How much work/how did you go about teaching the implied leave it? I would love for my dog to have a better implied leave it but I sometimes feel like he’s had so long NOT doing them that he’ll never really get it. He’s so curious and food motivated which I love, but he sucks at leave its in general let alone auto-leave its
That’s a really good question. My first piece advice would be that practice makes perfect (or “practice makes permanent” - whichever phrasing you prefer). If it’s been a while since you’ve worked with your pooch on Leave It, then I suggest dedicating some time to the concept. I worked a lot on Leave It with Kelsie, partially because it’s something you can work on literally anywhere as long as you have some kind of food with you (and in the early days of training, I had kibble/treats with me constantly – funnily enough, I’m back to having kibble on me constantly because Kelsie’s life is more interesting for her if she works for her kibble rather than getting it all in a meal).
I remember doing the “kibble name challenge” at one point, where you spell your dog’s name in kibble and have them Leave It (and I did her full name at the time, “Kelsie Iris”). And I thought I had the video of this somewhere but couldn’t find it: the first summer I had Kelsie, I did a training session in PetCo/PetsMart (they’re the same thing so idk which one), and I threw treats at her as a Leave It exercise – and one even landed on her head. I tried to come up with as many artificial Leave It scenarios as I could and practiced a lot with her.
When I have the time/energy, I like taking advantage of life’s many training moments. And a training moment that comes up quite frequently is Leave It. Whether you have a pet dog or a service dog, chances are you’ll be encountering dropped food frequently with your pooch – just the other day on our morning potty walk we randomly encountered three bagels on the sidewalk lol. And I’m definitely known to drop food in the kitchen/when I’m eating, so that’s always good practice.
As far as building up the “implied” part, I think a lot of that has to do with my Very Strict Rule of not giving the dog something that I told them to Leave It. Leave It is permanent. If I tell them to leave a treat that I placed in front of them, then I reward them with a different treat. Even when my friend spilled popcorn all over the floor and Kelsie and I rewarded Kelsie with a piece of popcorn, I treated her with a piece that I’d “hidden” from sight, rather than picking a piece up off the floor and directly giving it to her. I also make it very clear that any dog of mine, Kelsie included, isn’t allowed to eat/chew on something that I haven’t specifically told them they’re allowed to have, with the exception of toys, sticks (in Kelsie’s case), and food they’ve previously been given (e.g. if Kelsie hasn’t finished a frozen Kong or something, she’s allowed to go back to it at a later point). Kelsie loves prancing around with my clothes when she’s asked to take them off or to help with laundry, but she never, ever takes my clothes without permission despite the fact that I leave them all over the floor (whoops).
I will note that Kelsie was super easy to teach Leave It because she wasn’t super food motivated when I got her, so she didn’t really care excessively if she wasn’t allowed to eat something. She’s definitely gotten more food motivated as I’ve owned her, but that initial indifference really did help us create a solid foundation. I’d imagine Leave It would be hard for, say, a Lab, since a significant percentage of Labs have a gene that makes them never feel full from food (aka they’re always hungry - which is part of why they’re easy to train).
My second note is that no dog is perfect! They’ll make mistakes. Just this summer (or maybe the summer before? I don’t remember, time is a construct), I made a pasta dinner for my mom and me. We eat at a low coffee table (aka snoot-height), and I left the room momentarily (to refill my water or something). My mom was still in the room though. I walked back into the room to see Kelsie chowing down out of my mom’s bowl – and my mom didn’t even notice! When Kelsie heard me approach, she looked up, made eye contact with me, and deliberately took another bite of pasta. I found it so funny that I took a photo of my naughty pooch before telling her to Leave It (actually I doubt I even had to utter the command – usually I just have to say her name in that tone and she knows what I mean). So she’s not perfect. But she also has a mischievous/rebellious streak and likes to push boundaries every now and again, so I expect to be kept on my toes from time to time. And luckily there was nothing toxic to dogs so she was just fine – and probably even a little smug!