in his mouth.
You deserved better. You deserved a boyfriend who didn’t shove your face into the pillow, grunted into your hair like a beast and fucked you.
He turned to leave when Deran called his name under his breath.
“Yeah.” Andrew grumbled. “I’m coming.”
His eyes tracked along the shotgun on your table. He was pretty sure that hadn’t been there before.
“Taking your shirt back from her? That’s cold-blooded, man.” Craig smirked outside in the hall.
“What?”
“Chicks dig that kind of thing.” Craig shrugged. “Stealing their boyfriend’s clothes.” He clarified when Andrew’s expression didn’t shift away from confusion.
He wanted to protest, say you weren’t his girlfriend. It felt preposterous to lay such a claim over you.
“What would you know about girlfriends?” He muttered instead, already stalking down the hallway towards the stairwell, but Craig merely chuckled.
“Ask Nicky if you don’t believe me, bro.”
“I told you! I’m too stupid for this shit!”
You didn’t flinch at the raised voice, despite the way it made your ears ring. You remained unfazed, merely tapping your fingernail against the worksheet the agitated teenager tried to rip out from under you.
“You are not stupid. Don’t make me force you to write out affirmations on the board again, Tyler. You know I will.”
Tyler grumbled and slumped back into the cheap plastic chair. The aircon of the building where The Hub, as the kids had taken to calling the slightly run-down youth centre, was situated was broken once again, and consequently hormonal tempers were even thinner than usual. Not to mention the smell.
“I can’t do this shit, man!”
“You can’t do this shit, yet.” You corrected. “That’s why we are here, working on this. There was a time you couldn’t walk! You were born all squishy and useless and learnt to fucking walk. You learnt to speak and read and write. That is massive. You are capable of learning this too. Let’s take a deep breath and try again.”
You watched Tyler roll his shoulders and take a deep breath before hunching over the paper again, brows furrowed as he muttered to himself, dissecting the math problem like you’d been teaching him how.
“...35. X is 35?”
You raised a brow. “You askin’ or tellin’?”
“...telling.”
“Then you’d be right. It’s 35! Well done! See? I told you you can do it.” You pulled the paper away from him and with a red pen quickly checked off all the equations he’d been working on. You slid the graded paper back towards him, alongside a cheesy meme sticker praising his work. “You can be very proud of yourself, Tyler. It wasn’t easy, but you stuck with it, and it really paid off. I’m sure proud of you.”
Tyler blushed ever so slightly, but of course a proud, tough seventeen-year-old could not show or admit that he was flustered. He shot you an arrogant, crooked grin and tried to pretend like this was nothing, but you’d long spotted the sparkle in his eyes only kids who were made to feel like they were useless idiots who’d never amount to anything their whole lives ever got when hearing the word I'm proud of you.
“What do I get?”
“The satisfaction of a job well done.” You tucked your red pen away in your pocket and smirked at Tyler, who just rolled his eyes. How often had these kids heard that one from you by now? They were all sick of it, you could tell. “You aren’t doing this for me. You are doing it for yourself, and your future. There won’t always be rewards for getting the things done that have to get done.”
“Yeah, but like… when you have a job you get paid, right? That’s a reward.” Brian called over from where he lounged in a threadbare armchair, forcing himself through the novel his English teacher assigned - though he spent significantly more time distracting himself than he spent on actually reading the damn chapter. He could have read the chapter three times had he just focused on reading it.
The lengths they all went to to avoid doing their work…
“I suppose it kind of is, but don’t forget that it is also your right. You have a contract after all to be paid a certain amount of money for completing the agreed-upon work.”
Tyler wasn’t really paying attention.
You crossed your arms and leant back. “What do you want?” Sometimes - most of the time - they just asked for a bag of Takis or a can of Monster anyway. It was not worth the headache of getting roped into mock philosophical discussions with them.
The grin stretching across Tyler’s lips told you this was not about chips or energy drinks.
“I heard you’re Pope Cody’s girl.”
You raised your brow.
“Is it true, Ms G?” Ms G - because you, apparently, were the goat, whatever that meant. Tyler leant across the table. “Are you fucking Pope?!”
You thrust your arm out towards the far corner of the room. “Accountability corner, right now.” Tyler hung his head and marched over to the old toddler activity table sitting at the back of the room while the other teens cackled.
Tyler grumbled to himself as he slumped down on one of the pillows and plucked a blank card from a stack. On the wall behind him, a large poster visualised the steps of a proper apology. The toddler play table was a - perhaps slightly unethical - means to motivate offenders to take the assignment seriously because you didn’t let anyone leave it until they’d composed a comprehensive, reflected apology and read it out loud to you.
No seventeen-year-old boy wanted to sit at the toddler play table longer than they absolutely had to.
Listen, you worked with what you had. The toddler play table had been here longer than you, it would be a shame to not put it to good use!
“Pope Cody’s girl.” You muttered to yourself. “I’m nobody’s girl. I’m a grown ass woman!”
“But is it true, Ms G?” Brian felt like testing his luck today, it seemed. “Because I go to school with his nephew and I heard him telling his girlfriend he saw you at the Cody house!”
“And who's his nephew?”
Due to your time volunteering in the youth centre to keep at-risk youth off the streets and help them build a solid foundation for their future life, you knew a lot of teenagers around Oceanside. And most teenagers knew you or of you, even if they didn't come to the Hub.
“J. Josh. The brainy kid Nicky hangs out with.”
You looked up, frowning.
“J? J is a Cody?”
Puzzle pieces fell into place in your head. J's mom was called Julia, you knew that. You'd helped her a few times when she got clean, but you could never help make it stick. You made sure Josh was okay when you could. Getting them groceries, taking him out for some tacos or hot dogs when you were taking some of the Hub kids. You got him new shoes once and school supplies.
You never realised his Julia was Andrew's Julia.
“Moved in with them when his mom O.D.'d.”
Your heart sank.
You should have done more. You should have- Josh was living with Smurf now, under her control and manipulation because you fucking failed-
You squeezed your eyes shut and fought against the wave of nausea and guilt rushing to drown you.
The shrill sound of the doorbell rang through the room. Your body was up and moving on autopilot. The doors were always locked from the outside, just a safety precaution and also to ensure confidentiality during meetings or private conversations by preventing people from just strolling in.
It was protocol.
You expected a kid, someone who had decided last minute to join the study session after all, but standing outside the glass doors was no other than Andrew.
He looked exhausted in that way no sleep in the world could fix. An emotional exhaustion you had no doubt was exasperated by the night he’d spent with his family.
“Hey.” You murmured softly as you pushed the doors open. Some of the kids whistled. The sound withered when you swirled around to glare at them. You stepped outside and let the door fall shut.
Andrew stared at you.
”You’re sweaty.”
“Yeah, the AC is useless. What’s up?” You weren’t entirely happy Andrew showed up at the youth centre, and he could tell. He shoved his hands into his pockets and shrugged, looking sheepish but not sorry.
“You can talk to me. That hasn’t changed.”
“But you won’t let me fuck you when I tell you.”
“Same goes for lying to me.”
The corner of his mouth twitched.
“Didn’t know you had a shotgun. That’s kinda hot.”
“Not the only gun I have.”
His eyes flicked up to meet yours, his expression somewhere between surprise and wonder. This time it was you who shrugged.
Comfortable silence spread between you. You liked that you didn’t have to perform with Andrew. You could just stand there, leaning against the door of the youth centre, next to faded tags and sun-bleached flyers, surrounded by the shadow your father had cast over you that would never wash off and carrying all the fates of the kids inside on your shoulders so they got to just be… normal for a moment. Not social rejects, not young offenders, not the kids of drug addicts and deadbeats that had to grow up far too quickly.
Like you.
“Is your family okay?”
Something in his expression tightened. You hadn’t expected an answer, not when it came to his family. You never did.
“How’s J?”
His gaze flicked towards you just to slip away again. He shifted uncomfortably.
“You know J?”
“A little. I- I didn’t know he was your nephew.”
“‘tis fine.”
“I knew Julia too.”
Andrew froze. You reached out, tentatively, almost hesitating as you placed your hand on his arm.
“I’m sorry I didn’t realise she was your Julia.”
“Did you- did you look after her like you- did with me?”
“I tried.”
Andrew nodded as if that was enough, as if it was the only thing that mattered.
“I have my tools in the truck… could take a look at that AC if you want.”
You chewed on your bottom lip. A part of you was apprehensive about allowing Andrew into this part of your life, of letting your life melt into your work here. Another part knew the way you’d been cutting yourself off from everyone for years was not healthy, something you could not sustain any longer, especially seeing as how fast you’d let yourself grow comfortable with Andrew being a part of your life.
It would take weeks to get the approval to call out a technician, and they never seemed to be able to do much anyway.
“Yeah. That’d be great. Thanks.”
Andrew emitted a quiet grunt, the only confirmation he’d heard you you’d get. You watched him retrieve his toolbox from the truck bed and turned around to unlock the door. The kids inside quickly pretended to be busy with their work to conceal the fact they’d been watching you.
It must be quite the piece of juicy gossip to see you, their firm but usually so gentle and kind social worker, with the infamously unstable, violent Pope Cody.
None of them knew about the things you’d done when you were their age. You understood intimately how circumstances could shape a moral person into something they never thought they’d be capable of being. It helped in this line of work.
At least something good had come from it, you told yourself, and kept telling yourself anytime the memories were too strong to let go.
“It’s back there. Not that I understand any of that shit.”
“I’ll figure it out.” Andrew shot you a crooked grin and, before you had the chance to stop him, ducked down to kiss you. It was just a quick peck, decidedly innocent, especially considering the way you’d urged him to fuck you into the mattress last night, but perhaps that just threw you off all the more.
You felt the stares of half a dozen teenagers who shared the same understanding and respect for boundaries as Andrew boring into you. Andrew shot you a last grin - the same grin you thought a little boy who’d just stolen a cookie and gotten away with it would spot - and disappeared into the back.
“Brian, I want a summary of the chapter you’ve been reading. Tyler, how is that apology coming along? Jenny, I thought I told you to put that fucking vape away!” You held your hand out. Jenny groaned but got up, depositing the vape in your hand.
“Do I get that back later?”
“You can have it back when you turn eighteen - don’t look at me like that. If you’re going to break the law, at least don’t be stupid about it.”
You returned to your seat where you’d been filling out some paperwork before Tyler came over to ask for help with his schoolwork. You put his worksheets in a neat pile before returning to your own work.
In the distance, you heard the clank of Andrew’s tools.
Eventually, Tyler returned with his drafted apology. You leaned back in your seat, legs crossed and looked up at the teenager clutching his flash card in his hands, stuttering through the words he’d written. He’d improved his reading skills so much since you started working with him…
“Thank you for apologising.” You said and tugged the card into your bag. “Shall we continue?” You nodded towards the pile of worksheets. Tyler nodded sheepishly and slid into the chair.
Most of these kids never trusted the peace after an apology. It took time to realise once a conflict was settled, it was settled. You thanked them, forgave them, and whatever they had done was in the past once they’d made amends. The apology and thinking about what he’d said was enough amends in this case, but sometimes you had kids do something nice to the Hub. Create a banner to hang on the wall, tend the community garden in the back, clean the windows or sidewalk out front. Community service to make up for harming the community.
But once the agreed-upon amends were done? No hard feelings remained. Their mistake did not become ammunition for future conflicts.
It was just… settled.
It took Andrew three hours and one quick trip to the hardware store for some spare parts to get the AC running again. Cold air rushed through the vents, and you sighed, collapsing in your chair. The heat had grown so oppressive you thought about closing up early multiple times, but you knew most of these kids had no other place to go. They wouldn’t be going home, and it probably wasn’t very safe for some of them either. Poverty and substance abuse disorder were rampant issues in Oceanside.
Andrew returned with his toolbox in hand, some grime smeared across his tanned skin that was covered in a thin sheen of sweat.
The teens cheered and clapped, obviously grateful for being saved from the heat that was somehow worse in here than outside. Andrew stopped mid-stride, eyes wide, obviously unsure how to categorise this display of juvenile gratitude.
You got up to close the distance between you and him, taking his hand before tugging him towards the doors for some privacy.
“Thanks. You saved us.”
Andrew blushed. “‘tis nothing.”
“I’m still grateful.” You stopped at the doors. You didn’t want to throw him out, especially after he helped you, but you weren’t sure it would go over well with the management of the youth centre if you let a recently-released felon stay.
On the other hand, you’d practically single-handedly revived this whole place so he could suck it.
“Can I come over tonight?”
You shook your head. “I’m not home tonight.”
Andrew looked hurt. Your heart clenched in your chest. You had no reason to feel this way. You couldn’t be available every moment of every day for Andrew to follow you around like a lost puppy, and saying you had plans shouldn’t feel like rejection to Andrew - so why did you scramble to explain?
“I… kind of started this thing with the youth centre. The kids that can show they’ve stayed in school during the semester and tried to keep their grades up get to organise a block party for their friends and families. They do fundraisers to raise the money and work really hard. It’s tonight. We all volunteer to chaperone.”
“I could come.” He looked at you through his lashes, sad puppy dog eyes cutting right through any resistance you could have put up. “Block parties are for the neighbourhood. I- I- I am part of the neighbourhood.”
“Let him come, Ms G!” One of the kids shouted from behind you.
“Yeah, don’t be so cold!”
“He fixed the AC.”
“The party is tied to your effort at school, guys. This is study group, yet I don’t hear any pens.” You shouted over your shoulder. The hackling stopped immediately, replaced by the consistent scratch of pencils on paper.
“They are worse than you.” You muttered, earning a slight grin from Andrew.
“So, can I come?”
“Sure.” You sigh. “It’s for the whole community. But there is no alcohol. And tell your brother - Craig or Deran, whichever of them it is - if he brings drugs to this thing, I will castrate him.”
Andrew chuckled.
You raised a brow. “You think I’m joking?”
Andrew squinted at you. “You are… are you?”
“You’ll never know.” You got up on your tiptoes and pressed a fleeting kiss to his cheek before pushing the door open to gently shove him outside. “Maybe I’ve done it before.” With those words, you turned on your heels and marched back into the youth centre to collect the kids’ homework they were desperately scrambling to get done after slacking off for hours.
Andrew stayed outside the doors for a moment, staring at you, the swing of your hips, your hair, the warm smile you gave the kids that was so unlike the wicked glint that had gleamed in your eyes moments before.
He couldn’t get enough of you.
You were chewing on your bottom lip, standing on the sidewalk separating the beach from the parking lot.
Andrew had texted you just a moment ago that he was on his way, so why did you suddenly doubt he’d show?
You shoved the thought away roughly. Not two minutes later, you spotted his truck. You were standing by the driver's side door before he had even put it into park.
“Do you still have your tools?”
Andrew hesitated, taken aback by your sudden approach.
“Yeah.”
“The guy who volunteered to help set up the stage fell through, and I swear dealing with fifteen teens all in a tizzy is more exhausting than managing a goddamn prison riot!”
Usually if stuff like that happened it was you who jumped in and frantically figured out something. You had already made your way across the beach to the unassembled parts, mind racing to figure out how to put that shit together and spare your kids this disappointment when you stopped dead in your tracks - and remembered Andrew.
Perhaps… perhaps you didn’t have to figure it out? Perhaps you didn’t have to scramble for a solution?
Perhaps you could simply… lean on another person?
The thought felt foreign and that simple fact hurt.
Andrew smirked.
“So will you?”
“If you’ll let me get out of the car.”
You blinked. “Oh.” You stepped aside, giving Andrew the space to open his door and get out, just to find yourself with your back to the truck, his hands resting comfortably on your waist.
“Hey.” You whispered, ignoring the heat rushing to your cheeks at the sudden proximity. It made a strange warmth blossom in your stomach how needy Andrew was, how much he needed to be close to you, touch you, feel you.
You were used to being needed, to people clinging to you in their darkest moments, but with Andrew it was different. Personal. His need was not for your skills in navigating the world, the trials it set up and the help available to overcome them.
He was also beginning to know parts of you you had never bared to another soul before.
“Hey.” He rasped back, the corner of his mouth twitching. Before your ever-racing mind could talk you out of it again, you tipped your head back and kissed him. Andrew responded immediately, greedy hunger leading his every touch as he pressed you harder against the car, tongue lapping into your mouth, groaning softly against your lips.
Andrew’s fingertips dug into your flesh through the thin fabric of your dress you’d changed into. It was as though he feared someone would come and snatch you away, and if only he held you as tightly as he could, he could prevent that from happening.
You crossed your arms behind his neck and melted into his demanding presence, letting the frantic tingles his touch chased through your body cloak your mind into a girlish, giddy daze and overshadow racing thoughts. For the moment at least.
Eventually, later than you should but much sooner than you wanted, you pushed against his chest and briefly tucked your head into the crook of your neck to catch your breath before gently directing him towards the group of restless teens acting as if the end of the world had befallen them all.
Your eyes kept flicking towards him while you helped set up the rest. You helped carry ice to the makeshift bar for mocktail creations a group of girls had come up with to sell. Some kids had been baking and cooking all day in the Hub’s little kitchen and were already setting up their goodies on folding tables along the Strand. You helped with the canopy tents some local businesses loaned the Hub for the day and coordinated with artists and local makers who wanted to use the opportunity to sell some of their goods to the neighbourhood. This was new this year, a business proposition you gladly presented to your kids on behalf of the community. They came up with a few rules and a stand fee that they immediately reinvested into the block party.
Things really had grown- escalated, one might say - from the first celebration of this kind you organised two years ago. Back then it had just been you, a few other volunteers, the kids and a bonfire on the beach. You brought supplies for s'mores and twist bread, alongside some bottles of chilled soda. One of the kids had brought his guitar, another brought speakers.
It was just a nice little gathering to celebrate the effort the kids had put into their future, to acknowledge that, yes, they struggled in ways no child should have to and had to invest more energy into things like school, but despite all this, they still did it. Their accomplishments deserved recognition.
The next semester, some kids asked if their friends or siblings could join, and the idea of a block party was born.
You saw the effect it had on these kids. The instant rise in street cred, as one kid had called it, to be associated with the neighbourhood event was enough of a confidence booster for some kids to help them settle back into regular school attendance after almost flunking out.
You’d be a terrible liar to pretend seeing their development was not filling you with immense pride.
You’d hate to give any of this up…
The thought reminded you inadvertently of your father, out there somewhere in the country, probably already looking for a way to find you. You didn’t want any of these kids to get hurt because of you…
“Crisis averted.” Andrew rasped behind you, causing you to jump and swirl around with a furious frown etched onto your face. Andrew merely grinned his sheepish, adorably insincere apologetic grin.
He nodded weakly towards the stage on the beach.
The Hub had received some donated instruments a while back, and instantly bands had been founded and a room in the run-down building chosen as a practice room. The kids, while organising today, had decided today was the perfect day for some first gigs.
It would have broken your heart to see their plans foiled.
The stage wasn’t glorious or grand, but it was a stage, a real stage, and that meant everything to the kids who were otherwise never asked to show off their skill.
“Thank you, Andrew.” It was the most heartfelt expression of gratitude you might have ever uttered in your life. Andrew blushed at your earnestness and ducked his head, muttering a quiet ‘tis no big deal.
You made your last rounds with your clipboard tucked against your hip, ensuring everyone had what they needed. Tonight had been financed through fundraisers the kids organised, car-washes, weekly yard serviced for which they’d even gotten a local business to donate some custom printed polo shirts for, beginner surf courses for kids of tourists, even a few lemonade stands.
All proceeds the kids made tonight would flow back into improvements or new purchases for the Hub or go into a savings account for the next block party.
The kids’ proud faces and joy more than made up for the headache of filling out all the paperwork to get the necessary permits, though with this being the third big block party you helped organise, you were getting quite skilled in applying for them.
Andrew trailed after you like a lost puppy, ready to jump in whenever you noticed something that needed some work - a few screws that needed tightening, missing or loose tent anchors, unstable signs.
With the setting sun, the first people arrived, and once you’d assured yourself that the teens had a handle on things, you finally let yourself relax. You got some mocktails - a creation with fresh pineapple, passion fruit, Sprite and mint that was very delicious - that Andrew insisted on paying for even though the girls running the stall wanted to give them to you for free at first. You also got some cotton candy and kettle corn before falling into a pleasant little stroll along the sidewalk, watching the many stalls and people rushing between them.
“Fuck-”
You looked up, finding a pained expression on Andrew’s face.
“I didn’t- I didn’t tell her I’d be here-”
You followed his line of sight and quickly discovered the reason for the tension suddenly curling around him like a snake squeezing its prey to death.
Smurf.
She sauntered down the street towards you, a false smile plastered across her lips. Deran, Craig and Baz in tow, the latter accompanied by a woman who must be his wife, Cath and their little daughter. J trailed behind, looking more than a little lost among his estranged family.
“It’s fine. Everyone is invited.”
“I’m sorry.” Andrew croaked. It was obvious he had made every attempt to keep his family away from you - not that you for even one second believed such an undertaking would ever be fruitful. Or asked such a thing of him.
He grabbed your arm, a little tighter than he meant to, a sorrowful frown tugging on his brow the second he looked down at your arm. You hadn’t flinched. He still felt terrible.
“Don’t underestimate her. Please.”
A silent plea filled his pretty hazel eyes.
You cupped his cheek and gave him your warmest, sincerest smile. “I’m not. But I handle volatile sociopaths every day, handsome.” Andrew blushed at the pet name and squirmed under your intense focus. It was sweet. “Your mother doesn’t scare me, Andrew. That doesn’t mean I’m forgetting what she is capable of, but you should not forget who my father is.” With those words, you turned away from him and towards his approaching mother.
“So this is where you ran off to.” She hummed, casting a sharp look at Andrew before, almost as an afterthought, looking at you, sizing you up like she were trying to figure out how big of a threat you were - or whether you were small enough for her to simply devour whole.
Andrew shifted, taking half a step forward to shield your form from his mother’s piercing eyes.
As it was, his protectiveness only made Smurf hone in on you all the more.
“What an… adorable little party you’ve got here, baby.”
A cold shiver ran down your back, but you were more than used to ignoring the disgust that demeaning and too familiar nicknames slapped onto you by strangers caused.
“What a way to integrate yourself into the community.”
“This is the fourth block party the youth centre has organised.” You say with a smile so sweet and charming it grew teeth.
Oh, and Smurf felt them.
You were not unaware of her reputation, or how most of the locals were willing to ignore her criminal activities and her sons’ unruly behaviour because she threw parties at her house and tossed some money and surf competitions and sponsorships.
You knew she’d see the block party - never mind that it was the kids’ party and not yours - as a direct provocation, an attack on her status in Oceanside.
It just sucked for her that you’d been here for two years, and your roots already dug deep.
Deeper than Smurf was expecting.
And the thing with people was, their goodwill might be purchasable with parties and donations and some money tossed at them in times of need, at least for a little while, but people were not as dumb as Smurf thought, and they'd always be more drawn to people who took a genuine interest in them.
Her expression slipped, visibly caught off guard.
“I was surprised to never see you at these things.” You hummed, adding insult to injury. “But, ah well, we can’t always know everything going on in our town, hm? Please, feel free to look around.”
You crouched down and smiled at Lena hiding behind her mother’s leg.
“Hi, there. I’m your uncle’s friend. There’s a really awesome bouncy castle over there on the beach that I’d go check out if I were you.” You winked, coaxing a shy smile from the girl before getting back up.
“Hey, J.”
“Ms G.”
“I’m sorry I couldn’t make it to the funeral. I’ve been dealing with some family… stuff of my own. You hanging in there alright?”
The teenager gave a half shrug, a tiny motion he seemed to decide against halfway through.
“Well, you know where to find me, yeah? Why don’t you show Lena the bouncy castle? Nicky is helping with the cotton candy stall - I’m sure she’ll sneak you both some.”
J nodded. He knew you well enough to understand your thinly veiled hint and took the little girl’s hand. Her mother joined them.
“First my son, now my grandson. One could almost wonder why you are so invested in my family.” Smurf barely bothered to hide the venom in her voice beneath honey anymore.
“Well, I’ve known J for two years now. Curiously, I only heard he was your grandson today. Curious because I’ve heard you own half of Oceanside at this point, yet it was me who bought your grandson new shoes when his had holes in them. Or school supplies. Or dinner because he hadn’t eaten in three days.” You took a step towards Smurf, invading her personal space and enduring the older woman’s hateful glare with unbothered poise, yeah almost amusement. “And it was me who made sure your son didn’t get shanked, or killed by guards, or rotted in solitary until he went insane. I believe the better question is why you aren’t more invested in your own family than some rando social worker?”
A few people greeted you as they walked by, and you could practically see the realisation of just how deeply entwined with the community you had gotten sink in more with every single one of them.
So deeply entwined that people would notice your absence, that your absence would hurt. And if she showed you too much animosity, well, people would talk should anything happen to you, because they cared more about you than they feared her.
“But I don’t want to keep you.” You murmured with a false pout and an apologetic shrug of your shoulders, taking a step back. “Do enjoy yourself, Smurf.”
She all but bared her teeth like an animal pushed into a corner, but took the way you offered, turning to walk away.
You extended your arm to stop the largest of Andrew’s brothers.
“Which one are you again?”
The giant just blinked at you in confusion.
“Deran or Craig? I can’t keep you apart. The fuckass, self-assured grin on that one’s face tells me he is Baz" Andrew, behind you, bit back a snort, while the shorter guy smirked. "- the short hair also helps with the differentiating - you two-” You gestured from the tall long-haired man to the short long-haired man. “-is tricky.”
“Craig.” He grunted, sounding a little annoyed, a little offended, and entirely over this conversation.
“Craig.” You hummed. “Did your brother give you my message?”
Craig’s eyes flicked from you to Andrew, who was still standing behind you like a guard dog.
“Yeah.”
“Mhm… did you tell him what I said or just the gist of it?”
“I told him what you said.”
“Hm.”
“I didn’t bring any drugs to this lame as shit thing, alright?”
You took a step forward. Craig visibly struggled to resist the urge to back away despite being probably two heads taller than you.
It was your eyes, someone had once told you.
You had your father’s eyes, and not just because they were the same colour…
“I was quite serious about what I said.” You said softly. “It’s quite the… evolutionary disadvantage… external genitalia. Some animals do it much better than us in that regard, concealing them on the inside when they aren’t actively breeding. It’s so… vulnerable to have such a sensitive part exposed like that… and men do bleed like fucking pigs when you cut them down there.” Your voice had dipped into a menacing, low hiss. You cocked your head, gazing up at Craig lazily while watching your words sink in.
You extended your hand, palm up.
Craig shifted uncomfortably on the spot, sniffed and pulled a little baggie out of his pocket that he promptly slapped into your hand.
“Can I trust you to put this in your car, or do I have to get uncomfortable?”
Craig muttered something under his breath you couldn’t quite make out, but he took the baggie back and trudged away. When you turned around, you almost collided with Andrew who’d silently crept towards you sometime during your conversation with Smurf or Craig and was grinning down at you.
“Well.” You chirped, recovering quickly from the surprise. “Have fun!”
You didn’t get far.
Pete, rather brusquely, made his way through the crowd towards you. You rolled your eyes and braced yourself for the conversation you’d been avoiding for several days now. You felt Andrew tense behind you and slipped your hand into his, giving it a little squeeze before letting go again.
“Pete, I’m pretty sure I’m not due for an oil change yet.”
You met Pedro Trujillo five years ago when you first started working at Folsom. One of his associates thought they could turn you, intimidate or threaten you to smuggle contraband into the prison for them. Needless to say, that endeavour had not been fruitful, but you would call Pete a… not friend, but some secret third thing between acquaintance and friend.
“Cut the shit.” Pete hissed, drawing himself up to his full height in front of you in a weak attempt to force you into submission. Your smile didn’t waver.
“Come to see your niece play? I’m afraid her band isn’t up until later.”
“¿Me estás tomando el pelo? I’ve been trying to call you.”
“And I’ve been ignoring you.”
Pete grabbed your wrist. Andrew made to lunge at the man, but you stopped him by extending your arm.
“Right now we are talking. Let go of me right now, and we’ll continue talking.” Your voice had turned icy. Pete understood your threat without you needing to make it explicit.
Pete scoffed but dropped your wrist. “Marvin was right. You don’t give a shit about yourself.” His eyes flicked from you to the Codys still standing behind you, watching.
“What business do you have with the Codys anyway?” He hissed, voice lowered so only you - and maybe Andrew - could hear him.
“That is none of your concern.” You said calmly. “The same answer I gave Marvin. The same that goes for the situation with my father.”
“Yeah… fuck that. I will have some of my men on your street, keep an eye on you, hija.”
Your expression froze over. “You will do no such thing. I value our friendship, if you want to call it that, but that goes too far, Pedro.”
“He kills girls who look like you!” Pete shouted, loud enough for several heads to swivel around towards you. “Three so far already!”
You gritted your teeth.
Oh, how you loathed it when people dragged your personal business out into the public.
You’d done Pete some favours, helped some cousins with child protective services, kept an eye on his men currently doing stints in Folsom and such things - all legal favours, simply because you could, and it was always better to be on friendly terms with gangs - and in turn Pete had developed some odd sense of responsibility when it came to you.
Like Marvin had.
Like Andrew seemed to.
What was it with dangerous criminals taking a liking to you?
You really should rethink your life choices, it would seem.
“Keep your fucking voice down.” You hissed, crowding Pete like you had done with Smurf and Craig before - like your father always did.
“Yeah? What if I don’t? Whatcha gonna do, hm?”
Your lips curled in a menacing, blood-curdling grin. “I assure you, you don’t want to find out, Pete. You may have your little gang, yeah? But only one of us was down in Louisiana feeding severed human heads to alligators to get rid of evidence, darling. I could make you fall off the face of the earth so thoroughly nobody is ever even going to find a fucking toenail of yours.”
“The last body was found in Wyoming. What’s your plan, hija, hm? Sit around and wait for him to show up? Or perhaps that’s why you’ve let that mutt into your bed?”
Andrew curled his hands to fists. You didn’t even bat an eye.
“My father isn’t killing those girls because he wants to kill me, sweetheart. He kills them because they dare impersonate me. He’s fucking insane. Clinically insane, Pete, and he’s obsessed with me. He thinks I’m his greatest creation. He’ll try to convince me to go with him, not hurt me. So if you and Marvin could please remove that stick from your ass and get a fucking grip!”
