A/N: Part 3! So this part is actually not a request. I just had an idea and ran with it. You all seem to love these three and so do I. So I guess this is becoming a series? Maybe? Thank you for reading and I hope you enjoy!
Warnings: MDNI, NSFW, 18+, teasing, smut (unprotected, p/v, oral)
You felt the bed move and a kiss on your cheek. You knew it was Steve getting up to go to work. You snuggled closer to Gator and drifted back to sleep. You and Gator bought a bigger bed so Steve could sleep with both of you, along with doing other things. Steve has practically moved in.
When you woke up a bit later, Gator was looking at you. Right away you were already horny and could tell it was going to be one of those days. Giving Gator a good morning kiss you climbed on top of him and started to grind on him. The action sent pleasure through Gator causing him to moan.
“Mama ain’t it too early for this?” He asked you. You could feel his erection growing.
“Is it ever too early for this?” You asked him in the sweetest voice and moved your hips against him again.
“Hell no. Come here.” You bent down to kiss him as his hands started roaming your body. You took off your shirt and underwear and pulled his boxer briefs down. You got back on top of Gator and started riding him.
“Your tits bounce so fucking nice mama.” His hands were on your hips. His eyes were watching your breasts bounce as rode him.
“Fuck Gator. You feel so good inside of me.” Tilting your head back you were reaching your climax.
“Cum all over my cock y/n.” You did as you were told and Gator came soon after.
You snuggled into him knowing you only had a little time left before he had to leave. “I think I’m in a very horny mood today.” You pouted. You honestly wanted to go another round but knew Gator had to get up.
“I would take care of you all day but we know I gotta work. I’ll definitely be thinking about it all day.” Gator kissed your head and started getting up. You got up and threw the shirt you had on before back on. It wasn’t even yours. It was Steve’s shirt.
“So I should just suffer all day long? Or should I just pleasure myself?” You followed Gator around while he was getting dressed and putting gel in his hair to slick it back.
“Only if you record it and send it to me and Steve.” He gave you a smirk.
“Steve’s going to be home before you. We got to go to the store when he does. I want to cook you guys somethin’ real nice.” You basically said it for yourself as a reminder.
“As long as you’re dessert.” Gator came up to you and kissed you.
Moaning you said, “How am I supposed to last all day thinking of that?”
“Maybe Steve can take care of you.” You knew what Gator meant. You and Steve haven’t had sex without Gator.
“Are you sure?” You knew Gator could end up being jealous sometimes. His jealousy has gotten better though since the three of you started having a relationship. You guys never labeled it though. Everyone knew you and Gator have been dating for three years.
“Yeah. I think it’s good. We know he hasn’t been seeing anyone else. I guess it’s time that he can have you to himself once in a while. Just remember I’m number one.” Gator winked at you. He knew he was always number one. Even though Steve was number one as well now. “You should tease him. See how far he can handle it. I just want to know if he’d fuck you then tell me or be the good boy he is and tell me then fuck you.” You loved Gator’s plan. You agreed to it, you were in a mischievous mood. You told Gator bye and waited for Steve to come home to put the plan in action.
You had the day off so you were bored out of your mind. You looked in the closet for the best outfit to wear to make Steve crazy. You decided you’d do what Gator told you. You were horny and thinking of Steve and Gator did not help. The plan to tease Steve also didn’t help. So you pleasured yourself and sent it to the group chat with them.
Gator: fuck mama. Can’t wait to get home and eat dessert
Steve: Shit. You’re lucky I’m alone right now. I’m joining Gator and having dessert also
Laughing you got dressed. You wore a shirt that showed a bit more of your cleavage than usual and a skirt that if you bent down would expose a bit of your ass. You curled your hair and did your makeup. This was all a bit more than what you usually do. By the time you were done Steve should be home in a few minutes. You sat on the counter when he came in.
“Hey.” He kissed you on the cheek. “That was a nice surprise you sent.”
“Oh was it? I guess I was just feeling a certain way.” You smiled sweetly at Steve. “We need to go to the store. I got to get some things for dinner.” Steve agreed being oblivious that you had a plan.
On the drive to the store you seen Steve take several glances at you. You ignored it acting like you didn’t notice. “What’s with the look? I really like it by the way.”
“Oh, like I said. I guess I’m feeling a certain way today.” You grabbed his hand and casually placed it on your thigh. Your hand on top of his. Steve took a deep breath in but you kept acting oblivious to what you were doing to him.
Walking around in the store, Steve kept taking glances at your chest but tried to be respectful. No one knew what Steve was to you and Gator. You all just acted like friends when you were out. Teasing Steve out in public was testing the boundaries for him and for the town’s people. When you got to an empty aisle you knew this was a good time to tease Steve more. You bent at your waist to look at the lowest shelf. Acting clueless that your ass was showing.
Steve quickly noticed. “Y/n!” He quietly yelled. He got behind you so no one could look. Steve was a gentleman, at least in public.
Standing straight you asked him what’s wrong. “Your ass is practically hanging out. As much as I love your black lace thong, I don’t think Gator will like everyone else looking.”
