Elain and Azrielâs book is ACOTAR 5, and hereâs why:
Disclaimer: if you are not a fan of the couple or unwilling to open up to the possibility of them being together then please refrain yourself from reading this. This is just my opinion, if your opinion is different then thatâs okay, itâs natural, people think in opposition anyway. And Iâm not Native English speaker, so shall you find incorrect use of terms or grammar please forgive me, I know how frustrating it is when we encounter them.
For me, what makes me believe that Elainâs book is next is solely based on what she did on ACOSF, when she owned up to Nesta that she is capable of doing things herself, when she declares she is a part of the Night Court. Sure, some people would say that Elain shows little development but so does Nesta in ACOFAS. Her development would be shown in her own book. Iâm a fan of Elain and she definitely takes me by surprise with her talking back to Nesta, and for me that scene is showing her biggest development yet as Elain is often thought of as this meek, feminine, and pushover female. Other than that, ACOTAR 5 is most likely dealing with finding the fourth trove which we know Nesta couldnât find and it only leaves the possibility of Elain finding it.
All of that is then solidified further by Feysandâs POV and countless evidences of Sarah implying the second book is Elainâs. In my opinion, Azrielâs POV is intended to confirm him as Elainâs love interest and to set up the conflict for their relationship. The thing with Gwyn is very much similar with Cassian and Emerie in ACOFAS, if Sarah has done it before why would you think that she will not do it again? And to be frank, I donât interpret their scenes as romantic at all, it is up most very ambiguous. Sure, they could be mates but then Azrielâs reaction to Gwyn when she is kidnapped does not show mate behavior at all, quite the opposite when Elain is in danger or threatened to be honest. And it is definitely a possibility that Gwyn has the ability of a lightsinger seeing as both Nesta and Azrielâs shadow are drawn to Gwyn, particularly her voice.
Hence, there is literally no point of Elain being the common denominator in the two bonus content if her book is not going to be the next. Hereâs how I view it:
Feysand: Why of all equally important scenes in ACOSF does Sarah highlight the very scene where Elain takes anyone by surprise? And why does it go further by Rhysand mentioning that Elain is not who we think she is, that she is hiding her true identity in favor of pleasing everyone which stems from how she was raised by her mother.
Azriel: If Sarahâs intention in writing Azrielâs POV is to showcase only his lust and entitlement over Elain then it definitely backfires. Why? It completely ruins Azriel and his characterization, at least for me. The text implies that Azriel pleasures himself to the thought of Elain nightly, which for me, makes him a creep and ruins his future interactions with Elain if in the end they are not endgame. Thus, I firmly believe, if thatâs what Sarahâs intending then she wouldâve gone low and detailing his lust to a minimum instead of going on full detail that only left the readers uncomfortable in the future reread (similar as to many readers feel when they reread ACOTAR with the sex scene between Feyre and Tamlin, and we know now that Tamlin is hated in the fandom for his toxicity toward Feyre).
Thus, if you are going to use Azrielâs POV as the indication that his book is next, then why donât you extend the same courtesy to Feysandâs? Both are exclusive content, both are only available to US readers only, both are not being restocked, and most importantly both can be not read by the readers.
And if you are going to use Sarahâs word of âby the end of ACOSF we wouldâve known whoâs the next book going to beâ then only apply it to Azrielâs POV, how about the people who have Feysandâs POV? Is Feysand going to be the second book? We all know that in the end of ACOSF Sarah foreshadows Elain through Nesta placing a carved rose on top of her fatherâs grave which he made for Elain. And not to mention both exclusive content take place in the early and middle of ACOSF.
Letâs play hypothetical game and say that ACOTAR 5 is:
Then, the international reader wouldnât know that there is something going on between them as the possible evidence that they are mates is included in his POV only, which is only available to the US readers, as most of international readers interpret their scenes in ACOSF as a friendly banter and definitely incomparable with Elrielâs interactions alone in it. Adding to that, Gwyn and Azriel doesnât have enough evidence to tie them with the overarching plot (i.e. Koschei) thus, the plotline would be static, contributing nothing to the main plot of the series.
Then, the international reader would be confused as hell since in ACOSF there hadnât been any progress between them, and quite contrary, instead we got Elrielâs confirmation from ACOSF alone (i.e. the charged glance between them) and Elriel is completely left open-ended which begets possible endgame.
What about ACOTAR 6 then? In my opinion, we shouldnât speculate whoâs going to be the stars of ACOTAR 6 since whatâs going to happen in the third book is a direct result from the second book. But, letâs play another hypothetical game again shall we:
Letâs just say that Gwynrielâs book is the last, to see Gwynâs role in defeating Koschei and a possible build up to their relationship, but then why does Azriel get a POV in the end? The same goes for Elain, if her book is ACOTAR 6 then why Feysandâs POV showcasing Elainâs future development and blankly pointing that after they are done with Nesta they will deal with Elain? It still doesnât add up since both POV is supposed to be a teaser for what is to come as well as extra content (Rhys and Feyre choosing Nyxâs name).
Thus, in conclusion, Elrielâs endgame is the logical road for me. Not only their relationship has the most realistic build-up in the span of four books, but also some significant moments between them to just be dismissed as ânothingâ. I also believe if Sarah doesnât intend Elriel being endgame then she wouldnât have developed them as romantic in the first place. Why? It only complicates the matter further for Elucien when their conflict can be from Elainâs feelings toward Graysen, instead Sarah makes Elain move on from Graysen in favor of Azriel. The same goes for Gwynriel, Sarah could use Azrielâs feelings toward Morrigan instead of making him get over Morrigan in favor of Elain.
In addition, Elain and Azriel's relationship has the highest chance in resolving Beronâs situation. Beron is a part of the overarching plot, shown in his allegiance with Briallyn thus indirectly with Koschei. As of ACOSF, Beron-Briallyn alliance didn't make any sense and it ended in a cliff-hanger. Will Beron ally himself with Koschei? Will Beron stay idle? One thing for sure is that Elrielâs relationship will trigger that particular conflict as it is mentioned in Azriel and Rhysandâs discussion. More on that note, Beronâs situation would be dealt first, similar as Briallyn with Nesta, before Koschei is dealt in the last book.