Pete kissed his teeth, eyes roaming along your body, quietly assessing you. His jaw was tense, every muscle in his body taut, as though he was merely readying himself for round two of your row.
“I’ll have my men keep an eye on your street. If he tries anything-”
“I am not one of your little cohorts!” You hissed. “You have no authority over me and certainly no right to any of this. And if you hurt a single hair on his head-”
“-yeah? Who’s gonna stop me from it?-”
“-I’ll fucking destroy you, Pete. I’ll destroy your whole family and everything you and your father ever built. And I’ll pay you back tenfold for any harm you cause my father. You know I fucking will. And nobody is ever going to know.”
Pete’s nostrils flared.
“I choose to be a gentle person, and not because I am too weak to do evil shit, that I can assure you of! You do not want to see the vengeance a gentle person wreaks. My father is the only family I have, and he may be disturbed, I may want to see him admitted to a psychiatric unit and never leave it again, but he is my father, and I will make anyone who harms him pay for it.”
You took a step back and ran a hand through your hair, trying to shake off some of the tension this encounter had wrought around you.
“Now.” You said softly, as though none of the bloody threats from before had ever left your lips “Today is about celebrating the accomplishments of disadvantaged youth. Don’t kill the mood.”
You smiled at Andrew and made to resume your rounds through the stalls and clusters of excited teens. Pete stopped you, grabbing your arm just to let go when you shot a withering glare in his direction.
“I hope you know what you are doing, hija.” His eyes flicked towards Andrew, making clear he was not only talking about your father.
“Whether or not I do - it is not your concern.”
“Sí, always the ice queen…”
“Don’t call me that.” You grunted and turned away. This time nobody stopped you.
Andrew followed you, as he had done the whole day, every day since he was released really, but perhaps for the first time Smurf was there to watch it happen. To watch her oldest son, her first son, march after a woman who was not her.
He touched his fingertips to the back of your hand, a touch so gentle, so featherlight you barely felt it. You extended your hand a little, allowing Andrew to slip his into yours, weaving your fingers together in a gesture of such soft, easy intimacy, Andrew found himself incapable of looking away from it. He watched the way your hand all but disappeared in his larger one, watched your thumb, your nails painted a warm charcoal grey, stroke absentmindedly across the back of his hand.
You exhaled a breath you'd been holding since Smurf showed up.
“You fed severed heads to alligators?”
“Wouldn’t you like to know, lover boy.” You joked, though it fell flat, and Andrew knew you too well as that he’d miss the sober note in your voice, the hint of bitterness that was so unusual for you.
“You know Pete well?”
Andrew had a thousand questions burning on his tongue, but he didn’t know how to express any of them.
“A little. Criminals have the tendency to grow protective of me.” You turned to look at him, a smirk stealing onto your lips. “I don’t know why.”
Andrew knew, though he again lacked the words to express it. It was- it was the way you held his hand so softly even though you knew how much blood clung to it. It was the way you’d looked at Pete even when you threatened to hurt him, how your eyes never turned hard.
The way you held onto broken things and refused to give up on them. Even if you only did it because you thought if they were not lost yet, perhaps neither were you.
“What you said about your father-”
“I mean it.” Your voice slipped back into that low, warning tone you’d directed at Pete. “Hurt him and I will hurt you.” You hesitated, glancing at Andrew from the corner of your eye. “That doesn’t mean I want you to not fight back should he try to hurt you.”
“Will he?”
You shrugged. “He’s a jealous man.”
You didn’t need to elaborate. Andrew understood. You figured, with a mother like Smurf, he would.
“I just-” You cast your gaze down at the ground, something Andrew would almost call shame slipping into your expression. “He’s all I have. He’s terrible but- but he’s family.”
“I- I- I’m here.” Andrew pressed closer to your side, head ducked to catch your gaze, brows furrowed tightly as though he didn’t quite understand what his tentative promise entailed either.
“Mh, I noticed. What with you following me even when I tell you I don’t have time to hang out.”
You’d moved quite a bit away from the stalls. The light of the fairy lights strung around the tents and torches stuck in the sand barely reached you two, lapping at Andrew’s back as though he was absorbing it all. You came to a stand, not wanting to wander away too much in case someone needed you. The wind coming from the ocean was cold, painting goosebumps across your bare skin, and tasted of salt on your lips.
You stared at the ocean, watching the gentle waves lap at the beach and stones sticking out from it. The stars above you glinted, a thousand glowing pinpricks cutting through the dark sky, not yet fully swallowed by light pollution out here.
“How cruel…” You murmured, more to yourself than Andrew, who was staring at you like you were at the ocean. “To be afraid of something you love so much…”
Andrew wasn’t sure whether you were talking about the ocean or your father.
Perhaps both.
You wrapped your arms around yourself to stave off the cold. Andrew shrugged out of his hoodie and put it around your shoulders. You startled, ripped out of your thoughts by the warmth suddenly curling around you. You smiled at Andrew and slipped into the sleeves, drawing the warm fabric that smelled of him tighter around you.
Your hand half concealed by the hoodie cuff, you cupped his cheek and got up on your tiptoes to kiss him. Andrew’s hands found your waist and pulled you closer, deepening the kiss with the same despairing hunger that always led the way he touched you.
When you eventually dragged him back towards the crowd he’d usually despise but surprisingly barely noticed when you were at his side, he could not help but hear the odd whisper.
Pope’s girl, some muttered, but trailing behind you, basking in the warmth you extended to everyone who approached you to exchange a few words, talk about this or that inconsequential tidbit of your life you’d revealed to them, drowning in his jacket protecting you from the cold ocean air, Andrew could not help but feel that they were wrong.
So very wrong.
He was yours, not the other way around, and he’d cling to the light you’d fought so hard to regain and the way you held him as if he had no idea how it sounded when a skull cracked on asphalt, what it looked like when eye went dark and empty, or how long it took for someone set aflame to finally stop screaming for as long as you would let him.
You might have had your very own darkness, but you were the purest thing Pope’s life had ever seen…
Next Chapter
Taglist (Please feel free to let me know if you want to be added or removed): @princessgiyuu @chanelwidag @gabbyella @stardustworlds @mostdefinitelyhasissues @landpiranha-blog @vicky066 @pupppyyy55 @sofia-the-scholar @insidethegardenwall @mxkhxx @3-smi @bombtasticbritt91 @punkshyteee @honimoon @mortiswicki @morgan-aaa @tubby23 @snowwythegloww @annwoods91 @dendulinka6 @swiss-mrs @a-true-janian-reply @shellshore1 @buttercuppy8 @naxxsstuff @peachjellyy @g0dsfav0riteprincess @ceceseason @aoi-warrior @its-a-me-mario-21 @realwhoreforfictionalmen @flowerlover006 @jennataurus @imaginexred
ok so the mommy issues comment to samira makes even more sense now.
robby has worked with dana for years and she didn’t know about his mother. he has kept that part of himself completely separate.
his exact words were, “nobody knows. who needs to know? who gives a fuck!” so when samira lets that completely inform her entire work day, he simply can’t understand it. that’s something you bifurcate.
and worse, when samira complains about how her mother is too present, wants to talk to her too much, he can’t relate to that at all.
he doesn’t know what it’s like to have a mom that wants to talk to you. he doesn’t know what it’s like to be annoyed by too many phone calls. he doesn’t know what it’s like to be able to just go to people for help. he’s so envious of samira for so many reasons.
pope coming home from a long day and he looks oh so sad so u just sit at his feet and let him play with ur hair while resting ur face on his muscular thigh…..yeah.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality
Anya is LIVE right now
FREE
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
“Know I wanna beat it, wanna beat it bad
Oh, everyone looks happy in a photograph
I've crossed the county line, I cannot go back
I'm always on my own.”
-All Them Horses, Noah Kahan
summary: your family is in town for the annual ‘parents berating their kids for their decisions’ get together. jack overhears you talking about how much easier it would be if you had a boyfriend to shove in their face, and offers his services. No strings attached, of course.
wc: 15.7k (steak is too juicy lobster is too buttery)
tags/tropes: jack falls first and harder, reader is an eldest daughter (but not the eldest child) to a large judgmental family who are constantly disappointed in her, jack pretty much uses the fake dating as a chance to show reader what a good boyfriend he COULD be to her if she let herself have nice things, jack 'i'll pay for it' abbot, jack is YEARNING in this one, a teeny bit of mean dom jack as a treat
a/n: how are we all feeling about the latest noah kahan album. Doors is great. i do NOT repeat timestamp 2:14-2:21 of All Them Horses. i’m normal and can be trusted with noah kahan’s discography. fic has been crossposted on ao3 and is linked below :)
acknowledgements: thank you @wesandresons for the amazing gif and @saradika-graphics, @chrisssiren, and @uzmacchiato for the dividers! and thank you @leeknowpegger for your work in keeping up morale and being deranged with me
masterlist | ao3
“Your family’s in town?”
You’re at the nurses station, tucked into a corner with your head in your hands while Shen, of course, drinks what has to be his third Dunkin coffee of the day. Where he’s getting them is one of the world’s strangest unsolved mysteries.
You can’t see his face, on account of the heels of your hands being pressed into your eyes so hard stars are bursting and swirling behind your eyelids, but you can hear the grimace in his tone.
“Yeah. I moved out here to get away from them, but they decided to host the annual family dinner circuit here in Pittsburgh instead. My mom always complains about how it’s such a huge imposition to have the entire family fly out, but I never asked to do it and offered to just fly to them on multiple occasions. Apparently, my work schedule is too hard to work around.”
“Dinner circuit?”
You wave a hand. “It’s actually a lunch circuit now, since I work nights. Basically, for every single day that they’re here everybody has to attend a lunch, no matter what. Most of the time they’re at different restaurants, but sometimes my mom demands to have them at my place.”
“Yikes,” The attending says, sipping on the last bits of his coffee, “And the whole successful doctor thing doesn’t work on them? It got my parents off my back.”
You shake your head. “I’m the only doctor in the family, but they thought I should’ve been a hospitalist or go into general surgery.”
The sound of ice being shaken in a plastic cup rings in your ears. “There’s money in emergency medicine. Eventually.”
“There’s money in all medicine eventually,” You groan, lifting your head and leaning against the wall, blinking dazedly up at the flickering fluorescent lights. “I’m sure if I'd picked general surgery they would’ve found a problem with that too.”
“So your fucked, basically.”
Your eyes slip shut again. “Yep. Anything short of showing up with a rich boyfriend and a promise of grandkids on the way won’t get my mom off my back.”
Shen clasps you on the shoulder. “Best of luck with that. You’re the only intern the night shift has got, so we’d rather you don’t off yourself via poisoned wine.”
“I wouldn’t do poison. I’d choke on bread so they’d have to live with the guilt of not being able to save me.”
“Jesus fuck, man. I mean, clearly, they suck, but that’s brutal.”
You shrug. “Not as brutal as my mom not coming to my med school graduation.”
He gapes. “What reason could she have possibly had for not showing up?”
“I told her at dinner the night before that I was going into emergency medicine.”
“That’s…” Shen trails off, flabbergasted, “…Wow. Now I'm worried you’re going to kill one of them.”
“Way too much effort. They aren’t worth the jail time.”
The attending tosses his now empty coffee in a nearby trash can. “Well, if you snap and kill them all in a fit of extremely valid rage, please don’t call me. I can’t afford to be implicated.”
“You saying I can’t hide a body myself?”
“I’m saying I can’t hide a body.”
“Who’s hiding bodies?” Jack says, sidling up to the two of you with a tablet and a chart open in his hand.
Shen jams a thumb in your direction. “She’s killing her parents later today.”
You roll your eyes. “I’m not. Honestly, so long as I agree with whatever my mom says and don’t bring up any trigger topics, I’ll be fine.”
Jack snorts. “You’re describing being held hostage by someone mentally unstable.”
“Dr. Intern?” Ellis interrupts, using the stupid nickname Santos picked for you when she found out you’re the only PGY1 on the night shift, “There’s a woman in the lobby here to see you. Says she’s your mom.”
Your stomach drops to your feet and your heart seizes in your chest. “It’s six in the morning. Oh my god. Oh my god.”
Someone behind you says “Holy shit,” but you’re already gone. As you’re speed walking you whip out your phone, checking the dates of their flights that you’d only had a chance to skim and— fuck. They got in an hour ago. Why the fuck would she stop here? At the PTMC?
You practically slam the doors open and make eye contact with your mom across the crowded lobby.
“Mom?”
“There you are sweetie. I was trying to explain that there’s nothing wrong with me and I was here to see you, but they wouldn’t let me. Something about a security issue?”
“It’s not safe. We’ve had incidents in the past—“
She waves a hand, dismissing you. “I’m your mother. Honestly, I wouldn’t have had to come down here if you’d just respond to my texts.”
“I’ve told you mom, I’m really busy here and I don’t get very much time to look at my phone—“
“Your brothers take the time out of their busy schedules to text me back,” She sighs, then continues on, “Did you get time off this week for dinner?”
You frown. “I thought we were having lunch.”
“Well, I figured since we’re all making it easier for your work schedule to come to you, you could manage to take a few days off for your family. But if we need to make an extra effort—“
“It’s fine, mom,” You tell her with a gritted-toothed smile, “I can make something work. Can you just send me the dates again?”
“It’s this Friday and Saturday.”
Before you can even open your mouth to respond, a large, warm hand settles on your shoulder. Accompanied by the hand is a steadying one on your lower back, a familiar, rich scent and a low voice.
“Can I help you, ma’am?”
Jack.
Jack fucking Abbot.
Hottest man in the ED. Probably in the world.
Your mom blinks, clearly caught off guard, before regaining her judgy senses and narrowing her eyes at him.
“I’m trying to have a conversation with my daughter. Don’t tell me you’re security.”
You know for a fact that Jack has his stethoscope around his neck and his keycard in his scrub pocket that says ‘DOCTOR’ on it, so your mom’s just being bitchy. Figures.
Jack’s hand in your shoulder gives you a tiny, reassuring squeeze before he speaks.
“I’m Dr. Abbot,” He sticks out a hand for her to shake, the one that was on your shoulder, “I’m an attending here at the ED.”
And my boss, you mentally add. Your mom probably hears it anyway.
“You work with my daughter?”
“Yes ma’am. She’s the most promising intern we have here on the night shift.”
Your lips twitch at his words. He’s joking. Testing your mother— you’re the only PGY1 on the night shift. If your mom remembers that, she’ll pick up on his joke.
She doesn’t. She purses her lips for a moment before giving him one of her big, fake smiles.
“Well that’s good to hear. We’re very proud of her.”
Proud of the money I send home, maybe.
“If you’ll excuse us, I need her working on patients.”
“Oh yes, of course,” Your mom gushes, clearly already charmed by Jack. He has that effect on people. “I didn’t realize she was so important and busy here.“
You would if you’d ever let me talk about work before interrupting me and telling me what I should be doing better.
Jack’s thumb makes tiny sweeping motions on your lower back, little tingling motions that distract you enough to unclench your jaw and relax your shoulders.
“I’ll text you as soon as I can, okay mom?”
Your mom sweeps you into a hug, a rare show of affection. Putting on a show for Jack, more than likely.
“No rush. Whenever you get the chance, sweetheart.”
Jack gives her a parting nod, but you wait until your mom’s turned around and walking out of the lobby before allowing Jack to steer you back inside.
The second the doors close behind you and you’re enveloped in the sounds and smells of the heart of the PTMC, you shut your eyes and release a long exhale.
“I,” You start, “Am so sorry. I never thought she’d show up here, I got the flight times mixed up—“
“Hey,” Jack’s voice is low and steady, a much needed anchor. He uses the hand still on your lower back to turn you towards him, “None of that was your fault. We deal with patients like that every day. It is not your job to keep your mother in line.”
“I know. I know. Still, I’m sorry. She can be… difficult.”
He snorts. “Understatement of the year. But seriously. Don’t worry about it. If I didn’t want to get involved with her, I wouldn’t have swooped in there.”
You huff a laugh. “My hero. I’m pretty sure if you’d introduced yourself as my boyfriend she would’ve had an aneurysm. Or a heart attack.”
“Are those desired outcomes?”
“Mostly.”
He slides his hands into his pockets and leans against the opposite wall. “Might be worth a shot, then.”
It’s a very well kept secret that you’ve harbored an embarrassing, ‘think about him while you’re falling asleep at night’ crush on Jack.
So naturally, your response is to laugh. Loudly. And semi-awkwardly. Because he has to be joking. Obviously.
“Yeah, right,” You say, looking down at your feet because eye-contact has never been your forte and Jack’s gaze is too intense, “Could even take you to dinner with me. Maybe my dad would have a heart attack too. Really just wipe out the whole family.”
“You could.”
“Wipe out my entire family?”
“Take me to dinner with you.”
Jack’s body is relaxed and his tone is even. Not light and humor-filled. There’s no mischievous uptick to the corner of his lips. He looks like he’s serious.
“Are you joking?”
He can’t really be serious. He’s probably just fucking with you. He wouldn’t actually—
“No.”
You run a hand over your hair. “Yeah, sure, laugh it up, haha—“
“I’ll go to dinner with you. As your boyfriend.”
What. The. Fuck.
“No.” You gape, incredulous.
“No?” He raises an eyebrow.
“No, I mean— fuck. Dr. Abbot—“
“Jack.”
You purse your lips. “Jack. You can’t just… pretend to be my boyfriend at a family lunch.”
“Why not?”
“Why not?” You sputter, “For one, we hardly know each other—“
“You’ve been working here for three months. We’re hardly strangers.”
“You’re my boss, your way older than me, you’re—“ You cut yourself off before you can say something embarrassing like ‘you’re ridiculously fucking hot and I haven’t washed my socks in months’, “It wouldn’t even be believable. How would we even have met?”
“In the ED, obviously.”
“How long have we been together?”
“Month and a half.”
“Why are we even dating?”
“Because you’re a beautiful and intelligent woman, not to mention a good doctor.”
Your mouth goes dry, and your stomach does an entire gymnastics routine.
“Have you… thought about this?”
He makes a noncommittal hum, tilts his head back a bit. “Would it work?”
“Are you rich?”
There’s that devilish, pants dropping smile.
“I’m a senior attending on night shifts in an emergency department. I’m comfortable.”
You worry your lip between your teeth. “I still can’t… I appreciate the offer, but I can’t subject you to my family. No one else should have to suffer through these lunches and dinners.”
“But you do?”
“They’re my family.”
Jack doesn’t respond, but he doesn’t move off the wall and walk away either. Distantly, you really hope a patient isn’t coding somewhere.
You sigh. “Why would you even offer, anyway?”
“You need help, and I’m in a position to give it. Plus life has been kind of boring recently. My therapist told me to pick a new hobby that doesn’t involve people dying or getting shot at.”
“So you thought spending an evening being subjected to backhanded questions, comments, and not very subtle micro-aggressions was a good substitute?”
“Beats drinking beer in the park.”
You can’t say yes. It’s crazy. One, it would make your crush a million times worse and you might never recover on that fact alone, and two, when this inevitably blows up in your face, your family will never let you live it down and bring it up in literally every conversation for the rest of your life.
On the other hand, if it works, it will work. Your mom would probably get off your back for a while. You wouldn’t be a complete and total disappointment. If it works, it would be a much needed win.
“So. We’ve been dating for a month and a half?”
Jack nods, another smile playing at his lips. “I asked you out, of course.”
“Flowers?”
“Naturally.”
“You pay?”
“For every meal.”
“What’s my favorite color?”
“Navy blue. Mine?”
You roll your eyes. “Black. What are we going to tell my mom when she pokes at the age gap?”
Someone rushes by, pager beeping, and you both wordlessly start moseying towards your respective patients.
“Will she really be that upset about it?”
“Probably not, but she’ll definitely ask about it. My dad will probably be angry, but he’s easier to placate than my mom is.”
Jack hums thoughtfully. “When’s the lunch today?”
“Twelve-thirty, at that Italian place that has that mussel dish.”
“How about this,” He starts, apparently not needing anymore clarification on the location, “Lets focus on finishing our shifts right now. Then go home, get some sleep, and I’ll pick you up at eleven so you can pick my brain for every detail that you want to make this work. Deal?”
Last chance to back out. Say hell no, this is a crazy idea, why would you even volunteer for it, I changed my mind.
“Deal.”
—
Holy fucking shit. Jack Abbot is your boyfriend.
Fake boyfriend. But for the next few hours, he’s as good as yours. Kind of.
In a way.
You’re standing in front of your bathroom mirror, dressed in the outfit you picked out for the stupid lunch when your mom texted you the plane ticket details a month ago.
Neither your makeup nor your hair are cooperating and you really need them to because you have to be perfect, so you need your mascara and stop clumping and your hair to stop laying like that and you just don’t want to fucking go.
Before frustration induced tears can ruin your half-done makeup, a knock sounds at the door.
You rush through your apartment, nearly cracking your skull open on the corner of the couch when you trip over a stray shoe.
Shit, he’s here and you’re not ready, god he’s going to be so upset you have to make him wait it’s so rude—
“Hi!” You swing open the door and plaster what you hope is a cute-frazzled smile and not a panicked one. It’s a thin line between the two, “I’m almost ready, I’m so sorry, you can come in and sit down wherever, I promise I won’t take too long to finish up. Sorry.”
You turn, unable to bear the anger or frustration on his face and dart away (an old method— hiding and disappearing is much better for everyone in the long run) but a hand encircles your wrist before you can successfully escape.
“Woah, easy girl. Nobody’s mad at you. We have time, remember?”
Your smile is definitely coming across as panicked.
Your nails wander and find a hangnail to pick at while you talk. “I know, but that was so we’d have time to plan and it’s rude to make you wait and I really need time to plan, but I can’t get my makeup to look right—“
Jack nudges you into the house and you cut yourself off with another apology. Right. Cause he’s just standing in the hallway and you’re rambling on like someone deranged. God. Why can’t your brain just work? Get into gear? Actually function properly?
“First of all,” Jack starts, gently steering you towards your couch, “You look beautiful.”
Why does he have to say these things? Has he no care for what he’s doing to your heart? Is he unaware that Simone Biles would be impressed with the flip routine your stomach is currently doing?
He places a throw pillow in your hands which were previously clenched in your lap. It’s your favorite throw pillow, actually, because the texture is very soothing. You squeeze it and rub your fingers across the grain.
“Secondly, we don’t have to do this if you don’t want to. I can go home and go to bed and if you want, I’ll never bring it up again. Not even to Robby.”
You crack a wobbly smile. “Not even to Nurse Evans?”
“She’d probably guess on her own, but I would never confirm her suspicions.”
You tuck your feet under your legs, shrinking into the corner of your couch. “I couldn’t even if I wanted to. I already texted my mom to add a person to the reservation, and if I show up without a plus one there’ll be hell to pay.”
“You could swap me with someone else?”
“Do you think I would have agreed to let my boss be my fake boyfriend if I had someone else to bring?”
“Touché.”
The corner thread of your throw pillow has begun unraveling, and your wandering fingers pull and tug at it erratically.
“I’m sorry. I’m not usually this neurotic, I swear. My family brings out the worst in me.”
“I ain’t judging, sweetheart,” Jack soothes, “Besides. We’re ER doctors. We’re all a little neurotic.”
Steadfastly avoiding his gaze (again, just a little too knowing, like he can see every insecurity you’re trying to hide) you stand on shaky legs and rush to the bathroom.
“I’ll just. Finish up. Sorry again.”
“I’m gonna start a tally of unnecessary sorry’s. You’re gonna owe me an hour of overtime for each one.”
Oddly enough, getting ready (the rest of the way) feels much more manageable and much less difficult with Jack nearby. He doesn’t critique how long it takes you, the fact that you change earrings three times, or tell you that you look good enough and should just go.
He just hangs out in your living room, on the couch, practically oozing calm and nonchalance. The foolish, romance-starved part of you wants to cancel on your mom and spend the rest of the day curled up next to him on the couch, like a cat. Lazily dozing while Jack watches TV or something sounds like a much better way to spend your time after work than experiencing all five stages of grief over the course of one lunch. Repeatedly.
Finally ready, and with your sanity intact thanks to Jack, you pause by the kitchen and debate the merits of taking a shot to loosen your nerves. Unfortunately, your mom would undoubtedly somehow smell the alcohol on you and no doubt chew you out for a minimum of twenty minutes. Heaven forbid you make the event bearable.
Ever the kind host, you peek your head around the kitchen wall. “Do you want a shot, Jack?”
“You’re aware that I’m fifty?”
Right. That's probably an unhinged question.
“Just thought I’d offer,” You say, meekly tucking the bottle back under the shelf, slightly embarrassed, “Sometimes alcohol is the only way I can survive these things.”
He’s leaned up against the couch, hands in his pockets when you exit the kitchen. “It was very considerate, thank you. But I think the days of vodka and tequila shots are behind me. I’m more of a whiskey man, anyways.”
“I’ll keep that in mind when we end up at a bar afterwards to drink away memories of the lunch.”
Jack raises an eyebrow. “You act like we’re going to be hung, drawn, and quartered after showing up.”
You worry your bottom lip between your teeth. “Sorry. I just don’t want you to be unprepared, because they’re not always bad but when they’re bad they’re bad, you know? And I just don’t want to scare you off, and ruin the day you could be spending sleeping, and I really am thankful, by the way, I just don’t—“
“Do you always ramble when you’re worried?” Jack interrupts, tilting his head to the side.
“Um. No? I don’t know. I try not to. But like I said. My family brings out the worst in me.”
He searches your face for a moment, then taps the underside of your chin with a crooked finger, raising it slightly.
“We got this, okay? I’m not easy to scare. Combat med vet, remember? Plus, if it really gets that bad, I’ll fake a call from the hospital. Say there was some horrible accident and we’re being called in.”
“Won’t my mom get wise when she never hears it on the news?”
Jack shrugs. “It’s the city. Something horrible is always happening here.”
He holds the front door open for you when you’ve got your shoes on and purse ready, but as you’re sliding past him, he leans down, the angle of his jaw almost brushing the side of your neck, and breathes in deeply.
“You smell good.”
Fuck the gymnastics routine. Your stomach is going for Olympic Gold.
“Oh,” You exhale, a shiver running up your spine and a pleasant tingling sparking where your skin barely brushed his, “Uh— Thanks. Vanilla and spice. I like layering scents.”
“It’s nice. Suits you.”
You manage to squeak out another awkward “Thanks” before hastily locking the door, hoping he can’t tell just how flustered he keeps making you. Judging by the smile playing at his lips, your hopes are in vain.
The car ride to the restaurant is longer than it should be, on account of Pittsburgh traffic, but the time goes by quickly as you pepper Jack with questions to prepare for the million and one that your mother will no doubt ask.
(“What should I say if she asks if we’ve slept together?”
“Do you really, honestly, truly think your mother is going to bring up the topic of sex at the table, in a nice restaurant, with your entire family present?”
“Fair point.”)
By the time you arrive, you’ve picked and torn every single hangnail and loose cuticle around your fingers down to raw flesh and tiny dots of blood. Jack parks the car (parallel parks easily in one go, no repositioning needed, in downtown Pittsburgh. It’s one of the hottest things you’ve ever seen in your life) a good distance away from the restaurant, so that your family wouldn’t be able to see you if you decided to flee to his car to escape them.
At least, that’s what he says.
“I want you to hang onto the car keys, okay? If they get too much, you can sneak out through the kitchen and go to the car. I’ll meet you there.”
You can’t help but smile at his efforts. “And what will you be doing while I’m sneaking out?”
“Singing your praises, of course.”
Exhaustion from the shift you worked in what seems like a lifetime ago lines your limbs, but as you step out of the car (through the door Jack insists on opening for you “In case they’re still watching,”) and loop your arm through Jack’s, you feel… almost capable.
The lunch is going to suck. That’s a given. But Jack assured you he’s seen worse (“Probably done worse, sweetheart,”) and will not leave the lunch in a fit of rage and cause a scene. His arm is firm and solid —and fucking huge, how are his biceps that big— under your arm, and his presence is steadying.
As you cross the street and begin your final walk towards the building, he un-loops his arm from yours, but after you make a questioning noise in your throat, worried you’d be completely untethered (how pathetic to already be this reliant on a man, but there’s no time to unpack that now) but instead he wraps his arm around your waist instead, drawing you to his side and effectively grounding you to his body.
The entire left side of your body lights up at the contact, and if this were your apartment, it would be very difficult to refrain from climbing him like a tree or doing something equally embarrassing, like plastering yourself to his side and begging him to never stop touching you.
You’ve almost managed to come off unaffected, but then he leans down, lips almost brushing your ear, and whispers:
“You’ve got this, baby. And if you don’t, I do.”
Forget your family. Jack Abbot is going to be the death of you.
When you walk into the restaurant, hyper-aware of Jack’s grip on your body (your delusional mind has you thinking how… possessive the hand almost feels, if you ignore the fact that this is all fake) your family is waiting in the foyer, talking amongst themselves.
Your mother immediately zeroes in on you. “Honey, we’ve talked about you being on time to these things. You can’t be late to important family—“
You watch in real time as your mother’s gaze finally flicks to Jack, and the shades of recognition, shock, almost disgust, and confusion before settling back into forced pleasantness.
Your father, however, looks downright murderous. Looks like the age gap isn’t going down too well.
If Jack is at all nervous or put off by the several stares and outright glares from your family, he does not show it. He exudes cool confidence, the same unflappable energy he has during chaotic night shifts. The same calm that makes him so alluring to you in the first place.
He sticks out his hand for your mother to shake, a mirror of earlier that day in the PTMC lobby.
“I believe we’ve met before, but I’ll introduce myself again. I’m Dr. Jack Abbot.”
Your mother shakes his hand, but looks between the two of you like you’ve just spilled wine on her Persian rug that she can’t afford in the first place.
“You’re my daughter’s plus one?”
Jack nods. “Her boyfriend, yes.”
Your brother’s gape. Your dad’s glare intensifies. You want to kiss Jack.
“Honey,” Your mother says, gaze darting to you, “You didn’t say—“
“I didn’t want you to meet him at the hospital,” You tell her, hoping the lie doesn’t come across as too rehearsed, since you did rehearse it several times with Jack in the car on the way over, “The lobby of the hospital isn’t the best place to introduce people. And we really did have patients to get back to.”
