Is the “villain card” really a VILLAIN card- or something else?
So, I’ve been thinking a lot today about @faelapis‘s recent post (link in reblogs so this can go in tags) discussing the corrupted Steven theory, and specifically how he pointed out how in the intro… that the camera “zooms inside Steven’s heart” when transitioning to the shot that features Big Looming Pink Fella.
And I know the fandom generally refers to threatening spreads such as these as “villain cards,” since- at the time of the intro’s release in October, all of these characters were heavily implied to be antagonistic to our main characters in some way. But after seeing the first ten episodes of SUF in full, I feel we should pause and ask ourselves-
Are any of these characters really villains?
And if not, then what IS their role in the greater story of this epilogue, and more importantly- their role featured prominently in the show’s intro?
Let’s take a quick look at the characters we’ve seen already.
Thus far, Jasper has played the least antagonistic part she ever has in the entire history of Steven Universe. I’d even go so far as to consider her a shaky acquaintance of Steven’s, at this point.
But as far as her purpose in the show goes so far, Jasper is important because she is the very first person to mash it up with Pink Mode Steven. The very first person who catches a glimpse of this new ability of his to begin with. When Steven first shifted into this state, it was because she pushed him into a situation that was both emotionally and physically compromising. Jasper is every bit as stubborn as Steven. She knows exactly how to push his buttons. It’s for this reason that I don’t think he would’ve discovered his pink state without her, without her egging him on to fight.
Steven tries his best to be very patient with everyone, and yet his frustrations with Jasper’s inability to move forward (hypocrite, much?) elicited a rather jarring rush of directed anger that- before- he generally seemed to keep bottled inward.
I get the strong sense that he didn’t allow himself to freely and openly express these sorts of “negative” emotions at all before this encounter.
Furthermore, Jasper slapped him in the face with the biggest call-out of his mental state ever.
Jasper: “I don’t need your help. You’re the one that needs help. You think you’ve beaten me, but you’ve never beaten me on your own. You’ve always been a fusion. You’ve always had your friends because you’re nothing without them. You think everyone needs help.”
Jasper: “But it’s only you. No one is as pitiful as you.”
Every other episode of the show so far has only gone to further showcase that this is what Steven believes about himself right now. (See: Little Graduation, especially.)
And what happened with Jasper that day… was just the beginning of his slow decline.
This character… also isn’t big villain material. She’s barely even a threat.
Rather, Bluebird serves as a stark reminder for Steven that there are people out there that hate him for being him. Not only that, but those who would fuse for just that reason.
(I must admit, I still find the notion of Steven potentially falling apart because of a lack of self-love interesting, as much as it is heartbreaking. But I already wrote that post, so moving on-)
But she also is a reflection of how Steven is resistant to change right now.
Greg: “I mean, everyone can change, but not everyone wants to.”
He used to believe in the idea of positive change wholeheartedly, and yet… I think the passing years have led him to a place where he himself is scared of it, of the unknown, of moving on from what’s comfortable, of all the nebulous what-ifs. Which is why when Bluebird shows up, he projects his own resistance on this scenario. He doubts Bluebird’s ability to change for the better because he now doubts that for himself.
Instead, I think he fears he may be changing for the worse.
I strongly believe we’re going to see Bluebird again. I just get the sense that there’s more she can bring to the table.
“Mean” Lapis and “Nice” Lapis
Also not villains. Just obstacles.
Similarly to Bluebird, they seem to push that “resistance to change” theme further for Steven. Some people just… are stuck in their ways. (Thankfully though, not all of them. Thanks, Freckles. Love ya lots!)
Since Why So Blue is focused squarely on capping Lapis’ character arc, there’s not as much Steven-related meta threads I can glean from their first appearance, truth be told.
I think we’re likely to see more from these two, as well. If they do serve a greater role in the overarching story of SUF, it isn’t complete yet. Fingers crossed!
Dear goodness, this creature is completely innocent. Poor baby. XD
This poor fella plays the role of being a physical embodiment of- at the time of Prickly Pair- Steven’s mental state, and pushing the lad to repress his turbulent emotions even further.
Throughout SUF so far, Steven has become consumed by negative self-talk, (”I used to be helpful, but the Gems don’t need me anymore”), a stark reluctance to let anyone see the evidence of his mental instability, and explosive anger he cannot gain a handle on.
And as his mirror, Cactus Steven:
Repeats things Steven says, spilling all of that negative self-talk and the reasons why he doesn’t want to approach the Gems about his issues.
Is shoved away under a box, representing Steven’s emotional repression.
Warps into a monstrous form, explosive anger brimming at the surface.
Notably, Cactus Steven only fights in direct response to what others lay on him. He is not overtly antagonistic until Steven himself makes the first strike. Later, while the Gems are attempting to fight him back, he desperately tries pushing them away… much like Steven has been all season.
Cactus Steven: “Just… get… OUT!”
Furthermore, Steven creates him. He creates this monster. He’s the reason he becomes so messed up in the first place. That has to feel pretty awful, especially when he’s doubting his ability to be helpful nowadays. He tried to nurture this creature, and look where that got him? This furthers the narrative idea mentioned earlier, of Steven perhaps fearing that he’s now changing for the worse.
Finally, by by the end of this episode, it seems worryingly as if Steven’s reluctance to open up about his problems has solidified.
Pearl: “Is there anything you need to talk about…?”
Steven: “…I think I’ve said enough.”
We don’t yet know what role White Diamond will play, but it’s probable that it’ll be something that strongly impacts Steven in a personal way. And at this point in the show, I’m doubtful she’ll suddenly heel-turn back into villainy.
With all this in mind, my current theory is that…
These characters are not on this title sequence card as ‘villains’ at all, but rather, each serve as important ‘road markers’ on the path towards the eventual climax of SUF.
Meaning, Steven’s encounters with each of them will influence his way of thinking in a way that leads him further down the road towards eventual corruption. Or whatever else is waiting for him at the end.
And the camera specifically “zooms into Steven’s heart” because these characters, standing in front of that monster, represent the moments that lead him into that state.
What we’re seeing here is a visual record of the burden he carries inside him.