How Gus Grimstad Thinks About Tenant Retention: The Quiet Strategy That Builds Long-Term Success
Keeping good tenants isnât luckâitâs leadership with a plan
Tenant turnover is expensive. Every time a tenant moves out, it costs time, money, and momentum. Thereâs cleaning, repairs, marketing, showings, screening, vacancy periodsâand often unexpected stress.
Yet many landlords focus almost entirely on getting new tenants, while overlooking the quiet, consistent value of the ones they already have.
For multi-family property owners, retention isnât just about avoiding hassleâitâs a strategic advantage. And according to Gus Grimstad, a Wisconsin-based property manager who spends his days thinking about buildings, systems, and people, âRetention is rarely about grand gestures. Itâs about showing tenants that you pay attentionâconsistently.â
Hereâs a grounded, practical guide to tenant retention, built around the steady, thoughtful approach that Gus Grimstad is known for.
1. Start with Respectful Communication
Tenants donât need their landlord to be their best friend. But they do want clear, fair, and respectful communication.
Responding to maintenance requests promptly
Giving proper notice for inspections or repairs
Communicating lease renewals clearly and early
Setting expectations and honoring them
Gus Grimstad emphasizes simplicity over flashiness here.
âThe landlords who keep tenants the longest arenât the most charmingâtheyâre the most reliable.â
2. Make Maintenance a Priority (Before It Becomes a Complaint)
Nothing erodes trust faster than ignored maintenance. Tenants want to know that the place they call home is safe, functional, and cared for.
Fixing small issues before they grow
Checking in seasonally about appliances, heating, A/C
Keeping common areas clean and well-lit
Following up after repairs to ensure the issue is resolved
Preventive maintenance isnât just good for your buildingâit shows tenants that their comfort matters. And people stay where they feel respected.
Gus Grimstad often advises newer landlords:
âIf you treat the property well, tenants will follow that lead. Care breeds care.â
3. Review and Renew Proactively
Lease renewals shouldnât sneak up on youâor your tenants.
Reach out 90 days before the lease ends
Ask how things are going before discussing rent
Offer renewal options early, with incentives when possible
Provide clarity on any increases and why theyâre happening
Most tenants appreciate stability. When you give them a heads-upâand treat them as individuals rather than income linesâtheyâre more likely to stick around.
This kind of thoughtful timing is something Gus Grimstad builds into his calendar each quarter. It reduces friction and builds long-term trust.
4. Offer Small Touches That Go a Long Way
You donât need to spend thousands on luxury amenities. Sometimes, small thoughtful gestures make the biggest impact.
A welcome note for new tenants
A holiday card or small treat in December
Quick thank-you messages after on-time renewals
A shared message when snow removal is on the way
An annual feedback request (and action on it)
These moments show tenants that theyâre more than unit numbers.
Gus Grimstad shares that in one of his smaller buildings, the simple act of delivering winter prep notes and salt packs to front steps helped keep turnover almost nonexistent.
âIt wasnât about the salt. It was about showing we were thinking aheadâfor them.â
5. Keep the Rent Process Smooth and Predictable
Most tenants donât mind paying rent. What they mind is confusing systems, unclear deadlines, or penalties they didnât expect.
Retention improves when tenants can:
Pay easily (online options matter)
Understand exactly when and how rent is due
Get reminders in a professional, non-aggressive tone
Know what to expect if theyâre ever late
A friction-free rent system is a retention tool. It builds consistency. And consistency is what makes good tenants feel confident in staying.
6. Respect Their HomeâNot Just Your Property
A rental unit is a business asset for you. But for your tenant, itâs where their kid learned to ride a bike, where they cooked Thanksgiving dinner, where they unwind after long days.
Respecting their space means:
Not showing up unannounced
Not doing work without notice
Not entering units unless truly necessary
Being mindful during inspections or showings
Tenants who feel respected donât just stay longerâthey take better care of the space, too.
Gus Grimstad shares this quietly:
âEvery tenant deserves to feel like their space is their own. That trust is part of the leaseâeven if itâs not written down.â
Not every lease should be renewed.
If a tenant consistently breaks rules, disrespects neighbors, damages property, or causes headaches that outweigh their rentâsometimes, the best retention decision is non-renewal.
It frees you up to serve your good tenants better. And it keeps the overall tone of your building healthy.
Retention is not about keeping everyoneâitâs about keeping the right ones.
Final Thoughts: Retention Is a Leadership Choice
Tenant retention doesnât happen by accident. It happens when landlords commit to consistency, clear communication, and care.
Itâs not about flashy amenities or luxury perks. Itâs about building quiet trustâday after day, lease after lease.
The landlords who retain long-term tenants are the ones who lead well behind the scenes. They anticipate needs, respond professionally, and treat people like people.
Gus Grimstad says it best:
âMost retention isnât magic. Itâs just showing up, being steady, and fixing what you say youâll fix.â
That kind of leadership doesnât always show up in your bank account right away. But over time, it builds something much stronger: a reputation, a rhythm, and a rental business that actually lasts.