Your mother purses her lips. “Why the last minute addition? If you’d told me that he was coming before today, it would’ve been easier to make the reservation.”
Jack is quicker to respond than you. “That’s my fault, actually. I didn’t think I was going to be able to come, what with my shifts as a senior attending, but when we met in the lobby I understood how important it was to make the time.”
You have to try hard not to smile at Jack’s not-so-subtle flex. Senior attending.
“Yes, well. My daughter doesn’t always stress the importance of these things.”
Jack’s grip on your waist tightens ever-so-slightly at the backhanded remark, and your mother’s gaze darts to the point of contact. But your father jerks his head towards the tables before she can say anything. “I’m starving.”
Everyone files in behind him, with you and Jack at the back of the line. Again, he leans down to whisper to you.
“How’d I do?”
You elbow him in the side. “We’ll discuss your performance after this is over.”
“Looking forward to it.”
The hostess leads everyone over to a large table near a window (your mother is particularly about seating) and everyone finds a seat. One of your brothers, either as a test or just to be a shit (your money’s on the latter) slides into the open seat next to you before Jack can.
To his credit, Jack doesn’t cause a scene, but he doesn’t back down either. He just stares at your idiot brother for awhile before finally asking:
“Do you really wanna do this right now?”
Your brother must sense that Jack Abbot is not a man to be fucked with (just a man you want to fuck), and scurries to his own seat, tail between his legs.
Once everyone is seated and the food is ordered (you don’t bother ordering anything other than the salad; Jack orders the most expensive thing on their menu. He’s never seemed like one to care for finery and expensive Italian restaurants where you practically have to order in Italian, but again, his unfazed demeanor makes him fit in anywhere) your family immediately begins peppering him with questions. Questions you knew they’d ask and appropriately prepared him for.
“So. Dr. Abbot—”
“Just Jack is fine.”
“—How long have the two of you been dating?”
“A month and a half.”
“Why’d you start dating?”
You take a generous gulp of your wine.
“Because your daughter is an incredible woman and an even better doctor.”
“Do you think she’s pretty?” One of your brothers chimes in.
Jack takes it in stride, despite that not being a question you prepared. “I’d have to be blind and stupid if I didn’t.”
You feel hot from the tips of your ears down to your toes.
That’s going in the mental folder.
“Have you always wanted to be a doctor?”
“Pretty much. Took a bit of a detour as a combat medic first, though.”
“Why’d you leave?”
“Honorably discharged after I lost my right leg. Below the knee amputation.”
You drain the rest of your glass and inconspicuously motion to the waiter for more wine.
The table is silent for the customary length of time after someone drops the “got a limb chopped off” bomb. Your family is clearly mildly uncomfortable, but Jack just keeps sipping his drink, his free hand drifting down and brushing the side of your thigh.
Your dad clears his throat. Here we go. Home stretch. Final questions before we’re in the clear.
“Mr. Abbot—“
“Either Doctor or Jack works.”
Ooo. There was some bite in that one.
Your Dad frowns. He does not like to be interrupted or corrected. You’ve been on the receiving end of far too many hour long lectures (read: berating and borderline verbal abuse) to know better.
But Jack isn’t his daughter. Jack is pretty much his equal. Actually, the fact that Jack not only served but is now a doctor places him above your father, by social conventions.
This no doubt infuriates your father. He’s always hated it when he couldn’t tear somebody down to his level. A true coward.
“Jack,” Your dad continues, a trademarked forced smile to save face, “You’re a smart man, yeah? Haven’t you ever considered the age difference between the two of you might be a little much?”
Yikes. Questioning Jack’s competency is not the way to go. Jack is very competent. And smart. And capable. It’s really hot.
Your fake-boyfriend just reaches over and grasps your hand, over the table, and looks at you with such devotion in his eyes that you forget how to breathe.
“War doesn’t really lend to longevity. I’ve learned to hold on tight to things I care about.”
For a moment, it doesn’t feel fake. There’s raw, punched emotion in his voice, and his thumb rubs your hand gently. Like he really does care that much. Like he wants to hold on.
But then your brother fake-gags and your fake boyfriend looks away with that, he’s passed the tests, and the conversation moves onto to different topics. Jack laughs at all the right moments, doesn’t bring up any argument-starting topics, doesn’t rise to bait when it’s thrown his way.
He’s perfect.
Eventually lunch is drawn to a polite close. You have one last glass of wine while Jack settles the bill. Himself. With one card. He doesn’t even look.
Your mom sends a smirk your way after he waves off your father’s attempt at splitting the bill or offering to pay. It’s probably the third time she’s actually looked at you for the entire duration of the lunch, but since it’s positive, you’ll let it slide.
Pretty soon bags are grabbed, hands are shook, and Jack’s hand magically finds its way back to your lower back and you’re being (very gently) escorted out of the restaurant and to the car.
“Wow,” You breathe as you slide into the passenger seat of his car. “I think that’s the smoothest a lunch with my family has ever gone in my entire life. You’re really good at this.”
Jack doesn’t respond though. Doesn’t make any kind of noise that he heard you. His hands are nearly white knuckled on the steering wheel and he’s staring straight ahead.
“Jack?”
“They didn’t even talk to you.”
You blink.
“What?”
“Your family never tried to include you in the conversation. Didn’t even ask you any questions.”
You snort. “Trust me, it’s better that way.”
He hasn’t started the car yet, just keeps staring off into the middle ground. He can’t be old enough to start doing a thousand yard stare already, right?
“You ordered a salad.” He says, a very prominent frown on his lips.
“So? It wasn’t too expensive, was it? I swear, if I knew you were gonna pay for the whole bill I would’ve looked at something cheaper, I don’t know why salads are so expensive—“
“Please don’t apologize for ordering a salad,” Jack says, voice pained, “Especially because I know you hate salads.”
Oh.
“How do you know that?”
“I overheard you talking to Dr. King that time you two were discussing the merits of Olive Garden. You said the salad there was the only kind you like, because of the dressing and the pepperoncinis.”
Your cheeks heat. “I never said I hated all salads. I said I like that one in particular.”
“You hardly ate anything during lunch.”
“My family tends to have that effect on my appetite.”
Jack does not look placated. He doesn’t take the out that your little joke provides. Doesn't so much as huff. He looks upset. Distressed.
Something about what he said goes ding! in your mind.
“…Mel and I had that conversation like, last month. You seriously remembered that?”
He frowns harder, like the answer to your partly rhetorical question should be obvious.
(It’s not. Why would he remember that conversation? Why would he care at all?)
“Of course I remember.”
There isn’t much to say after that. You’re not really sure what in particular has upset Jack, what possibly blunder or error you’ve made to incur him going completely monosyllabic and frowny. Ever eager to appease, you refrain from any attempts to cajole him, make conversation, breathe too loudly, or make any kind of indication that you’re still present.
The tension in the car is thick and uncomfortable. It prickles at your skin and the hairs on the back of your neck, but the only thing you dare to do is scroll through Pinterest, only looking at the safest, basic boards in case Jack glances over (he doesn’t.)
But then he does glance over. He just doesn’t look at your phone.
Jack just keeps looking at you.
He’ll look over, eyes darting over your face like he’s looking for something, and then he’ll look away. Over and over for almost the entire course of the drive. He only stops when you accidentally time your staring (monitoring) of him wrong and make eye contact.
He parks by your place (he once again sexily parallel parks with ease) and then puts the car in park. And then he starts talking.
“You’re so much more than them.”
Jack has the heat on, but the air in the car suddenly feels cold.
“What?”
“Your family,” Jack clarifies, like that was the confusing part “Your parents. I hated watching you… disappear like that. You deserve better than that. You are better than that.”
You try to swallow, almost choking on the sudden lump in your throat.
“Listen,” You start, unaware of how to even begin processing what he said, let alone formulating the best response because your brain is just flashing abort! Abort! Abort! in big neon letters,, “Thank you for today. I really appreciate it. But if this is all just too much, I can handle things from here. Really. I can say that someone called out and you had to cover shifts—“
“No.”
Jack says it with such vehemence, bordering on vitriol, that it startles you, and you flinch backwards ever so slightly.
An old habit.
Something flashes across his face —gone before you can decipher it— and he noticeably forces himself calmer.
“I wouldn’t be able to live with myself if I let you go alone again. Ever.”
Your brain starts short-circuiting at his words. “I really can’t ask you to—“
“It’s a good thing you’re not asking me then.”
“Jack—“
“Please.”
You’re stunned silent at the rawness in his tone— the pain.
He said please. He said it like he was begging. He is begging.
“I don’t know how you do it,” He continues, jaw working, “I can see it on you, plain as day. How you hate what they do, how it makes you hurt. But you keep going.”
You shrug uselessly. “Is there another option?”
Jack reaches out for you, then falters, like he thought better. A tiny part of you wishes he’d followed through; bridged the yawning gap between the two of you that’s made up of the center console in his car, a couple decades, and your own unwillingness to try at vulnerability.
“I’ll walk you to your door.”
The walk to your door is a stark contrast to the walk to the restaurant. There’s no mischief on his face now, only a mask of stony distress.
At the doorway to your apartment building, you pause. It seems customary. Appropriate. Necessary.
Really, you just want to look at Jack some more. Try to puzzle out why the lunch that felt like it went so well made him so upset. Where you’re getting signals wrong and crossing wires. Why success to you is failure to him.
(As an ED resident, you’ve seen child abuse cases. You’ve seen foster care children littered with cigarette burns and criss-crossing scars of broken bottles and the corners of coffee tables and haunted eyes.
You know your family isn’t great. But there aren’t any cigarette burns or glass scars or eyes that track fast movement.)
You have this burning inclination to apologize to Jack. Logically, you know you haven’t done something wrong, but you feel like you have because he’s upset so maybe you can make it better?
“You have that look on your face.”
You frown. “What look?”
“The ‘I’m gonna apologize for something stupid’ look.”
“I wasn’t going to.”
“You were thinking about it,” Jack ducks down, catches your eyes, “Hey, listen to me. You cannot fix what I am upset about. It is not your job. My mood is not your responsibility.”
“It’s freaky when you do that.”
“Do what?”
“You always know what I’m thinking.”
Jack just huffs; shoves his hands in his pockets.
Emboldened by his reassurance, you ask: “Why are you upset?”
“Because your family treats you like shit, and I want to fix it, but I can’t.”
“Oh.”
It’s not that bad. It can’t be that bad. You’ve seen bad. This isn’t it. It’s hard, but it’s not bad.
He stays quiet, seemingly sensing the inner turmoil his words have sparked. That, or he really is that good at reading you.
Jack nods towards your door. “We can talk later. Get some sleep. We both have shifts tonight.”
Right. Yeah. All of these events roughly occurred over the course of six hours. Time makes sense.
Despite the fact that you are exhausted and desperately need to sleep if you have any chance of surviving your –quickly approaching– shift, you linger.
“How am I supposed to repay you for all of this?”
The question that’s been burning a hole in your pocket since he said I’ll do it.
He just shakes his head. Like it’s simple. Easy. “This isn’t something I want repayment for. Now go. You’re no good to me as a zombie.”
“I’ll just have some of Shen’s Dunkin.”
“He doesn’t share that shit. Besides, he’s off tomorrow.”
“Maybe I‘ll—“
“Sleep,” He points at your door, “Now.”
You smile at his insistence. He’s sort of like cold coffee with sugar. Seems all bitter but then you get a bit of that sweet crunch, so it balances out. He balances out.
Sometimes it feels like he balances you out.
“Goodnight.”
He gives you a little smile of his own.
“Goodnight.”
—
Jack Abbot does not take his own advice. Mostly because he knows if he doesn’t talk about what happened during that lunch from hell, he’s going to do something that will end in him being thrown in prison and having his medical license revoked. More importantly, if that happens, he won’t be around to take care of you.
So instead he collapses on his couch, works his prosthetic off to give his stump a needed break, and dials the number at the top of his favorites in his contact list.
“This really isn’t a good time—“
“Robby,” Jack starts, “They didn’t even fucking talk to her.”
“Jesus, okay. Whitaker! Cover for me a sec, will you? I gotta deal with this.”
“They just…” Jack continues, genuinely at a loss for words. His vocabulary feels woefully unequipped to relay the depth of anger he feels about the events of the lunch, “…Ignored her. They talked over her, didn’t ask her questions, hardly ever let her finish speaking when she did finally get a chance to speak, and threw jabs at her constantly. It was fucking awful.“
The background noise quiets over the phone, and Jack knows Robby’s moved to either the break room or an empty patient room.
“She fight back at all?”
“No. Just… grinned and beared it. It was fuckin’ unsettling, man. I’ve seen her yell back at rude patients, watched her stand her ground to EMT’s who think they know better. It was like she hollowed herself out to sit at that table.”
“Christ.”
“She flinched away from me. Afterwards, in the car, when I raised my voice on accident.”
“Fuck. Do you think—“
“I don’t know. Maybe when she was younger. They don’t live in state, so if they are, she’s safe.”
Jack scrubs a hand down his face. “God. I don’t know what to do, Robby. It doesn’t seem like she’s got… anybody. She didn’t even understand why I was upset. She doesn’t get why that would be upsetting.”
“She’s friends with Mel and Santos, right?”
“And Whitaker by extension, yeah. But those are recent friends. I’ve never heard her mention anybody from back home. No boyfriend or best friend or anything. She’s just been doing everything on her own.”
Jack can picture Robby nodding. “We’ve done our fair share of that.”
“Yeah, and look where that got us. I can’t just leave her here. Fuck, it was like watching someone kick a puppy, over and over.”
“That bad?”
“Yeah.”
The line goes silent for a bit, both men stewing on the subject at hand.
“She’s always had these habits. I thought they were just personality quirks, you know. I mean, we’re all fucked up, but watching it happen…”
“It’s different.”
“You could say that,” Jack sighs, “She soaks up praise like a fucking sponge. She looks surprised every time I do something nice for her. And she keeps trying to make me happy.”
“You lost me on that last one.”
“It doesn’t… She’s not doing it to make me happy, exactly. She just does everything she can to keep me from getting mad.”
“Is there a difference?”
“There is. Eager to please versus eager to appease.”
“Are you sure you want to get involved?”
“Bit late for that.”
“You could pull back.”
“Fuck no, I can’t. Then I’d be kicking the puppy.”
“She is a grown woman.”
“Who happens to look like a kicked puppy.”
He scrubs a hand down his face, groaning into the microphone.
“You finally realize how ridiculous you sound?”
Jack grunts. “I’m not giving you the satisfaction of answering that.”
The line crackles with the staticky sound of Robby chuckling. “That’s an answer in it of itself, and you know that.”
He lets the line go quiet again, briefly debating just hanging up.
“I don’t know, Robby. It’s just…”
“Worse than you expected?”
“Yeah.”
“Come on. You knew that was a possibility. Has it put you off, at all?”
“Fuck no.”
“Exactly. Now please, go to bed so I can get back to saving lives? Whitaker is covering for me and he’s only gone through two pairs of scrubs so far today. I’m not a betting man, but if I were, I’d bet money that he’s moved onto his third during this conversation.”
“I save lives too.”
“You won’t save any if you fall asleep on the drive over and die.”
“I would never fall asleep behind the wheel.”
“That’s what they all say.”
Jack really does hang up after that, plugging his phone in and rushing through everything he needs to do before bed.
But even as exhaustion pulls his body down into deep, dreamless sleep, he can’t stop thinking about that hollow look on your face. And he knows, even half-asleep, that he won’t be able to let it go.
—
The next night at work is weird, because nothing has changed, except now you know what the inside of Jack’s car looks like and how his voice sounded when he begged you to let him help.
It’s jarring, to say the least. Unsteadying and mildly world-rocking if you’re being honest.
But gossip travels fast within the walls of the PTMC, so by the time night shift is halfway over, you’re convinced you’ve heard every variation in existence of the same two questions:
“Did you and Jack go on a date yesterday?”
And:
“What’s Jack like on a date?”
The answer to the first question is complicated and embarrassing, so you don’t answer it or any of it’s variants. The answer to the second question is not complicated but it does, however, stir some very complicated feelings, so you refrain from answering that one too. You just try to refrain from thinking about or seeing him in general.
You’re not avoiding Jack, per se. Just keeping busy. With other stuff. That’s conveniently nowhere near him.
Ellis keeps shooting you entirely too knowing looks, Mckay, who’s pulling a double, pats your shoulder and tells you she’s there if you want to talk, Shen is absent as Jack said he would be, and Jack himself is acting like nothing happened and everything is normal and he’s never been to your apartment smelled your perfume.
(“…I like layering scents.”
“It’s nice. Suits you.”)
It’s all too much.
Hence the avoiding.
You try to curb your own ridiculousness for the sake of your patients, but it’s oddly difficult. You’ve always been amazing at compartmentalizing. If your family gave you any kind of skill, it’s the ability to shove your feelings in a box, and then shove that box in a corner of your mind you won’t access consciously until you end up on public transportation with your headphones. You should be more than capable of gathering up all the loose feelings labeled ‘For: Jack Abbot’ and tucking them all nice and neat in that little box and then shove it in a dark mental corner.
But you can’t. And along with the flurry of Jack Abbot causing a hurricane in your head, there’s a lesser storm that is the result of your family. More specifically, how they look to Jack.
All roads lead back to Rome. Or, in your case, to Jack.
You catch yourself during every spare moment or menial task that doesn’t require 100% of your brain power analyzing every interaction he had with them. Everything they said, everything they did, and how Jack would’ve taken it. And why. Because clearly, the act of dealing with them isn’t the problem. The ease and finesse in which he did so crosses that off the list. So it’s something else.
It’s how they treat you.
You understand, logically, that it would be upsetting, from his point of view. If you were in his place, you’d also probably be upset too.
But this feels different. Jack’s reaction is different. Jack is different.
It’s just never really been something that anyone should be upset over. Your family are who they are. Not great, but not truly bad either. You deal with them sparingly. You don’t even live in the same state anymore. It’s not a big deal.
“Why are you hiding from me in a supply closet?”
You whirl around, a box of gloves clutched in your hands.
“I’m not hiding from you.”
Jack crosses his arms and leans against the doorway. “This is the third time you’ve been here in two hours.”
“So? I just want to be… on top of things. I’m a productive person.”
“You are,” He amends, “But all of your productivity tonight has been pretty strictly nowhere near me. Funny how that works.”
You sigh, placing the gloves back on the rack. “Things are just… weird, okay? I don’t know how you’re being so normal about all this?”
Your fingers wander and find a loose piece of skin on the edge of your cuticle, and you begin absent-mindedly picking at it.
You can’t exactly disagree with him, right here, in the supply closet at the hospital. But you can’t quite bring yourself to agree either– because whether he acknowledges it or not, things have changed. Seeing him outside the hospital, perfectly placating your family into one of the most peaceful get-togethers you’ve had in years isn't just nothing.
It’s everything. And you, for one, can’t just pretend that it didn’t happen.
“Hey,” He calls your name softly, “What’s on your mind? What’s bugging you?”
“Nothing.”
He snorts, pushing off the doorframe and shutting the door behind him, so it’s just the two of you alone. “Liar.”
He doesn’t probe any further, just leans against the now closed door with his hands in his pockets, eyes flitting over you like they’re looking for an answer. An answer you’re too hesitant to give.
“I’m just worried.”
“You? Worried? No.”
You cut him a glare, “There’s a very real chance that this could all go horribly awry, you know.”
“Sure,” Jack dips his head, “But that’s not what you’re really worried about.”
“And how do you know that?”
“Because that doesn’t address the fact that you’re avoiding me.”
You sigh, scrubbing a hand across your face.
“Why do you care?”
The question that’s been nagging at you since the beginning. The little itch in the back of your mind that you just can’t seem to get rid of. The puzzle you can’t figure out; the tune you can’t place.
You’re a logic driven person. You like knowing how things works– why they work. Why things do the things they do.
You like having the why. Having the why makes the world make sense.
Nothing about Jack Abbot makes sense.
“Why do I care about what?”
“This,” You gesture vaguely to the air, “Me. I don’t buy that you just didn’t have anything better to do or whatever it was you said. People don’t just… do that. You’re really ruining your life for an entire week for what? So I'm a little less uncomfortable? Me? At the end of the day, we’re just coworkers. I know how important your down time is for you, so I just don’t get why you’re so okay with being miserable just for my sake. I’m not that important. These stupid lunches aren’t that important.”
It’s a stupid confession. Much too vulnerable for a supply closet and a man you’re harboring feelings for.
He doesn’t respond right away. Hums, stares at his shoes for a bit. Re-adjusts so his prosthetic isn’t taking so much weight.
“You are important. You’re important to me, to this hospital, to your patients. And for the record, I am not ‘ruining my week.’ If it was that easy for my week to be ruined, I never would have become a doctor, let alone joined the military.”
“But why?”
“Jesus, you watched a lot of the science channel growing up, didn’t you?”
You snort. “Guilty as charged.”
Now it’s his turn to sigh.
“You… seem to have this misguided belief that caring is reciprocal in nature.”
You frown. “It is.”
“It isn’t. At least it shouldn’t be, but I don’t think anyone ever told you that.”
You scoff. “So this is about my family.”
He shrugs. “Amongst other things.”
“They’re not that bad.”
“They are.”
“Other people have it worse.”
“It’s not a competition.”
You resist the urge to throw your hands in the air. “Why is this such a big deal to you?”
“Because it’s a big deal to you.”
The air gets quiet and tense. Like the supply closet and all the medical supplies in it are holding their breath. If they were alive, if they were holding their breath, you’re convinced they’d all be looking at you.
It’s Jack who speaks first though.
“I can see it. You do everything yourself, get back up even when it’s hard. You look out for other people more than you look out for yourself. You’re selfless and kind and I don’t think very many people give that back to you.”
A reflexive smile pulls at your lips, a habit you never quite managed to kick after years of people telling you ‘smile, look grateful, stop looking so upset, there’s nothing to cry about.’ It feels awkward and clunky on your mouth but you don’t know what else to do. There’s no pre-written protocol for something like this.
“I still don’t really get it.” You murmur, more to yourself than to Jack.
Jack sends you a light grin. “We’ll work on it.”
“We will?”
“Sure,” He shrugs, “Already started anyways.”
“If you’re sure.”
“I’m sure,” He opens the door, “Now get back out there. And bring the gloves too.”
You roll your eyes but comply, snagging the box off the shelf where you’d left it and following him out.
The rest of your shift passes much smoother than before, even with the routine influx of patients as the time inches closer to morning. Jack doesn’t hover, but doesn’t pull the disappearing act that you (totally fairly) pulled on him either. He truly seems unfazed. Like it really, actually doesn’t bother him.
Well. Correction. It does bother him, but not because it’s something he’s doing for you, the part that bothers him (apparently) is how all of this affects you. All this caring makes you feel like a deer in the headlights.
You recall something he said that night. Something that had made you shiver– something that hit the nail right on the head.
“Hey, listen to me. You cannot fix what I am upset about. It is not your job. My mood is not your responsibility.”
He always seems to know exactly what to say to you. How to act, what to do, what specific worry you’re feeling and the best course of action to soothe it. It’s great but it’s also difficult, because there’s a part of you that wants to let him keep doing it, but then there’s the part of you that bristles every time and wants to snap that you’re completely capable of doing things yourself.
That probably wouldn’t even work. He’d just say something infuriating and sexy, like “I know, but I want to do this for you.”
He would. He totally would.
The thought is equal parts haunting and reassuring.
(And maybe, also, a little, kind of really sweet?)
–
The next two lunches go great. Jack is still freakishly incredible at charming your family. And, with his help, you actually manage to hold a (mostly) civil conversation with your parents for the first time in… years.
The lunches are fine, but the part you’ve started looking forward to is the before and after. Before, Jack comes to pick you up, and sometimes he comes early and helps prepare (which mostly involves him either talking you off the ledge, pouring a shot or two, or assuring you that your makeup and outfit look great. Not fine, great) or just to hang out. The hanging out part is nice, because he never comes with any sort of expectation. He’ll sit on your couch and scroll through his phone and entertain all the inane chatter you like to get out of your system beforehand but never had an outlet for before.
The after is even more fun. You run through the highlights of the night and hate on all the annoying things your family said to you. This usually also involves stopping somewhere for food (only for you, Jack’s never hungry because he eats t=at the restaurants but you’re never allowed to order anything that isn’t a salad) and then the two fo you fight over who pays. You always insist since you’re the only one actually eating any of the food, but then Jack usually takes your card, puts it in his pocket, and uses his own.
It’s as frustrating as it is hot.
But for the most part, the lunches and your shifts at work have actually been pretty good– as good as night shifts in a trauma center can be, anyway. Jack’s presence is… steadying, even when he’s not physically there. He’s always present in some way– whether it’s little reminders he leaves at your favorite spot for charting (he only uses blue sticky notes) or a real lunch left for you in the breakroom fridge (you weren’t previously aware he actually knew how to cook, or that he knew how picky you are when it comes to what you’ll actually eat for lunch and how often you get too busy to properly make something.) Sometimes he’s there in your head; in little things he’s told or taught you that you remember in the moment.
It’s nice. To have someone be around. Someone you can relax with, joke with– someone who hasn’t looked down on you for the the way you turned out.
You were pretty ready to declare smooth sailing ahead, but then on the third lunch your mother shows up and is decidedly not in a good mood and the seas turn choppy and the boat smashes into the rocks below.
At least, two peach bellinis in, that’s what it feels like.
“Honestly,” Your mother puffs, “I don’t understand why making some simple appetizers could take so long. This is why I hate going to restaurants during lunch hours, the staff just gets so lazy. The menu is always better at dinner anyways.”
You ignore the thinly veiled dig and instead choose to quietly drain the rest of your third peach bellini. They taste like juice and take a much needed edge (or two) of the evening. Lunch. What-fucking-ever.
Jack, ever aware of the best way to survive these functions (somehow) whilst keeping his sanity, remains silent as your mom huffs and puffs, seeming to understand that trying to placate her when she gets in these moods is a fruitless endeavor that only leads to your mom getting more upset and everyone else more annoyed.
You, made slightly optimistic by the wonderful powers of alcohol, attempt to put her in a better mood.
“I have the next three days off, mom. We’ll be able to do dinners instead.”
Your mother, however, only scoffs. “That’s no good to anyone now. We’ve already spent half this week dealing with poor restaurant service. I mean, no respectable job would have such a ridiculous schedule."
“I’m a doctor, mom. It doesn’t get more respectable than that.”
Jack nudges your leg with his, either a silent laugh, show of support, or quiet question of your sanity. Maybe all three.
Another bellini appears in front of you, this one heavier on the alcohol than the last. Your server is getting a giant tip when this is all over.
“You work in the emergency department, dear. That’s hardly stable, and stable is respectable,” Jack clears his throat, and your mother at least has the manners to look mildly sheepish, “No offense, Jack.”
He smiles thinly. “None taken.”
Conversation from there is stilted at best with even your brothers tip-toeing around your mother. No one wants to be the subject of a nitpicking lecture, even when the version she gives them is a slap on the wrist compared to what you endure.
So you keep drinking your bellini’s and they keep coming. After your fourth, you think you should maybe slow down a little, but then your dad starts grilling Jack about his life (again) and you decide that alcohol is, in fact, necessary.
“Have you ever been in a serious relationship before, Jack?”
That one almost makes you ask the server for a shot of vodka, straight. That’s a question you ask a nineteen year-old pimple-faced boy, not a fucking fifty year old man.
“I have, yes. But, like most things in life, they were learning experiences. I’ve moved on.”
Your dad snorts, then gestures to you. “You could teach her a thing or two about moving on.”
Your blood runs cold.
Jack sets his glass down. “And what do you mean by that?”
It’s your mother who answers. Because one vulture circling your soon-to-be carcass wasn’t enough.
“I’m surprised she hasn’t told you. It was all she ever talked about for years. She’s had exactly one boyfriend before you– what was his name honey?”
“Christopher,” You answer hollowly, stomach churning.
Your dad snaps his fingers. “That’s it. It took ages for her to get her first boyfriend. We were fairly convinced it would never happen, but then one day she came home with Christopher. Whole family wanted to throw a party– finally found someone to put up with all that attitude!”
Your family laughs, but Jack doesn’t.
“Where’s the funny part, in all this?”
Your mother clears her throat, just a tad awkward. “When she broke up with him it was awful. She refused to leave her room for works, cried all the time. Honestly, I would have understood if he had broken up with her, but it was all her decision.”
Your dad nods in agreement. “We had to have a sit-down conversation with her about decisions and consequences before she finally stopped crying and hiding in her room. Christopher was such a nice boy, we hated to see him go.”
Jack opens his mouth, poised to fire something back and defend you, but you beat him to the punch.
“He cheated on me with my best friend.”
At that, your mother frowns. “That’s not what Christopher said. You were in your teen angst era, remember? Always picking fights? He told your brother that you were so distant with him he didn’t know you were still together.”
“I wasn’t distant, I was really busy. I was studying for the MCAT. He knew that. He knew how important medical school was to me.”
Your brother rolls his eyes. “Med school was all you talked about. It’s not like you were putting out.”
Your mother snaps her fingers once. “That is inappropriate talk for public. You know better.”
“Come on, mom. It’s true. Everyone knows–”
“Sorry to interrupt,” Jack says, not at all sounding sorry, “But the hospital just texted. There’s an emergency, and we’re needed, so we have to go.”
Jack does not wait for your mother or father to excuse him. He just stands, offering you his hand. It turns out that you need it, because there is, apparently, such a thing as too many peach bellinis. Your mom sends you a pointed glare as you stumble once, after which you make a concerted effort to look more sober.
Neither you nor Jack bother saying proper goodbyes. Once he grabs your jacket and purse (and your vision stops swimming so much and you’re sure you can walk in a convincing approximation of a straight line) you’re both gone. You pass your server on the way out, who is slipped a very generous cash tip for the excellent bellini service.
By the time you get to the car, you realize that you’re about to have to save patient lives and you are very, extremely, drunk. There is no way you are capable of doing any life-saving at the moment.
“Jack,” You mumble, fumbling with your seatbelt, “I think I’m too drunk to go in. Did they say how serious the emergency was? Can I just get a banana bag?”
“There is no emergency,” He says calmly, batting your hands away and buckling you in properly, “I made it up. I figured you’d be okay with ducking out of there.”