“Oh.” You put a sad look on your face. “I guess. But how am I supposed to get what I need if it’s on the bottom shelf?” You stepped closer to Steve. You pushed your chest into him and looked up at him with puppy eyes. His eyes kept going to yours and then your chest.
“Um. I guess I could get it” he said after a second. Then realizing he was in public, he took a step back. Steve ended up picking up every item for you. Even ones that were eye level to you. After paying and putting groceries in the trunk you got in the car. When Steve got in he looked at you. “You need to stop doing that in public.”
“Don’t play dumb. I know you’re smarter than how you’ve been acting. Did you forget I know you? I’ve known you since forever?” The embarrassment rushed to your cheeks.
“Sorry Steve.” You looked down, feeling stupid for acting dumb to tease him.
“Your teasing definitely worked though. It was difficult to get through that store without fucking you.” Steve admitted. “Only thing that kept stopping me, apart from being around people that don’t know, was Gator.”
“I think he’d be okay with it.” You didn’t want to tell Steve that you already talked to Gator about it.
“He would kick my ass.” Just as Steve said that his phone started ringing. “Speak of the devil.” Steve answered the phone. After a few quick yes or no answers he put it on speaker. “I think y/n has been more desperate today than either of us thought.” Steve looked at you. “Not sure if she can make it to dessert.” His eyes roamed over you. You clenched your thighs just by that single look.
“I think you should take care of her Harrington. Turns out I’m going to be stuck here for longer than I thought.” Steve looked surprised to hear Gator’s suggestion.
“Gator, you sure about that?” Steve would obviously love to but he didn’t need Gator being mad at him.
“Yeah. Actually, me and y/n talked about it this morning.” You could hear the cockiness in Gator’s voice. “Of course it was after I fucked her. But like you said, she’s desperate today. So go ahead. Please her. Anytime she wants.”
Steve gave you a look. “Will do.” He hung up still staring at you. “You guys talked about it?” You nodded. “Let me guess. His idea to have you tease me this whole time?” Again you nodded. “You two are evil.” Steve started the car and drove home.
When you got into the house, Steve was all over you. It’s like he’s been waiting to have you all to himself. You were making out with Steve while shuffling your way to the bedroom. Both of you pulling off each other’s clothes.
Steve picked you up and walked into the bedroom and tossed you on the bed. He climbed on top of you and kept kissing you. “I finally get you to myself. Do you know how long I’ve waited?”
“As long as me?” You asked. You always did want to know what it’d be like with just Steve.
“Longer.” Steve thrusted into you.
“Steve.” You moaned. Steve buried his face in your neck and kept going. He started biting and kissing your neck. Your fingers scratched at his back, his rhythm exactly how you needed it to be. Steve moved his lips back onto yours. He was more affectionate during sex than Gator. After a while you both reached your orgasms.
You cuddled into Steve satisfied. “I can still have dessert after this, right?” Steve asked and you chuckled.
“Yes. I’m sure Gator will want to share though.” You kissed Steve on the lips. It felt right. You loved that you could do all the things you did with just Gator, with just Steve now too. You loved it even more that the three of you could do it together.
“I’m okay with that. We should start dinner soon.”
You cooked dinner with Steve, upset that Gator couldn’t make it. You sat at the table with Steve and started eating.
“You know he would rather be here than there.” Steve reassured you.
“I know.” You gave him a slight smile. You understood Gator’s hours for his job weren’t always the same. You heard the door open up and Gator walked in a few seconds later.
You got up to go hug him. “Hey mama.” He kissed you. “It smells good in here.”
“Come eat.” You dragged him to the table wanting him to sit so you could go get him a plate. Before you could leave his hands found your waist and pulled you back.
“I’d rather have something else.” He whispered in your ear. “Did Steve take care of you today?” He asked aloud.
“Yes. He did an amazing job.” You looked at Steve who was clearly done eating.
“So it’s my turn?” Gator asked you.
Steve cleared the table and went to kiss you. “She’s all yours.” He told Gator. Steve left to go do the dishes.
Gator picked you up and put you on the table. While kissing him, he moved his hand down to rub your pussy. “No panties?” He smiled into your lips.
You shook your head. “They were drenched. And why ruin another pair?”
“I do love ripping them off you. But I guess having none on makes it easier.” Gator lowered himself until his face was by your cunt. “You’re already soaked.” His hot breath hitting you. You shuddered. Gator started licking you.
“Fuck.” You put your head back. Your hand going straight to his hair. You didn’t care if you messed it up. He entered two fingers and sucked on your clit. Your legs started shaking. You weren’t going to last long. As he continued his perfect rhythm you came all over his fingers, he licked it up.
“That was worth the wait.” Gator said and kissed you so you could taste yourself. He gave you a serious look for a second and asked, “Are you happy? With all of this?” You knew he was talking about the three of you.
“Of course I am. It’s like I’m living a fairytale.” You gave him a smile and kissed him. “Are you good with all of this?”
“As long as I got you, I’m the happiest I can be.”