“Oh. That was nice of you.”
He clicks you in and gives you a wry grin. “Told you I would handle things.”
You nod, the movement exaggerated and lopsided. “I hate it when they bring up Christpher. They always take his side. Like, is there ever a situation where it’s okay to cheat on a girl with her best friend? I was studying for the MCAT. I didn’t even wallow or break up with him when I found out. I waited until after I took the exam so I didn’t fuck up my score.”
“That’s my girl.”
“Christopher was an asshole. He was a real dickhead. The whole situation sucked. I lost the only two people who I thought cared about me at the same time. My family acted like I was the fucking anti-christ for being upset about it, too. It was fucking terrible. I’m so glad I don’t live with them anymore. I mean, I still love them, and I care about them, cause they’re my family, but everything is just so much easier when they’re not around.”
“You’re allowed to hate them, you know.”
“I know,” You say, fiddling with a hangnail. “I know I probably should.”
You sigh, tilting your head back against the headrest. “I always keep holding out hope, you know? That one day they’ll apologize, figure their shit out, care about me in a way that matters. I know it’s stupid.”
“It’s not stupid.”
You frown. “It’s not? It kinda seems stupid. You’d think by now I would know better.”
“No,” Jack eases the car out of the parking space, “We’re biologically wired to love our families. It’s the reason why they can fuck you up so bad. Your brain can’t compute why the people who are supposed to love you above all else just… don’t. Not in any of the right ways.”
You blow air through your lips. “I think my parents fucked me up. I was so happy when I matched into the Pitt, because it was so far away. But then I got out here it just kind of hit me, all at once, that I was alone. My best friend was gone, my ex boyfriend sucked, and I was too busy in med school taking care of myself and my family to make any friends.”
Shit, that sounds so whiny. “But it turns out it wasn’t so bad. Now I've got Mell, and Santos, and I’m pretty sure I’m friends with Shen too. Mckay is nice too. I like her. She’s cool.”
Jack huffs something that could be a laugh, and you turn to study him; the angles of his face awash in the glow of the red light you’re currently stopped at. From here, you can see the tiny bits of tension he carries in his face— a slight pinch in his brow, the tiniest downturn of his lips. It’s the only evidence that he’s not as unaffected by your family as he pretends to be.
Then the light turns green, and his face isn’t illuminated the same.
“And what about me?”
Oh. Well. That’s a loaded question.
The alcohol emboldens you to answer honestly. “I don’t know what to think about you.”
“Oh really?”
“Mmm. Nope.”
“How come?”
"You're so–” You gesture vaguely, “Confusing. I can’t figure you out. For a while there, I was pretty sure you hated me, but then you offered to help me with this and you keep saying you care so I think I’m wrong.”
“You think you’re wrong?”
“Still can’t figure you out.”
“And how can I show you that I mean it?”
That’s. Hmm.
“I don’t know. I think what you’re doing is working,” You pause, debating the pros and cons of continuing to just say whatever the fuck you want before deciding you’re too tired to care, “It helps that you’re really hot.”
His lips twitch. “Oh, does it now?”
“Mhm. You’ve got this whole… capable thing about you. It’s hot. Competency is in.”
“If you say so.”
“I do say so. I feel like if I had a problem I could call you or something and you would fix it. You’re so…”
“Competent?”
“That’s the word.”
If he’s at all irritated, annoyed, or otherwise put off by your stupid rambling, he didn’t show it.
“You should call me whenever you have a problem. Chances are, I can fix it.”
“Are you like Bob the Builder?”
“I’m a doctor, so no.”
“You’re kind of like Bob the Builder.”
“Whatever you say,” He pauses at an empty intersection before continuing on, “Before I start heading towards your place, do you want to stop by mine? You didn’t even get to eat your salad, and I have leftovers. You can say no.”
“Are you gonna be mad at me if I say no?”
“No.”
‘Then yes.”
“You sure? I wasn’t lying.”
“I know. But I like your cooking.”
You spend the drive to Jack’s continuing to ramble about nothing and everything, to which he entertains with a seemingly endless amount of patience. The only time he interrupts is to hand you a bottle of Gatorade he procured from his back seat. Apparently, he bought a few to keep in his car after the first lunch. “For any alcohol excursions.”
It’s freaky how prepared he is for every situation.
When you arrive, he unbuckles your seatbelt for you (unbuckling is just as difficult as buckling when you’ve had an unknown amount of peach bellinis) and helps you up the stairs to his apartment.
His gigantic apartment.
“Woah,” You mumble as you shuffle through the doorway, pulled along by your hand in Jacks, “I didn’t know they made apartments this size.”
“Its not that big.”
“I think, like, four of my apartments could fit in here. Your living room is the size of my entire place.”
You stumble once, heel catching on the little rug on the entry way, and he’s immediately motioning for you to sit on the little bench by the door and pats his thigh once. You clumsily raise your leg, barely managing to land your foot on the general area he gestures to. He pulls the first shoe off, then repeats with the second with an air of total calm. Like this is normal and he does this all the time for you. Like you regularly find yourself drunk in his apartment.
You decide to unpack the moment when you’re sober.
“One, it’s not that big, and two, that’s what you get for renting a studio apartment.”
“Like you could afford better when you were an intern.”
He snorts, leading you to his couch and gesturing for you to sit. “If you want to change clothes you can borrow some of mine.”
You chew on your lip. The outfits you choose to look nice for your mother are never exactly comfortable, and when else are you going to get the chance to privately live the scenario you fantasize about several times a week before falling asleep?
“Only if you don’t mind.”
“I wouldn't have offered if I wasn’t. Stay there.”
Jack’s only gone for a few minutes before he reappears with a dark grey sweatshirt and a pair of sweatpants in a slightly lighter shade. The sweatshirt is oversized and looks well worn, but the sweatpants are suspiciously new, close to your size, and look eerily similar to a pair you changed into after a shift a few weeks ago.
He hands them to you. Neither of you mention the sweatpants. “You can change in the bathroom. Door locks from the inside. I’m gonna change too, and then I’ll heat up the food.”
Jack shows you the bathroom (you don’t bother unpacking why exactly he felt the need to tell you that the door locks and from the inside, that’s for when you’re significantly more drunk than you are now and when you’re not in his fancy-ass apartment.)
Because he’s a man and men take approximately three seconds to change, he’s already in the kitchen setting stuff on the counter by the time you emerge from the bathroom. His countertops are solid granite, because the apartment is clearly expensive and he’s a man. They’re an inky black color with tiny flecks that sparkle when the light hits them just so.
“What are you doing?” Jack asks when he turns from the fridge to find you tilting your head this way and that.
“Looking at the sparkles.”
“Oookay. Do you want me to heat up the vodka pasta or the chicken?”
“You made vodka pasta?”
He shrugs. “You said you liked it.”
You slide into a seat at the kitchen island, a flush creeping up your neck. “The pasta, please.”
Suddenly exhausted now that you’re in soft, comfortable clothes that smell like Jack, you decide to just rest your head on your arms for a bit. And close your eyes. But you’re not going to fall asleep. You’re not.
“Don’t fall asleep. You need to eat something first.”
“M’ not fallin’ asleep.”
“Mhm. Sure.”
With great effort, you blink your eyes open and watch Jack while he heats up the pasta and prepares something else. A salad maybe?
“What’re’you’ making?”
“Just a little salad. In case the pasta is too heavy for you.”
“Oh. How come?”
“Because I don’t want you to throw up.”
“I promise I won’t throw up on your furniture. I don’t usually throw up when I’m hungover.”
“You drink often?”
“No,” Your head lulls to the side, “I’m too busy. I’m actually not-so-secretly very boring. I don’t really like partying. I much prefer staying at home.”
“Thought you went to that thing with King and Santos?”
“Yeah, but that was ‘cause Trinity really wanted me to come and I felt bad and I didn’t want her to think I was a boring, uptight bitch.”
“I see.”
“Yeah. I kinda had fun, though. I wished you were there.”
“Really?”
“Yeah,” You sigh, probably a hint too dreamily, “Makes me feel better when you’re around.”
“I’ll keep that in mind.”
He slides a little bowl with a light salad in it to you across the counter, and it's perfectly refreshing. Not at all heavy like the pasta ends up being.
“Sorry I couldn’t finish it,” You say, forcing down a yawn and resisting the urge to burrow into your arms and go to sleep right there, “I feel bad that you went through the trouble of making it and heating it up.”
“It wasn’t that much effort. Besides, now you can just eat it for lunch tomorrow instead. I’ll send it home with you.”
“Mhm.” You hum, slowly inching your arms forward and down onto the counter, your head quickly following suit.
Jack chuckles, and you can hear the light step of his feet as he rounds the corner of the island and nudges you in the arm.
“Come on, sweetheart. You wanna get home to bed, don’t you?”
“No,” You shake your head, “I wanna sleep right here. It’s comfortable.”
“It won’t be when you wake up.”
You whine, curling away from him.
He just puffs another little laugh. “You can either sleep in your bed, or my bed. You can’t sleep on the kitchen island.”
“Why not?” You finally lift your head, “And why is your bed an option?”
“One,” He lifts up one finger in front of your face and slowly drags it back and forth, “Because the kitchen island is not a bed. Two, I’m not letting you sleep on the couch.”
“Why? Is your couch uncomfortable?”
“No,” He says, shuffling back over to where the leftovers are and tucking all the food away in the proper places, “It’s just not right to make a woman sleep on the couch.”
“I like sleeping on couches.”
He shoots you a look over his shoulder, “I’m sure you do. But you’re still a little drunk, and my bed is closer to the bathroom than the couch is.”
You prop your head on your hand. “Who said I’m even staying here tonight?”
Jack closes the fridge. “Do you want to? Because I don’t care either way. We both have tomorrow off.”
“It’d be weird to wake up here.”
“Why?”
“Because you’re my boss.”
“And I’m faking being your boyfriend so your parents get off your back. Pretty sure we’re past coworkers.”
“What would we even do in the morning?”
“Sleep.”
“I don’t want to kick you out of your bed. I’ll sleep on the couch.”
“You’re my guest–”
“You’re already doing so much for me,” You blurt, stomach clenching, “I– You know me. I can only handle so much. Let me do this one thing? Please?”
Jack glowers for a bit, then sighs.
“Only because you asked nicely and I believe in rewarding good behavior. And because I know my couch isn’t uncomfortable. I’ll help you make it up.”
Jack’s apartment is surprisingly tidy for the fact that a man lives in it (Christopher’s room at his parent’s house always looked like shit) and he pulls down a couple options for bedding. You go with the plain black sheet and its matching thick, fluffy comforter. He insists on making up the couch himself (despite the fact that the alcohol has mostly worn off by now) and even sets up a glass of water, a liquid IV packet, and a bucket– “Just in case those bellini’s don’t love you back.”
The sight of it all is almost too much. It’s just so much care. All of it. The fact that he’s helping out with you and your disaster of a family, the way that despite the horribleness of it all he hasn’t judged you at all for how you deal with them. He refuses to let you drive yourself, always pays for every lunch for your entire family and the little snacks you get afterwards. Listens to you rant and he makes you food and gets you blankets and–
“You okay there?”
“Mhm,” You hum, “Just thinkin’.”
He leaves you be for a moment, busies himself with fixing your pillows and and tugging the comforter into its proper place.
Before you can talk yourself out of it, you turn, throwing your arms around Jack’s middle and burying your face in his chest.
“Thank you,” You say, voice muffled by the fabric, “For doing all of this. Thank you for looking out for me.”
Jack is still for a second, just long enough for you to second guess initiating physical contact –a line you were previously too scared to cross– but then his hands come up and it's so, immediately, remarkably over. Because you’re never ever going to draw that line again. You can never go back to your life without having this. Without having him.
Jack’s hands are big and deliciously warm as they slide up, around your waist, lingering to rub a few circles on the mid of your back before moving on. One arm stays, tightening around your waist and drawing you closer while his other glides further up, up, up, his callused palms sliding over the knob at the very base of your neck before his hand settles around your nape, fingers just barely brushing the edge of your hairline.
You barely manage to suppress a whine at how warm and incredible it feels to be fully enveloped by him. You never want him to let go. Goosebumps erupt everywhere he touches, little sparks of electricity lingering under your skin in his wake.
“I will always,” He presses the lightest of kisses to your temple, just a feathering of his lips, “Look out for you, baby. I’m always gonna be right here.”
His arms tighten around you, drawing you in— closer, closer, closer. Wrapped up in everything that is Jack you can’t help but sag, going completely boneless in his grip and allowing yourself to just bask in him.
“You smell good.” You mumble into his shirt, completely lost in the moment.
“Do I?”
“Yeah. Good. Like man.”
He chuckles, the sound vibrating pleasantly against your cheek. “Thank you sweetheart.”
“Why do you call me sweetheart?”
“Because you’re a sweetheart.”
“I am?”
“Don’t play dumb now,” He pulls back a little, just enough to get a good look at you, fingers curling in the fine hair at your nape and tugging down, angling your chin up so you’re forced to look at him, “You know you are.”
You shrug, eyes darting to the side, your cheeks flushing, “I don’t know. I was just making sure.”
“Mhm.” He hums, tone almost mocking, fingers tightening around your hair just before the precipice of pain.
You stay like that for a few moments of charged silence. Jack’s eyes shamelessly rove over the planes of your face, mapping it out in his mind. He keeps his grip on your hair, not completely forcing eye contact but keeping your head firmly in place.
It’s possessive. Bold. Probably too intimate for two people who (supposedly) are not actually dating
And you love it.
Jack only lets his hand (and your head) drop when your jaw opens in a splitting yawn.
“Okay,” He huffs, taking a step back, “Time for bed. Get going.”
Embarrassment is the only thing keeping you from whining at the loss of contact and impending reality of sleeping on the couch alone. But you made your bed (figuratively) so now you have to lie in it.
The couch does look comfortable. Especially since Jack put all the blankets together.
He waits until you’ve crawled under the comforter to bid you goodnight, followed by a parting reminder to “Wake him up if you start aspirating on vomit.” It’s a very Jack thing to say.
You’re out almost the second Jack turns the lights off. You fall into deep, blissful sleep, dreaming of that final moment in the living room, your eyes boring into each other.
Except in the dream, you tilt your head up those last few inches, and kiss your fake boyfriend as hard as you can.
–
Generally, the annual lecture event ends with a massive blow out argument. Something dramatic and filled with expletives, after which your mother will refuse to answer any texts or calls you send before finally telling you that’s she’s sorry if (always if) something she said offended you, but talking to you is just so hard sometimes so she doesn’t want to unless you’re ready to be more civil. By the time the two of you are on neutral terms again, it’s time for the next annual lunch circuit.
You’re a mess of nerves in the hours before the last one. Like usual, your mom requested that the last dinner be held at your place. “So it can feel like a real family dinner.” While you know that there isn’t any saying no to your mother, you also know that there is no way you’re cramming your entire family in your tiny ass studio apartment. It happened once. It will not happen again.
You originally asked Jack during a last minute shift you both got called in to cover if he would help you move some of the furniture at your place to accommodate them, and then he’d gotten this incredulous look on his face and then told you to tell your mom that you’re having dinner at his place.
“Jack,” You’d gaped at him, “It’s fine. My apartment isn’t that small, and you don’t have to help move the furniture if you don’t want to. I can ask Dennis to give me a hand instead. I really don’t think you want to host my family.”
“Sweetheart, it’s just logic. You’ve seen my place.”
“Okay. No need to rub it in.”
He’d just rolled his eyes and pinned you with a firm look. “Come on. You know this is the best option. If your mom throws a fit, tell her I insisted and give her my number.”
“Do you have a death wish?” You hiss, “That’s asking for torture.”
Jack had just shrugged. “Would having it at my place be easier for you?”
“...Yes?”
“Then we’ll do it there. You’re off in a bit, right?”
You’d nodded.
He fishes something small and shiny out of his pocket and tosses it to you. “That’s my spare key. I’ll be here later than you, so just let yourself in if you want to get there earlier to start setting up. I’ll be home soon.”
Robby shouted his name soon after and Jack was whisked away, leaving you standing in the middle of the ED, holding the fucking spare key to his apartment, gaping like a fish.
The line between real and fake has become so blurred you’re not sure if it ever was there to begin with.
He’s started calling you sweetheart more and more often– sometimes when no one's around. No familial audience to be persuaded into the romantic lie you’re selling. Is it still a lie if it doesn’t feel like one anymore?
The question and accompanying feeling follows you all day. All throughout your harried dinner preparation. Even now, with a solid hour until your family is supposed to start showing up, you can’t help but pace the length of Jack’s kitchen, heeled feet clicking on his floor. Jack himself is similarly dressed up, wearing a pair of dark jeans (“I’m not wearing slacks in my own home, and I’m not old enough to start wearing khakis with everything.”) and a black button down shirt with the first two buttons undone and the sleeves rolled up to his forearms. He makes a very nice view and under other circumstances you might take the opportunity to climb him like a tree. But alas. Anxiety.
“Take your shoes off if you’re going to pace. You’re gonna give yourself blisters.”
You ignore him, chewing on an already stinging cuticle.
“Things have been pretty good this far, right? Do you think she’s just waiting until the very end to bring up some secret thing that she’s upset about?”
Jack begins preparing the wine –your mother only likes red– for decanting. “I think if your mother were that upset about something she wouldn’t be able to hide it.”
“True. But what if?”
“I’m not going to help you spiral.”
“Why not?” You whine.
He looks at you with a heavy glare and points to the shoe tray at the door. “Shoes. Off. You can put them back on when they get here.”
You grumble under your breath the entire way but comply. Only because your feet were starting to hurt.
When your family finally does arrive, it ends up being annoyingly anti-climactic. You spend the entire time on the edge of your seat (literally and figuratively) waiting for the other shoe to drop. Waiting for conversation to turn sour, arguments to erupt, someone to choke on a piece of lettuce and die despite professional intervention.
But the argument never starts, conversation remains what it usually is and becomes no worse (or better, unfortunately) and no one passes away due to unevenly chopped vegetables.
The torture is over fairly quickly. Most everyone’s flight back home leaves early the next morning and your dad is paranoid about flight times.
Pretty soon it’s all just… over. They leave, your mother bickering with your father on the way out about something that probably doesn’t matter, and then it’s just you and Jack and the entire scheme is just done. Finished. Just like that.
There won't be anymore knee's brushing under the table, no more shared glances and pecks to the cheek when you make a joke that actually lands. No more excuses just to sit and watch him under the guise of playing the adoring girlfriend. No more late night milkshakes.
You'll just go back to being coworkers-- People who pretend not to know each other intimately. Jack probably won't struggle with it. But to you, right now, the idea of just not having him anymore seems like a another wound, right over top all the others.
You don't want him to become another person who used to know you.
You’ve been staring at the closed door for upwards of five full minutes, clenching and unclenching your fists when Jack comes up next to you. He hands you the same clothes you wore the last time you were there and jerks his head in the direction of the bathroom.
“Why don’t you go and change, huh?”
Your lip wobbles a bit as you answer. “But I want to help you clean up.”
“You can,” He soothes, “After you change.”
“But–”
“Hey,” He interrupts, “No. You’ve been stuck in those clothes for hours. Go change. I’ll wait for you.”
Jack keeps his word. He’s leaned up against the kitchen island when you emerge, rubbing at your –now bare, having had the foresight to bring makeup wipes with you– face.
He looks up when the door opens. “Better?”
“Yeah. Thanks.”
He just hums, heading back over to the kitchen table, stacking plates and cutlery. You follow in silence, and he thankfully doesn’t push for conversation.
Cleaning up doesn’t take long enough. Jack has a fancy dishwasher (and probably doesn’t want to stay standing any more than he has to this late in the day) and there aren’t any leftovers to pack up. Your brothers are bottomless pits when it comes to free food.
It can’t just be over like this. It can't.
When everything is finished and there isn't anything left to do, Jack wordlessly leads you to the couch and puts something quiet and calm on the TV. The white noise washes over you as you attempt to get comfortable, but the knowledge that it's all over proves to be an itch under your skin that you just can't seem to squash.
“So,” You say after the two of you are seated on opposite ends of the couch, “That’s it then.”
“So it is.”
“Guess I owe you big time, huh?”
“I’ve already told you I don’t care about that.”
“Right,” You look down at your lap, “Yeah. Sorry.”
You lapse into silence.
Jack sighs. “Sweetheart–”
“Was it fake to you?” You blurt, jiggling your knee, still staring at your lap, “Were you– did you mean it?”
It never felt fake. It never felt like pretending.
It felt real.
It felt like, for the first time in your life, things could be easy.
Maybe easy isn't the right word. But it life sure as hell didn't feel as hard.
When you look up, uncomfortable in his silence and hoping there’s answers in his face, but instead of finding something like disappointment or irritation, he’s grinning.
“What do you think?”
“I don’t know.”
He dips his head once. “Yes you do. You’re a smart girl, I think you can figure it out.”
Your fingers are curled around the hem of his sweatshirt, white-knuckling the fabric as if to stabilize yourself. Like you’re liable to somehow float away if you don’t dig your heels into the couch and hold on tight.
“What if I’m wrong?”
“You won’t be.”
A scoff escapes your lips, “You can’t know for sure.”
He taps his pointer finger on his leg in an unhurried rhythm.
“You do.”
Your stomach is rolling in a combination of leftover anxiety from the dinner that went better than it was supposed to and the weight of Jack’s gaze on you.
“I think…” You pause, worry threatening to overwhelm you, and take a deep breath before continuing, “I think you might like me.”
“You think,” He drawls, “I might.”
“I don’t want to be wrong!” You cry.
Jack huffs, throwing his head back in a good-natured sigh.
“Come here.”
You scoot further down the couch, sitting criss-cross right in front of him. This is not going the way you thought it would. You were almost certain you’d walk away shamed and embarrassed, forced to fake your death and flee the country out of the sheer humiliation of thinking your boss would actually have a crush on you.
Jack does love to prove you wrong.
“Soo,” You start, still hesitant, “You do like me.”
Jack props his head on his hand, his expression something you’re starting to recognize as fond. “Yes.”
“More than a little?”
“Yes.”
“And you weren’t faking anything. You were serious about the— You know.”
“Use your words.”
“The flirting.” You clarify, ears burning.
“All correct,” He nods, “Though I would have said it differently.”
You frown. “And how would you have put it?”
“I would have said,” He reaches out, snagging your arm and tugging until you fall down onto his chest with a little oof, “That you have a hard time believing things that are good, so I had to audition for my role. Like old-fashioned courting.”
You want to be offended, but unfortunately, it did work.
You frown.
Wait.
“Have you known I liked you this whole time?”
Jack snorts. “Overheard you talking to Whitaker about it during your second week.”
He’s known since the second week?
“Oh my god.”
“Don’t worry, I didn’t tell anyone. Except Robby. He’s been hoping you would figure it out for awhile now.”
“Oh my god.”
“I thought it was cute,” He smoothes a hand over your hair, “You were so much more nervous back then. You’ve come a long way.”
You shift uncomfortably at the praise, but Jack’s having none of it. He wraps his arms around you, holding you in place.
“Can you take a compliment?”
“No.”
He re-positions under you, getting more comfortable. “We’ll try again later.”
“Am I– Can I stay here tonight then?”
“Of course,” he murmurs, “My one condition is that you’re not sleeping on the couch.”
“Fine,” You sigh, long and drawn out, “I suppose we can share.”
“How kind of you to share my bed with me.”
“I have been told I’m kind.”
You both smile, and everything just feels so right and so perfect that you can't help but lean up, clearing the last few inches, and pressing a hesitant, gentle kiss to his lips.
It’s just like your dream.
Only this time, it’s real. And Jack is kissing you back.
In all the years Titus had been alive, no woman had ever captured his attention like you did. Titus could not explain it, he just knew, from the second he first met you, he needed you like air.
And he'd move heaven and hell if necessary to get you.
Not his father, not yours, not the Lawyer, Mr Le Bail or his demons he had watching over you could ever stop him.
Chapter 7 - The Deal
Masterlist | previous chapter| next chapter
Words: 8,5k
Content: Older Man/Younger Woman (Titus is 50, Reader in her early twenties but it's only mentioned in passing), Blood and Gore, Brutal Murder, Torture, Possessive Behaviour, Stalking, Slightly Dubious Consent, Eventual Smut, Obsessive Titus Danforth, Sexually Inexperienced Titus Danforth, Virgin!Reader, Agoraphobic Reader, Size Difference, Size Kink, Blood Kink, Dacryphilia
No use of y/n!
Read on Ao3 or below the cut:
The media had been positively frothing at their mouths since the perpetually single heir of the Danforth empire was seen with a mysterious, gorgeous young woman at the Breeders’ Cup Classic.
Titus Danforth was never seen with a woman who was not his twin at his side.
None of the so-called experts of high society life knew who you were, but it took nothing more than a little digging to find out, and if they’d been greedy for a story before, they were absolutely mad for one after.
Titus Danforth and the recluse Convington child.
It was a headline seemingly created for all those soppy romantics who clung to celebrity drama and gossip to forget about their own sad little lives - not that Titus had any particular problem with it when that attention was directed at him, and especially not if that public hunger and swooning was going to get him what he wanted.
You.
You found the media circus, intimidating as it was, rather amusing. And incomprehensible.
“They don’t even know us.” You hummed one evening while on the phone with Titus.
“They want to be us.” Titus replied, leaning back in his leather swivel chair in his office. The room was only illuminated by the fireplace and a single lamp on his desk. The smoke from his cigar hung thick in the air all around him. “But they can never be, so by fawning over us like demented lemmings they feel as close to their wish as they can ever possibly be. And it lets them escape from their mediocre, insignificant lives for a while. Does it matter either way, darlin’?”
“Daddy has been fuming.” Titus could practically hear the wicked grin curling around your lips. “He hates that they took that picture of us at the races.”
“But it’s such a pretty picture.” Titus glanced at the picture frame on his desk, right next to the lamp. He found the photographer who took the picture and managed to get a copy by tossing some cash at the man.
You did look absolutely delicious in your flowy dress, standing on your tiptoes on the race track to adjust the lapels of his jacket, smiling up at him with that delectable nervous expression you always wore outside your home.
The tabloids wasted no time once they realised there was a young woman from one of the world’s most influential families they had not reported on before. Titus saw you everywhere he went. Every magazine, gossip rag and podcast dedicated to the rich and famous was retelling the same few facts some rather ambitious journalists had dragged to the surface about you.
Pictures taken a long time ago and dug out again, blown up to show the slivers of you they caught in the background between other people. You at your oldest brother’s wedding, at a fundraiser when you were thirteen, hiding in the background while your father sat in the estate’s garden recording a speech for some charitable effort while the world was on lockdown.
The media had told every story possible about your brothers so many times, not even the most hungry-for-scandal reader could still be bothered to read about it. Who cared about that time Caspian was seen vomiting outside some filthy strip club? Forgotten was Sebastian setting fire to the family yacht while coked out of his mind, and even little Darius - the youngest of your six brothers - fucking his boyfriend on the lawn in front of his pretentious, prestigious boarding school, just to be found by the headmaster who promptly, at the sight of two teenage boys, one of whom has his cock balls deep in the other’s ass, had a heartattack and died.
It seemed almost impossible that the most interesting thing about you the media had to report about was the fact that you were a bit of a shut-in and currently working towards a degree in Mythology and Occultism through an online university.
Titus knew several, much more interesting things about you, starting with the way your tits fit perfectly into his hands and ending with the delicious sight of you covered in blood from head to toe.
Some more conservative, rich, shrivelled prunes took offence to your aspired degree, until Chester reminded them that your field of study fell under Anthropology and Religious Studies and sought nothing more than to preserve human heritage - something they had all taken up the cause of, funding several foundations keeping museums and research afloat, all tax-deductible, of course.
Titus didn’t care what anyone said. You were a little… bizarre, but he liked that about you.
At least you weren’t boring like the rest of the upper crust.
After a couple of weeks of silence from Titus - ordered by Chester, who was visibly enjoying all this, like a puppetmaster watching those attached to his strings jump and twirl at his every behest - Titus finally showed his face in public again, appearing at a high-profile fundraiser. More journalists and paparazzi than ever gathered outside the heritage building chosen as today’s location. Or perhaps the fundraiser was about collecting money for that building? It wasn’t like Titus cared either way.
You weren’t at his side.
That was all that mattered to him, and if you had been… well Titus wouldn’t be paying attention to some ancient house, would he?
He stepped out of the car and onto the red carpet. The assault of flashing camera lights was instant. He was alone, representing the Danforth name and fortune on his own, Ursula off to who knew where and Chester indisposed, as the old man had put it.
Titus knew both were a front.
Chester didn’t want anyone taking the attention away from Titus tonight, not when Richard Covington would be here too. It was dangerous to put Titus and your father into the same room together, but Chester had made sure to threaten Titus to play nice, or he’d never get what he wanted.
Titus could be remarkably compliant when one dangled a carrot in front of his nose, and nobody knew this better than Chester.
It didn’t take long, posing for a few pictures here or there, some handshaking in front of the cameras, for the line of questioning Chester had wanted to start.
Titus' name was shouted by the greedy leeches hiding behind their cameras on the other side of the barrier keeping the common people away from the invited guests. They tried so hard to get his attention, to get him to look at them over the countless other faceless cameras disappearing in the darkness beyond the camera flashes. Titus stood on the red carpet, wearing a mildly amused, charmingly contemptuous expression, posture straight but relaxed, and let the camera lightning storm wash over him.
“Titus! Are you and Ms Convington an item?!”
“Where is your sweetheart tonight?”
“Will you see Ms Convington again?!”
The longer Titus didn’t react to the inquiries after you, the hungrier the masses got for it.
“Can we expect an official announcement soon, Titus?!”
“Ah,” Titus chuckled, adjusting the cuffs of his suit absent-mindedly. “I rather fear her father does not approve of me.” He looked not so subtly to the side, finding Richard standing just within earshot. Seeing the other man’s jaw tense almost made Titus break character. He forced his expression to remain sorrowful.
“We spoke just last night, but… of course I do hope I will see her again soon.”
He ignored the frenzy his words caused and, without answering further questions, flanked by his personal assistant and security guards, disappeared within the venue.
Crumbs.
Crumbs was all he had to feed the masses to keep this rather pathetic hysteria going.
Briefly, Titus wondered the effect it would have had on the reporter had you been at his side that night… seeing him step out before you just to turn around and help you exit the car, seeing you two together, his hand around his waist, your fingers curling into the pocket of his jacket… oh, he could practically hear the roaring, demented mania you’d cause.
Titus looked up from the papers scattered on his desk at the knock resounding through the empty, dim office.
“Enter.”
Chester seemed surprised, the aliens touching down on earth-kind of surprised, to see Titus working so late - or perhaps to see him working at all, who knew?
“This is a… pleasant change.” His father murmured, more to himself than Titus and oh how Titus loathed when Chester did that, talking about him as if he weren’t even in the room. He wasn’t the most interested in business, sure, but the tasks set for him always got done. Maybe not as swiftly as Chester sometimes wanted, but always before the deadline passed!
“What can I do for you, Dad?”
“Hi, Mr Danforth!” You piped up, your voice slightly distorted by the speakers of his laptop. Titus turned it so the monitor and camera were pointing at Chester.
One had to almost commend Chester on how quickly he could adjust to situations he did not expect unfolding. He forced his expression to soften and smiled at you. Titus wasn’t fooled. He held no real warmth of affection for you, not that it was necessary. What use would another man’s affection be to you? You had Titus.
“What a pleasant surprise to see you, my dear. I hope you are not distracting Titus.”
“I’m studying until the ice melts.” You lift your book and point at the vase half filled with ice, half with water, and the soda can trapped within.
“I still don’t know why your self-imposed rules apply to me.” Titus muttered. He’d called you to talk to you, see you, maybe to convince you to watch him while he jerked off again. Not to be forced to work.
“Hm, not sure who you are talking to, Titus.” You mused in a sickly-sweet voice. “Certainly can’t be me, not with that tone.” Your smile didn’t waver.
Titus had discovered, despite his earlier assumption, that you were not shy. Nothing about you was shy. It had taken you a few video calls with him to be comfortable with that particular means of communication - but Titus simply had to see your face - and you were simply never comfortable outside the familiar walls of your home, but once you were comfortable around him, he’d been in for a rude awakening.
You had a tongue on you!
Not that he actually minded.
Yeah… nothing about you was shy. You were just terrified in public, and Titus had learnt to tell the difference. The thought of what a menace you must be towards your brothers and especially your father when you were mad, which was all the time lately, was deeply amusing to Titus.
“Forgive me, sweetheart.” Titus purred, putting his head into his hands to smile at you innocently. You merely huffed, but you couldn’t hide the way your lips curled despite your attempts to stop it.
“That is a nice bracelet.” Chester said. Your entire mood shifted immediately. You beamed at the old man and held your arm up to show the platinum and diamond Cartier bracelet off. Thirty-five individual diamonds curling around your wrist.
“It was a gift from Titus!” You cooed. You’d been so pleased when your maid dropped the package delivered by Titus’ assistant off. You’d been talking to each other, and Titus got to see your face when you opened it, squealing and gushing.
Titus already knew he’d never tire of spoiling you…
“Marvellous. Well, I do not wish to disturb the two of you any longer than I have to.”
Titus could not remember a time his father had been so civil. The old man truly was over the moon to finally see Titus interested in marriage and ensuring the survival of the Danforth main line. It was making him soft.
“An invitation.” Chester passed the thick, handmade piece of cardstock to Titus. It was handwritten with golden ink, inviting the Danforth family for dinner at the Covington residence. Titus read the card, smirking to himself, before flipping it around to show you. Your eyes went wide.
“You’re coming, right?”
“Nothing could keep me away, darlin'.”
Ursula was surprisingly docile the day of the dinner. Chester probably gave her a stern talking to not to ruin this. Not that Titus particularly cared.
He was starved for you.
Video calls every night could never be enough, never replace feeling the soft flesh of your body against his palms, of your breath against his skin, your body warming his sheets.
He preened like a goddamn fucking peacock when he stepped out of the car, just to be tackled by you rushing down the stone steps leading up to your ancestral home to fling your arms around his neck. The rest of the household stayed firmly in place, your brother arranged by age on one side, with the wives and kids standing on the other. Your father stood in the middle, in the entrance of his house, surrounded by his wealth and bloodline, arms folded behind his back.
Titus bore your weight with ease. He curled an arm around your middle as you collided with him and picked you up to swirl you around. You squealed and laughed, clinging to his shoulders with your face buried against his neck.
It made your insides tingle to be reminded just how strong Titus was.
He set you down carefully and caught your chin in his hand, meaty fingers settling against your flushed skin, his arm still securely around your waist.
“Am I not gettin’ a kiss?”
“No.” You grinned and turned out of his grasp. You caught his hand and tugged him along to the steps. “I want to show you my room!”
Your father stepped aside to make room for you, whirling past him, a benevolent, almost mocking expression gleaming in his eyes.
“Daddy dearest doesn’t have a problem with me alone in your bedroom?”
“Daddy only invited you to see what your father is willing to offer for my hand.” You chirped, chasing up a winding staircase before rushing down a hallway decked with rich tapestries and gold accents. “And he thinks I’ll bore you to death introducing you to everyone. Maybe he hopes I'll scare you off.”
You flung your arms around his neck again, letting Titus push you back against the wall. The door next to you bore your name in swirly, gilded letters.
“You hiding more demons in there, sweetheart?” Titus murmured. He was so close his nose almost touched yours. That enticing mixture of his aftershave and him filled your nostrils and invaded your brain, rendering all thinking impossible for a few moments.
“No, silly.” You pushed the doorhandle down and slipped under his arm and into your room. Titus followed on your heels. “This is everyone. Everyone, this is Titus!”
Approximately three dozen pairs of beady glass eyes stared down at Titus from antique shelves mounted to the dusky pink walls.
Mice.
Mice upon mice upon mice, trapped forever in their final moments, their bodies preserved to endure long after their death.
Mice in tutus arranged into different poses. Mice around a round table playing cards. A mouse slaughtering another with a bloody knife. A fairy mouse. A wizard mouse with a massive moustache. Mice on 20th-century school benches.
A grotesque collection of taxidermied mice.
“I don’t actually talk to them.” You purred in his ear and giggled. “I don’t kill them either.” You crossed your hands on his shoulder and rested your chin atop them, pouting up at him. “I don’t hurt animals. Animals are innocent. I just pull the skin off their bodies and preserve it, stitch it back together and pull it over foam cores… but my family sure thinks I’m fucking crazy.”
Titus’ eyes flicked across the room, observing the dead mice staring at him, trying to process this new information.
“That’s why your father offered you a new mouse for your collection in exchange for your compliance after the hunt. I didn’t much think of it then, but you said he doesn’t let you have pets.”
“Does it creep you out?” Your voice dipped into a low purr. An edge of danger, of corrupted fascination played around your words, almost as if you wanted him to be unnerved.
Titus shrugged. “We have dead bucks hanging on our wall. My great aunt kept her feral little lapdog after it died. Damn thing finally croaked just for it to show back up at the house weeks later as if nothing happened. Ursula hid the thing in my room all the time just to give me a scare every time I found it. Fucking rat.”
“What did you do with it?” Your lips brushed his earlobe. A shudder rushed down Titus’ back.
“Burnt it.”
“If you burn my Evangeline, I’ll cut your balls off and feed them to you, Titus.”
Another shudder, hot and prickling, eating right through his bones and settling in the marrow, chased down his spine. “Which one is Evangeline?”
“She’s a medieval princess today.” Your tongue darted out between your lips to graze his earlobe. “Isn’t she pretty?”
The mouse in question stood on your desk, right next to the textbooks on Occult studies you’d been poring over for the past weeks. It wore a poufy lilac dress and one of those ridiculous cone hats.
“Today?”
“She’s very fashionable.” You whispered. “She has her own wardrobe.”
You stepped away suddenly, without warning, leaving a gaping wound where you’d been a part of him.
“Daddy will be serving drinks soon.” You said casually, incidentally, as if you hadn’t been sucking on his earlobe and purring in his ear a moment ago. You brushed your fingertips across the buttons of your Bluetooth speaker. A dark disco, electropop song started playing.
Titus watched you slide the sleeves of your dress down your shoulders, transfixed, all but hypnotised by the way you moved to the beat. Your dress fell off you, pooling by your feet, leaving you only in a matching set of playful, lacy underwear. You ran your hands up along your sides and through your hair before lifting them above your head, swaying your hips.
Like a siren dragging him under her spell.
You turned around and moved towards him. His breath caught in his chest. His cock stirred in his pants and he’d never felt so desperate, so needy for someone as he felt for you.
You still had not touched him. Not once.
How could Titus feel like this for someone he met twice and otherwise only spoken to over the phone? What kind of power did you possess that you could have such an effect on him?
You settled your hands against his chest in a feather-light touch. Baby blue, pearlescent nails against the deep charcoal grey of his suit. You pressed yourself against him, feeling the fabric of his clothes against your exposed skin and moaning softly.
Titus obeyed your silent wish at the slightest pressure against his chest and sat down on the edge of your bed - a regal, gold wire frame topped with a luxurious, soft mattress and smothered in blankets and pillows. He watched you lower yourself to your knees, the song still playing in the background though Titus barely heard it over the blood pounding in his ears. His stomach clenched painfully under a debilitating wave of need punching through him at the sight of you there, on your knees, between his legs, resting your head on his thigh.
“I want to see it again.”
“Oh, sweetheart, you can do more than just see it.” Titus groaned, already getting his slacks open to draw himself out.
You frowned and tilted your head to the side. “What else would I do?”
Titus merely chuckled, not realising you were genuinely confused. Your attention didn’t linger on it. Your eyes flicked down to his hard cock, a mere few inches away from your head.
You just… stared at it.
Only in your underwear, kneeling between his thighs, staring.
His thick, veiny cock rested hard and aching against his stomach, the mushroom head an angry red and leaking pre cum. You watched it roll down his shaft, leaving his skin gleaming wetly.
You hummed and got up, turning on the spot to walk over to your antique wardrobe. Titus watched you pull a floor-length, shimmery, silver silk dress out of its depths and undo your bra, letting it carelessly drop to the ground before stepping into the dress and pulling the thin straps over your shoulder. The dress clung loosely to your frame like wet fabric, moulding to your shape in places while concealing it in others. It dipped low in the back, leaving your entire back bare. You plucked a pair of diamond earrings and a matching necklace off your vanity and put them on before turning back towards Titus.
“You shouldn’t leave daddy waiting.”
You walked out of your room without turning around to him again, leaving Titus behind with only his aching erection and your creepy collection of taxidermy.
It should piss him off.
It should make him furious what a little tease you were, how you kept getting him this hard and desperate but never touched him. It didn’t. Titus was obsessed with you, and everything you did only deepened his obsession further.
When he went downstairs to join you and his family in the sitting room, after his raging boner finally went away enough for him to tuck his cock back into his pants without wanting to die, he found you comfortably perched on your father’s lap. You sat sideways with your arm draped around his shoulders while you held a glass in your other hand. Your father looked smug. Far too fucking smug for Titus’ liking, and his words from the day at the races echoed through his head.
So you pleasured her, maybe she came back for another taste. You really think that means something? You think she’ll return the favour?
Titus gritted his teeth and took a seat on the sofa across from Richard and you, next to his sister.
“Enjoyed the tour?” Richard asked, a devilish glint in his eyes, and took a sip of his whiskey.
“Evageline sure looked lovely tonight.”
Your eyes lit up. “I made the dress myself.”
“Impressive.”
Titus savoured watching you preen under his attention and compliment, just to duck your head and grin down at your glass.
The conversation his arrival interrupted picked back up, meaningless, scathingly polite chattering. Ursula talked about the latest collection of some hot up-and-coming designer with your three sisters-in-law while Chester, Richard and Caspian talked business. Darius and Sebastian teased Tobias with a date that had apparently gone rather horribly.
Titus barely paid attention to any of it.
How could he when you were right there, on your father’s lap, his hand resting possessively on your hip, just… watching him.
“Take a picture, sweetheart. It’ll last you longer.”
Your smile widened, accentuating the apples of your cheeks that turned pink under his gaze.
“The last picture I took caused quite the stir.”
That it had.
Little minx that you were, you had taken a selfie of yourself reclined comfortably in your bed with your laptop next to you while you were on a video call with Titus. You created a new account on some social media app. Within just a couple of hours, the account had tens of millions of followers.
Your father threatened to take away your internet access again, to which you threatened to tell the internet he wasn’t letting you talk to Titus. His company’s stocks had already taken a big hit in the face of increased scrutiny and questions regarding his treatment of his daughter, accusations of misogyny and sexism, rumours Chester was for once not lifting a finger to conceal as he usually did for the High Council.
It was safe to say that Richard was quite motivated to contain the ever-escalating media attention.
“Sir, the children would like to say goodnight.” The butler announced from the door.
“Send them in.” Richard drawled. Five children, arranged by age, all wearing dressing robes over their pyjamas, hair brushed and braided for the girls, marched into the room. The youngest held the hand of the nanny and peered fearfully at Titus, Ursula and Chester.
You put your glass down and slipped off your father’s lap to kneel down in front of them. Caspian’s wife - Lucille - wanted to stop you, but Caspian grabbed her wrist before she could, shooting her a warning glance.
You embraced your nieces and nephews, showering them in kisses and sharing whispered words that made the children giggle.
The oldest couldn’t be older than six, not that Titus knew much about children.
Richard watched you with an insufferable, mockingly benevolent expression. Lucille grew more antsy the longer you interacted with the children. Sebastian’s and Remington’s wives didn’t look thrilled to have you so close to their spawns either.
Titus didn’t understand why.
You were nothing but gentle and sweet with them from what he saw - doting. And the children obviously adored you. Children did not laugh so freely with someone who they were scared of or who hurt them.
“Will you come?” The oldest of the bunch, Caspian’s first-born son, peered up at you with hopeful eyes.
You shook your head. “Not tonight.”
“But-” The boy’s eyes went wide. “You have to make sure there aren’t any monsters under my bed.”
Your father scoffed and rolled his eyes, but you stayed right where you were, kneeling in front of your nephew.
“Did you forget?” You grinned and adjusted his dressing gown. “All the monsters live under my bed. And if one of them gets lost, you just tell it to fuck off, or your auntie will hunt them down, hm? I’ll skin and gut them and hang them up outside as a warning. Nobody scares my little niblings and lives.”
“Could you not say such gruesome things in front of the children?”
Titus saw you roll your eyes.
“Your wife has been married into a devil-worshipping cult for what? Ten years? You’d think she’d have grown thicker skin by now.”
Richard chuckled. Even Caspian grinned, though he had the class to hide it behind the rim of his glass.
“He’ll get nightmares.” Lucille insisted.
You scoffed. “Nightmares?" You said without looking away from your nephew. "Who? You? You are the future Covington heir. You’re not scared of some blood, are you, baby?”
Your nephew shook his head.
“No, you’re not. When you’re a little bigger, I’ll teach you everything you need to know to serve Mr Le Bail.” You caught his face in your hands and pulled him closer to deposit several kisses on his face. Your nephew giggled and threw his arms around you.
“Goodnight, little bug.” You purred at the toddler holding the nanny’s hand. You poked and tickled her tummy playfully until she giggled and shrieked before bending down to press a final kiss to her forehead while your father called you back to his side.
You didn’t go to him.
You joined Titus, slipping onto his lap as if you had never sat anywhere else. You watched the children get ushered out and waved. Only once the butler closed the door to the sitting room again did you turn your attention towards Titus.
Lucille had turned to Caspian, muttering furiously under her breath about how she didn’t like you swearing in front of the children or talking about killing. Caspian brushed her off, telling her to be quiet, that they’d talk when the guests were gone, and all the platitudes husbands threw at their misbehaving wives.
“I do not understand why Mr Le Bail only tests the outsiders if he doesn't want them to join the bloodline.” You groaned as you curled your arm around Titus’ neck, playing with the curls at the base of his skull. “Seems short-sighted that outsiders can marry in without having to prove themselves worthy.”
“Yeah? How would you do it?”
You shrugged and snapped your fingers for a footman to bring you your glass you’d left on the table. “I just think they should have to prove they have what it takes to serve Mr Le Bail. Clearly some people here don’t.” You looked at Lucille, a silent challenge the older woman was not brave enough to take you up on, before glancing back at Titus. “Do you want children?”
“If they are yours.”
Your cheeks tinged pink. You tried and failed to fight off the smile sneaking onto your lips. “Yeah? You tellin’ the truth?”
“I wouldn’t lie to you, sweetheart.”
“Because my brothers sure think you only want to fuck me.”
Titus’ lips curled. “Well, to claim it is the only thing I want from you is rather the assault on my character.”
Your expression dropped. You sat up slightly, pushing away from him, frowning. “You- want-”
Titus bit back a nervous chuckle. “I want you to be my wife - with all that entails.”
“You want to put your penis inside me.”
This time the nervous chuckle broke through Titus’ defences. He did not know how to respond to your bluntness - especially when it was uttered so publicly. His family did not speak of carnal love, ever - or the unnerved expression on your face. He did not think he’d been subtle with his desire at all, so to see you so surprised by them was throwing him off.
Your father looked deeply pleased, smirking at Titus over the rim of his glass. Your brothers snorted and snickered, clearly not as blindsided by this response as he was.
“I don’t want that. That sounds disgusting.”
“Ah, there’s always IVF, I suppose.” Your father hummed, earning another round of snickers from your brothers.
Titus, not one to back down from a fight, recovered from his surprise enough to catch your chin between his thumb and forefinger and smirk up at you. “You did not seem disgusted when my tongue was inside you, sweetheart.”
Richard’s expression froze over. Gabriel choked on his drink. Caspian’s grip around his glass tightened to the point his knuckles went white. Tobias and Sebastian looked murderous. Remington seemed undecided whether to be amused or furious, and Darius, well, Darius was having the time of his life. His boyfriend had to hiss a warning into his ear to stop him from bursting out in laughter.
“Huh…” You tilted your head to the side, staring at Titus, utterly uncaring of your surroundings.
The butler came to Titus’ rescue, announcing that dinner was about to be served. The migration from the sitting room to the dining room helped alleviate some tension, but Richard’s murderous expression stayed firmly in place throughout all six courses.
It was becoming increasingly clear he had lost control over you - certainly more than he’d ever thought possible.
You didn’t get the opportunity to be alone with Titus again.
You couldn’t tell why, but it left you feeling restless and… unsatisfied. Like the distance the circumstances of tonight had forced upon you, after weeks of being kept away from him, had grown to manifest itself in an insistent, gnawing itch you could not shake.
Your father didn’t let you kill staff anymore because - according to him - it was getting difficult to find good replacements, so you paced your room, desperately trying to rid yourself of the sensation of a thousand insects rushing across your skin long enough to fall asleep.
It didn’t help.
Dressed only in your silk sleep dress, you made your way across the east wing, padding barefoot over the expensive runner until you reached your father’s bedroom.
You slipped inside without knocking.
Richard looked up from the book he was reading, already in bed, with only the lamp on his nightstand casting the room in a mellow, warm light. You crawled into his bed and curled up next to him, bedding your head on his lap.
“Hello, princess. Can’t sleep?”
Richard shifted his book into his left hand to thread the other one through your hair.
“I want Titus.”
His hand stilled mid-stroke. A fracture, a minuscule crack in his otherwise stern composure.
“Come here, love.” Richard set his book aside and opened his arms for you, letting you crawl onto his lap. He gripped your chin gently, a benevolent smile curling around his lips.
“That boy really has done a number on you, hm?” He clicked his tongue, a sound oozing such disappointment it made you flinch. He sighed. “It’s my fault. I should have known this would happen. You aren’t a child anymore… even if it hurts your old man to admit it.”
“I’ll always be your little girl.”
The corner of Richard’s mouth twitched. Something in his eyes softened, something that was never soft, for nobody else. Only ever for you. “Of course. But you are a young woman now, and a beautiful one too. It is only natural for you to have desires - Mr Le Bail is certainly not one to insist on stifling those, and who would I be to disobey his example? I suppose I cannot even be cross with Mr Danforth for being taken with a face like yours.”
Richard ran his knuckle along your cheek. You nuzzled into the easy display of affection.
“How about this? I will find you a toy more… suitable to your disposition, hm? Some handsome boy - or a more… mature man if that is your preference. Someone to explore with, to play with until you grow tired. Someone you can enjoy and dispose of just the way you want to.”
The thought of hands that did not belong to Titus touching you the way he had spread a foul taste through your mouth.
You shook your head.
“I want Titus.”
Richard’s nostrils flared. He never expected your childish rebellion to last this long.
“Am I that terrible to you? That you wish so desperately to leave me?”
“Of course not, daddy.”
“Then why are you suddenly so eager to marry and be rid of me?”
You sat up. “I don’t want to be rid of you! I just- I want Titus!”
“He’d take you away from me! Is that what you want? To leave your home, the place where you’ve been safe your whole life, to be with that petulant manchild? He doesn’t know you, love, not like I do. And you need me to take care of you. How would I do that when you leave me?”
“Titus would.”
Richard laughed, delighted and derisive both at once, making you feel like a silly little thing and causing you to shrink against him.
“Titus? That man cannot even take care of himself, how would he look after you?”
But he did, you thought, glaring defiantly up at your father. Titus did look after you during the race. He asked you what you needed and then gave it to you, and that was more than he or Caspian were doing lately!
Titus listened to you. He didn’t talk over you, and he took you seriously and tried to understand you even when you made no sense. He respected you, and you were beginning to think, reluctantly and with a heavy heart, that maybe… Richard didn’t.
It was stupid that you needed his permission to get married to Titus. You wouldn’t need it to marry any other man, so why should he get to decide this! The bylaws were wrong. If Richard didn’t let you have this then- then-
The itch, the perpetual squirming feeling of insects crawling across your skin intensified suddenly, growing tenfold until you couldn’t think, couldn’t breathe-
You squeezed your eyes shut, trying to push it down, trying to not think about losing the way Titus looked at you forever, the feeling of his hand on your waist, of his lips against your neck - but you couldn’t.
You were losing him.
You were losing him before he even got to be yours because of Richard, because Richard had a personal vendetta against Titus! And instead of setting it aside to make his only daughter happy, here he was suggesting you’d find some- some cheap replacement to give all the first experiences to that belonged to Titus!
Why should you kiss different lips? Why should you let those lips touch any part of your body? Why should you feel cheap pleasure at their caress when all you wanted was Titus?!
The sound of your name filling the quiet bedroom pulled you back.
You blinked, disoriented, and found yourself sitting above your father, straddling his chest, your knees pinning his arms to the mattress, with your razor blade pressed into his throat.
A drop of red blood beaded along the gleaming metal.
Richard’s eyes were wide. A predator that believed himself strong enough to cage a bigger, worse version of himself knocked off his pedestal. A man foolish enough to keep a chimpanzee as a pet and just got a taste of what they were truly capable of.
“I want Titus.” You hissed. Adrenaline pumped through your entire body, making you feel energised and restless.
“Take the blade away, silly girl.”
“What if I don’t?” Your eyes lit up with manic delight. Your lips curled into a grotesque, frantic grin. “What if I kill you, daddy? Sacrifice you to Mr Le Bail? There is no rule against that, daddy. What if I do to you what I did to mummy? Caspian would take your place. Caspian would let me get married. And if he doesn’t, I’ll kill him, and Tobias takes his place. And Sebastian after him. Remington. Gabriel. Darius sure as fuck isn’t going to say no to me. And if he does, if I kill him, my sweet, precious little Edmund would become the patriarch of this family, since you’ve probably excluded me from the succession. Edmund would want his auntie to be happy.”
“Would you do that?” Richard sneered. “Place the burden of leading a High Council family on a six-year-old? Kill your whole family to bind yourself to someone like that for the rest of eternity? There is no divorce for the High Council families!”
Mr Le Bail did not care about the values of his creator, but he valued loyalty and devotion, and he did not allow his High Council to fall into chaos over attempts to take the other families’ power and wealth through playing musical chairs with marriages.
You faltered for a second, long enough for Richard to free himself, throwing you to the side and off himself. You landed on the soft mattress, staring up at the ceiling.
“I’d kill every last one of you so you can never say no to me again.” You whispered. “So you stop treating me like a fucking child!”
“Then stop acting like one!”
You sat up and glared at your father with enough vitriol he felt it prickling on his skin. The shadows behind you squirmed, coming alive with something that was decidedly not alive.
“I will marry Titus.”
Glancing warily at the shadows, Richard decided to switch tactics.
“And then?” He murmured softly, kneeling down on the ground in front of the bed, taking your hands into his own. Blood ran down his neck in a thin trickle. You still held the bloody razor blade in your trembling fingers.
“What happens when you’ve married him? Have you thought about that? You’ll have to move. Leave behind everything you know. What if he decides he doesn’t want Rosehip and Biscuit? You can’t just kill your husband and be done with it. Mr Le Bail won’t even forgive you for taking out the Danforth heir over some goats.”
“He already said I can keep them.” You whispered, fighting the tears gathering in your eyes. “He said I won't ever need to ask him permission.”
Richard gave you a sympathetic, sad smile and tugged a strand of hair behind your ear. “Men make many lofty promises to get what they want, love. Especially a man like Titus. Do you think he loves you? Oh, sweetheart, he only loves what is between your thighs and that he’s the first to touch it.”
Richard got to his feet with a sigh and went into the bathroom adjacent to his bedroom. His hands were trembling when he retrieved a washcloth to wipe the blood from his neck. Fear clung to every inch of him, thick and cloying.
You’d threatened to kill him before in petulant displays of insolence, but never had you acted on them.
He took a deep breath, scrambling to hold onto his composure a little longer, as long as you were around at least.
He found you standing at the window, looking down at the dark estate. Titus stood on the terrace, smoke curling around him and Darius, who was leaning against a stone balustrade.
“Okay.” Richard whispered, stepping up behind you, hands settling on your waist. “I think you are making a mistake, but if this is what you want… though… if I do something for you, something I really do not wish to do… you have to do something for me in return.”
You turned your head ever so slightly, glancing at him through the corner of your eye.
“That’s only fair, wouldn’t you agree? Just like Mr Le Bail would ask something of you in return for forcing my hand in this matter, and it’s better to be indebted to me than him, don’t you think?”
“What- what do you want?”
“Everything.” Richard purred in your ear before straightening up to rest his chin on your head, staring down at the figure of Titus. “The thing I’ve always wanted. The High Seat.”
You frowned. “Titus’ father has the High Seat…”
“Which is why I’m going to ask something simple of you. Something you’re good at… I’ll let you marry Titus, and after a while, when you’ve had time to grow bored of him, when I tell you… you’ll kill him.”
You stiffened, but Richard’s grip around you stopped you from backing away, forcing you to listen to his full proposal, at once no longer father but businessman.
“Let him put a child in you first if you want to play mother so badly, but you will kill him. First, you’ll kill his father, of course. Then his insipid sister and at last, him. You’ll inherit the High Seat, and I’ll graciously take that burden off you. You can come home, even when you’re a Danforth." When you are no longer family, when you can no longer kill him. "Of course, you can - I’ll always take care of you - and everything will be as it used to be.”
Richard ran his hands up your arms, letting them settle on top of your shoulders.
“I know how you get, after all, when you’ve gotten something into your mind you just can’t get out. It's not your fault. I’ll let you have your fill of him, I’ll let you have what you want, and you’ll give me what I want. I think that is fair.”
Your mouth felt dry. You tried to swallow, but it felt like swallowing sand. You stared at Titus, his strong build next to your brother’s lithe appearance. You could hear a faint whisper of his laughter as the two spoke. Your heart ached for him. You’d never wanted something more than you wanted him.
“Okay.”
Richard tipped his head forward to press a kiss against the crown of your head, concealing a smirk against your scalp.
“I knew we could figure this out. My good girl…”
You turned on the spot, twisting out of his grasp to go lie down on the bed, hugging one of the pillows to your chest and fighting the tears burning in your eyes.
You had just gotten all you’ve been asking for - why did it not feel like a victory?
Richard settled in behind you, draping his arm over your waist and kissing your cheek.
“I love you, daddy.”
Richard chuckled. “I love you too, sweetheart.”
Titus watched the window even after you left. He exhaled a cloud of smoke and lowered his cigar.
“What is up with those two anyway?” He hummed, glancing at the youngest of your brothers. Darius shrugged.
“He’s weird with her, isn’t he? He’s always been like that. She’s probably the only one of us he loves, as much as he is capable of love, guess. It’s pretty insulting considering he never wanted her in the first place.” Darius was drunk, not so drunk he was slurring his words and couldn’t stand upright, but the weed he’d been smoking erased the last of his inhibitions.
Titus had gotten some useful information out of him. He liked Darius best out of all your brothers, though he supposed that wasn’t a difficult thing to accomplish with how much he’d grown to loathe Caspian and Tobias specifically.
“He swore off love a long time ago. When Le Bail made him kill his wife.”
“Your mother? I was under the impression your sister killed her.”
Darius chuckled. “Not my mother. His first wife. Le Bail may not let us divorce spouses, but there is no rule against killing them, is there? Father made his deal when he was sixteen. Two years later, when he had all the riches a prospective father-in-law could want his daughter’s suitor to have, he asked for the hand of his high school sweetheart. They got married, had a kid, the fairy tale. Until a drunk driver crashed into their car. Their son died. The wife survived, barely, but the surgery necessary to save her also removed her uterus. My father had to choose between the love of his life and the prospect of ever becoming part of the High Council. Lower families don’t have to have heirs. High Council families do. My father didn’t have siblings. He was twenty-one, without child, and with an infertile wife. Mr Le Bail made it clear. No child - no High Council. And no divorce.”
“So your father killed the love of his life?”
“Sacrificed her on the altar he built together with her in this very house. Then he found an heiress among the lower families he could stand the thought of having to look at for the rest of his life and married her. She gave him two sons, but she wanted a daughter. Years later-” Darius spread his arms and bowed mockingly. “-here we are. I’m not entirely convinced Mr Le Bail told my sister to kill our mother. Honestly, it might have been Father.”
Darius yawned and stretched. He stubbed out his joint on the stone bannister. Titus watched him from the corner of his mouth. It fascinated him how coldly your entire family spoke of your mother’s demise.
“You know she’ll take the goats, right?” Darius asked out of nowhere. At Titus’ confused expression, he nodded towards the garden where two goats in what looked like baby onesies were currently eating one of the manicured hedges.
“Man, I don’t give a fuck about the goats or the mice or the demons.” He looked back up to the window. “I just want her.”
Darius nodded. “As long as you make her happy.” He grabbed his crystal tumbler from the balustrade and threw back the last sip of whiskey. “She deserves to finally have something for herself. And I swear, Father acts so goddamn creepy around her sometimes. It’ll do her good to get away from that.”
Titus watched Darius walk inside and drag his boyfriend up the stairs. His eyes flicked back up to the window where you still did not stand.
The sound of expensive loafers stepping up the stone stairs had him swirling around.
The Lawyer merely smirked.
The flames dancing in the fireplace behind Mr Le Bail’s chair felt cold against your skin. Or perhaps it was simply you who could not feel warm.
You knelt on the carpet with your arms crossed on the armrest of his chair, your chin resting atop them, whispering with the being only you saw.
You fell silent the moment Titus appeared in the doorway.
Your heart sank at the same time as it beat faster. How could you feel both so much joy and apprehension at the same time?
“Darlin’?”
A prickling shiver rushed down your spine at the nickname and the soft, raspy purr of his voice.
“Aren’t you cold?”
Titus knew well the trouble of heating an old mansion like this. Seeing you on the ground in only a thin, short sleep dress made him frown.
You shook your head.
“I know you must be tired.” He made a step into the room. “I’ll let you catch some sleep in a moment, but- I cannot leave just yet.” He lowered himself onto one knee next to you. His fingers trembled almost unperceivable when he reached out to brush your hair behind your ear. You nuzzled into his touch. He leaned down, bringing his forehead to yours, and as if you’d never done anything else, you tipped your head up to catch his lips in a fleeting but no less yearning kiss.
Titus cupped the side of your face and deepened the kiss. His free hand slid into his pocket, pulling out the ring box he’d been carrying with him for weeks, the ring box he opened every night, without fail, picturing the sparkling, decadent ring on your finger.
He pulled back just enough to show you the box, to open it for you as he had pictured so many times…
Your eyes fell on the delicate ring. A three-carat, cushion-cut diamond surrounded by polished, glittering moonstones, set into a narrow platinum band.
It was decadent, but tasteful in the way old money always was, almost subtle when one wasn’t directly looking at it.
“Will you make me the happiest, richest man in the whole wide world and become my wife?” He whispered, forehead still pressed to yours, breath brushing across your lips as he spoke.
“Titus…”
“Just say yes.” Titus kissed the corner of your mouth. “Please just say yes, sweetheart. We’ll figure it all out… just be mine.”
You opened and closed your mouth. A tear rolled down your cheek. “Yes.”
Titus swept you up in his arms, getting to his feet with you as if you weighed nothing and kissed you, deep, hungry, practically glowing with joy.
You let him sit you down on the table and slip the ring onto your finger. It fit exactly right. It was beautiful. It was perfect. It had his and your initials engraved on the inside of the band. He hugged you again, burying his face against your neck and whispering sweet nothings and solemn promises into your skin.
Everything was perfect.
Why did it not feel perfect?
You looked to the side, finding Mr Le Bail's fiery eyes already on you.
He merely smirked and shrugged.
Next Chapter
tag list: (Feel free to let me know if you want to be added or removed) @agentroye @dorks2022 @skepticalriddleimp @moonlightartemisblog @torntaltos @gingermars830 @worstbiwer @bombtasticbritt91 @momdancingtomcr @disappearintofanfiction @1dhoe93 @prongs-moon @dgwsstuff @peanutbutternelly @theariespov @kneelforloki @multiversejumper @aoi-warrior @darknessofhell666-blog-blog @azaryix @rigglemethat @hahahahaylie @sunbonesss @melissa66orion @gulpgulpisthispoisondies @solarpotato @strangegirl26sff @snowfire0313 @btsgangleader @atombombjelly @phera-money @the-sassy-one @enbee3164 @landpiranha-blog @celestialsonglines @harrystylesfourthnipple924 @dahlia-blossom21 @countryandsweetbabygirl @pickles-the-jackalope @letstryagaintomorrow @yaansu @realwhoreforfictionalmen @fantasyreader130 @brzlnbarbie
Doppel-banger: a double of a living person who you wouldn't hesitate to tap
summary: five times you think you stumbled upon jack abbot vs. the one time it's actually him
tags: shawn hatosy universe, brett richards, sammy bryant, andrew "pope" cody, terry mccandless, titus dandforth, jack abbot, terry is lowkey creepy, titus mentions sacrificing somone, brett sammy and pope are all nice, canon pope staring, second hand embarrassment, younger fem!reader but age is not specified
notes: okay, so I had this idea of making a full oneshot about a reader mistaking pope for a concussed jack for an entire day, but the I thought it'd be really funny to make a collection of all the major shawn characters. i haven't seen any of the tv shows, but i read so much fan fiction, I am sorry if some of them are ooc, if you'd like to join my permanent taglist please comment on this post ! enjoy!
word count: 9.6k
By the time you finally escaped into the ambulance bay, the Pitt had descended into the fog that made everyone vaguely mean and snappy to each other.
A car had decided to plow through the front of a convenience store three blocks away just before noon, which somehow evolved into a gas leak, a grease fire from the kitchen next door, multiple smoke inhalations, and one man who’d managed to impale his own hand on a display rack while trying to “help.” The Pitt had been drowning ever since with no floaties in sight. Stretchers lined the hallways, Robby was barking orders over the chaos, and a med student was getting publicly destroyed for contaminating a sterile field.
Your entire body ached with exhaustion, and it wasn’t even 2:30 yet. Your scrub top clung uncomfortably to your back, your ponytail was halfway falling out, and the iced coffee you’d brought six hours ago had long since melted into a watery disappointment sitting untouched at the nurses’ station under Dana’s watchful eye.
You only stepped outside because you needed thirty seconds where nobody was actively bleeding near you.
The bay smelled faintly like smoke and gasoline, engines rumbling low beneath the distant screams of sirens out in the city. Paramedics moved around in practiced patterns, unloading equipment while firefighters lingered near one of the firetrucks parked crookedly next to an ambulance. You barely paid attention at first, too busy rubbing at the ache gathering behind your eyes.
You had started to walk back toward the Pitt but stopped entirely when you saw him; well—the back of him anyway with his broad shoulders and dark, soaked curls resting against his nape. Even if you couldn’t see his face, he somehow was able to stand out in a crowd even surrounded by firefighters in full turnout gear. One hand braced against the side of the engine while he spoke to someone beside him, his jacket stretched over his shoulders.
No matter what, you’d always be able to spot Jack Abbot in a crowd.
Your eyes dragged slowly over his newfound bright yellow firefighting gear, the reflective stripes glinting. The heavy boots and radio clipped to his chest had you pausing and staring for a solid three seconds, mind trying to process how exactly the man had apparently gone from night shift attending and SWAT medic to volunteer firefighter without mentioning it to anyone.
But more importantly, mentioning it to you.
Actually, when you thought about it, knowing Jack, the change tracked perfectly. The man already had a self-sacrificial streak a mile wide. Of course he’d look at one incredibly dangerous side quest and think You know what would make my life even better? Fire.
A deeply offended laugh escaped your lips, and without thinking too hard about it, you started moving toward him.
“Seriously, Abbot?” you called out over the noise of the bay. “You take one shift off and suddenly you’re fighting convivence store fires now?”
The man beside him glanced over first, obviously confused, but Jack turned more slowly, still halfway shrugging out of his jacket as you continued your approach.
“No, because SWAT clearly wasn’t stressful enough for you,” you continued, tired enough that the words just kept coming. “You looked at armed standoffs and thought, wow, my life is missing a little spontaneous combustion.”
By the time you reached them, the stranger standing beside him was openly staring at you in amusement. Meanwhile, Jack had gone very still.
That should have been your first warning.
But against all self-preservation, you planted your hands on your hips and kept going. “Do you know how insane it is that this is how I’m finding out? I had to see you standing next to a fire engine like some kind of hot, emotionally unstable calendar shoot—”
Jack finally turned fully toward you, and your brain stopped functioning completely.
Because the man in front of you was not Jack Abbot.
In your defense, he was close enough to knock the air from your lungs for a second. He had the same dark, hazel eyes, the same rough kind of handsomeness that looked better the more exhausted and grimed up they got. They even had the same intimidating build that made people move out of their way without a second glance.
But somehow, this man looked older that Jack, more self-assured in a way that only grew as he looked deeply entertained by your humiliation already unfolding in real time. The silence stretched until the firefighter next to him snorted loudly into his fist.
Your stomach dropped straight through the floor.
“I’m flattered you think I’m hot.” The not-Jack’s mouth twitched slightly. “But is it a bad time to mention my name’s not Jack?”
Heat flooded your face so fast it physically hurt. “No,” you breathed, horrified out of your mind. “No, no, no.”
Now the firefighter beside him was fully laughing, turning away entirely as though witnessing your embarrassment firsthand had become too much for him to handle.
You covered your face with both hands. “I need someone to hit me with an ambulance immediately.”
“That feels awfully dramatic,” the man said.
Your eyes found him through the slats of your fingers. “You have my attending’s face.”
“I’m starting to gather that.”
“You even stand like him,” you accused, voice muffled by your palms. “Which is apparently enough for me to lose all critical thinking skills.”
He laughed softly, low and rough enough to make the situation somehow worse. “Well,” he said, “in fairness, you seemed pretty confident.”
You lowered your hands just enough to glare at him. “Because I really thought my friend had secretly joined the fire department.”
The stranger folded his arms across his chest, turnout jacket hanging loosely from one hand while he studied you with open amusement. “So this Jack guy—he always gets yelled at like this by you?”
“Only when he does something stupid.”
“I’m starting to think I should meet him.”
You shook your head, hands finally dropping back to your sides. “You abso-fucking-lutely should not. I think seeing both of you in the same room might kill me instantly.”
He grinned wildly, quick but devastatingly effective enough it sent tingles up your spine.
Great. Fantastic. Love that for you. One Jack Abbot was hard enough to not stare at as is; having them both in the same room would actually cause a spontaneous combustion of your body.
You sighed heavily, dragging a hand down your face. “Okay. Wonderful. I’m gonna go crawl into oncoming traffic now if you don’t mind.”
Before you could make your great escape, he stuck out his hand toward you. “Captain Brett Richards.”
You looked at it suspiciously for a second before taking it. His grip was warm, firm, and rough with callouses in all the right places. You gave over your name reluctantly, still unable to fully look him in the face without feeling embarrassed all over again.
Unfortunately for you, he spoke again, timber all deep and ragged. “For the record, I was gonna let you keep going.”
Your eyes snapped to his hazel ones. “What?”
“I wanted to see how long it took you before you noticed.”
“You are a bad person, Brett Richards.”
“I’m a curious person. There’s a difference.”
“You stood there and listened to me accuse you of having a hero complex.”
“Seemed important to you.”
“I’ve been publicly humiliated!”
“Just humiliated between me and my friend. I don’t think that counts as the public.”
You pointed at him accusingly. “You’re creepy.”
“What?”
“The tone you’re doing right now.”
Brett blinked. “What tone?”
“The exact same tone he uses when he thinks I’m being ridiculous.”
“I don’t know what you’re talking about.”
“You sound exactly like him too.”
Now he looked offended. “I do not.”
“You absolutely do. You’re even doing the whole arms cross and puffing out your chest while simultaneously stretching your neck to look taller.”
The other firefighter chimed in. “Honestly, Brett? She’s kinda right.”
Brett looked over, absolute betrayal on his face. “Whose side are you on?”
“Definitely not yours.”
You laughed loudly, fatigue finally cracking enough to let something lighter through. At the same moment, your phone buzzed in your scrub pocket. You pulled it out, eyes widening at the incoming message.
Jack:
Running late. Scene turned into a disaster. Save me a trauma room before some other resident does something stupid.
“I bet you two text the same,” you grumbled, shoving your phone back into your pocket before looking back up at him.
He laughed outright at that, shoulders shaking slightly. “Sounds like you know this man intimately. Do you possibly have a type? Or do you grumble at every silver fox in your area.”
You glared at him as best you could. “I don’t have a type. Do not make this my problem.”
“Feels like your problem already.”
“Oh, we absolutely aren’t doing this today.” Still, a smile grew on your face before you started backing toward the ambulance bay doors again. “I’m leaving before this gets more psychologically damaging.”
Brett called after you easily, “Tell Jack Abbot I’m apparently his hotter firefighter version!”
You stepped dead in your tracks and slowly turned around. “. . .You know what?” you said thoughtfully. “I actually think saying that out loud near him might start a physical fight.”
Brett’s grin widened. “Now I definitely want to meet him.”
_______________________
The worst shifts always seem to end quietly and not anywhere close to peaceful. The Pitt, you liked to think, was incapable of achieving peace. Even now, close to midnight (almost five hours after your shift “officially ended”), you left behind blaring monitors, patients in needed of doctors, and exhausted coworkers who had just started to trade sarcastic insults at the station just to stay awake. But compared to the disaster the evening had started, the hospital had tasted almost manageable to where you believed they had everything handled.
Your feet dragged as you stepped out through the ambulance bay doors, the night air cool against the lingering heat trapped beneath your scrub jacket. The city smelled faintly damp from rain earlier in the evening, asphalt still dark under the lights.
You leaned against the brick wall beside the entrance for a second, closing your eyes briefly.
Today had been brutal in the particular way only emergency medicine could manage. There had been too many patients, too many families crying in the halls, too many moments where things almost went wrong before somebody caught it at the last second. You’d spent more than twelve hours keeping yourself stitched together with caffeine and momentum, and now that things finally slowed down enough, your brain had apparently decided to stop all regular functions, effective immediately.
Which was probably why, when you spotted a familiar figure standing near one of the patrol cars parked on the other side of the street, the pieces fell into place, your brain beaming Oh, Jack just left too?
Jack stood with his back partially toward you, shoulders slumped slightly beneath a dark jacket while one hand rested against the roof of the cruiser. His head tilted down toward the coffee in his hand, dark curls shadowed in the lack of street lights.
You didn’t even think before walking toward the warm, familiar build that held the same tired posture Jack adopted after a nasty shift, almost preparing his body to show up the next day anyway.
“Please tell me,” you called out tiredly, “that your shift was somehow worse than mine so I can feel better about my life choices.”
Jack glanced over at the sound of your voice, but you kept talking before fully seeing his face.
“Because if I have to hear one more over pompous med student stay the words ‘technically speaking,’ I’m actually going to commit a felony.”
A low huff of amusement answered you. “Long night?”
“Long life is more like it,” you corrected, finally stepping slow enough to see him properly.
You froze when he fully turned, because the universe apparently had a personal vendetta against you for probably your past life’s sins. Because once again, the man standing in front of you was not Jack Abbot. Yes, he was close enough to make your stomach drop for a second. His eyes glinted with the same sadness Jack’s did. He even had the same rough exhaustion written lines around his mouth. However, this man looked like someone who absorbed the weight of things instead of fighting against them.
Also, now that he was turned to you, his officer badge and uniform stuck out like a sore thumb.
And unlike Brett earlier in the week, this stranger didn’t look quite as amused by your mistake. He just looked tired.
You stopped short of the cruiser, horror crawling slowly up your spine. “Oh.”
He blinked once before taking a slow sip of coffee. “Bad start to the conversation?”
“Fuck me; I did it again,” you muttered to yourself.
“Again?”
You covered your face briefly with one hand, humiliation already blatant on your face. “There’s apparently two other guys walking around Pittsburgh with your exact face.”
“Well, that sound concerning.”
“I’m very concerned for my mental status.”
The corner of his mouth twitched, subtle enough you almost missed it.
You let out a defeated sigh, face turned toward the sky, before gesturing vaguely toward him. “You are not Jack Abbot.”
“Nope.”
“Perfect.”
“You wanna try my name instead?” There wasn’t even a hint of annoyance in his voice. If anything, he sounded mildly curious about the situation unfolding in front of him.
You laughed weakly, hands lightly tapping your thighs. “Honestly, I think I should just stop talking to strangers forever.”
“You always this extreme when mistaking people for another?”
“Only when I keep finding multiple emotionally exhausted men who all look exactly like my attending.”
That earned you a slightly more noticeable smile as he pushed away from the patrol car, holding out one hand toward you. “Sammy Bryant.”
You shook it, still staring at him in disbelief. “I’m sorry, Officer Bryant, but this is all still genuinely ridiculous to me.”
Sammy glanced down at your hospital badge as you gave him your name. “You work inside?”
“Unfortunately.”
“Late shift?”
You shook your head. “You could say that. I started at seven this morning.”
His eyebrows lifted. “And you’re still standing?”
“Barely.” You looked down at your body. “I think my soul high tailed it out of there around hour nine and never came back.”
A soft laugh escaped him, quieter than Brett’s hand been, but still holding the same warmth that made you feel comfortable.
You mentally made a decision before leaning back against his patrol car beside him, rubbing at your eyes with one hand. For a moment, neither of you spoke and just listened to the faint noises of the night.
Sammy took another sip of coffee before nodding toward the hospital. “Was it busy today?”
A long, shuddering breath whistled through your lips. “One trauma after another. Half the city apparently decided today was a great day to make terrible healthcare decisions.”
“Sounds about right.”
“And one student almost gave a patient the wrong dosage because he was trying to impress our boss.”
“We caught it before it happened, but still.” Your hair moved slowly across your forehead as you shook your head tiredly. “At some point though you just start wondering if everyone should stop touching things altogether or find some patience before they kill someone.”
He hummed softly in agreement, hazel eyes drifting toward the street. “You probably already know, but that feeling really doesn’t ever go away.”
You glanced over at him, taking in his face properly. Like your Jack, Sammy seemed to carry the same heaviness about him, like emergency services hadn’t been kind to either of them.
“How long have you been on the force?” you asked quietly, taking his uniform details in as your eyes roamed.
“Twelve years.”
“Explains your expression.”
At least he didn’t sound offended when he asked, “What expression?”
“The one that says humanity was a big mistake.”
He chuckled lowly. “Yeah,” he admitted. “You nailed that one perfectly.”
A faint smile hooked onto your lips before your head tipped back against the cruiser window behind you. “Jack has that look too.”
Sammy looked over. “The guy I apparently share a face with?”
“Yep.” You looked down at your hands, fingers picking at the skin around your nails. “Him and this firefighter named Richards.”
“What does Jack do?”
“He’s the night shift attending, and he volunteers as a SWAT medic during his free days.”
Sammy nodded along, understanding settling across his face as he listened. “That tracks.”
“You say that like you know him.”
“Don’t need to.” He shrugged. “You can tell what kind of person someone is by the jobs they stay in too long.”
For a second, you watched him quietly beneath the moonlight, struck again by how strange this whole thing felt. It wasn’t because he looked like Jack—though that continued to be deeply unsettling—but because talking to him felt easy in the same dangerous way talking to Jack always did; honesty dripping from their mouths the more tired they got.
Similarly, Sammy studied you for a moment before speaking again. “Are you okay?”
His question caught you off guard. Again, that genuine earnestness they both seemed to have bled through even if Sammy had only met you moments ago.
Your eyes traveled back down to your hands for a second before a half laugh bubbled softly under your breath. “You ever have one of those days where you think maybe everyone should stop needing things from you for like . . . twenty-four hours?”
“Yeah,” Sammy answered. “More than once. My ex-wife used to call me all the time, and I just begged for break.”
It was now your turn to wince. “Logically, I know it’s a terrible mindset to have as someone working in healthcare, but after the fifth screaming family member and the third guy trying to leave with an IV still in his arm, I’m starting to reconsider my commitment to helping people.”
“You’re tired,” he said simply.
“I think cranky is a better term for what I’m feeling right now.”
“You’re human.”
You glanced back up at him. “You know, you’re both annoyingly and suspiciously good at this whole peptalk thing.”
“Me and Jack?”
“Yeah. You have this calm voice thing. It’s irritating.”
Sammy smirked into his coffee cup. “Maybe you just trust guys who look too tired for life.”
“Maybe I need therapy.”
“That too.”
You laughed a bit harder at that than the joke deserved, but exhaustion always made you a bit slaphappy. Once the sound subsided, the two of you fell back into a comfortable silence. Sammy stayed leaned beside the cruiser, quiet in a way that didn’t feel awkward, and you realized that the comfortableness was probably the strangest part of the whole ordeal.
As a senior resident, most people demanded every ounce of energy from you. Conversation. Reassurance. Attention. They picked it all apart until a hollow shell of yourself went home to recharge for another day. But standing here with him felt easy in the same way standing beside Jack did after a nightmare shift. There wasn’t pressure to perform, zero expectation to be cheerful, just silent understanding between two people trying to survive difficult jobs.
Sammy finally glanced toward you again. “Whoever this Jack guy is,” he said casually, “he must be worth confusing strangers over.”
“That’s still up for debate.”
“But you still like him.”
You opened your mouth to argue before realizing you had no real defense against that, and Sammy absolutely noticed. A knowing sort of amusement flashed briefly across his face before he looked back out toward the street and the Pitt again, giving you an out without pressing further.
You sighed dramatically. “Unfortunately I do. He’s annoyingly competent.”
“Dangerous trait to have.”
And he does this thing where he acts like indifferent while actively solving all the problems.”
“Real terrible guy.”
You rolled your eyes fondly. “He’s just the worst.”
Sammy laughed quietly, and you smiled before finally pushing away from the cruiser.
“I should probably head to my car before somebody sees I’m still here and decides they need me to pull a double.”
His eyebrows rose. “Probably.”
“It was nice to meet you, Sammy.”
“Likewise.”
As you started in the direction of the parking lot, Sammy lifted his coffee slightly in farewell.
“And hey,” he called out after a few steps.
You paused and turned back toward him with a raised eyebrow.
“If you run into another one of us,” he said dryly, “maybe lead with the name first!”
Your laugh echoed across the bay as you flipped him the bird to which his boisterous laughter also joined in with yours all the way to the parking lot.
_______________________
By the fifth twelve-hour shift in a row, the Pitt stopped feeling real.
Time blurred through patient rooms. Daylight disappeared without warning. Meals became whatever you could hork down before another trauma alarm went off. Entire conversations slipped from your memory the second someone started coding. By three in the afternoon, the Pitt finally settled into a lapping wave instead of a tsunami, something easier to wade through instead of drown in.
You’d be done in four hours.
That’s all you could think as you found yourself wandering the full surprisingly empty area near radiology with a vending machine coffee clenched in one hand and your pager clipped crookedly to your scrub pants after catching another consult.
The coffee tasted burnt enough to qualify as chemical warfare.
You drank it down anyway.
Your shoulders ached as you rounded the corner toward the quieter hallway leading to imagine, gravity pulled extra heavily at your limbs. Most of the overhead lights had dimmed this far from the trauma bays, leaving the corridor washed in soft blue-gray shadows only broken by the occasional flicker of a light lucky enough to have had its bulbs changed recently.
That was when you spotted Jack sitting alone against the wall near the windows.
Your steps slowed automatically.
Even half-curled into one of the uncomfortable chairs that had been brought in from check-in, you found the familiar dark curls along his forehead and broad shoulders hunched beneath a black sweatshirt. His long legs stretched out in front of him while his hands rested loosely clasped together between his knees.
Your mind should have caught up by now that there was a 95 percent chance that the Jack in front of you was not actually Jack. The past two times, the odds had been against you. Even as you approached, you honestly weren’t sure if he actually was Jack.
But his Jack-Abbot shape and Jack-Abbot demeanor mixed with your weighted exhaustion overrode every caution light fast enough you continued to walk steadily towards him.
“You know handoff’s not for another four hours, right?” you asked tiredly. “Or are you here early again to save the day?”
Jack’s neck twisted as he looked up at you, and for one brief second, your brain short-circuited again.
Three and oh.
You found yourself truly wondering if you had the most absurd luck in finding the men who shared unsettling similarities (hazel eyes, rugged kind of handsomeness, a stillness that carried respect that could command a room) or if you were just unfortunately a Jack-Abbot-doppelganger magnet.
In this instance, you wished for neither because this one looked sad.
Where Jack’s exhaustion usually kept him sharp and tightly wound, this stranger looked just as weighed down as you felt. His expression stayed completely unreadable as he stared at you, hazel eyes fixed so intently on your face that you had stopped walking altogether.
You paused in front of him. “Oh no,” you whispered. “I did it again.”
The man continued staring at you silently, and you stared back. After a beat, he slowly tilted his head just slightly to one side in a movement so subtle it almost felt animal-like. Your stomach dropped.
“I’m going to take a wild guess and say you’re name isn’t Jack.”
Still, he said nothing; such a stark difference from Brett’s flirty amusement and Sammy’s conversational abilities. He just watched you.
You laughed weakly into the silence. “Okay, statistically this is getting insane.”
He blinked once before his gaze dropped briefly to the coffee in your hand before lifting back to your face. “Is that good?”
His voice was the thing to catch you off guard. Where Jack could bark orders quicker than he could blink, this man spoke slowly, careful with his words like he though each one over before letting it leave his mouth.
A startled exhale flew from your mouth. “No. But, I think I’m legally dead at this point, so what I put in my body really doesn’t matter.”
Another long pause settled in the space between you, and he didn’t seem bothered at all by it. If anything, he seemed pretty comfortable inside it unlike everyone else you knew (including yourself).
You shifted your weight awkwardly. “Sorry. Again. I thought you were someone else.”
He methodically nodded once, already having figured that part out. “The same someone else?”
“Damn, there’s enough resemblance now that people are starting to notice patterns.” You glanced toward an empty chair beside him before looking into his eyes with uncertainty. “Can I sit, or will I disturb the quiet zen you have going on back here?”
Another pause.
“You can sit.”
You lowered yourself carefully into the chair beside him, fatigue instantly sinking deeper into your bones the second you stopped moving. The burnt-gas-tasting coffee warmed your palms while the quiet hallway stretched around you, distant hospital noises muffled enough to sound almost unreal this far away from the Pitt.
Beside you, the stranger sat perfectly still like he was scared to breach an invisible wall of containment. After a few moments, you began to noticed the differences between him and Jack. He avoided looking directly at the lights. His fingers slowly rubbed against each other every few seconds like he needed the repetitive motion to stay grounded. He kept a careful distance between himself and you.
“Are you waiting on somebody?” you asked gently.
His eyes shifted toward you, intense enough that it almost felt like physical pressure.
“My brother,” he answered after a second. “He got hurt.”
Concern softened through your exhaustion. “Is he okay?”
He gave another small shrug. “He’s alive.”
His words may have been flat, but you could sense the ache badly enough that you heard it anyway.
You nodded. “That’s usually a good start around here. Can’t do much on a dead guy.”
A small almost-smile curled his lip.
You took a small sip of your coffee and grimaced before the liquid even reached your throat. “Holy fuck that’s terrible.”
His eyes looked down at the cup.
“How can anyone call this coffee when it tastes like somebody filtered dirty water through cigarette ash,” you informed him.
He stared at you for a half second longer than most people would have before asking unexpectedly, “Why are you still drinking it?”
You giggled softly. “Because I still have a few patients to get through before handoffs.”
“Oh.”
“Yeah. I feel the same way.”
A silence settled again, soft and comfortable where you found yourself glancing sideways at him occasionally while you sat there. Up close, the resemblance to Jack somehow became even more unfair. However, you guessed this is how Jack looked around 10 years ago with brownish-red hair and fewer wrinkles. But yet, the same feeling that both men carried too much responsibility around like extra weight strapped to their shoulders pulled at your heartstrings.
Also, where Jack’s emotions tended to sit close to the surface—irritation, protectiveness, frustration—this man kept everything buried so deeply you almost wondered if he realized that his expressions gave him away at all. Because despite how blank his face stayed while he either stared at the floor or stared at you, his eyes were devastatingly easy to read.
Lonely, your brain supplied.
You tore your eyes away. “So,” you said quietly after a while, “do you have a name, or should I keep mentally referring to you as Not Jack the Third?”
He pursed his lips. “Andrew.”
No nickname.
Not even a last name.
Just Andrew.
You smiled faintly. “Well, Andrew, for what it’s worth, you’re significantly less judgmental about mistaken identity than the last two.”
“The last two?”
“Long story.”
He nodded once like that answer satisfied him completely. Another few minutes passed quietly before your pager suddenly buzzed against your hip hard enough to make you jump. Andrew’s eyes tracked the movement carefully.
“Do you need to go help people?”
“Yep. Part of the job’s charm.”
“You’re tired.”
“There’s no rest for the wicked.” Your head tilted. “Or me for that matter.”
He looked at you again with that same strange, steady focus. “You should sleep more.”
“You sound like Jack.”
Andrew tilted his head slightly. “Is that good?”
“Yeah,” you answered softly. “It’s very good.”
His gaze lingered on your face for another long moment before he finally looked away first. You stood slowly from the chair, adjusting your pager against your waistband.
“I should go save the hospital from itself,” you muttered sarcastically.
Andrew nodded once. Then, just before you turned away completely, his voice stopped you again. “You looked happier when you talked about him . . . your Jack.”
You blinked before slowly looking back at him. Andrew sat exactly where you’d left him, hands loosely clasped together, sad eyes fixed on you under the dim hallway lights. He wasn’t flirting or trying to charm you; he was just stating something he’d noticed. His honesty hit harder than it probably should have.
You smiled warmly back at him. “Have a good rest of your day, Andrew.”
His gaze followed you all the way down the hallway until you disappeared around the corner and back into the Pitt.
_______________________
By now, you should have known better.
Key words: should have.
Three separate incidents should have been enough to teach your brain not to immediately trust broad shoulders and tired hazel eyes in low lighting, and yet apparently your never-ending exhaustion had burned away whatever survival instincts you normally possessed. At this point, the universe seemed committed to producing endless variations of the same emotionally damaged man just to see how many times you’d embarrassed yourself before learning.
Unfortunately, tonight really wasn’t helping your judgment.
Rain hammered steadily against your windshield as you pulled into the near-empty parking garage attached to the hospital, the concrete levels echoing faintly with the sound of tires and distant thunder. Your night shift was supposed to start soon, give or take an hour, but a last-minute emergency surgery had called you in early just in case Jack was held up or if the rain got too much for you to drive safely in.
All you wanted was to get inside, get your Dunkin from Shen, and live through this shift so that your following two days off were nothing but pure paradise.
Instead, you killed the engine and sat there for a second staring blankly through the rain-streaked windshield while tiredness settled heavy behind your eyes.
The parking garage was mostly empty this late at night. Lights buzzed overhead, washing the concrete levels in pale gray while rainwater dripped steadily from the ceiling near the ramps. Somewhere farther down the row, a radio played faintly form another parked car.
You grabbed your bag from the passenger seat with a tired sigh before climbing out into the cold damp air. The moment you were at full height, you spotted Jack leaning against one of the concrete support pillars a few rows over. You froze, hand still gripping your car door.
At this point, his face shouldn’t have been as shocking as it was, your stomach dropping every single time you got to lay eyes on him and his salt-and-pepper curls and sexy build partially hidden under a dark jacket while one hand rested causally in his pocket.
The faintest hint of This is probably another horrifyingly convincing copy of him. And honestly, who even knew anymore.
Jack glanced up at you as you started to walk; your footsteps echoed slightly. His face was partially shadowed by the buzzing lights. And before your brain could fully catch up, your own mouth betrayed you first.
Et tu, Brute?
“If you turn out to be another stranger, I’m actually gonna lose my mind.”
Jack’s eyebrows lifted slightly before the corner of his mouth curled into something that looked far too pleased.
“Well now,” he drawled, voice salted with a southern accent that instantly threw you off balance, “that ain’t usually how good-looking women start conversations with me.”
You stopped short, because absolutely nothing about that voice sounded like Jack or confident Brett or sweet Sammy or quiet Andrew. This one was different with something slick underneath his drawl like he found the entire interaction entertaining before it had even properly started.
“Oh no,” you muttered under your breath, arms wrapping around your middle to somehow protect you from his eyes.
The now stranger pushed off the pillar slowly, watching you with open amusement as he stepped fully into the lights. And unfortunately, the resemblance to Jack got worse the closer he got. Same face shape? Check. Same hazel eyes? Check (but his sent the wrong kind of chill up your spine).
However, unlike the others, this man looked at you like he already knew exactly how attractive he was, and that automatically made him the worst one to be around.
You narrowed your eyes suspiciously. “Gotta take a wild guess and say your name isn’t Jack Abbot.”
A wild grin slowly spread across his face. “No, ma’am but sounds like I oughta thank him for the introduction.”
You actually groaned aloud. “I cannot keep doing this.”
“Doin’ what?”
“Finding men who all have the same face.”
“That so?”
“Yes, and frankly it’s getting psychologically damaging.”
The stranger laughed softly, low and self-satisfied enough to make your skin prickle slightly. The same quiet internal warning that told you when patients were about to become aggressive before security even notices was sending a tingle up your arms.
You shifted your bag higher on your shoulder. “Okay. Great. Nice meeting you, mysterious parking garage man, but I’m gonna go before this gets more embarrassing for me.”
“Funny,” he said casually, “seems like you started this conversation pretty confident.”
You paused. “That was before you spoke.”
His grin widened somehow. “Little disappointed?”
“Concerned, actually. Very concerned.”
He laughed again, stepping away from the pillar entirely. “Damn, darlin’. You always this mean to strangers?”
The nickname landed wrong in your chest. Just the way he said it felt off. It wasn’t flirty, it was possessive, almost like he’d skipped straight past normal conversation and decided familiarity for himself. It all felt wrong; he felt wrong. Caution slowly sharpened under your exhaustion.
Still, you forced a polite smile. “Only the ones lurking dramatically in a hospital parking garage.”
He pouted, bottom lip jutted out dramatically. “You hurt my feelings a little.”
“You’ll survive.”
“Oh, I think I will.” His hazel eyes trailed up and down your body while he spoke.
Your stomach tightened faintly. This man felt dangerous in a way that had nothing to do with physical violence and everything to do with manipulation. Every work out of his mouth seemed like he’d already calculated it before he said it. The others had felt human and even awkward at times, but they had been grounded below it all.
This one, you understood a bit too late, was that he’d realized you were uncomfortable almost immediately and was enjoying watching you squirm under eyes that normally made you feel safe.
He tilted his head slightly, eyes moving over your face with unsettling ease. “So this Jack guy,” he said conversationally, “boyfriend?”
You sneered. “That’s none of your business.”
“Mhm.”
“Do you ask invasive questions to every woman you meet in parking garages?”
“Only the pretty little ones.”
You physically recoiled a little. “Ew.”
Somehow that only amused him more. “Do you always look this suspicious, or am I special?”
“You’re definitely something.”
Another slow grin spread across his face, but his eyes stayed sharp and watchful. You took a small step backward instinctively, and his gaze dropped to the movement. The awful feeling that he noticed everything tightened your chest.
“You got a name?” he asked.
Normally, under any other circumstance, you would’ve answered immediately. But something stopped you this time. The hesitation must have shown on your face because sick amusement flashed across his face and morphed into a look of interest.
“Smart girl,” he murmured.
Your spine stiffened.
The man straightened slightly before offering you a lazy, sleazy half-smile. “Terry. Terry McCandless.”
You nodded once carefully. “Okay . . . Terry. I’m gonna leave now.”
“Before tellin’ me yours?”
“Yes.”
His eyebrows lifted slightly at your blunt answer before he laughed under his breath, shaking his head like you’d surprised him. “Well,” he drawled, “now I’m definitely curious.”
You started backing slowly toward the Pitt, grip tightening around your bag’s strap. Terry noticed that too. For one long second, neither of you spoke. Rain echoed heavily through the garage, the entire level suddenly feeling far too empty. Terry tilted his head slightly again, studying you with blatant interest.
“You know,” he said casually, “most women would’ve already left.”
You forced a smile that didn’t quite reach your eyes. “Most women probably have better instincts than I do.”
“Mm.” His gaze lingered on you another second too long, so unlike how Andrew had watched you with a quiet curiosity. Here, Terry looked at you like he was hungry. “I don’t think that’s true.”
Suddenly, you understood with startling clarity exactly how dangerous his personality could become with the wrong person.
You took another step backward. “Goodnight, Terry.”
He smiled again, easy and handsome and entirely untrustworthy. “Night, darlin’.”
You didn’t breathe properly again until you got through the doors leading to the Pitt. And even then, as you walked down the hall and took a glance back toward the concrete pillar where he’d been standing, Terry was watching you the whole time.
_______________________
You hated when Robby voluntold you to attend hospital fundraising events.
The Pitt survived on donations almost as much as caffeine and trauma surgeons with superiority complexes. New equipment, expanded programs, research grants: all of it depended on wealthy people occasionally deciding to feel generous for tax purposes. However, that didn’t mean you wanted to spend your Friday night pretending to enjoy lukewarm champagne while hospital executives paraded donors around like show dogs ranked somewhere below “paperwork” and slightly above “food poisoning” on your list of favorite activities.
The ballroom glittered obnoxiously around you, gold light reflecting off crystal chandeliers while a string quartet played softly near the stage. Doctors mingled through clusters of wealthy sponsors in expensive dresses and tailored tuxedos, all perfectly polished smiles and practiced networking.
Meanwhile, you stood near the bar in horrifically high heel that you knew were actively trying to murder your feet and wondered if you could fake your own death before dessert was served.
“You look positively thrilled to be here,” a familiar, deep voice sounded behind you, causing you to sigh in desperate relief.
Without even turning around, you lifted your champagne flute toward him. “Jack, I swear if you’re actually not you and just another man with your face, I’m walking directly off the roof of this hotel.”
“Well now I’m interested.”
Your stomached dropped as you turned around slowly.
At this point, it honestly felt biblical like a divine comedy staring you as the leading role.
The resemblance hit just as hard as the others had: same hazel eyes, same shoulder width, same cutting-edge jawline, same good looks that apparently existed in endless horrifying variations across Pittsburgh. But where Brett had been charming and Sammy had been grounding and Andrew had carried that quiet sadness around him like a shadow and Terry had been intensely creepy, this man looked completely insane.
Sure, he exuded a I’m probably the wealthiest mother fucker in this room attitude. His black tuxedo was tailored perfectly across his shoulders, curls styled to perfection away from his face, large ring-adorned hands holding a crystal whiskey glass. He was rich, polished, and handsome enough that half the women in the ballroom had probably already given him bedroom eyes twice.
But there was something deeply unwell behind the hazel glint.
He smiled slowly. “How many of us are there?”
You stared at him in exhausted belief. “Enough that I’m considering neurological testing.”
“How funny it is that you’ve met them all.”
“I wouldn’t say funny. One of your little clones in a parking garage looked like he might actually kill me to swing a jury.”
Instead of reacting like a normal human being—wincing or flashing sympathy—the man had the audacity to laugh a rich, warm, delighted sound that absolutely did not match the deeply unsettling energy radiating off of him.
“Oh, I already like you,” he announced.
You took a cautious sip of champagne. “Somehow that made me less comfortable instead of more.”
“I get that a lot.”
You hummed. “Yes, I’m sure you do.”
He stepped closer easily, like your personal space was more of a suggestion than a rule. “And what exactly did this Jackdo to earn so such a reaction?”
“His face apparently exists just to humiliate me in public.”
“Do you seek his face out often?”
“Seems like it’s seeking me out more.”
“Ah. One of those situations.”
Your eyes narrowed questionably. “You say that like you know what I mean.”
“I know what obsession looks like, little dove.” Before you could respond, he extended his whiskey glass slightly toward you in a mock toast. “Titus Danforth.”
Oh.
Oh no.
For the first time, you actually recognized the same; not personally, obviously, but the Danforth family practically owned half the city at this point. Generational wealth that seems sketchy with endless political influence and charities where people pretended billionaires cared about humanity because they funded pediatric wings occasionally.
You straightened your shoulders and mused over his name in your mouth. “You’re that Danforth.”
His grin widened. “Now, don’t sound too accusatory, or I might think you have a deep resentment towards me already.”
“Who’s to say I haven’t always had a deep resentment.”
“Good.” He took another sip from his glass without breaking eye contact. “Most people here are too scared to insult me directly.”
“And that doesn’t concern you?”
“It mostly entertains me.”
You glanced toward the ballroom crowd again, briefly trying to find Robby and considering escape routes. However, Titus seemed to carry Terry’s unnaturally uncanny ability to notice things like that.
“Relax,” he drawled lazily. “You look like I’m planning to sacrifice you to Satan or something.”
A chill ran up your spine. “Are you?”
He looked down at you over his nose. “I’m still deciding on that.”
You blinked at hi, slowly. “I’m sorry. What?”
Titus looked downright delighted by being one the receiving end of your scrunched up face. “Oh, come on. You’re at a billionaire fundraiser. You have to know at least half these people are one blood ritual away from immortality.”
A look of horror washed over your face as your blood ran cold. He stared back, visibly trying not to laugh.
“You’re joking,” you finally decided on with a small, uncomfortable laugh.
“That’s the fun part.” He tilted his head slightly. “You really can never tell.”
Oh, absolutely not.
Every single alarm bell in your body started ringing simultaneously in a way that hadn’t happened yet. See, Terry hadn’t felt as dangerous as he was calculated and manipulative. Titus felt like mad chaos draped in designer fabric, like someone had handed a deeply unstable man unlimited money and simply hoped for the best.
“You have the exact same face as someone I trust,” you informed him cautiously, “and you’re doing irreparable damage the longer this conversation continues.”
“How will you ever recover?”
“Hopefully the moment we go our separate ways.”
Titus laughed softly again before gesturing out toward the ballroom. “So, what’s your role here? Underpaid attending? Morally exhausted nurse? One of those residents constantly on the verge of collapse?”
“You guessed all of those so confidently it’s a bit concerning.”
“I donate to hospitals constantly, and I’ve watched enough caffeine addictions develop in real time to identify the species.”
Despite yourself, a small giggle escaped, to which Titus noticed instantly. And the look on his face afterward morphed into something even more dangerous.
“So you are capable of laughing,” he murmured. “You look less miserable when you do that.”
The words hit unexpectedly hard because Andrew had said almost the exact same thing days earlier. However, when Andrew said it, it sounded like he did out of a deep concern, but when Titus said it, it sounded like you were a small bug under a microscope. Apparently, this entire cursed lineup shared one collective personality trait, and it was psychoanalyzing you against your will.
You pointed at him. “No. You don’t get to do that.”
His eyebrows lifted innocently. “Do what?”
“You are not allowed to suddenly become emotionally observant when you were just talking about devil sacrifice thirty seconds ago.”
“Is it a sin to be attentive?”
“It’s a sin to act like you care when obviously I’m merely just a game to you.”
Titus grinned into his glass. “Oh, I definitely like you.”
Before you could spit back another insult, another man suddenly appeared beside you with the kind of smooth interruption that felt almost rehearsed. You silently thanked everything that could hear you when the familiar height towered over you.
“There’s my favorite resident,” Robby announced as he took your right side.
You glanced over at him and tried not to melt at the sight of his navy suit that looked slightly less expensive than Titus’s but worn with significantly more exhaustion in the way Robby existed in. His expression softened as he looked down at you. You could have hugged him on sight.
Robby’s brown eyes, normally filled with kindness, bore fiery into Titus’s. “You don’t mind if I borrow her for a moment, do you? I think one of our department heads was looking into speaking to us on behalf of our emergency department.”
His lie was painfully obvious but deeply appreciated on your side. You started stepping away before Titus could start another conversation about ritual sacrifice, however, the sound of his voice made you pause and look back just as Titus was pulling out a sleek black checkbook from inside his tuxedo jacket.
Double oh no.
He scribbled something quickly before tearing the check free and holding it out toward you between two fingers. “For your hospital.”
You stared down at the number and tried not to faint on the spot.
“Titus—”
“What?” He looked genuinely amused now. “You people keep fixing rich idiots after yacht accidents. Consider it gratitude.”
“That is way too much money.”
“Probably.”
“You cannot casually hand people checks equivalent to a small lakeside house in Italy.”
“Sure I can.” His lips twitched into a smirk. “Watch me.”
You hesitated before slowly taking in.
Robby clanged at the amount over your shoulder and physically winced. “Holy fuck. Gloria’s going to be floored.”
Titus lifted his glass again with a lazy smile. “See? Devil worship pays well.”
You backed away after that. “Okay. I’m going to leave before you buy me a cursed mansion that makes me blow up or something.”
“How did you know that was next on my list?”
“It seemed very on brand.”
Thankfully, Robby took the break in conversation to steer you safely toward the other side of the ballroom, champagne still in one hand and a horrifyingly large Danforth charity check in the other.
Once the gap was large enough, Robby leaned down enough to whisper, “Tell me I’m not seeing things, and that he didn’t look exactly like Jack.”
You let out a large, exasperated sigh. “Robby, you have no idea.”
_______________________
At this point, you genuinely believed the universe was mocking you. There was no other sane explanation for the past few weeks.
One doppelgänger had been weird coincidence territory. Two had been unsettling. Three had crossed into psychological combat. Four had nearly gotten you murdered in a parking lot. And the fifth had tried to recruit you into what might’ve been a satanic cult before handing you a charity donation large enough to make a hospital board cry (Gloria did indeed faint as well).
You were simply done.
Officially. Completely. Done.
Which was exactly why, when you stepped out of the hospital just after sunrise (the result of a last-minute night-shift swap) and spotted a familiar figure leaning against the hood of a dark truck across the street, your immediate reaction wasn’t relief but unequivocal annoyance.
The city still looked half-asleep around you, pale morning light stretching across damp pavement while your exhausted coworkers shuffled toward their cars clutching coffee cups like lifelines. Your overnight shift had run disastrously long, leaving you tired enough that your thoughts felt wrapped in cotton. The added lack of a Jack Abbot didn’t do well to settle any wants of seeing the man again with your own two eyes.
And standing there beneath the weak gold light of sunrise was yet another salt and pepper-curly-haired man with nice shoulders and light hazel eyes.
Unbelievable.
You didn’t even break stride this time.
“Nope,” you called out while crossing the sidewalk. “Absolutely not. I’m not doing this again. You can’t pay me enough.”
The Jack-a-like straightened at the sound of your voice.
You pointed at him warningly before he could speak. “I don’t care if you’re emotionally repressed, weirdly observant, secretly corrupt, or involved in a ritual sacrifice. I’m done talking to Jack Abbot doppelgangers.”
A long silence followed before he said one word.
“What?”
You frowned at his voice and the way it felt familiar in your ears. None of the others had ever quite managed to get Jack’s timber down correctly. Your steps slowed, and the man pushed away from the truck fully now, confusion pulling at his features while dark circles sat heavily beneath his eyes like he hadn’t slept in days.
Your chest tightened achingly so, because that—that was Jack Abbot, actually Jack Abbot.
Your Jack.
For one horrible second, your brain refused to process it properly. After weeks of running into twisted reflections of him everywhere, seeing the real thing suddenly felt almost unreal itself. It made you suspicious.
You scoffed at him. “Okay. Which one are you?”
Jack stared at you with somehow even more confusion, your name coming out oddly through his lips. “Excuse me?”
“The firefighter was flirty. The cop was emotionally stable. The quiet one stared at me like a sad shelter dog in one of those ASPCA commercials. The southern one was definitely corrupt. And the rich one threatened me with devil worship.” You pointed accusingly at him. “So what’s your thing, and please make it quick because I obviously need more than six hours of sleep.”
Jack stared at you in complete silence.
“. . . You met a rich version of me?”
“You have no idea how bad this has gotten.”
“Sweetheart, what are you talking about?”
The utter bewilderment in his face finally settled something inside you, because none of the others had ever looked at you like that.
Brett had looked entertained.
Sammy had looked understanding.
Adnrew had looked curious and quietly lonely.
Terry had looked scheming.
Titus had looked delighted with a new play thing.
But Jack?
Jack looked at you like he’d been waiting long enough out here for you to start getting worried, like seeing you finally emerge from the Pitt had made him relax just enough. Suddenly, it all clicked at once.
“Oh.”
Jack’s brow furrowed deeper. “What?”
“You’re actually him.”
“Yeah?” He sounded almost offended. “Who else would I be?”
A helpless laugh escaped you before you could stop it as you visibly deflated, exhaustion and pure relief tangling together so suddenly it made your eyes sting.
Jack took a step closer, your name falling from his chest. “Hey. You okay?”
His immediate instinct to take care of you was what did it. It wasn’t his face or his voice or his tired eyes or broad shoulders or any of the things that the other had shared. His concern for your wellbeing that had seemingly been stitched directly into his bloodstream no matter how tired he got. Your throat tightened unexpectedly.
Jack’s expression softened as he moved closer. “What happened?”
“You happened,” you informed him weakly.
“That really didn’t explain anything.”
“It does in my head.”
“Which is terrifying.”
You laughed again softly, rubbing tiredly at your face before looking back up at him. Now that the real Jack stood in front of you, the differences felt almost embarrassingly obvious. Brett had been warm but too easygoing; Sammy had been grounding in a way that felt comforting but oddly distant; Andrew had carried gentleness around him so openly it hurt to look at; Terry had weaponized familiarity until it felt dangerous; and Titus had turned charm into performance art.
But above all, Jack felt safe.
Even as he was standing there exhausted and grumpy in front of you sleep-deprived with yesterday’s hoodie thrown over a wrinkled scrub top, something about him always made your world quiet enough to where it felt manageable, like you could get anything done without worrying about the next moment.
You stared at him for a long moment before realizing he was still waiting for an explanation. So, unfortunately, your exhausted brain chose honest-to-God honesty.
“You know what the worst part was?” you asked softly.
Jack crossed his arms in front of his chest. “I’m scared to answer that.”
“They all looked like you.” You voice quieted slightly. “But none of them were you.” You glanced away, trying to organize thoughts that had apparently been building for weeks now. “Brett was nice. Sammy was . . . easy to talk to. Andrew was sweet in this sad kind of way. Even the crazy rich one was weirdly funny.” You huffed out a tired laugh. “And every single time I kept thinking maybe that was why my brain kept confusing them for you.”
He stayed quiet.
“But each time, they failed horribly at being Jack Abbot for longer than a two-sentence introduction.” You looked back up at him with glassy eyes. “Because all they had was just your face. They didn’t have the way you make everything feel less awful when you walk into a room. They didn’t have the way you pay attention to people even when you pretend that you’re annoyed. They didn’t have the way I never have to wonder if I’m safe with you.”
Jack looked caught off guard.
“I kept meeting all these parallel versions of you,” you continued softly, exhaustion making everything spill easier than normal, “and every time something still felt missing.” Your mouth twitched faintly. “Turns out it was just . . . you.”
He kept quiet for a long moment as the morning traffic hummed somewhere down the street while patients and employees alike trickled from the Pitt’s doors. You bit your bottom lip, waiting with anticipation for him to say something.
Finally, very quietly, he spit out, “You compared me to a satanic billionaire before saying all that.”
A tired giggled burst out so suddenly it nearly doubled you over. “You can’t believe how thankful I am that it’s actually you this time.”
Jack shook his head slowly, but you caught the way his mouth softened slightly. “C’mere.”
The words barely left his mouth before he was reaching for you, hand gripping your forearm lightly before pulling you forward against his chest with the kind of familiarity that made your entire body finally relax for the first time in days.
That was another difference too.
None of the others had ever felt like home.
You buried your face against his chest with a tired groan. “If another man with your face talks to me this week, I’m filing a police report.”
Jack’s chest shook slightly beneath your cheek. “Again me?”
“Wouldn’t be entirely you,” you mumbled. “Just your face.”
A quiet laugh rumbled through him before his hand settled against the back of your head.
“C’mon,” he murmured. “I’m taking you home before you start hallucinating more versions of me.”
You tilted your head back just enough to look up at him. “You promise you’re the real one?”
Jack stared down at you for one long second.
“Did any of them kiss you?”
A blooming warmth covered your face. “What?”
“The firefighter,” he said evenly. “The cop. Satan guy.” His jaw tightened. “Did any of them kiss you?”
“No,” you admitted quietly. “Wouldn’t let them either because they weren’t you.”
His hand slid gently against your jaw before he kissed you like he’d been thinking about it the entire conversation. His lips felt warm; the kiss careful and tired in the same way you both were but all the same steady.
When he finally pulled back slightly, your forehead resting against his, nose brushing along the skin right under his eye, you smiled weakly.
“Okay,” you said softly out of breath. “Yeah. Definitely the real one.”
Jack laughed quietly against your mouth. “Are you 100 percent sure?”
You pretended to think for a second before shaking your head. “Nope. Gotta kiss you again just to be sure.”
He smirked before pulling you back into another soft kiss.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality
Anya is LIVE right now
FREE
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Watching Robby sit on his bike and use his shirt to wipe sweat off his face, revealling his squishy, hairy, sexy belly was really all it took…
Words: 7,9k (I can't just be normal, ever)
Content: Older Man/Yonger Woman (Reader is late 20s, Robby is in his fifty), Robby is a dick but reader is lowkey into it, belly riding, degradation, verbal humiliation, light dom/sub, daddy kink, PiV sex, rough sex, hair pulling, oral sex (f receiving), semi-public bj
This is just smut. I have no excuses for this. I was encouraged.
No use of Y/N
Read on Ao3 or below the cut:
It was a shit day in the Pitt.
When asked about your day, that was always your reply.
The patients were either monumentally stupid, disrespectful, verbally abusive assholes, intoxicated to the point they could not even hear the questions you asked, or the most precious, sweetest people ever - and the sweet, precious ones were always the sickest.
It was a cruel running gag of the universe, you were sure of it. The stupid assholes survived, and the sweet grandmas who called you hun and made you compliments, the polite single mums tearing themselves apart to keep their children’s worlds whole, died.
PTMC was chronically underfunded, the staff chronically overworked, running on shitty coffee, insomnia, saviour complexes and fumes, and the air conditioning unit perpetually shit.
What was there to love about this job?
You sat on the low wall by the ambulance bay, tucked away from the chaos of the ER against the corner by the wall with your knees drawn up to your chest and your head resting against the brick wall behind you.
It was your own personal little safe haven.
Everyone on staff had one.
Trinity and Dennis had the break room. Donnie and Jessy the hallways leading down into the subbasement where only the generators, central supply and the IT gremlins (as you affectionately called them) hid. Abbot and Robby had the roof.
You had this corner.
You took another sip from the can of soda you held in your lap. The late summer heat was oppressive, squeezing in around you until the air felt too heavy, too thick. The can was sweating as much as you, condensation seeping through the cheap fabric of your scrubs. Your feet were aching, your head too. Your hoodie lay discarded next to you on the wall. The ER itself was freezing cold, but the outside smoldering, and the waiting room was somehow even hotter.
ER waiting rooms often defied all laws of physics.
Yeah, when asked about your day, you always replied with shit.
The pay wasn’t enough for the backbreaking labour expected of you to keep the crumbling healthcare system afloat on your compassion and spite alone. The patients were ungrateful or so gut-wrenchingly tragic you couldn’t breathe. You woke in cold sweats most nights, remembering the faces of patients you’d lost years ago. The air conditioning unit might as well have come straight from hell with how it savoured torturing you. You were still paying off student loans and would continue to do so for many years just to have parents argue with you that vaccines were a hoax, their children lying in the next room as they slowly died from preventable diseases.
And yet, despite it all, you kept coming back. You came back every day. You picked up shifts when colleagues called out. You volunteered for holidays so those who actually had a family could spend the day with them. You stayed longer when the Pitt was swamped.
Perhaps you had some masochistic tendencies (you definitely had those).
Perhaps you were simply insane.
For some inexplicable reason, staying away from the hospital longer than two days in a row drove you mad with boredom. You stood in the front row of every mass casualty, swirling through the ER, past bloodied gurneys and screaming patients, blood pounding in your ears and feeling alive like never before amidst the death and devastation.
There was another perk to being an absolute, hopeless workaholic, and it was currently arriving for his shift.
Robby started riding his new motorcycle to work a few weeks back, and with the shock of PittFest still deep in everyone’s bones, it took a few days for people to even realise. It started with Dana pursing her lips. It ended with you somehow finding time to sneak away for your ‘lunch’ break every day at seven a.m. when Robby arrived for his shift.
He didn’t always notice you sitting on your wall with your packed lunch and ice-cold can of soda, no matter the weather. When he did, he shot you one of his strained, tight-lipped smiles or waved before heading inside to do handovers with Abbot.
You worked the midnight to noon shift, your time at the hospital overlapping with Abbot’s, Shen’s and Robby’s shift, a new system being tested by the hospital to provide greater continuity of care. The second-you worked from noon to midnight.
You didn’t mind.
You got to watch Robby arrive for work and wave him goodbye when you left to go home.
You looked forward to it. To these slammed eight hours you got to see him, be near him, work at his side, sometimes close enough to smell the scent of soap he used still clinging to his skin.
Robby never wore a helmet.
In front of Dana, he pretended he did. When you were around for one of their arguments on the matter, Robby always glanced over to you, sharing a private, conspiratorial smirk with you and winking.
Your knees went weak every single time.
It was pathetic really, how huge your crush on your much older attending had grown.
It started as fawning admiration for his skill and calm even amidst the shittiest, harshest shifts when you were nothing but a flustered med student who, no matter what she did, always stood in the way. When you were a resident, still overwhelmed that you actually got placed with your dream hospital, you worked tirelessly, making it your whole existence to prove to Dr Robby you could be trusted, that you were good, that you’d earned your spot here. That you soaked up everything he taught you. That you had not wasted the time he spent teaching you. You wanted to make him proud. You craved his approval and praise.
You were pathetic.
But when he’d been the first to congratulate you when you passed the boards, and he’d been the one to tell you your application for the attending position at PTMC’s ED had been accepted - those were your most cherished memories…
Robby parked in the same spot as always, close to the entrance of the ambulance bay. Sweat clung to his brow. The corners of his eyes were crinkled from a lifetime of smiling. You wondered when he stopped. What had sucked the joy and happiness out of him? Perhaps it was this job.
I’d make him happy again, that unhelpful, ridiculous little voice in your head whispered. You shoved it away roughly. What did you even have to offer a man at least twenty years your senior?
I’d suck him off so good he’d forget how to breathe.
“Oh my god.” You muttered to yourself, biting the inside of your cheek to fight off the heat creeping up your neck. When had you become such a fucking pervert? Lusting after some old man. Your former teacher. Your boss!
You were still watching Robby, like the unhinged little freak you’d become for him. He was checking his phone, still sitting on his bike. You watched him shove the phone back into the side pocket of his cargo pants and then, as if time had turned to molasses, you watched him shove his hand under the hem of his shirt and lift it up to wipe the sweat off his face and beard.
Your eyes glued themselves to the sight unfolding before you, to Robby’s soft, round stomach on full display, protruding over his belt like the most delicious fucking muffin you’d ever seen. You stared at his sweaty skin, the liberal dusting of coarse dark hair covering it, mouth quite literally watering at the sight.
Robby dropped his shirt again. It caught on his belly, leaving a delicious sliver uncovered, the same slivers you had stolen glances of every time he stretched his back in the ER, causing his scrubs to ride up.
Robby looked up and froze. Your eyes met across the ambulance bay. You couldn’t look away. What was wrong with you? Ogling his belly in public like some- some belly fetishist!
Heat suffused your face and neck, making even the scorching temperatures around you go green with envy.
Robby stared back at you. A slight pink tinge spread across his cheeks. He tugged on his shirt, even when it sat normally again and averted his eyes, twisting his head away with more force than necessary.
You were still staring at him.
You couldn’t stop.
Seeing his naked belly had broken something, fried some essential wiring in your brain, you were sure of it.
Robby didn’t look at you when he stalked past to disappear into the Pitt.
You stayed. Trapped between mortification at being caught ogling him and depraved delight at the sight that had burnt itself into your retinas.
This was not good.
This was not at all helpful with regards to your concerning, lecherous crush - though crush was far too tame a word to describe the absolutely filthy thoughts that came to haunt you every time you lay down in bed to catch some sleep between shifts.
You finished your soda, ate the last of your ‘lunch’ while desperately trying to remember how to act normal before heading back inside.
The scent of Robby’s aftershave, still fresh in the morning, still hung in the air. You felt yourself blush again. Oh god. You were fucked. You were so royally, monumentally FUCKED.
I want to fuck him.
“Oh my god, shut the fuck up.” You hissed to yourself.
Dana shot you an incredulous look over the edge of her glasses, one brow raised, no doubt seeing the blush still darkening your skin when you went to check the board. You forced yourself not to look for Robby before grabbing a tablet to throw yourself back into the ER madness - a mistake, you realised as you turned around and collided with another person.
A solid, soft, very good-smelling person.
“Dr- Dr Robby.” You muttered, backing away quickly. Could this day get any worse?
You looked up on reflex - it was impossible not to look at Robby, not to look for Robby, but all you could think about as you were peering up at your old mentor and object of all your desires was how you would ride your pillow tonight while thinking about the mouth-watering show he’d inadvertently put on for you this morning.
Your blush only darkened further.
Had you been any more sane in the moment, you’d have noticed Robby’s own flushed skin, or the fidgedy, uneasy energy surrounding him.
Dana looked from you to him and promptly decided she was not paid enough to deal with whatever was going on between the two attendings.
You were called away to one of your cases and quickly ducked around Robby to scurry away, taking all your perverted thoughts and shame with you.
Good thing mind-readers don’t exist. And in case they do, please don’t tell on me.
Your shift dragged on, tugging you along at the most infuriating, pointless pace ever. You liked your shift time slot. You liked that you got to spend one half with the nightshift crew and the second half with the dayshift. Nights were slower and somewhat calmer but also batshit crazy. Days were turbulent and demanding. You never wanted to go back to twelve uninterrupted hours of this shit ever again. Eight were more than enough.
You’d been avoiding Robby, and you’d almost made it to the end of your shift without interacting with him. You’d even voluntarily exiled yourself to chairs.
Just another hour to go before you could slink out, taking your shame with you and hopefully, hopefully Robby would have forgotten all about this by tomorrow. Or at least you could both pretend it had never happened.
You swirled around at the sound of your name being called - and cursed.
Robby made his way through the flow of staff and patients towards you.
“A word.” It was a question. He pushed the door to an empty exam room open and, hanging your head in defeat and embarrassment, you ducked under his arm and slipped into the room. Robby followed. The door fell shut. The chaos and noise of the ER faded away, leaving you alone with your stupid blush and stupid, feral thoughts and rapid heartbeat pounding in your ears.
Robby towered over you with his arms crossed, ridiculously tall and handsome and looking at you with that stern, sexy disappointed-teacher-look. You both shrunk under it and internally purred like a cat getting exactly what it wanted. He tilted his head and tipped it forward, looking down at you with those delicious dark puppy eyes-
“I expected more professionalism from you. If you have an issue, I thought you would have enough respect for me to bring it up with me personally, instead of doing this fucking charade of playing cat and mouse!”
Your eyes flicked down to his belly. Your severely unhelpful brain supplied pictures of you kneeling in front of him, feeling his belly against your forehead, choking on his cock while he berated you in exactly that tone.
Robby hissed your name. You flinched, head whipping up to meet his eyes again.
I’m no better than a man.
“I-” You mumbled unhelpfully, unsure of how to save yourself from the mess you were sinking into deeper and deeper the longer you were alone with him.
He was still going. Working himself up into a right frenzy while tearing into you in this new stress-fuelled way of his he never used to do before. You remember well how he knocked a former R4, who’d long since moved to another hospital after making attending, down a peg for shouting at you so hard after you made a harmless mistake you started crying and hyperventilating.
He was a very different man back then.
Not that you minded this new, rougher, meaner version of him.
“I know I am not the youngest man anymore-” An edge of insecurity slipped into his voice. “-but you are a doctor for Christ’s sake! I didn’t do anything inappropriate, so I don’t get what the fuck is going on with you that you can’t even do your fucking job today! Are you thinking about going to HR? Gloria? Is that it? Some snowflake shit about not being able to see some skin without getting offended?”
He was still going.
I want you to call me a filthy slut while I ride your sexy belly.
Silence.
No-
Oh god no-
“Did I say that-”
“Yep.”
You wanted to disappear. To stop existing. Better yet, for you to never have existed in the first place.
“I-” Your mouth went dry, so dry that every swallow felt like trying to force sand down your throat. “Fuck- I’m sorry-” You hid your face behind your hands and fought against the tears burning in your eyes.
Fuck.
Fucking stupid.
How could a decently smart person - and you had to at least be decently smart to have made it through med school and residency - be so fucking stupid?!
“Dr Robby, please- I-”
You bolted out of the room, leaving behind a stunned, slightly flushed Robby.
***
It was almost eight pm when a knock on your door tore you from your spiralling thoughts that shifted from berating yourself to considering resignation - because what else was there left to do at this point?
You’d stayed hidden in chairs until your shift was over and used the noon rush of people using their lunch break to see a doctor to slip out without bumping into Robby.
You barely slept, and you still had not decided whether you’d be showing up for your shift at midnight.
Peering through the peephole made your blood run cold.
Robby.
A dishevelled, sweaty, irritated-looking Robby. At your door.
You opened the door a crack, hiding behind it with only your head popping out. You felt Robby stare down at you, but you had no bravado left to face him. You didn’t have any bravado. You would have never said that to him, never confessed to your raunchy thoughts and fantasies. You still had no idea how the words slipped out.
“Can we talk?”
You nodded, still not looking up and stepped aside enough for him to slip into your apartment. You shut the door and slunk back down the hall and into the living room, where you sat down on your sofa, curling up into a tight ball with your knees to your chest and a pillow clutched in your arms.
Silence stretched between you, thick and loaded.
“Look…” Robby ran his hands through his hair and slumped down in the armchair on the other side of the coffee table with an audible sigh. “I don’t appreciate being ridiculed.”
Your head snapped up, brows dipping into a frown, lips parting as though to say something, but Robby lifted his hand, cutting you off.
“I made you uncomfortable, and instead of being a man about it and acknowledging it and apologising, I was a dick. That wasn’t right, but paying me back like that? That wasn’t cool either.”
“I- I didn’t-”
Robby snorted, a bitter, self-deprecating sound that sent a pang through your heart. “Right. Because I’m supposed to believe you meant that.”
“I did.” Your voice was a tiny, fragile little thing, bearing the evidence of the hours you’d spent panicking, thinking about what you were supposed to do to fix this, and no negligible amount of crying.
It was Robby’s turn to stare at you, opening and closing his mouth in a futile attempt to come up with something to say.
“I shouldn’t have- I never thought I’d say something like that to you, and that was so inappropriate, and I am sorry, but I won’t sit here and let you claim I was lying. Because I wasn’t.” Your cheeks burnt, but you forced yourself to hold eye contact even when your throat felt as though it was swelling shut.
“You- meant it?”
You nodded.
“You want to ride my belly?”
You looked away. Heat surrounded your face. “I think you look good. Really good.”
“Then you have very questionable taste, kid.”
You put the pillow down and got up, moving past your coffee table to stand in front of Robby. He watched you with a mixture of trepidation and anticipation. You set your knee against the edge of the cushion, right between his spread legs.
“Do you have a problem with my taste?”
Robby whispered your name, a warning that was already hanging on by a thread, brittle, too weak to conceal his own yearning he’d been fighting to keep hidden from you.
You were too young, too pure for him to drag you down with his own messiness and inability to commit. He didn’t care about workplace relationships, he should as department chair and man who’d been frozen out by scorned nurses to the point Dana had to berate everyone involved into restoring some semblance of professionalism, but you- he didn’t want to mess you up, and everything he touched got messed up.
“Maybe it’s not my taste that’s the issue.” You placed your hand against his shoulders, curling the fingers of the other around his chin softly to force him to look at you. “Maybe it’s your perception.”
You bent down further. Robby bristled, taking a sudden, deep inhale. He looked like a man trapped between resisting and breaking, and a wicked, depraved part of you desperately wanted to see him snap.
You dropped to your knees. Robby groaned and pinched the bridge of his nose, trying and failing to resist the temptation of looking at you, watching you huddled between his spread legs in your skimpy sleep shorts and loose shirt that did nothing to conceal the fact you weren’t wearing a bra.
You nuzzled the inside of his thigh with your head while dragging your hands down his chest, over his soft, warm belly-
You bit your lip to stifle a groan. You were too far gone to be embarrassed by how wet you already were for him, how needy and addled with pure, carnal lust that had been building for years, had grown to such devastating heights you apparently blurted it out in the middle of getting your ass handed to you - unfairly - by your attending.
You toyed with the hem of Robby’s scrub top.
“You’re crazy.”
“It would seem that way.” You murmured as you pushed his shirt up, eyes latching onto the delicious sight of soft, warm, hairy flesh. His body looked like the epitome of comfort. Lived-in, functional, not like those overly polished, eating disorder-driven fuck boys that clogged up your timeline on social media and flooded the dating apps, talking about discipline while eating unseasoned chicken with rice and making women feel shit about their very normal, very natural bodies. You could picture yourself curling up against Robby to leech off his warmth at night. Or resting your head on him while he ran his fingers through your hair.
“But since I already made a fucking spectacle of myself at work, I might as well do this.” You pressed your lips against his stomach and bit back a needy moan. Robby’s hand shot up to thread through your hair. He watched you mouth at his belly as if it was the hottest thing you’d ever seen, lavishing kisses and teasing kitten licks all over his squishy flesh.
He could not fathom how someone as pretty as you could ever be attracted to the worst part of him. Though perhaps these days the worst part of him was his steadily worsening temper… not that you seemed especially opposed to that too.
“Can I?” You looked up at him through your lashes.
“What?” Robby struggled to keep up with you, his mind preoccupied with trying to process how he’d ended up in your apartment with you kneeling between his legs and still somehow not to suck his cock.
“Ride your belly.” You painted languid patterns onto his exposed belly with your fingers, kempt nails scraping softly over his skin, making him shiver.
“Yeah.”
His reply came out breathless, without him really thinking about it. You emitted a squeaking noise of pure delight, and any inhibitions he might still have had melted away under it. You got to your feet, shimmying out of your shorts and panties before straddling him. You tugged and pulled impatiently on his shirt, but Robby needed a moment to get over the way your tits were in his face.
His shirt joined your shirts on the ground. Your fingers found their way into his hair and beard, toying with the coarse hair while rolling your hips against him. You stifled a moan against his temple, insides clenching violently around nothing as you dragged your soaked folds over his soft flesh. You applied more pressure, and his flesh gave way for you, allowing you more friction without it hurting or overstimulating your already swollen clit. You felt his hair against your inner thighs and heated flesh, a teasing tickle that sent prickling shivers of desire and need down your spine.
“Robby-” You moaned breathlessly. His face caught in your hands, you tipped his head back and slanted your lips over his. It was a messy kiss, uncoordinated and frankly, pathetically eager.
But was it your fault this sad old man underneath you was so fucking hot it burnt your neurons to just look at him?
After a stunned moment, Robby reciprocated. He cupped the back of your head with one hand while the other settled on the small of your back to pull you closer. He slipped down on the armchair a little, making it easier for you to grind against him.
“Fuck, sweetheart-” He muttered against your lips when you pulled back to gasp for air. “This what you wanted? You young people have some fucking issues…”
You shuddered above him.
Robby’s eyes lit up with mirth.
“Right… no, this is not all you wanted, is it? What was it you said? You want me to call you a filthy slut?”
You could only nod.
“Tell me, baby.” His hands fell to your hips, fingertips digging into your flesh as he pulled you down harder against him. “What is it your deranged mind pictured when you thought about this? Did you get yourself off to the thoughts of an old man’s floppy stomach?”
You nodded again.
“Words, sweetheart. Can’t help you if you don’t talk. Come on, be a big girl and use your words.”
You moaned.
Robby forcibly stilled the movement of your hips.
“I-” You couldn’t meet his eyes. Embarrassment burnt a path up your throat, and for some terrible, filthy reason it turned you on all the more. “You’re pulling my hair, holding my arms behind my back, and degrade me. Sometimes- sometimes you tell me to stroke your cock while I get myself off. To make myself useful.”
Robby inhaled a hissing breath through his teeth.
Slowly, he ran his hand up your spine, just to drag it back down and catch the hem of your shirt. You lift your arms to help him peel it off you. His eyes flicked down to your breasts immediately, mentally cataloguing the sight of you, saving it to his memory.
He threaded his fingers through your hair, palms flush against your scalp, just to curl his fingers, gripping your hair tightly at the root, and you thought you could have come right then, just from finding out Robby knew how to properly pull a girl’s hair.
He caught your wrist and twisted your arm behind your back, just enough to hurt but not so much he would dislocate your shoulder, dragging another stuttering moan from you.
“Go on then.” Robby purred, voice lower than before, eyes dark with hunger. “If you’re getting yourself off by rubbing your little cunt all over me like a fucking slut, you might as well make it worth my while.”
You could barely move. Between the silent threat of your arm twisted behind your back, forcing you to arch your back and lewdly present your breasts to Robby, and his hand in your hair, you were trapped.
It was so much better than you ever thought it would be.
Robby chuckled. “Fucking hell… and here I thought you were this innocent, well-behaved little thing.”
You finally managed to reach the waistband of his pants. It took you several attempts to manage to slip your hand under it, straining in Robby’s grasp and gasping when a movement had your shoulder aching. Robby, all the while, mocked you for struggling, for dripping all over him like a fucking whore, for getting so turned on by being man-handled.
“There you go… see, that wasn’t hard, was it? Pretending to be a useless, dumb bitch isn’t going to get you out of this, sweetheart. You put yourself in this situation, now be a big girl about it, hm-” Robby was cut off by a groan when you managed to close your fingers around his hard length. You tugged, forcing him out of the confines of his boxers. He felt big - long and heavy in your hand. Robby’s grip tightened around your wrist, dragging another stuttering moan from your lips.
You rolled your hips, rutting helplessly against his belly, immobilised by his strong arms around you, his cock throbbing against your palm-
“That’s all you can do? Hm? You get your hand around a cock, and suddenly that brain of yours doesn’t work anymore? Come on, sweetheart, put some effort in it. I thought you were going to make this worth my while? Why should I sit here and watch some whore get off?”
Pleasure pounded through your veins and rose to your head, wrapping your brain into a fuzzy blanket of bliss. Robby’s words made shame and embarrassment skyrocket in your chest. His hand around your wrist, twisting your arm behind your back, had sharp pain shooting through you, gasoline to the already raging storm of desire and need wreaking havoc over you.
“Robby- Robby, fuck- don’t stop-”
Tears clung to your lashes and rolled down your cheeks. Your chest rose and fell with each laboured breath you forced into your lungs. Your skin prickled as though you’d touched a live wire.
Robby’s dark eyes were glued to you, glinting with desire and wonder at the discovery of your own depravity. Never, never would he have expected the bubbly, sweet, innocent girl who’d been his med student all those years ago would get up to shit like this.
In all the years he’d spent pining after you, he never dared to think you would be this fucking perfect for him.
“Are you going to come? Are you seriously going to come from this? Fucking hell, sweetheart… such a disgusting, filthy fucking whore…”
“Y-yes-” You threw your head back, just for him to pull on your hair tighter, force your head back further until your toes were curling and your lips falling open around a suffocated moan. Your hand, already slick with pre-cum, tensed around his throbbing cock. “I’m a disgusting whore- your- your filthy whore- Robby- ah-”
“Oh, mine, are you? Am I to believe you won’t crawl to another man to have him throw you around the second I leave here?”
You tried to nod, but you could barely move your head.
“You can pretend to be a good girl all you want, baby, I don’t fucking believe you.”
“Daddy-”
A shudder tore through Robby, followed by a grin splitting across his face.
“Daddy? Oh ho ho, sweetheart.”
Your cheeks heated up under a fierce, bright red blush spreading across them.
“No no no, don’t you dare pretend you didn’t say that. Jesus, you’re such a fucking mess… no wonder you’re getting off to me tossing you around like you’re nothing but a used cum rag.”
“Robby-”
“No, baby.” Robby let go of your hair just to grab your chin. “No backpaddling now. Address me properly, pet.”
“D-daddy-”
“There you go. So there is some brain in that pretty head of yours after all.”
“Fuck me, daddy- please- ohmygod- I want to come on your dick-”
Robby was too far gone to question anything at this point. He was far too old to act like this, far too old to not waste a single thought of contraception or STIs or just the fact that he was your boss and you were far too young for him.
Robby let go of your arm. He had enough mental wherewithal about him still to ease it out of the uncomfortable position he held it in. He watched you for a second to make sure he’d not done any damage. You might be a little sore tomorrow, but from the way you moved it and rolled your shoulder to shake off the tension clinging to your muscles, he was sure you were fine.
You emitted a surprised squeal when Robby stood up with you in his arms, effortlessly, as though you weighed nothing. He turned you around and pushed you face-first onto the armchair. Your knees sank into the cushion. You clung to the backrest, just for Robby to grab your hair and push your face down. His fingers dug into your side, thumb pressing down on the small of your back viciously until you arched your back for him.
“Fuck- don’t even need any training, huh?”
You felt his blunt head rub through your soaked folds, heard the sharp intake of air he took in your ear as he bent over you, his front moulding to your back, belly pressed flush against your back-
“Keep that up and I might let you come.”
“Daddy-”
“Yeah, yeah, I know. Can’t trust a stupid slut to do as she’s told.” Robby forced your head to the side. You met his eyes through tear-soaked lashes. His lips brushed harshly against your cheek, his beard scratching your skin deliciously. “Tell me what you want, sweetheart. Come on. Beg me. I know you want to.”
“I want you-” You moaned, bucking against him, desperately seeking some friction to ease the painful pressure between your legs. “I want you to fuck me, daddy- I’ve wanted you- ah- wanted you for so long-”
“Yeah? How long, baby? How long have you been thinking about my cock stretching out that slutty little cunt?”
“Years-” Your nails dug into the fabric of your armchair, the material straining beneath your desperate grip, tears tumbling down your cheeks and falling off your jaw. A desperate sob tore through your chest. “Robby, please-”
You were cut off by the overwhelming stretch of his cock breaching you, pushing forward in a single, devastating thrust that had you trembling and whimpering under Robby. He felt so good- so fucking good- The stretch of him forcing your body to open up to him was just short of too much. He filled you up so good, thick and hot and heavy, a solid, throbbing weight inside your quivering, sopping cunt you could not forget.
“Shut up.” Robby hissed in your ear, knowing his sharp tone would only drag more delicious, high-pitched whines from you. “You got yourself into this mess, now be a good girl and take what daddy gives you. I don’t want to fucking hear you complain, sweetheart. You didn’t have to act like a fucking whore, you chose to, and now you see what daddy does to pathetic sluts throwing themselves at him.”
He fucked you in quick, jostling thrusts that had the feet of the armchair scraping across your flood. A distant, very distant part of you worried about Robby knocking the whole thing over from how hard he was pounding into you, but it quickly shut up when he let go of your hair to hold onto your waist, face nuzzling into the back of your neck.
He was panting, breathing loud and heavily, only interrupted by low, deep, rumbling grunts. His hips slammed into you, slamming you into the worn cushions. His star of david necklace tapped against your shoulder blade on every thrust while he mouthed at your ear and the side of your face, beard scraping deliciously over your sweaty skin.
The feeling of your cunt clamped down around him like a vice had apparently melted away every nasty word he could have thrown at you for your own sick, twisted pleasure, replacing the severe, struggling man you’d grown used to interacting with with a much softer version.
He muttered sweet nothings and tender praise into your skin while clinging to your waist as if you were a life raft.
And fuck, you’d be his raft, life preserver and stress relief if only he kept fucking you like this.
A younger version of you made a vow what felt like lifetimes ago to not waste any more of your time on toxic, unstable men, but for Robby you might just throw every common sense out the window.
Robby’s big nose smushed into your cheek, he kissed the tears off your skin, telling you how good you were doing for him, how good you felt for him, while a ceaseless, barely comprehensible string of daddy and please tumbled off your lips and into the cushion he’d shoved your face into.
Within minutes - or had it been hours? You weren’t sure. You sure as hell couldn’t trust your mind in this situation - Robby had reduced you to a whimpering, drooling mess. Your own arousal mixed with his pre-cum ran down your thighs and slicked up every thrust, causing an obscene symphony of wet noises paired with the telltale slap slap slap of skin hitting skin to fill up your dim living room.
Robby pressed his face into the space between your shoulder blades. He reached around you, pressing two fingers to your swollen clit, rubbing the pads of his fingers over it at just the right rhythm to make you fall apart with a strangled scream, his name still on your lips.
He thrust into you once, twice more before following you, grunting against your skin and coming inside you. His hips kept moving, almost automatically, fucking his cum deeper inside you until it covered his whole length and dripped down his balls.
You’d turned to putty under him. Drooling, happy, satisfied putty. You let your body slide down the backrest, collapsing on the armchair that was no doubt traumatised now, covered in your own arousal, cum, tears and drool as it was now.
You rubbed a hand over your face, humming in contentment.
“Where’s your bedroom?”
Robby’s voice was soft, caring, the way it only got with injured, scared children and hearing him address you with it after he just wrecked you and called you a useless, disgusting slut had your insides turn all mushy and warm.
You gestured down the hall, unable to get enough of your bearing to talk. You didn’t expect him to stay. You certainly didn’t expect him to pick you up bridal style and carry you to your bedroom, or to fetch a warm washcloth from your bathroom and use it and his tongue to carefully but thoroughly clean you up.
He set you down on your unmade bed and dragged the warm cloth over your thighs before, almost as an afterthought, cleaning himself up. He settled himself between your legs, face smushed against your heated flesh and lapped at your cunt until every last drop of him was gone and you were clinging to his hair, whimpering his name sweetly.
And because Robby was apparently a depraved, wretched old man, he stayed there. He stayed there, kissing and licking and sucking at your skin until he’d dragged another orgasm from you and Jesus, you sounded so fucking sweet and tasted so fucking good- Robby couldn’t pull himself away. No matter how much he should. No matter how much guilt crashed down on him now that the lust and hunger had subsided.
You wanted it, but how could he talk to you like that? Use you like that? You were such a sweet, young thing… how could you even know whether this was something you truly wanted? Not something you were made to believe you should enjoy? Robby had seen it before, and he had never wanted to be a part of it.
Even when you smiled at him, fingers playing with his hair and beard absentmindedly, he couldn’t help but feel like he’d done something terrible to you.
“Stay.” You croaked, and Robby felt himself nod before he could really think about the request, but yeah… what else was he going to do? Leave you? Fuck no.
He tossed the washcloth into your hamper and fetched you a glass of water. You gulped it down greedily before settling down, curling up against his side and nuzzling your face into his chest, your hand resting on his belly, drawing lazy circles onto his skin and playing with his hair. Robby buried his nose in your hair, the exhaustion of his shift finally crushing down on him, eyes falling shut…
Your alarm dragged you out of the easy, content, warm nap you’d slipped into. Your body felt pleasantly loosened, limbs still tingling faintly. Your arm felt sore, and a sharp, but not entirely unpleasant sting between your legs tore through you when you shifted.
Robby had wrapped his arms around you tightly, and it took some effort to extract yourself from him without waking him.
You tried to be as silent as you could as you took a shower and gathered your things for work. You left a note on the bedside table, telling Robby to stay as long as he wanted, and off you were.
You had an extra pep to your step as you strolled into the ER at midnight, just in time for your shift, and Lena commented on it right away - of course she did - gifting you one of her warm grins and peering at you over the edge of her glasses.
“Who’s the lucky guy?”
“A girl doesn’t kiss and tell.” You smirked and promptly slipped away to put your lunch in the fridge and your things into your locker before jumping into the nightly madness.
Your good mood stayed, and it did not go unnoticed by the rest of the Pitt either. Abbot shot you a questioning glance, a brow raised when your reply to his question came out a little more chirped than it should have. Ellis slapped you on the shoulder, grinning at you. Shen seemed a little intimidated, if not downright scared.
Seven a.m. rolled around, and you snuck away, grabbing your food and soda from the fridge, and made your way outside for your break you did not negotiate on. Seated on your wall by the entrance, you waited, perhaps with a little more anticipation than usual.
You watched Robby pull up on his motorcycle, the same motorcycle you saw parked outside your place when you left, a sight that put a grin onto your lips.
Whatever giddy, girlish delighted joy had carried you through the night, it withered the moment Robby got off his bike.
He didn’t look at you.
He didn’t acknowledge you.
He got off his bike, grabbed the helmet he never wore and marched right past you into the ER.
Tears stung in your eyes, and you didn’t know whether you hated yourself more for crying or for having had sex with him in the first place.
You knew he never committed to anyone. You knew his dating pool was basically limited to the hospital and the women who got into ill-advised affairs with him despite his reputation. You hadn’t even asked for anything. You had just had sex. Of course that didn’t have to mean anything you expected- you thought- that he’d at least look at you.
You chewed on your bottom lip, fingers trembling around your can of soda, trying not to let your thoughts spiral into self-loathing or self-deprecating versions of He is disgusted with you, of course he is. You are disgusting, playing on repeat in your head.
You finished your soda despite the nausea welling up inside your throat and dumped the rest of your lunch before heading back inside.
The change in your mood was felt viscerally by the whole ER, questioning looks following you on your way to your locker to deposit your lunch box. You didn’t notice Robby following you with his eyes, nor the concerned crease forming between his brows, but he was pulled away on an urgent case before he could make up his mind about whether to talk to you.
It was two hours into his shift when the silence between you became too much for him. The first chance he got, he slipped away, grabbed your wrist and tugged you with him into the family room.
You steeled yourself for another lecture.
It didn’t come.
“I-” Robby started, but stopped himself. “Are you okay?”
“Yeah. I was. Until you started ignoring me again.” You shrugged.
Robby winced. “Look- I shouldn’t have come to your place. We shouldn’t have- that-” He sighed. “It can’t happen again.”
“Why? Am I that disgusting to you?”
“Wh-what? No! How would you even come to that conclusion?!”
“Well, everything was fine last night, and now you’re back to being a dick. What else am I supposed to think? I’m sure most women don’t ask you to call them a slut while fucking them.”
“I don’t- Do you think most guys get off on calling the woman they’re with a slut?”
“Yeah, actually, they probably do.”
Robby hesitated. “Okay… point taken. Not that it was about calling you awful things for me. It was about you- about knowing I was making you feel good…”
You crossed your arms. “Then where’s the issue, Robby?”
He gestured vaguely at you. “You. All of you.”
“Wow. Thanks.” You deadpanned, glaring up at him.
“No! Not like that! Jesus. Look, you’re too young, yeah? And far too good to waste your time on someone like me. You deserve someone who’s kind and sweet and gentle. Not whatever the fuck I did to you last night.”
“You don’t get to tell me what’s good enough for me.” You sniffed. “You did what I asked you to do, you don’t think I deserve someone who does what I ask?”
“Come on, sweetheart, you don’t have to pretend with me. You didn’t actually enjoy that-”
“Why not? Oh, so you can be into BDSM but not me? Is that it? Leave me alone with that internalised sexism bullshit!”
“Woah, I’m not sexist.” Robby blinked at you.
You snorted.
“I’m not! I respect women.”
“Yeah, the thing with internalised things is you are not usually aware of them, but I’m not fucking getting into that with you now. Are you coming over tonight?”
Robby opened his mouth just to close it again. He had an odd resemblance to a fish in a moment, and you briefly wondered how it was fair for a man to be so handsome that even that didn’t turn you off.
“What?”
You rolled your eyes. “You need hearing aids or something? I asked if you’re coming over tonight.”
“Why?”
You shrugged and took a step forward, letting your hand trail over his protruding, soft belly. “I want to feel this against my forehead while I choke on you.”
Robby all but sputtered. He looked around frantically, as though to make extra sure the family room was empty, just to hiss your name under his breath.
You grinned.
Slowly, you lowered yourself to your knees. Robby didn’t stop you. You popped open the button of his cargo pants and dragged down the zipper, all the while looking up at Robby. He glanced from you to the door and back to you.
“I wanna suck you dick, daddy.” You purred. Robby cursed under his breath. He braced his hand against the door before slumping against it with his back when you curled your hand around his soft dick to pull it from his boxers.
“Jesus, kid-”
“Is that a yes?” You asked in a painfully fake, high-pitched, whiny tone.
“Yeah-”
You grinned to yourself as you parted your lips to take him into your mouth. He grew hard under your touch, under the insistent drag of your tongue over his velvety skin. You sucked on his tip until he was cursing, and giggled around him when he grabbed your hair to force you down, burying himself as deep in your throat as he could. He squished your nose into the coarse, dark curls at his base and your forehead into his soft belly.
You moaned around him, eyes fluttering shut.
It was so much better than you ever thought it would be.
A few minutes later, throat sore and hair more or less smoothed down, you emerged from the family room with a renewed pep in your step. Robby slunk out behind you a while later, once you’d cleared the hallway and hopefully nobody would put two and two together.
Dana shot him a withering, disapproving glare from central, Jack next to her merely raising his brow before shaking his head.
Robby blushed.
That night, after his shift, he found his way back to your apartment, and the night after that, and the night after… He was fucking addicted, and he didn’t even care when you sucked his cock like that or cried his name out so sweetly while coming around him - and especially not when you lay in bed next to him, playing with his stomach hair and smiling up at him so prettily…
🧩 ⇢ what will make you click away from a fanfiction immediately?
Oof, I don't like the way a lot of fanfic reader have moved away from fandom etiquette and started publicly discussing, and often also linking to, the fics they haven't enjoyed for one reason or another. I'm, especially as a dead dove writer, a big supporter of Don't Like, Don't Read and YKINMKBYKIOK - that being said, if I enjoy an author's way of writing, I'll read basically anything. I've gotten into ships purely because I liked an author's works so much. I've read fics about fandoms I have never engaged with because I liked that author's other stories.
I'm always open to discovering new tropes, kinks or plots.
The only thing I can think of that makes me silently exist fics is when characters are depicted as too OOC. Some I can always get past, especially if the characters are put in a situation they've never been in. Like a canon character who's been lonely their entire life is obviously going to be a little different if the fic establishes they met their soulmate early in life or something like that. As long as the core of the character remains, I don't mind.
🧸 ⇢ what's the fastest way to become your mutual?
Oh that's really easy. Just start yapping at me. I'll yap back. And I'll take any excuse to yap about my stories or fandoms.
I'm also living with severe social anxiety so the likelyhood of me starting a conversation are low, because I always feel like I'm just annoying other people or being too much or shit like that.
All of my friends became my friends by adopting me, and they only discovered the crazy once it was too late :D
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality
Anya is LIVE right now
FREE
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming